It is time for someone from India to point out the problems within India ratger than using China as a Boogeyman for its failures. Imagine the power of Asia if India and China can resolve its borders peacefully by negotiation, join hand and seriously work together with BRICS. Only then that Asians can be a participant in writing the international rules that so far are fominated by the Europeans to continue its neocolonialism of the world.
American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
@wisdomhighschool9975 You need products from China for that to happen. Apple only has you slapping parts together nothing more, yet you folks failed the iPhone 15 CAUSING APPLE TO DISCOUNT THEIR LOWER END LINE WHICH CAUSE MASSIVE LOSES TO THEM. As per other points, you better do real research now.
@@wisdomhighschool9975don't kid yourself. Companie are shifting out of India. Apple found out the quality and class of India and moved production back to China.
@@Private-rm5dy😂😂 Instead of peddling Chinese Propaganda,Go and Check the CONSTRUCTION SITES of Foxconn is Building a $ 1.5 Billion Dollar Plant in Bangalore,$ 500 Million Dollar Plant in Hyderabad,Is Doubling Investments and Workforce In TN, Tata Electronics is Expanding it's Factory to 500 Acres in Hosur all this Becoz Apple has already Announced to Shift 25% of iPhone Manufacturing and Assembling to India by 2026, Corning is now Building iPhone Glass Manufacturing Plant in TN etc
@@Private-rm5dy😂 Instead of peddling Chinese Propaganda,Go and Check the CONSTRUCTION SITES of Foxconn is Building a $ 1.5 Billion Dollar Plant in Bangalore,$ 500 Million Dollar Plant in Hyderabad,Is Doubling Investments and Workforce In TN, Tata Electronics is Expanding it's Factory to 500 Acres in Hosur all this Becoz Apple has already Announced to Shift 25% of iPhone Manufacturing and Assembling to India by 2026, Corning is now Building iPhone Glass Manufacturing Plant in TN etc
Very impressive. I have yet to view and hear a real expert on this matter until now. Pravin has in-depth knowledge, a world view and the objectivity that puts everything into the right perspective. No hyping, no emotional interpretations.
Using PPP(purchasing price parity) measurement, China has already surpass US economy in 2014. IMF and the CIA uses the more accurate PPP measurement in their official reports.
Scholars like Pravin are rare in India today. He is an objective and independent thinker. Most of Elite Indian are Western mindset and comply with Western Ideology from a Chinese perspective.
I think this man should be running for India's leadership. His intelligence and knowledge are what is needed to reflect and make wise decision for India.
No he is not. He is a negativity ranter. He speaks the truth for sure but his ideas of how to deal with China - Idi-ots have better ideas. Also, India's strategy against China is well underway and is working: Per Reuters: The value of announced U.S. and European greenfield investment into India shot up by some $65 billion or 400% between 2021 and 2022, Wednesday's report said, while investment into China dropped to less than $20 billion last year, from a peak of $120 billion in 2018. "Diversification is well underway," the research organisation said, but acknowledging: "it will take years for advanced economies to achieve the objectives behind their 'de-risking' policies," as China is so central to global supply chains.
@@bradmayer1639 Pravin speaking the truth, Indian elite policies is why majority of Indians are still so poor.....Only institutionalized intellectual slaves believe what Reuters says with no 'dialectic materialism'. Over 90% of Corp. medias are owned by few of the same people on the same team. When the BRICS uses as less USD as possible those USD investment will mean little, especially if China won't accept USD investment in the future. China has a huge internal economic because people living in China are much better off than India. The 'Chinese Reset' is going to hurt them short term but in the future they will do better. Nobody wants too much rupees because country like Russia with lots rupees can't buy anything hi-tech where Russia needs. India's elite policies only shot themselves in the foot, like in Maldives, Bhutan, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh etc...The counter de-frisking policies won't work as majority of the Global South supports China + Russia.....
@@bradmayer1639, you forgot to add other fake news and dirty news from CNN, MSNBC, CBS, ABC, NBC, FoxNews, BBC, France 24, Associated Press, NYT, etc, etc. 😂😂 They also reported inflation in US is only 4%, Ukraine is winning the war against Russia, Russia economy tanked bcos of US economic sanctions, Chip Act crippled China technology, China stole 5G from US, and India is the next superpower; and that's why Russia asked pymts in Chinese Yuan in oil export bcos Rupee has higher exchange rate than the Yuan. 😢😢😂
Also as centre of excellence or hub for online scam and bank/credit card frauds of all kind, except for those love scams which championship still rest with Nigeria, lol.
The border issue is of the least importance to China as it has more than enough land it needs. And the border land in dispute are remote land of little economic value for now and for the future. India is hyping it up as a big issue when it is almost totally irrelevant to China. China is spending its resources and attention in many more important economic and development issues. India can spend all its resources squabbling about the border issue for all it wants. China does not care. Good luck to India's fantasy in the borders. But India should not push its luck too far. The land in dispute were Chinese land stolen by the Brits.
American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
India is even praised by Paxtani Experts for Having INDEPENDENT FOREIGN POLICY by Importing Oil from Russia and Exporting India Made Cisco Servers to US and American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
@@eswaribalan164American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
China capabilities are very well analyzed and understood. The West, East, North and South have no choice except improving relationship with china it have risen peacefully and continue to rise. The west needs to accept this reality, as rightly said by Sir Praveen there is no need to contain China , as it won't work. Let it rise peacefully for the benefit of the developing world. Thank you sir for taking time for this deep analysis. ❤
As a Chinese living in Australia I have associated with Indian people for many years, iNdian people are great people and friends, I hope Modi will do the right think to improve the ties with China, Mark my word, America will contain India one day for sure
India has no real foreign policy. Jayant Bhandari hit the nail on the head. Any fool can see that the West is merely using India as a pawn in their geopolitical game. The rise of India to superpower will also be contained by the US in time to come.
Truly a balanced, fair and truthful assessment. I think all Indians should view this to get a true perspective of where they really stand and how to move forward forward realistically instead of the usual Indian hubris spark off by western propaganda to counter China. Also more Americans who are fed daily on US propaganda and disinformation about China should view this understand the reality.
@@medialcanthus9681American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
@@IronMan-nu3rbAmerican Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
India may have the largest consumer market in the world but not in terms of spending power! India's consumer market spends much much less than China's consumer market! Hence China still has the world,'s largest consumer market in monetary spending power to attract high end products and high end manufacturing!
Simple explanation..India tried to " control " its neighbourhood because it believes as the biggest country in the neighbourhood it should be the "Boss" ..which is the mindset of most Indians politicians and population....The Chinese instead offer trade..prosperity ..infrastructure ..without political interfetence and will work with any incumbent Political power ..Every nation does not want its affairs " dictated " by external countries...it is So simple yet..so difficult for India to understand...so those around India will try subtetly to distance itself from India..in case India decide to "assist" that country by placing its military there and interfere "indirectly "in their nation political process..
And now that they have the largest population they believe they are the Leader of the Global South. If this is how India acts whe they are poor it's scary to imagine how they would act if they're rich
From Geneva Switzerland 🇨🇭. I am from Pakistan, living in Switzerland for the last 30 years . I listened to all your videos to understand World Order China India Pakistan and the rest of the world. Thanks for the balanced opening
Assalamualaikum sir from India. An Indian Muslim here. Switzerland main kitne Indian Muslims hein?? Kabhi kisi se Mulakat hua he aapka?🙂 Aur wahan kitne Pakistani hein?
I stumbled upon this podcast. This is mind opening analysis with facts laid bare for his audience. And he ask his audience to reflect on the facts without imposing his view. From what is presented, obviously he has the interest for his own country India to reflect, and adjust so that it is not left "holding the baby" and going forward in the downward orbit. Great Indian scholar and I must admit I need to understand his background and be educated on this aspect. Perhaps someone can help or point me to the right direction. Or I need to spend time digging through the internet? Best wishes to him and his audience and India on whatever journey route or adjustment they decide to take from his scholarly thoughts.
There is something wrong with our government foreign policy need to be revisit that after the USA all our neighbouring countries starting slapping India why? Indian domestic politics should not imposed on Indian foreign policy we’re heading towards isolation! Money wouldn’t buy a respect in international relations. In Asia we have only one friend Bangladesh and in the West France France only in for their own interest once the present French government gone maybe we will not even have the same support, supporting Israel blindly we are also losing respect in the Muslim world specially in the Middle East. One side we say we’re nonalignment but our actions tell us a different story.
The Indians "think" they're the inheritance of British empire, and would love to "inherit" the size of the British empire with it's colonies in the present world, they prove to the world by swallowing Sikkim, now make a guess, what will it's neighbors think of India? 😁😁
The Hindu fanatics govt of India conducted genocides against Muslims and openly supported the Israelies genocides in Gaza, make a guess, what's the image of India in the Islamic world?
But deffinately money is an important criteria for respect in international relations .Thats why no one champion of islam is daring to talk about the prosecution of wighur muslims in china .Not even quater and pakistan.china is the manufacturing hub of the world .They have to purchase lot of oil from arab countries as the raw metarial .According to famous saying if you have to choose between your firend and your customer then please choose customer
@@markvelber8664 Bro there is nothing called unconditional friendship in foreign policy .usa gift 30 billion dollar to pakistan and finally Pakistan's worst possible enemy osama bin laden was found in Pakistan .Pakistanis have released osamas fanily members and associates but have not yet released from prison he doctor liable for founding out osama
Correct. Pakistani and China should hand over pakistan occupied Kashmir and aksai chin to india. So that we all can work on regional connectivity and fail West.
Xi had talked to Modi more than twenty time directly and indirectly on Pak-India-China issues which countries should settled the differences and striving towards peace and prosperity but Xi came up empty and Xi wouldn't even bother looking at Modi as if he was invisible !
India needs more pragmatic and critical thinking. You can't live on pride and boasting. The future is educating your youth and building infrastructure to create a better life.
Sure thing, most of you appreciate the pacifist and deflater under the garb of a truth crusader. All he does is state the truth and then the recommendations that he gives are super low quality. Indian government is tackling China well and the results are showing up. Here is the truth that this idi-ot does not talk about: Per Reuters: The value of announced U.S. and European greenfield investment into India shot up by some $65 billion or 400% between 2021 and 2022, Wednesday's report said, while investment into China dropped to less than $20 billion last year, from a peak of $120 billion in 2018. "Diversification is well underway," the research organisation said, but acknowledging: "it will take years for advanced economies to achieve the objectives behind their 'de-risking' policies," as China is so central to global supply chains.
I am from Lebanon, yet I always have a pleasure listening and learning from you. Unfortunately though, the much closer Indian leadership seems not to be listening, and surely isn't learning. Should your ideas be adopted by the leadership, I am sure India would embark on a path of rapid development.
Your layout of the facts are fairly accurate cos I have monitoring the situation as well. Many Indians do NOT agree with your concluding remarks, from @27.54min onwards. I do agree with you.
He is not telling the truth on Maldives, India China tussle started after Manmohan Govt signed Nuke deal with USA, which BJP opposed. It was further escalated by QUAD, BECCA. Now China is using all India's neighbors to get rid friendship with USA, which India can't afford. China is using all money power to buy these small countries. Sri Lanka and Nepal have realized this game and they have now resettled relation with India. Maldives has gone too far making making personal comment. Maldives is also angry that India is supporting Israel . This channel is China paid so he talk more on GREAT CHINA.
Wow ! That’s a clear minded assessment about the true situation especially the strength and weakness about India China and Russia I can predict Russia will leapfrog their global position in term of economy once their Far East picked up the development with China investment.
I personally believe BRICS will have a major change of membership after the India next election, If Modie lose , India will / should be continue to be full part of BRICS organization ,a Modie win will be isolate India from any future plan with BRICS , currently Modie is playing school yard game between EAST and WEST ! " “A man’s got to know his limitations” Clint Eastwood famous quote .playing with both side always a loser at the end !
At that moment china is not in a position to isolate china .During the last meeting between shi xin ping and joe biden our friend poo ask for a debt of 800 billion dollar to usa .usa it self is not in a very good position in financial terms and thats why now the republicans are talking about to sack 16 lakh govt employee of usa .Only india is the countrey which is investing 5 trillion dollars in the infrastructure .indian infrastructure projects are big market for chineese real estate companies amidst loss of 13 trillion dollar in home front .in short china it self cant isolate it self from india at that moment of time
. Yeah, Pravin is an honest Joe. My opinion is he’d make for a cool leader not only for India but for all Asia and the world… Pravin more likely go to the negotiation table (in an air of friendship and neighborliness) with her neighbors than to try and resolve regional issues by copying Americans tactics as Modi did in the Balakok and Ladakh stand-off or misadventures… Modi extends himself as if he’s a God, sounds like a God, smells like a God, which is what Indians wanted and as such Indians will fall victim to the same wrath of God like Saddam did cuz Whitman don’t kid around. Once the Chinese threat (of yellow peril) is over and done with, it will be Indians the Americans will go after next..: .
. Hey ! Me Chini too. I wonder how many proud and young wives he (Modi) have stashed away in India and how many rolls Royce’s he have hidden in his garage… That’s how Gods operate you know. .
. Look, your average Indian guys are such simpletons they share their wives and their daughters with the maestro and they take deep pride in that sharing spirit… .
China, Russia and US are classified as great powers, Japan France, Germany etc are major powers as Mr Pravin says. However Indian media says India is SUPERPOWER . 😂😂. Say that a thousand times and India is a superpower to all Indians 😂😂
Bro yourself is saying that Germany and France is major power .If Germany and France are major power then India become automatically the super power because India spend as much for its defence budget of Germany and France combined .in 2022 official defence budget of India was 70 billion dollar .According to the sipri peace research institute the actual budget the actual budget was 83.5 billion. India do not pay its 14 lakh strong paramilitary forces through its defence budget but by its home ministry budget which is also comparable to the defence budget of Israel .May be India is not paying its 5 lakh volunteers from territorial army at regular basis but definitely pay for their equipment's .in short the real defence budget of India in 2022 was nearly 110 billion dollars in 2022.As indian armed forcess are going through major modernisation thats why the actual budget could be even more than my calculation .permanent non lapsable fund for armed forces and paramilitery forces modernisation is not less than 30 billion dollars .More than the defence budget of many european nattion
Thank you, Dr. Sawhney, for your realistic assessment of the current Indian Ocean and global situation. I hope that Mr. Modi and the Indian MEA have the intelligence to realize the challenges India is facing. Chest beating, India's fifth-largest economy is just an embarrassment. The Indian leadership must make policies to lift Indians from abject poverty and help institutions change their mindset like most of the progressive countries in the world have done to make scientific progress.
Pakistani leaders must keep begging in imf to keep 95 percentage Sunni dailt converted in poverty. I do not understand why pakistan beg for 3 billion dollar instead of 3 trillion dollar 😂😂😂😂😂
A truly realistic comment in its entirety. India wants to create a 3rd block but is devoid of capabilities beyond its means. It does not, for reasons of discriminative policies within its border, cannot come up with tangibles like China to showcase its capabilities.
@@bvssrsguntur6338 Obviously. The world's biggest communist state is miles ahead of the world's biggest democracy. Can't you even see that? I won't cite the physical evidence because I know you will be offended and go off in hysteria in typical fashion.
Maldives doesn't want to be militarily occupied by India. Simply look at Japan. They've been occupied by the American since the end of world war 2. S.Korea is also militarily occupied be US. These are two examples. Once the American built their military bases there they will not leave. Maldives new PM see that. Also I'm sure Maldives sees how Muslims are being treated in India with Hindutva lurking as BJP backbone.
We also know how maldivian constitution is biased for sunni muslims... U have highest per capita recruitment for ISIS in the world..it just shows how muldivian society is radicalised with islam...indians R also seeing those😊
I must add that my earlier comment was purely directed at your reference to the Maldives being "traditionally in India's area of influence". Other than that, I must admit that most of the remainder of your presentation is well-researched and factual, especially regarding the place of China in the global economy. While you have alluded to technological reasons for China's place in the global economy, currently and in the not-too-distant future, there are other reasons too. For example, here in New Zealand, the Chinese are increasingly more respected than Indians because the Chinese appear more sophisticated and refined than Indians, culturally and in social interaction. The air of colonial, British sophistication that some Indians exhibited in the 1970s has disappeared altogether, to be replaced by the brash conduct of such characters as your premier, Modi. This is certainly a huge reversal over the fifty or so years that I have lived in New Zealand. New Zealanders now choose to teach our children Mandarin as a foreign language at school rather than Hindi. While the New Zealand national education curriculum offers Mandarin as a school subject, it does not offer Hindi or Gujarati in spite of the fact that we have had a tiny, Gujarati-speaking minority since the 19th century.
We need more and regular videos from you sir....am fed up with media narrative of portraying as if it's all raining flowers from heaven vis a vis indian geopolitical news
He is not telling the truth on Maldives, India China tussle started after Manmohan Govt signed Nuke deal with USA, which BJP opposed. It was further escalated by QUAD, BECCA. Now China is using all India's neighbors to get rid friendship with USA, which India can't afford. China is using all money power to buy these small countries. Sri Lanka and Nepal have realized this game and they have now resettled relation with India. Maldives has gone too far making making personal comment. Maldives is also angry that India is supporting Israel . This channel is China paid so he talk more on GREAT CHINA.
Thanks for your objective presentation. It is what it is. There will be progressive people and leaders rising up in India who have the vision to know that all countries, including India and China, will benefit if all countries adopt a win-win mentality and cooperate for mutual benefits. However, I am not optimistic about the current Indian foreign policy. Hindu Modi seems to adopt a zero-sum mentality. At every corner, he is trying to undermine BRICs. I believe this behaviour is being moulded by thousands of years of Hindu hierarchical caste systems embedded into their DNA of all Hindu. This may explain why Indians have this behaviour " Either I am your Master or I am your Servant." There is no middle path. There is no win-win partnership. Indians believe in "If you win, I will lose" mantra. Maybe this explained why Hindu Modi is insane ( or extremely jealous) when countries are better than India. It can turn into volience. Indians from the outside seem to be very emotional and highly charged human beings. It is not surprise to learn that an Indian will kill his wife if she leaves him. Not only did this killing occur just in India but Indian diaspora living abroad. Why is India such a bully towards Maldives leaders when they visited Beijing, but it is not an issue when Hindu Modi visits President Biden in the White House. The USA is my master and Maldives is my servant. Is it their DNA controlling their behaviours towards other people, or it is more complicated??
Great n honest intellectual of india who dont shy to say the truth n dont do self deception n unnecessary claim self as great or vishwa guru n free of any hatred towards anybody so if india has unbiased n truthful knowledgeable intellectual like him then soon nothing can stop india
Mr Sawhney has an excellent understanding of realities geopolitical world. IMO he and M.K. Bhadrakumar are two commentators that more people should follow to better understand this part of the world. Why does Mr Sawhney has less than 100,000 subscribers ? He should have at least 1 million Indian subscribers. Understand that China is largest trading nation in the world. Therefore trading in Chinese Yuan makes sense for many nations. India is not a major trading nation and this presents an issue of what do other nations do when have Indian rupees. Rupees are a domestic currency. Modi's India is trying to play a very complicated geopolitical game in a geopolitical landscape that is both unstable and evolving. India is trying to sit on top of a very high fence between the global north and its desire to retain its hegemony and the global south that is raising. Sitting on a narrow fence, places a bright spotlight on India. Each side wants to see which way it is leaning. India's actions are seen by each side as being either pro or against them. THEREFORE neither side can fully TRUST India. Yes, the US wants to sell weapons to India, BUT not its best weapons. Those only go to select allies.
Everyone knows how hollow Indian support can be. Also, India is very bossy towards small nations. No wonder they’re pulling out. Also, China is simply too attractive an ally. There is just no comparison between what can be offered by China and India. To lose Maldives is catastrophic.
Sir . Please do a piece on the battle in Gaza & try to put it in a correct & apolitical perspective . And the challenge faced in dealing with the Lebanon factor .
Pravin Sh - excellent discourse. Do pls mention to ur audience about the accuracy of Baidu vs GPS and also the enhanced Huawei’s chips in the satellite’s that enables high speed data transmission from Baidu satellites down to earth stations and supercomputers - this enables China to accurately define actions faster as pictures are downloaded faster.
While China every day is making amazing progress, achieving real results for technology, infrastructure, improving the nation building and working hard to improve the standard of living for the people. China next door neighbor "I" on the west border is always busy with their ton of boastful hypes, self-praise on their leadership, chanting superpower, dreaming of replacing China as world manufacturing country. But with not much real achievement, progress and result. Beside they still have the gut and not ashamed to belittle and criticizing China infrastructures are built like tofu. China success must have made them very upset, jealous and frustrating that many of their media channels, no a day we don't see negative news, fake news and propaganda reports bashing and mocking China like a dog barking at the neighbor daily. But the China just ignored the dog barking noises and keep moving forward to get their business done to achieve what they aim for.
Sir kindly help us understand the impact on India due to the on going war in Middle East- Hamas-Isreal-Yemen-Lebanon-Iran and the US (west). Kindly make a video on this.
He is not telling the truth on Maldives, India China tussle started after Manmohan Govt signed Nuke deal with USA, which BJP opposed. It was further escalated by QUAD, BECCA. Now China is using all India's neighbors to get rid friendship with USA, which India can't afford. China is using all money power to buy these small countries. Sri Lanka and Nepal have realized this game and they have now resettled relation with India. Maldives has gone too far making making personal comment. Maldives is also angry that India is supporting Israel . This channel is China paid so he talk more on GREAT CHINA.
An honest and unbiased indian narrative of China, very rare! Great job!
India is beholden and in awe of western countries.
It does not have a strong backbone.
Modi is an American idolizing lapdog
It is time for someone from India to point out the problems within India ratger than using China as a Boogeyman for its failures. Imagine the power of Asia if India and China can resolve its borders peacefully by negotiation, join hand and seriously work together with BRICS. Only then that Asians can be a participant in writing the international rules that so far are fominated by the Europeans to continue its neocolonialism of the world.
American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
@wisdomhighschool9975 You need products from China for that to happen. Apple only has you slapping parts together nothing more, yet you folks failed the iPhone 15 CAUSING APPLE TO DISCOUNT THEIR LOWER END LINE WHICH CAUSE MASSIVE LOSES TO THEM.
As per other points, you better do real research now.
@@wisdomhighschool9975don't kid yourself. Companie are shifting out of India. Apple found out the quality and class of India and moved production back to China.
@@Private-rm5dy😂😂 Instead of peddling Chinese Propaganda,Go and Check the CONSTRUCTION SITES of Foxconn is Building a $ 1.5 Billion Dollar Plant in Bangalore,$ 500 Million Dollar Plant in Hyderabad,Is Doubling Investments and Workforce In TN, Tata Electronics is Expanding it's Factory to 500 Acres in Hosur all this Becoz Apple has already Announced to Shift 25% of iPhone Manufacturing and Assembling to India by 2026, Corning is now Building iPhone Glass Manufacturing Plant in TN etc
@@Private-rm5dy😂 Instead of peddling Chinese Propaganda,Go and Check the CONSTRUCTION SITES of Foxconn is Building a $ 1.5 Billion Dollar Plant in Bangalore,$ 500 Million Dollar Plant in Hyderabad,Is Doubling Investments and Workforce In TN, Tata Electronics is Expanding it's Factory to 500 Acres in Hosur all this Becoz Apple has already Announced to Shift 25% of iPhone Manufacturing and Assembling to India by 2026, Corning is now Building iPhone Glass Manufacturing Plant in TN etc
Very impressive. I have yet to view and hear a real expert on this matter until now. Pravin has in-depth knowledge, a world view and the objectivity that puts everything into the right perspective. No hyping, no emotional interpretations.
Just look at the wealth distribution across the classes in India and China and you will know why China is succeeding so much faster than India.
If u minus American weaponry sales, China economy is larger than US.
American friendship means buy more arms, what other products US have to offer ?
Well said
It is absolutely right usa policy is creating trouble in others countries and then starts selling weapons.looks at philipines
Using PPP(purchasing price parity) measurement, China has already surpass US economy in 2014.
IMF and the CIA uses the more accurate PPP measurement in their official reports.
True
It's not America's weapo sales but their money printing out of thin air that keeps their economy the largest. It's a Facade and fake economic power
Scholars like Pravin are rare in India today. He is an objective and independent thinker. Most of Elite Indian are Western mindset and comply with Western Ideology from a Chinese perspective.
I think this man should be running for India's leadership. His intelligence and knowledge are what is needed to reflect and make wise decision for India.
Indians will call him 'traitor to motherland' and 'foreign agent' and never vote for him. 😂😂😂
I bet if this guy take over Modi, India’s economy will zoom to stratosphere. He knows history and geopolitics well and speaks the truth.
@@charliecheng3340 His position also illustrated willingness to learn and adapt from other's. Cooperation is always a win win.
@@charliecheng3340😂😂
He is too smart for the present government. Even the current FM, Jaishankar cannot stand up to him.
I always enjoy listening to Pravin Sawhney. He is very well informed and makes intelligent comments on the India- China relationships.
No he is not. He is a negativity ranter. He speaks the truth for sure but his ideas of how to deal with China - Idi-ots have better ideas. Also, India's strategy against China is well underway and is working:
Per Reuters:
The value of announced U.S. and European greenfield investment into India shot up by some $65 billion or 400% between 2021 and 2022, Wednesday's report said, while investment into China dropped to less than $20 billion last year, from a peak of $120 billion in 2018.
"Diversification is well underway," the research organisation said, but acknowledging: "it will take years for advanced economies to achieve the objectives behind their 'de-risking' policies," as China is so central to global supply chains.
@@bradmayer1639 Pravin speaking the truth, Indian elite policies is why majority of Indians are still so poor.....Only institutionalized intellectual slaves believe what Reuters says with no 'dialectic materialism'. Over 90% of Corp. medias are owned by few of the same people on the same team. When the BRICS uses as less USD as possible those USD investment will mean little, especially if China won't accept USD investment in the future. China has a huge internal economic because people living in China are much better off than India. The 'Chinese Reset' is going to hurt them short term but in the future they will do better. Nobody wants too much rupees because country like Russia with lots rupees can't buy anything hi-tech where Russia needs. India's elite policies only shot themselves in the foot, like in Maldives, Bhutan, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh etc...The counter de-frisking policies won't work as majority of the Global South supports China + Russia.....
Try comparing between apples and oranges is like comparing 3.7T economy with 19T economy. Lol.....a very long road to ever catch up.@@bradmayer1639
@@bradmayer1639, you forgot to add other fake news and dirty news from CNN, MSNBC, CBS, ABC, NBC, FoxNews, BBC, France 24, Associated Press, NYT, etc, etc. 😂😂 They also reported inflation in US is only 4%, Ukraine is winning the war against Russia, Russia economy tanked bcos of US economic sanctions, Chip Act crippled China technology, China stole 5G from US, and India is the next superpower; and that's why Russia asked pymts in Chinese Yuan in oil export bcos Rupee has higher exchange rate than the Yuan. 😢😢😂
India is leader in population growth, bollywood movies, cricket😂
India's population growth is stable, not booming. Africa is leader in pop growth.
@@CountingStars333 You are correct. However, India leads the world in under-nourishment. It has 220 million people undernourished. Its a world leader.
And your Pakistan is leader in terrorism. Thanks for barking.
Also as centre of excellence or hub for online scam and bank/credit card frauds of all kind, except for those love scams which championship still rest with Nigeria, lol.
The border issue is of the least importance to China as it has more than enough land it needs. And the border land in dispute are remote land of little economic value for now and for the future. India is hyping it up as a big issue when it is almost totally irrelevant to China. China is spending its resources and attention in many more important economic and development issues. India can spend all its resources squabbling about the border issue for all it wants. China does not care. Good luck to India's fantasy in the borders. But India should not push its luck too far. The land in dispute were Chinese land stolen by the Brits.
Indian foreign policy is to follow the orders of India's colonial masters.
Time to stand on your own grounds...
@@eswaribalan164 but india is standing with MacCauley's chip installed inside its skull.
American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
India is even praised by Paxtani Experts for Having INDEPENDENT FOREIGN POLICY by Importing Oil from Russia and Exporting India Made Cisco Servers to US and American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
@@eswaribalan164American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
China capabilities are very well analyzed and understood. The West, East, North and South have no choice except improving relationship with china it have risen peacefully and continue to rise. The west needs to accept this reality, as rightly said by Sir Praveen there is no need to contain China , as it won't work. Let it rise peacefully for the benefit of the developing world.
Thank you sir for taking time for this deep analysis. ❤
🇨🇳🐔👍 It is heart warming to hear from you. You are one of the few persons
in the world who chooses not to
demonise China.
👍🐔🇨🇳🌎👪🥂🐲
As a Chinese living in Australia I have associated with Indian people for many years, iNdian people are great people and friends, I hope Modi will do the right think to improve the ties with China, Mark my word, America will contain India one day for sure
When that day comes.. India will not be able to stand up to the US like China did. India will just say Yes Sir
India is beholden and in awe of western countries. It doesn't have a strong backbone
India has no real foreign policy. Jayant Bhandari hit the nail on the head. Any fool can see that the West is merely using India as a pawn in their geopolitical game. The rise of India to superpower will also be contained by the US in time to come.
Yes time for India to improve ties with China and go for it. But they fear the northern border problem, which is a fact.
America is already trying to contain India by funding Pakistan and Bangladesh
Truly a balanced, fair and truthful assessment. I think all Indians should view this to get a true perspective of where they really stand and how to move forward forward realistically instead of the usual Indian hubris spark off by western propaganda to counter China. Also more Americans who are fed daily on US propaganda and disinformation about China should view this understand the reality.
Especially palki n her worshippers.
@@medialcanthus9681😂😂Cry,The USA are The Biggest Investors and Foreign Job providers in India
@@medialcanthus9681American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
A classic example of an intelligent Indian reporting unbias truth. Respect to you sir
People like him are very less in India now
A truly rarity you are!
American Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
@@IronMan-nu3rbAmerican Companies Have Built India's World Class IT Industry and Now US companies like Apple,Cisco,Micron Semiconductors etc are Shifting Manufacturing from China to India like iPhones,Micron Chips & Cisco Servers etc The facts Are Recent Chinese Data shows Chinese Long term Growth is faltering due to Faltering Population Nd The short term growth is faltering due to Huge Debt and Sanctions and China's Nominal GDP growth has come down to 4.2%,Lowest in 48 Years
@@wisdomhighschool9975 Ok beta
India may have the largest consumer market in the world but not in terms of spending power! India's consumer market spends much much less than China's consumer market! Hence China still has the world,'s largest consumer market in monetary spending power to attract high end products and high end manufacturing!
Simple explanation..India tried to " control " its neighbourhood because it believes as the biggest country in the neighbourhood it should be the "Boss" ..which is the mindset of most Indians politicians and population....The Chinese instead offer trade..prosperity ..infrastructure ..without political interfetence and will work with any incumbent Political power ..Every nation does not want its affairs " dictated " by external countries...it is So simple yet..so difficult for India to understand...so those around India will try subtetly to distance itself from India..in case India decide to "assist" that country by placing its military there and interfere "indirectly "in their nation political process..
And now that they have the largest population they believe they are the Leader of the Global South. If this is how India acts whe they are poor it's scary to imagine how they would act if they're rich
From Geneva Switzerland 🇨🇭.
I am from Pakistan, living in Switzerland for the last 30 years .
I listened to all your videos to understand World Order China India Pakistan and the rest of the world.
Thanks for the balanced opening
Assalamualaikum sir from India. An Indian Muslim here.
Switzerland main kitne Indian Muslims hein?? Kabhi kisi se Mulakat hua he aapka?🙂 Aur wahan kitne Pakistani hein?
If only India would listen to you, Mr Pravin Sawhney.
I stumbled upon this podcast. This is mind opening analysis with facts laid bare for his audience. And he ask his audience to reflect on the facts without imposing his view.
From what is presented, obviously he has the interest for his own country India to reflect, and adjust so that it is not left "holding the baby" and going forward in the downward orbit.
Great Indian scholar and I must admit I need to understand his background and be educated on this aspect. Perhaps someone can help or point me to the right direction. Or I need to spend time digging through the internet?
Best wishes to him and his audience and India on whatever journey route or adjustment they decide to take from his scholarly thoughts.
There is something wrong with our government foreign policy need to be revisit that after the USA all our neighbouring countries starting slapping India why? Indian domestic politics should not imposed on Indian foreign policy we’re heading towards isolation! Money wouldn’t buy a respect in international relations.
In Asia we have only one friend Bangladesh and in the West France France only in for their own interest once the present French government gone maybe we will not even have the same support, supporting Israel blindly we are also losing respect in the Muslim world specially in the Middle East. One side we say we’re nonalignment but our actions tell us a different story.
The Indians "think" they're the inheritance of British empire, and would love to "inherit" the size of the British empire with it's colonies in the present world, they prove to the world by swallowing Sikkim, now make a guess, what will it's neighbors think of India? 😁😁
The Hindu fanatics govt of India conducted genocides against Muslims and openly supported the Israelies genocides in Gaza, make a guess, what's the image of India in the Islamic world?
But deffinately money is an important criteria for respect in international relations .Thats why no one champion of islam is daring to talk about the prosecution of wighur muslims in china .Not even quater and pakistan.china is the manufacturing hub of the world .They have to purchase lot of oil from arab countries as the raw metarial .According to famous saying if you have to choose between your firend and your customer then please choose customer
@@amalchakrabarti2357 you might be right for the sake of the argument but what it has got to do with my comment? Let’s open up the debate…"
@@markvelber8664 Bro there is nothing called unconditional friendship in foreign policy .usa gift 30 billion dollar to pakistan and finally Pakistan's worst possible enemy osama bin laden was found in Pakistan .Pakistanis have released osamas fanily members and associates but have not yet released from prison he doctor liable for founding out osama
Excellent unbiased analysis of the global geopolitics.
It is important that China India Pakistan join together to develop this region instead of fighting. Time to think sensibly
Correct.
Pakistani and China should hand over pakistan occupied Kashmir and aksai chin to india. So that we all can work on regional connectivity and fail West.
Xi had talked to Modi more than twenty time directly and indirectly on Pak-India-China issues which countries should settled the differences and striving towards peace and prosperity but Xi came up empty and Xi wouldn't even bother looking at Modi as if he was invisible !
@@santhugowda7179Nope...India should happily hand over Kashmir and Ladakh region to Pak and China and then all problem will be solved
@@santhugowda7179that will only happen when pigs fly.
Very good proposal.
I appreciate your honest and balanced views Mr Pravin 🙏🏼
India needs more pragmatic and critical thinking. You can't live on pride and boasting. The future is educating your youth and building infrastructure to create a better life.
In India emphasis on communal politics .
Finally a very fair and non partisan assessment of the situation at hand. Appreciate the bold and truthful narrative. Thank you.
Sure thing, most of you appreciate the pacifist and deflater under the garb of a truth crusader. All he does is state the truth and then the recommendations that he gives are super low quality. Indian government is tackling China well and the results are showing up. Here is the truth that this idi-ot does not talk about:
Per Reuters:
The value of announced U.S. and European greenfield investment into India shot up by some $65 billion or 400% between 2021 and 2022, Wednesday's report said, while investment into China dropped to less than $20 billion last year, from a peak of $120 billion in 2018.
"Diversification is well underway," the research organisation said, but acknowledging: "it will take years for advanced economies to achieve the objectives behind their 'de-risking' policies," as China is so central to global supply chains.
Wow Mr. Pravin, your analysis is the best in 2024. Straight forward facts without bias. 👍👏
The Indian foreign minister Jashankar is overrated by the Indians themselves. He is just a very good talker.. that's all lots of hot air.
JS is oversmart 🤭
Good observance...ya they hype him up
Excellent insight! Keep it up! Looking forward to your next video.
Very insightful, hope all Indians can understand this.
Except Hindutva RRS 😂😂😂😂
Jai ho RSS
Bhai we are busy with building our Ram Mandir and upcoming elections ☹️☹️☹️🥵
China Mata khi Jai
@@Indu-uw3nz2rt9i why Modiji hide under his bed 🛌 when it come to China?
India is losing its colonies, more like. India should let go of its dream of recreating the British Empire
@monipenny408 As the power of the West falls, so also the power of Indian rulers will decrease
Very clear eyed and to the point analysis of the current geopolitical situation that exists in the world today. Excellent work!
Excellent analysis as always
Excellent analysis. I always look for your talks. They are authentic and logical. Please keep posting more of them. Regards.
I am from Lebanon, yet I always have a pleasure listening and learning from you. Unfortunately though, the much closer Indian leadership seems not to be listening, and surely isn't learning.
Should your ideas be adopted by the leadership, I am sure India would embark on a path of rapid development.
Sir you have forgotten Chinese lead in nano technology.
Only sane person in india . Who is analyzing the things correctly instaed of chest thumping and false glory .. haeds off to u sir.
Your layout of the facts are fairly accurate cos I have monitoring the situation as well. Many Indians do NOT agree with your concluding remarks, from @27.54min onwards. I do agree with you.
He is not telling the truth on Maldives, India China tussle started after Manmohan Govt signed Nuke deal with USA, which BJP opposed. It was further escalated by QUAD, BECCA. Now China is using all India's neighbors to get rid friendship with USA, which India can't afford. China is using all money power to buy these small countries. Sri Lanka and Nepal have realized this game and they have now resettled relation with India. Maldives has gone too far making making personal comment. Maldives is also angry that India is supporting Israel . This channel is China paid so he talk more on GREAT CHINA.
@@nirmalbhel3231seems 3231 dude is the lonely trolling soldier
Excellent vlog thanks for your efforts and comprehensive analysis
Your analysis is excellent and based on facts, and unlike other Indian media
Analysis based on facts can only help India. Bitter truth
@@alextan4776But only if Indians are ready to accept the Truth and are Not arrogant,delusional
Excellent, fair & honest analysis. 👍👍👍
2:42 way to underscore a powerful argument!
Awesome vlog, Sir, after a very long wait.
Insightful. Hope the leaders of Global south can understand these real situationa. Thanks sir!
Excellent picture you have given on this topic. Love your vlog ❤.
There is no comparison! India must review its regional policies, and not leap into the american lap.
Awesome commentary ❤
Thank you dr. Sahni ,for your unbiased and honest analysis.
Thanks for your thoughtful analysis and explanations into such complicated geopolitical situations.
Thanks for the valuable information
Wow ! That’s a clear minded assessment about the true situation especially the strength and weakness about India China and Russia
I can predict Russia will leapfrog their global position in term of economy once their Far East picked up the development with China investment.
I personally believe BRICS will have a major change of membership after the India next election, If Modie lose , India will / should be continue to be full part of BRICS organization ,a Modie win will be isolate India from any future plan with BRICS , currently Modie is playing school yard game between EAST and WEST ! " “A man’s got to know his limitations” Clint Eastwood famous quote .playing with both side always a loser at the end !
At that moment china is not in a position to isolate china .During the last meeting between shi xin ping and joe biden our friend poo ask for a debt of 800 billion dollar to usa .usa it self is not in a very good position in financial terms and thats why now the republicans are talking about to sack 16 lakh govt employee of usa .Only india is the countrey which is investing 5 trillion dollars in the infrastructure .indian infrastructure projects are big market for chineese real estate companies amidst loss of 13 trillion dollar in home front .in short china it self cant isolate it self from india at that moment of time
sorry the second china in first line in the first line is actually india .i dont why but its actually tampering
India has been an hindrance to the BRICS. Time to change the “ I” in BRICS from India to Indonesia.
@@michaeldelisieux52522we already have a inner cl;ub within brics called ibsa .i for india.B for brazil and sa for south africa22222222222
@@michaeldelisieux5252Iran and Indonesia = BRI+ICS. The plus is for other members.
VERY LOGICALLY SPEACH . 👍
.
Yeah, Pravin is an honest Joe.
My opinion is he’d make for a cool leader not only for India but for all Asia and the world…
Pravin more likely go to the negotiation table (in an air of friendship and neighborliness) with her neighbors than to try and resolve regional issues by copying Americans tactics as Modi did in the Balakok and Ladakh stand-off or misadventures…
Modi extends himself as if he’s a God, sounds like a God, smells like a God, which is what Indians wanted and as such Indians will fall victim to the same wrath of God like Saddam did cuz Whitman don’t kid around.
Once the Chinese threat (of yellow peril) is over and done with, it will be Indians the Americans will go after next..:
.
Interestingly, the Chinese also refer Modi as an Indian god, btw, it's not a praise. 😁😁
Modi the blind, leading blind Indians, that's what makes India great. Jai hind 🤣
.
Hey ! Me Chini too.
I wonder how many proud and young wives he (Modi) have stashed away in India and how many rolls Royce’s he have hidden in his garage…
That’s how Gods operate you know.
.
.
Look, your average Indian guys are such simpletons they share their wives and their daughters with the maestro and they take deep pride in that sharing spirit…
.
Free Nagaland, Nagas are proud people and their culture is different from India.
China, Russia and US are classified as great powers, Japan France, Germany etc are major powers as Mr Pravin says. However Indian media says India is SUPERPOWER . 😂😂. Say that a thousand times and India is a superpower to all Indians 😂😂
Well said 👏 ❤
Thanks to the propaganda fed by gov and all others especially media of every kind
Not true, says wion and palki. India is real superpower🤣🤣🤣
Godi Média and Gobar minds of Castiest goons can only spew gobar
Bro yourself is saying that Germany and France is major power .If Germany and France are major power then India become automatically the super power because India spend as much for its defence budget of Germany and France combined .in 2022 official defence budget of India was 70 billion dollar .According to the sipri peace research institute the actual budget the actual budget was 83.5 billion. India do not pay its 14 lakh strong paramilitary forces through its defence budget but by its home ministry budget which is also comparable to the defence budget of Israel .May be India is not paying its 5 lakh volunteers from territorial army at regular basis but definitely pay for their equipment's .in short the real defence budget of India in 2022 was nearly 110 billion dollars in 2022.As indian armed forcess are going through major modernisation thats why the actual budget could be even more than my calculation .permanent non lapsable fund for armed forces and paramilitery forces modernisation is not less than 30 billion dollars .More than the defence budget of many european nattion
Thank you, Dr. Sawhney, for your realistic assessment of the current Indian Ocean and global situation. I hope that Mr. Modi and the Indian MEA have the intelligence to realize the challenges India is facing. Chest beating, India's fifth-largest economy is just an embarrassment. The Indian leadership must make policies to lift Indians from abject poverty and help institutions change their mindset like most of the progressive countries in the world have done to make scientific progress.
So clear and well said.
@@eswaribalan164 👍
Pakistani leaders must keep begging in imf to keep 95 percentage Sunni dailt converted in poverty.
I do not understand why pakistan beg for 3 billion dollar instead of 3 trillion dollar 😂😂😂😂😂
A lot of thanks for giving us valuable information😊
Hits all important points, well balanced and factual analysis. Thanks alot.
T.Q FOR THESE INFO.BRO. THIS IS A CHANNEL, SPEAKER OF TRUTH N FACTS.❤
Thank and appreciate for very informative and analytical presentation.
Excellent analysis and narrative!
A truly realistic comment in its entirety. India wants to create a 3rd block but is devoid of capabilities beyond its means. It does not, for reasons of discriminative policies within its border, cannot come up with tangibles like China to showcase its capabilities.
Excellent, very dispassionate well informed analysis.
You are a true scholar indeed and you are a great asset to your nation and only if your leaders
will take heed?
Excellent talk. Very informative and educating.
The data used and its analysis by Pravin Sawhney Sahib is very realistic.
Excellent analysis!
Brilliant analysis
All thevery best for Colonel Parvin
This is by far the best geopolitics channel ❤
China leaders focus on what benefits China. India's leaders must focus on either retaining or winning power.
So you say communism better than democracy
@@bvssrsguntur6338 if communism is so worst and wrong then why is china and Russia so ahead....
@@bvssrsguntur6338 Obviously. The world's biggest communist state is miles ahead of the world's biggest democracy. Can't you even see that? I won't cite the physical evidence because I know you will be offended and go off in hysteria in typical fashion.
@bvssrsguntur6338 ...
Incorruptibility, hardworking and diligence works for for any country with any ideology...
@@bvssrsguntur6338It's doesn't matter if the cat is Chinese or Indian so as long as it catches the mice.....Modi. 😂
Maldives doesn't want to be militarily occupied by India.
Simply look at Japan. They've been occupied by the American since the end of world war 2.
S.Korea is also militarily occupied be US. These are two examples. Once the American built their military bases there they will not leave.
Maldives new PM see that.
Also I'm sure Maldives sees how Muslims are being treated in India with Hindutva lurking as BJP backbone.
Hater.
Hindus doesn't have their own temples while Muslims occupied India with wakf board lands
We also know how maldivian constitution is biased for sunni muslims... U have highest per capita recruitment for ISIS in the world..it just shows how muldivian society is radicalised with islam...indians R also seeing those😊
Vote congress✋for I.N. D. I. A Alliance, save our country INDIA
@@mainhoopmchaiwalamodi2244 i prefer a chaiwala over a dynasty
I would vote chaiwalla instead of pappu Dynasty@@mainhoopmchaiwalamodi2244
Welcome back Pravin. You have lots of followers, wanting to hear your point of views. 👍👍👍👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️
Another brilliant video
I must add that my earlier comment was purely directed at your reference to the Maldives being "traditionally in India's area of influence". Other than that, I must admit that most of the remainder of your presentation is well-researched and factual, especially regarding the place of China in the global economy. While you have alluded to technological reasons for China's place in the global economy, currently and in the not-too-distant future, there are other reasons too. For example, here in New Zealand, the Chinese are increasingly more respected than Indians because the Chinese appear more sophisticated and refined than Indians, culturally and in social interaction. The air of colonial, British sophistication that some Indians exhibited in the 1970s has disappeared altogether, to be replaced by the brash conduct of such characters as your premier, Modi. This is certainly a huge reversal over the fifty or so years that I have lived in New Zealand. New Zealanders now choose to teach our children Mandarin as a foreign language at school rather than Hindi. While the New Zealand national education curriculum offers Mandarin as a school subject, it does not offer Hindi or Gujarati in spite of the fact that we have had a tiny, Gujarati-speaking minority since the 19th century.
We need more and regular videos from you sir....am fed up with media narrative of portraying as if it's all raining flowers from heaven vis a vis indian geopolitical news
Thank you. So much effort to inform and educate.
He is not telling the truth on Maldives, India China tussle started after Manmohan Govt signed Nuke deal with USA, which BJP opposed. It was further escalated by QUAD, BECCA. Now China is using all India's neighbors to get rid friendship with USA, which India can't afford. China is using all money power to buy these small countries. Sri Lanka and Nepal have realized this game and they have now resettled relation with India. Maldives has gone too far making making personal comment. Maldives is also angry that India is supporting Israel . This channel is China paid so he talk more on GREAT CHINA.
Thanks for your objective presentation. It is what it is. There will be progressive people and leaders rising up in India who have the vision to know that all countries, including India and China, will benefit if all countries adopt a win-win mentality and cooperate for mutual benefits. However, I am not optimistic about the current Indian foreign policy. Hindu Modi seems to adopt a zero-sum mentality. At every corner, he is trying to undermine BRICs. I believe this behaviour is being moulded by thousands of years of Hindu hierarchical caste systems embedded into their DNA of all Hindu. This may explain why Indians have this behaviour " Either I am your Master or I am your Servant." There is no middle path. There is no win-win partnership. Indians believe in "If you win, I will lose" mantra. Maybe this explained why Hindu Modi is insane ( or extremely jealous) when countries are better than India. It can turn into volience. Indians from the outside seem to be very emotional and highly charged human beings. It is not surprise to learn that an Indian will kill his wife if she leaves him. Not only did this killing occur just in India but Indian diaspora living abroad. Why is India such a bully towards Maldives leaders when they visited Beijing, but it is not an issue when Hindu Modi visits President Biden in the White House. The USA is my master and Maldives is my servant. Is it their DNA controlling their behaviours towards other people, or it is more complicated??
Absolute right. Respect China and their vision. Also great video.
Wonderful analysis as always!
Great n honest intellectual of india who dont shy to say the truth n dont do self deception n unnecessary claim self as great or vishwa guru n free of any hatred towards anybody so if india has unbiased n truthful knowledgeable intellectual like him then soon nothing can stop india
Mr Sawhney has an excellent understanding of realities geopolitical world. IMO he and M.K. Bhadrakumar are two commentators that more people should follow to better understand this part of the world.
Why does Mr Sawhney has less than 100,000 subscribers ? He should have at least 1 million Indian subscribers.
Understand that China is largest trading nation in the world. Therefore trading in Chinese Yuan makes sense for many nations. India is not a major trading nation and this presents an issue of what do other nations do when have Indian rupees. Rupees are a domestic currency.
Modi's India is trying to play a very complicated geopolitical game in a geopolitical landscape that is both unstable and evolving. India is trying to sit on top of a very high fence between the global north and its desire to retain its hegemony and the global south that is raising.
Sitting on a narrow fence, places a bright spotlight on India. Each side wants to see which way it is leaning. India's actions are seen by each side as being either pro or against them. THEREFORE neither side can fully TRUST India.
Yes, the US wants to sell weapons to India, BUT not its best weapons. Those only go to select allies.
Very clearly stated the facts, with good analysis.
As always great work..
Everyone knows how hollow Indian support can be. Also, India is very bossy towards small nations. No wonder they’re pulling out. Also, China is simply too attractive an ally. There is just no comparison between what can be offered by China and India.
To lose Maldives is catastrophic.
Soon Maldives country will be rich just like Singapore.
Sir . Please do a piece on the battle in Gaza & try to put it in a correct & apolitical perspective . And the challenge faced in dealing with the Lebanon factor .
AS ALWAYS BRILLIANT ANALYSIS SIR ❤
A very reasoned commentary.
First class analysis, accurate and reliable, I'm a convert to this channel.
A very sensible realistic assessment of the world trade
Mr Sahney u should make ur videos more frequently.
They r very informative.
Pravin Sh - excellent discourse. Do pls mention to ur audience about the accuracy of Baidu vs GPS and also the enhanced Huawei’s chips in the satellite’s that enables high speed data transmission from Baidu satellites down to earth stations and supercomputers - this enables China to accurately define actions faster as pictures are downloaded faster.
What a wise, man, wisdom if more people like him India than the India can be a great country
*VERY GOOD ANALYSIS*
God bless you sir
While China every day is making amazing progress, achieving real results for technology, infrastructure, improving the nation building and working hard to improve the standard of living for the people. China next door neighbor "I" on the west border is always busy with their ton of boastful hypes, self-praise on their leadership, chanting superpower, dreaming of replacing China as world manufacturing country. But with not much real achievement, progress and result. Beside they still have the gut and not ashamed to belittle and criticizing China infrastructures are built like tofu. China success must have made them very upset, jealous and frustrating that many of their media channels, no a day we don't see negative news, fake news and propaganda reports bashing and mocking China like a dog barking at the neighbor daily. But the China just ignored the dog barking noises and keep moving forward to get their business done to achieve what they aim for.
Sir kindly help us understand the impact on India due to the on going war in Middle East- Hamas-Isreal-Yemen-Lebanon-Iran and the US (west). Kindly make a video on this.
Thanks
Always insightfull
He is not telling the truth on Maldives, India China tussle started after Manmohan Govt signed Nuke deal with USA, which BJP opposed. It was further escalated by QUAD, BECCA. Now China is using all India's neighbors to get rid friendship with USA, which India can't afford. China is using all money power to buy these small countries. Sri Lanka and Nepal have realized this game and they have now resettled relation with India. Maldives has gone too far making making personal comment. Maldives is also angry that India is supporting Israel . This channel is China paid so he talk more on GREAT CHINA.
After long time@parveen sir.