India’s Military Power Can it deter Pakistan and China? A Khanversation with Ghazala Wahab
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- This interview first appeared on Prof. Muqtedar Khan's RUclips Channel Khanversations. It is being published here with permission. This was part of the series of conversations he held with the contributors to his anthology Rise of India as a World Power. Ghazala contributed a chapter on military power.
The links to the anthology as well as her chapter are given below.
Link to the Ebook: The Rise of India as a World Power: anthologies.ne......
Link to the PDF of The Rise of India as a World Power: tinyurl.com/5f...
Ghazala Wahab's Chapter: anthologies.ne......
Ghazala Wahab's Books: www.alephbookc....
Subscribe to Force Magazine at forceindia.net...
India needs to come out of bollywood mode and start to think realistically.
Its too late for that 😅
Maybe this government falls and the new government wakes up?
We here in Pakistan keep your army on our toes but as far as Bollywood heroes are concerned, we are worried that one day Akshay Kumar will come alone and destroy our entire army.
This woman has more common sense and wisdom than most Indian leaders. As a Buddhist I must admit people of the North East does not belong to India and is not a part of India. To call Buddha Indian is insulting. Indian propaganda made Buddha INDIAN when Buddha was, is and NEVER INDIAN. ALL OF NORTH EAST should separate from India completely.
Sakyamuni Buddha lived as a teacher in ancient India for many years, so it is ok to call him Indian. Agree that India should stop its expansionist, belligerent policies and conclude peace treaties with neighbours 👍
@@gauravtejpal8901 Wasn't he born in Nepal?
Buddha is Indian. But what’s wrong with Buddha being Indian? (Asking as a Singaporean Chinese)
@@therover65 it's simply not factual
@@therover65Buddha was a Nepalese not a Indian
She is brave to say what she is saying, matching her beauty. India 🇮🇳 I respect so much as the leader of the global south has now become more and more the vassal state of the USA.
Does she is brave enough to talk about the Racist caste system that slave the Indigenous peoples and discriminates them and called them the untouchables and human trafficking them and rape there girls and used that caste as a tool? Does she is brave enough to talk about selling poor kids organs to rich tourists? Does she is brave enough to talk about here occupation to the Himalayan state and Manipur and Rajasthan and Jammu and Kashmir and Punjab and Andhra and many states that want to break from the inhumane Indian union that committed against those states atrocities genocide and slavery? Does she is brave enough to talk about here pollution and how India Is polluting the world? And what global South that you talking about which is already dumping your dollar and start using there local currency which is there right to secure there nations interests from the dollar that you are weaponizing it for your own Americans interests to commit aggression against other nation.
Sorry India is unqualified to be leader of Global South, please focus on ending poverty, hunger and starvation and development. If you can't help India's, poor how is India going to do anything for anyone????
but her knowledge is very shallow 20:01 China will not fight the land battle
what it will do is bomb India and compltely wipe out Indian infrastructure and heavey military equipment and then it will give a free hand to pakistan
once India is softened when the war begins
Most Indians think that China will roll in with their tanks and then India will kill them in a guerella kind of war with its great population greatly damaging China.
but that will not be the scenario
China will first bomb India into pulp and completely soften Indian defences and then it will send pakistan to take over India - and pakistan will willingly do that for China an occupy India and parts of Indian territory for its own gain.
It is this combination of china pakistan which is very dangerous because Pakistan will gain immensely because of this.
India did a big mistake by taking ownership of the American hegemony ... but India was stuck because much of modi's election financing came from overseas Gujju living in the USA and they wanted great relationship between India and USA for their own benefit - business lines diamond trade etc.
that is why if you see
USA did not sanction oil sales when India bought oil from Russia - USA surgically sanctioned the diamond trade business - because Modi and his finances are hurt when the gujju community based in India is hurt.
@leoxing7697
Being a leader of the global south don't mean because i have the most poverty striken children and peoples that i deserve to lead🤭it means you have to have the capability to get the poors out of poverty
@@gmanlee575 True. Actually, India has the capacity to get people out of poverty - but the intention to do so is lacking among the ruling classes...
Following the Galwan clash, China released video of Chinese soldiers trying to stop hundred of Indian soldiers advancing into Chinese territory after crossing the river and that is backed by Modi statement that " There is no intrusion by the enemy or koi gussa nahi ". Yet many Indian still view Chinese as an aggressor instead of condemning their own arrogant behavior. I guess rationality doesn't exist in some people.
It is not a lack of rationality - information in India is controlled by the government and they are suppressing this information due to their ideology
@@gauravtejpal8901Like PALKI Sharma who is with 'First Post'.
The Adani group owns both First Post and her former network WION.
@@timothychung4811 Thanks for this bit of information. I follow Plaki's reports and while I like her style, I also knew that her analysis was based on a higher political agenda. Is the Adani group controlled by the Indian Gov?
The reckless behavior of the Indian Army in 2020 is no different from the Indian Army’s "Forward Policy" in 1962. Both are crossing the line, and of course the results are the same.
What about India's involvement behind terrorism in Pakistan?? We have suffered heavy casualties of our Army forces personnel & civilians and we do know Indians have been using Afghan soil to train terrorists so if anything our response should be more intense! I don't support violence & war but India deserves to be hit for sponsoring terrorism in Pakistan!
Kashmiris are happy without Kashmiris knowing they are happy.
If that's not colonialism, what is? You cage them up for months, snap mobile connection, Internet, telephone landlines and even cable TV! And u don't let anyone hear from them. Leave alone foreign press u don't even allow your own "journalists". You snatch their rights - conditions "as your own records" suggest were for accession n yet you claim Kashmiris are happy. If so why don't you call for a referendum as the UN resolutions call for and which the honorable lady conveniently forgot to mention or was it deliberate?
INDIA TALKS WITH FORKED TONGUE DIPLOMATICALLY...... TALK STRAIGHT INDIA MIGHT GET SOMEWHERE......
And in my country, we have an informal proverb that says, "If you see and Indian and a snake, hit the Indian first before going after the snake"!🤣
Yes Jaishankar is great with minced words.
In my country too Singapore and they are proud of such quote
@@Esperalzi-Esfaral smart!
Exactly my view what the lady says! I've always argued with Indians that except in 1971 India-Pakistan War which India won decisively and led to birth of Bangladesh, India has not won any war against Pakistan in Kashmir. All India's wars in Kashmir against Pakistan ended in stalemate in which neither won all of Kashmir. The only place India won all of Kashmir against Pakistan is in its MAPS (every map published by India shows entire Kashmir including China-controlled Aksai Chin within Indian borders). Same with Pakistan, it owns all of Kashmir only in the maps. India owns only 45% od what it owns in the map while Pakistan owns 35% and China 20%😁
Drawing maps to your liking is like trying to fool your own self.
It was a very realistic discussion. We as Indians should see the reality and prepare ourselves
Wow kumar. Hard to find someone like you....
I think the discussion was very shallow and not very well researched.
20:01 China will not fight the land battle
what it will do is bomb India and compltely wipe out Indian infrastructure and heavey military equipment and then it will give a free hand to pakistan
once India is softened when the war begins
Most Indians think that China will roll in with their tanks and then India will kill them in a guerella kind of war with its great population greatly damaging China.
but that will not be the scenario
China will first bomb India into pulp and completely soften Indian defences and then it will send pakistan to take over India - and pakistan will willingly do that for China an occupy India and parts of Indian territory for its own gain.
It is this combination of china pakistan which is very dangerous because Pakistan will gain immensely because of this.
India did a big mistake by taking ownership of the American hegemony ... but India was stuck because much of modi's election financing came from overseas Gujju living in the USA and they wanted great relationship between India and USA for their own benefit - business lines diamond trade etc.
that is why if you see
USA did not sanction oil sales when India bought oil from Russia - USA surgically sanctioned the diamond trade business - because Modi and his finances are hurt when the gujju community based in India is hurt.
@@johnvalentino576 I completely agree. How do you fight in extreme mountainous range with tanks etc.
That said, once China starts, Pakistan will fight, but, on the larger scale, India will face separatist breaking India into a few new countries. They will take those advantages.
@@johnvalentino576lol you are totally clueless about modern warfare. No. You are wrong. That's how the Indian military fights war using 1960 war doctrine. You are stuck with those obsolete ideas.
@@KittyCat-qg4vd Explain your found thoughts.
Dear Media , I Am Gun Shot Wounded In A Fierce Gun Battle in Indian Kashmir On 10th September 1996AD While Serving 2 PARA BN , CO Was Col Deepak Sinha . Till Today Indian Army Denied My Battle Casualty War injury Allowances Wound Medal . This Injustices Partiality Among Indians Causes Kalisthan Kashmir Nagaland Unwilling To Stay Under India Government. This Injustice Is Much More Danger Than Pakistan Terrorism. India Will Face A Multiple Divide Soon Like USSR In 1991AD. Poor Fate. Thanks For Watching. Former Paratrooper 2 PARA BN . Tamilnaaaadu.
I am so sorry to hear this.
Yes India will definitely fragment at some point in the future due to its expansionist philosophy.
You sound as an anti Indian l doubt your story. Perhaps the army doubts as well.
FREEDOM FOR KASHMIR..........
Freedom from Kashmiris😅
Destroy Pakistan now
Ban curry 🍛😅
Except for the 1971 bangladesh liberation war, all other wars with pakistan are ended in stalemate and defeats.😂
@Red.bulldozer3 if india won all wars why pakistan has 40% of the kashmir??😂😂.....if i come into ur house and break all stuff and go back it will be very shameful for u to say i won i won i won😂😂
@@sobant4795during that time kashmir was not a part of India. Its an independent country ruled by a king called hari singh .you captured 35% of kashmir from hari singh not from India
@@DrEvil-sj3ym straighten ur facts tough guy....
The TRIBALS captured 60% from the RAJA...
At that time THERE WAS NO ISI NO CONTROL OVER TRIBALS...
The rest 40% RAJA gave ur army A WALK OVER
You took 20% back from the TRIBALS
Then came the pakistan army and
PAK ARMY WENT IN KASHMIR as deep as DARAS LEH and LADAKH...
We took POONCH
WE TOOK RAJOURI
We even TOOK AKHNOOR
It was only bcz the SUPPLY LINES WERE STRETCHED TOO THIN TOO FAST THAT MOST OF THE REGION HAD TO BE ABANDONED DUE TO WINTER...
ASK UR ARMY HAS IT EVER SEEN THE
KOTLI
MUZAFFARABAD
OR ANY OTHER CITY OF PAKISTANI SIDE OF KASHMIR🤣....
SO RELAX ....
Work for peace, that's the best guarantee of security.
Thanks for objectively analyzing the region and the challenges India faces today and in the foreseeable future.
"india a world power"? 😂😂😂
Curry power! Some of the best curry dishes from India. That's about all when it comes to India's power
Gobar power
Correction, super power.😊
India is a POO POO Power --- you can see the evidence on rail tracks and some beaches,
Pooper/Power
Very realistic and informative discussion.
Muqtedar Khan Sahab
Ghazala Wahab Sahiba
As Salam U Alaikum
Very good discussion indeed
This is the first time,that I have listened to Ms Wahab,and her
answer(s) to question(s) clearly
shows her understanding of strategic
issues and presenting them “As is”
and separating reality from fiction.
Thank you
Hartford/CT/USA
From Moscow / Moscow Oblast Russia we will kick USA out of Europe and Asia
Good analysis and a wake up call. But I doubt how many officials in current India government really understand and even buy in
Dr Pravin Sawhney Sahib is the Best 👍🙏🇮🇳👈
A very thought provoking and honest discussion. My respect to the commentators honesty. It is India’s intransigence and pig-headedness of Indian politicians that they have unilaterally decided that the whole of Kashmir and GB is not a disputed issue and not an unresolved issue of partition. If that was not the case then how come Kashmir issue is an active item on the UN agenda. Regarding discussion on India’s military prowess and threats to take over Kashmir by force is not only unrealistic but suicidal.?let’s face it , India can never force Pakistan militarily unless it chooses to ignore the nuclear response ( to the destruction of both countries) from Pakistan in the event that India tries to corner Pakistan militarily. The nuclear status of Pakistan changes the scenario completely. I am not even including the China factor yet. So , the drum beating of war and superior military capabilities of India is a myth. It behooves India to act like a major country and settle the Kashmir issue with Pakistan thru dialogue with give and take. A haughty Indian posture is not going to resolve the perennial territorial problem between India/Pakistan which will remain detrimental to both if left unresolved and simmering.
We are at a point where we do not have to be the superior power . We do not need a solution with Pakistan - we want a solution but we can live despite that .
Their is no need for give and take . Give and take requires political changes on the ground - it's unnecessary . Our strategy at this point in time should be to exact heavy punishment on Pakistan if they try to act out of line . Do we initiate a war - no , but we can destabilize Pakistan . That is enough because India is a democracy and Pakistan is not . Democracy isn't exactly great at handling military adventures but it is great in diplomatic tools and subversion . We do not need a war because we can get from Pakistan what we want without fighting a war .
She's absolutely right about Millitary preparedness.
Troubles is, BJP or Congress, no government has been competent in building up India's millitary deterence vis a vis Pak, let alone China.
International Powerplay and Weapon Lobbies directing our Politicians and Policies ever since Independence.
Pakistan and India should solve the JK problem outstanding since independence. Referendum is the only solution. Lacks of soldiers and Kashmiris killed since partition..Matter is still outstanding in United Nation.
Which planet have you been living on, india is obsessed with destroying / reclaiming Pakistan. It is india that does not want peace, it wants domination over Pakistan and muslims. It is india that has never allowed the UN resolution approved plebiscite to take place. This will not end well for india.
Terrorism from paxtan is also an issue to be looked after
No referendum.
It's like saying kick out all Palestinians and do refendrum in Palestine. Let's see who win. Same way you cannot kick out kashmiri pandits and do refendrum.
The best option is for the region peaceful negotiation with neighbors.
QUAD and Akus nothing but a paper dream.
Modi should take back the new Indiam map declared
August 2019, the source of the problem in Himalayas.
Yes the QUAD is a mecahinism for the US to make use of India.. AUKUS has thr real power. India is the weakest link in QUAD they said ..
Pravin Sir nahi hai discussion main.
India may this time around humiliate Pakistan Militarily but the cost for India, Pakistan and the whole Region in particular might b unthinkable and utterly Disastrous.
we Indians are ready for it.
India's goals and objective vis -a - vis Pakistan is not to humiliate or teach a lesson, it is to protect the integrity of the country, although we may have offensive plans but it is limited to ensure to the integrity of the country.
I hope Indians read carefully and experience with their hearts. The huge difference in the founding of China and India determines the biggest difference between India and China. Just look at the modern history of both countries and you will understand. India was colonized by Britain for more than 200 years. In 1947, Britain experienced World War II, with its strength greatly reduced and its position replaced by the United States. India took the opportunity to achieve independence through a "non violent and non cooperative" approach. In other words, India's independence has not experienced the test of blood and fire, so an independent country lacks cohesion and willpower, as well as a sense of national identity. Now let's talk about China. Since the British defeated the corrupt and incompetent Qing government in 1840, the Chinese people have been living in a state of deep suffering. Various disasters and wars followed one after another. At that time, China was very poor and backward, suffering various humiliations. Including the cession of Hong Kong and Macau, Taiwan becoming a Japanese colony, the Eight Nation Alliance burning the Old Summer Palace, and the subsequent comprehensive and brutal invasion of China by Japan. In 1931, Japan launched a full-scale invasion of China. From 1931 to 1945, the war lasted for 14 years. The Chinese military and civilians rose up to resist, fought in bloody battles for fourteen years, and suffered 30 million casualties, ultimately achieving victory. Do you know why there are so many casualties in China? There are hundreds of reasons, and I will only give an example to illustrate one of them: Chinese troops are in conflict with the Japanese army. Often, if the number of Chinese soldiers participating in the war is 100, they only have 20 to 30 firearms. The remaining soldiers did not give up resistance or surrender. They bravely fought against the Japanese machine guns and cannons with machetes, steel forks, and wooden sticks until they sacrificed. This spirit of returning to death and never retreating is the Chinese spirit. 30 million casualties! Do you think this can happen in India? For India, it is zero casualties because India's knees are soft. India will soon give up resistance. Do you know why there was the "Nanjing Massacre"? Because of the desperate resistance of the Chinese military and civilians, they will never surrender or give up. After Japan broke through Nanjing, it was first to vent its anger and secondly to scare off other Chinese soldiers and civilians who were resisting. However, the "Nanjing Massacre" not only did not deter any Chinese people, but also further stirred up the resistance of the Chinese people. The establishment of New China has gone through the test of blood and fire. Do you know why the Chinese national flag is red? That's because the establishment of New China was bought with the blood of countless Chinese ancestors, and we Chinese people will always remember it. From 1945 to 1949, during the Chinese Civil War, the Kuomintang fled to Taiwan. Originally, the Chinese people thought they could live a peaceful life they had long longed for, but in 1950, the Korean War broke out, lasting three years. The Chinese Volunteer Army successfully resisted the US northward route without air or sea control, outdated military equipment, and extremely poor logistics, at the cost of losing hundreds of thousands of brave PLA soldiers. As for the 1962 Sino Indian War, which India never forgets and feels extremely humiliated, in the eyes of us Chinese, it was not a war at all. Firstly, it only took 32 days. Secondly, from 1959 to 1961, China experienced the most difficult three years after its founding, during which many people starved to death. In 1962, India's economy far surpassed that of China. The United States, Soviet Union, and Britain both support India. At that time, India implemented a "forward policy" and used elite troops to attack China. We Chinese people really don't want to go to war. The Chinese troops who joined the war with India in 1962 were ordinary border defense forces, not regular People's Liberation Army. In China, military personnel are known as the "cutest people". There is a Chinese proverb: without a country, there is no home, and military personnel are the backbone of the country. Thank you to our brave soldiers of the People's Liberation Army who are always ready to defend the border of our motherland. No matter how India develops its military, it cannot surpass China. Whether in the past, present, or future, China can always defeat India. This is determined by the history and culture of both countries. Chinese people value the spirit of dedication and sacrifice. Do not surrender, do not yield, resist to the death, and face death as if returning on the battlefield. If Chinese soldiers surrender on the battlefield, it is a great shame, and the spirit of dying rather than yielding is deeply engraved in the bones of every Chinese person. These are all things that Indians do not possess. So, even now or in the future, India will never be able to defeat China. Now, do you think India can stand tall in the world like China? Absolutely impossible.
The Indian army is the worst of all Chinese opponents. China's War of Resistance Against Japan lasted for 14 years, China's Civil War lasted for 4 years, the Korean War lasted for 3 years, China's self-defense and counterattack against Vietnam lasted for 2 months, and China's border war against Vietnam lasted for 10 years. India's understanding of 'war' is too narrow. We Chinese believe that India has never experienced a real war. In 1962, in the eyes of the Chinese people, it was not a war, it was just an armed conflict between China and India. In 1962, a brief, just 32 day armed conflict continued India's nightmare for decades. What makes Chinese people feel funny is that a border conflict has transformed India into a "New Delhi Capital Defense War".
Ghazala knows her stuff but this ain't
complete w/out Dr. Praveen Sawhney.
Ms Ghazala Wahab what you think the military power this regional,
who went do you think did india
Patriotic Indian lady with unbiased and real analysis! Nice service for her country! Salute from Pakistan
You are a patriotic pakistani, because for you Indian's hating India is patriotism.
In a none nuclear war India will have a hard time taking on NORTH KOREA. According to Indian media India is the BEST AND #1 SUPERPOWDER!!! GOOD CURRY!!!
In the last Cabinet meeting on war I dia could not last a week in an all out war...all resources would have depleted... ...
India should not spend their precious money and tax in military any longer
She being a Muslim lady, unfortunately takes Anti Indian stand and openly supports Pakistan and PRC.
Qaum comes first
Indian army general had said before indian army is so powerful and has the ability to wallop chinostan and pakustan at one go😂
Good Khanversation!
بحثیت پاکستانی میں نے کبھی نہیں سنا کہ کسی گاؤں سے کوئ بندہ کشمیر لڑنے گیا ہو۔ سراسر بہتان ہے اور ہوائ تبصرہ بازی ہے۔ لگے رہو
Tambi Muti & his horde of snakes r howling like a wolf in preparation for war to give a feel good sentiment but in reality their balls r shaking at home.
Aatma nirbher Bharat ki to aatma rol di Apne....
Never underestimate your enemy, this will soon surpass Pakistan military; if they can reach moon, they can develop crippling cyber attack on Pakistan. Our generals will just grow crops for dubai.
@@BigBrother4Life you dont need to worry, all you need to worry about 420 khan and your ego
@@BigBrother4Lifesurpass Pakistan militarily after breaking you into two you couldn't even take Kashmir for 76 years what are you talking ABOUT
@@user-cw3kj1td2m Well, you were able to take POK?... No.
@@BigBrother4Life acha hai kehne ko
One statement that describe Tambi Muti & horde of snakes is" They do no have common sense but rather has snake sense doing the double summer Sault while wearing the silly hat to glorify their ego only
Mam,
1971, War:
To draw your attention to the Western sector, while E. Pakistan was defeated by the foolproof strategy with decisive action under the Chairmanship of the then General Sam Manekshaw MC.
He further wanted to takeaway the Western sector of Pakistan as General Yayah Khan was humiliated, and his Army was demoralized in fighting spirit with India 🇮🇳
The then PM Indira Gandhi did not sanction the further attacks on Western Sector and thus aborted the operation of #IndianArmy devised by Sam Bahadur.
Good conversation.
WHY - MAYBE I MISSED SOMETHING
Probably you missed the part where she said that india has never won a war against pak except 1971 contrary to the popular belief in india so RIP 😁😁😁 your belief.
BJP is best govt for Pakistan
Really , sounds bit Funny idea. Wisdom must prevail. Appreciate logical balanced discussion.
Very thoughtful discussion.
Brave lady
Mullahy explaining security saturation😅😅
India's military power cannot deter a mouse figuratively
India unprepared
O, Indian military power cannot deter anyone as Political & Military Leadership has no idea of Application of Military Force. We are three decades behind the world in war fighting concepts. Lazy Leadership, basically, not professional at all.
Very boring, too much talking. Just get to the bloody point.
So that statement the Tambi Muti is nothing but snake with his tambis especially the one that has Just sunk Car is not honourable but just like his senior which is a double headed snake.
India should fix first its traffic problem before talking about detering pakistan and china...
I always thought that Pravin Sawhney was an Anti Indian person masquerading as an impartial analyst. Just realized that Force magazine itself is an extremely Anti Indian organization. Ghazala's story doesn't have holes, but the whole story is itself a big hole held by a few strings of fact. Pravin always had an Indira gandhi image behind him which was removed only upon being pointed out by a pakistani journalist. So much for his neutrality. This lady also talks highly about the initial period of independence lead by Nehru again displaying her bias. Most of the analysis was amusing to say the least. Anyway India is not China which you people admire to put you behind bars. Enjoy your liberty of hating India believing it as being a realist. If India was really weak both Pakistan and China your dear friends would have broken it up long ago.
Its wrong to say that the world understands kashmir as a legitamate political problem, well Trump as president tacitly consented to Indian Military's actions against Pakistan.
Yes
This beautiful lady is very intelligent and above all she have a brave heart. ♥️
Balakot 🌴🌴🌴🌴🦅 and Abhinandan ☕️☕️☕️☕️The Tea is Fantastic 😎😎😎😁😁😁🤣🤣🤣
kya bakwas hai kahin b chawal mar dete ho
Kattorachap paxtan get one atta now 😂
The flag behind the man says it all, America's lackey.
Look at INDIAS 🇮🇳 BOSS UNITED STATES 🇺🇸 OF AMERICA
The first initiation of violence in Kashmir was brought forward in 1965 by Pakistan which altered Kashmir landscape forever resulting to further initiation of insurgency from 1989. Strategically to understand India’s war time capabilities vis a vis through the Lens of insurgency is not a perfect way to analyse. However, we cannot disagree with the ambivalence that is there in our strategic mind frame vis a vis China. And that the pacifist India was struggling internally with various political ambitions within must be one of the reasons that our external policies have always suffered in regards to China & Pakistan. In short India has to shed its ambivalence and take a firm stand on its world view vis a vis Pakistan and more to do with China. However, the dichotomy for the policy makers is to let any conflicts remain localised until the economy of India attain a certain size and proportion to manage the larger fall out.
Save your bullshit for your children.
A very dispassionate analysis by Ghazala Wahab. ❤
So you prefer lies and deceitfulness?
Now Ghazala has become desh drohi due to telling the truth
less introduction please thanks
Mr Biden has lost in afganistan as well created a stalemate in Ukraine
The US has never won a war since Iraq and in Iraq too they finally got chase out...why did India agree to be a stooge to the US..
Dr Khan: Please study again, what you call as "revocation" of Article 370. The article has NOT been revoked (it is still there, check it out), it was just made dysfunctional.
If the government can avoid the discriminate on races and religious issues, improve on the social structures, land ownership, bureaucratic practice in government agencies, eliminate corruption practices in agencies, the road in path with china will get close.
Does India plan to skip a generation by going from 4th Gen warplanes straight to 6th Gen? Also, an Indian Airforce general said India has the ability to track J-20s and did so several times, so it seems India isn't worried about China's stealth aircrafts.
India can track everything but sadly India can't track growing poverty and hunger in India.
😂😂😂😂 thanks for the comedy
the radar systems in Taiwan are manned by US contractors, the system failed to track J20s.
btw the radar systems in taiwan are for the benefit of US, not taiwan.
Haha track J20... Stealth plane can be track if they not in stealth mode.. J20 appear beside a F35 in the south China sea without a F35 knowing and Indian can track them..India dont know anything about stealth plane.. Please...
You have a point here but sadly India does not produce it. The only one aircraft that India produces is Tejas with the Russian spare parts, which may be below 03rd generation , and why don"t you listen to or read Gen. HS Panag's talk or articles, because your airforce generl's claim is bogus because China is far far ahead of India in all kind of technology and only way out for the war with China is the tunnel warfare according to him.
Mr Khan is not showing the right pictures, need to fair and honesty, missing both.
Really I suppose godi media is really balanced.
India today doesn't deter anyone, leave alone Pakistan. The reason is that the ownership of its national defense has been abdicated by the present ruling contraption. Never before in history have we been as vulnereable as we are today on our national borders.
This whole perception that all wars ended in stalemate is misleading ..Pakistan started the war and when it ran out of options other countries intervened ..This is being twisted out of context ..
A very informative discussion but be prepared for knocks on your door at 4 am in the morning.
I think she is talking about indias weakness it some how is right , but issue is who is behind this conflict , 4 conflicts in the world like Palistime vs Israel north vs south Korea West vs Middle east , India vs pakistan,
Why war is necessary is as simple is that for wealth .these 4 countries when ever war like situations they spend 10 to 20 % on their annual budget and who is exporter of weapons you will get an answer So Black rock, and rothshield their are running entire world so you will get an answer ,Don't waste your precious time on these small things.. Looking at your study, it seems that you write more about dogs and not about its owner.
All the best.
If we look into Afghanistan, NATO was fail to occupy the whole mountain area from Taliban.
Very hard for any military to land grab.
Free Nagaland,
Free Kashmir.
Very good suggestion!
A very interesting discussion.
To
Indian
For God sake ! U r dancing nation, and we love to watch u dancing.... its British who gave u the control of India n still west is supporting u. Plzz dont talk about war by default u cant fight war n u never faught. Less time is left plzzz understand stop killing Muslims in kashmir
She has my vote to be the PM of India!
Sir , Madam,
India is no longer in Quad.
Very true not acceptable to the powers that be
Honest discussion
Beautiful woman.
you need a pair of glasses 😂
Very refreshing to hear this brave, knowledgeable, and honest lady call it as it is !! Also, it seems the first time someone from india has admitted openly that the IAF and the government fabricated the lie that Abhinandan shot down an F-16 !! They even gave the poor man a gallantry award to cover up this blatant lie, that the sorry pilot has to live with rest of his life ! 😅
M’am Ghazala, Why don’t you educate the Indian masses by writing in print media, TV channels to educate the people of your country about the false sense of well-being by the Modi government. Certainly people will throw this government out or for that matter any government. Whatever you’re telling here has very poor viewership and does no good to your country. Otherwise, you’ll be marked as biased person. Thank you.
Very revealing. More such enlightned interviews needed
Why is there no credit given to the victory in Kargil
No way.
Ghazala is wrong. Pakistan has been the aggressor since 1948, 1965, Kargil, 26/11, Pulwama, Pathankot, etc etc. So if, as she says, that these were a stalemate, then Pakistan's aggressions were a failure. Capische?
Being a pakistani i would say that she is right, Practically on grounds pakistan lost only one war against india in 1971, when pak military was busy in east pakistan against rebellion. India attacked at that time.
Otherwise in all other wars pakistan was aggressor they started war first.
And they were not failures, by attacking small areas and choke points l,pakistan kept the issue alive and continues to support kashmiris in freedom fight.with such small wars.
In pakistan there is a concept that to get kashmir we have to wait till indians are so week they themselves will break like USSR.
It may take 10,20or 50years.
But as long as the ussue us alive we have chance.
@@Farooq_Tv U need to read about how Operation Gibraltar and operation grand slam of Pakistan Army in 1965 failed miserably..
Their objective was to capture akhnoor to cut off India from kashmir and capture it militarily bt couldn't achieve it. Then Indian military opened multiple fronts on LOC and Pakistan was defensive.
Learn from Israel how to achieve military objectives.
By the end of 1967 six day war.. Whole sinnai peninsula of Egypt, Golan heights of Syria and Jerusalem of Jordan was under Israeli control.
You read too much Indian news... They are totally bias
@@nishantshrivastava9674 bla bla bla - the LOC is still there; hence the stalemate.
@@Aiza45 LOC has been changed multiple times.. It's not the same as 1948.
Don't trust me or gazala.. Read by urself.
Read about Tashkent agreement after 1965 war and Shimla agreement after 1971 and find who lost most of land in these war on LOC😊
Congress spokespersons running force magazine ..
Well she is doing more Chinese PR rather than telling facts. There's no doubt that chinese money is going to force magazine. She totally denied to talked about Yangtze river clash where India gave bloody nose to Chinese. She didn't see that India is going to oceans to put pressures on Chinese.She wants that India should avoid competition with china and accept their bully nature. Actually she wants to be submissive for China🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤷♂️And Funny thing is she really believes that bankrupt Pakistan has same capabilities as per Indians in case of War with Pak🤦♂️🤦♂️🤷♂️🤣🤣
India can hold it. That is a big deal, compared to Nehru's time.
you cant tolerate any view that is opposite to yours. Have courage to leave comments and dont delete our comments. You are biased.
99.9% Indians don’t identify your channel on RUclips & 0.1% like us accidentally go through these channels.
Rarely one hears truth!!
The not-so-diplomatic statement by the USA was, "Either you are With us or *Against* us!"
Now, kindly rethink your premise and come over with the correct analysis, please.
The point stands, it is you that missed what was said.
@@Private-rm5dy
Aye, aye, Mr. Right! 😃
Calling 71 war a stalemate is childish
This video is absurd wasting time of viewers and should be deleted by youtube
What about Modi’s Chandrayaan success story
do you mean isro-success story stolen by modi from isro? beware of indians stealing from indians!
Looks like half knowledge discussion
Title is 😂😂😂😂😂😂 and so is the video😂😂😂😂😂
Maay bee promoting a pakistani narrative
Lady needs to speak better English as it’s very hard following her conversation.
Maybe not chew pan or ghotka while speaking.
S is pronounced as SH.
In English it’s very hard to comprehend.
India will probably be a Power to reckon with in the next 10 years or so.
Not even close. In ten years, your GDP might reach 6 trillion. FEED AND EDUCATE YOUR POPULATION. China built theirs for the reason the US has so many military bases around them.