India’s recent move away from the Global South to support U.S. Hegemony and militarization of the Indo-Pacific is dramatic even though as noted here, we have seen this building for some time. But what’s very disturbing is India's apparent move to oppress economic development, and expansion of the BRICS nations. India might not like China, but it is CHINA that's giving something to the Global South empowering millions and improving the quality of their lives. At this moment in world history only China has proven a reliable partner treating countries and their people with respect and equality. India has given nothing to the very people it believes it should have some leadership role with. With India's economic model failing, India like the U.S. and NATO countries is falling back on aggressive militarization of the region and balancing China for its failures. There is a saying that some countries who experienced severe White Colonial occupation, oppression, and atrocities such as England did to the Indian people, that years later that the oppressed nation would take on the same characteristics as its occupier. Are we now seeing this with India in its actions against the people of the Global South and inability to diplomatically solve their problems with China?
Good morning. It's so refreshing to come across such candid honest views from an Indian on You Tube. I hope the people who control India at the moment learn to listen to you and others like you. Because the western world specifically the USA wants to use India as a proxy against China and more importantly to create an atmosphere of war. I hope this does not occur, because it will be bad for all concerned in the region.
what review ? he has not put across any good point he first says that we are afraid of china to take action and then again in the video he says we are being aggressive on borrowed strength .
After watching Sir pravin's precise and impartial analysis of the situation, notoriety of today's journalism is suppressed to some extent. Otherwise media today is full of fake news and wishful, self-coined news. Thank you Mr. Pravin shawney to address this selflessly.
Abe barking from bhikaristan your country is verge of bankrupcy , energy crisis, economic turmoil, total collapse, soon Gilgit Balisthan, Baluchistan will seperate from bhikaristan
@kuldiparora564 @kuldiparora564 Absolutely. These Indians are doing hate speech unknowingly or without care. This mentality will finish off India. But then most Indians cannot think like you. So much hates. Just like the Ukrainians. They ripe to be harvested like the Ukrainians. They are ready to sell India to feed their hates. @kuldiparora564 1 day ago When you guys start talking Hindu Rashtra and govt support this,that is when Muslims Sikhs Bengali and other small communities start feeling they are not included in one india,UNITED INDIA WHERE DIFFERENT RELIGION COMMUNITIES ARE LIVING..Then lots of hate speeches are damaging this beautiful bunch of flowers (INDIA)So better stop this mentality and let every one live in India like one BIG FAMILY 🙏
Sir you are one smart gentleman. New Delhi is arrogant and ignorant and will pay a price that you have defined. The US is a loose cannon no longer an economic power. A bully which is on its back foot now. Love your analysis always. Be well
Sorry to interrupt you Sir. If afgans can defeat USA and Pakistan... Ukraine is giving befitting reply to Russia...then India also can balance CCP PLA out in Himalayas.
@@biswajitbordoloi8092 I do not understand your analogy. What is has india learnt from the Chinese….nothing I guess as they will beat india at any location any time. Even the Afghans if let loose they would chase Indian forces to Delhi get your facts straight
@@rashidzaidi5211 sorry to say Sir but India has buried thousands of afgan Talibans+ Pakistani terrorist/ jihadist since 1990s in mass graves of Kashmir when your generals diverted them since the end of afgan jihad against Russians.... Pakistanis still crying in United nation and UNHRC about these mass graves.. you can varify it from Mr sawhani if you like...
@@markvelber8664 but Pakistan doesn’t have mogli as PM…bcoz Mogli is a Bhagwan as per Bhakts and he’s leading the world fighting against aliens…. What the vedic sh&t
There is a lot to unpack in this video. China is #1 trading partner with 90%+ countries of the world. China is #1 investor and solutions provider for most part of Global South and ASEAN. India lost sway with countries bordering itself but wants to be the voice for Global South. The only options remaining available for West are impediment and sabotage, India wants to be part of that.
@@nayanmalig Strategy of avoidance has its own limit and all ready it's have touched the limit . Chineese side have to must deal with india before going for Taiwan because they can't simply handle a two front war scenario . Either it's through hard way or soft way that does not matter . We have used the word rejunivation of china and india in the joint statement issued by both the countries after the last year bilateral meeting s . China is using the word rejunivation to mention the proposed unification of Taiwan .i don't know what is the meaning of rejunivation of India . Was it about pok ,gilgit baltistan ,?
West could be anything but not idiot . Look at the Afghanistan . Deadly terror outfits with Weapons worth of 80 billion dollars are roamanig free in the backyards of russia . Best way to create pressure on the limited resources of the Russian army by opening a second front in their backyard without taking the risk of nuclear war
I don't think that even jaishanker can fathom this strategic shift,the team at work seems too much playing to the domestic theatrics rather than on a geostrategy. Self boasting will become too dangerous of a strategy to satisfy global strategic challenges and domestic bravado.
@@drjabble Jaishanker is a good in politics and know how to get the people's support for him His foreign policy is not helping the Indian people as a whole only to placate some ego. . One day Power may get into his head and he may take over Modi's post. He is more popular than Modi now .
This is a very informative talk. I have to watch this a few times and found that his analysis came true especially the debacle of the G20 meeting when India is seen as a failure in not able to come out with a joint statement..and failed to be seen as the leader of the global south countries...as rightly it could not be.
India's problem is she wants assistance from West against Pakistan 😆but west wants it bilaterally against China khtm Tata bye bye esko kehte hai galey mein wo haddi lelena jo na ugli Jaye na nigli Jaye 😂
Yeah you are a bunch of third class beggars Who are screwed over by your military on an industrial scale Your number 1 enemy is taliban not india and your army is incapable of beating it
93000 Pakistani soldiers have surrendered to the 3000 Indian soldiers in Dhaka ,not to 3000 soldiers of west . According to the news report of rishav gulathi during the civil war of Yemen 10000 soldiers of pakistan have surrendered against the huthi rebels . But in that's case the ratio of the captor and prisonars were not 1:30 but it's opposite. According to the Saddam Hussein s famous quote "with the ten percent soldiers of the Indian army i could win the world.
@@amalchakrabarti2357 chutiya bnaney ki machine tou tmhara media bana he huwa hai hamesha se or wo sabit bhe krdia tumne andbhakt 🤣🤣3000 Indian soldiers beta tumse na ho payega tum jao wrna zaleel hogy kaha se aatay ho bansuri k tum jese log b.c thori tou aqal use krlo ya chitta mein he lekr jaogy sath jalaney k liye ab 3000 se zyada Bharti Afghanistan mein pely gaye bina ksi maqsad k begani shadi mein nachty huwe ye tou ksi ne nahi btaya hoga 😂 aukaat mein raha kro frustrated nation or kuch dikhany ko hai Jo nai purey Bharat ko truck ki batti k peche lgaya huwa
Very well thought out analysis of the geopolitics that is happening today. My hope is that India will look at the bigger picture and will not be used nor bullied by the western powers again.
This is absolutely amazing and best foreign policy analysis l have heard or red in 50 years BRAVO and hats off to you Mr. Praveen Sawhney. Prof.Dr.Nasir Fazal gold medalist Cambridge USA Best regards.
@@mysmartkryptonite354 Gaurav Arya is our answer to your lal topi & Orya Maqbool Jan types. We don't take him seriously just as we don't take Sawhney seriously . Both of them are essentially addressing you . One's taking the Mickey out of you the other is giving you wet dreams. Our job is to watch the fun . You job as of now is - muflisi mein aata gila karna.
@@ic9771 really when I say lal topi is talking facts. Well I feel no difference between lal topi and Gaurav. Both of them talk without facts and it's pure propaganda. Neither of them have no knowledge about modern warfare. Alteast Sawhney has the knowledge and also tohas guts to say the truth .
@@mysmartkryptonite354 you're mistaken there . All 4 talk nonsense but do it with 1 purpose - propoganda. However , Maj Arya's purpose is to ridicule you using hyperbole , Lal Topi , Orya & Sawhney's is to make you feel good . I've heard Sawhney declare 1971 as the year West Paxtan triumphed over India . Why , coz India couldn't vivisect it ? When it's pointed out that India did & Bangladesh is proof of it , he cooly points out that he's referring to west Pakistan . Of course you'd be thrilled to hear it . That's his MO.
Praveen sawhney is nothing but a chainees agent. He often travels to china and meets chainees official. He has only Pakistani fan base. What He do is all talk negative against india, a useful idiot for the chainees against india. That's info war. A 5th gen warfare.
Dr.Pravin is really what India needs to get on track to be a nation worthy of Indian aspirations. He is a realist set amongst a sea of Indian dreamers who can give Indian a path to reality, but the culture of Indians are too steeped in dreams for the moment and it will take many more followers of the Dr.Pravin vision to set the correct course to success. Indians have the mental capacity to dream big, but they have need to wake up from their dreams and Act in concert.
He is peddling psychological warfare on behalf of the CCP. He at once rebukes the Indian government for "surrendering to China / not going to war with China" as well as rebukes it for making geopolitical agreements with USA which will, according to him, end up in India going to war with China. He can't answer a simple question : does he support India going to war with China or not. If he doesn't support that, he should be glad that India surrendered to China. If he supports the war, he should support the BECA agreement with USA. He can't criticise both.
Sir, you are Mis quoting the Joint Statement Bet India-China on Sep 10, 2020. Nowhere on that statement has Mr. Jaishankar said that India Accepts the 1959 Border dictated by China. I am attaching that Statement Below: Joint Press Statement - Meeting of External Affairs Minister and the Foreign Minister of China (September 10, 2020) September 10, 2020 H.E. Dr. S. Jaishankar, External Affairs Minister of India met H.E. Wang Yi, State Councillor and Foreign Minister of China on 10th September in Moscow on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meeting. Both Ministers had a frank and constructive discussion on the developments in the India-China border areas as well as on India-China relations and agreed as follows: 1. The two Ministers agreed that both sides should take guidance from the series of consensus of the leaders on developing India-China relations, including not allowing differences to become disputes. 2. The two Foreign Ministers agreed that the current situation in the border areas is not in the interest of either side. They agreed therefore that the border troops of both sides should continue their dialogue, quickly disengage, maintain proper distance and ease tensions. 3. The two Ministers agreed that both sides shall abide by all the existing agreements and protocol on China-India boundary affairs, maintain peace and tranquillity in the border areas and avoid any action that could escalate matters. 4. The two sides also agreed to continue to have dialogue and communication through the Special Representative mechanism on the India-China boundary question. They also agreed in this context that the Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination on India-China border affairs (WMCC), should also continue its meetings. 5. The Ministers agreed that as the situation eases, the two sides should expedite work to conclude new Confidence Building Measures to maintain and enhance peace and tranquillity in the border areas. Moscow September 10, 2020
India dont need to be too emotional in dealing with China..both are great ancient civilisations..use ancient Wisdom to resolve regional issues..be independent on your own National Interests etc,,
A war between india and china is good chance for indians to avenge the 1962 defeat. Indians are telling now they are different from 1962 and now have the capability to wallop 2 enemies at once just like bollywood movie heroes 😂
Good analysis, Dr. Sawhney as always. The whole Indo-Pacific strategy of the US is a disaster for India. It looks like at least a couple of trillion dollars for all that preparation, equipment buying, training, and getting a trade hit with China; a disastrous proposition for India. Mr. Jaishankar has trapped himself and the future of India in a very expensive proposition that has no way out. I don't know what the policymakers in Delhi eat or think; they seem very incompetent since the head of affairs, Mr. Modi, is a self-centred and incapable man who can't think beyond the next election. The quote from the former Indian Admiral shows his lack of understanding of the Chinese Cyber, Space and AI power that will destroy the Indian navy without even letting them know what has happened. The way Russian EW Jammer Mig. 25 did to AIEGES Naval Ship in the Black Sea in 2018 should be enough to warn the Indian navy and its Air Defence system in a hot zone, which means the Chinese may take the Indian navy as sitting ducks. It's embarrassing to see Indian leadership, carrier diplomats and politicians pledging India's future, its people's prosperity, and peace of mind in American hands; what a pity. But I think the fundamental problem, people in the policy-making circles don't say what they need to say because Mr. Modi is a self-centred man with narcissistic tendencies; people are afraid of doing their best for India because they don't want to ruin their careers and serve sentences on false charges. Until the culture in Delhi changes, India's problems in international relations, the geo-political domain, economic growth, and social uplift will only multiply. Mr. Jaishankar and Mr. Doval need to retrain to behave in a multipolar world; instead of trying to punch above its weight, India should mend its ties with China to have a peaceful border in the Himalayas in the Indo-Pacific regions and improve trade and technology transfer from the Chinese. India can't afford a confrontation with China; it's not sane, and it's not a winning game for India. Moreover, it would cost India more time to improve jobs, infrastructure, manufacturing, and technology development and provide better healthcare to its people. All these are doable by avoiding further confrontation with China and getting out of the US trap.
How will this magic happen. We can’t make peace with Pakistan on Pakistani terms. It is morally inferior polity. Till then we need figure out all possible ways to counter balance China. Praveen is by the way not a doctor. He is retired fauji. Who is now an editor.
What China wants is that India should agree to Chinese terms, they are... give Dokalam, Tawang areas in Arunachal, Lithium areas of Ladakh. Pakistan is agreeing to all Chinese term so they have peace with China. India is not so weak against China, in a long war, India will loose a lot but China will back many many years too. US will continue to remain super power for many many years. Jai Shankar Ajith Doval are not fools. Doval is from Cong party. In current situation, only Modi and his team can make India strong. That's why you can seen many media is attacking India for a Govt change. West many world power want weak Indian Govt
@@asadahmed786 Uncle Xi proposed this to chacha Modi in 2019 summit. Make peace with Pakistan. That cannot happen with Pakistans terms. It is an inferior weak and flawed polity.
If you are a pakistani Just take care of your terrorists please I mean abe hind benaga Pakistan campaign is kind of nonsensical and shows your true auqat
According to defence expert Russia defeat Ukraine in 7 days. According to defence expert after 15 th August afganistan is a defecto of Pakistan. But in reality we see the truth.
In my teens I studied British India for history and felt the injustice where the Indians were manipulated by the ‘divide and rule’ policy practised by the British on the Indian Hindus and Indian Muslim that led to many bloodsheds. Now in my old age I see her being manipulated again this time against another country. Am really sad, war and aggression only brings death, pain and destruction-no one wins. Wisdom should prevail to preserve peace and prosperity for her people. Ukraine, should always be a reminder of devastation of a nation and her people. My sympathies are for the common Ukrainians.
You are wrong here sire. This corrupt regime of bjp is really scared now in their mind everyone attacking their flawed ship coz they are standing with Russia not thinking their ship is flawed at first point. What we seeing here is pose internationally we are helpless.
Sir, you're an amazing strategic analyst. The British Empire granted Independence to India last century in 1947. Neocolonism returned in the form of "America East India" , after 70 plus years. India without the Western yoke seems listless without clear national direction. The Sun rises in the East, the setting Sun destined for the West.
I have heard it said that in a conflict, the worst place to be is in the middle, that is, neutral. India needs to see that the fight between UUSS and China is much broader than that. The West is fighting any nation that threatens its dominance. After China, it would be India. Why should a country with a very small population be the only nation to develop and enrich itself at the expense of the whole world?
Modi is a wily PM. He used Doklam when his monetization failed. You don't go to war with anybody unless absolutely necessary and it could be a miscalculation. At the LAC he might miscalculate and cause India to suffer. What India needs now is peace to develop properly.
You are a wise man a professional but IMO the Hindu politicians & Hindu Sena won't dare provoke China despite USA prodding. Sikhs dalits won't support a Hindu war against China.
Firstly I am not sure if this is a fake account from a Pakistani or a genuine one. But considering it is a genuine one here is my answer - There is no entity as Hindu sena. It is Indian army and Sikhs have been integral part of it and have led from front. If God forbid there is another war, I am 100% sure Sikhs will again display the same valor they displayed in previous wars. A few disgruntled people like you will not make any difference.
Why not consider all of India? In the past, the conflict between China and India could be understood as a hangover from the colonial era. It makes no sense for China to wage a massive war for these histories. Now, India is committed to proving itself as an enemy of China. Then China should choose to eradicate the threat. These are two very different logics.
I agree India historically has been a great trading country not a good warring country. Now messing with China for no reason, they are averted from the real battle in the north and are planning to impact China in the south of India and choke points. China does not want anything to do with India. Even the 1962 war it was only intended as lesson to India for them to realize their own power. For long India has been seeking Veto power in Nato and this pursue of long term dream will be India undoing. If China attacks India, USA will do nothing, and all progress India made will be lost. I see it as a win, as couple of Nations will emerge from India, Free Kashmir, Khalistan and Assam may be couple more due to domino effect. As Pakistan is a reality and now India is a reality as well as India is digging its own grave.
Agree but that was past. Nehru wanted to develop India ignoring Defense. 1962 and 1965 changed India. Indira developed Army resulting stunning victory in 1971. Somehow after fall of USSR, Indian defense became weak. Even Modi also ignored for few years. Uri, Pulwama changed Modi's mind. It is good that US has cornered China giving some space for India to catch up... China cannot think of attacking India now
@@nirmalbhel3231 why do you think the west come to china in the first place,it is not only the cheap labour but the potential massive market that is the main attraction?china no longer give special favours to foreign investment which is their main frustration but those that leave is only seen as less competition for local producers.
China doesn't want full fledged war these days , particularly with india. Today is may 31s 2023, it has not happened yet. I know there is one more guy Hamid Zaidi (popularly known as Lal Topi) who always talks about india Pakistan war that may happen next day. They should stop this buffoonery
Chiana-India war. In the best of times war destroys the economy. Example. Germany lost every thing. England won but lost all the territories. China is not doing well economically. War makes it worse.
Free Tibet from all illegal Indian occupations now! Until then China should end all investments, and water flow to India. I can see why there in no more Buddhism in India.
basically India is the next Ukraine being or will be used against by china by usa it is being used as larger defence deterrence for the benefits of pentagon latest objective containment of china in which India is a larger tool
Well india will never allow drone strikes in its borders unlike a certain other country Plus we can buy Russian oil unlike another country Plus a terrorist group don't have a parallel government in our country unlike s certain country Plus we are not out of money , fuel snd food and an other country
ITs better for India not force herself to be recognize as leader of the South and let the South choose who will be their leader based on the role it plays in the economies of the South...
Sir from last 3 years you are praising China 🇨🇳, in today’s lecture you said because US can’t do things alone so he is using India and many more things. How much someone can be so negative about everything. And As you use Vajpayee’s name and things happened in his time. Without taking name of Congress and things happened in their times. It’s seems that it’s purely an agenda driven analysis, directed in some particular direction. But i will still watch your upcoming videos. Good luck in spreading this propaganda .
Any adventure between India and China will have serious consequences for both countries and also for rest of the world. It many kindles third world war. Can we afford that?
I have been watching Mr Sawhney dishing out distorted views of Geo Politics . Please note the following. India China border dispute long Pre dates America China discord. India China problem is independent of America China problem. Yes India needs America to safe guard it's borders and Amarica needs India to safe guard it's Super Power status. True India and Amarica are at the two ends of the Globe but they have much in common. On the other hand China and Pakistan have nothing in common. Only thing that they have in common is their desire to keep India down
india is trying to gain leverage against china as china is too close to pakistan, unfortunately both india and pakistan are also trying to balance between china and us, imo its such a mess and unless something breaks the status quo it will continue to be soo as both china and us tries to manage india and pakistan to their advantage, tough times ahead when china and us are at odds...
You don’t want India to ally with USA , the how do you suggest India to take on China ?? China became it is today because it had allied with USA and it became self reliant on tech , it became competitor of USA.
India being the voice of the global south? Laughable. India can't even voice for itself unless usa gave an OK, how can India be such voice. Brazil or south Africa or Iran or Indonesia has more independent sovereignty to represent the voice of the global south. These nations are better to stands up for the global south's interest instead of for that of the west or NATO.
We bought Russian oil and did not join USA in any of it's regime change wars plus we did not allow USA to bomb our lands unlike a certain riyast i madina lol
India’s recent move away from the Global South to support U.S. Hegemony and militarization of the Indo-Pacific is dramatic even though as noted here, we have seen this building for some time.
But what’s very disturbing is India's apparent move to oppress economic development, and expansion of the BRICS nations.
India might not like China, but it is CHINA that's giving something to the Global South empowering millions and improving the quality of their lives.
At this moment in world history only China has proven a reliable partner treating countries and their people with respect and equality.
India has given nothing to the very people it believes it should have some leadership role with.
With India's economic model failing, India like the U.S. and NATO countries is falling back on aggressive militarization of the region and balancing China for its failures.
There is a saying that some countries who experienced severe White Colonial occupation, oppression, and atrocities such as England did to the Indian people, that years later that the oppressed nation would take on the same characteristics as its occupier.
Are we now seeing this with India in its actions against the people of the Global South and inability to diplomatically solve their problems with China?
India and the Philippines suffer from Colonial Mindset. Pathetic willing slaves
Good morning. It's so refreshing to come across such candid honest views from an Indian on You Tube. I hope the people who control India at the moment learn to listen to you and others like you. Because the western world specifically the USA wants to use India as a proxy against China and more importantly to create an atmosphere of war. I hope this does not occur, because it will be bad for all concerned in the region.
This man goes on speculating war and that India will lose miserably in war , whether with China or Pakistan..
what review ? he has not put across any good point he first says that we are afraid of china to take action and then again in the video he says we are being aggressive on borrowed strength .
After watching Sir pravin's precise and impartial analysis of the situation, notoriety of today's journalism is suppressed to some extent. Otherwise media today is full of fake news and wishful, self-coined news.
Thank you Mr. Pravin shawney to address this selflessly.
Indian Media is run by the establishment and it's intel agencies...
Abe barking from bhikaristan your country is verge of bankrupcy , energy crisis, economic turmoil, total collapse, soon Gilgit Balisthan, Baluchistan will seperate from bhikaristan
@@lifestylemaster6186 Your comment is exactly what a barking dog means. Lage raho
@@farissyed4564 meant for bit( hes like you, bhikaristan ho kya bhikari ki terah ki raho jyada kudo na
However the indian military elite is far more brilliant than this guy..... All his concerns would have been facited by India long back
Excellent analysis. India falls trap to US, without realising what they have done to Ukraine as of right now.
Indians think they are smarter than the Ukrainian and won't fall into the trap.. how naive
Really??
@@rashmiranjanswain-wb6pl Remember they eat dogs 😂 so Indians should be worried for their lives
Now russia is also your enemy.
@kuldiparora564 @kuldiparora564 Absolutely. These Indians are doing hate speech unknowingly or without care. This mentality will finish off India. But then most Indians cannot think like you. So much hates. Just like the Ukrainians. They ripe to be harvested like the Ukrainians. They are ready to sell India to feed their hates.
@kuldiparora564
1 day ago
When you guys start talking Hindu Rashtra and govt support this,that is when Muslims Sikhs Bengali and other small communities start feeling they are not included in one india,UNITED INDIA WHERE DIFFERENT RELIGION COMMUNITIES ARE LIVING..Then lots of hate speeches are damaging this beautiful bunch of flowers (INDIA)So better stop this mentality and let every one live in India like one BIG FAMILY 🙏
Sir you are one smart gentleman. New Delhi is arrogant and ignorant and will pay a price that you have defined. The US is a loose cannon no longer an economic power. A bully which is on its back foot now. Love your analysis always. Be well
Endia can never become anything big like China, First Ednia must stop t£rr0r groups attacking Muslim countries..
Sorry to interrupt you Sir. If afgans can defeat USA and Pakistan... Ukraine is giving befitting reply to Russia...then India also can balance CCP PLA out in Himalayas.
@@biswajitbordoloi8092 I do not understand your analogy. What is has india learnt from the Chinese….nothing I guess as they will beat india at any location any time. Even the Afghans if let loose they would chase Indian forces to Delhi get your facts straight
@@rashidzaidi5211 sorry to say Sir but India has buried thousands of afgan Talibans+ Pakistani terrorist/ jihadist since 1990s in mass graves of Kashmir when your generals diverted them since the end of afgan jihad against Russians.... Pakistanis still crying in United nation and UNHRC about these mass graves.. you can varify it from Mr sawhani if you like...
My analogy is simple..
Pakistanis never won a war.
Chinese never won since 1962
India never lost since 1962.
So Just chill....
Once you depend on their weapons, you will be pulled by the nose...A subordinate forever. Plenty of examples in history
Such as Pakistan
@@markvelber8664 Pakistan has largely offset American influence by becoming friendly with China.
@@markvelber8664 but Pakistan doesn’t have mogli as PM…bcoz Mogli is a Bhagwan as per Bhakts and he’s leading the world fighting against aliens….
What the vedic sh&t
@@markvelber8664 India is becoming more dependent on usa
@@manishgrg639 No both are getting dependent on each other
There is a lot to unpack in this video. China is #1 trading partner with 90%+ countries of the world. China is #1 investor and solutions provider for most part of Global South and ASEAN. India lost sway with countries bordering itself but wants to be the voice for Global South. The only options remaining available for West are impediment and sabotage, India wants to be part of that.
Solution provider seriously are you kidding dude have you seen Pakistan and sri Lanka
India should cool it down with China somehow. Or else would end up as a huge but weak regional power. Avoid humiliation at all cost.
@@nayanmalig Strategy of avoidance has its own limit and all ready it's have touched the limit . Chineese side have to must deal with india before going for Taiwan because they can't simply handle a two front war scenario . Either it's through hard way or soft way that does not matter . We have used the word rejunivation of china and india in the joint statement issued by both the countries after the last year bilateral meeting s . China is using the word rejunivation to mention the proposed unification of Taiwan .i don't know what is the meaning of rejunivation of India . Was it about pok ,gilgit baltistan ,?
West could be anything but not idiot . Look at the Afghanistan . Deadly terror outfits with Weapons worth of 80 billion dollars are roamanig free in the backyards of russia . Best way to create pressure on the limited resources of the Russian army by opening a second front in their backyard without taking the risk of nuclear war
इसकी तरह एक मेरा दोस्त बहुत ओवरएक्टिंग करता था
बहुत समझाया लेकिन नही माना,
फिर उसको एक दिन हिजड़े उठा ले गए😊
Dr Pravin speaks from the heart and I salute Him!
I don't think that even jaishanker can fathom this strategic shift,the team at work seems too much playing to the domestic theatrics rather than on a geostrategy.
Self boasting will become too dangerous of a strategy to satisfy global strategic challenges and domestic bravado.
Jaishanker is a prolific liar....
@@drjabble Jaishanker is a good in politics and know how to get the people's support for him His foreign policy is not helping the Indian people as a whole only to placate some ego. . One day Power may get into his head and he may take over Modi's post. He is more popular than Modi now .
This is a very informative talk. I have to watch this a few times and found that his analysis came true especially the debacle of the G20 meeting when India is seen as a failure in not able to come out with a joint statement..and failed to be seen as the leader of the global south countries...as rightly it could not be.
Absolutely flawless analysis bravo
Unbiased analysis. keep it up ,sir. We learn much from your analysis.
India's problem is she wants assistance from West against Pakistan 😆but west wants it bilaterally against China khtm Tata bye bye esko kehte hai galey mein wo haddi lelena jo na ugli Jaye na nigli Jaye 😂
Pak is no more a threat and India will ignore Pak... India will focus on China and how to stop China's advance against India
Yeah you are a bunch of third class beggars
Who are screwed over by your military on an industrial scale
Your number 1 enemy is taliban not india and your army is incapable of beating it
93000 Pakistani soldiers have surrendered to the 3000 Indian soldiers in Dhaka ,not to 3000 soldiers of west . According to the news report of rishav gulathi during the civil war of Yemen 10000 soldiers of pakistan have surrendered against the huthi rebels . But in that's case the ratio of the captor and prisonars were not 1:30 but it's opposite. According to the Saddam Hussein s famous quote "with the ten percent soldiers of the Indian army i could win the world.
@@amalchakrabarti2357 chutiya bnaney ki machine tou tmhara media bana he huwa hai hamesha se or wo sabit bhe krdia tumne andbhakt 🤣🤣3000 Indian soldiers beta tumse na ho payega tum jao wrna zaleel hogy kaha se aatay ho bansuri k tum jese log b.c thori tou aqal use krlo ya chitta mein he lekr jaogy sath jalaney k liye ab 3000 se zyada Bharti Afghanistan mein pely gaye bina ksi maqsad k begani shadi mein nachty huwe ye tou ksi ne nahi btaya hoga 😂 aukaat mein raha kro frustrated nation or kuch dikhany ko hai Jo nai purey Bharat ko truck ki batti k peche lgaya huwa
India loses America wins....
Is china interested in beating India or not making America win....
So self contradictory
Very well thought out analysis of the geopolitics that is happening today. My hope is that India will look at the bigger picture and will not be used nor bullied by the western powers again.
This is absolutely amazing and best foreign policy analysis l have heard or red in 50 years BRAVO and hats off to you Mr. Praveen Sawhney. Prof.Dr.Nasir Fazal gold medalist Cambridge USA
Best regards.
wow, this man can predict Indian 5 months ago fall in the trap of the US. Now it is happening.
India is in the North Atlantic!
Praveen sir's videos are every pakistani's wet dreams
Same for you when gaurav arya makes nonsense
@@mysmartkryptonite354 Gaurav Arya is our answer to your lal topi & Orya Maqbool Jan types. We don't take him seriously just as we don't take Sawhney seriously . Both of them are essentially addressing you . One's taking the Mickey out of you the other is giving you wet dreams. Our job is to watch the fun . You job as of now is - muflisi mein aata gila karna.
@@ic9771 really when I say lal topi is talking facts. Well I feel no difference between lal topi and Gaurav. Both of them talk without facts and it's pure propaganda. Neither of them have no knowledge about modern warfare. Alteast Sawhney has the knowledge and also tohas guts to say the truth .
@@mysmartkryptonite354 you're mistaken there . All 4 talk nonsense but do it with 1 purpose - propoganda.
However , Maj Arya's purpose is to ridicule you using hyperbole , Lal Topi , Orya & Sawhney's is to make you feel good .
I've heard Sawhney declare 1971 as the year West Paxtan triumphed over India . Why , coz India couldn't vivisect it ? When it's pointed out that India did & Bangladesh is proof of it , he cooly points out that he's referring to west Pakistan .
Of course you'd be thrilled to hear it . That's his MO.
Praveen sawhney is nothing but a chainees agent.
He often travels to china and meets chainees official.
He has only Pakistani fan base. What He do is all talk negative against india, a useful idiot for the chainees against india.
That's info war. A 5th gen warfare.
Though I am from Pakistan. Sir You have such a logical, reality on the ground analysis
Pakistan is better country than Hindu run India.
This is scary. This is so disappointing for us Indians. We are living in delusion.
Amazing analysis by Dr Pravin Sawhney
Thank you Sir
It seems America is willing to fight the Chinese to the last Indian, last Taiwanese, last Filipiano and last Japanese!
India should never sit in Americans Lap.
India China shouldn't go to a war. China needs to step back as Americans are pushing India towards war.
Dont worry . Ex Army chief Rawat had said indians have the ability to wallop chinese and pakistanis at same time😂
Sir a lot of love and respect for you from 🇵🇰 we would love to see you again in 🇵🇰
Bsdk rakh lena maat aane dena. Iske baadle Hina khar ko bhej dena.
Pakistan ki Pehchan- Bhookha, Nanga, Kangal Dehshat Gard Pakistan🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Nice shirt Sir and good to see you again after long time.
Dr.Pravin is really what India needs to get on track to be a nation worthy of Indian aspirations. He is a realist set amongst a sea of Indian dreamers who can give Indian a path to reality, but the culture of Indians are too steeped in dreams for the moment and it will take many more followers of the Dr.Pravin vision to set the correct course to success. Indians have the mental capacity to dream big, but they have need to wake up from their dreams and Act in concert.
pakistan se war pe jai shree ram ke nare lagane wale china pe kahan chale jate hain😅
It is always easy for a country to start a war but to finish it is often in another country's hands!
Yes.. in the end .its RUSSIA . and he will pick with a big letter - C .
We don't get this sort of analysis on Western media channels. Thank you for sharing,
Many times you have said India has surrendered then WHY THE HELL CHINA WILL ATTACK INDIA IF INDIA HAS SURRENDERED. MAKES NO SENSE
He is peddling psychological warfare on behalf of the CCP. He at once rebukes the Indian government for "surrendering to China / not going to war with China" as well as rebukes it for making geopolitical agreements with USA which will, according to him, end up in India going to war with China. He can't answer a simple question : does he support India going to war with China or not. If he doesn't support that, he should be glad that India surrendered to China. If he supports the war, he should support the BECA agreement with USA. He can't criticise both.
But modi said NO Chinese on india land. Lol
“Wisdom”
Few are blessed with it,
Few understand it,
Few apply it.
As a Kashmiri- i should say your talking nonsense - then again your advice is going to fall on deaf ears…
India is doing well in some ways in many fields but this guy can’t digest it in any way don’t know why.😅
A very nice analysis you can disagree but he is logical. Great
19th century Indians never change mentality
Sir, you are Mis quoting the Joint Statement Bet India-China on Sep 10, 2020. Nowhere on that statement has Mr. Jaishankar said that India Accepts the 1959 Border dictated by China. I am attaching that Statement Below:
Joint Press Statement - Meeting of External Affairs Minister and the Foreign
Minister of China (September 10, 2020)
September 10, 2020
H.E. Dr. S. Jaishankar, External Affairs Minister of India met H.E. Wang Yi, State
Councillor and Foreign Minister of China on 10th September in Moscow on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meeting. Both Ministers had a
frank and constructive discussion on the developments in the India-China border areas
as well as on India-China relations and agreed as follows:
1. The two Ministers agreed that both sides should take guidance from the series of
consensus of the leaders on developing India-China relations, including not allowing
differences to become disputes.
2. The two Foreign Ministers agreed that the current situation in the border areas is not
in the interest of either side. They agreed therefore that the border troops of both sides
should continue their dialogue, quickly disengage, maintain proper distance and ease
tensions.
3. The two Ministers agreed that both sides shall abide by all the existing agreements
and protocol on China-India boundary affairs, maintain peace and tranquillity in the
border areas and avoid any action that could escalate matters.
4. The two sides also agreed to continue to have dialogue and communication through
the Special Representative mechanism on the India-China boundary question. They
also agreed in this context that the Working Mechanism for Consultation and
Coordination on India-China border affairs (WMCC), should also continue its meetings.
5. The Ministers agreed that as the situation eases, the two sides should expedite work
to conclude new Confidence Building Measures to maintain and enhance peace and
tranquillity in the border areas.
Moscow
September 10, 2020
He always speak against India and praise Pakistan😂
It's always world is going to end for him
It was Modi accepted when PLA settled in finger 4 who had proclaimed China didn't intrude to the Indian Territory !
These old man talkingis nonense without clarity and facts.
As an ethnic Chinese I greatly admire Dr Pravin.
India dont need to be too emotional in dealing with China..both are great ancient civilisations..use ancient Wisdom to resolve regional issues..be independent on your own National Interests etc,,
Except that Chinese pla chaps are unrealistic territory beggars like it's crazy
A war between india and china is good chance for indians to avenge the 1962 defeat.
Indians are telling now they are different from 1962 and now have the capability to wallop 2 enemies at once just like bollywood movie heroes 😂
Whats so different now 🤔 India economy in 1947 was 3% global share. Today its 3,5% only.
@@nmew6926 you don’t see the difference 🤣
Good analysis, Dr. Sawhney as always. The whole Indo-Pacific strategy of the US is a disaster for India. It looks like at least a couple of trillion dollars for all that preparation, equipment buying, training, and getting a trade hit with China; a disastrous proposition for India. Mr. Jaishankar has trapped himself and the future of India in a very expensive proposition that has no way out. I don't know what the policymakers in Delhi eat or think; they seem very incompetent since the head of affairs, Mr. Modi, is a self-centred and incapable man who can't think beyond the next election. The quote from the former Indian Admiral shows his lack of understanding of the Chinese Cyber, Space and AI power that will destroy the Indian navy without even letting them know what has happened. The way Russian EW Jammer Mig. 25 did to AIEGES Naval Ship in the Black Sea in 2018 should be enough to warn the Indian navy and its Air Defence system in a hot zone, which means the Chinese may take the Indian navy as sitting ducks.
It's embarrassing to see Indian leadership, carrier diplomats and politicians pledging India's future, its people's prosperity, and peace of mind in American hands; what a pity. But I think the fundamental problem, people in the policy-making circles don't say what they need to say because Mr. Modi is a self-centred man with narcissistic tendencies; people are afraid of doing their best for India because they don't want to ruin their careers and serve sentences on false charges. Until the culture in Delhi changes, India's problems in international relations, the geo-political domain, economic growth, and social uplift will only multiply.
Mr. Jaishankar and Mr. Doval need to retrain to behave in a multipolar world; instead of trying to punch above its weight, India should mend its ties with China to have a peaceful border in the Himalayas in the Indo-Pacific regions and improve trade and technology transfer from the Chinese. India can't afford a confrontation with China; it's not sane, and it's not a winning game for India. Moreover, it would cost India more time to improve jobs, infrastructure, manufacturing, and technology development and provide better healthcare to its people. All these are doable by avoiding further confrontation with China and getting out of the US trap.
How will this magic happen. We can’t make peace with Pakistan on Pakistani terms. It is morally inferior polity. Till then we need figure out all possible ways to counter balance China. Praveen is by the way not a doctor. He is retired fauji. Who is now an editor.
Fully agreed.
@@MannSingh1973 This is about India and China. Don't bring Pakistan into it.
What China wants is that India should agree to Chinese terms, they are... give Dokalam, Tawang areas in Arunachal, Lithium areas of Ladakh. Pakistan is agreeing to all Chinese term so they have peace with China. India is not so weak against China, in a long war, India will loose a lot but China will back many many years too. US will continue to remain super power for many many years.
Jai Shankar Ajith Doval are not fools. Doval is from Cong party. In current situation, only Modi and his team can make India strong. That's why you can seen many media is attacking India for a Govt change. West many world power want weak Indian Govt
@@asadahmed786 Uncle Xi proposed this to chacha Modi in 2019 summit. Make peace with Pakistan. That cannot happen with Pakistans terms. It is an inferior weak and flawed polity.
Subcontinent does not need anymore wars. Not between India China or India Pakistan. Spend on people, health and education and build something like EU.
Amazing clarity of explanation Sir, easy for lay men to understand.
War is always on other country's soil.... Don't be fooled my Indian friends
You are very familiar with American war strategy.
If you are a pakistani
Just take care of your terrorists please
I mean abe hind benaga Pakistan campaign is kind of nonsensical and shows your true auqat
According to defence expert Russia defeat Ukraine in 7 days. According to defence expert after 15 th August afganistan is a defecto of Pakistan. But in reality we see the truth.
In my teens I studied British India for history and felt the injustice where the Indians were manipulated by the ‘divide and rule’ policy practised by the British on the Indian Hindus and Indian Muslim that led to many bloodsheds. Now in my old age I see her being manipulated again this time against another country. Am really sad, war and aggression only brings death, pain and destruction-no one wins. Wisdom should prevail to preserve peace and prosperity for her people. Ukraine, should always be a reminder of devastation of a nation and her people. My sympathies are for the common Ukrainians.
You are wrong here sire. This corrupt regime of bjp is really scared now in their mind everyone attacking their flawed ship coz they are standing with Russia not thinking their ship is flawed at first point.
What we seeing here is pose internationally we are helpless.
As usual important topic outstanding explanation and analysis thanks
As always you are a fountain of knowledge, a very rare beacon of light in a meddy world
Brilliant analyses all in the true interest of India but seems very limited listeners and buyers of these thoughts in India
Because majority of Indians are far right extremists, racists and islamophobes
The only channel where I click like even before I start watching the video.
Sublime and absorbing analysis. A huge applause for your straight talk.
Sir, you're an amazing strategic analyst.
The British Empire granted Independence to India last century in 1947.
Neocolonism returned in the form of "America East India" , after 70 plus years.
India without the Western yoke seems listless without clear national direction.
The Sun rises in the East, the setting Sun destined for the West.
The last words of this analysis were very hard to understand for both the USA and India.
Superb, this man squeaky cleans your doubts.
तेंदुए और बाघ की लड़ाई जैसा होगा भारत चीन युद्ध। अब आप अंदाजा लगाइए कि कौन तेंदुआ है और कौन बाघ।
I have heard it said that in a conflict, the worst place to be is in the middle, that is, neutral. India needs to see that the fight between UUSS and China is much broader than that. The West is fighting any nation that threatens its dominance. After China, it would be India. Why should a country with a very small population be the only nation to develop and enrich itself at the expense of the whole world?
AREY DIKRA 🤡 MODI is already in the QUAD❗️ Totally ISOLATED ‼️
Illusion and reality . india can never realize the difference much less distinguish between the two.😢
Think about this and do not dare challenging China on the wink of US
You clowns care about your debt and starvation and also taliban
India is in a million times better position than you
Bring it on Xi, this is good chance for take revenge on 1962 defeat for indians.
...........and then the Indian pissed the American off by buying cheap Russian gas.
What India has been doing geopolitically has been disappointing for the entire region. Remember, when the water rises, all boats are lifted.
Modi is a wily PM. He used Doklam when his monetization failed. You don't go to war with anybody unless absolutely necessary and it could be a miscalculation. At the LAC he might miscalculate and cause India to suffer. What India needs now is peace to develop properly.
The reality is painful. Thank you for your clarity and fortright pronunciation of the truth.
Seven months now there was no war between India and China what is he trying to say 😅
Love ur analysis...support from nepal
You are a wise man a professional but IMO the Hindu politicians & Hindu Sena won't dare provoke China despite USA prodding. Sikhs dalits won't support a Hindu war against China.
Firstly I am not sure if this is a fake account from a Pakistani or a genuine one. But considering it is a genuine one here is my answer -
There is no entity as Hindu sena. It is Indian army and Sikhs have been integral part of it and have led from front. If God forbid there is another war, I am 100% sure Sikhs will again display the same valor they displayed in previous wars.
A few disgruntled people like you will not make any difference.
You are not a Hindu
@@chandrashekarv5676 I shall fight hindus to avenge June 1984 thug military attack on Sikhism.
few question
1. war for which region arunachal or ladhak
2. will it happen before taiwan
I guess China would take everything they claim as their own. That is if India fails to defend effectively.
Why not consider all of India?
In the past, the conflict between China and India could be understood as a hangover from the colonial era. It makes no sense for China to wage a massive war for these histories.
Now, India is committed to proving itself as an enemy of China. Then China should choose to eradicate the threat. These are two very different logics.
China should not have returned Arunachal Pradesh after occupying it in 62. Big mistake by Mao to give it up. Chinese lives were lost.
I agree India historically has been a great trading country not a good warring country. Now messing with China for no reason, they are averted from the real battle in the north and are planning to impact China in the south of India and choke points. China does not want anything to do with India. Even the 1962 war it was only intended as lesson to India for them to realize their own power. For long India has been seeking Veto power in Nato and this pursue of long term dream will be India undoing. If China attacks India, USA will do nothing, and all progress India made will be lost. I see it as a win, as couple of Nations will emerge from India, Free Kashmir, Khalistan and Assam may be couple more due to domino effect. As Pakistan is a reality and now India is a reality as well as India is digging its own grave.
Agree but that was past. Nehru wanted to develop India ignoring Defense. 1962 and 1965 changed India. Indira developed Army resulting stunning victory in 1971. Somehow after fall of USSR, Indian defense became weak. Even Modi also ignored for few years. Uri, Pulwama changed Modi's mind. It is good that US has cornered China giving some space for India to catch up... China cannot think of attacking India now
@@nirmalbhel3231 US is going to be shafted by china and is going to be a cry baby soon
@@nirmalbhel3231 the us is in great decline they cannot stop china
@@spade1974 US has started removing its factories from China and China is declining. Let's see for another 5 years
@@nirmalbhel3231 why do you think the west come to china in the first place,it is not only the cheap labour but the potential massive market that is the main attraction?china no longer give special favours to foreign investment which is their main frustration but those that leave is only seen as less competition for local producers.
China doesn't want full fledged war these days , particularly with india. Today is may 31s 2023, it has not happened yet.
I know there is one more guy Hamid Zaidi (popularly known as Lal Topi) who always talks about india Pakistan war that may happen next day. They should stop this buffoonery
Chiana-India war. In the best of times war destroys the economy. Example. Germany
lost every thing. England won but lost all the territories. China is not doing well
economically. War makes it worse.
Free Tibet from all illegal Indian occupations now! Until then China should end all investments, and water flow to India. I can see why there in no more Buddhism in India.
Soon all of north india will belong to china, while the chaiwalla keeps giving jumlas upon jumlas and calling all is changasi.
Wow. Grt analysis. Is there anyway to contribute to this channel?
basically India is the next Ukraine being or will be used against by china by usa it is being used as larger defence deterrence for the benefits of pentagon latest objective containment of china in which India is a larger tool
Well india will never allow drone strikes in its borders unlike a certain other country
Plus we can buy Russian oil unlike another country
Plus a terrorist group don't have a parallel government in our country unlike s certain country
Plus we are not out of money , fuel snd food and an other country
By staying neutral India cannot avoid war with China, it anyway needs to militarily align with West.
There are more Indians working and living in America. Can you say that for China?
ITs better for India not force herself to be recognize as leader of the South and let the South choose who will be their leader based on the role it plays in the economies of the South...
In other words, India must quietly do what China demands!
Pravin Ji, thanks you have scared me, now we have to be prepared to hit back, before the dragon 🐉 attacks.
Sir from last 3 years you are praising China 🇨🇳, in today’s lecture you said because US can’t do things alone so he is using India and many more things. How much someone can be so negative about everything. And As you use Vajpayee’s name and things happened in his time. Without taking name of Congress and things happened in their times. It’s seems that it’s purely an agenda driven analysis, directed in some particular direction. But i will still watch your upcoming videos. Good luck in spreading this propaganda .
इसकी तरह एक मेरा दोस्त बहुत ओवरएक्टिंग करता था
बहुत समझाया लेकिन नही माना,
फिर उसको एक दिन हिजड़े उठा ले गए😊
who is this guy?
Reference for Brijesh Mishra request to US to avoid war during 2001-2 needs to be given
Any adventure between India and China will have serious consequences for both countries and also for rest of the world. It many kindles third world war. Can we afford that?
Modi ji runs with hare and hunts with the hound. We can get best from US and Russia
I have been watching Mr Sawhney dishing out distorted views of Geo Politics . Please note the following.
India China border dispute long Pre dates America China discord. India China problem is independent of America China problem. Yes India needs America to safe guard it's borders and Amarica needs India to safe guard it's Super Power status. True India and Amarica are at the two ends of the Globe but they have much in common. On the other hand China and Pakistan have nothing in common. Only thing that they have in common is their desire to keep India down
Merchant of Gujarat will prove you wrong...
Terrific vlog Sir, after a long wait.
Is is on Chinese payroll , clearly
How can someone be so consistent I bashing india and praising Chinese always
Great analysis- fantastic keep it up
Very factual true Analysis, should be given weightage
Why not China headed for war with India?😂
india is trying to gain leverage against china as china is too close to pakistan, unfortunately both india and pakistan are also trying to balance between china and us, imo its such a mess and unless something breaks the status quo it will continue to be soo as both china and us tries to manage india and pakistan to their advantage, tough times ahead when china and us are at odds...
You don’t want India to ally with USA , the how do you suggest India to take on China ?? China became it is today because it had allied with USA and it became self reliant on tech , it became competitor of USA.
Don't give your enemy a target to shoot at............. Period.
Well said and explained
You seem to be joking....so so anti India...what's your agenda, mister??
Excellent video and your comments, totally agree, thanks
India being the voice of the global south? Laughable. India can't even voice for itself unless usa gave an OK, how can India be such voice. Brazil or south Africa or Iran or Indonesia has more independent sovereignty to represent the voice of the global south. These nations are better to stands up for the global south's interest instead of for that of the west or NATO.
We bought Russian oil and did not join USA in any of it's regime change wars plus we did not allow USA to bomb our lands unlike a certain riyast i madina lol
India will go hungry!
Excellent in-depth knowledge - Thank you