Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Between Fiction and Fantasy : 10 Years of Modi Government Foreign Policy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 фев 2024
- Join Pravin Sawhney on 'Bottom Line' as he delves into the intricacies of India's foreign policy, dissecting key points from S Jaishankar's book, 'Why Bharat Matters ' The discussion spans critical aspects such as India-China relations, the rise of artificial intelligence, and the geopolitical implications of technological advancements. Sawhney provides a comprehensive analysis of the nation's military and economic power in comparison to China, shedding light on the impact of initiatives like the Belt and Road Initiative and India's 'neighborhood first' policy. With a keen eye on global geopolitics, this episode explores India's role in the Quad and the strategic assumptions surrounding its position as a premier power. Don't miss this insightful episode that navigates the complex landscape of India's foreign policy.
I'm surprised and amazed that an East Indian can look at India and China objectively and in an unbiased way. Congrats on your courage!
When you Chinese will have right to free speech in China???
he is on China payroll so he always says China is great India is bad
Now ley us hope that there is a Chinese who can look at India and China objectively and in an unbiased way, at the same high level.
@@thomaslau1214 Everybody in India wants good relations with neighbors. Lets hope border issue will be settle soon.
@@thomaslau1214 Objectively speaking , China has never see india as their rival n never look at india in any other way than unbiased .
Sir please make your vdo once a week, I have been waiting so long, I never seen any Indian who talks truth and straight. God bless you.
he's not actually that truthful, but yeah, he is much better than any Indian analyst, especially when China topic's surfacing.
@@edhiepitzHe is a paid dog of China whose job is to demoralize India as a nation.
Another Indian whom speaks the blunt truth is Jayant Bhandari.
Very sane and realistic sadly most Indian elites won't listen to his wisdom
Because Indians know better than this paid propaganda mouthpiece and Chinese troll army.
Wisdom!!! just like visionary PM JLN 😂
Wisdom? You also seem very visionary 😂
@@AMITKUMAR-bv7qmshe is Chinese not Indian
He is from the old school, Nehruvian thought. He is just anti-Modi.
If India wants to catch up with China, it must first assess its own capabilities: 1. Caste issues; 2. Racial and religious discrimination issues, excluding Muslims and Sikhs, only taking care of Hindus, and one-third of pagans are excluded; 3. There are still two thirds of the population who are illiterate, and education needs more work; 4. Corruption and bureaucracy are everywhere; 5. Land ownership and even land acquisition are a big problem; 6. There is still a lot to be improved in infrastructure, including water conservancy, electricity and sanitation. It will take at least 25 years to achieve the above problems, so we will have to wait and see.
NOT IN YOUR LIFETIME 😂🤣
Indians already think and have said that they are now a super power country. Indian skin are very thin. They boasted they are on par with China
And China won’t stand still for the next 25 years.
@@kenkarko5432To add to the areas highlighted here, the first prerequisite for change is identifying the problem correctly and accepting it. This first stage itself is nowhere in sight. Instead rubbish about 3rd largest economy in a few years is the mantra circulated and even the so called educated believe it, when the reality is over 1 Billion live on a per capita of around Rs 50k annually. This is further obscured by using laughable poverty rates and boasting how many have come out of poverty while the opposite is happening. Building temples has become the foundation for the resurgence of the nation but what are the teachings of religions and what is the reality of conduct, be it corruption, honesty, compassion, cunning, cruelty, caste, etc of the average person is never mentioned. Building a nation with some 20 percent of the population alienated is a bizarre way of progressing, but here too no one dares to bring up such subjects into the sunlight. The list is endless. In summary there is nil prospect of equal status with China this century unless China stops growing.
@@kitkat25353:49
Fantastic speech.....very well presented and very informative and knowledgeable speech. Congratulations...
This is the most outstanding speech I have heard in the last 5 years. Extremely informative. Thank you, and congratulations, Mr. Parvin Sawhney.
American here. I've watched about half of Mr Sawhney's vids...I would respectfully like to know what the hell India has been doing for the last 40 years? China and India were near peers back in the day.
Leadership frailty.
China and India aren't same. China is a Han Chinese nation state just like France is French nation state, Italy is Italian nation state, Japan is Japanese nation state, Bangladesh is Bangla nation state, Netherlands is Dutch nation states. India is a fa*ke country created out of British Indian empire on basis of two nations bogus theory. People of British Indian empire assumed Islam and hindusim are two nations in this subcontinent and hence created two countries 😅😅
India is home to dozens of nations and various civilisations illegally occupied by British and handed over to Indian empire (against their wishes of right to self determination of nation). Now you understand the difference between China and India ?
Read Ashoka Mody: India is broken.. He lays it out. There are Discussions with him on RUclips as well.
If u don't know much about India...then my advice is stay Away from Indian Right Wing people... because in their world view...India is already super power😂🤣🤣
@@shaundudley4576 Thanks
Sir to me you are a genius with your critical thinking.
India 🇮🇳 needs people like yoou in policy making for India.
In 3 years he changed narrative from disputed territory to border dispute.😝😝😝😝😂😂😂
Awesome analysis my friend. Thanks for sharing it with us. It's quite unexpected from an Indian thinker to depart from the aggressive posture that most Indians have against China's rebirth. I sincerely believe that Modi is choosing the wrong partner in his vision of a greater India. I guess he hasn't got enough whipping from the colonial powers. If he can work with his archenemies, why can't he works out some minor skirmishes with his friend? Can't he see that the West is scared of an India-China joint venture in advancing cyberspace and AI technologies together? Russia is welcoming China in this domain because in spite of its domination in this domain, he does not see China as the belligerent domination of the USA. India and Argentina wanna be western look alike democracy is undermining its own potential for really taking of. China took off with a larger population than India and with poorer economical conditions. I am struggling to understand why India would align its foreign policies with the G7. Africa, South America , Russia, Iran... largely look up to the BRI as a real asset for their transformative development, why not india? it's mind boggling to listen to most Indian podcasters smearing China using western propagandas. It's shameful, to say the least, to invest in this mentality to handicap the competition by knee capping it.
China is the most insecure and fraudulent country in the entire world. No wonder even in 21st century China is scared of giving free speech right to its own people. Why so much insecurity?? No independent media, no independent judiciary. BRI is nothing but a debt trap to control poor countries sovereignty. Xi Jinping is paranoid about everything. He is one who created Covid virus to destroy world economy.
Kissinger: To be an enemy of the US is dangerous. To be a friend of the US is fatal.
Excellent analysis. You are the only one in India who has such deep knowledge pertaining to military capabilities and other related technologies. Thank you.
DRDO is obselete ... my brother was working on a project for DRDO as contratcer .... He said that people in DRDO was very lazy .. lagging behind recent advancement and they spend most of thier time playing teen patti.
BHARAT MATA IS OBSOLETE ‼️
Please learn proper English
Absolutely bang on...
Lot of respect for honest comment ....
Thank you, Dr. Sawhney, for objectively analyzing Mr. Jaishankar's book, Why Bharat Matters. India is a big country with people of very small hearts running the show in Delhi. Indian neighbours wish Mr Modi had the intellectual capability to choose the right team for the 21st-century world. Unfortunately, Mr. Jaishanakr proved to be a small-stature man with tunnel vision and a narrow perspective that has damaged India even in its neighbourhood. The Bangladeshi want India out; the Maldives have chosen India out; the Chinese are upset with the unilateral revocation of Article 370 and 35 A, and the Pakistanis consider India a terror-sponsoring country in Baluchistan under Mr Ajit Doval's comradeship.
Mr. Jaisahnk's foreign policy blunders have cost the people of India at least a couple of trillion dollars, and two lost decades due to conflict with China. For the past fifty years, the world has not experienced such an incompetent, self-praising, and small-thinking man, Mr. Jaishankar, the foreign minister of any country, as the EAM of India, the world's most populous country with a history of 5000 years. God will bless the people of India with a statesman PM in Delhi in the coming elections. God bless India with capable people who can serve the people of India instead of leaders like Mr. Modi.
@AnnieT369: I think this can be possible only if either Pravin or the ”Great Leader” do a 180°.
@@greybeard9396 You are probably right.
Mr. Jaishnk is a small man with a small mind working for an equal small minded government and people . The entire political spectrum of India is languishing in the their past glorious Hindu glory.
@@wh4uf That's right to an extent, India is a 5000-year-old civilization, no one can deny that. However, Mr. Modi and his team have shown the worst of Indian faces.
@@zaffazad4040 Modi and his team had changed the secular nature of the Indian parliament into a Hindu fanatical system where everyone other than a Hindu do not have the right to exist in India .
You are a true Indian nationalist. Populism will not listen to you both at the public and official levels. Therefore, you will remain an outsider. But keep doing the good work. India needs you more than she needs divisive leaders like Modi,.
He's bloody good isn't he. Bless him. Always a pleasure listening to Mr Sawhney.
Modi will last only for few more years, then someone will come. This guy is on China payroll so he always says China is great India is bad
Why u mullahs have problem with modi😭
India, predominantly, a backward country. Without an argument, The BJP very openly promoted and supported the staunch Hindu mindset and caused a big dent to secular India. The extreme superstitious behaviour is encouraged in a way that pundit, prohits, pujari and hindutava based politicians appear to take a pride of their silly belief while educated and broad-minded hindu individuals and families are seen highly embarrassed. For his vibrant foreign policy and positive approach, I used to like Dr. Jay Shankar but during an interview he expressed sorry for wasting his time acquiring education (PhD) and confessed that he would have been better off studying Hanoman and Ram mythology. I seriously felt gutted and realised that all this higher education failed in carving out a civilised and sophisticated person. What a shame.
High illiteracy rate, corruption, unnecessary inclination towards Russia and clueless animosity with China are the big hurdles which will always pull India backward. Western countries look for broadminded and progressive partners. India just don't fit to that criteria.
yes India is a backward country but UN has said India pulled up 150 millions from poverty line.
@@nirmalbhel3231where exactly are those people ?. 75% of indians still defecate in the open.
亲爱的朋友，印度教至上是很可怕的思想，不讲革命，不讲团结，不讲发展是很难成为世界的一级的，是成为不了超级大国的，我是学历史文化的，纵观印度历史，印度教至上的利益分配和种姓文化只能让印度的影响力在南亚传播生存。就像你们印度国父尼赫鲁说的:“印度是不能在国际世界中扮演二等角色的，要么做一个有声有色的大国，要么销声匿迹。”包括不结盟运动当时都是想创造除了苏联和美国之外的另外一级。而现在印度却高喊印度教至上，不等于印度退出了成为超级大国的竞争吗？
What I observe at present is Modi popularity sweeping the country , not only the Modi Bhakts, even many a reasonable Indians both home and worldwide despite Modi's flaunting of outdated religious nationalism.
With a national IQ of 82 it'll take another 200-300 years to move forward.
When walking along the streets in India you need to be careful as you will step on human faeces!
Joke he is always on the roads of Kerala.😂😂😂😂
Let me summarise the entire talk on one line as per my analysis. This propaganda book is for domestic consumption only targeting domestic vote politics to show Modi as some world level leader.
But the problem is that the when you integrate your domestic consumption to your foreign policy it will eventually give you a slap 👋 on your face.
@@markvelber8664 I don't think they mind a slap on their face. they have thick skin.
Mr Pravin Sawhney, you should be an advisor to Modi's government.
he would've been fired immediately because speaking too much fact
No , do not go into the stable with your clean dhoti .
In present Indian govt, no bureaucrat is liked if they open their mouth. No advisor or cabinet ministers, only you-know-who, can speak. This has been told by a former bureaucrat Anil Swarup
ruclips.net/video/2cyaprLKGMA/видео.htmlsi=Ll-yvfU1UPMoj0Vs
Modi only likes yes men and lickers. Pravin won't last an hour with him
I think he should not get involved in that shit. The smell of it will put everyone off.
Indian foreign minister has tried to match India with china by adopting by polar Asia policy. But the hard fact is that it is merely a wishful equation. India is at least 50 years behind china in all aspects . India must consider her domestic instability while trying to match china. There are about 40 different separistic movements like khalistan ,Nagaland Kashmir etc going on in India. Modis extremist policies towards religious minorities like Muslims sikhs and Christians is making matters bad to worst. This political instability is boiling up gradually . Now as far as economics is concerned ,china successfully managed to raise almost 50% of her population above poverty line in just 2 decades. While in India there are about 30 odd families controlling entire Indian economy. The real fruits of economic prosperity has not trickled down to masses. In fact 85% Indians are under poverty line ,barely managing two times square meals . 50% of population has no toilet facility . Suicide rate among poor farmers is on the rise due to heavy interests on loans by loan sharks. Reason for Indian importance is primarily because Americans wish to use India to checkmate china. This very point was high lightened by American ambassador to India in his remarks about India being in driving seat but having America in controling seat. Those very remarks clearly indicate the stats of affairs behind indias sudden rise in her geopolitical importance. She is merely being used as a trap to lure china in some sort of military conflict . This seems unlikely but would be suicidal for India if ever happened.
Pakistani Chinese twaddle 😂😂😂😂
As myself someone from the technology domain - totally stunned by this treasure of knowledge. Pravin Saab Thank you sure. I really enjoyed every bit of this video. Ohhh my boy !!!!! what a learning that i had today !!!!!
Bro to unerstand political science and international relations you have to read some domain related book.if i have to say something about deep tech domain then i have to must read about them because i am not from core technological field
Indian think tank is mostly aspirational rather than being actually rational. While China runs on what it needs to do today with 24 hours in hand. Thats the difference! India will never be able to challenge china, and a thought of going to war if god forbid comes to fruition the economy will contract tremendously and will bring back india into its 90s era.
Nor will Uighur muslims of Xian
Muslims will always jump on any bandwagon criticizing India. You are inherently incapable of thinking rationally. This man is a hired Chinese mouthpiece. Why would so many Chinese who don’t have rights to free speech come to watch an indian you tuber? India has its own challenges like any other country and is doing well. Of course it can always do better. China is rattled by India’s stability and its economy growing faster, hence this propaganda. When will you worry about Pakistan and Muslims in the world??
India 1st Cold War chose for Soviet Union ! And now chose for USA ! Why Indians thinkers always miscalculated?
India survived and thriving becoming 5th largest economy in the world. Why trolls like you think that others cannot see through your silly comments???
@@User-w4g3i India can do much better if makes good choice ! Years 80s same GDP like china , but today only 16-20% gdp of china !
是思维方式的不同，我们一直在想办法努力创造一套属于中国的体系，而印度更多的是跟随某一方做选择@@JackRotterdam
可能这是我们最大的区别吧
24:49 you're wrong when you said China invest in Technology at the same time as Dengxiao Ping's reform policy. in fact China have been invested since the Era of Mao or even after their Independence.
The problem with India getting 5G and 6G from USA is as follows. USA does not make 5G telecom let alone 6G.
Lots of praise for China -- and I completely agree that China is a super power - and has been for many centuries. India is far behind for sure. Also agree that current BJP Govt placing a rather heavy emphasis on religion that is creating resentment in neighbors -- Maldives, Bangladesh. Even Nepal, Bhutan slipping away. The West (led by US) is also declining on a relative basis. Unfortunately, China is quite hostile to India - pressing us on the borders, opposing us on NSG membership, voting against us in the UNU Security Council - on and on. India has had weak Govt that has allowed separatists to flourish in the guise of "Secular" govt. Given this difficult scenario left by poor Congress Governance over decades, BJP has to gradually recover this sinking ship. While I agree that this should not be done at the expense of Minorities, the BJP is working hard to unify the Country and develop alliances with the West (Western companies bring the new technology - cannot depend on China for that) -- has good relations with Middle East (Islamic) Countries. It is a slow process - cannot right this sinking ship called India in a few short years - and certainly cannot look to China - given its obvious hostility towards us.
Sir
Kanthaswamy Balasubramaniam on Quora has been harping this for years now
Fantastic analysis. Thank you sir. Always enjoy your objectivity and thorough content
Muslim
I wish you would run for office in India. It desperately needs an educated and learned leadership
And for the highest office of Pakistan too.
I wish PLA Generals take over highest offices in Pakistan as your politicians are currently unable.
He would never be elected as Indians prefer to vote for politicians who make empty promises. Indians in general are not wired to recognize reality.
@@arjunverma8435 PLA Generals would also do the same for India too.
This man is a genius
Muslim
Very honest review of Geo Politics
Well said. No major powered country today in the world encourages religious nationalism.
Except for Pakistan
@@arjunverma8435Pakistani people never in history voted for religious Party to take over the country. But India has extremists Hindus Party to take over India.
@@mohammedmir777 but your brave army did rape, maim and exterminte fellow Muslims on the Easr wing.
@arjunverma8435 So Pakistan is a "major powered country"?
Modi can’t handle the truth especially if it’s inconvenient. He’s laser focused on concentrating power even at the expense of religious harmony.
Its really rare to find someone here with such a deep level of critical thinking! and analyzation. please keep making videos we need to know more from you.
For every topic, this guy will bring in China and will tell China is greatest country in the world, India is way behind.
It was tiring to listen to such a long vlog. You should have divided it into two parts. Very good analysis.
It takes half the time if you view and listen at 2.0X speed.
The BOTTOM LINE is BHARAT MATA is COMPLETELY BLOCKED on all sides ‼️ When you can’t beat them; then JOIN them 👍
And Pakistan is open from all sides. This is why it is receiving bullets and rockets from all frontiers.
Now they start serving sharaab in medressa besides exploiting young kids??? You see condition of Pukistan?? Or Muslims in general?? How long you will wish destruction for others when it is already happening in your country and community???
Ttp is best friend of pakistan army 😂😂😂😂😂
Taliban is brother of pakistan 😝😝😝😝😆😆😆😆
Iran Shia is close ally of dalit Sunni pakistan 😂😂😂😂😂
And in the last india is number 1 friend of pakistan.😂😂😂😂😂
So fortunate is pakistan and pakistani.😆😆😆😆😆😆
Thank you sir for excellent analysis.
Muslim
Indian Ocean should be renamed to Galle Ocean. Galle is a port city and historic in Sri Lanka.
Much of Indian Ocean is International Waters. So it should be renamed to Galle Ocean. Can't say about SC sea. It's call of people of those areas.
Please first pay back Chinese debts. Else name it President Xi ocean. You dont own any ports. All ports are pledged to Chinese masters.
The Indian Ocean is controlled and ruled by the Americans. The Americans have one of the biggest military nuclear base in Diego Garcia.The Indians are afraid to face this painful truth, pretending that the Americans were not there and the Indians are the sole military power in the Indian Ocean.
Brilliant post-mortem on the book. I always listen with great interest and admire you for your honesty.
Muslim
RSS is working on it as the Chinese Delegation visited Nagpur few days before. Also, RSS tried the good relation with China in 2012 ( before come in power) through Sitaram Yachuri but failed.
RSS and it's wrong Ideology is the problem of India. RSS should be Banned and it's ideology Rejected.
Now the CHINESE fully know the RSS is a FAKE 🥸 organization ‼️
RSS and it's Wrong ideology is the problem
😂😂😂Chinese will run circles around RSS.
It's not even close. Come on bro.
......for the Myanmar border issues only not much more..
. Thankyou Sir for very important analysis..
Our country's decision makers must listen you ...
🙏🙏
Thank you for sharing your analysis. It makes a lot of sense in global logistics.
Thank you Mr. Pravin for your insights.
Thanks as always 😊
professor has put up an extremely insightful analysis on Chinese state policies. very eye openimg
Gōng xǐ fā cái “Wishing you all prosperity and wealth.”) Wàn shì rú yì “May everything go well for you.”) Fú shòu shuāng quán “May you enjoy both longevity and blessing.”) Wishing you peace, happiness and luck in the new year.😊😊😊
Bravo
On 13th January 2024 modi attended a secret meeting with cds, naval chief and ajit doval. Please make a video about this.
Praveenji, pls let us know if in reality Indian land area is occupied by china post 2020 indicent. If yes, how much area - in reality.
Indian politician is no difference from EU/N.America counter parts under similar liberal democracy. Why so surprise.
Are most of India's the top tier AI talent staying put to work on domestic AI projects, or have they exited for US and other Western countries? If the latter, then can India succeed in developing domestic AI programs that can match US and PRC?
Sahney sahib please upload discussion in Hindi also so it can reach to more Hindi speakers.
With 1.75x or 1.5x best to listen the wise man
A comprehensive talk. Many Thanks.
What you telling is right but it’s right for only you. I think you know things more than Modi, Doval, and Jaishankar together as if the world leaders first talk to you and lie to the above people.
The assessment that all the three stages of industrial revolution happened in the west, is completely erroneous. To say that the Soviet Union disintegrated because it could not keep pace with the technology revolution in the west, is not only naive but grossly ignorant. The commentator should understand that Information technology can at best be a facilitator not a core technology. Soviet Union was the leader in space technology and space exploration. Soviet Union was the leader in the basic sciences.as well as in material sciences .In aeronautics and communication technologies Soviet Union was a leader. Nuclear energy was another area where Soviet Union was a leading force. In all core technologies Soviet Union was a world power. Soviet Union disintegrated because of economic reasons not technology.
Excellent coverage
Thanks for opening all layers of this complex issue.
As always, an excellent video. Very well thought through and discussed. I hope the Indian government and the majority of Indians take note and see through its own hype. Awareness can only bring greatness to India. Pravin Sawhney is a real thinker. I will try to buy his book. Very enlightening discussion.
Our netas destroyed small scale lndustry
Playing for the losing side.
Praveen backs up his observations with hard facts.
Is the govt listening to him?
BRILLIANT TALK...
Intelligent and critical analysis. As rare as the Bengal Tiger in India. Please sir make weekly videos. Otherwise your message will be lost in the sea of corruption and nationalism.
The fact that US has played a hegemonic role in East Asia since the end of WWII is anomalous and unlikely to last long. Compared with India, especially before eternal the Bhagavad Gita, the Upanishad and the Panchatantra, America is a young nation lacks of political and social experiences. After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the US was so arrogant that bragged “the end of history” theory, and made colossal geopolitical mistakes such as invading Iraq and created a political vacuum ironically for Iran.
“The end of history” is not only American hubris, but also the utmost blasphemy of God. Nietzsche declared that God is dead in the 19th century, who is a madman after all, however. And America stripped the omnipresent and omnipotent of God - time only belong to God. That history is end means time is frozen. Why does America still need God's blessing? How could God bless a blasphemous America?
Modi India starts with J Shree Ram and ends with Ram Mander in between eight hundred fifty million people barefooted half fed decanting in open.( The super power).
Please pay your debts to China, Saudi A, UAE and IMF.
First learn some English and basic maths. I bet you don’t know difference between million and billion. That’s how much they teach in medressahs.
Deep analysis. But "actors " never going to accept it
Very good very informative video
Jaishankar has flaws in his strategic thinking, I respect him in many other ways .
Very informative
Mr Sawhiney, great review …. Self deceit is a bigger illness … realistic self realization is required to progress. The FM and his book are self serving , trying to curry favour with Modi Ji and further inflating his 56 inch chest.
Modi had the opportunity to lift 300 million out of poverty … he did not. China did. In China, hardly anybody defecates in the open. in India, women go into the fields to relieve themselves as a ritual. In one movie, Akshay had this as a subject, where toilets in homes were a taboo. Contradictions abound…. Reaching for the moon on one hand, and on the other, no clean water. Trains with hundred riding on the roof …. Foot pedaled rickshaws, poor and destitute sleeping on footpaths.
Yes - dream big, plan to progress but do not be dillusional. In Hindi, there is a great saying …. Apni chadar mein raho.
relegius nationalism will do to india what it did to Pakistan in last 60 years
Both India and Pakistan are fa*ke countries based on religious nationalism and Not on ethnic nationalism unlike Europe and Bangladesh. Read my article below.
Why India and Pakistan Should Be Divided into Smaller Nation-States
India (Republic of India) didn't exist before 1947. Italy didn't exist before 1860. Turkey didn't exist before 1922, Germany didn't exist before 1871, Saudi Arabia didn't exist before 1932 and so on. Concept of Countries was invented in Europe in the 18th century. Before the invention of the concept of countries, there were only empires and kingdoms everywhere around world. Germany, France, Italy, Austria, Denmark, Poland, Switzerland, Slovenia, Netherlands, lechesiten etc were created after fall of Holy Roman empire and subsequent kingdoms in Europe.
After the fall of the Ottomans empire in 1922, many countries were created based on their nationalities.Saudi Arabia didn't exist When Prophet Muhammad was born in Mecca.Turkey was created in 1923 and Saudi Arabia was created in 1932 after the fall of Ottomans Empire in 1922. Europe and Middle East was united under various empires and kingdoms for most of the history just like India. India was the name for the region east to river Indus. It was never a country before 1947 but a region or subcontinent where various empires and kingdoms existed just like in Europe, Middle East or other parts and continents of world.
Now the question is what is nation and nationality? A nation is a society that shares a common language, culture, and history and has shared interests. For example English, German, Italian, Turkish, French, Russian, Dutch, Spanish, Arabs, Persian, Kurds, Japanese, Korean, Punjabi, kashmiri, Marathi, Bengali, Tamil, Malyalam, Thai etc are nations and a country based on single nation or nationality or where a single nationality dominates culturally, politically, in economy and military is called a nation state. Most countries in Europe or 'civilised world' are based on single nationalities and are nation states or simply called nations.
There are dozens of nations within India and Pakistan. And hence India and Pakistan are union of nations or multinational countries. Nations are Punjab, Kashmir, sindh, Baluchistan, Gujarat, Bengal, Maharashtra, Tamilnadu etc. And in modern civilised world countries are created on basis of nationality like the countries in Europe (England, France, Germany, Poland, Norway, Sweden, Croatia etc) or in Asia (Korea, Japan, China,Thailand, Philippines etc) and Bangladesh etc are countries based on nationalities.
Among the 650 major nations in the world, the nations in the union of India are one of the largest nations in the world. After Han Chinese Mandrain, Spanish, Anglo Saxons English, and Arabic
Bengali - world's 5th largest nationality
Punjabi- 10th largest nationality in world
Marathi- 13th largest nationality in world
Hindustani- 14th largest
Telugu- 15th largest nationality
Tamil- 17th largest nationality in world
Gujarati- 24th largest nationality in world
Bhojpuri- 25th largest
Kannada- 29thth largest
Malyalam- 30th largest
Oriya- 32nd largest
Maithili- 40th largest
Awadhi- 46th largest
Assamese- 65th largest
Haryanvi, Marwari, Magahi, Deccan, etc in top 100 nationalities of world.
(Hindi, Urdu are not nationalities but artificial languages developed from Hindustani language and imposed on some nations in some regions, with only few native speakers. These regions have their own nationalities and languages. Hindustani is a nationality in western Uttar pradesh with Hindustani as native language).
Republic of India was created in 1947 out of the British Indian empire on the basis of two nations bogus theory. Two nations were assumed as Islam and hindusim. But in reality, Islam and Hinduism are not nations. India and Pakistan were not created based on nationalities but on two nation (Islam Hinduism) bogus theory. Hence, these countries are based on religions. On the other hand, Bangladesh is a nation state which was created on the basis of Bangla nationality in 1971 (5th biggest nationality in world). British empire changed ownership rights in 1947
Three predominant civilisations in Republic of India, Indo Aryans, Dravidian and Sino Tibetic ( North East nations in the Republic of India) don't share anything although the first two civilisations share religion hence religion is the biggest binding force of the country followed by Military Power which is used to occupy non Hindu nations (Punjab, Kashmir, Nagaland, Mizoram, Meghalaya) with the country. Most of Hindus in Indian subcontinent prefer religion over their nationalities unlike muslims (Kashmiri, Bangla, Baluch, Sindhi, Pashto) who identify themselves with their nationalities and even support nation states like Bangladesh.
According to research, Higher ethnic or national diversity within a country negatively affects economic growth through conflict between interests of various nations or ethnicities (Don't confuse the ethnic or national diversity with the multiculturalism in west due to migration, the migrants mix with diverse society and become part of nationality of the host country and work for the interests of the dominant nationality).
High 'nationality or ethnic' Diversity correlates with low GDP per capita.
Strong democracy correlates with ethnic or national homogeneity.
Punjab and Kashmir should be a free countries based on Punjabi and Kashmiri nationalities like Bangladesh. But Hindu Punjabis, Hindu Kashmiris and Muslim Punjabi don't want to leave unions of india and Pakistan, so Punjabi Sikhs, or Kashmiri muslims can't force them to follow to support the idea of Nation-States. Hindu Punjabis, who had deserted Punjabi language in 1951 and 1961 census by declaring Hindi as their mother tongue would never support a Punjabi nation state. They support a Indian state based on the Hindu religion. Similarly, Punjabi Muslims of Pakistan dont support Punjabi nation state either. They support Pakistan state that is based on Islam religion.
Similarly, Bengali Hindus and Kashmiri Hindus don't support Bangla nation state Bangladesh and Azad Kashmir and want to live in India which is based on Hinduism. So Punjabi muslims, Punjabi Hindus, Kashmiri Hindus and Bengali Hindus are free to stay in their respective countries based on religions. But similar to Bangla Muslims of East Pakistan, who created Bangla nation state Bangladesh without Indian Bengali Hindus, Sikhs have the right to create Azad Punjab (a Punjabi nation state) without Punjabi Hindus and Punjabi Muslims (and Azad Kashmir without Kashmiri Hindus). As simple as that.
We Punjabi Sikhs have no problem living in a Punjabi Muslims or Punjabi Hindu majority Punjabi nation state but non Sikh Punjabis don't support idea of nation-state unlike modern civilised world but a state based on religion.
The Punjabi speaker population of Muslims is around 10 crore. Punjabi speaking population of Hindus is around 3 crore (Punjabi Hindus in Punjab, Himchal, Haryana, Jammu and Delhi). Punjabi speaker Sikh population is around 2 crore. Hence Sikhs would be minority if both Punjabi muslims and Hindus or either one of them come form a Punjabi nation state with us Sikhs. We Sikhs have no problem living as minority in Punjabi nation state among majority Punjabi muslims and Punjabi Hindus, But their radicals minds prefer religion over their nationality and they love to give up their Punjabi nationality and adopt Hindi and Urdu nationality in order to create a state based on their respective religions.
So when Sikhs alone form a Punjabi nation state, it would automatically be a Sikh majority Punjabi nation state called Khalistan. What's in the name? We are open to change the name and keep it Punjab instead of Khalistan and also write the word secular state in constitution because it wouldn't change anything in practice. In practice it would still be Khalistan just like India is a Hindu rashtra in practice regardless of its official name or regardless of its constitution..
The base of India and Pakistan is religious hatred and bigotry. A country should be based on nationality like Bangladesh or countries in Europe but India is based on Hinduism. Bengali Hindus should join the Bangla nation state Bangladesh under their own conditions like great autonomy, 50% reservations for Hindus in parliament and army regardless the population size of Hindu and Muslims bengalis.
But Bengali Hindus would never leave india because they support religion over bangla identity unlike bangla Muslims who prefer their national bangla identity over their religious identity and left Pakistan for the sake of bangla nation. Baluch nation been trying for the same. Europe did same. Nations in Yugoslavia did same. Catalonia in Spain and Kosov in Serbia, Kurdish in Turkey, Kashmiri Punjabi nagas and all North eastern nations in the fake union of India been trying for the same.
Contrary to rest of the world, Indian Hindus don't care about their national identity but religious identity. That's why india is poor and Backward and would always continue to do so, because it's not a nation state but a multinational state (fake union of nations) and multinational states can never prosper because they would always be busy fixing their internal problems and their whole resources and energy would be wasted to keep the fake country united rather than expending the same on prosperity. See how Bangladesh is better than india on HDI and gdp per capita since it doesn't have to waste its resources and energy on defence and fights with neighbours or on internal disputes arising due to conflicting interests of various nations in the multinational state, where majority nation or nations try to exploit and prey on the resources and interests of minority
A country is a physical form of the identity, entity, ideas, fundamental principles and represents the interests of those ideas on which it is based, established, founded or created. For example the country Germany is based on the idea of German nationality and represents the interests of the German nationality. Similarly the countries, Italy, France, Turkey, Bangladesh, etc represent the interests of the Italian, French, Turkish, Bangla and nationalities.
Saudi Arabia is an modern empire in the form of country which was established on idea of Freedom of Self Determination for Arab Tribes from Ottomans empire which was dominanted by Turkish nationals. Saud's Arabia is one part of large Arab nation and is an empire ruled by House of Saud (a noble family of 2000 most influential members) and represents the interests of the Saud family. If country Saudi Arabia gets weaker, the power of Saud family would diminish hence they lose the supremacy and all privileges. Conversly, The power and influence of Arab nationality may become stronger and a Arab nation state might be established which represents the interests of Arab nation (unlike the interests of Saud family) just like other nation states in world.
The country Pakistan that is based on Islamic idea and identity, represents the interests of the Islam religion. If Pakistan becomes weaker or disintegrates, the power of the Islam hence muslims would become weaker in the Indian subcontinent. After the disintegration of Pakistan in 1971, the power and influence of Islam and Muslims in the subcontinent decreased, however the power and influence of Bangla nationality increased and it flourished. Similarly with the disintegration of Pakistan, although the power of Islam (the interests of the idea it represents) would decrease but the power and influence of the nationalities would be unaffected. The disintegration of Pakistan wouldn't weaken the nationalities (linguistically and culturally) forming the Pakistan but only the Islamic ideas and its power. The language and culture of
Punjabi, Sindhi, kashmiri, Pashto, Baluch nationalities would get stronger, Autonomous and empowered. So a country represents the interests of the idea on which it is based. If Pakistan gets stronger and influential, Islam would get stronger and more influential but doesn't mean the idea of nationalities within country would follow suit. Rather the idea of nationalities or ethnic identities may get weaker. The society may become linguistically, culturally, more homogeneous.
The country Bangladesh that is based on Bangla nationality, represents interests of Bangla nationality. If Bangladesh gets stronger, the Bangla identity, language, culture would get stronger and florish. The islam may get weaker since the foundation of the country is nationality not religion.
The foundation of Soviet union was communism. The state represented the interests of the Communist ideology, not the interests of nationalities forming the union. When the Soviet union got weaker, the idea it represented got weaker. Communism declined worldwide but the sense of nationalism among nationalities forming the Soviet union increased and they established their independent sovereign nation states based on their nationalities.
Similarly the Republic of India whose foundation is Sanatan religion (it was created in 1947 on basis of two nation bogus theory hence on Hinduism) represents the interests of the Sanatan ideology and identity. When the country gets stronger, the idea of Santan religion and identity would get stronger. The idea of nationalities and ethnicities (their language and cultures) forming the union of India may get weaker and country may become linguistically and culturally more homogeneous.
Hence we see that country is not mere a geographical area with a government. It is the physical representation of the power of the idea on which it is based or was established. So next time when you think of serving your country, keep in mind you are serving the idea on which country is based and whose interests it represents.
@@SatpalVerma000 Pakistan is already small...India should be divided. There was Never an India...before Mughals came to the Sub continent. Only Multiple Kingdoms were present in South Asia.
I learned in business school eons ago that problem-solving began with problem identification. Deng Xiaoping unmistakably identified China's problem when he came to power after Mao's death. The communist cadres' minds were shut airtight after decades of Marxist indoctrination. Unless Deng could pry open their minds to accept learnings from the outside world, China had no future. I can see Mr. Sawhney is an Indian patriot. He earnestly wanted to pry open the minds of the Indian ruling elites. I wish him the very best.
Sir Modiji is running a teastall on a motorway or highway.
Please borrow money from IMF to import tea in your country.
You know condition of Pakistan??? Or Muslims in general??
Pakistan bhikhari nahi hai .
Pakistan is member of imf.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂😂
...so you want to be the leader of this region, eh!!
... show us the money, and what else can, do you offer? 😅😅😅😅😅
Thank you Dr Sawhney, very unbiased truth, if only India has political figures who think like you instead of clowns running the country.
Great analysis. Thanks!
Very nicely narrated topic..
Please enlighten us about India put policy of Bangladesh
Advice for India: Let go 1000 rupees, in the future get back a million rupees in return.
Really appreciate your Deep Insights.
Sir about a video on
1. Recent turmoil in Ladhak and it's implications for India given Chinese interest in the region.
2. Fate of QUAD ( which India is a member of) in view of Biden administration's recent efforts to patch relations with China.
Give any topic to Mr Sawany he will link it up with AI, Belt and road initiative.
I really appreciate his videos. I enabled RUclips notification only on his video.
Multi polar world: US, EU, Brazil, Russia, China, India, Saudi Arabia, Iran, South Africa, Australia
The 85 raids committed by US and UK Air Force against Iraqi tribes just costed $500 millions.
What I don't get is why does India hate China so much when its only a boarder dispute unless its jealousy as they are able to forgive forget what the west did to India in the past.
Sir . Its so late now for indians to understand the threat they are facing . We r divided .. very vulnerable. Hate ..poverty .. understanding of world politics. Etc .. its too late already . But best of luck.
Mr. Swamy how can I contribute to your good work?
Every time I listen to him I feel he is disillusioned. He is no expert in AI , why does he speak as if he knows .
Data keeps changing . Today you might like a certain kind of shirt , 10 years back you were liking different kind of shirt so data changed , so will model
He is your father, baniya
Excellent analysis,Notanki of Govt
The Link West started with Israel. India is providing labor, Capital as well as personnel for Israeli army. Videos have come out showing Indians soldiers fighting for Israelis in Gaza. Further India has followed the heels of US and UK in providing its naval ships in the Red Sea.
Ppl knows china has big high tech company ! But do ppl knows how china has made this companies ?? When India understands how Chinese has doen ! Than India will be a strong country !
Thank u sir for teaching me!
You are the most impressive with most truthful historic views and the world respect such useful information. Long live your podcast and God bless.
In the wake of soon to be AI/robots being mainstream labour, assembly Line managers and workers will soon be made redundant. Great Replacement ahead.
After watching both the video i understood that, everything this is just an opinion as of now, the same thing which is present as a victory of the current govt has been called a sham/blunder in here. Here it is being said that India is not powerful enough to compete with china and china is now the main superpower and the USA has become weak not as powerful as it used to be and india should work together with china. Other side believes India is not as weak to be dictated by other countries but considers to work more with usa instead of china, whose opinion comes out to be the correct one, only time will tell.
As of now i lean towards the current govt. India should work with usa but should not put it's faith completely in usa, i think this govt knows that but wants to use the situation between china and usa for its own benefit which it believes is more with usa as it will help india to be a pole in this current multipolar world but india is working with china in bricks and trying to bring an alternative for USA dollars. This govt has just chosen the fields in which it wants to work with china and Russia and in which it wants to work with the USA.
Being independent is what you want india to do but that is what the government is claiming to be doing. How well they are doing is the question? Only time will tell.
But i agree india needs to invest more in r&d, but i don't see a problem in getting latest technological knowhow from other countries, as developing indigenous technology on its own now will take time and money which India doesn't have now, same as china, only when its economy was strong enough then only it was able to invest in latest technology. And I don't believe if a state of the art technology which has strategic importance any country will agree to give it so easily. India should try to do both.
Nirvana sb. Please Hindi or Urdu ma baat kia karain. Kio Keh aik Arab sa ziada log Jo Bharat or Pakistan ma hain English ko acha sa understand nahi kar sakta.
Jub tak majority understand he nahi Kara gi to. Muamlat kasa Sahi site per la ka jain ga
With all due respect, sir, please learn English. It’s not a bad language, and by learning English you won’t be putting down other languages also…
@@sunboat800press auto translation captions to Hindi.
@@sunboat800 hamasha wo nations hi destination per pohanchti hain jinho na apni language ko permot kia ha.
Now 77 years are gone and we are still putting their leagcy.
Hope you understand my point of view
The Indian Government represents not only the over 1.4Bn Indians and counting in the country...
But Also the interests of the East and West of Asia to further reap the rewards of it's consumer population.
The Western World too is depending on India's and Indians' willingness to prioritize the interests of the West over it's own.
India's consumer population gives over $US300Bn ANNUALLY outside it's borders!
This Money would stay in India if Indians in India buy solely Indian owned goods and services.
From Toothpaste all the way to Motor vehicles. From Biscuits to Chapas. From laptops to mobile phones. From chocolate to clothing. From wrist watches to sodas.
India's world views are too simple! The world has never been unipolar, it has always been multipolar. China treats the world as a 194+ pieces chess game. Balance the pieces to achieve the best outcome for the whole of China's economy, not just their upper-class citizens.
AI is fast becoming a means to achieve mass mind control. This might work in a relatively homogeneous society like Singapore, but will never work for countries having numerous diasporas. To simply put it , AI capabilities can only be used for offensive purposes which will also have to be very human resources intensive. Also the ethical lapses that have happened will render much of the AI expenses as sunk costs with added penalties. AI is a risky bet which will only make the world more unstable as we are currently observing.
china developing anti hypersonics using ai technology