What If Steven Spielberg Directed Jurassic Park 3?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- A Very Special Thanks to InGen Executives Brett Rouleau, Daniel Cole, Christopher Siehda, Jonathan Murphy, Charles Rix, Jack Barnett, George Albott, Luis (Blamo_Guy) Santiago, Rob Langridge, David Bell, Flower Bro, The Sandman, Travis Whatley, Bailey Smith, Alexandre Raison, Cobalttheunicorn, Conner Losco, Cory Lydick, Greg Thornton, Timothy, Chris Stoddard, Cassandra Castaneda, Casey Morris, Andrew Fallon, Sam Lowe, TIMAN, The Melting Squad, FAMOUSLASTWORDS, Colin Paul, BigDanFTW, Matt S, Eddie Hoplight, Nicholas Brown, Verlando Brown, Rob Tallman, Balcora, Nicholas Roque, Bryson Knox, Kevin McDonald, Robert Messing, Brianna Christie, Ben Wilders, Robbie Brown, Joel Elizondo, Jacob Hagelstein, Ryan Moser, Ellis Ozley, Hunter Brown, Isaac Rovenko, Lee Hallewell, Kboss, Patrick Perry, Steven, Mark Rainbow, Andy Lucas, Richard Humbert and Michael Mendez! As well as my Game Wardens Paul Chandler, Tyrannical Rex, Doughnut Guy, Martin Ipsen, Libby MacEachern, Andrew Wilmot, Bledsitter, Mulluns, Lauren Hutton, Chase Acker, Auraya Frost, Roger Coleman, Kyle Oxley, RyanHamster, Mike Wu, Lisa Kay, Melissa Rocha, Steven Ray Morris, Keith Powell, Larry Gillis, Cass Wart, Jared Meza, Mark Davies, Jordan J Robles, Brittany Toliver, Logan Howlett, Saturn Sky, Chris Webb, James Luong, Raul Luis-Solorio, Derek Hazen, Ryan LeBrecht, Brandon Bowers, Paolo Caday, Luke Davis, Matthew Buffington and Alex! Seriously, you guys are awesome! :D
If you want to Donate to the Channel, click here! : www.patreon.co...
Check out Daryl Leigh Lynn's Channel! : / @darylleighlynn
Buy Official Klayton Fioriti Merch Here!: www.redbubble....
Official Klayton Fioriti Discord Server (Sorna)! : / discord
Official Klayton Fioriti Discord Server (Nublar)! : / discord
JP3 was directed by Joe Johnston and released in 2001 after going through a production without a completed script. However, originally the movie was going to be made with an idea by Steven Spielberg and Michael Crichton himself. This video is essentially made on the idea of this: What if Steven Spielberg Directed Jurassic Park 3? The feathered raptors, pteranodons and Spinosaurus would probably be quite different in that version of the movie and I'm not so sure that the Spinosaurus vs Tyrannosaurus scene would've even made it in the final cut...I'd love to know what all of you think about this. :D
If Spielberg directed, you can guarandamntee that the Tyrannosaurus would not have been killed off like it was. That was Horner finagling his bias into the ear of Johnston. Spielberg likely wouldn't have allowed his star attraction to be unceremoniously killed off in his vision.
Jason Krueger and be killed by the shittiest dinosaur possible
Still better than fallen kingdom
@@troppie7823 I wouldn’t say the spino was the worst option but still not the best not to mention that this spino is specifically genetically modified to kill t-rexs I’m pretty sure
@@Godzilla-jr5gi Still better than Dominion.
@@comicbookprodigy995 that I can now agree with
honestly i like the idea of grant staying on the island to study the dinosaurs, in the first movie even when he was watching the t-rex eat the gallimimus, he was still interested in how it ate and hunt. i think if the idea was changed up a bit it could’ve worked out. he could’ve discovered more about velociraptor behavior and INGEN’s more secretive plans involving dinosaurs and cloning; which could have better set the stage for jurassic worlds ‘trained raptors’ and hybrid dinosaurs. the only way i think this wouldn’t work out is because of the overall plot and suspense. but that’s just my opinion. hopefully in JW3 we see grant and sattler again tho
Whenever I hear about the original idea of Grant studying dinosaurs in the trees, I get super excited (as if I'm going to get to see it). Then I get super sad because I know that I'll never see it. Unless I can travel to a parallel universe where that movie actually got made.
Was just thinking this exact same thing haha
I personally think that if Spielberg directed the third film, it would be a much better film. I would have liked to see Alan doing more research on the dinosaurs on Sorna. And yes, every film goes through three stages of writing. Pre production, production, and post production. As I'm editing my JP fan film, it's not holding up to my original vision. We changed a few things in the script during filming because some things didn't make sense. Spielberg is a cinematic genius when it comes to shots and composition. His use of dolly shots and oner scenes are just mind blowing to me.
Great video! Awesome topic to talk about.
@@speedracer2008 Precisely, it's what Spielberg never really "gave" apparently. He just wanted the whole "Robinson Crusoe" deal but he was unable to convince Johnston of "why" would someone who survived being chased and almost killed several times would want to go back to the same hell. I mean, Spielberg himself directed Lost World where Ian Malcolm quite adamantly called Jurassic Park hell and refused to go back. Grant may be a paleontologist but studying bones is not the same thing as risking life and limb studying gigantic and dangerous living animals.
Also, the entire RObsinson Crusoe idea was apparently tossed fairly early in pre-production. There was also an extra extremely complex story about Grant helping to investigate dino attacks on the mainland which was also tossed because it was too complex.
Damn it Joe Johnston! >:( Great video as always Klayton, love your channel :D
Hey thank you! I really appreciate hearing that! I love your videos too! The Fallen Kingdom Musical has become addictive to me! :D
Well Hello.
LHUGUENY hello
LHUGUENY cause they hit my huge fin with their plane
Wow you watch his vids...Cool
Yeah I've personally always really liked how in JP3 Grant is pessimistic about the whole situation, always made him feel more believable personally, especially after JP1.
But then in Dominion I think it also makes sense that he's still in the dinosaur profession because that's what he knows best and he needs to make money. Plus when you've experienced the things he has then you're more qualified than a lot of people when it comes to dinosaur related jobs.
If Steven Spielberg made Jurassic Park III, he would really made the movie based on the book and it would be different from Joe Johnson’s own movie.
I don't disagree about it potentially being a better movie, but there is no third book.
there is no third book......idot
@@KING__Videos It would be based off the 2 books.
If Crichton had stayed on it would have been great.
Wished he made a third book...
@@XDarket Wonder how it would go though considering that Nublar was bombed and Sorna's dinosaurs had a virus that will kill them in the future, unless of course Crichton would have made a 3rd story about the dinosaurs in going to main lands if he was still alive.
@@nexusprime2487 OH MY GOD! I READ THE BOOKS 4 TIMES AND DIDN'T GET THE HINT THAT THEY WILL DIE IN THE FUTURE!!!
SO A 3RD IS IMPOSSIBLE!!!
I KNEW THEY HAD VIRUS BUT MAN AM I DENSE!!!
....maybe life finds a way?
You know, chimps are somewhat immune now to HIV.
Yay new video and did you get your silver play button yet
he definitely needs one
Yeah, he deserves it.
That's the gold play button, GamingTV. You only need 100k subs for the silver one.
That's not true, it's 100k for silver, 1M for gold, 10M for diamond and 50M for ruby. If you don't trust me, go check it on the RUclips Creators' Awards page
@GamingTV I hope you are trolling
I agree with Joe Johnson. Wether you like JP3 or not. Grant would never stay on that island if he had a choice. Imho
Yeah, I have to agree. Personally I think all the JP movies went downhill after the first with the possible exception of JW.
Yeah it made way more sense that he was into bones and that it was a dying science so he needed the money 💰...also leading into Jurassic world where genetics are the future even as humans
Yes it does make sense and when you are hunted and attacked by an animal or any kind it can be very traumatizing along with his overall experience of trying to survive with the other characters. But it does make me wonder if he may have not have felt that way entirely because his experience has inspired him to do more research on raptor intelligence, which Klayton Firoriti has mentioned in another video, and you can see this in the movie when he talks with Ellie. So maybe he would for sure be more cautious and not taking things for granted, and he would still be willing to go back due to his curiosity and fascination, which is something of a reason I think can relate to everyone for wanting to visit a dinosaur island despite the risks.
@@Eric_1991 Nah, I liked the lost world.
@SLY GXP He dropped it on Nublar not Sorna
I don't dislike the third entry as many others, but I do feel that the major problem was a lack of ambition and seemed to not want to take the story in a newer or unique direction. I enjoy it and feel it has a cool modern B-movie feel, but I wish they stuck to the original idea with Grant which felt more like natural progression than what we got.
I wish JP3 had focused on Erik's time surviving the island rather than following the rescue team throughout the entire movie.
Yes. It would be great to know how the hell he managed to get T-rex piss.
TH3GPS Haha! I know right!
YES! It would be awesomely terrifying to see Erik's 8 weeks on Sorna because as terrifying as it is for an adult, it HAS to be worse for a kid, especially since he doesn't seem to have any training. It would've been cool to see him build up from scratch.
You should read Jurassic Park Adventures Survivor. It's a book that accounts Eric's 8 weeks on Sorna.
Terrordome 3000 I had no idea that existed! Thanks for the info! Love your channel too btw.
Steven Spielberg was the true director who has supposed to make JP///
Spielberg was too busy with A.I. as was John Williams who handed the helm to Don Davis.
I think Spielberg would’ve made a better JP3, but I had no idea he had his own plans for the story. It wouldve been very interesting to see how that story would’ve worked. Hopefully, it would’ve had the T-Rex still portrayed awesomely and not get killed by the Spinosaurus. I mean, I would’ve been ok with the Spino being the main antagonist if it wasn’t for that fight sequence.
But the t rex was still portrayed good.
It kicked the spino's ass.
You are saying you dident like the movie for 1 scene then you are stupid honestly
That one scene is not the only reason I dislike JP3. There's also Amanda Kirby, a little too much predatory dinosaur action and not enough peaceful dinosaur moments, some scenes not making sense, and Grant and Sattler's breakup. Sheesh!
A person can dislike a movie for one scene in the movie. It depends on how significant it is, or lack of significance.
Like there was no reason to include that short fight, and would not have started the controversy in the first place.
@@Proteus_Ridley so it's rigth saying you don't like the hard work of the animators and engeniers that made the Dino's bcs of a 20 seconds scene
I personally am a fan of Jurassic Park 3, but I have no doubt that if Spielberg directed this film, it would have been great. I think would have been cool to see Grant studying dinosaurs on Sorna.
Possibly a pretty good film. And congrats on 100k.
Dennis Brännvall hello there
If Spielberg was directing, it would have be A Lot Better. It's sad what we loss...
Yea but at least it wasn’t some stupid teenager movie like it was originally gonna be
no u
Yea
@@dougrattman4110 but it wss like comedy the first hole hour
Steven Spielberg had it right the first time. I didn't like the way they portrayed Alan Grant is a big old grump that hates dinosaurs. The only thing he was a little bit of a grump about was the trees and kids but he got over that.
Girlsaurus Rex I mean after the first incident you really would resent them
@@LeonGun8 Right but that's irrelevant to what I said so...
@@Blinko7 Never mind, I think I replied to the wrong comment.
@@LeonGun8 I get the point though it is true. He still shows an interest in them as he's doing a velociraptor excavation when you first see him in JP3 and as you say, the recreations are 'theme park monsters'.
@@Blinko7 Yep, that'swhy I honestly never found Grant's characterization bad in JP3.It's the very simplistic concept of "kid gets lost, trick Grant to go to the island" that I found extremely lazy. Even knowing the truth about how they removed the last big dino moment of the movie shows just how on the fly the movie was done.
It would have been much better if Steven made JP3.
@GamingTV the only reason why I didn't like it as much as the others is because the film itself doesn't have that Jurassic Park touch. Also the way it ended, this film was going to be the one to end the trilogy, but it ends so abruptly and though I actually like the Spinosaurus, it's only purpose in the film is to kill the T-Rex and be the main antagonist. It's not like the indominus Rex where there is a reason for why she is the main threat and focus than the T-Rex.
@GamingTV I do agree with you on them Disneyfied the dinos, but they don't do it to all of them only the raptors and personally I like that about Jurassic World, giving the raptors different personalities helps us differentiate them from one another. The raptors aren't overly friendly either and Owen even said that they are dangerous animals same thing can be said about lions, lions are wild, dangerous animals but if you raise it when it's young (like what Owen did Blue and her sisters) and you stay with it for the rest of its life, then it would come to respect you, it's not a pet thing it's a respect thing (just like Owen said). But I respect your opinion of why you don't like Jurassic World over JP3.
@GamingTV right, I guess you win then. Sorry 😞
GamingTV I'm not a fan of the Jurassic World movies. But, uh, the domesticated dinosaurs (as you call them) do go insane and cause chaos. So, if anything, it's exactly what Malcolm and Grant warned. On a grander scale.. because they trained these dinosaurs, have GPS trackers embedded in them, and (stupid) security with live ammunition.. and shit hit the fan. Actually, Jurassic World is more like shit, birds, and concrete hits the jet engine. Again, I dislike the Jurassic World movies.. but chaos theory is still present in them. So present, in fact, that it beats you over the head with it. I mean, fuck, chaos happens to chaos what with the Mosasaurus stepping into the fight.. after Rexy... and the Raptors step in. I'm honestly not sure why I'm typing anymore. Fuck Jurassic World. Chaos theory happened to the franchise--and THAT is what Malcolm warned. Trevorrow discovered Jurassic Park and BAM he packaged it. Sold it. But didn't earn the right to wield it.
Trey Rex don’t give up yet you had super valid reasons, keep pushing.
Jp3 would probably be more interesting if spielberg directed it
Kinda wish Crichton directed it
Definitely here because I was wondering how it would go honestly! Thanks for uploading this!!
I’m interested Klayton, how would you have done Jurassic Park 3?
I am a uge Steven Spielberg fan and I love every single one of his movies from Jaws two et two Jurassic Park and last but not least the back to the Future movie
The process of Jurassic Park 3, and the various what-ifs throughout the entire franchise, and the lead up to Jurassic World is so interesting and exhausting at the same time lol. Great video as always, Klayton
Can you do a video on how Owen survived getting tranquilized? It was stated that the tranq-darts used on Blue could be a lethal dosage and one small prick can kill a full grown man. It always bothered me on that Owen and even Henry Wu survived getting shot/jabbed by one of the deadly darts.
They actually explain that in the movie. The reason Zia Rodriguez goes along with Wheatley in Fallen Kingdom is because she's worried about him injecting Blue with too many tranq darts. She even pulls one out on his vest and shows what the darts look like before telling him that one too many can kill her. When Owen is shot and falls to the ground she immediately runs to his body and pulls the dart out of him. There is a close up of the pulled dart in her hand and you can see that only half of the blue liquid went into Owen. I'm not so sure what kind of tranquilizer was used on Henry Wu but the stuff with Owen is explained on screen. Hope this helps :)
Yeah but just a small amount enough could have been already been flooded into his blood stream, which is alot different from a full grown raptor. It's filled with Carfentanil, which is extremely potent and has a lethal human dose in the micrograms, meaning any human injected with a dinosaur-sized dosage of it should have experienced fatal respiratory failure. Yet Wu and Owen recover fairly quickly and suffer no lingering side effects.
+NickyVendetta
Plot armor.
Spielberg would have given us a better movie.
One of the many Matts so true .
Dude the movie was alright
@@AA-ck6kg in your opinion. It should have been alright, but it was an awful film at best.
@@mrsinister8978 true we have opinions can’t like everything
Still better than fallen kingdom
Well, if Johnston argued that grant wanting to go back never made sense, how do you explain Malcolm's desire to check sorna in the lost world novel? That idea was from the source author himself. I mean, Malcolm had practically died and come back because of these Dinos. So, I don't think the idea was that unbelievable. So, I'm sorry, but screw you, Johnston. You've made great movies, but you fucked up JP3.
toast wh1sp3r3r so true he did make a bad jp movie.
@toast, I know the video about the deleted scenes was after this video. But the story made a whoooole lot better sense if they would of included the cut content. What we got was a rushed film with no real story or explanation. But that had to be cut out due to the ever invisible barrier known in the movie business at the two hour length. The jurassic park series really has suffered because of this fault.
Malcom didnt "want to", he told Levine that if if Levine found enough evidence he would go on Levine's expedition...
As the above commenter said, Malcom had no choice but to accompany Levine, knowing he would be in danger otherwise. Also, Levine actually asked Malcolm to help him investigate dinosaur attacks in Costa Rica. Malcolm was pretty much already forced to help once Levine confirms evidence of dinosaurs in the Central American lands. Plus there's the fact Levine decides to explore the place by himself and Malcolm realises BioSyn infiltrated their offices and found out about Isla Sorna. So yeah, Malcolm didn't "choose to go", he was "forced to go".
In fact, it's not very differently in the movie itself. Malcolm doesn't want to go to Isla Sorna in the movie, Hammond basically sends Sarah Harding to the island and then informs Malcom about it,making it impossible for Malcom to refuse.
Three was awesome
Spielberg would have definitely made a better movie. I'm no fan of JP3 exactly, but I love this franchise & will always watch every movie. JP3, what we got, has its moments. So I do try to enjoy it. The Pteranodon scene is cool. The T-Rex/Spino will always suck. It wasn't even a good fight to begin. Also, now I see Billy as an unsung hero. Haha. And give Amanda credit for not screaming when she was face to face with the Raptors.
Julie R How do you know?
I wanted kirbies to die
If Steven Spielberg directed JP3, Grant and Ellie would still be together.
I actually think Jurassic Park 3 was okay & it doesn't deserve all the hate that it gets by everyone Klayton. 😭😢
Same
@@obiguanche5512 it makes the way to Jurassic world & Jurassic world fallen kingdom so let's stop all hate. 😢😭😉😇
I enjoyed it more than jw and fallen kingdom
@@prathapkutty7407 I love each & every last movie in the franchise in fact there isn't a bad movie &me& my mom loved both Jurassic world & Jurassic world fallen kingdom & they did a amazing job one them so Jurassic world 3 please. 😉😇💖💗
& when Jurassic world fallen kingdom comes out next week I will be picking it from where I work before I get started on October 18& I can't wait to buy my very own copy. 💗😇💖
That would be dope to see Sam sneaked in and sleep out in the tree can be intriguing. :).
I feel like Spielberg’s story would have been a lot better and wouldn’t have played out so clunky. Also things like Amanda Kirby’s consistent ignorance would not have been an issue, if they were in the movie at all. With those things being said, in ways I’m thankful that JP3 is how it is for a few reasons.
Firstly, I feel that with it tanking like it did it made the wait for the next movie that much sweeter. Being able to enjoy the next chapter of JP as an adult is something that I’m very grateful for because I have a much higher appreciation for the story than I did as a child.
Secondly, I feel like if Spielberg and Crichton would have stayed on together they would have wrapped up a lot of the ideas that are being addressed now in this new trilogy.
Thirdly, things like the DPG and all that info wouldn’t weigh as heavy and be as exciting as they are if Johnson’s version was never made. The JP franchise suffered dramatically from large portions of things that simply didn’t make sense or line up after the release of JP3. JP3 basically said to hell with the ideas and stories that have been building, we’re making an adventure film. While fun to watch, it severely hurt the direction of the franchise because there was simply no where to go after what it did. The DPG has bridged all of those gaps and made the lore more interesting than I ever thought it would be(so I guess in all fairness, that’s more on the creativity of the DPG people).
You know what would've been awesome? If we saw Spinosaurus battle with Cerataurus and kill it instead or maybe have the smaller T-rex die but later towards the ending of the movie we see Spino come face to face with the same T-Rex couple from Lost World and wage war with each other with the T-Rex pair winning. that would've been cool.
I like the intro haha and background music
Steven Spielberg should have done Jp3. Though we wouldn't have gotten to see the spinosaurus. Awesome video as always. Keep up the awesome work! :)
we probably would have a spinosaurus as the main dinosaur but better story tho
Johnson is right, Alan Grant is a sane man. No way he'd willingly go back to either dinosaur filled island after nearly losing his life the first time.
Klayton is never going to get over the Rex being beat.
I got a good one. What if the events of Fallen kingdom played out in a similar way the volcano, indoraptor and Dino's on the mainland but the script for the film was written by Michael Crichton.
Fang This would’ve been great but unfortunately Crichton passed away in 2008
DenotheFreak I wonder if the hypocritical nit picky fallen kingdom reviewers would still use petty criticisms
@@Competitive_Bid_ Probably not.
Fang I hope your right.
There is no petty criticism, Fallen Kingdom is just not a good movie.
Klayton: the T. rex decided to sit this one out after a bad neck injury
Me:😆😂
Easy! It would’ve been far cooler than it already is.
But then i think there would be less spinosaurus awesome scenes
“Than it already is” lmao it’s not cool at all.
@@blunew467 it is
That trex neck joke actually got me, props to you for that 😂
I may have laughed a little too hard at the “neck injury” joke. Lol!!!
It would actually be good
Maybe its writing problems would not have been so severe. Also this video is way better then nostalgia critics JP 3 review. Also the bird cage scene is my favorite scene also what do you think of fallen kingdoms objective criticisms and when is that Jurassic Park criticisms video coming out?
Honestly Jurassic Park 3 would have been better film with Spielberg as director! He would have been far respectful to universe that he created.
Still better than fallen kingdom
I'd like to think that if Spielberg had directed JP3 a lot of his go-to crew would have been involved: Janusz Kaminski as cinematographer, David Koepp helping as an additional writer, John Williams composing the soundtrack, etc. On top of that, I think we'd also see a more ambitious directorial style like what we got in TLW with its long-takes and tracking shots. Lastly, I think Spielberg would've been much more careful with the usage of CGI-using it mostly for wide shots, dark scenes, or moments where practical effects otherwise wouldn't be possible.
Don't forget Michael Kahn as editor.
I never thought about this.. this would have been an amazing movie
The T Rex neck joke was funny lol
I think there isn't enough talk on the Speilberg side of the Jurassic Park franchise, so this video was a fantastic watch. Having worked on a few student films myself and been on blockbuster films in a professional capacity, I can attest to how any creative work can change day-to-day when they're being made. Creativity is at its best when it's fluid and changing to make the idea the best it can possibly be in the eyes of the creators. Peter Jackson's King Kong originally had a scene with the protagonist hitting a baseball with his buddy as they fly WWII FIGHTER PLANES. Tones of entire movies can change, as seen with JPIII: I don't think Spielberg's version of the movie would have looked quite so grimy with the cooler, more temperate colour grading.
On Alan Grant's perspective in JPIII, personally I think it was very understandable. The scene with Lex and Tim was made at an optimistic hope spot in the film with the herbivores, and notably was a long time before he and Lex and Tim would encounter the Raptors. I would bet that when Lex and Tim recalled their encounter to him, it would have dredged up the horror of when he first heard InGen had bred Raptors and swung his entire opinion of the park around. Jurassic Park has always had two sides of the coin to me: the optimistic beauty with the herbivores and the pessimistic horror with the carnivores. JPIII changed from the former to the latter regarding Alan during its development.
As of now I am working on a fan edit of Jurassic Park 3, i’m editing the film in a way that Spielberg would’ve directed it. I am obviously calling it, “Jurassic Park 3 - The Steven Spielberg Version”
It is currently not finished but I’m still working on it. Just wanted to tell you in case if you’re interested.
I wish Spielberg had more involvement in it. It would of made the movie just so much better
I wish he had more involvement on the Transformers films as well. I mean, he was an executive producer of that franchise in case you didn't know. And same with Cowboys & Aliens and Real Steel.
Still better than fallen kingdom
@@Godzilla-jr5gi No
@@MediaLoverChris02 yep
@@Godzilla-jr5gi Fallen Kingdom is the best movie since Lost World.
JP3 might be better than Jurassic World though.
Great video! I could agree with both versions at the end of the day!
I already knew about the original Jurassic Park III idea, and it would have been interesting to see it. But I like the version we ended up getting cause we wouldn't have the Spinosaurus or the Velociraptor Sornaensis(Raptor variant with Quills) or the exciting Pteranodon bird cage scene
Your amazing dude keep it up
Personally I always found Alan Grant hating dinosaurs (or at the very least INGEN's clones) to actually make less sense. Yeah the raptors tried to kill him and so did good o'l Rexy but, I'm sure as the paleontologist Grant is he would have recognized that they were just animals doing what comes naturally to them. It makes sense for Ian Malcolm to hate the dinos and to not want to have anything to do with them. He was a nay sayer from the start and through the events of the first film his Chaos Theory was proven correct.
Finally it's THE video...
1:08 You never fail to impress me, Klayton
I loved that JP3 used parts of the two novels that didn't appear in the films. There's a lot of great stuff in that movie and it gets a bad press. Is it as good as the first two, dunno. Is it a good film in its own right? I imagine it sold a lot of popcorn. I'd definitely watch it again.
Interesting idea, I would of liked to see Steven Spielberg do the 3rd one, if it was more like dinosaurs crisis lol
Honestly Johnston's refusal to put the 'Caruso' twist in is probably a good idea. It really would seem like a retcon given that Grant makes his feelings about the island clear at the end of the first film.
I think I would’ve liked it if the Baryonyx was the main dinosaur in this film, but that’s probably nostalgia since it was one of my favorites growing up.
I'm not sure what the plot would have been if Grant was studying them. It might have ended up as still a rescue story with Grant needing help. And I hope Ellie and Grant would have been a couple.
The unused baryonyx logo can still be used in Jurassic world 3. Cause personally, I think having another dinosaur besides the trex on the logo would make it unique, and stand out from all the others.
I love watching your videos there amazing i grew up with watching the JP movies and since i found your channel I don't have do wait for the movies and you make that possible thank you
i love that concept , i never bought that grant grew to dislike dinosaurs especially as he goes back on that in the movie. They wanted to turn him into malcom
If Steven Directed Jurassic Park III, I personally think it would have been a far better movie. But with that being said if it weren’t for Jurassic Park III turning out the way it did, we probably wouldn’t have Jurassic World and Jurassic World fallen kingdom. So I guess there’s always something to be grateful for.
I'm pretty sure we would've gotten Jurassic World either way.
If they wanted another scarier Trex, there was always the Giganotosaurus. Or Carcharodontosaudus. Even an Acrocanthosaurus! No problem with Spinosaurus, just waiting for an epic movie with 3 or more titan dinosaurs fighting.
Spielburgs idea sounds pretty cool
I have a theory that originally they were going to use the steven speilberg and maichel crighton script but the scriptwriter took the jhonston and steven script with him on a super far away pee and he accidentally dropped both scripts down a hill and he only found the script steven didnt like
The Crusoe thing wasn't Crichton's idea though. We don't know what ideas Crichton had for it as he dropped out of the project.
No I never knew that and now want to know how Steven's movie would have gone and would think that everyone wouldn't hate the movie and thanks for the info can't wait for next video
That early script sounds like it would have given some nice screentime to scenes from the second book not put into TLW film
I believed that Spielberg's version was the one of his idea for Jurassic Park 4 and that previously it would be for Jurassic Park 3, with Alan Grant and Ian Malcom
If it was made by Steven, there sure wont be any scene with a raptor saying "Alan"
0:44 XD those teeth
Joe Johnson: "Alan Grant wanting to see the dinosaurs again is not believable. What is believable is that he would have a nightmare about seeing them again because of a raptor saying his name next to him on a plane."
6:40 Is that Dilophosaurus supposed to look like a monarch butterfly? If so, that's pretty interesting and creative.
I just discovered from my film screenwriting teacher, who is an Oscar winner, that Spielberg has NEVER written his own screenplays. Yes, he’s jotted down ideas for stories but never a script which actually surprises me. Spielberg knows how to take a good (or bad) screenplay and make it better than it is. Which is why I believe Jurassic Park 3 would’ve been a 10x better had he directed it.
However, JP3 still holds a special place in my heart as the first Jurassic Park film I witnessed in theaters as a kid.
Whether this movie was good or not its still way better than fallen kingdom for sure
Spielberg's idea on JP3 is what I think JW3 should be like, humans studying the dinosaurs' behaviours and adapting to live with them. Also don't forget to put more of the cautionary themes into the mix.
I like the concept of what they did in the movie. Where Dr. Grant has almost PTSD and fears the dinosaurs because of his traumatic experiences. It could have been put together a little bit better, but i liked that idea.
Jurassic Park 3 is AWESOME
Jurassic Park III took place on a different part of Isla Sorna than The Lost World did, I thought was the explanation for the (according to some people, anyway, I guess) "different looks" between the two movies?
I had heard about Spielberg's idea before, but honestly I had forgotten about it. Likely Crichton stepped away because he didn't agree with Spielberg's story direction. I agree with Johnston that it would not make sense and like his take on Grant's idea about Hammond's dinosaurs and even felt he took it back to the book by breaking up Ellie and Alan. Also, the way the film production went, I think we can be quite sure, had Spielberg been at the helm, the movie would probably have been canceled completely and though some might prefer that, I think that would have been a real waste. I like JP3 a lot now. Sure, it's far from perfect, but by now it inspired so much nice fan and also canon theories.
If I made Jurassic Park 3, I would instead have a story revolve around a group of college students who have been shipwrecked and stranded on Isla Sorna. The Spinosaurus is still the main antagonist, but the T-Rex vs Spino fight is gone.
5:27 The only part I don't understand about Johnston's point of view is, while I mostly agree with it, by the end of the first film the Dr. Grant portrayed on screen I attest would want nothing more to do with dinosaurs including a career in paleontology.
Klyton can you please make a site c aka isla Muerta video
David Meza We have no fcking interesting information on Muerta
3:50 "scientifically impossible"
Me: Well that's not going to bite them in the ass in tge future.
I definitely think Spielberg's version might have been better, at least as far as Grant and tone of the story and creatures may have been concerned. And if the story was going to incorporate elements from Michael Crichton's Lost World novel, then I could see dinosaur poaching being an antagonistic issue for that story. Maybe we would have seen Biosyn play a bigger part, and possible wrap up the story arc from the original Jurassic film too?
The baryonx was removed for the sake of realism, and is replaced by a an even more unrealistic Spino. Funny how that turned out.
By the way, I just finished reading the Lost World, and I have to say, it may not be the page turner the first book was, and Dodgson's role feels like an afterthought, but I can totally see a few of the sequences from the book put back into a movie.
Jumanji was brilliant, would have been cool to see him direct a sequel or maybe a monster movie
The Trex and Spino scene should have been towards the end of the film. It’s much more believable if the spino got distracted fighting a trex and letting the humans escape vs some fire making the spinosaurs run away.
I have to admit I'm happy that Steven did not direct because I love the Spinosaurus as my favorite dinosaur and animal ever and if he did direct I don't think spino would be in the movie.
I think you are right in that the Spielberg JP3 would have probably focused more on the disease aspect and the lack of maternity aspect from the Lost World. Those two themes trickled into JW and JW:FK but not as strong as I think Spielberg would have made them. Grant was probably gonna be studying the change of the dinosaurs from genetically modifed to something more environmentally selected on.
Hey Klayton. Another awesome and interesting video! Just wanted to drop by and pose a question: would you be willing to post videos about other film series and their trivia, such as the Alien or Predator movies? Or would you like your channel to mainly revolve around the JP franchise? Just thought that your insight into those universes could be very interesting.
There would have been more slowed down wonder moments if Spielberg was in charge. Would've loved to see Alan Grant studying the dinosaurs from a high hide!
Sorna is a lot bigger than Nublar, so different parts of the island could look a lot different.
Dr Grant is my all time favorite Jurassic character. I was already hugely disappointed by JP3. If they screw up yet another movie with him, I will never forgive Universal. Here's hoping that Dominion will be at least as good as the other two JW movies. I'm honestly hoping for better, because both JW movies suffer from the same attention deficit that most modern movies have.
Btw, JP3 was the first time I ever noticed this nuhollywood obsession with not focusing on one thing for more than a couple minutes. How many JP3 scenes can you fit into... the kitchen scene from JP? How many JW scenes can you fit into the T-Rex breakout? How many Fallen Kingdom scenes fit into the Nedry vs Dilo scene?
Granted, JW at least has some longer scenes, but not a lot. The longest scene is probably when Owen investigates the Indominus paddock. Even then, that scene is separated by the film cutting to other things.
I think I would have liked Speilberg's product overall better.
I do wonder as Crichton was a filmmaker as well and have made films like Westworld, Coma, The Great Train robbery and I wonder how he would have done it that is if they would have let him have done JP 3 as some sort of thank you because he was the franchise father I guess a darker tone would have been there like the novels and more scenes not used in the films as well.
Honestly, if Jurassic World 3 is going to be the last film in the franchise (until another reboot), it'd only make sense if Steven Spielberg directed it. I know Colin is making it and it is his trilogy, but it only feels right to say Steven should be the one to end it since he birthed this incredible (film) franchise and someone who was very close to Michael and understood what they had in terms of visuals and themes even if the films presented them differently.