Which Brand Makes The BEST DOWN JACKET?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 июл 2024
- Canada Goose Expedition + Moose Knuckles 3Q + Alpha Industries N3B + North Face + Helly Hansen Svalbard Parka Down Jacket Men's Winter + Review + Size + Fit Guide + Try On
Where to buy:
Canada Goose Expedition Parka Jacket: amzn.to/3JcwiTq
Moose Knuckles 3Q Down Jacket: amzn.to/3yPGXi2
Alpha Industries N3B Jacket: amzn.to/30PPhBE
North Face Bedford Down Parka Jacket: amzn.to/3H9uSH8
Helly Hansen Svalbard Winter Parka Jacket: amzn.to/3EngyJB
Check out all episodes of "Which Brand Makes The Best...": • Which Brand Makes The ...
-------------------------------
Time Stamps:
0:00 Intro
0:45 Down Jacket #5
3:40 Down Jacket #5 Fit
5:16 Down Jacket #4
8:04 Down Jacket #4 Fit
9:39 Down Jacket #3
13:34 Down Jacket #3 Fit
15:35 Down Jacket #2
19:17 Down Jacket #2 Fit
21:04 Down Jacket #1
25:08 Down Jacket #1 Fit
27:05 Final Scores/Results!
-------------------------------
Follow me on IG: / mensfashionfiles
-------------------------------
FTC Disclaimer: The links above are affiliate links where I'll make a small commission if you make a purchase at no extra cost to you! This helps my small channel a lot and allows me to continue making videos like this. Thank you for the support! 
Хобби
Check out part 2 here! (includes WARMTH TEST!): ruclips.net/video/c-btd2ym-gw/видео.html
Nice
Try Nanga！
Since you said you polled whats popular are you going by whats popular or whats warm, has the quality, best materials, best customer service, best warranty and so fourth ? What determines whats best?
@@pdnehc8620 Thanks for the suggestion, will check out Nanga for sure!
@@Kev4Kev My criteria for the best wasn't specific. The voters give me their favorite brands and I just to go into detail talking about all the factors you mentioned to determine what I thought is the best down jacket.
When everybody here in Canada was buying Canada Goose maybe 10-15 year ago my sister who's in the fashion industry got me a jacket as a gift, it was the first gen mooseknuckle jacket that she purchased for the fraction of what they charge now. I still have it and it's almost too warm to wear if you're a bit of an active person. Most of the time I just wear a t-shirt underneath and this jacket.. it's thick and very well insulated.
But Kanuk IS Better them😂😂😂
Kanuk was traditionally for retired folks lol. Also most of them used synthetic fibers and not goosedown... I do see they are trying to be hip and have different more interesting models targeting younger folks. Glad both Kanuk and MKnuckle are local (Montreal) brands.
Fun fact;
The reason Alpha industries have orange lining is to be used if you want to be spotted by rescue teams.
You just turn the jacket inside out so the bright orange lining is showing so you can be spotted by helicopters or mountain rescue teams.
Woow that was so fun..instead of watching fireworks on New Year’s Eve in just had people read that fact
what about parajumpers? xD
Seems like a dumb idea to have to turn your jacket inside out in freezing temperatures. -points for that design flaw
@@duluthdjs2588 it's cool that's why ppl buy it
PARKA did this years ago
This is a solid review. I have a CG jacket and don't really have any regrets buying it. It's keeps me warm in Cleveland and Boston winters. If I had to buy another jacket, it would for sure be Moose Knuckles
Thanks for doing a noise test in this video! It's also my pet peeve when down jackets make that annoying crinkling and swishing sound whenever I move. I always knew North Face would be loud. Impressed by how quiet Moose Knuckles and Alpha Industries are though.
I'm surprised too, wasn't expecting Moose Knuckles to top the list either
The noise test is pointless. You don't buy these types of jackets for the sound rating. The host should've taken this out in the elements to prove how well they function.
Canada Goose makes a nice jacket but they are definitely purchased as a status symbol by lots of people. You see a ton of them in Toronto with people only going from the home to their cars and into underground parking in the downtown office buildings. About 5 years ago I once had a banker lady tell me she just bought one, and I pretended I had no idea what she was talking about. She looked pretty disappointed that she didn't impress me.
Exactly you “pretended”
@@1stAmendmentfukyoutube wym?
@@eirik.9384 self explanatory. He pretended not to know about Canada Goose but he still did. Obviously jealous
Definitely bought mostly as status symbols. Most of the users probably have never ventured outside of their parking lots or shopping malls and hiked in the countryside … 😁😁
All Asian Kids are having Canada Goose Jackets in Toronto . Haaaaa...... lol
I bought a Moose Knuckle 3Q in 2017 for $795. Well worth the investment! One thing to consider prior to purchase: you can detach the hood if you are driving as it may block your blind spot (I'm sure other jackets have this problem too if they have puffy hoods/fur). Canada Goose has some tech where female jackets have that butterfly overalls hanging thing (?) where it hangs the jacket on your back with some straps. That seems quite useful and I wish more companies could copy that lol.
Moose knuckle? Isn't that a name for when you can see a fat chick's pussy through some yoga pants she shouldn't be wearing?
I bought the moose knuckle ballistic and it’s the best jacket I own, nothing compares.
moncler has those same straps with some of their jackets, very useful imo i definitely agree.
I have been choosing a warm jacket for myself for almost a year and when I saw it, there was no doubt left, I became the happy owner of Moose Knuckles Stirling parka, however, in three winter seasons I wore it about 10 times, because it is too warm for our winters and I have to wear shorter and less warm jackets. Moscow, Russia
My Westcomb Mision jacket looks and functions like the first day I brought it home 7 years ago. Love it. I now have many Wescomb pieces with the Apoc as my go to hard shell. Beautiful Canadian made products.
This was so helpful, as I am trying to buy a jacket for my nephew, and being a girl, your perspective is so valuable. The way it hangs on your body, and the weight of each jacket were really helpful details. There are so many details about a jacket, you really go over the pertinent ones on each. Thank you!
Great video thank you! Throughout the years I had numerous parkas from different brands. For the past 3 years I settled with a mix of 3 parkas brands depending on the temperature and forecast. I work on a shipyard in the north east and these 3 jackets keep me very warm and dry.
North face. Mt. Elbert parka
Eddy Bauer. Superior down parka
Nobis. Yatesy parka
Awesome to hear that! Appreciate the suggestions as well, will include those brands in a part 2 👀
I’m a firm believer in TNF. Got my first jacket in 1998. Red and black Hydroseal And I still run it on -20 and colder. I live in Alberta and it’s cold here in the winter ❄️
Did you ever wear a Canada Goose ? It's a world of difference. Even though the TNF can keep you warm enough.
I have a westcomb, also a Canadian made jacket that used to supply for arcteryx.It's slightly cheaper than Canada Goose or Moose Knuckles and I've worn it in below zero temps and felt toasty.
I found your video interesting and solid good start with the criteria used to evaluate a down jacket. What I would have liked to see is how friendly these down parkas are when it comes to wearing gloves. The reason why the Canadian brands have wider and dealer cuffs are to accommodate gloves. I would have liked to see you… or maybe you can do a companion video, on how easy and comfortable these parkas are for gloves. Most of these jackets if worn in extreme cold would need a gauntlet style mitt. Being from Winnipeg and having done a 25 year career in the military… I have a lot of extreme cold experience… and understanding if what works outside… my greatest frustration is getting a new parka home and finding out that my gloves and mitts do not easily fit inside the sleeve… which gives the best protection against wind if you do not need to remove your gloves…. I also get frustrated if the sleeve is too bulky or too thin on a parka meant for working outside - where you need a gauntlet glove as you need to remove your hand coverings to perform certain tasks. I would also like to see you field test your parkas. I have also experienced disappointment with top brand name parkas because the cold and wind find their way in from the seams, especially where the sleeves attach to the main jacket. Often you do not know this is a problem until the temp starts creeping below -15 degrees Celsius and / or the windchill gets intense. I have a parka graveyard in my basement and have donated many of my disappointing choices to local charities (we have a coats for kids drive in most Canadian cities that donates gently used winter clothing to needy families) That is why I find good value in your videos as I get a more informed perspective on fit and function so I don’t purchase an expensive parka that someone else will eventually end up with if I get it wrong and only find out months into winter (January) when temps hit -40 without windchill). Great start. I would enjoy more videos on fashionable / functional outdoor clothing.
I love my Canada Goose Expedition parka. It’s so warm. I live in the country in Minnesota and it’s will be -25 deg this weekend. I will get good use once again this winter with my parka.
The best Canadaens Parkas are the Kanuk Parkas
I’m pretty happy with LL Bean’s 800 powerfill tech goose. They kept my parents warm. I have a long coat from CG - the longest I count find. It keeps me so warm in sub zero F winters.
Canada Goose are made in Canada,2 places Winnipeg and Toronto by workers who are paid a decent wage,definitely not foreign sweat shop .
Yeah like wtf these plp super duper sped fr lol
They also trap & kill coyotes just to make the fur trim
The quality is subpar. I’m sorry it’s just not there for the price. Back in 2016-2017 the quality was great. Now you go to the store and literally the threads will be falling out of the jacket. You can see the jacket falling apart. That’s not okay for the price tag made in Canada or not. They look amazing but if you look closely the quality is just bonkers. It’s mind boggling.
I want my sex panther to have real panther! I want my textiles to have real child tears’ 😅
Kinda early for dark humor, supporting that Canada goose is legit 🤙🤙
@@stephencruickshanks3794 not anymore
If I am working 8 hours outdoors in Alaska or Siberia, then I would choose the most expensive one, however I find "The North Face" the most elegant.
Thanks for the Vid
Agreed, you gotta get Canada Goose or Moose Knuckles if you're gonna be out in Alaska or Siberia. For urban environments, North Face will do the job just fine
I am very surprised that Eddie Baure is not included. Love mine for daily transit commuting in Chicago. The shell is extra durable with tons of over stitching at stress points, big, easy to access, insulated pockets, 2-way zip . . . Was -7 today and I walked 1.5 miles to my dentist appointment; no complaintes.
Agreed! But it’s probably because it not a super popular, stylish brand. Personally it’s my favorite outdoor clothing brand.
Eddie Bauer used to be a high end Brand here in the North West but the quality on the cheaper models have gone downhill in recent years. I still have a 30 year old jacket in excellent condition and at the time of purchase, it had a Lifetime warranty. There was even an Eddie Bauer edition SUV from Ford, and Subaru, certainly a lifestyle choice for many people here in the Northwest. REI is another Northwest brand that makes excellent lightweight and waterproof winter garments.
AMEN 🙏
@@chaslau2345 AGREE I saw some of the best coats in Seattle in the early 90s quality can't be beat 🙂
How much. I’m struggling commuting through the trains
I LOVE Moose Knuckle. My son & I each own one and we love it. Great honest review. I also have a Monclear that is warm.
Just want to mention that all these brands he’s talking about is his own personal opinion. In my opinion all these brands are pretty good. If you have one and take care of it fair enough then it will last 10 - 15 even 20 years as long as you fit in the jacket. So keep enjoying what you have and be open to ideas ✌️
well said, thanks for watching🙂
These are the next level in terms of costs. Would love to see the Parkas from the cheaper brands: Columbia, LL Bean, Eddie Bauer, Patagonia.
I agree. For the price you could get a Schott Perfecto leather jacket and one of your choices for the same as the higher dollar ones shown.
My Columbia down jacket was like $500 but I got it with a 50% discount
@@chrisvda88 And the season to buy those jackets at a huge discount starts now through July. Your discount is what smart buyers can expect.
I wouldn't say Patagonia is cheap, but Eddie Bauer jackets are a great value for the performance and quality they provide. And they were the first company to start selling down jackets, back in the 1930's, which I think is pretty cool.
How about Fjällraven, a good eco conscious option.
Have a Marmot parka jacket with 700 down fill and it's waterproof... just saying that any temperature over -5C and i'm boiling. Just love the quality, fit and features this jacket has to offer. This is my 5th year I'm using it and have to say that i enjoy having a walk at -20C
I always found fill Power ratings to be somewhat irrelevant unless the fill weight is provided along with it. Fill Power x Fill Weight is what you really want to know as it's going to give you a better idea of the loft, which is what keeps you warm..Very few companies provide that information though - Montbell is one of the few who do, which I appreciate.
My main jacket is the "Kathmandu Epiq Down Jacket" Its really comfortable and I think the bright green on the inside looks really nice too
I'm glad the Moose Knuckles 3q was the best because it's the one I have. Fantastic jacket, warm, excellent build quality and looks really good. If you shop around you can get it cheaper than the price quoted.
Glad to hear that brother, thanks for watching 🙂
Too many people have this jacket and when stuff like thisbis popular in urban areas its bootleg..I seen people who I know can't afford this coat on and I know it's a bootleg
@@djunknownnyc
Where I live which is not a very prosperous area, you certainly see lots of people wearing Canada Goose, not so much Moose Knuckles. I'm sure a lot of it is bootleg too, but that applies to all designer brands.
Should have sized up to an M for the Moose Knuckle. It would look and more functional.
People have a tendency to try to make everything into a slim fit these days, but Winter jacket should not be one of them.
When it is -30 and snowing, nobody cares what your Winter jacket looks like, especially with the front open. Speaking of leaving ghe front open...When it is warm enough to leave the front open, you don't need a Winter jacket.
Exactly, the fact he doesn't performance test these jackets shows he care more about fit and design than what a parka was actually made for.
ah yes i wont open my jacket up if im feeling a little warm.
Appreciate the feedback. Wanted to keep sizing consistent for a more 1 to 1 comparison so stuck with S for all the jackets but if I had known, about the slim fit, I would go with M next time. Also, wasn't able to do a performance test because it doesn't snow in California lol
wish comparison will include how each jacket fair under cold weather (snow, wind and rain) conditions rathert han physical features only . Thanks for the good effort put together. Thumbs up!.
Great. Thank you. I just bought a Moose Knucles coat and was very satisfied, now more satisfied that after seeing this.
Glad you agree. Making a part 2 this winter where I actually test its warmth instead of a noise test lol. Stay tuned!!
Woolrich Goose Down jacket $270 years ago was my favorite and the warmest coat & waterproof with coyote fur. I gave to my Family member it was too big for me after losing weight.
I have the Svalbard and was very sceptical on how warm it would be because it's so incredibly light. I wore it the whole of winter with just a t-shirt underneath. -10⁰ Celsius were no problem. So I am sure that with just a hoodie to layer it would be warm in most conditions. It also doesn't feel like a winter jacket you are still very mobile
Appreciate the recommendation! will check it out
I once had an Alpha coat from 2015, but it wasn't a down jacket, but it was very warm. In 2017 I bought a Canada Goose down coat (Langford in Olive) and it was one of the best decisions I've made to date. Brutally warm, but very expensive. But OK. As an adult, you don't buy a new winter coat every year.
I have a Polar Jacket made by AI and I've been checking Canda Goose but they don't seem as good to me
I have a Moose Knuckles ballistic bomber that I bought from an outlet! Hands down the warmest a best quality item I own!
this is an amazing review.. I wish ppl reviewed jackets like this!!!
Strellson makes my favourite down parka. 3 seasons in northern Canada (it’s -35C right now) and it never lets me down. This brand also makes combat wear for the Swiss military, so the seams/stitches are dependable.
i am using North Face products for years and i am very happy with the performance, especially my NF600 down jacket is lasting for over 7 years now....
the main focus on winter gear is obviously to stay warm while maintaining max movement ability as well as rapid drying, NF tics all of those boxes and is robust & stylish too.
worth every penny especially when hunting previous season sales.
My original Mcmurdo served me well for 15 years and was still going strong when I gave it to someone in need and upgraded to the mcmurdo 2, which is still going strong 7 years later 😄
Incredible value coats, especially if you buy out of season and get a discount. I got both mine for nearly half price buying in the sales out of season
lol
You also get 2 years warranty if anything goes wrong with the construction of it, although I bought a lhotse last year and this weird pull appeared in the material and pulled all the colour of the pattern out in a strand. Even though I would say it's wear and tear, they still replaced the jacket for me. I own several different jackets and got to say they last a long time and still look good.
Love the Gotham 2 jacket, got me through so many NY winters. Only complaint is I wish there was a larger inner pocket. Either way it is a super nice jacket
Wow such an in depth review! And the subtle jokes!!
🙂
I think you gave, overall a good example of winter Parker jackets, thank you
Just a note that Canada Goose has a line for smaller body frames (sorter sleeves, shorter length, etc.) called Fusion. I'm 4'11 and I went with CG for this reason (and that it's very warm) 😬
you can also get it if you want a more tapered fit. im 5'10 and 184 lbs and i have a fusion fit langford in xl that fits perfectly
@@truckin3266 is the Langford worth it? I’m planning to replace my Eddie Bauer jacket with a CG
A bit unfair to compare cheap jackets from one company to expensive jackets from another. North Face and HH also have jackets in the same price class as the more expensive ones.
@Jake how so?
@Jake-oq2bq I've had mine for almost 10 years and I love it
I love my north face Himalayan down jacket. Keeps me nice and warm and very comfortable
Pockets make any jacket look at of shape when used. I argue that a few well placed pockets is more important than a ton of pockets especially if it's for city use.
When I arrived to Canada, my first jacket was a Mountain Warehouse 60cad rated -40c .for the price and quality the best deal is MW, just pic a jacket that fits you and rated -40 and you are good to Go. Yo don't need to buy down jackets to survive, sintético insulations works really well
Literally, that’s the point of the down jacket. At the temperatures the jackets are meant to be worn at, it’s supposed to keep you alive from freezing cold
I like how you reviewed these 5 jackets. Thanks for all the info. I didn't know Canada Goose which is the most expensive jacket turns out so messed up with the size.
thanks for watching!
Such a comprehensive and wide ranging channel. Always happy to see these types of videos
thank you, new down jacket review here: ruclips.net/video/c-btd2ym-gw/видео.html
Awesome I just found a moose knuckle jacket at the goodwill for $10 . I had no clue that it was so expensive at retail . Wow thanks
Wow
If you are not a.brand snob then NF is a good all rounder. I am not a fanboy; just commenting from experience. I have NF jackets/parkas that are over 15yrs old and they are still performing strongly in all weather and situations.
I was thinking, "When did I post a comment on this video? I've never seen this one." 😆
I too have TNF jackets from 10-15 years ago that still function well and I wear to this day. And to be fair, back in the day TNF was the brand for brand snobs but has now been usurped by Moose Knuckles, Canada Goose, etc.
Same, TNF used to be THE brand. I still wear those 15+ yo down jackets…and they’re still in style. There are other brands that he left out, like Marmot, Patagonia, Arc’teryx, Mountain Hardwear, etc etc etc…
.... I gifted myself a "Canada Goose" for 2021 Christmas, so I'm very thankful for your stellar review [even though your review was for men]..... Thanks ...
good to hear that and sounded like you had an awesome Christmas!
fantastic video, love the noise test
I have worked in Russia and Sweden n Norway n Finland. I can say you never need these super expensive warm jackets unless your going Siberia. Most people will wear several layers before putting jacket. So Take layers into account when selecting jacket.
My Alpha snorkel is top layer. Underneath is thermal, long sleeve cotton shirt, thin fleece with high neck, scarf, balaclava and/or watch cap. Gloves or mittens depending on how awful it is outside.
I absolutely love my jacket from Finland. We had about - 37 last year and i was warm and cozy. I can wash it in home. It was about 200 euro. I don't understand the point if famous outdoor clothing it should be wearable and convenient.
Well done, intuitive comparisons. Here in Canada - Ottawa - the Canada Goose Expedition is an excellent choice - they were much less expensive when we bought ours.
Canada Goose uses real fur just for that it's a fail.
Canadian Goose is not part of RDS. Responsible down sourcing in this day and age is very important. Epic Fail IMO
Probably because they are no longer actually made in Canada.
@@kathleenaerin2436 where you get that info from?
@@fabienneisore7831 And it's a bonus to me. To each their own.
I’m going with the mackage very warm, stylish and not played out
Frank and oak hygga jacket. Got it for my wife for Christmas and it's been a game changer for her
My Canada Goose Chilliwack has been solid for over 10 years, and still going strong. Got another a couple months ago, the old one is relegated to "dirtier" scenarios. I am so satisfied with the performance and longevity it demonstrates. It's not hype, and don't know about status symbol as I don't care, trends change over time anyways. Thankfully there are so many good options here in Canada, can't go wrong.
someone I know went through such a jacket in 2 years... then holes started to develop in the sleeves. And YES, it was for sure an original!! I have more or less the same experience with my longer parka. It's just a cotton mix and that DOES wear out way more quickly than a 100% nylon or polyester jacket....
The Canada Goose is well made but there are other high quality options such as Fjallraven, 66 deg North, Arcteryx, Haglofs, Norrona, Peak Performance, Musto, and many more.
I don't understand why an entry level synthetic Helly Hansen parka is compared with 2 much pricier down parkas. You can get much better stuff from Helly if you want at greater cost, eg the Arctic Patrol down range or the Bouvet. I get that this selection may be discussed on the North American market but even then, Arcteryx or Patagonia are natural choices. A direct European competitor to the Canada Goose parka is the Fjallraven Expedition down no. 1 parka. As rugged but refined a design as anything CG offers.
Hi Sdemosi, love your comment and I actually searched all the brands you mentioned and they are all good. There are too many choices and its confusing. Can you recommend a couple of Men down parka for Alberta weather. Sometimes it reaches -30 or -40 and I'm looking for a jacket for those days. Thank you!
Gotcha! Check out my new video covering arcteryx: ruclips.net/video/dPPiAN4gO9w/видео.html
@@MensFashionFiles that's great. The synthetic down jacket I wear the most is the Haglofs V Series Mimic. It's equivalent to about 750 FP down with graphene threads spreading heat throughout the jacket and a gore tex infinium liner for wind resistance. It's light, packable and I bring it on all my light winter treks in Ireland, Wales and Scotland. It fits easily under a GTX Pro jacket and it's stylish for urban wear too.
Woolrich. Unterstatement, no obnoxious logos, extremely durable and warm.
My absolute go to. Love my Woolrich parkas.
My go to brand is mackage best bang for your buck in my opinion. I love their signature in lining Bib making it impossible for wind to get through. If anyone is looking for a high end winter parka I really recommend the Edward jacket. You can get with fur or can also purchase a furless one.
thanks for the suggestion!
Northface is the warmest jacket I ever owned and I owned many high end jackets. Not to say the others weren't good, but you could actually sweat in a blizzard while wearing a Northface 😄 They will stick to your body like a warm blanket. Even the lower priced ones.
THF is wank compare to CG
@@vadim452 And that price tag will be wank to. I rather spend half the price on a nice North Face than a Canada Goose. Atleast I know it will do the job like its known to do.
Northface Himalaya parka is the best out of all these the best bang for your buck idk about pig knuckles, Canada goose, what ever the face is the best point blank
I'm surprised that you didn't test the North Face parka using a "McMurdo-2". This would have been a much better comparison.
Came here to say this. I enjoyed the video, but it seemed really biased from the jump since he chose top models for every other brand, but then chose the cheapest north face version.
McMurdo would’ve been nice, but he should’ve chose an expedition model to be completely fair.
Very methodical and thorough review! Thanks.
thanks for watching!
Very helpful and detailed, thanks!
It’s funny that the Alpha Industries jacket is on this list, since it’s not down to begin with. The N3B parka is an Air Force parka, and the genuine N3B are so much better, I own one, but once again this was never down. The one parka that should be included here is the US Army M-65 Fishtail Parka, which is a synthetic ultra toasty beast, which for value for money is pretty much unbeatable compared to all the others here. I own one of those too. Again, not a brand and not down either, but what a parka!
I just checked out Fishtail Parka and that jacket look interesting to say the least haha
I feel like he used the worst alpha industries jacket to compare. It’s satin for crying out loud.
25:57 "The hood on this is perrrfect if you wanna scare kids at your local park." WTF? 😂
check out my IG for the pic! 😂
If you do what I did and buy a Canada Goose body warmer you’re sorted. It’s not overkill if you don’t work at The North Pole and yet it’s warm on a chilly day. You won’t get the swinging sleeve noise as you walk because there are no sleeves. If it’s seriously cold put one of your other coats over it. It’s quick to put on and take off and doesn’t take up lots of space on the coat rack. It’s my ‘go to’ garment most of the year. I got mine for under £300 I think ? Mind you that was three years ago I could be wrong.
Your review convinced me to buy the Moose Knuckle jacket.. It is an awesome jacket!
glad to hear! you wont be disappointed 🙂
One thing about the CG that may not be the case with the other brands is you can wear a t-shirt in extremely cold temperature and still be sweating. The hood is also excellent against high winds. I've owned one before and would take it over all of the jackets listed. IMO the only things that hurt it are the price and not waterproof. I believe the CG has an unlimited warranty as well.
Having been to Siberia in the mid of winter I would like to mention that sweating is not a good thing in the cold ;) Jackets that can't regulate the body temperature with the outside temperature tend to make you sweat. Once the cold hits the sweat, you won't stay warm any longer. The best thing to protect from getting cold is layering up. Base thermal layer, fleece and a good jacket that allows your body to breath will keep you warm all day long.
Why would it matter if a CG Jacket is waterproof or not? No point in wearing one unless it's below the freezing point - they're too warm for anything other than that.
yeah, and EXACTLY because they are not water proof... and made out of an ordinary cotton mix, you should take a look at Nobis. These are a bit lower priced(!) but you get soooo much more jacket for the money... look at that outer fabric, it's WAY more classy than ANY CG jacket. I can know this... I own 4 or 5 jackets of each brand.
The HH is a sea brand. The primaloft is not as warm as down when dry. However it will keep you 80% warm when it gets wet. Down totally fails in the wet
Plus, down jackets don't breathe so if you gget too hot and start to sweat you have to take it off or you'll be absolutely soaked.
We used HH top model for sailing bad weather. Keep us dry and warm.
yes HH is good for rainy season
Appreciate the great reviews!
thanks brother!
Thanks for the great review. I just picked up a Canada Goose Forester as a Christmas gift for myself . Based on your review I will get me a Moose Knuckle jacket next , was looking at the model you reviewed.
I kind of like Canada Goose, but the only people that wear it where I live are wannabe gangstas and bums… Probably fakes, but I’d rather not be associated with that kind of people.
Congrats on the purchase tho, if I didn’t live in such a shitty country I’d definitely buy one…
@@nogoodname8133 hope that the Moose Knuckles does not take on that type of connection like Canada Goose . Here in Atlanta you don’t see CG much because it gets really cold usually in January and February.
@Steven Dye I really hate when good items get bad connotations like that, you know. I'm already dark skinned, if I were to wear a CG jacket I'd be asking to be profiled by the police here... it's not worth the headache for me.
@@nogoodname8133 that is unfortunate brother. Here in Atlanta, as an African American I don’t get bothered with profiling. Ran a stop sigh once at 1am in morning , technically did not come to complete stop, the Italian cop said if you have nothing on your record I will not write a ticket, gave me a pass on the ticket.
Wish you tested the warmth / temp retention of these jackets. I don’t think polyester and synthetic fills are as warm as down, but would like to see a test between different jackets with these different fills to see if that is true.
Appreciate the suggestion. Ill take your recommendation when I make a part 2
Sad Fjallraven wasn’t included in this review. The Fjallraven Singi Down jacket has so many positive reviews. I have been comparing it to these jackets and the Fjallraven seems to not only have similar features but more durably constructed.
Agree with ye… works well in -45
100% agree!!! I love the Ovik!!
Actually I tried Canada goose unsuccessful .. and then I bought a Fjallraven Yupik top in splendor and warmth
I was between getting the Fjallraven arktis and the Canada Goose expedition. I tried them both on and the Fjallraven just felt so much sturdier, so that’s what I went with. Love that jacket.
we actually switch from $1K+ CG's to Fjallraven. My kids like CG, well, because its CG... we are pass that and absolutely prefer Fjallraven now... less than 1/2 the cost too.....
I have a north face gotham 3 550 fill down parka i have never been anything but warm while wearing even in temperatures past -30℃ and that's not counting the windchill. The down coverage is the full parka.
It was $420ish in Canada dollars. I picked it up in the off season for a hundred and some change less than that and it's been the best coat I have ever owned it's water proof breathable and just awesome and for as warm as it is i'm never tearing it off sweating even after multi kilometer walks in the snow.
Oh and it has 7 pockets one inner six outer four of the exterior pockets are hand warmer lined and of the pockets 3 are zippered one inner and two outer.
Appreciate the suggestion. Making a part 2 this winter where I actually test its warmth instead of a noise test lol. Stay tuned!!
It depends where you intend to go and how cold it is, I have a Hagloff cost £450.00 its great for what I bought it for.
Great video. I like how detailed your review is but I don't think the jackets you chose is a fair comparison. Some are entry level vs more premium styles. Also, I think the Canada Goose jacket is sized larger to allow for layering underneath. Looking forward to your future videos.
Appreciate the feedback. Will try to compare more like priced items in my next video
First time hearing about 4 out of 5 brands. Its probably being because I wear outdoor brand jackets. Patagonia, The North Face, Columbia, and Eddie Bauer. With the last one being my favorite out of all these. Good video!
thanks brother! sounds like you got great taste
@@MensFashionFiles you mean basic taste, jus naming most popular brands :)
Ive had a couple of these. But tbh... The new MARMOT cube technology is the best. Always layer your jacket for best warmth factor
Moose knuckle is the best you’re right !
glad you agree!!
If you’re out on a SAR ( search and rescue ) mission at 0200 hrs, -10 deg in 3’ of snow, I can promise you you’re not going to give a damn how much noise the jacket makes as you work your assignment……(or how pretty the fabric happens to be…..!!!)
Just hand me the Canadian Goose and go test some swimming suits when it gets light out………
I actually considered buying the Alpha Industries jacket, thanks for informing me of the flaws
First time seeing a review like this. Wish I had saw it before I bought my north face. Thanks bud.
Thanks for watching! Hope you like this video style
Canada Goose has a excellent warranty a friend had one that was 5 years old and the zipper broke he took it back to Canada Goose to get it fixed they gave him a new Jacket you can't complain about that
Thats awesome customer service right there
I'm currently wearing a LL Bean ($300 on sale) - compares to the 2 Canadian coats you tested and a lot less expensive. Overkill for town use. I had an Alpha a few years ago. ($100 on sale) better construction then yours. Best for city use. I also used to own 2 genuine 1950's US Air Force snorkel coats. ($20 in 1970) I wore these woking outdoors on the docks as a human wind break, Very heavy (lots of wool batting), very warm. Very tiring to wear all day If still made would be crazy expensive, (I gave my last one to a homeless guy.) Today, I mostly wear a poly insulated shell over a down ski jacket. Layering is the way to go.
I also own two of the original N3B's, one from the 60s and one from the 80s. They are both well made but the one from the 80s for sure uses cheaper materials. The 60s jacket has a coyote or wolf fur hood and the jacket is filled with a mix of wool and cotton. The newer 80s version has a faux hood fur and synthetic lining.
@@heiner71 I got the one from the 80's and the good thing about is that it's LIGHT and repeals wind. If you coat that stuff in 3M, it's water repellent too.
Given you reviewed the ultra high end CG I think you should have thrown the OSC Atka ( Outdoor Survival Canada) into the mix.
On that note having Alpha Industries in a lineup with CG is kinda apples and oranges.
Very thorough and fair reviews. 👍
OSC Canada (Outdoor Survival Canada). Not OCS
@@codetwohigh Thanks for that! I had a feeling I had it wrong. 👍
Amazing video and reviews!
Thank you!!
Fjällräven makes pretty great parkas. I own Barnets parka, fjallraven Nuuk however have more insulation and more functionality with 27! pockets :) All of the jackets except the canada goose in this video are “dress” jackets. They would not be that functional in rl out in the woods.
Asså herregud, lägg ner din , lever du i 2012 eller? Han testar stora märken som är kände värden ut och du kommer med ditt förslag att testa en svenne bannan jacka som inte ens finns att köpa där han bor😂 är du helt seriös nu? Vet du ens vad mose innebär?
Och majoriteten av dom som kollar är inte i "the woods" utan vanliga individer som vill klara av en kylig vinter! Så nu håller du ett knip på flabbe-fanskapet du har under näsan och kollar , sedan köper en moose eller canada och ge fan i att gå ut till "the Woods" finns väll ta me fan inte en enda svamp jävel såhär dags i skogen? Eller?
TNF it's the best, but you should use TNF Mountain Murdo Goretex.
check out my new video on TNF Mcmurdo : ruclips.net/video/c-btd2ym-gw/видео.html
great Video, but tbh for Northface to have a chance should of used the Mcmurdo or Outerboroughs jackets. IMO miinus the fur trim, northface is very similar to Canada Goose for warmth and is about 90% of the quality of Canada Goose. Canada Goose is just better if you live in a remote area but if you live in an urban centre and don't care about the fur trim too much (or you can modify it to a nice one and still save money). i say go for the outboroughs or McMurdo parkas from Northface ( I live in Canada) it gives the best value to brand recognition , but Canada Goose just like Moncler have a higher status symbol.
The north face is solid. I still have mine from 2001. Still looks brand new.
Wow over 20 years is impressive!
Exactly North Face rules
When it’s very cold fashion gets thrown out the window for function. When it’s -10 F the only people who look stupid are the people who look cold. That said, when it comes to fill I wouldn’t buy anything less than 700. CG often has 600 Fill and to make up for the inferior down they have to have more of it which makes their coats so heavy. Personally, I prefer the Arcteryx brand. Their coats tend to have an athletic cut which compliments my body. They also use Goose down as opposed to duck so they tend to have a higher Fill which makes their coats lighter. Bonus almost all their coats are wind and water proof and breathable and anyone who know the cold knows that the windchill is the real enemy of staying warm. My Camosum is not the warmest jacket but it can handle most winter days. For the really cold days I will just wear a puffer underneath. Of course I have no doubt my Arcteryx would fail most noise tests. Moose Knuckles, CG, Nobis and some of the more extreme coats have their place to. In particular for someone who has a dog that needs to be walked three times a day. So much nicer to just be able to throw on a big heavy coat u can wear over your pajamas and hide under a nice fury hood…and not spend the time putting on a bunch of layers.
Agreed! Great points too. Makes life a lot easier to throw on the jacket without layering. Canada Goose does a great job at that even if its 600 fill. Aritzia supper puff jacket is a good option too with 700 fill at only $250
I'd be interested in getting equivalent CG jackets on the scale - one with 800FP goose down and one with their normal 600FP duck down, and see what the real weight difference is. My feeling is the weight of CG jackets is more due to the materials they use for their outershells, than the down itself. Or - if they actually published their fill weights (thank you Montbell!), you could just figure out how much 700 or 800 FP down you would need to get equivalent loft, and then do some math to determine the weight difference.
I have a CG and NorthFace. Both very good for the cold. The only difference is the difference in price. Canada cold is tolerable with the cheaper brand The NorthFace. Personal preference
All good choices but Frahm out of the UK makes the best jacket around with their thermal military parka. You buy any of their jackets and you buy for life. Only downside is that they often sell out a year ahead! Styling is very cool as well: very detailed with Italian stainless clasps and military grade snaps. It’s also lower in cost than the top rated here. I love mine.
Thanks for the suggestion, will check out Frahm for sure!
66 North isn't well known outside of Iceland yet, but after living here for 3 years I've definitely noticed tourists wear Canada goose but Icelanders can't get enough of the 66 gear.
I'm heading to iceland next year and was looking at North 66.. The I found a post saying that some of their stuff is now being made in China??
@@ceezfotography I’ve found China Portugal Sweden and Romania listed as production partners for 66 north, not sure if any of it is produced in Iceland these days but it’s still very popular and high quality. To be fair with the wages here if it was all made from scratch in Iceland the prices would be astronomical
I've been riding bicycle all winter time for the past 35 years in Canada and you only need a wind and waterproof down jacket. My Eddie Bauer gore tech coat is still holding up for 30 years and only costs me 200$. You don't really need a $1000-plus jacket to keep you warm unless you just want to show off.
Agreed, and thanks for the suggestion, will check them out!
I always thought the North Face logo was a rainbow haha
So did I
Awesome video! As a recommendation, you should do next the Parajumpers Kodiak parka, which is a pretty strong/premium brand here in Canada.
Thanks for the suggestion! Will keep that in mind, Look out for a part 2 👌
I live in northern Minnesota and the helly Hansen is warmer then you’d think for how thin it is prima lift does great and if it so cold where it jacketed isn’t enough it’s to cold to go outside anyways
I'm afraid you're doing your fitting all wrong and this is why despite the Canada Goose jacket was all around perfect you found its fitting loose.
If it's really that cold to justify a jacket like this you are supposed to be wearing a mid layer underneath not just a t-shirt.
It's always the layers that keep you warm not just one thick jacket so the ones you found perfect fit for you were in fact all too small.
The quilted lining inside the jacket was also a significant feature not present in all of the jackets but important in keeping the filling properly distributed and in place this needs to be mentioned.
Not sure what the necessity of the sound test is as nobody swing their arms like that as they walk and these jackets aren't designed for military purpose. In any case the noise would have meant nothing when you are walking in the outdoor.
I used to live in Montreal and was in the army and did Arctic Warfare training and exercises all the time and the Canada Goose one was the closest to what we got issued.
Arc'teryx Macai is down and should be on this list. $1100 Canadian but it's been keeping me very warm in -30 Saskatchewan winter past 2 weeks. Very light and great flexibility. Canada Goose is too heavy and bulky.
I'm afraid you're gonna have to close your mouth
Thanks for the suggestion. Arc'teryx is a brand I regret not including in my video
Check out my new video featuring the arcteryx atom ar: ruclips.net/video/dPPiAN4gO9w/видео.html
Good stuff man, keep it up!
appreciate it!
Judging on looks alone, the North Face jacket looked the best. But I agree that it lacked in pockets, etc.
thanks for watching!
TNF jackets are the best for me in terms of the quality and pricing.
check out my new review featuring TNF McMurdo: ruclips.net/video/c-btd2ym-gw/видео.html