A Historically Significant Screwup Part 2 Star Trek Lower Decks

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 янв 2025

Комментарии • 90

  • @seanwolslau-holdren6731
    @seanwolslau-holdren6731 Год назад +552

    Actually, Boimler's not the one to blame for all this. Its the Curators fault for not doing more of a thorough inspection of Voyager before shipping her off to the exhibit.

    • @Darlf_Sevil
      @Darlf_Sevil Год назад +21

      Well is strange how that virus survival so long and no one find it befor

    • @LexYeen
      @LexYeen Год назад +14

      ​@@Darlf_Sevilbro, some viruses in the real world can go dormant. why couldn't some alien macro-virus?

    • @Darlf_Sevil
      @Darlf_Sevil Год назад +5

      @@LexYeen it big, more dna, ect. More things what can go wrong abaut it biology

    • @DD8842
      @DD8842 Год назад +25

      Yep That ship was not inspected well enough if that stuff was all there. The voyager crew had no space dock to work with WTF was this guys excuse?

    • @wizofauzz
      @wizofauzz Год назад +24

      Yeah his so called refitting was shitshow. He missed a Borg Nanite. Can you imagine how bad that could have been if they found that AFTER it became a museum with no starfleet to guard it?

  • @raistlin3462
    @raistlin3462 Год назад +266

    To think Boimler would be willing to ruin his chances for promotion over his friendship with Mariner. He truly has grown as a character.

  • @JohnPeacekeeper
    @JohnPeacekeeper Год назад +329

    How fitting that the Borg-beating expert gets promoted facing a Borg adversary
    Also I love the character growth that Mariner fully trusts Boimler now

    • @jamesshaw3500
      @jamesshaw3500 Год назад +23

      Yeah, those hours spent in the HoloDeck that one episode really paid off here.

    • @craytherlaygaming2852
      @craytherlaygaming2852 11 месяцев назад +6

      Dude went so haard he actually taught them empathy and stopped them being borge... till he was forced to go one final round.

    • @MatthewJamesKalasky
      @MatthewJamesKalasky 10 месяцев назад +3

      The fact that she's also willing to stay stuck there so Boimler can save the ship instead is also worth mentioning.

  • @VoidNull9222
    @VoidNull9222 Год назад +89

    It took the ending shot of Voyager on the ground in San Francisco to get me to remember; in Endgame Future Janeway says that Voyager is a museum in her timeline “On a clear day you can see Alcatraz from here”
    Looks like that’s true for the main Trek timeline too, Nice callback!

  • @FFF813
    @FFF813 4 месяца назад +23

    3:42 “we did it! We broke Voyager!” That feels like an insane statement having watched Voyager when I was a child lol

  • @youdontneedtoseehisidentif4939
    @youdontneedtoseehisidentif4939 Год назад +173

    I’m so dumb - I just realised that its Salamander!Janeway (or an animatronic of her, anyway) sitting in the captain’s chair

    • @Brasswatchman
      @Brasswatchman Год назад +7

      Or a replica thereof.

    • @sanfordrussell8549
      @sanfordrussell8549 2 месяца назад +1

      That trope of adding an exclamation point to a descriptive of a character before their name is so cringe, it can't be that hard to just say "salamander janeway", can it?

  • @daniels7907
    @daniels7907 Год назад +157

    2:17 "I miss my wife". Yeah, pity that Janeway deleted her so that she could have you for herself.

    • @TiredMoonRabbit
      @TiredMoonRabbit Год назад +30

      "I miss my wife tails"

    • @alternative915
      @alternative915 Год назад +1

      @@TiredMoonRabbit AAHHA

    • @Robert-hz9bj
      @Robert-hz9bj Год назад +15

      Janeway's cruelty was pretty legendary throughout the Delta Quadrant...

    • @brll5733
      @brll5733 Год назад +2

      One of the best scenes in Trek ever

    • @daniels7907
      @daniels7907 Год назад +23

      @@Robert-hz9bj - It probably took the Federation centuries of diplomacy to convince the Delta Quadrant civilizations that they weren't all like Janeway.

  • @AndrewStephen-d4g
    @AndrewStephen-d4g 10 месяцев назад +30

    I like how Mariner has went from downplaying their friendship in S1 to not even trying to hide just how much she cares for him in later seasons. Their friendship is one of the best things about the show.

  • @captaintalon4485
    @captaintalon4485 Год назад +71

    And now Boimler and Rutherford are a part of Voyager history

    • @UpStartTugBoat
      @UpStartTugBoat 9 месяцев назад +1

      Janeway will be proud of them.

  • @Ooilei
    @Ooilei Год назад +85

    I love that this is all also canon now

    • @Willie5000
      @Willie5000 Год назад +27

      The characters said flat out in the episode that Janeway committed murder. So there we have it. Janeway murdered Tuvix, it’s canon.

    • @booombasa
      @booombasa Год назад +11

      @@Willie5000 We only know a certain few characters in universe who thinks that. It is probably an ongoing debate there aswell as among fans. :p
      Im on the save Tuvix side, but Janeway did not get committed or reprimanded by Starfleet for this 'murder' so by in universe law shes all good. Morals and ethics on the other hand.... This debate will last as long as the human race.

    • @nuzlocke2266
      @nuzlocke2266 Год назад +6

      @@booombasa She murdered him.
      Technically she wouldn't get a reprimand, as it was truly a morel dilemma. There was no "right" answer. She chose to save Tuvix. She will live with the guilt of having to kill someone to do it till the day she dies.

    • @JohnPeacekeeper
      @JohnPeacekeeper Год назад +3

      @@Willie5000 I mean, Prodigy also establishes that Janeway has an MO to "clean house"
      She's still my favorite Captain but I get she's kinda messed up too

    • @Mark73
      @Mark73 Год назад

      @@nuzlocke2266 Simple solution. Do a Will/Thomas Riker transporter duplicate thing on Tuvix, and before materialization split one of them apart.

  • @alternative915
    @alternative915 Год назад +77

    If you think about it, Bomlier has already visit famous places and already make a name for himself like Deep space 9 Dabo master, SNW Enterprise "the guy who get to meet his idol", USS Titan "the guy who like the enterprise D" now USS Voyager with the cheese thing and has all the Voy plate collection,
    i hope one day he get to visit the NX-01

    • @MarshalStomm
      @MarshalStomm Год назад +6

      It's mentioned in SNW that he and Mariner toured it in the museum, and learned the things that helped them get back to their own time.

  • @HavocParadox
    @HavocParadox Год назад +41

    i love hearing the voyager theme.. it just feels so good

  • @Kindafu
    @Kindafu Год назад +38

    Brad does only two things: save the day and follow protocol

    • @copter2000
      @copter2000 6 месяцев назад +1

      I came here to save the day and follow protocols. And I'm out of protocols.

  • @spyrofan9681
    @spyrofan9681 Год назад +96

    I hope Boimler actually plays Captain Proton Holonovels as the Son of Captain Proton it's too perfect
    Also love the Clown's banter with Chaotica it reads so well.

  • @Robert-hz9bj
    @Robert-hz9bj Год назад +53

    Boimler reaching a point where he values his connections to other people more than he values the chance to get promoted is some fine-ass character development. Season 1 Boimler was willing to leave his friends behind (albeit reluctantly) to take a promotion to the Titan. Season 4 Boimler is willing to self-sabotage because his loyalty to his friends is such that he measures his worthiness to advance by how well he supports and believes in them. Good man, Brad...

    • @poshboy4749
      @poshboy4749 Год назад

      Maybe his friends should happy for him success in his career, not demand that he put being then over a promotion.

    • @JohnPeacekeeper
      @JohnPeacekeeper 11 месяцев назад

      What I like is that we also have a direct mirror in William Boimler taking the complete opposite route. Isolating himself even from the Titan's crew for a more "prestigious" position with a Section 31

  • @sasukesarutobi3862
    @sasukesarutobi3862 15 дней назад

    One of my favourite pieces of trivia from this episode is that the name of the curator, Beljo Tweekle, seems to be inspired by Bjo Trimble, who was one of the leading people in the letter-writing campaign that got TOS renewed for a third season, as well as authoring the very first Star Trek episode guide and being involved in a number of other things in Star Trek history.

  • @Adam-ln4og
    @Adam-ln4og Год назад +14

    Am I the only one who wonders how Janeway would react to this news?

    • @jordanloux3883
      @jordanloux3883 Год назад +10

      I imagine she'd punch Boimler in the throat and then give him a handshake for a job well done.

  • @sonicguyver7445
    @sonicguyver7445 7 месяцев назад +4

    "I used the Neelix cheese! It gummed yo the neural network just the way it likes!"
    Oh Rutherford, don't ever stop being you.
    Also just realized Boimler's voice actor is the current Superman from My Adventures with Superman. A superb choice, they both have that nervous energy and are a little too eager to please everyone around them.

  • @tyronehigginbottom4679
    @tyronehigginbottom4679 Год назад +15

    The Cerritos Crew as cameo figures on Voyager. #stld

  • @eugeniamonerratpinzonbalam3451
    @eugeniamonerratpinzonbalam3451 Год назад +10

    2:17 sudedenly I have flashback to Dr Eggman 😅

  • @robertballasty395
    @robertballasty395 10 дней назад

    2:49 The only way this could have been more perfect is if the salamander in the command chair had one of Janeway's coffee cups.

  • @davethomas8410
    @davethomas8410 Год назад +9

    ive missed voyager it was good to see her again voyager is my favourite star trek show

  • @bluekitty3731
    @bluekitty3731 6 месяцев назад +1

    "It belongs in a museum!"... Opps wrong franchise!

  • @Karen-du3pj
    @Karen-du3pj Год назад +4

    The music says it all🌛🌛

  • @ThePongles
    @ThePongles 11 дней назад

    Small detail, but I like how Ransom was smart enough to shut up as soon as it would get them caught even though he was against the current course of action. He wasn't stubborn or spiteful even though he would have preferred to have a sense of control over the situation.

  • @rickhobson3211
    @rickhobson3211 Год назад +16

    What I don't get is that Voyager isn't an old ship. She's contemporary to the Enterprise. Why would they decommission her?

    • @rulerofdiscord
      @rulerofdiscord Год назад +27

      it probably has to do with the numerous modifications that had been done to the ship. I also believe that the gel pack route may have been viewed as too strategically significant to keep the ship active. Your ship is now not only vulnerable to physical attack and energy attack but also biological.

    • @hfar_in_the_sky
      @hfar_in_the_sky Год назад +15

      @@rulerofdiscord I came to the same conclusion. Because yeah, Rick is right that Voyager is a relatively new ship class. And you honestly can’t tell me that Voyager is “too old” when Starfleet still has Miranda and Excelsior class ships still in service. So Voyager being too irregular in its design after all the modifications is about the only reason I can think of

    • @Brasswatchman
      @Brasswatchman Год назад +30

      Seven years in the Delta Quadrant without refits or proper maintenance seems to have done a proper number on her.

    • @Eradicator-jv9xr
      @Eradicator-jv9xr Год назад +10

      ​@@rulerofdiscordnah man, every ship in the fleet has since adopted bio neural circuitry and isolinear hybrid computer systems, they decommissioned it because starfleet RnD got their hands on it and tore every non essential part from it's Hull for research. They added a stellar cartography room, the database filled with so many planets and scans, the doctor, borg enhancements done multiple times, the transphasic torpedo and the ablative shield, neelixes cooking, etc

    • @reddyredwolf3931
      @reddyredwolf3931 Год назад +21

      Voyager is a historically significant ship. Also the Voyager-A is on the way. Starfleet took two years to catalog and remove classified modifications from Voyager like Borg enhancements, Slipstream drive, deployable ablative armor and Borg killing torpedoes.

  • @vismortis
    @vismortis Год назад +7

    What did you do? Like dude the ship is under the control of the Borg and headed to a cube. If it gets there and you don’t have control back you will be a drone. That’s assuming you left the weapons and armor on the ship without that your toast, Voyager was never going to take a cube in a fire fight

  • @Mrblackfox966
    @Mrblackfox966 29 дней назад

    God the voyager theme

  • @SecondBestArtMuseum
    @SecondBestArtMuseum 24 дня назад

    I miss my wife, Tails. I miss her a lot.

  • @TheMGSlow
    @TheMGSlow Год назад +4

    I miss my wife :(

  • @Mogget01
    @Mogget01 Год назад

    Woah, Fear itself

  • @redrasegarden
    @redrasegarden Год назад

    Yeah when you stop and think about it.

  • @TommyRayzer
    @TommyRayzer 8 месяцев назад

    No time to cut them down, yet takes 3 seconds to cut one of them down. So he couldn't spare 6 more seconds?

    • @KentuckyKaiju
      @KentuckyKaiju 5 месяцев назад +3

      Well, no. The Sullivan hologram circled back literally as they scampered away.

  • @Lightescape1
    @Lightescape1 11 месяцев назад +2

    I love watching these clips but it makes me want to turn youtube off and put the show on..... so I'm off bye.....