Hasan Nisar said that had all Muslims left India in 1947, India would have been an advanced economy by this time. Most of these guys produce like rabbits, don't send children to good schools, live on government subsidies, and despite being the second largest majority still claim to be a minority.
But he failed to complete his job of getting every Muslim out of India. Pakistanis and Jenna did nothing in rhe freedom struggle but sat on their asses and got two free countries. It was Hindus who fought against the British and went to jail in large numbers for years to win freedom.
@user-bo8bu7jl2rwhole Pakistan and subcontinent belongs to India. Our past leaders were dumbs they must had implemented one India policy like one China policy. We should have invaded all our neighbours like China with ideology of communism. Because nehuru and Indira Gandhi were communism lover.
There is lot of half baked truth he omitted for eg he sincerely minus the Islamic 🐫 🕌 G Haadi terrorist attack on India 🇮🇳 in kasmir in on 22 September 1947 by pakistani G Haadi army and pashtun tribes. He also omitted genocide on Hindu's 🕉️ 🚩 Sikhs in Kashmir in 1989 1990 which was started around 4 or 5 years back, he also omitted the pakistani 🇵🇰 🕌 G Haadi army support of khalistani terrorist movement in 80s.
@@AnujKumar-wj3ju avoiding mentions is fine as far as there is no fake information. I have seenmany guests who self claimed many things about India which I found false. I also saw guests who gave false reference of history many times to prove their knowledge about the topic. Some also uttered illogical things about India nad Pak in over excitement.
@@NYN_000 Hiding information which is in public & present a half baked truth is as good as lieing. It's standard narrative of Pakistan so called intellectual that every thing gone south because of zia ul haq.
@@puneetmishra4726Bro, it was impossible to make Bangladesh as their province, India would become globally isolated oppressor, With tons of sanctions Which would have crushed India's economy & somewhat leftover power, As, India also don't have oil reserves like Iran or Russia to combat sanctions 😂🤣🤣 & 2ndly Bangaalis would never accept India as ruler When they got freedom from these fanatic Hjndus After huge political struggle. So, Bengaal would have become an ultra pro max 2nd Kashmir for India With much worse consequences & India didn't had enough power & resources & manpower, to manage that at all.!! It's not as easy to occupy a big country of over 10 million people, 😂 A small place like Kashmir with small population is still requiring India to put 1 million army & a lot of resources there 😂😂 So, Bangladesh woukd require 5 million+ army to control which is impossible 😂🤣 India would have even lost Kashmir & many parts & pretty much get themselves destroyed, like a suicide If they had tried to make Bangladesh a province So, You're lucky that at that time people with some brain were doing these tasks, So, they just politically influenced bangladesh with their favorable govt. in Bangladesh & Not some fanatics like you 🤣🤣
@@zahurmalik9447 hatred obsession is predominantly one way, remember N@zis hated Jews, Jews were not the ones who hated German/N@zis first. Similarly Pakistan's hatred for India came first, Indian hate to Pakistan is the retaliation.
@@MsShakirshah forget kashmir for 20 years And work on every foriegn policy that economically benefits people of Pakistan Make Pakistan business friendly country so that foriegn direct investment and come and increase your exports
Pakistan military and leadership - very well know what they are doing! IT is well planned process - They take loans after loans from anyone who can give? Transfer it to Europe/USA/canada/Australia - Year after years!! Ultimately - Poor people will pay the price and all loans!! Examples - Where all the retire Chiefs live? Where their Kids live???
I admire Mr. Zahid Hussain for describing the problems pertinent to Pakistan without comparing to India. He doesn’t suffer from ‘also in India’ syndrome. His clarity about the problems is truly admirable.
Maximum Pakistanis want shariya in their state according to pew research survey,but they are against TTP.bhai mulq me confusion ni hai pura mulq hi confused hai😛😛
It is funny that Indians are so active here commenting about Muslims wanting Shariya in Pakistan, when that is not really true, while in their country, they are establishing the extreme form of hinduism. Why are Indians wanting hindutva country?
There are diff interpretations of sharia according to diff schools of thought. Nobody wants the TTP's so called "sharia". Let's not even call it "sharia" in the first place
@Rogue_Terminator True, there are issues, but one can go by perception , or one can go by a thing called FACTS. Even in the worst time of General Zia under whom the military establishment strongly supported religious parties, they got 16% seats. Also, in the last election, ALL religious parties performed poorly. You talk of TLP, how seats did they win, TELL ME?. But the thing is when one finds faults in the "other" than probably its easier to reconcile with that ones own state has many short commings and the government is turning authoritarian...
Even as a leftist contributor in the Pakistani space, I find it astonishing that you are unable to unequivocally condemn how the encouragement of fundamentalist Islam and terrorism by Pakistan has destroyed the Kashmiri youth and the possibility of peace with India. It was a stupid foreign policy and even now the civilian leaders refuse to acknowledge it, asking for proof and such. You can find the records of ISI directing the Mumbai attacks. Be a responsible neighbor if you want to progress. Roti, kapda,padhai aur makaan are the basic needs of our populace.
Muslim leftist never speak against Islam because they know next day they will have STSJ unlike in other religion were Leftist thrive just because of bashing their own religion
You are just beating around the bush. The fundamental problem with Pakistan is that it follows Islam. It does not matter how much you treat the symptoms, all of which arise out of the base issue. And since it is not a problem that you will ever be able to solve or diminsh, you are doomed to fail miserably. Good riddance.
@@cinefile0075 Military's predominance over the civilian government is just another symptom of Islam. All the countries you mentioned where there is an apparent democracy are just in their transition phase. Islam always triumphs in the long run unless ofcourse, you escape its clutches. Let oil run out in Saudi and UAE, which works as the bulwark against their tumble. Or let European influence run out in Turkey and you will see that it won't take too long for these countries to start behaving according to their basest animal instincts.
Well, Turkiye and Malaysia, Indonesia are all Muslim. In fact, their per capita GDP exceeds India's by FAR. Even the growth rates of Bangladesh in the last years exceed that of India. Now, should one ever claim that the real reason for the low GDP per capita (per head) comes from the fact that the majority Indians are Hindu🤦🏻♂️. Context matters, something BJP IT cell trolls are blind to.
So by your logic, the recent happenings in India with places of worship, rising extremism and suppression of minority sufficient to day that the "fundamental problem with India is that it follows Hinduism"?
Sirf Kashmir ke bare mein suchane se Tera Desh kangal hogaya to 3 states ki baat kar Raha hai to soch Tera Desh ka kya hal hoga pura samnadar mein tabdil ho jayega@@gagaq-xd7cj
We thank Jinnah for his enormous (indirect) services to the purification of Bharath and its growth and development. He is a visionary leader who knows exactly how to take out the shit from Bharath. His indirect services are very much appreciated.
@@rakadus you won't believe but india will give kashmir to Pakistan if all muslim promise to go to Pakistan with Kashmir . Unfortunately it is not possible .
Thank you for the wonderful podcast with Zahid Hussain Saab! The conversation was engaging, but I was taken aback when Hussain Saab mentioned "Kashmir mein militancy theek thaa." I'm confused about what he meant by that. Is he suggesting that militancy is acceptable in Kashmir but not in Pakistan? It's important to remember that extremism, militancy, or terrorism is never justifiable, regardless of the location. Unless people change their mindset, Pakistan will keep heading towards extremism.
Yes as long as it was done by Kashmiri Muslims, not by Muslims from other regions. And Pakistan pushed Muslims from other countries as making Kashmiri Muslims a terrorist was a difficult job.
@@NewYork0110J Yes, sane minds nature and extermism comes out when it is Hindu, Kashmir or Islam, No question about it and that's why extremism will never end in Pakistan. Hatred is and will be Pakistan's downfall.
Note: when it comes to India and Kashmir no Pakistani is honest and has the balls to be honest. Liars liars and liars is how Pakistani establishment is identified in the world.😊
My God. What a soft spoken person. So devoid of malice. So erudite. Yet so hard hitting. Almost a whistle blower. So Un-Pakistani. I viewed this twice. I may do so again.
I have never come across any Pakistani who is so bluntly accepting the role of ISI. These vlogs are the primary reason why Pakistan wants to control social media
1946 pakistan banega 1947 pakistan zindabad 1970 operation searchlight 1971 bangladesh zindabad 2024 taliban ttp mission sharia 2025 khybar Pakhtunkhwa zindabad 2029 baloch liberation army 2030 balochistan zindabad 2034 sindh separatist movement 2035 sindhudesh zindabad 2040 ek tha pakistan 2050 kon tha pakistan lee jinnah did i create 5 countries or 1 whatever being jinnah i am proud that i created world jihadist factory saved india
8:46 history of supporting militancy in Afghanistan started in 1972 by ISI. Christiane faire in her book referred based on green books of pakistani army.
Well! There is nobody in Pakistan that has unbiased knowledge of history (maybe syed Muzamil, but even he doesn't have knowledge on Indology Or history of ancient Or medivil india(on medivil india his knowledge is limited) ,he just has read many books and speaks his opinions and his knowledge is limited to one or two topics in history mostly European cause that's the only one taught as history and not propaganda). U should not except pakistani to talk on these stuff, the foundation of this country was built as an inheritor of the islamic rule of india. Every indian needs to stand for himself and not accept anything from pakistani. In 1971 91k soldiers got away after raping 300k Bangladeshi women. They glorify gazni, gori etc, their values r different, we are not the same.
@@ChakraVart1Well actually he didn't talk on the same. He was trying to equate bhagat singh to hamas He was trying to justify oct 7th. It seems u r new. Also if u look at the time invested, then he just touches the sensitive topics so that, in future people would not accuse him of not covering the same.
Comment at start of video: Indian, just starting to watch this video, Indian who has faced terror attacks that originated from Pakistan. Train and bus Bomb blasts all across the country. Ahmedabad reeled and people lost lives. Security forces in swift preventive action captured bombs in Surat. All across the city!! Saw 1999 hijack at the turn of the century, filled with extreme anger and hatred. Saw the Akshardham attack first hand. Angered to the core. Relatives faced the Mumbai terror. A gory reminder that we cannot trust Pakistan. Kargil cannot be forgotten. 26/11 took up the uniform to avenge the lack of action of India against terrorism. Parliament attacks an affront to democracy where elected representatives from all over India were holding court and parliament was in session. Just starting to watch. Let’s see what Shehzad’s guest says and what the host asks in questions.
You will find some Pakistanis that admit that they adopted a militancy policy. You will find zero pakis that demonstrate any shame for what they consistently did to India. If India had done one of those things the streets would have been flooded with protests. The will and character of our people is different.
Get your history right !!! The jihadist campaign in Kashmir did not start with Zia-ul-Haq. As early as in 1950s, covert militancy campaign was started by Pakistan Army. Read about Salim Jahangir Khan, Major Asgar Ali, Abbas Ali Shah (SP of Rawalpindi police). They played prominent role in spreading militancy in those days. And in Mizoram in North East India, Pak Army armed a massive insurgency lead by MNF. So much so that Indira administration had to resort to aerial bombing to protect the trapped Govt employees from sure death. Mizo incident may have prompted Indira to decisively go for support of secession of East Pakistan. Yes, this is the event that made India immensely insecure and convinced India that it can not afford this relentless two front covert war. The contact was established with Seikh Mujib immediately after.
No doubt Zahid Hussain is one of the season security analysts of Pakistan. He can be a Top-notch advisor, it's always a treat to watch ' Past-present-Future ' national security dynamics of Pakistan through the lens of Zahid Hussian analysis!!!!!
Plz somebody show this video to kashmiri muslims who were saying that indian army is the culprit.indian army is doing this that blah blah.now a Pakistani himself is saying that who did the uprising in Kashmir in the 1980s.
Simply Brilliant.. I am a great fan of Zahid Hussain sb. Have the privilege of reading his all books.He is a true researcher and a great historian with amazing analysis.
@@Babav-xz8vutere papa hai khalistan..papa baloch log nahi hai..gilgit China ko Dede tumse naa ho payega kuch..yaad rakh khalistan banega naa toh pakistan ka Punjab bhi jayega...pagla
In 3 months time Pakistan needs to pay $6 billion dollars to IMF for previous loans. But they already thinking to barrow $6 billion in the next 3 months. How is that possible ???????
Pakistan is going to become a colony of the West or China again. They will need to fight for independence for real. No sponging off Gandhi et al this time.
Wow! This gentleman is refreshingly honest (8:47 to 17:57) I hope he is ok after saying all this! Very balanced and nuanced surmisation of the mess that Pakistan establishment has created for Masla-e-Kashmir. Need more people like in him in Pakistan. Great podcast and a good history lesson with regional geopolitics as well overall.
Zahid sb is so erudite & so very pleasing to listen to .... :) thank you once again SGS... :)) will also look up Zahid sb's other work/writings/interviews, now that SGS has facilitated this taarruf for the likes of me.
This was a great episode. I would request you to bring him back and have a much longer conversation. The best of this particular episode is that you let him talk without deflecting the core topic and giving him the freedom to take it wherever he wants to. Zahid Saab was brilliant and quick.
Pakistan ( military, state & society both) wanted TALIBAN Nizam in Afghanistan. TALIBAN now wants similar TALIBAN Nizam in Pakistan. What's the issue now 😅😅
Zahid Hussain is a decent man without a doubt. However, the Pakistani state's embrace of extremist Islam is guided by an ideology that has its origins in the Two-Nation Theory which is basically a statement of Islam's superiority over Hinduism. The Pakistani state had to devote itself to Islamic expansionism--otherwise, it would have been contrary to its very raison d'être. Even the theory of American money fueling Islamic extremism is a flawed one; Pakistan became a member of SEATO, CENTO, and other alliances to have access to American money and materiel but its focus never wavered from the prize, which was the defeat of the land of kufr--India and ultimately the global victory of Islam. Whatever else may be the shortcomings of the Pakistani elite and state--and there are many, to be sure--they have never been deficient in world-dominating ambition.
Partition was correct. But it would be better if population exchange happen properly. . India would be peaceful and developed. 14% of population. 1% in army. 2% contribution to economy. 30% in jails.
0percent Tax. 100percent subsidy, electricity theft, criminal records more than population share. This 14 percent is a burden we are carrying. This is dragging nation building otherwise we would have been developed by now if 95percent were Hindu
If such type of religion who declared war against other believers is only politics not religion..... Islam is one of them.Peace and Islam is eachother ways 😢
@@ThePakistanExperience I find your guests to be interesting however I don't like your opinions but those guests are the quality. Answering your "Kahi or guests dekho": Sure, I see a variety of podcasts & I hardly know anyone's guests. I only get to know them once they're on youtube.
Shehzad you are such a gem and beauty of your podcast is that i always learn something from your session i believe lot of young generations will learn and understand about our country l.
Kakar being an Army hack and a puppet, Bajwa asking family members of top leadership who they wanted( That blew my mind). This podcast was one of your best. Brilliant stuff.
it's not the fault of military to interfere in political decisions its the incompetency, lack of mutual consensus, and corruption of so called democratic leaders that paved the way towards intervention.😢
The uprising of Baloch against the barbarism of Pakistan army did not get the international support it deserved. Hopefully Balochistan will soon be free nation again.
Ghor aur Ghazni aaj Indian wheat ki Khairat pe zinda hain… Ahmed Shah Abdali ki koi descendent nhi bacha… Aurangzeb aur Mughal khandan wale aaj Old Delhi ke hotels mai bartan dho rhe hain Somnath temple and Ram Janmabhoomi are flourishing and fabulous ….India is going on to be the 3 rd largest economy in the world with associated development and global prominence This is the greatness of old Vedic civilisational values Loot paat doosro ka mal khane wale jyada Samay nhi chalte Waqt katil hai saheb
Running the affairs of country need a cool and calm mindset. A military mindset would always see force as the only solution to every problem. Musharraf, being a soldier, was unable to look at the roots of problem and possible solution to those problems. He used force to crush his opponents. I think a militia mind can never rule prosperously.
Not sure what you meant by that but Zia did that and killed close to 10,000 Palestinians. Pakistan's state policy has always been on a two-state solution, not on a single state.
Please make a podcast on GB's issue, historical background which is unfortunately missing in Pakistani readings, also what will be the future and fate of Gbians!
True Liberals would not accept him. He was justifying killing on oct 7th. He is socialist. His criticism to Lebralise the pakistani society is very soft. He is in bed with religious scholars(eg. Engineer ali mirza), which goes against the liberal values. Yes, u can label him to be liberal in Pakistani context but he is more centrist to the radical and liberal values (not even the extreme liberal values). Maybe his life would be in danger if he became liberal in true sense.
Excellent analysis by Mohtaram Zahid Hussain Sahib.When we expect Politicians to run the state of affairs of the country, it should also be realized that most of the politicians are self proclaimed.None of them ever studied Political science as a subject.There should be an academy having learned professors and people interested in running for elections or forming a political party should be trained here.
The present state of affairs in Pakistan shows that PARTITION OF THE COUNTRY proved to be blessings in disguise 🥸.It would have been very difficult for the undivided India to handle 700 million Muslims more than one third of the Umma.The radicals would have created havoc and majority of non-radcalised would have been silent.India would have been in a great Mess.Difficult to imagine a frightful situation the would have been 😢
This is the new Pakistan private think tank and all wishes for your channel and hardwork ahead. Hope whole Pakistan change from now with this facts and learnings
Thanks TPE for producing another master piece. Huge fan of his writing but in today's podcast I feel that he have too much to talk about and almost on all topics of Pakistan. There should be a series with separate topics of each podcasts like Kashmir, Balochistan, Afghanistan, Politicians and Army etc. Waiting for next episode ☺️
Ayub khan , zia ul haqq , musharraf and hameed gul is real indian supporter of india i appreciate all of them nawaz shareef and benazir bhutto is enemy of india agar samjh sako to samjh lo humko dushmani suit karti hai america russia china ka hathyaar bik raha hai ye hi policy hai world politics ki .
Amusing, with all the naxol, boroland, khalistan, tamil, dravidaland and dozens more separatist movements in India, indians trying to play Pakistan down in comments. instead of sorting their own issues, they are interested in other's. your provinces are having armed clashes against each other. sort your own place first.
Excellent. Your column is among the first things, I look in the daily Dawn. Excellent interview. May Almighty always bless you. 1 point sir. The incompetency of political elite creates the Power Gap that is naturally filled by the PPl with inherent power. The core problem is the incapacity of our political elite to take charge and Deliver ( My opinion only).
Pakistan destroyed itself with the Kashmir obsession. The Afgan play was just to pay bills.
Kashmir was/is just a cover story.
Jinnah was right. Thanks to him for separating this mess from India.
India would not have been this much ahead today without partition.
Hhhh love u bro, i wish our leader Abdul Ghafar khan (Bacha Khan) would have make a seperate state Pashtunistan.
Hasan Nisar said that had all Muslims left India in 1947, India would have been an advanced economy by this time. Most of these guys produce like rabbits, don't send children to good schools, live on government subsidies, and despite being the second largest majority still claim to be a minority.
But he failed to complete his job of getting every Muslim out of India. Pakistanis and Jenna did nothing in rhe freedom struggle but sat on their asses and got two free countries. It was Hindus who fought against the British and went to jail in large numbers for years to win freedom.
@@pashtoeditz1264 Yes separate Pashtun nation or re-merger with Afgh would have been best for all Pashtuns
Soon Indians would be celebrating Jinnah and Pakistan Gandhi.
Please don't forget that it was Benazir only who gave official call of Jehad against India while visiting POK .
Every Bhutto was a great danger to India and destructive of a Rational Approach in Pakistan.
@user-bo8bu7jl2rwhole Pakistan and subcontinent belongs to India. Our past leaders were dumbs they must had implemented one India policy like one China policy. We should have invaded all our neighbours like China with ideology of communism. Because nehuru and Indira Gandhi were communism lover.
Yeah I remember “Jag-Jag mo-mo han-han” from the beloved liberal icon of Pakistan, Madam Bhutto
@user-bo8bu7jl2ryou mean apart from the signed instrument of accession?
@@sdmh3In 20 years Jammu, Kashmir & Ladakh combined GDP will be more than entirety of Pakistan. Be thankful you are live overseas not in Pakistan.
He is good guest. Right on the point.
No drama, no self-claims, no false history narration like other guests.
Then what is the solution, my friend
@@MsShakirshahmedia people can't give solutions
There is lot of half baked truth he omitted for eg he sincerely minus the Islamic 🐫 🕌 G Haadi terrorist attack on India 🇮🇳 in kasmir in on 22 September 1947 by pakistani G Haadi army and pashtun tribes. He also omitted genocide on Hindu's 🕉️ 🚩 Sikhs in Kashmir in 1989 1990 which was started around 4 or 5 years back, he also omitted the pakistani 🇵🇰 🕌 G Haadi army support of khalistani terrorist movement in 80s.
@@AnujKumar-wj3ju avoiding mentions is fine as far as there is no fake information.
I have seenmany guests who self claimed many things about India which I found false.
I also saw guests who gave false reference of history many times to prove their knowledge about the topic.
Some also uttered illogical things about India nad Pak in over excitement.
@@NYN_000 Hiding information which is in public & present a half baked truth is as good as lieing. It's standard narrative of Pakistan so called intellectual that every thing gone south because of zia ul haq.
Pakistan’s India hatred and its obsession with hurting India has truly destroyed the country. Almost to the point of no recovery…
Hatred obsession has always been two way. Keep in mind; the AKHND BHARAT concept
@@zahurmalik9447 If India really wanted "Akhand Bharat", Bangladesh would have been made a province of the Republic of India.
@@puneetmishra4726bhai inko itna samjh me aa jata to fir bat hi kya thi
@@puneetmishra4726Bro, it was impossible to make Bangladesh as their province,
India would become globally isolated oppressor,
With tons of sanctions
Which would have crushed India's economy & somewhat leftover power,
As,
India also don't have oil reserves like Iran or Russia to combat sanctions 😂🤣🤣
&
2ndly Bangaalis would never accept India as ruler
When they got freedom from these fanatic Hjndus
After huge political struggle.
So,
Bengaal would have become an ultra pro max 2nd Kashmir for India
With much worse consequences
& India didn't had enough power & resources & manpower, to manage that at all.!!
It's not as easy to occupy a big country of over 10 million people, 😂
A small place like Kashmir with small population is still requiring India to put 1 million army & a lot of resources there 😂😂
So, Bangladesh woukd require 5 million+ army to control which is impossible 😂🤣
India would have even lost Kashmir & many parts & pretty much get themselves destroyed, like a suicide
If they had tried to make Bangladesh a province
So,
You're lucky that at that time people with some brain were doing these tasks,
So, they just politically influenced bangladesh with their favorable govt. in Bangladesh
&
Not some fanatics like you 🤣🤣
@@zahurmalik9447 hatred obsession is predominantly one way, remember N@zis hated Jews, Jews were not the ones who hated German/N@zis first.
Similarly Pakistan's hatred for India came first, Indian hate to Pakistan is the retaliation.
The tragedy is that Pakistan military and leadership is not realizing their mistakes, even now .
Tell us the solution
@@MsShakirshah forget kashmir for 20 years
And work on every foriegn policy that economically benefits people of Pakistan
Make Pakistan business friendly country so that foriegn direct investment and come and increase your exports
@@Anonymous-px9wk so true my friend
impossible, everything is haram under madrasastan@@Anonymous-px9wk
Pakistan military and leadership - very well know what they are doing! IT is well planned process - They take loans after loans from anyone who can give? Transfer it to Europe/USA/canada/Australia - Year after years!! Ultimately - Poor people will pay the price and all loans!! Examples - Where all the retire Chiefs live? Where their Kids live???
I admire Mr. Zahid Hussain for describing the problems pertinent to Pakistan without comparing to India. He doesn’t suffer from ‘also in India’ syndrome. His clarity about the problems is truly admirable.
Maximum Pakistanis want shariya in their state according to pew research survey,but they are against TTP.bhai mulq me confusion ni hai pura mulq hi confused hai😛😛
It all depends on what you understand by these labels.
It is funny that Indians are so active here commenting about Muslims wanting Shariya in Pakistan, when that is not really true, while in their country, they are establishing the extreme form of hinduism. Why are Indians wanting hindutva country?
There are diff interpretations of sharia according to diff schools of thought. Nobody wants the TTP's so called "sharia". Let's not even call it "sharia" in the first place
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s No you just lack basic knowledge of pakistani culture and the vision and interpretation of Islam majority subscribe to.
@Rogue_Terminator
True, there are issues, but
one can go by perception , or one can go by a thing called FACTS. Even in the worst time of General Zia under whom the military establishment strongly supported religious parties, they got 16% seats. Also, in the last election, ALL religious parties performed poorly. You talk of TLP, how seats did they win, TELL ME?. But the thing is when one finds faults in the "other" than probably its easier to reconcile with that ones own state has many short commings and the government is turning authoritarian...
Even as a leftist contributor in the Pakistani space, I find it astonishing that you are unable to unequivocally condemn how the encouragement of fundamentalist Islam and terrorism by Pakistan has destroyed the Kashmiri youth and the possibility of peace with India. It was a stupid foreign policy and even now the civilian leaders refuse to acknowledge it, asking for proof and such. You can find the records of ISI directing the Mumbai attacks. Be a responsible neighbor if you want to progress. Roti, kapda,padhai aur makaan are the basic needs of our populace.
Dear Leftists all over the world work hand in glove with Islamists 😊
Muslim leftist never speak against Islam because they know next day they will have STSJ unlike in other religion were Leftist thrive just because of bashing their own religion
All leftist world over are hand in glove with Islamists they have a strong eco system. 😊
There is peace at the LoC, i reckon.
Infact, that's possibly the most uneventful of your borders at present.
Logic stops working west of Wagah border.
You are just beating around the bush. The fundamental problem with Pakistan is that it follows Islam. It does not matter how much you treat the symptoms, all of which arise out of the base issue. And since it is not a problem that you will ever be able to solve or diminsh, you are doomed to fail miserably. Good riddance.
@@cinefile0075 Military's predominance over the civilian government is just another symptom of Islam. All the countries you mentioned where there is an apparent democracy are just in their transition phase. Islam always triumphs in the long run unless ofcourse, you escape its clutches. Let oil run out in Saudi and UAE, which works as the bulwark against their tumble. Or let European influence run out in Turkey and you will see that it won't take too long for these countries to start behaving according to their basest animal instincts.
@@cinefile0075how is India a " flawed" democracy?
Well, Turkiye and Malaysia, Indonesia are all Muslim. In fact, their per capita GDP exceeds India's by FAR. Even the growth rates of Bangladesh in the last years exceed that of India. Now, should one ever claim that the real reason for the low GDP per capita (per head) comes from the fact that the majority Indians are Hindu🤦🏻♂️. Context matters, something BJP IT cell trolls are blind to.
So by your logic, the recent happenings in India with places of worship, rising extremism and suppression of minority sufficient to day that the "fundamental problem with India is that it follows Hinduism"?
@@user-rh5jp2sh4snot talking about GDP but politics
Very informative, The awaited person finally came.Thanks TPE
❤️
@@ThePakistanExperiencehave a video on Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil freedom
Sirf Kashmir ke bare mein suchane se Tera Desh kangal hogaya to 3 states ki baat kar Raha hai to soch Tera Desh ka kya hal hoga pura samnadar mein tabdil ho jayega@@gagaq-xd7cj
@@gagaq-xd7cj if you want a video on non existing movements don't you think 'ummah ka chummah' should be his first priority?
We thank Jinnah for his enormous (indirect) services to the purification of Bharath and its growth and development.
He is a visionary leader who knows exactly how to take out the shit from Bharath.
His indirect services are very much appreciated.
Are you waiting for another Jinnah?
@@rakadus you won't believe but india will give kashmir to Pakistan if all muslim promise to go to Pakistan with Kashmir . Unfortunately it is not possible .
Then kindly learn from jinnah and leave the shit kashmir as well😂
@@sudhanshu7115😂😂😂😂😂😂 cry more, they ain’t going anywhere
Thank you for the wonderful podcast with Zahid Hussain Saab! The conversation was engaging, but I was taken aback when Hussain Saab mentioned "Kashmir mein militancy theek thaa." I'm confused about what he meant by that. Is he suggesting that militancy is acceptable in Kashmir but not in Pakistan? It's important to remember that extremism, militancy, or terrorism is never justifiable, regardless of the location. Unless people change their mindset, Pakistan will keep heading towards extremism.
Hate still find space in sane looking minds
Yes as long as it was done by Kashmiri Muslims, not by Muslims from other regions. And Pakistan pushed Muslims from other countries as making Kashmiri Muslims a terrorist was a difficult job.
@@NewYork0110J Yes, sane minds nature and extermism comes out when it is Hindu, Kashmir or Islam, No question about it and that's why extremism will never end in Pakistan. Hatred is and will be Pakistan's downfall.
Note: when it comes to India and Kashmir no Pakistani is honest and has the balls to be honest.
Liars liars and liars is how Pakistani establishment is identified in the world.😊
My God.
What a soft spoken person. So devoid of malice. So erudite. Yet so hard hitting. Almost a whistle blower.
So Un-Pakistani.
I viewed this twice. I may do so again.
I have never come across any Pakistani who is so bluntly accepting the role of ISI. These vlogs are the primary reason why Pakistan wants to control social media
1946 pakistan banega
1947 pakistan zindabad
1970 operation searchlight
1971 bangladesh zindabad
2024 taliban ttp mission sharia
2025 khybar Pakhtunkhwa zindabad
2029 baloch liberation army
2030 balochistan zindabad
2034 sindh separatist movement
2035 sindhudesh zindabad
2040 ek tha pakistan
2050 kon tha pakistan
lee jinnah
did i create 5 countries or 1
whatever being jinnah i am proud that i created world jihadist factory saved india
Am Nepali Hindu I stand with Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil
abdul aata mila kya😢
@@Babav-xz8vu aata mila kya
@@Babav-xz8vuAbdul ammi ka halala mutah misyar hua ???
@@Babav-xz8vuthen you are standing alone 😂
17:00 adrian levy's book on ISI details how ISI made money from drug trade. Drug trade was also done inside Pakistan with disastrous consequences.
That is done through Dawood Ibrahim.
You've brought another favourite person to the program.
His book No win war is one of my favourites.
❤️
8:46 history of supporting militancy in Afghanistan started in 1972 by ISI. Christiane faire in her book referred based on green books of pakistani army.
I feel humbled listening to these sane, knowledgeable amd thought provoking voices.
Great going Shehzad bhai
❤️
Could have talked on kasmiri Hindu too
Hah lol you must be new here
Well! There is nobody in Pakistan that has unbiased knowledge of history (maybe syed Muzamil, but even he doesn't have knowledge on Indology Or history of ancient Or medivil india(on medivil india his knowledge is limited) ,he just has read many books and speaks his opinions and his knowledge is limited to one or two topics in history mostly European cause that's the only one taught as history and not propaganda).
U should not except pakistani to talk on these stuff, the foundation of this country was built as an inheritor of the islamic rule of india.
Every indian needs to stand for himself and not accept anything from pakistani.
In 1971 91k soldiers got away after raping 300k Bangladeshi women.
They glorify gazni, gori etc, their values r different, we are not the same.
@@ChakraVart1Well actually he didn't talk on the same.
He was trying to equate bhagat singh to hamas
He was trying to justify oct 7th.
It seems u r new.
Also if u look at the time invested, then he just touches the sensitive topics so that, in future people would not accuse him of not covering the same.
Comment at start of video:
Indian, just starting to watch this video, Indian who has faced terror attacks that originated from Pakistan. Train and bus Bomb blasts all across the country. Ahmedabad reeled and people lost lives. Security forces in swift preventive action captured bombs in Surat. All across the city!! Saw 1999 hijack at the turn of the century, filled with extreme anger and hatred. Saw the Akshardham attack first hand. Angered to the core. Relatives faced the Mumbai terror. A gory reminder that we cannot trust Pakistan. Kargil cannot be forgotten. 26/11 took up the uniform to avenge the lack of action of India against terrorism. Parliament attacks an affront to democracy where elected representatives from all over India were holding court and parliament was in session.
Just starting to watch. Let’s see what Shehzad’s guest says and what the host asks in questions.
You will find some Pakistanis that admit that they adopted a militancy policy. You will find zero pakis that demonstrate any shame for what they consistently did to India. If India had done one of those things the streets would have been flooded with protests. The will and character of our people is different.
Gazab ka stolkholm syndrome hai inn desi converts mein
Humara sabse ghatiya stock convert hua : Lalachi + Darpok
@@DonzaiNoHana correct
@@DonzaiNoHana hoor ka lalach aur qayamat ka darr🤣
@@KKPR533 Aur upper caste se chhid
Militancy policy failate failate Pakistan ka " Moye Moye " ho gaya 😂😂😂
1947 Pakistan
2047 Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil
@@Modi-oy1gl tumhare khwab me .. dekhte raho
@@Modi-oy1gl 1971 Bangladesh
1950 Balochistan, South Afghanistan,Shindustan, Khalistan 😂😂🎉 moye moye
Manipur is located in Pakistan
China occupied land part of Arunachal, Ladakh from Pakistan 😄😄
When you only have optimism on your side and you don't let it go. Number of times the bravest people don't have the 'look'. More power to him and you.
🙌
Wonderful discussion. Refreshing to see the honest & straight forward commentary. Great guest.
Get your history right !!! The jihadist campaign in Kashmir did not start with Zia-ul-Haq. As early as in 1950s, covert militancy campaign was started by Pakistan Army. Read about Salim Jahangir Khan, Major Asgar Ali, Abbas Ali Shah (SP of Rawalpindi police). They played prominent role in spreading militancy in those days. And in Mizoram in North East India, Pak Army armed a massive insurgency lead by MNF. So much so that Indira administration had to resort to aerial bombing to protect the trapped Govt employees from sure death. Mizo incident may have prompted Indira to decisively go for support of secession of East Pakistan. Yes, this is the event that made India immensely insecure and convinced India that it can not afford this relentless two front covert war. The contact was established with Seikh Mujib immediately after.
This was such an amazing podcast!! Shehzad you're a gem for bringing the best guests!!! ❤
❤️
Thank you very much Shehzad for having Zahid Sb in !!!
One of the ace journalists of Pakistan!
More & More Power To You Sir !!!
✊️👊🤛🤜
🙌
What an analysis and interview! Simply wow!
🙌
No doubt Zahid Hussain is one of the season security analysts of Pakistan. He can be a Top-notch advisor, it's always a treat to watch ' Past-present-Future ' national security dynamics of Pakistan through the lens of Zahid Hussian analysis!!!!!
Zahid Hussain is a well articulated person.
Plz somebody show this video to kashmiri muslims who were saying that indian army is the culprit.indian army is doing this that blah blah.now a Pakistani himself is saying that who did the uprising in Kashmir in the 1980s.
Simply Brilliant.. I am a great fan of Zahid Hussain sb. Have the privilege of reading his all books.He is a true researcher and a great historian with amazing analysis.
🙌
IMF is going to say Hiiii in 3 Months to Pakistan 🇵🇰
Khalistan Jindabad
@@Babav-xz8vu: Pehle aatey ki soch.
@@Babav-xz8vutere papa hai khalistan..papa baloch log nahi hai..gilgit China ko Dede tumse naa ho payega kuch..yaad rakh khalistan banega naa toh pakistan ka Punjab bhi jayega...pagla
In 3 months time Pakistan needs to pay $6 billion dollars to IMF for previous loans. But they already thinking to barrow $6 billion in the next 3 months.
How is that possible ???????
Pakistan is going to become a colony of the West or China again. They will need to fight for independence for real. No sponging off Gandhi et al this time.
Gonna re-read scorpions tail after listening to this podcast!
Thankyou shezad for yet another banger, also god save my exam tomorrow
❤️
Wow! This gentleman is refreshingly honest (8:47 to 17:57) I hope he is ok after saying all this! Very balanced and nuanced surmisation of the mess that Pakistan establishment has created for Masla-e-Kashmir. Need more people like in him in Pakistan. Great podcast and a good history lesson with regional geopolitics as well overall.
I am fond of his columns in Dawn. Listening to him is enlightenment.
Zahid sb is so erudite & so very pleasing to listen to .... :)
thank you once again SGS... :))
will also look up Zahid sb's other work/writings/interviews, now that SGS has facilitated this taarruf for the likes of me.
🙌
Truly Explosive 🧨✨🌟 Please take Care 🇮🇳🇮🇳💖
Zahid Saab ❤
Very grounded ,well informed and a humble guest !
Kashmir मांगेंगे तो पूरा Pakistan ले लेंगे 🇮🇳🇮🇳
पाकिस्तान लेंगे लेकिन जिहादी कौम के बगैर लेंगे...
koi jarrurat nai hai bikhari mulk lena ke. ya kaho kashmir mangoge to 5 tumara tukda kar dega
@@sachindhoni2095Jihadi kaum ke aadmiyo ka narsanhar karenge aur baakiyon ko apna Gulam banayenge 😂
Khalistan Jindabad
@@Modi-oy1gl 4 chavani ghoda te khalistan loda te
This was a great episode. I would request you to bring him back and have a much longer conversation. The best of this particular episode is that you let him talk without deflecting the core topic and giving him the freedom to take it wherever he wants to. Zahid Saab was brilliant and quick.
🙌
Every country has an army. But pak army has a country . It summerize everything .😂
Pakistan ( military, state & society both) wanted TALIBAN Nizam in Afghanistan.
TALIBAN now wants similar TALIBAN Nizam in Pakistan.
What's the issue now 😅😅
Always a pleasure to listen to Zahid Hussain saab, such great researcher and acedemic gaint
100%
But majority still believe in Gazwa e hind
Pakistan politicians always act as duffer, now the new PM have put kashmir & Palestine together merely to please local audience.
Demicracy in Pakistan is helpless only due to lack of sincerity and presence of slefishness in power corrdor
I'm watching it again. It's a brilliant show as usual. An eye-opening conversation. Thank you ❤
❤️
Bhoot acha laga. Such objective brave people r also avl in Pakistan
We are were in NSF 1969 .1977 . While Dr Rashid Hassan Khan.
Our best journalist and political analyst.
You continue to discuss difficult topics and bring to fore a conversation that’s never been had before. Great Podcast bud. 👏🏽
🙌
Very insightful discussion. ❤
❤️
Zahid Hussain is a decent man without a doubt. However, the Pakistani state's embrace of extremist Islam is guided by an ideology that has its origins in the Two-Nation Theory which is basically a statement of Islam's superiority over Hinduism. The Pakistani state had to devote itself to Islamic expansionism--otherwise, it would have been contrary to its very raison d'être. Even the theory of American money fueling Islamic extremism is a flawed one; Pakistan became a member of SEATO, CENTO, and other alliances to have access to American money and materiel but its focus never wavered from the prize, which was the defeat of the land of kufr--India and ultimately the global victory of Islam. Whatever else may be the shortcomings of the Pakistani elite and state--and there are many, to be sure--they have never been deficient in world-dominating ambition.
In pre-independence British India, Muslims leagues had Muslim Guards promoting that.
Zahid Hussain sahib Haq baat krne pe apko Salam paish krte hy
Partition was correct. But it would be better if population exchange happen properly. . India would be peaceful and developed. 14% of population. 1% in army. 2% contribution to economy. 30% in jails.
0percent Tax. 100percent subsidy, electricity theft, criminal records more than population share. This 14 percent is a burden we are carrying. This is dragging nation building otherwise we would have been developed by now if 95percent were Hindu
If such type of religion who declared war against other believers is only politics not religion..... Islam is one of them.Peace and Islam is eachother ways 😢
Zahid Hussain Speaks Urdu the way they speak in UP .I guess he is from a migrant family. Seems like a fair-minded journalist.
Does it matter? 😊
Best podcast of you to this day where you were completely neutral rather then cutting guest every time with your opinions.
Why listen to my podcast if you don’t want to hear my opinions?
@@ThePakistanExperiencepeople come to listen your guests not to you
They can listen to the guests anywhere else, internet bohat bara hay, mujhay nahee suna toh meri podcast na suno bhai
@@ThePakistanExperience ok nahin sunenge ab
@@ThePakistanExperience I find your guests to be interesting however I don't like your opinions but those guests are the quality.
Answering your "Kahi or guests dekho":
Sure, I see a variety of podcasts & I hardly know anyone's guests. I only get to know them once they're on youtube.
بہت اچھا انٹرویو کیا ہے آپ نے۔ بہت شکریہ
🙌
Shehzad you are such a gem and beauty of your podcast is that i always learn something from your session i believe lot of young generations will learn and understand about our country l.
🙌
Watching from India...will purchase all three books he has written
🙌
Kakar being an Army hack and a puppet, Bajwa asking family members of top leadership who they wanted( That blew my mind). This podcast was one of your best. Brilliant stuff.
🙌
I can see many Indians 🇮🇳 in comments on these discussion.
It’s on RUclips
how on earth someone watch His podcast and don't subscribe. What a shame for non subscriber. Amazing content Shehzad bhai.
🙌🙌🙌🙌
LEARN FROM YOUR PAST EXPERIENCE TO MOVE FORWARD FOR BETTER FUTURE
it's not the fault of military to interfere in political decisions its the incompetency, lack of mutual consensus, and corruption of so called democratic leaders that paved the way towards intervention.😢
The uprising of Baloch against the barbarism of Pakistan army did not get the international support it deserved. Hopefully Balochistan will soon be free nation again.
Salam Bro!
Firstly ,I appreciate your working way. Secondly ,I suggest you a book that title is ' Nine lives of Pakistan'.
❤️
Ghor aur Ghazni aaj Indian wheat ki Khairat pe zinda hain… Ahmed Shah Abdali ki koi descendent nhi bacha… Aurangzeb aur Mughal khandan wale aaj Old Delhi ke hotels mai bartan dho rhe hain
Somnath temple and Ram Janmabhoomi are flourishing and fabulous ….India is going on to be the 3 rd largest economy in the world with associated development and global prominence
This is the greatness of old Vedic civilisational values
Loot paat doosro ka mal khane wale jyada Samay nhi chalte
Waqt katil hai saheb
Nobody talked about the real problam of Pakistan,
Real problam is islam aur shariya,neither milatary nor people's of pakistan।
Running the affairs of country need a cool and calm mindset. A military mindset would always see force as the only solution to every problem. Musharraf, being a soldier, was unable to look at the roots of problem and possible solution to those problems. He used force to crush his opponents. I think a militia mind can never rule prosperously.
Very impressive 👍👍
What a gen of a journalist 👍👍👍 keep writing Sir
Thank you
🙌
Interesting subject and informative discussion.
Allow the democratic political system to work is the solution for Pakistan.
It was pleasure to watch Zahid Sahib.
very informative
Being a nuclear state we can play role in Palestine issue but unfortunately we have lack of Jihadi generals.
Not sure what you meant by that but Zia did that and killed close to 10,000 Palestinians. Pakistan's state policy has always been on a two-state solution, not on a single state.
Do not try to distrub India now onwards, then India will play tough game.Geopolitics is changing very fast.
Please make a podcast on GB's issue, historical background which is unfortunately missing in Pakistani readings, also what will be the future and fate of Gbians!
Rarely pakistan has true and serious liberal left ppl. This guy is one of em.
True Liberals would not accept him.
He was justifying killing on oct 7th.
He is socialist.
His criticism to Lebralise the pakistani society is very soft.
He is in bed with religious scholars(eg. Engineer ali mirza), which goes against the liberal values.
Yes, u can label him to be liberal in Pakistani context but he is more centrist to the radical and liberal values (not even the extreme liberal values).
Maybe his life would be in danger if he became liberal in true sense.
This type of self critical perspective is going to help improve Pakistan. it's not going to change fast it's going to take long time!
Lucky This man still Alive to say all😊
Excellent analysis by Mohtaram Zahid Hussain Sahib.When we expect Politicians to run the state of affairs of the country, it should also be realized that most of
the politicians are self
proclaimed.None of them ever studied Political science as a subject.There should be an academy having learned professors and people interested in running for elections or forming a political party should be trained here.
The present state of affairs in Pakistan shows that PARTITION OF THE COUNTRY proved to be blessings in disguise 🥸.It would have been very difficult for the undivided India to handle 700 million Muslims more than one third of the Umma.The radicals would have created havoc and majority of non-radcalised would have been silent.India would have been in a great Mess.Difficult to imagine a frightful situation the would have been 😢
Jinnah ji should be given Bharat Ratna. His actual name was Jignesh and was RAA agent. Creation of Pakistan was first raa ki sazis 😂😂😂😂😂
This is the new Pakistan private think tank and all wishes for your channel and hardwork ahead. Hope whole Pakistan change from now with this facts and learnings
❤️
Islam=teŕŕõřïśm
Atal bihari poem that time....dushro ke ghar aag lagane sapana sada apne hi ghar kharab hota hai..that line fit on you
Thanks TPE for producing another master piece.
Huge fan of his writing but in today's podcast I feel that he have too much to talk about and almost on all topics of Pakistan.
There should be a series with separate topics of each podcasts like Kashmir, Balochistan, Afghanistan, Politicians and Army etc.
Waiting for next episode ☺️
🙌
Yes, Pakistan destroyed Kashmiri independence movement and helped Indian state.
Pakistani destroyed Pakistan also in the name of Kashmir banega Pakistan 😂
ISLAM brotherwood, Do not mess up with Taliban they will teach the Real Islam.
One who digs graves for others ar the first to fall in it... Pakistan is experiencing the same thing...
Ayub khan , zia ul haqq , musharraf and hameed gul is real indian supporter of india i appreciate all of them nawaz shareef and benazir bhutto is enemy of india agar samjh sako to samjh lo humko dushmani suit karti hai america russia china ka hathyaar bik raha hai ye hi policy hai world politics ki .
Reverse UNO to sahi Mai Pakistan ke saath hua hai.......bicharon ke liye ek taraf Kuan aur ek taraf khai hai 😂
Khalistan Nagaland freedom comming soon
before: pak+ west+ muslim world+china.
now: pak+ youtube.
Kon kon ex-Muslim hai❤❤❤❤❤❤
Excellent vedio
About kashmir truth
🙌
Amusing, with all the naxol, boroland, khalistan, tamil, dravidaland and dozens more separatist movements in India, indians trying to play Pakistan down in comments. instead of sorting their own issues, they are interested in other's.
your provinces are having armed clashes against each other. sort your own place first.
Excellent. Your column is among the first things, I look in the daily Dawn. Excellent interview. May Almighty always bless you. 1 point sir. The incompetency of political elite creates the Power Gap that is naturally filled by the PPl with inherent power. The core problem is the incapacity of our political elite to take charge and Deliver ( My opinion only).
🙌