Are you getting a cut for the telegraph subscription? Sir, you are now officially a businessman, in my opinion, not the truth seeker you once were. Nothing wrong with that.
@@doctorlefthandthreadNot entirely (my opinion), if you want your business (image, influence, whatever) to do well there will be some form of bias involved in your thought process even if its subconscious.
Here's one of many, many Jews who desperately wish we could be at peace - as demonstrated by the thousands of years in which Jews have never once instigated war or violence.
War is just a racket. A racket is best described, I believe, as something that is not what it seems to the majority of people. Only a small inside group knows what it is about. It is conducted for the benefit of the very few at the expense of the masses. - Major General Smedley Butler
Lack of widespread critical thinking skills. Coupled with the mob mentality of identarian manipulation, clever leaders can move millions to acts of inhuman violence.
God bless you and all the jews who are against the war (in USA and elsewhere). We see you and we will not forget. We lived together thousands of years in North Africa. History attest of that.
If you read the quoran you wouldn’t be saying that. Jews and Muslims are literally mortal enemies. All that positive bs is gonna get your head cut clean off by a true Muslim when the time comes.
@@BrikMalek Surely (the ones) who have disbelieved among the population of the Book (Or: family of the Book; i.e., the Jews and Christians) and the associators (Those who associate others with Allah) will be in the Fire of Hell, eternally (abiding) therein; those are they who are the most evil beings (Literally: Initiated creatures).
@@reemm4696 read quran 98:6 it says jews and christians are the worst of cretures worst then dogs and bugs , allah puts the sins of muslims on christians and jews who will burn in hell forever they teach you guys are morons maybe READ R E A D THE QURAN
Essentially a new world order is requisite, other than the current setup of de-facto darwinism hiding behind a thin veneer of exclusively western hypocrite morality.
I am so so with JP....sometimes he is right but to me he is another over hyped font of dubious wisdom to be taken at face value, issue by issue. Iran and Saudi Arabia of late have actually being moving closer together and while I don't have to like any of their rulers any more than I like the American infants in the room, I do not, like Jordan, convenientlly give them chief bogey man status. The chief bogey man status in this conflict is undoubtedly Israel, or more specifically, Bibi, Likud and the fanatic Jews who continue to steal land and murder innocents in the West Bank - not to mention that it was they who created Hamas in the first place.
Dr. Peterson, I'm a long time viewer and follower of your content. You've inspired and changed many across the whole world. While I appreciate the sentiment expressed inside your article, there's a severe misrepresentation that takes place here. While any rational person must rightly condemn what Hamas did on October 7th, most of the protests that take place aren't an expression of solidarity with Hamas, but a just condemnation of what Israel has done in the occupied West Bank and Gaza. You speak about the Iran backed Hamas and what happens in Israel/ Gaza as a consequence, but how does that explain the year-on-year deaths of dozens, sometimes hundreds, of innocent Palestinians in the West bank? The government there is secular and nationalist in nature. It has recognised Israel since 1993 and it is powerless to do anything about the constantly en-roaching Israeli settlements, which are illegal under international law. They suffer daily indignities and humiliations. Some might even say that it is possible to appreciate how this could potentially radicalise some people. As for Gazans, they do not represent Hamas. 50% of the population is below the age of 18. What Israel does with them is completely disproportionate. And while people from all over the world are asked or expected to condemn the atrocities of Hamas, the same leaders and pundits are relatively silent when it comes any of the litany of wrongs Israel has visited on the Palestinian peoples. This is what people are protesting.
WRONG: this has nothing to do with "occupation" you are spewing the "palestinian" lie. Take the case of Ahmad Manasra at 13 in 2015 stabbed two israeli's. How do you get a 13yr old to commit such atrocities? child abuse and indoctrinate in a false ideology that Israel is changing the status of AlAksa! ie.. not occupation, not oppression, not apartheid or any other lie. The lie is AlAksa.. and the Jewish people, being the indigenous owners of the land of Israel of course had a temple there 1000 years or so before Islam was invented. So your false narrative reflects your ignorance of history.. now go learn! ps.. Hamas entry? called the AlAksa Flood! The 1929 hebron massacre? 20 years before the state of israel? motivation: change of status of AlAksa.. getting the pattern now? This is about a false ideology trying to push western democracies off this planet.
I have seen and heard enough of Mr. Peterson that I knew he was referring Hamas terrorists and NOT Muslims. But people that are looking for division, and attention and gains are being deceitful. As always thanks for such a bird's eye view in the whole situation. I'm still heart broken for all Jews, Palestinian victims of violence. Praying .
A man with the level of intellect as Mr. Peterson should've clearly stated Hamas in his statement and not just, give them he'll. Whose the "them" he was referring too. I truly admire Mr. Peterson and listen to nearly all his podcast. He even interviewed Mohammed hajib twice or more on his channel, but I could see how people misconstrued what he said, because I was one of them. I say peace to all the innocent people and animals on both sides! The Earth itself is being destroyed with all those drone strikes and bullets.
The Palestinians are not victims. They have earned their violent deaths. They deliberately put the people responsible for this attack in power because they hate the Israelis as much as the attackers did. The Palestinians are no different from the Terrorists they support. I have no dog in this fight in terms of religion as an atheist, but that should be obvious to all outside observers.
Harry Nilsson said this. "You see what you want to see, and you hear what you want to hear." It somehow seems relevant, because there are no easy answers in life even when things are going relatively well and smoothly.
Mr. Peterson, could you ask Mr. Netanyahu why he hasn't adhered to UN resolutions, dismantled settlements, or taken meaningful steps toward peace in the past 30 years? We, Palestinians, desire peace, but continuous massacres and lack of genuine efforts hinder progress. We seek understanding and a peaceful coexistence. I also expected you to address the recent massacre at the Ahli Hospital in Gaza perpetrated by the Israeli occupation forces We desire peace, but not a peace that displaces 60% of us, incarcerates us, and seizes our sacred sites. We seek a fair and comprehensive peace that addresses all issues simultaneously, rather than one that benefits one side at the expense of the other. The undeniable truth remains: Israel functions as a colonial power. While peaceful assistance and development are welcome, their actions have instead led to humiliation, massacres, destruction of our identity, and the seizure of our sacred places-all justified by unfounded claims to the land. I urge you to be fairer and more open-minded. While we welcome Jews, we reject the imposition of colonial power. Regardless of your arguments, the harsh realities on the ground remain unchanged, sir.
As an Israeli I think the problem is Hamas, I know netanyahu gives them money but still.. we are a democratic country and eventually he will be retired and replaced by someone better. I think as a community you need to somehow kick the terror (Hamas) of Gaza because we Israelis want peace too and the terror makes it impossible for us 😞 What happened on 7.10 deeply traumatized me. I lived under rockets in the middle of Tel Aviv! Also southern Israel has lived under rockets their whole lives and me? I was in a bubble in Tel Aviv I didn't understand how traumatizing it is for the southern Jews in Israel. I hope you understand my point, Peace doesn't come from one side. The world doesn't work like that. If you want peace you should somehow kick out Hamas.❤🇮🇱✌🏻🕊️☮️
@@Gili44 There were terror from both sides long before Israel were founded, what matters is that today it's Israel who have the power to stop this, but they would rather build settlements and occupy more land
This is not a religious matter. This has nothing to do with "Muslim" or "Jew" whether you are pro or not!what is happening is wrong. The people who are being killed are PEOPLE. It's enough to say that we are all PRO-LIFE and pro the right to know that you DESERVE to live!!!!!
It's nice to think like that, but no one cared about "people" when Seria killed 400k people in its land. When it comes to Israel everyone stand on their toes.. People actually stop to think whether Israel is just or not with it's response to a massicure, rape, killing of a prognant women and opening her belly and killing the unborn. Monstrosities that no one could imagin And yet, the world talks about "maybe Hamas is right" It's not about people, it's about the world not getting the idea of jews in their land. 😢
Yes. Well, also, technically "Muslim" is a culture, not a religion afaik, but it gets thrown around as a word and used in so much variety of ways i'm probably just being pedantic. Anyways, i mostly just wanted to give you props for making the simple, to-the-point, statement that brings the focus to a better one; talk (dogma, philosophy etc) is useful/interesting but in the end, actions matter most.
The fact that Muslim and Jew is being thrown in so heavily is making this a antiseptic and Islamophobic phenomenon even though as you said it should not.
Israel overplayed their hand. I was disgusted by the kidnapping and the actions of Hamas. But the response from Israel has been far more barbaric. In the sense that it is a clear eye for an eye meant to teach a lesson to the people in Gaza. As if the retaliation of Hamas was simply reduced to them being lovers of war. As if there was no need to consider the conditions in which Gaza exists. The lack of old Republicans to understand that they would probably fight twice as hard if they were living under such conditions. For far less than that, they kicked the British out. This is a new turning point; not only the new right could not careless about Israel, but the unconditional support Israel dies with the next layer of humans who are in line to complete their cycle of life.
I know this won’t be read but Peterson should read “people of the lie” it’s a great book about this exact thing. Hiding in institutions of power and holiness to hide your evil.
While I appreciate this message, the main problem I see is that the thuggery of Netanyahu goes unmentioned. Netanyahu was aiming to become the supreme leader of Israel prior to this conflict and was in trouble. Now, he is using this conflict to gain back control. Too convenient. 8 days prior to the attack, Egypt warned Israel it was coming. Israel ignored the warnings. Too convenient. On the day of the attack, security forces were absent from the border and no warning went out to Israelis until 9-12 hours after the incursion, leading to a completely unnecessary massacre. Did they get a stand down order? It's starting to look that way. Simultaneously, the Iron Dome underperformed that day. You need to look deeper, as you are buddies with a man that clearly knew this attack was coming, and that allowed it to happen. A man who himself is in part responsible for building up Hamas. Everything points to the Israeli administration having betrayed their people to cement total power, and you're cosying up to them. As somebody who has studied tyranny and evil for so long, that you should fail to at the very least consider this in the hour of need is very hard to tolerate. So please, wake up. You were too slow with Covid, but got there in the end. I know you are under enormous pressure, but please be faster this time, even at the cost of your relationship with Shapiro and Netanyahu.
Thank you for stating the truth and facts 💯 “Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palest inian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” he [Neta nyahu] told a meeting of his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy - to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.” (Haaretz, October 9, 2023, emphasis added)
So was and is the deal with my country Iran, except that our number 1 man is literally called the supreme leader and it has been this way for almost 40 years! Although at the end i definitely do not support netanyaho and i do think that doctor Peterson is making a mistake in taking sides with him. Almost of this is spot on the people ruling over us are certainly an evil bunch. And I'm pretty thay they've done even more damage to the image of islam then terrorist groups like ISIS did
not to mention that now we know a LOT more about what happened (or DIDN'T happen) on Oct 7th and the important role the IDF played in the killing that day... Hannibal Directive...
Dr Peterson I would like to thank you deeply. I know you probably won't see this but your work and lectures have changed my life for the better in significant ways, I got in contact with my father (who left when I was 2) I cleaned my room, I left my "friends" who in reality are drug addicts, I started improving myself and looking deeply inside myself while asking the question who am I. Turns out I was a young boy with potential, and that potential has been slowly fading. So i have taught myself discipline, I have been rough but truthful And I have started to become my best self. So my deepest thank you, Dr Peterson for changing my life, and making me open my eyes. I cannot thank you enough. Without you I would be a fatherless depressed, angry person, living in my hoarder mother's home. With your help I changed that. For that I am truly grateful
@@keo0101 and they should send them hell. If you disagree, take a look at any of the videos where Hamas shows you themselves what they did in Israel. It will make you sick and traumatize you, but at least you'll know this is no play. ❤🩹
@@masada2828 Palestinians are Arabs, you genius. So if they are Arabs, they should die or leave their land or something? Weren't there Palestinian jews all throughout history, yes, Arab jews you
I pray for you continually, Dr. Peterson. We Christians have been poor stewards of the souls around us, and it is only by the truthfulness of teachers like you that we can exist. We have not lived the way that we ought to live, we have not said the words that we ought to say, and we have not loved in the way that we ought to love: "If the Lord of hosts had not left us a few survivors, we should have been like Sodom, and become like Gomorrah."
@@John-uo1qf We are God's chosen people. "One who slaps the cheek of a Jew is considered as though he slapped the cheek of the Divine Presence" Sanhedrin 58b
I recommend reading the text version of this statement by Dr. Peterson - I found it easier to process, follow, and go back when I didn't immediately comprehend something. Telegraph article is called "This unholy axis of Iranian thugs and Marxist psychopaths is an enemy of Muslims too"
@@cameronclark3725 hello cameron clark. did you read about the palestinian partition the United Nations came up with decades ago. to my eyes arabs and jews got pretty equal shares. jews got the coastal cities and arabs got the inland cities. jerusalem would be a special administrative area like the vatican. but arabs would not accept the division and attacked in 1947..
@@cameronclark3725If you have something to say, why not write your own article about it? Not everyone focuses on the same issues you do (for good reasons).
What about the Palestinians oppressed by Israel in the West Bank. I haven't heard a single good explanation for it. Israel needs to take their own religion seriously.
Mr. Peterson! I have followed you for many years. I have read and watch everything you published! It is very unfortunate to see how much you have changed since you started working for Ben Shapiro, the change is extremely evident! You are a very strong minded individual and you will most likely never believe my observation in this matter! But it is very obvious! I truly hope one day we will get back the wise Dr. Peterson.
With all due respect Dr. Peterson. There seems to be a conflation of parties here with two very vocal portions and one that speaks some level of civility, on one side you have those favoring Israel ignoring the crimes that are openly committing by simply pointing out the atrocities hamas committed and on the other rests a very confused pro hamas group that defends their actions based on some perceived slight. But neither of you seem to be willing to listen to reason and those that ask for simply all civilians be allowed to exit the Gaza Strip so Israel can properly address the terrorists threat that is hamas.
“If anyone has ears to hear, let him hear.” And He said to them, “Take heed what you hear. With the same measure you use, it will be measured to you; and to you who hear, more will be given. For whoever has, to him more will be given; but whoever does not have, even what he has will be taken away from him.” Mark 4:23-25
So invading Al Masjid Al AQSA "a muslim-only holy building" with dirty shoes of Israeli people and kicking palestinians out of their houses and properties a million times with no reason or justification is okay, but when palestinians stand up for their country and do some counterattacks as a reaction it's called terrorism? Thank you DR. JP for making me lose all the respect i once had for you and most importantly thanks for prioritizing some people's lives over others'.
Why is Al aqsa a Muslim only building? It’s where the Jewish holy temple once stood. How come the Jews aren’t allowed to go there? The only houses demolished by the idf is the houses of people who have killed innocent civilians as an act of terror. That is not for no reason. If the idf destroyed houses for no reason there would be none left.
@Dewbird6995 there is no single historical proof of the claimed Temple Mountain, nor there is any evidence that the biblical text that speaks about it was said by or revealed to Moses.
@@Dewbird6995if the idf wasn’t choosing places at random they wouldn’t tell everyone everywhere to leave the area. If they knew they were hitting H homes they wouldn’t give them a heads up.
@@Absolute42 lmfao. Sometimes I want to respond to people but when they say some outstandingly dumb things I give up. “the idf has only destroyed terorrists houses” 😂😂😂
Its terrorism because they purposely went after civilians, they could have only gone after military targets because the idf doesnt hide behind women and children like hamas does, so they cant go after specific military targets when they are located in schools, hospitals, apartment buildings etc. I dont blindly support israel, i dont blindly support hamas, but i, and many others who arent driven by ideological propaganda from either side, are anti hamas, we are saying this while acknowledging both sides have their legitimate grievances.
Honestly this type of content available for free is stunning to me. I just dropped my jaw, and learned more than I have in the last 20 years. Sir please take care of yourself Voices that ring this true. Have been silenced by the scum of the universe time and time again!
What's your excuse for piping up irrationally here towards @BwAaS whilst he was attributing thanks and gratitude for the words of wisdom most of the WORLD yearns for - 'insert your pronoun here' @@catnapgee5357 Dr. Peterson just taught us something meaningful about the whole of societal culture - East, Middle East, and West alike and the social moray consequences of treacherous lies, religious falsehoods and theocratic tyranny, but you missed it. I wish you well. Godspeed in your search for the truth.
The concept of you being simple minded, with all due respect is the truth. You see, Jordan Peterson in this video is nothing but the equivalent of taking the main stream news propaganda by Israel and the US, shoving them into some kind of an AI Content Writer and choosing "make it sound really fancy" and then proceed to simply give it out with what I have to admit to be quite a performance, he is talented in preforming I'll have to be honest about that. Want me to prove it to you? Tell me what did you learn from this that you haven't learned in the last 20 years, and I promise, the things you'll find yourself learning are exactly the things on every news station in the west.
You have articulated, with precision, the deep and difficult situations we now find ourselves in. What’s important now is to shed light wherever we can.
Mr Jordan peterson I see u are revolving around the main point. I believe you are very smart to know that before giving any advice about this you need to make sure you have studied the case in details. I as Muslim truly appreciate your efforts in trying to unify the people of the book but it is not simple. So you really need to teach yourself more about this issue if you really want to contribute in solving this problem
@kosiekoos9408 it was a false flag netanyahu was supposed to be charged and protested against by 500k israelis he did all this to distract ppl like u who easily believe in propaganda.
What is your point? That terrorism and killing innocent people is justified if you're muslim? Because you're so butthurt about the fact that your people haven't achieved anything purposeful in over half a millenia? Or do you want to say that islam actually is the religion of love and peace? Well, then begin acting like it, or people won't believe you.
He really going around. I mess with Jordan work. He made me a better person. But you are right. He is ignoring the point. He's only going from one attack recently not knowing nowhere near enough information. He hasn't followed the events closely enough.
@@kosiekoos9408 do u realise that so far 3500 Palestinian civilian died since 7th of october and 500 died today due to israeli bombing of a hospital? 80 of the 500 were children, so far what we are seeing is the end of Palestinian people not HAMAS
Dr jordan am a huge huge fan. I believe you have touched upon a lot of accurate points. But i also believe you totally missed the core reason of the conflict. Yes iran is orchestrating. But the core fuel of the conflict is gaza the largest open air prison in the world. The core fuel is the israeli settlements that made through years the two state solution impossible. The core issue is the abraham accords is striking peace with all arabs but the palestinians whether it be the plo or any palestinian side. The core issue is israel left no livable options to the palestinians. So, like all such situations in politics a country such as iran utilized the situation. You are perfectly right yet so far away from the full picture. Your noble hope for peace is biasing your critical thinking. And am so sure some day you will see it. The abraham accords unfortunately were doomed to collapse one way or another cause their core foundations is unfair. And their objective isnt peace. Some day i hope you see it. Until then my prayers to you, i love you despite how much i disagree with your political assessment of the situation.
I understand punishing Hamas and those involved in the attack. That said, I condemn the collective punishment of 2.2 million people in Gaza, many of whom had nothing to do with the attack. Gaza is a hopeless prison, it should be no surprise that some people resort to extremism in those conditions. I didn't know what the answer is, but I know it's not killing thousands of civilians and calling it " collateral damage " You'll only push more people to extremism.
Who made it a prison? Israel left in 2005, hoping to be left in peace. It could have been turned into a beautiful flourishing place into which millions of international aid was poured. Israel left its greenhouses to help the people of Gaza. Instead Gaza elected Hamas, who turned it into a bed of terror. Israel had no choice but to protect its border. And explain why is it that it’s border with Egypt is closed? Is that Israel’s fault as well?
All this verbal masturbation for damage control and to hide the fact that you are not allowed to criticize Jews at all for some reason, even when they themselves do the same, or even worse things to enemy civilians. I've noticed this a while ago but chose to ignore it as I have tremendous respect for your work and have been following you for over 7 years now. Why is it so hard to acknowledge that those "special people" commit atrocities as well. and indeed at this very moment, because of their narcissistic belief that God chose them to be the special nation.
Right on. Plus, didn't the jews break their covenant with God and God took their land away and cursed them to be "wanderers of nations"? And Israel isn't supposed to exist until after the 2nd coming of the Messiah. As Revelation Ch2 Vs9 says "they say they are jews but they are the synagogue of satan".
As someone who I assmed to be very knowledgable, I'm shocked you haven't heard of the 75 years of Israeli occupation of the Palestinian land, and more shocked that you don't understand what resistance is!
@@dave9547 Did you think this was a clever retort? Terrorists make civilians their target and don't care about the people who will die in retaliation, which they know is coming. Military targets terrorists and ends up with accidental (though known) civilian casualties. You decide.
This is the most important comment here IMO. Dr JP, while I don’t know your sources and so would be presumptuous to malign them, I am confident that utter commitment to the “virtue” of the Israeli version of the narrative will serve you about as well as did commitment to the “humanity” of those promoting the official **rona narrative. Those peddlers of heartwarming virtue-signaling “information” were never innocent not even in February 2020, and neither are they in this new situation.
Please state the thugs on the other side with reasoning as to why you would call them thugs. (Israel handed over Gaza in 2005, which has been controlled by Hamas since 2006.)
And Israel is now killing innocent civilians. That is thug behavior. The Israeli government are thugs. It's very hard to dispute that.@@stephenkramp5602
Thanks be to God for the heart, mind and intellect of Jordan Peterson. May God protect him and his family. He’s calling out the forces of evil who live and breathe and move among us. We must listen!!!
Jordan Peterson is employed by Ben Shapiro's company, The Daily Wire. The Daily Wire is funded by Kape Technologies, whose CEO is Israeli Intelligence Duvdevan Unit veteran Ido Erlichman.
"do not attribute to yourself the virtue of the Divine when acting on your own behalf" is one of the many valuable lessons I learned from Dennis Preger who says the correct wording (and I agree) is "do not TAKE [carry] God's name in vain"
Paul prayed (trevailed) to see Christ formed within his readers... once formed, and given free reign; who can stop the rivers of living water that flows from the divine?
I’m with you on this Peterson. Choosing not to fall prey to easy answers, and moral ascendency which is nothing of the sort. To choose wisdom, because you recognize how little you know. To choose to speak what you believe is true, because you fear the proper things. To not cower for fear of offense. Keep speaking. Keep looking for the highest nexus of good and truth. So that you might discern in the midst of a blinded and deafened wailing chorus. Of unrenewed minds. Of seared conscience. One may take your life, but they cannot take the truth from your heart.
The only ascendant truth that matters is Christ as the crucified and risen Saviour of mankind. If it's true, the line between good and evil runs straight through the human heart than we all need a redeemer, to redeem that which is good, to restore the conscience and bring us into right standing with God. The propensity for evil within us precludes us from being candidates for such a task, but God, who is holy, who created us, can, legally rectify our situation by stepping into human history and his own creation, taking on human flesh so as to do it legally in this realm where he has given us dominion. By using a human vessel to take on the brutality of mankind to overcome it, and conquer death itself to offer us not just a way out, but the ultimate solution, a way through; through Him. "For there is no other name under Heaven and in all the earth, given by men, whereby we might be saved." Put your trust in Jesus and not yourself and He will ensure that when all's said and done the suffering will be over, as you will have eternity with Him, where He is and descended from and returned to: Heaven. May God bless you, in Jesus' holy name, amen. 🙏
@@MrShabbaaaa hey shabba. are you kidding or dimwitted? what words of wisdom or encouragement would you have given nettanyahu when hamas went on a murder spree? "I never did give them hell. I just told the truth, and they thought it was hell." ― Harry S. Truman
@@georgeh8937 no you are the dimwit. Completely ignorant of the wider implications of egging on a thug like Netanyahu, conclusion so far being war crimes and crimes against humanity, worst of which being a hospital that gets airstriked killing over 500 civilians including women, children, babies, patients, doctors, refugees. And who knows how far Netanyahu will go in "giving them hell". Btw you know a lot *Israelis* themselves are against Netanyahu and his actions, you don't care about that though do you?
With all the greatest respect and admiration I have for you Dr. Peterson, I do not personally believe these 'Message To [X]' videos/articles on current affairs to be constructive. I think they are both tonally flawed and symptomatic of you stretching yourself out too thin in attempt to wrestle with every issue. You don't have to do this, in spite of your platform. There are people more specialised in these areas. At the very least host them, but your own words are subpar here in my view. I ask instead to please continue addressing the personal/esoteric issues, and providing positive, inspiring content out of that, such as the biblical seminars you and DW have so generously shared for free on your channel. They are the light in the darkness, for everyone, at all times. These rants, that I do not find to be as organised as you intend, in my view do not do this. They boil down to poorly structured punditry of a generic sort. I do not think they set the right standard. That's just my view and I mean it with all good will.
100% agree. I respect the standards he held himself to 5 years ago, and I know he's smarter than this. It's like he got fed up with the left and decided to do the one thing he always warned against: To pick a side. I adore his talks on principle and the nature of truth. But how he applies that to current issues is tilted in ways he should be better at detecting and accounting for. Sometimes you don't owe the enemy of your enemy your friendship. Sometimes the whole bloody game is rotten to the core and you should walk away. Speaking for myself and you might be right to disagree with me here, I'm of the opinion that Israel and Hamas are engaged in a bloody game rotten to the core, and Americans need to stop running intellectual/emotional defense for Netanyahu's reputation. The man had all the resources to stop this war begot it happened, and he decided to let it proceed anyway, knowing exactly what would happen to the civilians. I'm not about to run defense for a man who doesn't want to be helped. The civilians on both sides are the ones who need help, that's where my attention will go.
Disagree, this was a very insightful perspective. “The hottest places in hell are reserved for those who, in times of great moral crisis, maintain their neutrality.”
“"Do not spread false rumors, and do not help a guilty person by giving false testimony. Do not follow the majority when they do wrong or when they give testimony that perverts justice. Do not show partiality to a poor person at his trial. "If you happen to see your enemy's cow or donkey running loose, take it back to him. If his donkey has fallen under its load, help him get the donkey to its feet again; don't just walk off. "Do not deny justice to a poor person when he appears in court. Do not make false accusations, and do not put an innocent person to death, for I will condemn anyone who does such an evil thing. Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe makes people blind to what is right and ruins the cause of those who are innocent.” (Exo 23:1-8, GNB)
"Why can't we just be pro people and anti wrong?" 1. Because everyone is righteous in their own eyes. Proverbs 21:2-3. 2. Because almost everyone is like the Pharisees, and not like the tax-collector: Luke 18:9-14. 3. Because we see ourselves as clean even when we are immersed in darkness. Proverbs 30:12 Asked to a murderous soldier, who had been propagandized from youth: "How could you have committed such atrocities?" Answer: "Easy. We were doing good and making the world a better place."
Nope, he's just an excessive blowhard, and if he was what I'm sure you're implying then there's no reason to believe he wouldn't be forthright about it.
I feel sad for myself and you Jordan .You have to stop nosing into political matters and stick to what you are helpful with. I learned about you in early 2021 and used to walk everyday listing to lectures and motivational videos about what you teach and how to be a better human, father , husband or son for hours but for the last year or so you are all about politics and debates and recently asking for the killing of people in a conflict that now is escalating very badly. I hope your family helps you out of this dark tunnel you have decided to walk yourself thru.
Dr. Peterson. Look here, man! I love you, I really do, but on the Palestinian/Israeli problem I do not think our understanding and thoughts aligns vis a vis the occupation and decimation of Palestinians . Your presentation here says that you are looking at this issue through the prism of your preferences. This serves to alienate good people. Anyone who wants to come over as a fair contributor to the debate has to look at the issue in its broader context and must have a deeper and clearer understanding of the problems. Any psychological analysis must take into account the entire gamut of psychosocial factors, a failure to place things in their proper context will undoubtedly necessitate unpleasant reactions such as the ones you receive. I believe that you have to properly familiarise yourself with this contentious problem lest it backfires.
I'm a big fan of so much of Peterson, especially the vintage stuff. Reading him changed me for the better and have so much appreciation in general for him and his work. I can't help but feel the bitterness, sarcasm and mockery in the delivery of what is actually probably useful information here, is only going to serve to polarise and entrench more. There's every justification for him to be embittered after everything he's been through, and he absolutely has the right to it. I guess I don't see people rolling over and acquiescing with their ideas in the face of lectures like these, when what they really probably want is some kind of acknowledgement that their pain matters, ala Chris Voss/Marshall Rosenberg/Carl Rogers work style work. We have to live together (as he's talked about with marriage and the divided US) and I don't see us shaming and ridiculing each other to that end. Too much pain on every side, we actually do need some softer edges to hold that so one side doesn't obliterate the other and we all end up going to hell. I hope he can help us further to that end as he's done for so many already.
Can you not see the hope of unity with pure evil was I’ll advised to begin with and is now ludicrous? As Rush said for years, you cannot compromise with this madness, you have to DEFEAT IT! And many years before his time, a wise man (and I do not remember who, so you can google it if interested ) “You cannot compromise with evil because evil will not compromise with you. Evil is out to take it all!” Evil abounds not only in foreign lands, but right here in the once great USA.
I think he's angry at the carnage. At least that's what seems to come across. I agree though with your comment that perhaps softer medicine is needed right now. Many ordinary Palestinians are in practical and existential pain, want and absolutely abject desolation. Everyone needs to separate those poor souls from the extremist thugs Peterson is so rightly angry with. I remember many years ago I went to a roundtable discussion with young people in their 20s who were members of the Basque separatist violent political arm of that party known as ETA. These young people genuinely believed in their cause and that violence was justified. I was shocked to discover that they saw no dichotomy in going to Mass on Sunday and then killing people in a car bombing later the same day. The same is probably true for some Palestinians who see Hamas as their people's voice. While understanding and empathizing with their pain, as gently as I can, I join my voice with those who remind us all that violence begets violence and brings out the worst in humankind. Terrorism has no place on this planet we must share together, no matter which group or organization engages in it. I ask all Muslims to imitate Allah, the all-merciful one. I, for my part, as a Christian imitating Christ's love for all as much as I am able, pledge to advocate for and to stand for peace wherever I may have influence and in whatever situation I may find myself. I stand in solidarity with my Muslim brothers and sisters as fellow people of the Book.
Pretentious to paraphrase Jordon but some of what I got was: religion needs to take a step back mullahs and rabbis need to be more humble(stop playing god) and the internet is bad. also Iran is a bad faith player in this global game.
I think one pertinent question is whether the reports are true of Netanyahu admitting his strategy was to support Hamas in order to prevent Palestinian unity. If they are, I think there would be something to say of Machiavelli and thuggery.
I generally agree with the premise of the message, especially as an Iranian-Canadian, but zero criticism of Israel? What does that imply? That Israel is completely beyond reproach here?
When one group does such animalistic behavior as that shown by Hamas when they attacked, there is no “both sides” argument to be made. Hamas must be eradicated. Period, end of story. Put as much effort as possible towards limiting innocent deaths, but Hamas (like any terror group) is filled with cowards that would rather hide behind civilians than face anyone in combat like actual men.
@@antibull4869I wonder how the victims of the first Holocaust and their supporters, can support and justify another Holocaust being perpetrated on the Palestinian people, crying ‘Hamas’, ‘Hamas’
I love JP, always have, I have immense respect for him. The issue starts, when a Psychologist feels he has a good grasp of the Theology of another religion. He needs to read the Quran to understand the underlying ideology of Islam. The doctrines of Islam, what the religion encourages them to do. Dr.Peterson thinks Islam is like Christianity, "Love your enemy" .How wrong can he be?
hello michael. i am pretty sure peterson confirmed that islam is shady after talking to the boastful mohammaed hijab two times. besides peterson has made it clear he is not interested in religious doctrine but the inner meaning of religious stories.
You have an American view os Islam. They too are called to love their enemies and banish hate from their hearts. It's only the radical version.....version....version of this religion. Ultimately that is all it is, another works religion full of satanic deception.
@@georgeh8937 religious stories? well I have news for him, religion is not the fairy tale he is looking for. if he wants story, he should read 1001 Arabian nights. Now, that is a story.
As a Muslim, Dr. Peterson I must say that listening to you always gives me relief in knowing that not everyone sees us as radical monsters - but that we too want peace. Hamas and the Mullahs are muslims only in name. The people of the book have much more in common than not, and I pray that one day we will find the unity and peace we're looking for.
You need to do something about the radical monsters though and only from within can they be fought, from a survivor of islam propagated genocide to you with love.
I suggest you read Acts of the Apostles . This scripture provides an exposition on free speech, and an indication that evil self interest always attempts to silence the truth from being spoken.
Your description of the pathology of the cluster B disorders is spot on! I too came to the same conclusion about the woke but I never made the connection to Marxism and religious extremism.
I'm confused as to how you didn't draw those connections. The woke act in very extremists ways by default, and their connection to Marxism is almost direct, with about 30% of their talking points being Marxian (meaning, Communist). Maybe you just saw the woke in isolation, is why?
@@SwitchTalkChannel Disenfranchised and hopeless people typically turn to radical ideologies to feel a sense of belongings; many times no matter the cost to current society.
@@SwitchTalkChannelI don’t think so, for that you don’t really need marxism to hate the abrahamic religions, there are plenty reasons that’s self-evident. Just imagine someone who literally thinks he is god, and his ideals must be followed by everyone else, and he will happily torture anyone who don’t obey his ideals for eternity IF HE CAN. So yeah, it deserves to be hated, narcissism at its very extreme.
No matter how controversial any of Jordan's statements may seem, there's always truth and good meaning behind the initial statement. When he decides to explain the reason behind his statements, it always shows that he's aligned with the truth and the good.
And it absolutely infuriates Atheists, because they can't make sense of it how a "religious charlatan" like him can be more helpful and pragmatic than their high and mighty brain power.
I listen to 95% of RUclips content at 1.5x or 2x speed, but when Dr. Peterson is speaking I have to slow it down so I can appreciate and absorb the brilliance and logic properly. His are also among the few videos I watch repeatedly because they inspire, educate, and chastise in equal measure.
I'm really sorry to say that but you completely missed the point. You are almost repeating what the main stream media is saying about the situation. The reality is that Israel has been occupying, killing, humiliating, discriminating, torturing, prisoning palestinian men, women and children for decades treating them like animals. No body aided them but left them to suffer. Some Palestinians lost hope and made a reaction and rsisted the brutal Isreali occupation. Yes their deed was brutal and included crimes which are condemned. But it was a reaction to a long history of slavery caused by the israeli. Any one who addresses what happened on the 7th of October without giving the context and the prehistory is missing the point. Ukrain is allowed to resist the russian occupation and supported with money, weapons and media coverage. On the other hand the palestinians are condemned if they resist the Israeli occupation. Imagin a woman being brutally raped by a strong, wealthy man every single day for years while neighbours and police pretend not see and never react even when the raper killed the children of that woman. At one point the woman tries to resist and fights back and plocks the eye of the raper. Then all the neighbours, police and the wprld starts condemning the raped woman for her deed and support the criminal man.
It amazes me how we live in an era so devoid of morality and ethics, where saying that you’re against violence and in the side of peace and the innocents that are victim of such atrocities, no particular side, will gain you nothing but being accused of wanting the murder of the Palestinian people.
He literally wrote "Give them hell" to his friend Netanyahu. The latter said Israel is an ethnonation only for Jews and wants to ethnic cleanse every non Jew and never allow anything resembling a Palestinian establishment. Bibi encouraged all Israeli parties to fund Hamas for that reason 3years ago
@@Lalakis does Hamas not constantly call for the genocide of the Jews? Haven’t they expressed themselves very clearly that they don’t want peace, they want the lands back. Didn’t the Arab forces in WWII ally themselves with Hitler and follow his path of genocide towards the Jews? This is not a one side has all the blame. Although I do blame the American warmongering left, and their government. Not only is Ukraine their fault for their unwillingness to negotiate, but the tensions im the middle eastern zone are high once again because he refused to keep working on what Trump achieved with the Abraham accords, and his utter failure in the Afghanistan departure besides leaving a bunch of expensive arsenal to be distributed, showed the geopolitical and military incompetency of his government and Biden’s current leadership.
@@Lalakisprobably referring to said thugs who are using religion as a veil for radical beliefs and violence, NOT INNOCENT Palestinians, right? Just think about it a little bit more, that’s all
@@Lalakis Netanyahu is Jew-supremacist. And the only reason that has come to pass into law is because all the Arab natins near it are Muslim-supremacist, and this entire conflict is about Muslim-supremacy. There was fundamentally no other reason why the Arab states opposed the creation of a Jewish state. Netanyahu is not for ethnic cleansing or genocide, but Hamas' founding document anticipates genocide of the Jews in the name of Allah. When Muslims see nonmuslims behaving just like they have, or not even as badly, they have an anueurysm about how unfair it is.
Wow, I never thought I would experience those college classes, in which you want to get an understanding of something but the only thing you are left with at the end, is more confusion. You see, big words and psychological analysis of a situation serve only as a red herring when the situation is quite simple to understand. Moreover, one tends to over-explain and overcomplicate the matter when one is given a narrative and is told to stick to it no matter what. This also happens when one goes against one’s own values and beliefs. In order to make the response less shameful and avoid more damage to the self, ego, and reputation, one gives an overly complex and highly irrelevant response in the hopes, that the audience will be overwhelmed by the complexity and fail to notice the irrelevance of the response. This is a great technique, because one gets to, later on, “clarify” and “rectify” the complexly vague response. The truth is always apparent and bright. Similar to the Sun. One can never cover or cloud the truth for too long. Similarly, the clouds can never cover the Sun for too long. Unlike, when the Sun is covered with black clouds, there’s benefit, however, when one attempts to cover the truth with black clouds, there’s only destruction.
@@wildboar122 his response is nothing but irrelevant. He mentions only the resistance shown on October 7th, in which innocent people have been killed which is unacceptable. (Palestinians have been suffering this everyday for 70+ years) Nothing at all about the ongoing indiscriminate and brutal Israeli air strikes that have killed at least 1500 children. He was quick to tweet “Give ‘em hell” on October 7th, but somehow he is slower than a slug for condemning the killing of children, women and elderly. And he won’t condemn it. To be honest, his condemnation is not needed anyway. These kinds of people come and go but the truth remains.
If you actually sat through all 20 minutes of this video and truly believe it was "big words and psychological analysis" serving as a "red herring", I am truly sorry for you. That is outright unbelievable and saddening to read. Best of luck with your future learning.
And those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it. But studying history alone does not give us solutions, it only gives us context. Sometimes we have to leave the past behind.
I’ve been to Israel in October 2015 and we met and ate with Jews, Muslims, & Christians all at the same table and yes at the same time. We shared our love for good food (Pakistani mothers made lunch for us every day except for Friday, their holyday), love for family, friends and for Israel who Jewish doctors were treating Muslim children from Iraq, Pakistan, Iran… that needed heart surgery. We spent time, cared for the Muslim children and mothers/fathers as they were getting we medical care. So yes we can live together, serve together, and enjoy live together.
I have cousins in israel and every time I go there to visit, we hangout together, with their arab friends, who work as policemen. Arab men working as policemen in israel. The media will never show that
I doubt if most people know that 21% of people living and working in Israel (and who are allowed to vote) are not Jews or Palestinians. They are from other religions - Christianity, Moslems, etc. @@arimoff
I love you Jordan. Online hate and shaming is a hivemind-like process. Andrew Tate and his following call you unintelligent and wrong when they are hardly able to THINK, period. Love you as always jordan, very adequately spoken and elegant and graceful. Thank you for the update revolving around the bias clipped no-context narratives being spun around online about you, without letting you have the chance to defend yourself in civil discussion and break down and or clarify points made and rooted for against you. I stand with you, and I stand with Israel ♥️
@@lordpenetron4285 One thing out of this and the Ukraine war I can say are a positive, is seeing all these people who love BOTH sides civilians, and not just one sides. Everyone has a bias to who they think the enemy is in this war, but regardless of who has that opinion, myself included, we all rally to pray and hope for the civilians ♥️🙏
Shekoyach (meaning with strength in Hebrew - an exhortation) Jordan Peterson! What an amazing speech - every word could be not more true and insightful.
Love hearing JP and his take on human nature which is spot on. The thugs get rich off the sheep who want to feel they are good people while in reality they blindly follow elitist goals and gains via political rhetoric
In college I took Judaism classes to study the differences between Orthodox, Reform, Conservative, and Reconstructionist Jews. I went on a synagogue tour to learn more about all the different kinds of Judaism. I did volunteer work at the museum of tolerance. And I have always admired Israel but now I am angry to see so many Palestinian children dying. And I feel I can not continue to feel the same way about Israel. I feel like something is dying inside of me. Like when someone you love betrays you 💔
Please remember it’s not Orthodox Jews it is a facet of Zionists who don’t care and only seek to obtain the land. There are jewish people that stand against the apartheid and occupation it’s just in Israel they face two years jail time for speaking out.
We just aren’t hearing their voices because there is a language barrier and they are being silenced by jail time for the last decades or even longer. On RUclips search you will see proof of this in some documentaries. They also state that these Zionists do not follow the Torah because they have been stealing land via settlements and land grabbing which is fundamentally considered a sin.
HAMAS made the children stay so they could hide behind them like the cowards they are, IDF gave opportunity and warning to leave the warzone at their own additional risk.
I have deep admiration for Dr. Peterson ability to explain very complex issues that affect the individuals in our western society, however his interpretation of the geopolitical clashes around the globe is inadequate. I’m hopeful that won’t be too long before Dr. Peterson comes to terms with the emergence of a Tri-polar world as China and Russia grow to more parity with the United States.
I have always been a fan of Jordan Peterson and followed everything, but this is something I don't think anyone who is of influence should be put in the opinion in. I don't think anybody truly knows enough. I don't think either side is correct. I don't know the end result but I don't think either side. I'll do in the right thing
Opinions definitely no. Facts yes. Read the Balføur Déclaration and understand that Zionists' Rothschild bankers funded the two world wars for the creation is Ißrael. Ißrael is the occupier for 75 years. The other side is the so called boogeymen hàmàs. It is a creation of Ißrael Møssad to use as false flags and avoid peace and to perpetuate bombing Palestinians on false pretexts. Don't take my word on it, go ahead and fact check. There are many reliable expertsnabd historians on this issue that dedicated their whole lives on it and does not have a monopoly in supporting either side, JP is not it. “Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palest inian state has to support bolstering Ha mas and transferring money to Ha mas,” he [Neta nyahu] told a meeting of his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy - to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.” (Haaretz, October 9, 2023, emphasis added)
This is the game behind the game. And without knowing what's truly at play in the world right now on this event and what's at stake, everyone is heading right into the pit they've dug. I hope the machinations of evil doesn't prevail and we achieve peace and unity.
Unlikely, we need a massive catastrophe to then learn our lesson. We have had “relative”peace since the Cold War. But no true peace with tension on going throughout the world.
@@creed22solar123 how about you watch israel videos of what they did? a HOSPITAL was bombed today, 500 Palestinian lives were taken, 80 of them were children, this is a WAR CRIME and your hypocrisy is astonishing
@@creed22solar123hàmàs is a creation of Ißrael Møssad to avoid peace and use as false flags, so it is a game and you are losing because you don't read a history book that false flagging is the oldest trick in the book. JP is also playing with all of you like pawns on his chessboard, we know very well he had dinners with Netanyahu, they are in bed with this, the warmonger and the propagandist henchman.
Much better put. Get off Twitter for your own good. You gained popularity through long form content with well explained and thought out ideas. Twitter posts don’t allow that.
(To cut it short on the parrots - We condemn Hammas in what they did on Oct the 7th, got it? now I can speak). As a half European half Arab Muslim, despite all I've learned from Dr. Peterson; I find this video offensive in many different ways. 1. Addressing Muslims as a bunch of poor astray children that are simply crying out there unable to recognize political alliances from true friends. 2. Dismissing everything relevant to the facts related to the Arab/Israeli conflict in its entirety and the factual systematic ethnic cleansing driven by Israel with the support of its allies in the west. 3. I believe its as factual as the sunlight - what Israel is currently doing exceeds many of the Nazi crimes, to have an open concentration camp live before the entire world's eyes systematically carpet bombing 2 million people whom half of them are children, this is is not a war, it is an oppressive ethnic cleansing no matter what the justification is. 4. To claim and dictate to us what Allah wants from us; that is one hell of a statement to make - yes, you have read, meeting few online influencers - I am sad to inform you that after almost watching all you had to say in public about Islam and Arabs no matter how genuine you were - you are far from understanding the core values and the teachings of Islam. 5. You obviously realized the magnitude of the online response to your statement earlier and If this video was an attempt to manage the crisis, it is another offense, I've watched it till the end - I am truly disappointed. In the end, we have a say in the Arab world, everyman can be quoted/taken from and argued against, no matter the side you choose, you are to be credited in certain fields where you are an expert without a doubt and there is a lot to learn from you - but it is sad, truly sad to learn that you were not true to yourself and to the public in being a seeker of the truth and to learn about the dual standards that became very evident.
Well done bro. Excellent answer. Personally for me...Jordan Peterson is a real disappointment, especially after that terrible tweet of his about the Palestinians.
As a human being, what must not be lost is conscience and common sense. because there are so many smart people who don't have a conscience and common sense that can destroy a civilization. It's quite sad to see people who are and have great influence using their strengths but not using their conscience and common sense. can't see the good and the bad, can't see what is appropriate or inappropriate to do.
yeah, too bad Jordan Peterson can't see the good in those Hamas videos of them in Israel recently, having fun at the festival etc. And that he can't see the bad in Israelis trying to rid the world of these peace loving humans, without understanding that this is simply a middle-eastern tactic of negotiation. I am very disappointed in JP.
Happy that this world hero is from right here in Alberta, Canada:) the voice of God is logic and love, this man is at the top of both, more people should listen to this man for a better and more peaceful life.
I can't say agree with you with my mom coming from Lebanon. I/my ancestors has seen what Islam has done to middle-east Christians and jews since its inception. Their God has a standing order to destroy non-believers and their quran/hadiths on jews is disturbing though it makes you understand why some do what they do and others celebrate their evil acts as uncomfortable as that may be to observe.
I agree. islam is a tyranny. I believe science will save us. like look at the space race or nuclear power or internet or now Mars. like even if islam got it's so called victory do you think they can make it afterward? I think islam is just a blood thirsty tyranny that wants to bring chaos and dance in it
I started to read the Quran to have first hand understanding of what it says. It’s very disturbing, the explicit hatred and contempt for Jews and Christians is eye opening.
Is-Lame is the reason for all the Terrorism. Surah 9:29 Fight those People of the Book who do not believe in Allah, nor in the Last Day, and do not take as unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have declared as unlawful, and do not profess the Faith of Truth; (fight them) until they pay jizyah with their own hands while they are subdued.
It's important to clarify that religions themselves are not inherently at fault, but rather it's a minority of individuals who exploit religion as a cover to achieve their selfish goals, often at the expense of people's well-being. Additionally, even ideologies like communism, which are typically anti-religion, can develop their own form of "belief system" to exert control over people. Therefore, it's crucial to distinguish between genuine religious beliefs and the actions of a malevolent minority.
The religion is entirely at fault. What do you think the goal of Islam is? Look at the Saudi flag for instance. Why do you think they underlined the passage of all and muhamad with a sword? Don't be stupid.
There are a few issues I take with this video: 1. Bringing in the rationality of the LGBTQ community in the light of this war, is a distracting side-show that has no bearing on the military conflict whatsoever. 2. Does anti-thug mean being anti state-bombing of an occupied civilian population? I did not hear anything being adressed in relation to the actions of israel (which are still ongoing).
A wise man once said that If more people assumed they could learn from "truly listening" to others, they might actually learn something they didnt know.
@@Rick-bi9fw Peterson is a man who becomes quite emotional when he's listened to the distressing journey's of the human experience. To place him in a sentence as though he is condoning suffering of innocence in "concentration camps" has demonstrated clearly your incapacity to "truly listen".
@@pauliewalsh6875he invited Netanyahu to his podcast and have dinners, many have adviced in comments, don't go down the route, he did not listen. Calling people who disagrees with him and I quote on his X account murderous anti Semitic rats is hardly listening. He had many many discourses and I listened to it all but I felt when it comes to with Muslims it's always gaslighting because he turn around the next week and stab them in the back pretending they didn't have a cordial discussion explaining all his queries or criticisms. It's because I've been following closely to his content that I know he doesn't listen.
“The Accords, mediated by the Trump administration, were hailed as a major breakthrough in Middle East diplomacy. However, the agreements have been met with widespread opposition from Palestinians, who believe they fail to address the root causes of the conflict. When asked about the impact of the Accords, 52 percent of those surveyed said that the agreement had made Israel more aggressive towards the Palestinians, while 43 percent said they had seen no impact or change, and only 6 percent said they believed the agreement had made the situation better. The results of the poll highlight a deep mistrust of Palestinians towards a possible peaceful resolution of the conflict, as they show that the Abraham Accords failed to produce tangible improvements for Palestinians.” Dr peterson, how can you see the abraham accords as a true peaceful solution while it completely ignores the palestenians and the two state solution in any form? How can you see this as a true diagnosis? You taught us to think and criticise. To tackle root causes. Hamas attacking not limiting their prison break to military targets made a grave grave mistake yes enticed by iran you are right. But how about the root cause doctor? Please address this i urge your humanity to address it
The problem is that the world is not run by people like Jordan but by Rothschild who use violence and deceit. The division of labor in the world is forced by force, not by industry. China is effectively breaking the dollar, soon more Arab countries were to join BRICS and America and Israel do not want to lose influence in the Middle East. There will be a bloody union with many countries, a greater conflict than in Ukraine. That's why America immediately sent aircraft carriers there as if for a war, they are waiting for a signal, probably a false flag.
how isn't every description you gave for the "thugs" doesn't apply to Israel more, historically and now? If you decide to turn a blind eye to the thugs who started all of this and are maintaining it, don't judge the other side.
Is it just me or does any1 else notice how everything he says from 7:49 to 8:43 seems to describe Israel's government extremely well 🤔 Bassem Youssef just made this exact same point the other day on Piers Morgans show and suddenly a psychologist breaks the whole thing down and now it's hard to not see all of the "dark tetrad" qualities of the Israeli govt and Military 🤣
As a Pole i wish the best for Iran and its ppl. I hope we can one day be united. My great grandfather escaped to Iran during ww2 when Poland was over run by the Nazis and Soviets. 75,000 polish soldiers and 40,000 polish civilians managed to make it to Iran. Most were shipped in from the USSR, some basically made it their on foot. Even though Iran supplied hitler with oil early on, the Iranian government and its ppl took in over 100,000 poles into their homes and government buildings sharing what little food and supplies they had. My great grand father escaped occupied Poland and with the help of polish units already in iran he received support and walked and hitch hiked from europe all the way to Iran with his army unit. They joined the allies and fought in the Italian campaigns. He was part of the units that liberated the Monastery at Monte Cassino and later attacked the Hitler line which led to the Anzio breakthrough opening the road to Rome. this led to the Italians surrendering, Killing Benito Mussolini and joining the Allied armies. lol rant over. i just like ww2 and the many achievements of my family in those days . Fun fact, The biggest refugee cemetary in iran is Polish. its is to this day taken care of and maintained by the ppl of Iran. I have a picture of my great grandfather giving a iranian child a chocolate bar, hes never eaten chocolate in his life before this. He looked like he discovered the meaning of life after eating the chocolate, I have one picture of my great grandfather of him together with the Iranian family who took him into their home when he first made it to Iran, I wish i could somehow track down their living relatives but all I have is a picture, no names, no city..... the only hope would be for someone to recognize the background and somehow find out the general area of where the pic was taken. maybe one day........
So I was listening to Jordan Petersons exodus. It has been absolutely incredible couldn’t recommend it enough. However there was a passage they awkwardly skipped over that I wish they addressed. Exodus 15:14: "The people shall hear, and be afraid: sorrow shall take hold on the inhabitants of Palestina."
@@isabelblancas8230 I, for one, listened to all of it. And the silence of what he DIDN'T say was so clangingly loud it nearly wrecked the eardrums of my soul. You go ahead, dear, and keep enjoying the intoxication from the devil's cup of your confirmation bias.
@turtlesongs2012 Disregarding your personal attacks because you don't actually care about the issue or topic here. What did you want him to say that would affirm your opinion of him lacking criticism?
@@ibraheemkhan6660the hell the Muslims have coming is well deserved. They’ve been a thorn in the side of Christians and Jews for centuries. Although at some basic level the 3 religious sects do have something common. Maybe everyone should consider that. However I don’t see it ever happening because concessions would have to be made.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Link to The Telegraph Article: www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/10/16/unholy-axis-of-iranian-thugs-and-marxist-psychopaths/
Are you getting a cut for the telegraph subscription?
Sir, you are now officially a businessman, in my opinion, not the truth seeker you once were. Nothing wrong with that.
@@strodo7013I am not dismissing your comment but can't he be both a business man and a truth seeker?
@@doctorlefthandthreadNot entirely (my opinion), if you want your business (image, influence, whatever) to do well there will be some form of bias involved in your thought process even if its subconscious.
Here's one of many, many Jews who desperately wish we could be at peace - as demonstrated by the thousands of years in which Jews have never once instigated war or violence.
@@strodo7013 thanks for answering. I only asked because I wanted to understand what you meant.
Why can't people just be "pro people" and "anti wrong"??
Well because people are bad and sometimes wrong is better
Because we’re broken
that would make you anti islam
War is just a racket.
A racket is best described, I believe, as something that is not what it seems to the majority of people.
Only a small inside group knows what it is about.
It is conducted for the benefit of the very few at the expense of the masses.
- Major General Smedley Butler
Lack of widespread critical thinking skills. Coupled with the mob mentality of identarian manipulation, clever leaders can move millions to acts of inhuman violence.
As a Jew I stand with our muslim sisters and brothers
God bless 👍
God bless you and all the jews who are against the war (in USA and elsewhere). We see you and we will not forget. We lived together thousands of years in North Africa. History attest of that.
If you read the quoran you wouldn’t be saying that. Jews and Muslims are literally mortal enemies. All that positive bs is gonna get your head cut clean off by a true Muslim when the time comes.
@@BrikMalek Surely (the ones) who have disbelieved among the population of the Book (Or: family of the Book; i.e., the Jews and Christians) and the associators (Those who associate others with Allah) will be in the Fire of Hell, eternally (abiding) therein; those are they who are the most evil beings (Literally: Initiated creatures).
@@reemm4696 read quran 98:6 it says jews and christians are the worst of cretures worst then dogs and bugs , allah puts the sins of muslims on christians and jews who will burn in hell forever they teach you guys are morons maybe READ R E A D THE QURAN
We should hold world leaders to account. The same way we are treated for illegal actions.
Unfortunately that sometimes means war. Dictators don't normally turn themselves in.
Essentially a new world order is requisite, other than the current setup of de-facto darwinism hiding behind a thin veneer of exclusively western hypocrite morality.
I am so so with JP....sometimes he is right but to me he is another over hyped font of dubious wisdom to be taken at face value, issue by issue.
Iran and Saudi Arabia of late have actually being moving closer together and while I don't have to like any of their rulers any more than I like the American infants in the room, I do not, like Jordan, convenientlly give them chief bogey man status.
The chief bogey man status in this conflict is undoubtedly Israel, or more specifically, Bibi, Likud and the fanatic Jews who continue to steal land and murder innocents in the West Bank - not to mention that it was they who created Hamas in the first place.
@@macnicolson5452 ---I would much rather have america as a ruler than Saudi arabia or Iran; I cannot imagine anyone thinking otherwise.
Who hold world leaders accountable? Then let me ask who holds that group or person accountable?
Dr. Peterson, I'm a long time viewer and follower of your content. You've inspired and changed many across the whole world. While I appreciate the sentiment expressed inside your article, there's a severe misrepresentation that takes place here.
While any rational person must rightly condemn what Hamas did on October 7th, most of the protests that take place aren't an expression of solidarity with Hamas, but a just condemnation of what Israel has done in the occupied West Bank and Gaza. You speak about the Iran backed Hamas and what happens in Israel/ Gaza as a consequence, but how does that explain the year-on-year deaths of dozens, sometimes hundreds, of innocent Palestinians in the West bank?
The government there is secular and nationalist in nature. It has recognised Israel since 1993 and it is powerless to do anything about the constantly en-roaching Israeli settlements, which are illegal under international law. They suffer daily indignities and humiliations. Some might even say that it is possible to appreciate how this could potentially radicalise some people.
As for Gazans, they do not represent Hamas. 50% of the population is below the age of 18. What Israel does with them is completely disproportionate. And while people from all over the world are asked or expected to condemn the atrocities of Hamas, the same leaders and pundits are relatively silent when it comes any of the litany of wrongs Israel has visited on the Palestinian peoples.
This is what people are protesting.
Well said
It's spelled croissant, dummy.
100%
@@zarine1958 100% with a terrorist apologist?
WRONG: this has nothing to do with "occupation" you are spewing the "palestinian" lie. Take the case of Ahmad Manasra at 13 in 2015 stabbed two israeli's. How do you get a 13yr old to commit such atrocities? child abuse and indoctrinate in a false ideology that Israel is changing the status of AlAksa! ie.. not occupation, not oppression, not apartheid or any other lie. The lie is AlAksa.. and the Jewish people, being the indigenous owners of the land of Israel of course had a temple there 1000 years or so before Islam was invented. So your false narrative reflects your ignorance of history.. now go learn! ps.. Hamas entry? called the AlAksa Flood! The 1929 hebron massacre? 20 years before the state of israel? motivation: change of status of AlAksa.. getting the pattern now? This is about a false ideology trying to push western democracies off this planet.
I have seen and heard enough of Mr. Peterson that I knew he was referring Hamas terrorists and NOT Muslims. But people that are looking for division, and attention and gains are being deceitful. As always thanks for such a bird's eye view in the whole situation. I'm still heart broken for all Jews, Palestinian victims of violence. Praying .
How do we separate the "Palestinians" that elected a savage Muslim terrorist govt?
A man with the level of intellect as Mr. Peterson should've clearly stated Hamas in his statement and not just, give them he'll. Whose the "them" he was referring too. I truly admire Mr. Peterson and listen to nearly all his podcast. He even interviewed Mohammed hajib twice or more on his channel, but I could see how people misconstrued what he said, because I was one of them. I say peace to all the innocent people and animals on both sides! The Earth itself is being destroyed with all those drone strikes and bullets.
Weird video title
Pray into one hand and poop in the other, see which one fills up first.
The Palestinians are not victims. They have earned their violent deaths. They deliberately put the people responsible for this attack in power because they hate the Israelis as much as the attackers did. The Palestinians are no different from the Terrorists they support. I have no dog in this fight in terms of religion as an atheist, but that should be obvious to all outside observers.
Jordan Peterson said - if you love God you will hate evil
Strange, that’s the opposite of what Christ taught
@@blueguitarist Yeah, Jesus taught to love evil.
@@theshizzzyea… no but nice bait
Just pointing out the idiocy of this guy's comment.@@TheAncientEmo
Yet Hamas, al-Qaeda, IS, Boko Haram, al-Shabaab all say they' have god on their side.
Harry Nilsson said this. "You see what you want to see, and you hear what you want to hear." It somehow seems relevant, because there are no easy answers in life even when things are going relatively well and smoothly.
Mr. Peterson, could you ask Mr. Netanyahu why he hasn't adhered to UN resolutions, dismantled settlements, or taken meaningful steps toward peace in the past 30 years? We, Palestinians, desire peace, but continuous massacres and lack of genuine efforts hinder progress. We seek understanding and a peaceful coexistence.
I also expected you to address the recent massacre at the Ahli Hospital in Gaza perpetrated by the Israeli occupation forces
We desire peace, but not a peace that displaces 60% of us, incarcerates us, and seizes our sacred sites. We seek a fair and comprehensive peace that addresses all issues simultaneously, rather than one that benefits one side at the expense of the other.
The undeniable truth remains: Israel functions as a colonial power. While peaceful assistance and development are welcome, their actions have instead led to humiliation, massacres, destruction of our identity, and the seizure of our sacred places-all justified by unfounded claims to the land. I urge you to be fairer and more open-minded. While we welcome Jews, we reject the imposition of colonial power. Regardless of your arguments, the harsh realities on the ground remain unchanged, sir.
JP is a hypocrite repeating israeli talking points
As an Israeli I think the problem is Hamas, I know netanyahu gives them money but still.. we are a democratic country and eventually he will be retired and replaced by someone better. I think as a community you need to somehow kick the terror (Hamas) of Gaza because we Israelis want peace too and the terror makes it impossible for us 😞
What happened on 7.10 deeply traumatized me. I lived under rockets in the middle of Tel Aviv! Also southern Israel has lived under rockets their whole lives and me? I was in a bubble in Tel Aviv I didn't understand how traumatizing it is for the southern Jews in Israel.
I hope you understand my point,
Peace doesn't come from one side. The world doesn't work like that. If you want peace you should somehow kick out Hamas.❤🇮🇱✌🏻🕊️☮️
@@Gili44 but the settlements project started in 1964, Hamas were founded in 1989
@@emad3241 there was plently of terror and murdering jews before the name "hamas" 🤦🏻♀️
@@Gili44 There were terror from both sides long before Israel were founded, what matters is that today it's Israel who have the power to stop this, but they would rather build settlements and occupy more land
This is not a religious matter. This has nothing to do with "Muslim" or "Jew" whether you are pro or not!what is happening is wrong. The people who are being killed are PEOPLE. It's enough to say that we are all PRO-LIFE and pro the right to know that you DESERVE to live!!!!!
It's nice to think like that, but no one cared about "people" when Seria killed 400k people in its land. When it comes to Israel everyone stand on their toes..
People actually stop to think whether Israel is just or not with it's response to a massicure, rape, killing of a prognant women and opening her belly and killing the unborn. Monstrosities that no one could imagin
And yet, the world talks about "maybe Hamas is right"
It's not about people, it's about the world not getting the idea of jews in their land. 😢
Yes. Well, also, technically "Muslim" is a culture, not a religion afaik, but it gets thrown around as a word and used in so much variety of ways i'm probably just being pedantic. Anyways, i mostly just wanted to give you props for making the simple, to-the-point, statement that brings the focus to a better one; talk (dogma, philosophy etc) is useful/interesting but in the end, actions matter most.
The fact that Muslim and Jew is being thrown in so heavily is making this a antiseptic and Islamophobic phenomenon even though as you said it should not.
Exactly many in the West fail to realize MeNA has always beeb multi faith this is about occupation and this video is so off
Israel overplayed their hand. I was disgusted by the kidnapping and the actions of Hamas. But the response from Israel has been far more barbaric. In the sense that it is a clear eye for an eye meant to teach a lesson to the people in Gaza. As if the retaliation of Hamas was simply reduced to them being lovers of war. As if there was no need to consider the conditions in which Gaza exists. The lack of old Republicans to understand that they would probably fight twice as hard if they were living under such conditions. For far less than that, they kicked the British out. This is a new turning point; not only the new right could not careless about Israel, but the unconditional support Israel dies with the next layer of humans who are in line to complete their cycle of life.
I know this won’t be read but Peterson should read “people of the lie” it’s a great book about this exact thing. Hiding in institutions of power and holiness to hide your evil.
“People of the Lie” was one of the scariest books I’ve ever read. True, unequivocal evil.
Ilan Pape is a good start too
Its hopeless I really thought this guy was better than the rest of them..
People of the lie sounds like book about Jews
Well I'd like to read it so thanks for the suggestion on my part. ☺️
While I appreciate this message, the main problem I see is that the thuggery of Netanyahu goes unmentioned.
Netanyahu was aiming to become the supreme leader of Israel prior to this conflict and was in trouble. Now, he is using this conflict to gain back control.
Too convenient.
8 days prior to the attack, Egypt warned Israel it was coming. Israel ignored the warnings.
Too convenient.
On the day of the attack, security forces were absent from the border and no warning went out to Israelis until 9-12 hours after the incursion, leading to a completely unnecessary massacre.
Did they get a stand down order? It's starting to look that way.
Simultaneously, the Iron Dome underperformed that day.
You need to look deeper, as you are buddies with a man that clearly knew this attack was coming, and that allowed it to happen.
A man who himself is in part responsible for building up Hamas.
Everything points to the Israeli administration having betrayed their people to cement total power, and you're cosying up to them.
As somebody who has studied tyranny and evil for so long, that you should fail to at the very least consider this in the hour of need is very hard to tolerate.
So please, wake up.
You were too slow with Covid, but got there in the end.
I know you are under enormous pressure, but please be faster this time, even at the cost of your relationship with Shapiro and Netanyahu.
Thank you for stating the truth and facts 💯
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palest inian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” he [Neta nyahu] told a meeting of his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy - to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.” (Haaretz, October 9, 2023, emphasis added)
Full of soy, this guy. AND estrogen.
So was and is the deal with my country Iran, except that our number 1 man is literally called the supreme leader and it has been this way for almost 40 years! Although at the end i definitely do not support netanyaho and i do think that doctor Peterson is making a mistake in taking sides with him. Almost of this is spot on the people ruling over us are certainly an evil bunch. And I'm pretty thay they've done even more damage to the image of islam then terrorist groups like ISIS did
not to mention that now we know a LOT more about what happened (or DIDN'T happen) on Oct 7th and the important role the IDF played in the killing that day... Hannibal Directive...
Dr Peterson I would like to thank you deeply. I know you probably won't see this but your work and lectures have changed my life for the better in significant ways, I got in contact with my father (who left when I was 2) I cleaned my room, I left my "friends" who in reality are drug addicts, I started improving myself and looking deeply inside myself while asking the question who am I. Turns out I was a young boy with potential, and that potential has been slowly fading. So i have taught myself discipline, I have been rough but truthful And I have started to become my best self. So my deepest thank you, Dr Peterson for changing my life, and making me open my eyes. I cannot thank you enough.
Without you I would be a fatherless depressed, angry person, living in my hoarder mother's home. With your help I changed that. For that I am truly grateful
Even if he never sees your comment, I did and was glad. Keep up the good work!
You brought tears to my eyes, Brother. I'm proud of you.
I'm happy for you, dr. Peterson is a friend of my soul too .
Very well done. That’s a LOT of hard work and preserving
This speaks to many young men I personally know.
I genuinely feel that ur entire monologue applies also to Israel even more than iran or hamas thoug
You've made your position abundantly CLEAR. No need to play with words❤
His postion being?
Israel good, Palestinians bad
@@GeneralMorphie "send them hell"
@@keo0101 and they should send them hell. If you disagree, take a look at any of the videos where Hamas shows you themselves what they did in Israel. It will make you sick and traumatize you, but at least you'll know this is no play. ❤🩹
@@creed22solar123you've fallen for the trap Netanyahu sets every time he gets elected. Well done
Their land? It's the Palestinian's land
Tell God that! They are Arabs, Palestinian is an adopted name.
@@masada2828 Palestinians are Arabs, you genius. So if they are Arabs, they should die or leave their land or something? Weren't there Palestinian jews all throughout history, yes, Arab jews you
Eh Not anymore
Your knowledge of history is faulty.
@@joannecash7243oh do please enlighten me with the correct history
I pray for you continually, Dr. Peterson. We Christians have been poor stewards of the souls around us, and it is only by the truthfulness of teachers like you that we can exist. We have not lived the way that we ought to live, we have not said the words that we ought to say, and we have not loved in the way that we ought to love: "If the Lord of hosts had not left us a few survivors, we should have been like Sodom, and become like Gomorrah."
"Once the Messiah comes, all the nations will be subservient to the Jewish people" -Eruvin 43b
@@bojackson3073 why are you quoting the Talmud? What's your point?
"All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God." Romans 3:23. Jesus is the only sacrificial lamb of God whereby fallen man can be united with God
"We Christians"
You don't speak for me.
@@John-uo1qf We are God's chosen people.
"One who slaps the cheek of a Jew is considered as though he slapped the cheek of the Divine Presence" Sanhedrin 58b
I recommend reading the text version of this statement by Dr. Peterson - I found it easier to process, follow, and go back when I didn't immediately comprehend something.
Telegraph article is called "This unholy axis of Iranian thugs and Marxist psychopaths is an enemy of Muslims too"
What about the unholy axis of Israeli oppressors and American Capitalists?
Thanks for this information…I’m also needing to digest this again.
@@cameronclark3725what about, what about, what about. That’s the drama triangle he outlines. Blame someone else. It’s never my fault.
@@cameronclark3725 hello cameron clark. did you read about the palestinian partition the United Nations came up with decades ago. to my eyes arabs and jews got pretty equal shares. jews got the coastal cities and arabs got the inland cities. jerusalem would be a special administrative area like the vatican. but arabs would not accept the division and attacked in 1947..
@@cameronclark3725If you have something to say, why not write your own article about it? Not everyone focuses on the same issues you do (for good reasons).
What about the Palestinians oppressed by Israel in the West Bank. I haven't heard a single good explanation for it. Israel needs to take their own religion seriously.
Mr. Peterson! I have followed you for many years. I have read and watch everything you published! It is very unfortunate to see how much you have changed since you started working for Ben Shapiro, the change is extremely evident! You are a very strong minded individual and you will most likely never believe my observation in this matter! But it is very obvious! I truly hope one day we will get back the wise Dr. Peterson.
Totally agree.
Ben Shapiro, great guy.
@@Bitcoinaire1If you say so, Mr Hamas.
@@johncollins8304"Ben Shapiro the smartest guy to walk on earth'" Bassem Yousef
@@johncollins8304 no, I’m not Israel’s payroll. If your empty head did not know, Bibi Yahu said they fund Hamas to keep Palestinians divided.
Jordan Peterson out here spitting it like a diss track to these guys
With all due respect Dr. Peterson. There seems to be a conflation of parties here with two very vocal portions and one that speaks some level of civility, on one side you have those favoring Israel ignoring the crimes that are openly committing by simply pointing out the atrocities hamas committed and on the other rests a very confused pro hamas group that defends their actions based on some perceived slight. But neither of you seem to be willing to listen to reason and those that ask for simply all civilians be allowed to exit the Gaza Strip so Israel can properly address the terrorists threat that is hamas.
“If anyone has ears to hear, let him hear.” And He said to them, “Take heed what you hear. With the same measure you use, it will be measured to you; and to you who hear, more will be given. For whoever has, to him more will be given; but whoever does not have, even what he has will be taken away from him.” Mark 4:23-25
So invading Al Masjid Al AQSA "a muslim-only holy building" with dirty shoes of Israeli people and kicking palestinians out of their houses and properties a million times with no reason or justification is okay, but when palestinians stand up for their country and do some counterattacks as a reaction it's called terrorism? Thank you DR. JP for making me lose all the respect i once had for you and most importantly thanks for prioritizing some people's lives over others'.
Why is Al aqsa a Muslim only building?
It’s where the Jewish holy temple once stood. How come the Jews aren’t allowed to go there?
The only houses demolished by the idf is the houses of people who have killed innocent civilians as an act of terror. That is not for no reason.
If the idf destroyed houses for no reason there would be none left.
@Dewbird6995 there is no single historical proof of the claimed Temple Mountain, nor there is any evidence that the biblical text that speaks about it was said by or revealed to Moses.
@@Dewbird6995if the idf wasn’t choosing places at random they wouldn’t tell everyone everywhere to leave the area. If they knew they were hitting H homes they wouldn’t give them a heads up.
@@Absolute42 lmfao. Sometimes I want to respond to people but when they say some outstandingly dumb things I give up. “the idf has only destroyed terorrists houses” 😂😂😂
Its terrorism because they purposely went after civilians, they could have only gone after military targets because the idf doesnt hide behind women and children like hamas does, so they cant go after specific military targets when they are located in schools, hospitals, apartment buildings etc. I dont blindly support israel, i dont blindly support hamas, but i, and many others who arent driven by ideological propaganda from either side, are anti hamas, we are saying this while acknowledging both sides have their legitimate grievances.
Honestly this type of content available for free is stunning to me. I just dropped my jaw, and learned more than I have in the last 20 years. Sir please take care of yourself Voices that ring this true. Have been silenced by the scum of the universe time and time again!
thats cause you're simple minded
@@catnapgee5357 I mean do you actually feel better about yourself now?
What's your excuse for piping up irrationally here towards @BwAaS whilst he was attributing thanks and gratitude for the words of wisdom most of the WORLD yearns for - 'insert your pronoun here' @@catnapgee5357 Dr. Peterson just taught us something meaningful about the whole of societal culture - East, Middle East, and West alike and the social moray consequences of treacherous lies, religious falsehoods and theocratic tyranny, but you missed it. I wish you well. Godspeed in your search for the truth.
The concept of you being simple minded, with all due respect is the truth. You see, Jordan Peterson in this video is nothing but the equivalent of taking the main stream news propaganda by Israel and the US, shoving them into some kind of an AI Content Writer and choosing "make it sound really fancy" and then proceed to simply give it out with what I have to admit to be quite a performance, he is talented in preforming I'll have to be honest about that.
Want me to prove it to you? Tell me what did you learn from this that you haven't learned in the last 20 years, and I promise, the things you'll find yourself learning are exactly the things on every news station in the west.
@@justinmccray5014I think he has said that he views being trolled with that variant of his name as an honor.
You have articulated, with precision, the deep and difficult situations we now find ourselves in. What’s important now is to shed light wherever we can.
Articulation is an art. Be precise in your speech, Buckos.
Mr Jordan peterson I see u are revolving around the main point. I believe you are very smart to know that before giving any advice about this you need to make sure you have studied the case in details. I as Muslim truly appreciate your efforts in trying to unify the people of the book but it is not simple. So you really need to teach yourself more about this issue if you really want to contribute in solving this problem
@kosiekoos9408 it was a false flag netanyahu was supposed to be charged and protested against by 500k israelis he did all this to distract ppl like u who easily believe in propaganda.
What is your point? That terrorism and killing innocent people is justified if you're muslim? Because you're so butthurt about the fact that your people haven't achieved anything purposeful in over half a millenia? Or do you want to say that islam actually is the religion of love and peace? Well, then begin acting like it, or people won't believe you.
Solve what problem?
He really going around. I mess with Jordan work. He made me a better person. But you are right. He is ignoring the point. He's only going from one attack recently not knowing nowhere near enough information. He hasn't followed the events closely enough.
@@kosiekoos9408
do u realise that so far 3500 Palestinian civilian died since 7th of october and 500 died today due to israeli bombing of a hospital? 80 of the 500 were children, so far what we are seeing is the end of Palestinian people not HAMAS
Dr jordan am a huge huge fan. I believe you have touched upon a lot of accurate points. But i also believe you totally missed the core reason of the conflict. Yes iran is orchestrating. But the core fuel of the conflict is gaza the largest open air prison in the world. The core fuel is the israeli settlements that made through years the two state solution impossible. The core issue is the abraham accords is striking peace with all arabs but the palestinians whether it be the plo or any palestinian side. The core issue is israel left no livable options to the palestinians. So, like all such situations in politics a country such as iran utilized the situation. You are perfectly right yet so far away from the full picture. Your noble hope for peace is biasing your critical thinking. And am so sure some day you will see it. The abraham accords unfortunately were doomed to collapse one way or another cause their core foundations is unfair. And their objective isnt peace. Some day i hope you see it. Until then my prayers to you, i love you despite how much i disagree with your political assessment of the situation.
I understand punishing Hamas and those involved in the attack. That said, I condemn the collective punishment of 2.2 million people in Gaza, many of whom had nothing to do with the attack.
Gaza is a hopeless prison, it should be no surprise that some people resort to extremism in those conditions.
I didn't know what the answer is, but I know it's not killing thousands of civilians and calling it " collateral damage "
You'll only push more people to extremism.
Who made it a prison? Israel left in 2005, hoping to be left in peace. It could have been turned into a beautiful flourishing place into which millions of international aid was poured. Israel left its greenhouses to help the people of Gaza. Instead Gaza elected Hamas, who turned it into a bed of terror. Israel had no choice but to protect its border. And explain why is it that it’s border with Egypt is closed? Is that Israel’s fault as well?
All this verbal masturbation for damage control and to hide the fact that you are not allowed to criticize Jews at all for some reason, even when they themselves do the same, or even worse things to enemy civilians.
I've noticed this a while ago but chose to ignore it as I have tremendous respect for your work and have been following you for over 7 years now.
Why is it so hard to acknowledge that those "special people" commit atrocities as well. and indeed at this very moment, because of their narcissistic belief that God chose them to be the special nation.
Right on.
Plus, didn't the jews break their covenant with God and God took their land away and cursed them to be "wanderers of nations"? And Israel isn't supposed to exist until after the 2nd coming of the Messiah. As Revelation Ch2 Vs9 says "they say they are jews but they are the synagogue of satan".
Best comment 😂👌
Jordan goes scorched Earth, and is absolutely on the money!
Can you translate your comment for non native speaker.
@@barbara_mat6789he is upset Jordan made a comment affected emotionally that came true and wasn’t the right thing to be delivered
As someone who I assmed to be very knowledgable, I'm shocked you haven't heard of the 75 years of Israeli occupation of the Palestinian land, and more shocked that you don't understand what resistance is!
Jews there 3000 years, Arabs about 1000 years
@@Pacdoc-Oz So you personally have been living there for more than 3000 yrs !
@@Trickyksa I have
@@crustykeycap5670What kind of blood do you suck other than Palestinian blood these days
@@Pacdoc-Oz ancestral claims to land are bogus.
Only imagine if world leaders spoke with this level of passion and ethos. Bravo, Dr. Peterson.
Most of the world leaders have hearts of stone and are incapable of it.
Like give them Hell
@@maxamed4yare You don't think terrorists should be given hell?
@@dave9547 Did you think this was a clever retort? Terrorists make civilians their target and don't care about the people who will die in retaliation, which they know is coming. Military targets terrorists and ends up with accidental (though known) civilian casualties. You decide.
Were are all against thugs. But we need to be against the thugs on both sides. One bunch of thugs should not get a pass.
This is the most important comment here IMO. Dr JP, while I don’t know your sources and so would be presumptuous to malign them, I am confident that utter commitment to the “virtue” of the Israeli version of the narrative will serve you about as well as did commitment to the “humanity” of those promoting the official **rona narrative. Those peddlers of heartwarming virtue-signaling “information” were never innocent not even in February 2020, and neither are they in this new situation.
Please state the thugs on the other side with reasoning as to why you would call them thugs. (Israel handed over Gaza in 2005, which has been controlled by Hamas since 2006.)
And Israel is now killing innocent civilians. That is thug behavior. The Israeli government are thugs. It's very hard to dispute that.@@stephenkramp5602
Thanks be to God for the heart, mind and intellect of Jordan Peterson. May God protect him and his family.
He’s calling out the forces of evil who live and breathe and move among us. We must listen!!!
Please, stand up for ALL HUMAN RIGHTS
Jordan Peterson is employed by Ben Shapiro's company, The Daily Wire. The Daily Wire is funded by Kape Technologies, whose CEO is Israeli Intelligence Duvdevan Unit veteran Ido Erlichman.
We should ask ourselves, before we condemn others, how would we behave if we were in their shoes?
Missing of course deliberately. Some people need to pontificate to fill airtime
"do not attribute to yourself the virtue of the Divine when acting on your own behalf" is one of the many valuable lessons I learned from Dennis Preger who says the correct wording (and I agree) is "do not TAKE [carry] God's name in vain"
Dennis Prager is a former Mossad asset, looks on Christians with disgust and argues positively for phonography.
Paul prayed (trevailed) to see Christ formed within his readers... once formed, and given free reign; who can stop the rivers of living water that flows from the divine?
When you were explaining the dark triad traits…it’s like you found a perfect description for israel.
I’m with you on this Peterson. Choosing not to fall prey to easy answers, and moral ascendency which is nothing of the sort. To choose wisdom, because you recognize how little you know. To choose to speak what you believe is true, because you fear the proper things. To not cower for fear of offense.
Keep speaking. Keep looking for the highest nexus of good and truth. So that you might discern in the midst of a blinded and deafened wailing chorus. Of unrenewed minds. Of seared conscience. One may take your life, but they cannot take the truth from your heart.
"Give 'em hell" - can you please explain how that was "choosing wisdom" and not an "easy answer" Jordan posted on twitter when this all kicked off?
The only ascendant truth that matters is Christ as the crucified and risen Saviour of mankind. If it's true, the line between good and evil runs straight through the human heart than we all need a redeemer, to redeem that which is good, to restore the conscience and bring us into right standing with God. The propensity for evil within us precludes us from being candidates for such a task, but God, who is holy, who created us, can, legally rectify our situation by stepping into human history and his own creation, taking on human flesh so as to do it legally in this realm where he has given us dominion. By using a human vessel to take on the brutality of mankind to overcome it, and conquer death itself to offer us not just a way out, but the ultimate solution, a way through; through Him.
"For there is no other name under Heaven and in all the earth, given by men, whereby we might be saved." Put your trust in Jesus and not yourself and He will ensure that when all's said and done the suffering will be over, as you will have eternity with Him, where He is and descended from and returned to: Heaven.
May God bless you, in Jesus' holy name, amen. 🙏
Hamas is ISIS. Rape, hostage taking and killing of civilians is classic ISIS, also classic Mohammad Peace and Blessings Upon Him.
@@MrShabbaaaa hey shabba. are you kidding or dimwitted? what words of wisdom or encouragement would you have given nettanyahu when hamas went on a murder spree? "I never did give them hell. I just told the truth, and they thought it was hell." ― Harry S. Truman
@@georgeh8937 no you are the dimwit. Completely ignorant of the wider implications of egging on a thug like Netanyahu, conclusion so far being war crimes and crimes against humanity, worst of which being a hospital that gets airstriked killing over 500 civilians including women, children, babies, patients, doctors, refugees. And who knows how far Netanyahu will go in "giving them hell". Btw you know a lot *Israelis* themselves are against Netanyahu and his actions, you don't care about that though do you?
With all the greatest respect and admiration I have for you Dr. Peterson, I do not personally believe these 'Message To [X]' videos/articles on current affairs to be constructive. I think they are both tonally flawed and symptomatic of you stretching yourself out too thin in attempt to wrestle with every issue. You don't have to do this, in spite of your platform. There are people more specialised in these areas. At the very least host them, but your own words are subpar here in my view. I ask instead to please continue addressing the personal/esoteric issues, and providing positive, inspiring content out of that, such as the biblical seminars you and DW have so generously shared for free on your channel. They are the light in the darkness, for everyone, at all times. These rants, that I do not find to be as organised as you intend, in my view do not do this. They boil down to poorly structured punditry of a generic sort. I do not think they set the right standard. That's just my view and I mean it with all good will.
100% agree. I respect the standards he held himself to 5 years ago, and I know he's smarter than this.
It's like he got fed up with the left and decided to do the one thing he always warned against: To pick a side.
I adore his talks on principle and the nature of truth. But how he applies that to current issues is tilted in ways he should be better at detecting and accounting for. Sometimes you don't owe the enemy of your enemy your friendship. Sometimes the whole bloody game is rotten to the core and you should walk away.
Speaking for myself and you might be right to disagree with me here, I'm of the opinion that Israel and Hamas are engaged in a bloody game rotten to the core, and Americans need to stop running intellectual/emotional defense for Netanyahu's reputation.
The man had all the resources to stop this war begot it happened, and he decided to let it proceed anyway, knowing exactly what would happen to the civilians. I'm not about to run defense for a man who doesn't want to be helped.
The civilians on both sides are the ones who need help, that's where my attention will go.
This is delusional. Peterson provided a much needed psychoanalytic perspective on this timeless situation.
@@LUNAofCAIRO Feel free to disagree with the criticism, but that doesn't make it delusion.
Disagree, this was a very insightful perspective. “The hottest places in hell are reserved for those who, in times of great moral crisis, maintain their neutrality.”
Nothing wrong with the psychoanalysis of mass delusion in favor of a subject everyone seems so drawn to but understand so little of
“Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe makes people blind to what is right and ruins the cause of those who are innocent.” (Exo 23:8, GNB)
“"Do not spread false rumors, and do not help a guilty person by giving false testimony. Do not follow the majority when they do wrong or when they give testimony that perverts justice. Do not show partiality to a poor person at his trial. "If you happen to see your enemy's cow or donkey running loose, take it back to him. If his donkey has fallen under its load, help him get the donkey to its feet again; don't just walk off. "Do not deny justice to a poor person when he appears in court. Do not make false accusations, and do not put an innocent person to death, for I will condemn anyone who does such an evil thing. Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe makes people blind to what is right and ruins the cause of those who are innocent.” (Exo 23:1-8, GNB)
"Why can't we just be pro people and anti wrong?"
1. Because everyone is righteous in their own eyes. Proverbs 21:2-3.
2. Because almost everyone is like the Pharisees, and not like the tax-collector: Luke 18:9-14.
3. Because we see ourselves as clean even when we are immersed in darkness. Proverbs 30:12
Asked to a murderous soldier, who had been propagandized from youth: "How could you have committed such atrocities?" Answer: "Easy. We were doing good and making the world a better place."
No. You cannot weasel your way out of this one. You have been exposed for what you really are
Could you be more vague?
Nope, he's just an excessive blowhard, and if he was what I'm sure you're implying then there's no reason to believe he wouldn't be forthright about it.
I’m going to have to listen to this a few more times. Very powerful.
Me too
Can you please summarize??
@@mervyn2316Summarize?
I feel sad for myself and you Jordan .You have to stop nosing into political matters and stick to what you are helpful with. I learned about you in early 2021 and used to walk everyday listing to lectures and motivational videos about what you teach and how to be a better human, father , husband or son for hours but for the last year or so you are all about politics and debates and recently asking for the killing of people in a conflict that now is escalating very badly. I hope your family helps you out of this dark tunnel you have decided to walk yourself thru.
He has not and would not ask for any killing if you pay attention. Listen carefully
Dr. Peterson.
Look here, man! I love you, I really do, but on the Palestinian/Israeli problem I do not think our understanding and thoughts aligns vis a vis the occupation and decimation of Palestinians . Your presentation here says that you are looking at this issue through the prism of your preferences. This serves to alienate good people. Anyone who wants to come over as a fair contributor to the debate has to look at the issue in its broader context and must have a deeper and clearer understanding of the problems. Any psychological analysis must take into account the entire gamut of psychosocial factors, a failure to place things in their proper context will undoubtedly necessitate unpleasant reactions such as the ones you receive. I believe that you have to properly familiarise yourself with this contentious problem lest it backfires.
﴿مُّذَبۡذَبِینَ بَیۡنَ ذَ ٰلِكَ لَاۤ إِلَىٰ هَـٰۤؤُلَاۤءِ وَلَاۤ إِلَىٰ هَـٰۤؤُلَاۤءِۚ وَمَن یُضۡلِلِ ٱللَّهُ فَلَن تَجِدَ لَهُۥ سَبِیلࣰا﴾ [النساء ١٤٣]
I'm a big fan of so much of Peterson, especially the vintage stuff. Reading him changed me for the better and have so much appreciation in general for him and his work. I can't help but feel the bitterness, sarcasm and mockery in the delivery of what is actually probably useful information here, is only going to serve to polarise and entrench more. There's every justification for him to be embittered after everything he's been through, and he absolutely has the right to it. I guess I don't see people rolling over and acquiescing with their ideas in the face of lectures like these, when what they really probably want is some kind of acknowledgement that their pain matters, ala Chris Voss/Marshall Rosenberg/Carl Rogers work style work. We have to live together (as he's talked about with marriage and the divided US) and I don't see us shaming and ridiculing each other to that end. Too much pain on every side, we actually do need some softer edges to hold that so one side doesn't obliterate the other and we all end up going to hell. I hope he can help us further to that end as he's done for so many already.
Can you not see the hope of unity with pure evil was I’ll advised to begin with and is now ludicrous? As Rush said for years, you cannot compromise with this madness, you have to DEFEAT IT! And many years before his time, a wise man (and I do not remember who, so you can google it if interested ) “You cannot compromise with evil because evil will not compromise with you. Evil is out to take it all!” Evil abounds not only in foreign lands, but right here in the once great USA.
I think he's angry at the carnage. At least that's what seems to come across. I agree though with your comment that perhaps softer medicine is needed right now. Many ordinary Palestinians are in practical and existential pain, want and absolutely abject desolation. Everyone needs to separate those poor souls from the extremist thugs Peterson is so rightly angry with.
I remember many years ago I went to a roundtable discussion with young people in their 20s who were members of the Basque separatist violent political arm of that party known as ETA. These young people genuinely believed in their cause and that violence was justified. I was shocked to discover that they saw no dichotomy in going to Mass on Sunday and then killing people in a car bombing later the same day. The same is probably true for some Palestinians who see Hamas as their people's voice. While understanding and empathizing with their pain, as gently as I can, I join my voice with those who remind us all that violence begets violence and brings out the worst in humankind. Terrorism has no place on this planet we must share together, no matter which group or organization engages in it. I ask all Muslims to imitate Allah, the all-merciful one. I, for my part, as a Christian imitating Christ's love for all as much as I am able, pledge to advocate for and to stand for peace wherever I may have influence and in whatever situation I may find myself. I stand in solidarity with my Muslim brothers and sisters as fellow people of the Book.
Pretentious to paraphrase Jordon but some of what I got was: religion needs to take a step back mullahs and rabbis need to be more humble(stop playing god) and the internet is bad. also Iran is a bad faith player in this global game.
This is well said
very sensible comment
I think one pertinent question is whether the reports are true of Netanyahu admitting his strategy was to support Hamas in order to prevent Palestinian unity. If they are, I think there would be something to say of Machiavelli and thuggery.
Just a little googling will provide you with evidence, including government officials admitting what they did. It's not only Netanyahu, it goes back.
I generally agree with the premise of the message, especially as an Iranian-Canadian, but zero criticism of Israel? What does that imply? That Israel is completely beyond reproach here?
When one group does such animalistic behavior as that shown by Hamas when they attacked, there is no “both sides” argument to be made.
Hamas must be eradicated. Period, end of story. Put as much effort as possible towards limiting innocent deaths, but Hamas (like any terror group) is filled with cowards that would rather hide behind civilians than face anyone in combat like actual men.
@@antibull4869I wonder how the victims of the first Holocaust and their supporters, can support and justify another Holocaust being perpetrated on the Palestinian people, crying ‘Hamas’, ‘Hamas’
I love JP, always have, I have immense respect for him. The issue starts, when a Psychologist feels he has a good grasp of the Theology of another religion. He needs to read the Quran to understand the underlying ideology of Islam. The doctrines of Islam, what the religion encourages them to do. Dr.Peterson thinks Islam is like Christianity, "Love your enemy" .How wrong can he be?
hello michael. i am pretty sure peterson confirmed that islam is shady after talking to the boastful mohammaed hijab two times. besides peterson has made it clear he is not interested in religious doctrine but the inner meaning of religious stories.
you're ignorant if you don't know his talks with Muslim people
You have an American view os Islam. They too are called to love their enemies and banish hate from their hearts. It's only the radical version.....version....version of this religion. Ultimately that is all it is, another works religion full of satanic deception.
@@georgeh8937 religious stories? well I have news for him, religion is not the fairy tale he is looking for. if he wants story, he should read 1001 Arabian nights. Now, that is a story.
@@fairlady5117hello lady. what exactly are you trying to say about religion and about peterson?
Thank you Dr. Peterson. A shining light in a sea of endless dark
As a Muslim, Dr. Peterson I must say that listening to you always gives me relief in knowing that not everyone sees us as radical monsters - but that we too want peace. Hamas and the Mullahs are muslims only in name. The people of the book have much more in common than not, and I pray that one day we will find the unity and peace we're looking for.
Amen🇮🇱🙏
You need to do something about the radical monsters though and only from within can they be fought, from a survivor of islam propagated genocide to you with love.
Allah is the Greatest.
I suggest you read Acts of the Apostles . This scripture provides an exposition on free speech, and an indication that evil self interest always attempts to silence the truth from being spoken.
Shalom and Salaam, Abraham and Ibrahim ... Its all the same ....Sad to see people divided despite being very nearly the same...
I am from iran and i have to say this is true Iran is not as religious as it may seem...... At least not genuinely.
Your description of the pathology of the cluster B disorders is spot on! I too came to the same conclusion about the woke but I never made the connection to Marxism and religious extremism.
I'm confused as to how you didn't draw those connections. The woke act in very extremists ways by default, and their connection to Marxism is almost direct, with about 30% of their talking points being Marxian (meaning, Communist). Maybe you just saw the woke in isolation, is why?
@@SwitchTalkChannel Disenfranchised and hopeless people typically turn to radical ideologies to feel a sense of belongings; many times no matter the cost to current society.
@@SwitchTalkChannelI don’t think so, for that you don’t really need marxism to hate the abrahamic religions, there are plenty reasons that’s self-evident. Just imagine someone who literally thinks he is god, and his ideals must be followed by everyone else, and he will happily torture anyone who don’t obey his ideals for eternity IF HE CAN.
So yeah, it deserves to be hated, narcissism at its very extreme.
No matter how controversial any of Jordan's statements may seem, there's always truth and good meaning behind the initial statement. When he decides to explain the reason behind his statements, it always shows that he's aligned with the truth and the good.
And it absolutely infuriates Atheists, because they can't make sense of it how a "religious charlatan" like him can be more helpful and pragmatic than their high and mighty brain power.
@@amaterasu5001uhhh no peg
@@amaterasu5001no, only you think that.
@amaterasu5001 when you're willing to burn everything, anything can be fuel.
Jordan Peterson is always right? No absolutely not
I listen to 95% of RUclips content at 1.5x or 2x speed, but when Dr. Peterson is speaking I have to slow it down so I can appreciate and absorb the brilliance and logic properly. His are also among the few videos I watch repeatedly because they inspire, educate, and chastise in equal measure.
You should listen to some real genius like Joshua Bach or Bernardo Kastrup if you are having trouble with Peterson's word salads for kids
I'm really sorry to say that but you completely missed the point. You are almost repeating what the main stream media is saying about the situation. The reality is that Israel has been occupying, killing, humiliating, discriminating, torturing, prisoning palestinian men, women and children for decades treating them like animals. No body aided them but left them to suffer. Some Palestinians lost hope and made a reaction and rsisted the brutal Isreali occupation. Yes their deed was brutal and included crimes which are condemned. But it was a reaction to a long history of slavery caused by the israeli. Any one who addresses what happened on the 7th of October without giving the context and the prehistory is missing the point. Ukrain is allowed to resist the russian occupation and supported with money, weapons and media coverage. On the other hand the palestinians are condemned if they resist the Israeli occupation. Imagin a woman being brutally raped by a strong, wealthy man every single day for years while neighbours and police pretend not see and never react even when the raper killed the children of that woman. At one point the woman tries to resist and fights back and plocks the eye of the raper. Then all the neighbours, police and the wprld starts condemning the raped woman for her deed and support the criminal man.
Exactly. He’s a disgusting grifter. We should all unfollow and ignore him moving forward.
Your eyes are clouded with hate.
RUclips needs to allow for “TWO THUMBS UP”!! This needs to be shared around the globe!!
this man called out Iran for exactly what it is
Right on but does he have the balls to call out israel for what it is?
Who decides who is a thug
It amazes me how we live in an era so devoid of morality and ethics, where saying that you’re against violence and in the side of peace and the innocents that are victim of such atrocities, no particular side, will gain you nothing but being accused of wanting the murder of the Palestinian people.
He literally wrote "Give them hell" to his friend Netanyahu. The latter said Israel is an ethnonation only for Jews and wants to ethnic cleanse every non Jew and never allow anything resembling a Palestinian establishment. Bibi encouraged all Israeli parties to fund Hamas for that reason 3years ago
@@Lalakis does Hamas not constantly call for the genocide of the Jews? Haven’t they expressed themselves very clearly that they don’t want peace, they want the lands back. Didn’t the Arab forces in WWII ally themselves with Hitler and follow his path of genocide towards the Jews?
This is not a one side has all the blame. Although I do blame the American warmongering left, and their government. Not only is Ukraine their fault for their unwillingness to negotiate, but the tensions im the middle eastern zone are high once again because he refused to keep working on what Trump achieved with the Abraham accords, and his utter failure in the Afghanistan departure besides leaving a bunch of expensive arsenal to be distributed, showed the geopolitical and military incompetency of his government and Biden’s current leadership.
@@Lalakisprobably referring to said thugs who are using religion as a veil for radical beliefs and violence, NOT INNOCENT Palestinians, right? Just think about it a little bit more, that’s all
@@TherealTFfromKingstonyes ofc ofc... Why didn't he specify it
@@Lalakis Netanyahu is Jew-supremacist. And the only reason that has come to pass into law is because all the Arab natins near it are Muslim-supremacist, and this entire conflict is about Muslim-supremacy. There was fundamentally no other reason why the Arab states opposed the creation of a Jewish state. Netanyahu is not for ethnic cleansing or genocide, but Hamas' founding document anticipates genocide of the Jews in the name of Allah.
When Muslims see nonmuslims behaving just like they have, or not even as badly, they have an anueurysm about how unfair it is.
Wow, I never thought I would experience those college classes, in which you want to get an understanding of something but the only thing you are left with at the end, is more confusion.
You see, big words and psychological analysis of a situation serve only as a red herring when the situation is quite simple to understand. Moreover, one tends to over-explain and overcomplicate the matter when one is given a narrative and is told to stick to it no matter what. This also happens when one goes against one’s own values and beliefs. In order to make the response less shameful and avoid more damage to the self, ego, and reputation, one gives an overly complex and highly irrelevant response in the hopes, that the audience will be overwhelmed by the complexity and fail to notice the irrelevance of the response. This is a great technique, because one gets to, later on, “clarify” and “rectify” the complexly vague response.
The truth is always apparent and bright. Similar to the Sun. One can never cover or cloud the truth for too long. Similarly, the clouds can never cover the Sun for too long. Unlike, when the Sun is covered with black clouds, there’s benefit, however, when one attempts to cover the truth with black clouds, there’s only destruction.
His message was clear as day. Can't say the same for yours even though I read it in 20 seconds.
@@wildboar122 his response is nothing but irrelevant. He mentions only the resistance shown on October 7th, in which innocent people have been killed which is unacceptable. (Palestinians have been suffering this everyday for 70+ years) Nothing at all about the ongoing indiscriminate and brutal Israeli air strikes that have killed at least 1500 children. He was quick to tweet “Give ‘em hell” on October 7th, but somehow he is slower than a slug for condemning the killing of children, women and elderly. And he won’t condemn it.
To be honest, his condemnation is not needed anyway. These kinds of people come and go but the truth remains.
Does anybody remember Shakespeare's Macbeth:'it is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound & fury, signifying nothing'
The truth is both sides are forces for evil. Which one is more reprehensible is up for debate.
If you actually sat through all 20 minutes of this video and truly believe it was "big words and psychological analysis" serving as a "red herring", I am truly sorry for you. That is outright unbelievable and saddening to read. Best of luck with your future learning.
History freaking matters Jordan.
And those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it. But studying history alone does not give us solutions, it only gives us context. Sometimes we have to leave the past behind.
I’ve been to Israel in October 2015 and we met and ate with Jews, Muslims, & Christians all at the same table and yes at the same time. We shared our love for good food (Pakistani mothers made lunch for us every day except for Friday, their holyday), love for family, friends and for Israel who Jewish doctors were treating Muslim children from Iraq, Pakistan, Iran… that needed heart surgery. We spent time, cared for the Muslim children and mothers/fathers as they were getting we medical care. So yes we can live together, serve together, and enjoy live together.
I have cousins in israel and every time I go there to visit, we hangout together, with their arab friends, who work as policemen. Arab men working as policemen in israel. The media will never show that
@@arimoff The media only gets revenue from acts of terror, so it must encourage it for its own survival
As it should be ❤
I doubt if most people know that 21% of people living and working in Israel (and who are allowed to vote) are not Jews or Palestinians. They are from other religions - Christianity, Moslems, etc. @@arimoff
If you weren't in Israel with those people doing that, you would not be able to do any of that with those people in any of their countries.
I love you Jordan. Online hate and shaming is a hivemind-like process. Andrew Tate and his following call you unintelligent and wrong when they are hardly able to THINK, period. Love you as always jordan, very adequately spoken and elegant and graceful. Thank you for the update revolving around the bias clipped no-context narratives being spun around online about you, without letting you have the chance to defend yourself in civil discussion and break down and or clarify points made and rooted for against you.
I stand with you, and I stand with Israel ♥️
@@lordpenetron4285 One thing out of this and the Ukraine war I can say are a positive, is seeing all these people who love BOTH sides civilians, and not just one sides. Everyone has a bias to who they think the enemy is in this war, but regardless of who has that opinion, myself included, we all rally to pray and hope for the civilians ♥️🙏
Shekoyach (meaning with strength in Hebrew - an exhortation) Jordan Peterson! What an amazing speech - every word could be not more true and insightful.
Love hearing JP and his take on human nature which is spot on.
The thugs get rich off the sheep who want to feel they are good people while in reality they blindly follow elitist goals and gains via political rhetoric
13:15 Sir, I got a hearty laugh out of the "alphabet brigade" commentary. Man I needed that. Thank you.
In college I took Judaism classes to study the differences between Orthodox, Reform, Conservative, and Reconstructionist Jews. I went on a synagogue tour to learn more about all the different kinds of Judaism. I did volunteer work at the museum of tolerance. And I have always admired Israel but now I am angry to see so many Palestinian children dying. And I feel I can not continue to feel the same way about Israel. I feel like something is dying inside of me. Like when someone you love betrays you 💔
The Israeli government has betrayed it's people! True Judaism and Jewish people do not oppress nor accept genocide
Please remember it’s not Orthodox Jews it is a facet of Zionists who don’t care and only seek to obtain the land. There are jewish people that stand against the apartheid and occupation it’s just in Israel they face two years jail time for speaking out.
We just aren’t hearing their voices because there is a language barrier and they are being silenced by jail time for the last decades or even longer. On RUclips search you will see proof of this in some documentaries. They also state that these Zionists do not follow the Torah because they have been stealing land via settlements and land grabbing which is fundamentally considered a sin.
HAMAS made the children stay so they could hide behind them like the cowards they are, IDF gave opportunity and warning to leave the warzone at their own additional risk.
Their ruthless murder of 4000 children in one month is frightening and the number is growing every hour. Is there anyone who could stop this genocide?
I have deep admiration for Dr. Peterson ability to explain very complex issues that affect the individuals in our western society, however his interpretation of the geopolitical clashes around the globe is inadequate. I’m hopeful that won’t be too long before Dr. Peterson comes to terms with the emergence of a Tri-polar world as China and Russia grow to more parity with the United States.
Will go down in history as one of the greatest Canadian minds. Hands down. Thank you good sir.
One of the greatest minds in the world, also.
One of the greatest Canadian frauds lmao
Canada hasn't had much great minds then.
That one tweet changed my perception of JP completely, dont even want to listen to his excuses and explanations
I have always been a fan of Jordan Peterson and followed everything, but this is something I don't think anyone who is of influence should be put in the opinion in. I don't think anybody truly knows enough. I don't think either side is correct. I don't know the end result but I don't think either side. I'll do in the right thing
Opinions definitely no. Facts yes. Read the Balføur Déclaration and understand that Zionists' Rothschild bankers funded the two world wars for the creation is Ißrael.
Ißrael is the occupier for 75 years.
The other side is the so called boogeymen hàmàs. It is a creation of Ißrael Møssad to use as false flags and avoid peace and to perpetuate bombing Palestinians on false pretexts. Don't take my word on it, go ahead and fact check. There are many reliable expertsnabd historians on this issue that dedicated their whole lives on it and does not have a monopoly in supporting either side, JP is not it.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palest inian state has to support bolstering Ha mas and transferring money to Ha mas,” he [Neta nyahu] told a meeting of his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy - to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.” (Haaretz, October 9, 2023, emphasis added)
Hey Peterson, interview Norman Finkelstein
And Noam Chomsky and Ilan Pappe.
This is the game behind the game. And without knowing what's truly at play in the world right now on this event and what's at stake, everyone is heading right into the pit they've dug. I hope the machinations of evil doesn't prevail and we achieve peace and unity.
What does peace and unity look like to you?
Unlikely, we need a massive catastrophe to then learn our lesson.
We have had “relative”peace since the Cold War. But no true peace with tension on going throughout the world.
yeah, except it's not. It's evil vs good. Watch Hamas videos of what they did and then call this a game.
@@creed22solar123
how about you watch israel videos of what they did? a HOSPITAL was bombed today, 500 Palestinian lives were taken, 80 of them were children, this is a WAR CRIME and your hypocrisy is astonishing
@@creed22solar123hàmàs is a creation of Ißrael Møssad to avoid peace and use as false flags, so it is a game and you are losing because you don't read a history book that false flagging is the oldest trick in the book. JP is also playing with all of you like pawns on his chessboard, we know very well he had dinners with Netanyahu, they are in bed with this, the warmonger and the propagandist henchman.
May God bless you brother Peterson. Thank you for your courageous voice.
100% .. we are so lucky to have Dr. Peterson sharing his wisdom with us.
Much better put. Get off Twitter for your own good. You gained popularity through long form content with well explained and thought out ideas. Twitter posts don’t allow that.
(To cut it short on the parrots - We condemn Hammas in what they did on Oct the 7th, got it? now I can speak).
As a half European half Arab Muslim, despite all I've learned from Dr. Peterson; I find this video offensive in many different ways.
1. Addressing Muslims as a bunch of poor astray children that are simply crying out there unable to recognize political alliances from true friends.
2. Dismissing everything relevant to the facts related to the Arab/Israeli conflict in its entirety and the factual systematic ethnic cleansing driven by Israel with the support of its allies in the west.
3. I believe its as factual as the sunlight - what Israel is currently doing exceeds many of the Nazi crimes, to have an open concentration camp live before the entire world's eyes systematically carpet bombing 2 million people whom half of them are children, this is is not a war, it is an oppressive ethnic cleansing no matter what the justification is.
4. To claim and dictate to us what Allah wants from us; that is one hell of a statement to make - yes, you have read, meeting few online influencers - I am sad to inform you that after almost watching all you had to say in public about Islam and Arabs no matter how genuine you were - you are far from understanding the core values and the teachings of Islam.
5. You obviously realized the magnitude of the online response to your statement earlier and If this video was an attempt to manage the crisis, it is another offense, I've watched it till the end - I am truly disappointed.
In the end, we have a say in the Arab world, everyman can be quoted/taken from and argued against, no matter the side you choose, you are to be credited in certain fields where you are an expert without a doubt and there is a lot to learn from you - but it is sad, truly sad to learn that you were not true to yourself and to the public in being a seeker of the truth and to learn about the dual standards that became very evident.
Well done bro. Excellent answer. Personally for me...Jordan Peterson is a real disappointment, especially after that terrible tweet of his about the Palestinians.
500,000 muslims perished in yemen, why only when it come to israel muslims are acting absolutely rabid
How is it a concentration camp?
As a human being, what must not be lost is conscience and common sense. because there are so many smart people who don't have a conscience and common sense that can destroy a civilization.
It's quite sad to see people who are and have great influence using their strengths but not using their conscience and common sense. can't see the good and the bad, can't see what is appropriate or inappropriate to do.
He's afraid of his masters (Zionists)
No moral code
Jordan is broken - and I have lost ALL respect for him - because Truth was his brand
Good thing you have so much of it! You must rest well at night knowing that you are never wrong because your "common sense" is bulletproof.
yeah, too bad Jordan Peterson can't see the good in those Hamas videos of them in Israel recently, having fun at the festival etc. And that he can't see the bad in Israelis trying to rid the world of these peace loving humans, without understanding that this is simply a middle-eastern tactic of negotiation. I am very disappointed in JP.
Happy that this world hero is from right here in Alberta, Canada:) the voice of God is logic and love, this man is at the top of both, more people should listen to this man for a better and more peaceful life.
@@mar-c3y thanks for letting us know you're a big clown!
I can't say agree with you with my mom coming from Lebanon. I/my ancestors has seen what Islam has done to middle-east Christians and jews since its inception. Their God has a standing order to destroy non-believers and their quran/hadiths on jews is disturbing though it makes you understand why some do what they do and others celebrate their evil acts as uncomfortable as that may be to observe.
True.
I agree. islam is a tyranny. I believe science will save us. like look at the space race or nuclear power or internet or now Mars. like even if islam got it's so called victory do you think they can make it afterward? I think islam is just a blood thirsty tyranny that wants to bring chaos and dance in it
I agree 100%
You’re right, but he can’t say that because the intended audience wouldn’t listen
I started to read the Quran to have first hand understanding of what it says. It’s very disturbing, the explicit hatred and contempt for Jews and Christians is eye opening.
Is-Lame is the reason for all the Terrorism.
Surah 9:29
Fight those People of the Book who do not believe in Allah, nor in the Last Day, and do not take as unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have declared as unlawful, and do not profess the Faith of Truth; (fight them) until they pay jizyah with their own hands while they are subdued.
It's important to clarify that religions themselves are not inherently at fault, but rather it's a minority of individuals who exploit religion as a cover to achieve their selfish goals, often at the expense of people's well-being. Additionally, even ideologies like communism, which are typically anti-religion, can develop their own form of "belief system" to exert control over people. Therefore, it's crucial to distinguish between genuine religious beliefs and the actions of a malevolent minority.
The religion is entirely at fault. What do you think the goal of Islam is? Look at the Saudi flag for instance. Why do you think they underlined the passage of all and muhamad with a sword? Don't be stupid.
There are a few issues I take with this video:
1. Bringing in the rationality of the LGBTQ community in the light of this war, is a distracting side-show that has no bearing on the military conflict whatsoever.
2. Does anti-thug mean being anti state-bombing of an occupied civilian population? I did not hear anything being adressed in relation to the actions of israel (which are still ongoing).
A wise man once said that If more people assumed they could learn from "truly listening" to others, they might actually learn something they didnt know.
Ironic since Jordan won't listen to the Palestinians in concentration camps.
I think I might know who that wise person was
What concentration camp? Show proof
@@Rick-bi9fw Peterson is a man who becomes quite emotional when he's listened to the distressing journey's of the human experience. To place him in a sentence as though he is condoning suffering of innocence in "concentration camps" has demonstrated clearly your incapacity to "truly listen".
@@pauliewalsh6875he invited Netanyahu to his podcast and have dinners, many have adviced in comments, don't go down the route, he did not listen. Calling people who disagrees with him and I quote on his X account murderous anti Semitic rats is hardly listening. He had many many discourses and I listened to it all but I felt when it comes to with Muslims it's always gaslighting because he turn around the next week and stab them in the back pretending they didn't have a cordial discussion explaining all his queries or criticisms. It's because I've been following closely to his content that I know he doesn't listen.
“The Accords, mediated by the Trump administration, were hailed as a major breakthrough in Middle East diplomacy.
However, the agreements have been met with widespread opposition from Palestinians, who believe they fail to address the root causes of the conflict.
When asked about the impact of the Accords, 52 percent of those surveyed said that the agreement had made Israel more aggressive towards the Palestinians, while 43 percent said they had seen no impact or change, and only 6 percent said they believed the agreement had made the situation better.
The results of the poll highlight a deep mistrust of Palestinians towards a possible peaceful resolution of the conflict, as they show that the Abraham Accords failed to produce tangible improvements for Palestinians.”
Dr peterson, how can you see the abraham accords as a true peaceful solution while it completely ignores the palestenians and the two state solution in any form? How can you see this as a true diagnosis? You taught us to think and criticise. To tackle root causes. Hamas attacking not limiting their prison break to military targets made a grave grave mistake yes enticed by iran you are right. But how about the root cause doctor? Please address this i urge your humanity to address it
An absolute ethical and intellectual treat! Great analysis and sound intellectual leadership.
Genocide apologist.
Just a few days ago he said quote “give ‘em hell” now that seems very ethical, to call for ethnic cleansing.
@@tristan4175I think that comment is a fundamentally inaccurate read of what he is saying. But it certainly packs emotional punch.
@@adamgates1142 ok.
ignore these brainwashed idiots@@RossBern_Inc
Thanks for pulling so many threads together in an excellent overview of this shocking situation. I always appreciate what you have to say ❤
The problem is that the world is not run by people like Jordan but by Rothschild who use violence and deceit. The division of labor in the world is forced by force, not by industry. China is effectively breaking the dollar, soon more Arab countries were to join BRICS and America and Israel do not want to lose influence in the Middle East. There will be a bloody union with many countries, a greater conflict than in Ukraine. That's why America immediately sent aircraft carriers there as if for a war, they are waiting for a signal, probably a false flag.
@@justinmccray5014- OK 🤡
@@justinmccray5014 Ok, Jihaadi Putason
how isn't every description you gave for the "thugs" doesn't apply to Israel more, historically and now?
If you decide to turn a blind eye to the thugs who started all of this and are maintaining it, don't judge the other side.
Because historically speaking they are the thugs and Israel has only been defending themselves
Is it just me or does any1 else notice how everything he says from 7:49 to 8:43 seems to describe Israel's government extremely well 🤔 Bassem Youssef just made this exact same point the other day on Piers Morgans show and suddenly a psychologist breaks the whole thing down and now it's hard to not see all of the "dark tetrad" qualities of the Israeli govt and Military 🤣
I miss the old Jordan Peterson videos. The lectures and introspections. You changed the way I perceive and analyse the world around me
They still exist.
Have you listed to his recent Exodus series? You sound like the kind of person who would appreciate them.
As an Iranian in Canada, I approve of this message!
As a Pole i wish the best for Iran and its ppl. I hope we can one day be united. My great grandfather escaped to Iran during ww2 when Poland was over run by the Nazis and Soviets. 75,000 polish soldiers and 40,000 polish civilians managed to make it to Iran. Most were shipped in from the USSR, some basically made it their on foot. Even though Iran supplied hitler with oil early on, the Iranian government and its ppl took in over 100,000 poles into their homes and government buildings sharing what little food and supplies they had. My great grand father escaped occupied Poland and with the help of polish units already in iran he received support and walked and hitch hiked from europe all the way to Iran with his army unit. They joined the allies and fought in the Italian campaigns. He was part of the units that liberated the Monastery at Monte Cassino and later attacked the Hitler line which led to the Anzio breakthrough opening the road to Rome. this led to the Italians surrendering, Killing Benito Mussolini and joining the Allied armies. lol rant over. i just like ww2 and the many achievements of my family in those days . Fun fact, The biggest refugee cemetary in iran is Polish. its is to this day taken care of and maintained by the ppl of Iran. I have a picture of my great grandfather giving a iranian child a chocolate bar, hes never eaten chocolate in his life before this. He looked like he discovered the meaning of life after eating the chocolate, I have one picture of my great grandfather of him together with the Iranian family who took him into their home when he first made it to Iran, I wish i could somehow track down their living relatives but all I have is a picture, no names, no city..... the only hope would be for someone to recognize the background and somehow find out the general area of where the pic was taken. maybe one day........
Pick me Persian
Look, there's a difference between Iran and the Islamic Regime ruling Iran.
You’re no Iranian, you’re no Canadian either sweetheart. You’re just another fallen dried leaf.
@@Medium341There’s something I like about your comment. Might it be from “300”?
This went in a different direction than I was expecting, but aligns with my thoughts perfectly.
I dont think the title helped......
So I was listening to Jordan Petersons exodus. It has been absolutely incredible couldn’t recommend it enough. However there was a passage they awkwardly skipped over that I wish they addressed.
Exodus 15:14: "The people shall hear, and be afraid: sorrow shall take hold on the inhabitants of Palestina."
Dr. Peterson is getting old. We need to preserve this man.
@@tayzk5929 Give Hamas hell!
I think he looks pretty damn good!😂
He looks great!
Da fk you talking about? Dude looks great
Take it from me, we are all getting old…but your mind never old…it just quits working!
The absolute absence of criticism is quite concerning
You didn't listen to anything he said
@@isabelblancas8230 I, for one, listened to all of it. And the silence of what he DIDN'T say was so clangingly loud it nearly wrecked the eardrums of my soul. You go ahead, dear, and keep enjoying the intoxication from the devil's cup of your confirmation bias.
@@isabelblancas8230 no I listened to the whole video and in addition I'm a fan of JP in general, but there's still lack of criticism towards isreal
@turtlesongs2012 Disregarding your personal attacks because you don't actually care about the issue or topic here. What did you want him to say that would affirm your opinion of him lacking criticism?
@@islisula767 What specifically did you need him to say to satisfy criticism of Israel?
May the world listen to these wise words🙏🏻
@@ibraheemkhan6660the hell the Muslims have coming is well deserved. They’ve been a thorn in the side of Christians and Jews for centuries. Although at some basic level the 3 religious sects do have something common. Maybe everyone should consider that. However I don’t see it ever happening because concessions would have to be made.