4:15 "In Long Shadows, chapter 29..." Me: Goes to bookshelf and pulls out copy of Long Shadows. Sees that the last chapter is chapter 28, where they find Ashfur's dead body and wonder who killed him. _Nice._
Whether the imposter is Ashfur or Shrewpaw, I feel that this whole “imposter thing” is just an excuse for the Erins to make Bramblestar seem more likeable.
@@janeoathdragon5793 (This commentor was making a joke. Bramblestar sucks, so the Erins are making it seem like hes amazing, compared to the impostor at least.)
WOAH. I never put the pieces together, but it's totally Shrewpaw!! Can't wait for the epic battle at the end of the next book where Squirrelflight talks him down by becoming his mate and abandoning Bramblestar!
AshFur. Edit: (Maybe it would be a really good plot twist, if it was HAWKFROST controlling BrambleStar- Like, he didn’t die in Omen Of The Stars, and was possessing His half bro :OOOO ) Edit: While reading the back cover of ‘Veil of Shadows,’ something was brought to my attention. *’The imposter of Bramblestar has been punishing and exiling those who broke the code.’* The two suspects who we all expect are the imposters: Ashfur and Darktail. Darktail did not care for the code. He killed multiple cats, and he wasnt really a clan cat. He was never loyal to the code, and he would have no reason to exile cats who broke the warrior code *Ashfur, on the other hand.* Squirrelflight ‘broke the code’ when she took in Leafpools kits. Leafpool broke the code. Ashfur had *every* reason to posses Bramblestar and exile cats.
*Everyone:* I want ThunderClan to SUFFER for once they've been sitting pretty since they got to the lake *Erins:* super easy, barely an inconvenience _two broken code books and one super edition later_ *Everyone:* Wait no stop! *Erins:* nah making ThunderClan cats suffer is tight
@Lauren Alexander Erins never stated whether she's still alive or not. We know that she must have been quite older than Leafpool because when the latter was still an apprentice, Cody already had at least one litter of kits.
I was thinking that the imposter was CLEARLY Ashfu- Moonkitti: It's Shrewpaw! I just sat there in silence, reevaluating my life and mentally arguing that it IS Ashfur. Then at the very end I saw *April Fools. It's Ashfur you guys I'm so sorry.*
THE WHOLE FANDOM HAS BEEN SCREAMING ITS ASHFUR I HAVE NEVER BELIEVED ANYONE THAT IT WAS ASHFUR Thank you Moonkitti for finding another cat who could be the imposter! Edit: PEOPLE! So far I have 37 comments about this. I KNOOOOOOOW it was an April Fools!!!!!!!!!!!! I made that comment at the beginning of the video! I’ve been too lazy for the last two months too change the comment. Also yes, I KNOW ITS ASHFUR! I just wanted to have another theory ready in case it WASNT ASHFUR. Thank you :)
Moonkitti: *goes on a rant about how it’s shrewpaw* Me: wait this kinda makes sense. Moomkitti: April fools! Me: WHY WHY *sobbing* Edit:I know I spelled it moomkitti but I’m not going to edit it out because... well idk just because. Also thanks for all the likes!
We all know that the imposter is Sootfur, it all matches up, he was in the lake territory for a short time, and has interacted with Squirrelflight before, it all adds up, Stootfur is the true imposter
The imposter is CLEARLY Jayfeather, guys it’s so obvious. Because he never ACTUALLY came back from the past with the tribe a double has been living his life, so he wants revenge
“You guessed it!” Me: Uh... Ashf- “Shrewpaw!” I know it was an April fools joke that it was Shrewpaw, but still, it would’ve been AMAZING if it was him.
No, it's breezepelt, the real breezepelt was forced out of their body right after dovewing's silence and wanted to continue his plans but only found a way now
Yeah, We never saw Shrewpaw in Starclan when JayFeather rallied everyone in starclan up, or Ashfur! *-Maybe Shrewpaw killed Ashfur because Ashfur liked Squirrelflight, then was hiding away in the dark forest or something from SHAMMMEEEEE-* *-I don’t believe this is April fools >:[]-*
the imposter has got to be Stormfur (wait is he still alive not sure I lost track when he joined the Tribe) he loved Squielflight but knew Bramble held her affection not him and so he ran off to the tribe to be mates with a tribe cat instead so as to not have to endure the pain of seeing her and knowing he can not be with her lol jk
another thing that's important to note, is that the impostor has a dislike for specific cats (lionblaze, jayfeather, etc) that have at least a somewhat connection to squirrelflight. the impostor is also wild about the warrior code so i'm thinking it's someone who's death broke the warrior code or they were hurt by someome breaking the warrior code. people keep thinking i'm saying the impostor is hollyleaf, so i'm gonna note that i'm saying the impostor was killed by hollyleaf, not that they are hollyleaf. hollyleaf wasn't killed by a clanmate and doesn't have anything against her family.
People keep suggesting Hollyleaf, but why would she have anything against her brothers? They had a rough relationship, yeah, but she died loving them, and she died *for* the clans during the Great Battle. I don’t see it being in character for her to try to sabotage ThunderClan.
@@pansysoupbrand6558 did i not just say that i'm suggesting the impostor was killed by hollyleaf, and not that the impostor is hollyleaf? besides, hollyleaf wasn't killed by a clanmate, she was killed by the dark forest.
i was screaming "ITS ASHFUR! ITS ASHFURRRR!" then she says shrewpaw. when moon said it was shrew paw I shit you not i literally shriveled up into a raisin from laughter
this is such a good idea! i could totally see it being shrewpaw, but he was so minor to the series I wouldn't be surprised if the erins forgot about him.
Me: it’s Ashfur Moon: It’s shrewpaw Me: *listens to the rest of the vid in silence and starts to think it actually is shrewpaw* Moon: APRIL FOOLS! IT’S ASHFUR!!! Me: 😐
Me: "Oh I know Moonkitti is going to be talking about Ashfur!" Moonkitti- "Its S H R E W P A W" Me: "My life is a lie" Moonkitti: "Jk april fools its Ashfur"
i don’t care if we already know it’s ashfur this has convinced me that the hunters were gonna make it shrewpaw then someone said it would make more sence to be ashfur
Me: I'm pretty sure it's Ashfur (even though I've only fully read the veryfirst warrior cat series and only know this stuff from the internet) *-S H R E W P A W-* ... I'm so glad I watched till the end
ok but SINCE bramblestar's ghost is still around while bramblestar's body is up and walking that means that we don't have to rule out all the cats that seem to be living, so long as they had a somewhat near-death experience before Skyclan came by, and we can imagine that maybe somehow their body got reposessed by a different ghost, and theirs is now wandering. Is that a stretch? Yes. But it does pave the way for an interesting option: Breezepelt as the impostor. What if he died in the tunnels at some point in Crowfeather's trial, and his body was posessed, maybe inadvertently, by fallen leaves or rock? It would both explain his sudden redemption arc (although they did a pretty good job of that, ngl) and the origins of the impostor. Of course it's a stretch and it doesn't explain why he's crushing on squilf but I think it has some potential in terms of plot arcs.
I remember from the book, 'Bramblestar' said to give the prey to the stronger cats. And while watching Moon talking about Shrewpaw, I'm just thinking about Bramblestar but with Shrewpaws head
Why it’s not Ashfur: Because IN THE SILENT THAW IT SAYS THAT THE CAT WAS FROM OUTSIDE OF THE CLANS but no hate lol this was a good vid Also I still think it’s sleekwhisker
Midnight yep mostly cause when I was designing her I went. “Ok what can I do with the fact the I combined what most people call the most beautiful tribes” So I basically made her a mixture of blue purple and light pink. Cause I really like that color combo My only rule is that she can’t change her scales black since Silkwings can’t be black.
But Ashfur knew the lake territories. He ran from the lake to the Thunderclan camp to tell Squirrelflight where Firestar was and that Hawkfrost was going to kill him. So it's not Ashfur.
that made me laugh when you said it is I yelled ASHFUR and then you said shrootpaw I was like what? no? im so sad. At the end oh yea its april fools I forgot I was right all along :3
I've never read the broken code yet but I was for sure it was ash fur Clues 1. Ashfur liked squirrelflight 2. Ashfur was in the time zone when sky clan wasn't a thing 3. HE IS EVIL NO MATTER WHAT YOU SAY
Shrewpaw: *exists*
Moonkitti: he's EVIL
Lol
Shrewpaw: *breathes*
Moonkitti, instantly: EEEEEEEEVIL
I seriously don't think it's Shrewpaw, he dosn't really seem evil, and the Erin's just kill him off. LOL
Melody Zhang nah it’s definitely not him.
The imposter is obviously Cory, from everyone's favorite anime Cory in the House
BrightSkyInTheWinter I mean... or the sexy beast Danny Devito
Cory in the house is the best anime
I KNEW IT
You're wrong, my favorite Anime is Toy Story.
BrightSkyInTheWinter
Who is Cory? :/
Im 90% sure it's Berrynose's dead evil twin brother, Noseberry
Diana W but berrynose is evil as well?
@@alex-zd2kw 👀 👀 👀
*gasps* b- berrystumpytail?
Berrystumpytail: owo yes, it is i, uwu
Diana W WUT
@@ponylover766 perhaps berrystumpytail was secretly helped with his evil plans by jayno-eyes.
Plot twist: the imposter is actually just Bramblestar.
O h m y s t a r c l a n
Or hes being a jerk
Plot twist: He ate too much cat nip or whatever makes cats go crazy
Plot twist, it’s jayfeather, he has blue eyes!
my god i love that username
plot twist: *there* *is* *no* *imposter,* *rootpaw* *is* *just* *crazy*
Double plot twist: all the cats in the series is crazy and Starclan and The Dark Forrest does not exist.
@@serenitythesiren5031 Yeah and Cloudtail to!! YEEEEEEESSS!
Triple plotwisy: inspite of Starclan’s nonexistance, Bramblestar is still possessed and its Ashfur
Crazy plot twist: the entire world knows it's Ashfur
Plot twist: the imposter is actually the erins
Edit: omg thank you so much for the likes
what a twist
DUN DUN DUUUUNNN
xD
Y e s
Omg YEES
4:15 "In Long Shadows, chapter 29..."
Me: Goes to bookshelf and pulls out copy of Long Shadows.
Sees that the last chapter is chapter 28, where they find Ashfur's dead body and wonder who killed him.
_Nice._
Daaang she got me good 😂
SAME
HAHAHA
“Feed him some of the twoleg stuff by the thunderpath”
-feeds bramblestar motor oil-
well done rootpaw the tree child
Delicious👌
I thought that ment cigarettes
Dragon Flame 02 It is canon. Bramblestar smokes.
--bramblestar, what have I told you about drugs?--
Whether the imposter is Ashfur or Shrewpaw, I feel that this whole “imposter thing” is just an excuse for the Erins to make Bramblestar seem more likeable.
hi dovewing
Hey dovewing
What’s your eye color Dovewing?
But - but he was never likable, not after the second arc at least.
@@janeoathdragon5793 (This commentor was making a joke. Bramblestar sucks, so the Erins are making it seem like hes amazing, compared to the impostor at least.)
Imagine if the imposter IS actually Shrewpaw and isn't Ashfur.
GreyJay we’d all be like MOONKITTI WAS RIGHT
@@alex-zd2kw the moonkitti has spoken
Then I'd have no reason to live
Its Not Shrewpaw and Not Ashfur. Its Nutwhisker!!! The Brother of Yellowfang!!!
@@river3604 its april fools
It’s obviously me, the sleep deprived demon child who exploded in a easy bake oven
OH MAG GOD SAME
Username cuts off-
Guess it wasn’t an easy bake as it was an easy Accident
@@francisire Lol
Are you me and my entire friend group
Plot twist: It's MOONKITTI
Feuerhawk CONSPIRACY!
GASP
WHAT
DUN DUN DUNNN
WOAH. I never put the pieces together, but it's totally Shrewpaw!! Can't wait for the epic battle at the end of the next book where Squirrelflight talks him down by becoming his mate and abandoning Bramblestar!
River Pond it says April fool's "it's ashfur guys" at the end
@@Killdahcake Yeah, I know. I was joking too.
River Pond XD
I knew this was going to be a joke ha ha but I'm glad we can all agree the imposter is Honeyfern.
Yes
It says the imposter was a past leader of thunderclan . honeyfern was a leader???
NOOO Honeyfern is a confirmed StarClan member! I think it’s either Flametail or Rain (The one from Darktail’s Kin) OR Stormfur.
@@selmaspeackman9842 wait, Ashfur was a leader?
No it's Bramblestar
AshFur.
Edit: (Maybe it would be a really good plot twist, if it was HAWKFROST controlling BrambleStar-
Like, he didn’t die in Omen Of The Stars, and was possessing His half bro :OOOO )
Edit: While reading the back cover of ‘Veil of Shadows,’ something was brought to my attention.
*’The imposter of Bramblestar has been punishing and exiling those who broke the code.’*
The two suspects who we all expect are the imposters:
Ashfur and Darktail.
Darktail did not care for the code. He killed multiple cats, and he wasnt really a clan cat. He was never loyal to the code, and he would have no reason to exile cats who broke the warrior code
*Ashfur, on the other hand.*
Squirrelflight ‘broke the code’ when she took in Leafpools kits. Leafpool broke the code. Ashfur had *every* reason to posses Bramblestar and exile cats.
Ah yes. Her evil ex
That would make no sense! Moonkitti made so many good points on how it’s actually Shrewpaw.
I would like it to be Darktail but I also kinda want it to be Ashfur. Which one should I choose?
Yes me and my friend has the name theory yay I’m not the only one :)
FlarinaFairy but all the hints point to ashfur as well
*Everyone:* I want ThunderClan to SUFFER for once they've been sitting pretty since they got to the lake
*Erins:* super easy, barely an inconvenience
_two broken code books and one super edition later_
*Everyone:* Wait no stop!
*Erins:* nah making ThunderClan cats suffer is tight
Never expected to see a Ryan George ref on a Moonkitti video
@@static7974 unexpected references are TIGHT hahaha
Always lol
everyone: but shouldn’t we give thunderclan some slack?
The Erin’s: oh, jeez. Get off my back.
Everyone: oh ok I’ll get off that thing
I can't explain how much I love this, I can hear it in his voice XD
The imposter is Cody the kittypet, Leafpool's ex-girlfriend. The writers just changed her gender like they did with Rowanclaw and Mosskit.
Huh??????????????????????????
DUN DUN DUN DUNNNN
Hol up-
All 3 written female then just male
Trans cats! Nah but seriously
@Lauren Alexander Erins never stated whether she's still alive or not. We know that she must have been quite older than Leafpool because when the latter was still an apprentice, Cody already had at least one litter of kits.
I was thinking that the imposter was CLEARLY Ashfu-
Moonkitti: It's Shrewpaw!
I just sat there in silence, reevaluating my life and mentally arguing that it IS Ashfur.
Then at the very end I saw *April Fools. It's Ashfur you guys I'm so sorry.*
THE WHOLE FANDOM HAS BEEN SCREAMING ITS ASHFUR
I HAVE NEVER BELIEVED ANYONE THAT IT WAS ASHFUR
Thank you Moonkitti for finding another cat who could be the imposter!
Edit: PEOPLE! So far I have 37 comments about this. I KNOOOOOOOW it was an April Fools!!!!!!!!!!!! I made that comment at the beginning of the video! I’ve been too lazy for the last two months too change the comment. Also yes, I KNOW ITS ASHFUR! I just wanted to have another theory ready in case it WASNT ASHFUR. Thank you :)
mudclaw? Haven’t seen it yet lol
LOLL
Yes it’s Ashfur watch till very end
Watch till the end :/
I’m gonna have to r/whoooosh some of these replies
Well to be honest almost every tom-cat who met Squirrelflight fell in love with her: Bramblestar, Ashfur, Stormfur...
Samantha Martínez firestar....
JOKING
PLOT TWIST
it’s the evilness bramblestar has that went away after his arc because he needs do be a saint according to the authors
His evilness wanted to be included so it can brag to the niceness that it got to banish an old main character
PolaroidPaws Imma ruin those 100 likes and turn it into 101 :)
Moonkitti: *goes on a rant about how it’s shrewpaw*
Me: wait this kinda makes sense.
Moomkitti: April fools!
Me: WHY WHY *sobbing*
Edit:I know I spelled it moomkitti but I’m not going to edit it out because... well idk just because. Also thanks for all the likes!
Moomkitti? It says Moomkitti
DUDE U WERE RIGHT although I did feel that this vid was suspicious
That's me XD
MomKitti lol
@@kyleeh6607 XD
We all know that the imposter is Sootfur, it all matches up, he was in the lake territory for a short time, and has interacted with Squirrelflight before, it all adds up, Stootfur is the true imposter
Plot twist: Bramblestar isn’t possessed, he just wanted to pretend he was so that he could let out all that dad-issue anger he definitely always had!
Moonkitti: **Makes a joke about it being Shrewpaw**
Erin Hunter: ... **Laughs nervously**
Lol
Well it's me of course.
Oh yeah it's definitely you
Wait are you two different or the same person?
@@sparkfrog777
No, im the real Swiftpaw
LMAO THERE'S TWO OF YOU LMFAOOOOOO
@@LostSwiftpaw
NO I AM
Moon: Who does cover all these points???
Me: ASHFU-
Moon: *shrewpaw*
That’s the best April fools joke I’ve ever seen
The imposter is CLEARLY Jayfeather, guys it’s so obvious. Because he never ACTUALLY came back from the past with the tribe a double has been living his life, so he wants revenge
“You guessed it!”
Me: Uh... Ashf-
“Shrewpaw!”
I know it was an April fools joke that it was Shrewpaw, but still, it would’ve been AMAZING if it was him.
FLAMETAIL
The pains of being Australian.
It’s already April 2nd so your joke doesn’t work on me. >:p
Espresso CG your in the future
I KNEW TIME TRAVELERS EXSISTED GAAASP
Same
and I'm in New Zealand so it's also not April Fools :3
Aussie problems
Video : WHO IS THE IMPOSTER?
Me: It’s Ashfu-
Moonkitti: ITS SHREWPAW!
Edit: thanks for the likes 👍 Edits edit: Wow 900 like thanks so much 🥳
That's what I was thinking and when she said shrewpaw I stopped dead and listened to the rest of the video in silence
lol
i though the same............wait is this a April fools?
That was totally me
I think ashfur is too chill now.
No, it's breezepelt, the real breezepelt was forced out of their body right after dovewing's silence and wanted to continue his plans but only found a way now
so breezepelt smashes his father's lover's sister. genius boii
um
what about crowfeathers trial then?
Plot Twist: there is no imposter and its really Bramblestar's split personality that he's been hiding for his whole life.
HDJELGSKFDGJLIPSALOXOWMD
yeah and his zodiac sign is gemini
This actually would make sense! He is confirmed to have had a crush on Squirrelflight! Not even April Fool’s Day stuff, again this is possible.
i think it's ashfur
I was expecting the imposter to be Rick Astley
Kipp the Rainwing 2: Electric Boogaloo
lmfao
Boi it's Astley.
@@the-silliest-goose oh fuck I'm an idiot
its me im the imposter
Im shocked
We have all been bamboozled
Lol
*gasp*
I knew it!
Me: I need to have someone to talk to about this in real time.
Me: Forces the I spoil series on my friend
Me tho
that’s what i actually did oop
Finally a video that isn’t related to Among Us that talks about imposters
Ikr
Me, searching for an Among Us video:
*finds this video*
I was so confused by everything until I remembered, "Wait, it's April 1st..."
Yeah, We never saw Shrewpaw in Starclan when JayFeather rallied everyone in starclan up, or Ashfur! *-Maybe Shrewpaw killed Ashfur because Ashfur liked Squirrelflight, then was hiding away in the dark forest or something from SHAMMMEEEEE-*
*-I don’t believe this is April fools >:[]-*
BUT WHERE DID FLAMETAIL GO IN OMEN OF THE STARS AFTER IVYPOOL TIRIED TO KILL HIM!!!!!??????
@@blazingstarofdawnclan5279 he was seen in starclan after Ivypool almost killed him.
the imposter has got to be Stormfur (wait is he still alive not sure I lost track when he joined the Tribe)
he loved Squielflight but knew Bramble held her affection not him and so he ran off to the tribe to be mates with a tribe cat instead so as to not have to endure the pain of seeing her and knowing he can not be with her
lol jk
He's alive I think....
Wait it's Stormfur not Stonetail
who?
Do you mean Stormfur....?
sorry Stormfur I forgot his name
Teddy 3293 you mean stormfur?
It's Ashfur, he's sus. I saw him vent in electrical.
"hoooh... woah... you're not subscribed to moonktti?"
me: *looks angrily at my friend who watches moonlitti constantly but isn't subscribed*
@Chikara
i didn't see that mistake before but it's perfect so i'm not going to remove it
it's probable that it is shrewpaw since brambleclaw, ashfur and a lot of the other suspects weren't apprentices with her.
WAHAHAHAHAHA ITS WARIOPAW
*WALLUIGI*
@@spoopymantis4329 *WAAAAAAA*
Hm.. What if it's Scarp-....
I thought nearly noone remember shrewpaw and his attraction to squirrleflight-
4:08 “now we know what his warrior name is, it’s *BRAMBLESTAR”*
"His warrior name is ..Bramblestar" actually got a good laugh out of me, thank you.
I’m sure starclan is so glad that they let ashfur in now. I mean, _all he did was love too much._
GippyHappy obviously...
another thing that's important to note, is that the impostor has a dislike for specific cats (lionblaze, jayfeather, etc) that have at least a somewhat connection to squirrelflight. the impostor is also wild about the warrior code so i'm thinking it's someone who's death broke the warrior code or they were hurt by someome breaking the warrior code.
people keep thinking i'm saying the impostor is hollyleaf, so i'm gonna note that i'm saying the impostor was killed by hollyleaf, not that they are hollyleaf. hollyleaf wasn't killed by a clanmate and doesn't have anything against her family.
On one of the warrior cat quizzes when it’s asking a question about the imposter, it says he/him. But yeah I agree with all the other stuff
No they wouldn’t put a she-cat in a tom’s body....... that would be too wierd
@@sunspotgamer5388 i'm saying there were killed by hollyleaf, not that the impostor is hollyleaf.
People keep suggesting Hollyleaf, but why would she have anything against her brothers? They had a rough relationship, yeah, but she died loving them, and she died *for* the clans during the Great Battle. I don’t see it being in character for her to try to sabotage ThunderClan.
@@pansysoupbrand6558 did i not just say that i'm suggesting the impostor was killed by hollyleaf, and not that the impostor is hollyleaf? besides, hollyleaf wasn't killed by a clanmate, she was killed by the dark forest.
i was screaming "ITS ASHFUR! ITS ASHFURRRR!"
then she says shrewpaw.
when moon said it was shrew paw I shit you not i literally shriveled up into a raisin from laughter
In a few words : Moonkitti played among us with bramblestar and shrewpaw
The books: Ashfur
Us: Ashfur
Moonkitti: Shrewpaw
When you have nothing to do because of COVID19 so you theorize for hours.
This whole thing was dripping with sarcasm. I love it.
"Who fits all these descriptions?"
Me: ASHFUR!
Moonkitti: YOU GUESSED IT, IT'S *SHREWPAW*
oh come on it's Seedpaw who died saving Jayfeather's stick in Bramblestar's Storm
I know, right? Its so obvious
Omg!!! I was literally thinking about Shrewpaw when you mentioned this cat loved Squirrelflight!!! Yesssssssssiiirrrrr!!!
April fools.
the second last frame is surprisingly adorable wtf
It’s absolutely -Ashfur- Shrewpaw, change my mind.
oh my god, i’m so out of loop with the books, what is going ON?
SAME I havent read any of the books since omen of the stars, and i am so lost
moonkitti is the imposter
(also i love how you just randomly threw smudge in there as a candidate that actually made me laugh)
mata schmata mothwing’s atheism
"I WILL ALWAYS COME BACK FOR YOU, EVEN IF I'M DEAD" Sounds like Fnaf to me-"I always come back."
I'm the inposter moonkitti
In the words of Alexander Hamilton,
"YOU CAN'T BE SERIOUS..."
yes I'm subbed and trust me I knew this would be an April Fools
h a m i l t o n i s b e s t
It’s shrewpaw!
Shrewpaw: exists
Me: wait, wait, wait- I thought it was ash fur
this is such a good idea! i could totally see it being shrewpaw, but he was so minor to the series I wouldn't be surprised if the erins forgot about him.
plot twist: StarClan and the Dark forest doesn’t exist and the book series is just kittypets & stray cats getting way into a feral cat roleplay.
Me: it’s Ashfur
Moon: It’s shrewpaw
Me: *listens to the rest of the vid in silence and starts to think it actually is shrewpaw*
Moon: APRIL FOOLS! IT’S ASHFUR!!!
Me: 😐
Me: "Oh I know Moonkitti is going to be talking about Ashfur!"
Moonkitti- "Its S H R E W P A W"
Me: "My life is a lie"
Moonkitti: "Jk april fools its Ashfur"
When you said "your not subscribed to moonkitti?"
I said "i aM!" Then i wasnt and screamed, "iM soRry"
Dw moon, put on notifications too ^^
i don’t care if we already know it’s ashfur this has convinced me that the hunters were gonna make it shrewpaw then someone said it would make more sence to be ashfur
when shrewpaw confessed his undying love for squilf and she said "prey is running well in thunderclan" i KNEW they were meant to be ❤
Plot twist: This is an among us video
Me: I'm pretty sure it's Ashfur (even though I've only fully read the veryfirst warrior cat series and only know this stuff from the internet)
*-S H R E W P A W-*
... I'm so glad I watched till the end
Miint OwO it’s Definitely Ashfur
I've read this series 2 times, ALL of the books, and I cant remember who shrewpaw is???? WHY, MY MEMORY HAS FAILED MEEEEEEEEE!?!?!
HOW DARE U!
ok
but
SINCE bramblestar's ghost is still around while bramblestar's body is up and walking
that means that we don't have to rule out all the cats that seem to be living, so long as they had a somewhat near-death experience before Skyclan came by, and we can imagine that maybe somehow their body got reposessed by a different ghost, and theirs is now wandering.
Is that a stretch? Yes. But it does pave the way for an interesting option:
Breezepelt as the impostor.
What if he died in the tunnels at some point in Crowfeather's trial, and his body was posessed, maybe inadvertently, by fallen leaves or rock? It would both explain his sudden redemption arc (although they did a pretty good job of that, ngl) and the origins of the impostor. Of course it's a stretch and it doesn't explain why he's crushing on squilf but I think it has some potential in terms of plot arcs.
It's GOT to be Shrewpaw!
When I was reading the broken code my number one guess was always Ashfur. Never doubted it
It's clearly Benjamin Froaklin
carter. the espurr’s name is carter.
*screams in GinjaNinjaOwO*
@@Emily-cy6ej HOWDEY HEY!!!
@@finch8703 HOWDEY HEY I'M (not) RAE!!!
@@Emily-cy6ej YESSSSSSSSSS
Plot twist: bramble only just caught rabies
I remember from the book, 'Bramblestar' said to give the prey to the stronger cats.
And while watching Moon talking about Shrewpaw, I'm just thinking about Bramblestar but with Shrewpaws head
Ashfur in star clan with blonde hair: (Sees Squirrelflight get banished) “Narrows eyes and put paws together”
“Yeees. Dis is good.”
To be honest I did not expect the end. I’m really going to be fooled by every April fools ;w;
Why it’s not Ashfur: Because IN THE SILENT THAW IT SAYS THAT THE CAT WAS FROM OUTSIDE OF THE CLANS
but no hate lol this was a good vid
Also I still think it’s sleekwhisker
I think Sleekwhisker is still alive...
It’s definitely Marmalade then.
What if Myler turned evil and poseesed ????
tery !
One eye
NightFluff yup, spread the word
I’m excited for the prank give me your worse.
Edit: called it this is beautiful.
Rainwing Silkwing hybrid? That sounds like one pretty dragon.
Midnight yep mostly cause when I was designing her I went.
“Ok what can I do with the fact the I combined what most people call the most beautiful tribes”
So I basically made her a mixture of blue purple and light pink. Cause I really like that color combo
My only rule is that she can’t change her scales black since Silkwings can’t be black.
Omg I love how u ended it, about the subscribing, and I'm pretty Ashfur
Moonkitty:"WHO'S THE IMPOSTER?!"
Me who hasn't read any books since Dawn of the Clans:"Yo what the fuck is going on there"
But Ashfur knew the lake territories. He ran from the lake to the Thunderclan camp to tell Squirrelflight where Firestar was and that Hawkfrost was going to kill him. So it's not Ashfur.
*watching this 4 years later knowing it’s ashfur*
Don’t we all
that made me laugh when you said it is I yelled ASHFUR and then you said shrootpaw I was like what? no? im so sad. At the end oh yea its april fools I forgot I was right all along :3
Ah yes, Shrootpaw
I keep forgetting Moonkitti exists when busy watching Jacksepticeye and then I get the next video Moonkitti makes and i'm like 'oh yeah'
Moonkitti: Are you not subscribed to Moonkitti?
Me: Scrolls down as fast as humanly possible and subscribes to Moonkitti.
Is this an April fools joke? I was NOT expecting this.
I've never read the broken code yet but I was for sure it was ash fur
Clues
1. Ashfur liked squirrelflight
2. Ashfur was in the time zone when sky clan wasn't a thing
3. HE IS EVIL NO MATTER WHAT YOU SAY
:O
Plot twist: Shrewpaw really is the imposter
Plot twist: Starclan is just messing with everyones brain and this whole arc is a dream sequence.