Interesting observations. I would describe it the other way around. To me Sarah seemed to just enjoy her sound more than the lyric, whereas Ella seemed more connected to the art form.
I'm not going to say one singer is better than the other but Sarah's voice and phrasing speaks more to my emotional interpretations. Sarah's voice plays my emotional strings and vocal sensibilities like no other with her vocal tones, phrasings and style.
Sarah's technique is superior, incomparably great.But I think Sarah's emotions sound more calculated, Ella is warmer and more natural. Her singing goes straight to my heart. Of course this is subjective.
I'm ready to recognize that Sarah is the better singer technically and voice wise, but "it don't mean a thing if it ain't got that swing". Ella touches my soul in a way no other jazz singer does (well, maybe Billie, some days).
I can't choose. Both insane vocally. I'd only really say that Sarah is more of a technical singer, whereas Ella more stylistic and gritty. But both had incredible technique when they wanted.
Sarah is one of my favorite singers and has one of the greatest voices and ability to sing than most singers. My vote is for her but that's not to take anything from the superb improvisons of Ella. I actually believe How High the Moon and It Don't Mean a Thing are sung and scatted best by Ella. They have their own style and songs that belong to them. Lullaby of Birdland is sung and scatted best by Sarah in my opinion. Love them both, but Sarah is my preference.
These two are very similar in how they captured the ears of listeners and influenced generations of musicians, but their styles are very different. It's hard to compare. Sarah has the advantage when it comes to lows, her approach and lower voice. Ella's lows are impressive considering how high her voice is, though the majority of the clips are both of them in their later years. Ella takes belts for sure, they're so good for a jazz singer. Hv is hard for me, but I prefer Sarah's. Very neck and neck.
These two divas of vocal excelence are beyond excellent in. Style technique and smooth fluid captivating listening pleasure of sound.....in complete control and command...
In her prime I Sarah Vaughan had a voice which with the proper training would have made her an excellent opera singer. During the 40s and 50s her voice had control, flexibility, resonance, richness, a stunning lower register, and an ability to reach a high C that were very reminiscent of classical singers. For Sarah Vaughan at her most "operatic" please listen to her performance of the song "Say You'll Wait For Me". Both Ella Fitzgerald and Sarah Vaughan were wonderful singers. However, from a purely technical standpoint I think that Sarah Vaughan had the superior voice.
Lets start by saying these are two of the greatest singers ever! As far as scatting , its no comparison Ella wins hands down, she has more vocal agility and creativity in her scatting, and can do it twice as fast as anyone on the planet. I love the tickness of Sarahs voice, and her bottom notes are insane. However when I hear the perfect pitch and diction and cleanliness of Ella's voice especially on her ballads, she puts me in a trance! Her voice is also colorless and colorful at the same time, which gives her a more universal appeal.......its Ella the magnificent for me!!!!!
I love both of em disciplined and technically sound singers both of em are. Ellas voice is so agile and clean. Like water in a stream. Sarah voice is smooth like a thick syrup and butter on pancakes.
For me it's Sarah Vaughan. Her reach for notes is more effortless. She has a warmer tone for me and her timing is far superior. She also, in her live shows, showed more humour and intimacy with her audiences. That said, both are better than all the others.
Both of them were great. I prefer Sassy. Ella Fitzgerald was more of a scatter. Sarah I like the way she interpreted her ballads more. How she soared from high to low and vice versa. A plus Sarah played the piano
Two absolute Legends of music! This is Real talent and professionalism on a grand scale. They are both Jazz, Music, and Vocal Icons. Ella is my absolute favorite singer and i also love and Have a huge amount of respect and admiration for Sara “Sassy” Vaughn! 2 💎💎
I really love their styles so very much. Scat singing wise. Sarah had beautiful vocals. When she'd scat, she'd sing melodies with her voice that connected to everyone's ear. Satisfying but beautiful. Ella on the other hand. She had a very beautiful way of improvising when it came to scatting. She improvised the same way a trumpet player would, and depicted her voice as a jazz instrument for her band, and her audience. It's a tie, however, in my opinion. Ella Fitzgerald is jazz's most perfect singer. While Sarah Vaughan is one of jazz's most satisfying and soulful singers.
WHAT A FABULOUS VIDEO- THANK YOU SO MUCH !!! I love both, but I prefer Ella. I listen more "Soul" when Ella sings. Also more genuineness. I think Sarah sings more deliberately, more intellectually, and very mannered in her late recordings. . It's certainly very subjective, but I feel that Ellas radiates more happiness and joy when she sings. Sarah's best live album ever is Swings At the Tivoli 1963. I never tire of hearing it over and over again. I would like to point out these words from one of jazz's most important critics:Leonard Feather described Sarah's skills: “Recently I heard a classical, a pop and a jazz singer. A soprano, a contra-alto and a coloratura singer. A singer with the spontaneity of Ella Fitzgerald, the soul of Aretha Franklin, the warmth of Peggy Lee and the flawless phrasing of Carmen McRae. They were all on the same show and they were all Sarah Vaughan"
This was a fairly good match even though it was between women of different strengths and styles. It was very fairly displayed. I think if I had to choose which woman I would rather listen to on a regular basis it’s probably Sarah Vaughan. And I went into this thinking it would be Ella Fitzgerald. It might still be though… I think I listen to Ella Fitzgerald more often anyway. I’m a little confused now, lol.
I generally dislike these kinds of “contest” when it comes to artistic expression. I love them both but because of my love of opera im more fascinated by Sarah’s voice. Although no one can touch Ella’s scatting. I’m a ballad person and in that arena Sarah Soars!
People will always have their favorites, choose their sides, make their camps, et cetera; but NO ONE will be able to deny that BOTH of them were vocal titans, both marble pillars in their respective and individual abilities, deliveries and techniques; both equal luminaries in a galaxy of music and most importantly that genre known as jazz in which both set permanent and unforgettable standards…
Both of them have quite an unlimited range. I find new notes from them almost everyday, especially Ella. Ella mixing B5s with absolute ease and singing (well, grumbling) an F2. Found tons of C6s but no good notes above though.
I’m halfway through but I’m gonna make a few comments; Sarah Vaughan was a very beautiful woman in her youth. Now, looks aside and vocally speaking, they were mostly equally good in the lower registers. With Sarah winning out for me a few times because she has that depth that can’t be beat. But Ella was equally strong on most of them with her very clear voice and if excellent forward Placement that helped her carry those low notes. They both have tremendous support, especially Ella. On belting, I think that Ella shined more on the fourth octave so far. She has more of that Belty quality, that chassis quality and is comfortable on those notes, whereas in may have been a little bit high in comparison for Sarah who sounds a little more light and soft and mixy to me. And there’s nothing wrong with that.
@@Rosannasfriend Yep, Ella was primarily a chest belter. A more stylistic, raw singer. Sarah was quite influenced by classical soprano singing which is very apparent in her approach and style. I find it hard to compare.
@@vyeagra420 I think it is more due to the approach rather than trying to sound like a higher voice. Her approach is very akin to how some classically-trained sopranos and mezzos who sang jazz sounded.
Improvisation, musicality and spontaneity wise - Ella wins for me… However, vocally Sarah due to her musical training always had the upper hand - technique wise . Hence, the quality of her voice was at its peak/prime throughout her life.
They were both phenomenal vocalists…though, apropos of your theme, it’s interesting to note that Ella herself thought, and said many times, that she thought Sarah was the greatest singer of their generation….there’s no battle…they are very different artists. Both great….but I would offer that Sarah had the greater instrument….and certainly a much greater vocal range.
Both were the most absolutely towering figures in mid-century American Songbook music. Impossible to say one is better than the other. Ella had a certain brightness to her voice, her pitch was perfect and she burst with versatility (Sunshine of My Love!) Sarah had stunning drama and sweeping operatic high notes. To be a bit nit picky, Ella wasn't a deep interpreter of lyrics and Sarah could overdo that slushy style at times. I can listen to them both for long streches, but Dinah Washington is actually the only singer I never tire of listening to.
Im am , & have been in awe of both singers from my teenage years. Then when I started extensively collecring their CD's, I found Sarah's repotoire more captivating. However, just lately, I've been mesmerized by the extensive musical renditions of Lena Horne. But the bottom line, - they all are my ladies of song, including, Dina Washington. Now run & tell that!
It's an easy choice for me ,Ella all the way ,she more flexible ,Blues ,Rock,Jazz and more of all round entertainer she was smooth as silk. I looked in my record collection i have one album of Sarah ,Ella i lost count, Cds and LPs she sang with all the great .From Sinatra ,Dean Martine , Nat cole ,Armstrong ,Tom Jones she has done it all.
Ella Fitzgerald had it till the end. The notes for me as music teacher are crispier to the ear. You can see them both reach heights with ease, the breath control from Ella astounding. If anything Ella was freer in that her persona never left her grasp. Sarah however did. Ella Fitzgerald will be forever you see her even now gaining popularity.
@@monicabella7894 Sarah is wonderful, I love her - but first of all I think Ella is musically more versatile and I would like to say that your assessment of Ella is a big underestimate. Excuse me if I write this - your statement about Ella Fitzgerald: "Ella Fitzgerald is good for a nice relaxed musical background, that's all" is actually an embarrassingly stupid statement for every jazz connoisseur. If you told that to the world famous jazz legends that Ella worked with, they would laugh at you. Ella is so much more than just nice relaxed music. I think you don't know enough about Ella's huge record work. I've seen Ella live about 15 times. She was more than fantastic, simply unbelievable.
I can hear them both in todays female vocalist….who are continuing the legacy….Such as Dee Dee Bridgewater, Dianne Reeves, Nnenna Freelon, Rachelle Ferrell, Jazzmeia Horn, Samara Joy, Ledisi, and etc.
Also, I like to compare both singing the same song- then I assign "that" song to the version I enjoy the modt! But they are equally represented on the Diva 's top chart!
❤❤❤ BOTH ARE NUMBER 1. ELLA'S WAS LIQUID SILK AND SARAH'S WAS LIQUID GOLD ! NOW, WE HAVE PATTI AUSTIN, DIANNE KRALL, MAYSA LEAKS ÀND. LINDSEY WEBSTER .... DON'T FORGET NANCY WILSON
I would say that Sarah Vaughan had the more "perfect" voice, but to me she often seems rather detached from the lyrics and like she's listening to herself, which I find distracting. I feel like she is more about vocal technique and about an intellectual approach to harmony, than about really connecting with the idea and feeling of the song. Ella Fitzgerald is certainly no slouch technically, and she did have a strong level of engagement with the lyrics, as well as a musical freedom and spontaneity, all of which put her ahead as a singer in my book.
Ellla is pitchy and raspy, especially when striving for the highest and lowest notes. Sarah has control and a measurably accurate and pure pitch. I wish this channel would do an episode on how well and wide an interval these ladies can sings--with elegance.
Ella for me. Sarah always seems to be “putting on a display” rather than singing the song - I find the meaning of the song gets lost. Ella had all the talent and technique but she got out of the way of the song and only used technique to tell the story. Ella =🥇
In terms of head voice I think Sarah Vaughn has better control over it. She has vibrato, whereas Ella almost never has vibrato in her head voice it seems. Not in this video. Though I’m not a vibrato freak anyway, but there’s other factors. Ella‘s head voice tended to sound a little bit pushed all the time, and abrasive and a little bit too harsh/bright. I don’t mind that sound as a choice, but it seems to be her only choice most of the time. Though I did appreciate her warm F5. Sarah can crescendo and decrescendo and have a bright tone and warmth in her voice and sustain and go from a long held notes and phrase different notes after coming down on the same breath and do everything with her head voice. So I was very impressed by that.
I've never been able to choose It's like Biggie or Pac. They're two powerhouses with different approaches. Only wish I got to see Ella and Sassy do something together.
Sarah is amazing, but Ella is so touching. She takes one on her velvety wings. Oh, "'Round Midnight" by Ella is sooooooooo moving. Il love you, Ella! (Besides, Sarah sometimes uses vocal effects lacking feeling)
@@godhand-mo7qh it’s a performance of “how high the moon” but I can’t seem to find the specific performance. It might have gotten removed from RUclips.
Sarah Vaughan seems to have become more appreciated after her passing. I think younger generations might enjoy her more than Ella because a lot of her stylings were carried on by R&B/gospel singers like Dionne Warwick, Chaka Khan, Daryl Coley, Mariah Carey, and Anita Baker. Ella was a genius, but I don't hear her influence in modern day singers as much as Sarah Vaughan's. Which is interesting since Ella was more popular and respected than Sarah in their hey day.
That is a really interesting observation. I myself am 23 and have been besotted by Sarah's voice since I first heard it back when I was around 18. I would say Ella's voice was fantastic, but Sarah's was just superbly untouchable, to a level that very few singers have ever been able to achieve, and certainly not achieving now in today's popular artists! I think that has definitely caused younger generations to explore past artists by picking up these videos on RUclips and keep exploring alternatives to today.
Sarah. Love you Ella. But it’s Sarah for me.
Ella's singing was silky and smooth. Her pitch was almost perfect. I enjoy her style way more. She was one of a kind.
The Devine,. Sassy......... Sarah. She's the Blueprint. Both Stalwarts though.
Ella shows the Pleasure of Singing. Sarah represents the Art of Song.
Las dos eran geniales
Interesting observations. I would describe it the other way around. To me Sarah seemed to just enjoy her sound more than the lyric, whereas Ella seemed more connected to the art form.
I'm not going to say one singer is better than the other but Sarah's voice and phrasing speaks more to my emotional interpretations. Sarah's voice plays my emotional strings and vocal sensibilities like no other with her vocal tones, phrasings and style.
Sarah's technique is superior, incomparably great.But I think Sarah's emotions sound more calculated, Ella is warmer and more natural. Her singing goes straight to my heart. Of course this is subjective.
I’m the opposite. It’s all subjective
I'm ready to recognize that Sarah is the better singer technically and voice wise, but "it don't mean a thing if it ain't got that swing". Ella touches my soul in a way no other jazz singer does (well, maybe Billie, some days).
I can't choose. Both insane vocally. I'd only really say that Sarah is more of a technical singer, whereas Ella more stylistic and gritty. But both had incredible technique when they wanted.
I think it’s the other way around…. Sarah is the stylistic one…. But in another breathe…. They both are skilled in both areas of style and technic.
I get you cause Sarah played piano and understood music very well. But Ella just had a natural and free ear. both with astronomical results.
Sassy all day long. I love how she interprets a song, she transports me.
Both great singers but Sarah had the ability to emotionally touch me so I'm team Sarah
It's funny because i don't hear and feel any emotion when she sings.i ear a great vocal technician...but émotion,no
@@christophepena2212 interesting
Am just grateful that I am alive to enjoy these heavenly talents.Praise the Lord.
In the low notes, no one in the world can beat miss Sarah. In belts and head voice both are incredible
Both are the Legends of Jazz Vocalists. Both are the national treasures of USA!
Ella going from Bb2 to Bb5 in only seconds is crazy. And Sarah’s lows are out of this world. These are two of the greatest voices of ALL time.
Perfectly said!
Sarah is one of my favorite singers and has one of the greatest voices and ability to sing than most singers. My vote is for her but that's not to take anything from the superb improvisons of Ella. I actually believe How High the Moon and It Don't Mean a Thing are sung and scatted best by Ella. They have their own style and songs that belong to them. Lullaby of Birdland is sung and scatted best by Sarah in my opinion. Love them both, but Sarah is my preference.
These two are very similar in how they captured the ears of listeners and influenced generations of musicians, but their styles are very different. It's hard to compare.
Sarah has the advantage when it comes to lows, her approach and lower voice. Ella's lows are impressive considering how high her voice is, though the majority of the clips are both of them in their later years.
Ella takes belts for sure, they're so good for a jazz singer.
Hv is hard for me, but I prefer Sarah's.
Very neck and neck.
These two divas of vocal excelence are beyond excellent in. Style technique and smooth fluid captivating listening pleasure of sound.....in complete control and command...
These two legends both fell in love with my favorite singer's voice in the late and great Phyllis Hyman.
In her prime I Sarah Vaughan had a voice which with the proper training would have made her an excellent opera singer. During the 40s and 50s her voice had control, flexibility, resonance, richness, a stunning lower register, and an ability to reach a high C that were very reminiscent of classical singers. For Sarah Vaughan at her most "operatic" please listen to her performance of the song "Say You'll Wait For Me". Both Ella Fitzgerald and Sarah Vaughan were wonderful singers. However, from a purely technical standpoint I think that Sarah Vaughan had the superior voice.
Good thing she chose to stick with the superior art form of Jazz.
@@lubabalomahlombe451 I wouldn't say that jazz music is superior to classical music. They are two distinct and legitimate art forms.
I know this was a labor of love compiling this. Thank you for this! They were both so extraordinary.
@@CarolWyatt-e6d finally a positive comment on this video, haven’t seen one of these in a while lol
I like them both but Sarah I really love
Sarah had that four octave range and clarity of pitch putting her in a class ALL her own. DIVINE for certain!!
How dare you make me pick between these two 😩
Si tambien pienso lo mismo
Lets start by saying these are two of the greatest singers ever! As far as scatting , its no comparison Ella wins hands down, she has more vocal agility and creativity in her scatting, and can do it twice as fast as anyone on the planet. I love the tickness of Sarahs voice, and her bottom notes are insane. However when I hear the perfect pitch and diction and cleanliness of Ella's voice especially on her ballads, she puts me in a trance! Her voice is also colorless and colorful at the same time, which gives her a more universal appeal.......its Ella the magnificent for me!!!!!
I love both of em disciplined and technically sound singers both of em are.
Ellas voice is so agile and clean. Like water in a stream.
Sarah voice is smooth like a thick syrup and butter on pancakes.
❤❤❤❤
Both incredible singers ..Ella fitzgerald wins by a hair
Both are huge. Pioneers powerful women in the Jazz genre but I do have a preference for Sarah Vaughan. She exudes something magical.
Two of my favorites
For me it's Sarah Vaughan. Her reach for notes is more effortless. She has a warmer tone for me and her timing is far superior. She also, in her live shows, showed more humour and intimacy with her audiences. That said, both are better than all the others.
A timing far superior!?...NO
Ella all day everyday ❤
Both of them were great. I prefer Sassy. Ella Fitzgerald was more of a scatter. Sarah I like the way she interpreted her ballads more. How she soared from high to low and vice versa. A plus Sarah played the piano
Sarah all day! The range, the nuance, the phrasing control, the emotion -- ALL DIVINE!
Sarah hands down. Her sound is like no other.
But when it comes to swinging and faster paces Ella is unmatched.
Yes ....but ella sounds like no other too...not even half a second and you know that it's her Who sings.
Sarah’s voice was more interesting, but everything that came out of Ella’s throat was perfect. Then again, same case with Sarah.
Two absolute Legends of music! This is Real talent and professionalism on a grand scale.
They are both Jazz, Music, and Vocal Icons. Ella is my absolute favorite singer and i also love and
Have a huge amount of respect and admiration for Sara “Sassy” Vaughn! 2 💎💎
MAGNÍFICAS,GLORIOSAS,ESCANDALOSAS NA ARTE DE INTERPRETAR CANÇÕES !!!!
No contest Simply Sassie
Sarah hands down
I like Sarah for her poise, her style on stage.
Bouth great Ella scat the best sarah voice more long sustain!!!
Ella !!!! Even tho Sarah was brilliant…Ella just has this connection to Song that NO ONE has 😭😭
Love you Ella but the Divine one is mine
Incredible singers.
Absolutely sublime!
I really love their styles so very much. Scat singing wise. Sarah had beautiful vocals. When she'd scat, she'd sing melodies with her voice that connected to everyone's ear. Satisfying but beautiful.
Ella on the other hand. She had a very beautiful way of improvising when it came to scatting. She improvised the same way a trumpet player would, and depicted her voice as a jazz instrument for her band, and her audience.
It's a tie, however, in my opinion. Ella Fitzgerald is jazz's most perfect singer. While Sarah Vaughan is one of jazz's most satisfying and soulful singers.
Sarah all day and night
WHAT A FABULOUS VIDEO- THANK YOU SO MUCH !!! I love both, but I prefer Ella. I listen more "Soul" when Ella sings. Also more genuineness. I think Sarah sings more deliberately, more intellectually, and very mannered in her late recordings. . It's certainly very subjective, but I feel that Ellas radiates more happiness and joy when she sings. Sarah's best live album ever is Swings At the Tivoli 1963. I never tire of hearing it over and over again. I would like to point out these words from one of jazz's most important critics:Leonard Feather described Sarah's skills: “Recently I heard a classical, a pop and a jazz singer. A soprano, a contra-alto and a coloratura singer. A singer with the spontaneity of Ella Fitzgerald, the soul of Aretha Franklin, the warmth of Peggy Lee and the flawless phrasing of Carmen McRae. They were all on the same show and they were all Sarah Vaughan"
Both are legendary singers and vocalists but I just prefer Sarah more because she plays with her timbre more
This was a fairly good match even though it was between women of different strengths and styles. It was very fairly displayed. I think if I had to choose which woman I would rather listen to on a regular basis it’s probably Sarah Vaughan. And I went into this thinking it would be Ella Fitzgerald. It might still be though… I think I listen to Ella Fitzgerald more often anyway. I’m a little confused now, lol.
For me, Sarah wins hands down. I still consider her to be the best of all time.
I generally dislike these kinds of “contest” when it comes to artistic expression. I love them both but because of my love of opera im more fascinated by Sarah’s voice. Although no one can touch Ella’s scatting. I’m a ballad person and in that arena Sarah Soars!
They're both equally talented in their own unique way, at the top of the Jazz field
Nobody touching Sarah😎
Ella wins for me … though I love them both….
I listen to both all the time
Ella spoke very highly of Sarah's voice
People will always have their favorites, choose their sides, make their camps, et cetera; but NO ONE will be able to deny that BOTH of them were vocal titans, both marble pillars in their respective and individual abilities, deliveries and techniques; both equal luminaries in a galaxy of music and most importantly that genre known as jazz in which both set permanent and unforgettable standards…
Ella the better singer. Sarah the better vocalist.
Profound comment 👍
Okay, te la compro (!) 👍🏻
Both of them have quite an unlimited range. I find new notes from them almost everyday, especially Ella. Ella mixing B5s with absolute ease and singing (well, grumbling) an F2. Found tons of C6s but no good notes above though.
I’m halfway through but I’m gonna make a few comments; Sarah Vaughan was a very beautiful woman in her youth. Now, looks aside and vocally speaking, they were mostly equally good in the lower registers. With Sarah winning out for me a few times because she has that depth that can’t be beat. But Ella was equally strong on most of them with her very clear voice and if excellent forward Placement that helped her carry those low notes. They both have tremendous support, especially Ella. On belting, I think that Ella shined more on the fourth octave so far. She has more of that Belty quality, that chassis quality and is comfortable on those notes, whereas in may have been a little bit high in comparison for Sarah who sounds a little more light and soft and mixy to me. And there’s nothing wrong with that.
When describing Ella, I was trying to say “that chesty quality“, my phone ended up writing “that chassis quality“.
@@Rosannasfriend Yep, Ella was primarily a chest belter. A more stylistic, raw singer. Sarah was quite influenced by classical soprano singing which is very apparent in her approach and style. I find it hard to compare.
@@Rosannasfriend do u think the reason sarah mixes is to sound more "lighter"?she was a dark soprano after all
@@vyeagra420 I think it is more due to the approach rather than trying to sound like a higher voice. Her approach is very akin to how some classically-trained sopranos and mezzos who sang jazz sounded.
@@KajiVocals that's prob the reason why she has a solid headvoice
Ella came first and paved the way for other singers.
Improvisation, musicality and spontaneity wise - Ella wins for me… However, vocally Sarah due to her musical training always had the upper hand - technique wise . Hence, the quality of her voice was at its peak/prime throughout her life.
La voz de Ella me gusta mas,.pero sarah tenia una voz mas ronca pero perfecta las dos eran buenisimas
I love Ella but Sarah gives me goosebumps!
They were both phenomenal vocalists…though, apropos of your theme, it’s interesting to note that Ella herself thought, and said many times, that she thought Sarah was the greatest singer of their generation….there’s no battle…they are very different artists. Both great….but I would offer that Sarah had the greater instrument….and certainly a much greater vocal range.
Both were the most absolutely towering figures in mid-century American Songbook music. Impossible to say one is better than the other. Ella had a certain brightness to her voice, her pitch was perfect and she burst with versatility (Sunshine of My Love!) Sarah had stunning drama and sweeping operatic high notes. To be a bit nit picky, Ella wasn't a deep interpreter of lyrics and Sarah could overdo that slushy style at times. I can listen to them both for long streches, but Dinah Washington is actually the only singer I never tire of listening to.
These two fabulous gals are gifted with undescribable vocalviscosity so smoothe and pristine...
From a vocal viewpoint? Definitely Sarah
I love Ella but... La Davina is, for me, the greatest singer that ever lived. Peace.
Im am , & have been in awe of both singers from my teenage years. Then when I started extensively collecring their CD's, I found Sarah's repotoire more captivating. However, just lately, I've been mesmerized by the extensive musical renditions of Lena Horne.
But the bottom line, - they all are my ladies of song, including, Dina Washington. Now run & tell that!
Ella always ❤
It's an easy choice for me ,Ella all the way ,she more flexible ,Blues ,Rock,Jazz and more of all round entertainer she was smooth as silk. I looked in my record collection i have one album of Sarah ,Ella i lost count, Cds and LPs she sang with all the great .From Sinatra ,Dean Martine , Nat cole ,Armstrong ,Tom Jones she has done it all.
Sarah ❤❤❤❤❤
Ella brought me to the dance so I’ll stick with her but Sarah sure is mighty fine!
Sarah has a better head voice...
Ella Fitzgerald had it till the end. The notes for me as music teacher are crispier to the ear. You can see them both reach heights with ease, the breath control from Ella astounding. If anything Ella was freer in that her persona never left her grasp. Sarah however did. Ella Fitzgerald will be forever you see her even now gaining popularity.
❤❤❤
@@monicabella7894 Sarah is wonderful, I love her - but first of all I think Ella is musically more versatile and I would like to say that your assessment of Ella is a big underestimate. Excuse me if I write this - your statement about Ella Fitzgerald: "Ella Fitzgerald is good for a nice relaxed musical background, that's all" is actually an embarrassingly stupid statement for every jazz connoisseur. If you told that to the world famous jazz legends that Ella worked with, they would laugh at you. Ella is so much more than just nice relaxed music. I think you don't know enough about Ella's huge record work. I've seen Ella live about 15 times. She was more than fantastic, simply unbelievable.
Love Sarah…but it’s all about ELLA for me and always will be. Her scat alone sends me…only other scat was Sammy Davis, Junior.
Sarah, who is so sassy, and Ella, who is so jazzy, are the two best vocalists who ever lived.
I prefer Sassy, she’s actually my favourite female American vocalist ever.
I can hear them both in todays female vocalist….who are continuing the legacy….Such as Dee Dee Bridgewater, Dianne Reeves, Nnenna Freelon, Rachelle Ferrell, Jazzmeia Horn, Samara Joy, Ledisi, and etc.
Also, I like to compare both singing the same song- then I assign "that" song to the version I enjoy the modt! But they are equally represented on the Diva 's top chart!
Sarah was warned not to get into an uptempo battle with Ella cause she’d get worn out in the end!
Las dos buenisimas cantantes Ella es una de mis cantantes favoritas , sarah tambien me gusta mucho las dos son grandes y brillaran por siempre
❤❤❤ BOTH ARE NUMBER 1. ELLA'S WAS LIQUID SILK AND SARAH'S WAS LIQUID GOLD ! NOW, WE HAVE PATTI AUSTIN, DIANNE KRALL, MAYSA LEAKS ÀND. LINDSEY WEBSTER .... DON'T FORGET NANCY WILSON
Why choose -so blessed with both!
Both.
I would say that Sarah Vaughan had the more "perfect" voice, but to me she often seems rather detached from the lyrics and like she's listening to herself, which I find distracting. I feel like she is more about vocal technique and about an intellectual approach to harmony, than about really connecting with the idea and feeling of the song. Ella Fitzgerald is certainly no slouch technically, and she did have a strong level of engagement with the lyrics, as well as a musical freedom and spontaneity, all of which put her ahead as a singer in my book.
Sombody could tell me the name of song than Miss Sara Vaughan sing in F5 or the name of album?
Sarah’s voice has always been been more rich to me
Ella is my favorite singer, but I have a lot of respect for Ms. Sarah too
Both of them...
Ellla is pitchy and raspy, especially when striving for the highest and lowest notes. Sarah has control and a measurably accurate and pure pitch. I wish this channel would do an episode on how well and wide an interval these ladies can sings--with elegance.
Ella for me. Sarah always seems to be “putting on a display” rather than singing the song - I find the meaning of the song gets lost. Ella had all the talent and technique but she got out of the way of the song and only used technique to tell the story. Ella =🥇
It depends on the song...some Ella wins, some Sarah wins.
If Ella is a choice for best singer, she always wins for me. I respect everyone's opinion. My ear tells me Ella, always.
In terms of head voice I think Sarah Vaughn has better control over it. She has vibrato, whereas Ella almost never has vibrato in her head voice it seems. Not in this video. Though I’m not a vibrato freak anyway, but there’s other factors. Ella‘s head voice tended to sound a little bit pushed all the time, and abrasive and a little bit too harsh/bright. I don’t mind that sound as a choice, but it seems to be her only choice most of the time. Though I did appreciate her warm F5. Sarah can crescendo and decrescendo and have a bright tone and warmth in her voice and sustain and go from a long held notes and phrase different notes after coming down on the same breath and do everything with her head voice. So I was very impressed by that.
No importa ella me encanta sarah para mi 2do lugar
I've never been able to choose It's like Biggie or Pac. They're two powerhouses with different approaches. Only wish I got to see Ella and Sassy do something together.
Type in ella pearl sarah. You'll see
Sarah is amazing, but Ella is so touching. She takes one on her velvety wings. Oh, "'Round Midnight" by Ella is sooooooooo moving. Il love you, Ella! (Besides, Sarah sometimes uses vocal effects lacking feeling)
Ella Ella Ella!!
I prefer Sarah Vaughan for technical and Ella for mood in general (though I think older Sarah edges out too)
27:16 where’s the clip from ?
@@godhand-mo7qh it’s a performance of “how high the moon” but I can’t seem to find the specific performance. It might have gotten removed from RUclips.
Sarah Vaughan seems to have become more appreciated after her passing. I think younger generations might enjoy her more than Ella because a lot of her stylings were carried on by R&B/gospel singers like Dionne Warwick, Chaka Khan, Daryl Coley, Mariah Carey, and Anita Baker. Ella was a genius, but I don't hear her influence in modern day singers as much as Sarah Vaughan's. Which is interesting since Ella was more popular and respected than Sarah in their hey day.
Sarah is my favorite but her sound was more ethnic and yet a bit operatic neither of which was popular back in the day
That is a really interesting observation. I myself am 23 and have been besotted by Sarah's voice since I first heard it back when I was around 18. I would say Ella's voice was fantastic, but Sarah's was just superbly untouchable, to a level that very few singers have ever been able to achieve, and certainly not achieving now in today's popular artists! I think that has definitely caused younger generations to explore past artists by picking up these videos on RUclips and keep exploring alternatives to today.
That is so astute! Very interesting theory.
There is no battle 🥰 it's one Queen doing her thing after the other one that's All ❤️🖤💚✊🏾❤️🖤💚🥰
They were both superb singers with unique styles. I have original vinyl LPs of both ladies. I prefer to listen to lots of Ella with a dash of Sarah.
.......a Sassy dash, at that