Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Lt Gen Kidwai has issued enough of a Warning
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 авг 2024
- Join Pravin Sawhney on "The Bottom Line" as we unravel Pakistan's nuclear policy and India's political provocations. Explore General Khalid Kidwai's crucial role and the red lines for nuclear weapon use. Discover how China's support impacts the strategic landscape. Stay informed and gain critical insights in this concise video. Like, share, and subscribe to Force Magazine for more!
I am a retired Pakistani physician living in the US. Greatly appreciate, admire and respect your honest analysis of strategic issues of our two countries. Salutation to your bravery to be critical of even the most powerful. A lesson to to be learned by everyone. Need more people like you on both sides of border . Thank you Pravin sir .
Stay in US or Canada, or UK wherever they still allow you and dont come back. Your country is about to blow .
Bhikaristan pehle apne logo ko khana khilale phir, pehle apne imran khan ko bacha le
True
One correction. India never provoked. It's Pakistan always provoking India. Pakistan only initiated 4 wars with India and lost all the four wars which led to serious damage politically, economically and socially. So your analysis is totally false and it seems that politically motivated against current government. It's also understood that u are a supporter of China. Never talked a single word about India.
@@venkataramanaduvva7418 this sahani is a stooge of congress government and linked with junkina and even might be a spy for bhikaristan
Kargil was not a vctory rather it was American sponsored arrangment for withdrawal of pak forces from Kargil.
Why is that? Why American wanted that?
Sorry, we won the peaks with our blood. If Americans had earlier intervened, India would have waited it out. Pak Army begged NS to go to US to save their asses after IA started winning peaks back with huge casualties, Arty fire. PA has never claimed its dead soldiers till date who all died in Vain. Please find the actual casualties in Pak especially NLI.
@@jioboy2676 bcz indian pm wqchpai begged CLINTON😂😂
@@ajayrawat-bf9pc
1 pak had 100 peaks in its control it is highly stupid of u to think that PAK BEGGED USA bcz PAK NEVER CLAIMED THE ARMY TOOK THE PEAKS RATHER THE MUJAHIDEEN😂
2 ONCE THE VACHPAI govt got to know that PAK HAD 100 PEAKS VACHPAI SENT HIS FM TO USA TO BEG CLINTON TO TELL PAK TO LEAVE😂😂
3 u WON ONLY TIGER HILL by mere 20 pak troops by the death of 100s of UR troops😂😂😂..
4 pak never used its Airforce😂😂
U used airforce and gunship and lost 2 mig 29 fulcrums 😂😂😂..
And 5 gunship helicopters😂😂
5 pakistan deployed 5 BRIGADES to a total of 5000 TROOPS on these 100 PEAKS....
6 in response UR NO GOOD ARMY deployed 4.5 DIVISIONS...TO a total of 50000 troops😂😂😂....
7 PAKISTAN STILL HAS 30 OF THESE PEAKS IN ITS CONTROL😂😂
SO MUCH FOR BLOOD AND SWEAT😂😂😂
What a brain he is, always on point and honest. This kind of sense needed on both sides so we could live peacefully and with love for each other.
I agreed with your true analysis.
He is often seen on Wire with intelltuals like Arfa Khanum Sherwani. You can easily understand his mindset snd source of livlihood.
Grt u should also start a similar channel in competition u will get more funds n u can make good money
He as well as Aarfa. Are head and shoulders above Modi and Rajnath in intelligence and national spirit.
Thank God we have you sir to know the backend of what's going on in our country, please keep doing the good work sir.
What a great analysis
He is just a think tank. No powers and no influence. So don't get carried away by his rhetoric.
China brokered peace between iran and saudi. China could do the same for Pakistan and India
problem is .... Modi is hard headed. The delusion of someday ruling the global south plus the promise by America to support India's rise.
trusting America will be Modi's downfall
The PRC successfully brokered peace between Iran and KSA because it has no excess baggage with either country and can be seen as a neutral third party. In other words, there's enough trust by both Iran and KSA for the PRC to foster an environment conducive for negotiation. That's not the case with India; it's probably easier for Martians to be accepted by India than China.
The value of American support promise can be well understood in recent Russia Ukraine war
@@tonyyin8524are you Taiwanese?
@@AR-rf9hc - US will probably remain as neutral as possible in an India-Pakistan conflict. Reason is Washington has little to gain from overtly supporting one side and thus destroying relations with the other. Also, the amount of chaos generated by wars in the IOR is more problematic for Beijing than Washington. Beltway neocon-libs would likely be thrilled with that.
@@pisablavatsky-cb3dd - I'm an American of Han Chinese ethnicity.
Pakistan is yet to produce a Defence analyst of Mr. Pravin Sawhney's caliber. Probably the credit goes to freedom of speech in India and stomach to listen criticism by the Indian military Command. Had Mr Pravin be a Pakistani defence analyst, his days would be numbered or forced to leave the country by now.
Bravo Sir, for your courage and wisdom.
You see INDIAN COMMENTS HERE. WESTERN COUNTRIES SHALL BAN HATERS
Most interesting thing of this episode was quoting Brig Feroz Hasan Khan that Pakistan has never lost to India or has matched Indian army in every war,,,Okay then India must have requested Lt Gen A A K Niyazi to pretend as if he has surrendered with 93000 soldiers,,,,Kargil heights are still under Pakistan's control ,,, Strange ,,didn't know it,,,Thanks Col for making the things clear,,,,,Your point is to sit quietly and let Pakistan do whatever it thinks of,,,,Great,,,,but I fail to understand if Pakistan is so potent then why it doesn't decimate India,,,,
Col, always eagerly waiting for your videos. After all menace, hope is still there. In so many insane voices we hear logic. Keep it going.
Excellent analysis... India under Modi appears to be going in the wrong direction... It is not a smart move to engage in a confrontation with neighbouring countries such as Pakistan and China just to prove India's military strength or sheer ego. It should stay neutral with respect to USA, by militarily engaging with US and Europe, it is inviting the anger of Russia and China. USA is trying it's best to influence Modi so that India will not remain as a good partner in the BRICS.
Our leaders be it any field are very immature. They give any statement.
Pakistani are very mature that is they are begging for peace money etc.😊
What about the former PM , IK while addressing UN threatned the whole world with Nuclear war consequences if the K issue is not settled as per Pakistan’s terms ?
Excellent analysis as always. Always an education.
Am a German-Pakistani and a big Fan of u 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪☺️☺️☺️☺️War is never any Solution for any Country and the World doesn't need a Third World War.
Greetings Sir. War will be bad for both countries, already in dire straights of political and economic instability.
“To be an enemy of the US is dangerous, but to be a friend is Fatal “ - Henry Kissinger.
is that the reason Pakistan has been a slave of USA for close to 60 years?
India has an economy, Pakistan has none. War will be good for Indian industry.
@DrRashidQurash-ds8re Of course, thats why pakistan is still begging usa for loans.
You guys are in dire situation not us,yes war is bad but u have to understand that till now only pakistan has waged war to snatch kashmir, India is yet to go kinetic on POK, lets see what happens in future.
Bdw wholeheartedly agree with the 2nd point
@@KKPR533I guess this journalist work for USI😅😂😂😂
The best option is that the two countries should sort out all their maters on the table through negotiations and implementation. No body wants wars at the cost of people who need peace, harmony, for their next generations. It should end once and for all. The two governments should focus on developing their countries through cooperation with each other.
It's the Indians who don't want to settle the border issue because they know they don't have any logical or legal claim to a border a White man drew on a map with a pen. They would have to give up their fake claims to the border.
I, being a 77years old person, fail to understand the policies of the Indian leaders. Is it, not the time to resolve the petty issues between the two states instead of hype-creating efforts.
They are fascists
True
Even we young generation dont understand why Indian deep state wants fight with its neighbours?
We Indians had extended our hands of friendship several times & every times we Indians were backstabbed. Late Gen Zia ul Haq's militant policy in 1980s to bleed India through 1000 cuts & now it's our turn by PM Modi to isolate Pakistan in every spheres & every platforms & made them to beg. This is how it stands.
Chacha it is not hype creating but solid strategy to keep busy the whole 5 lakh strong pakistan army in its eastern border so that the baloch can operate freely in the western border . According to the Nsa Ajit dovals famous dialogue _if there will be another 26 / 11 , Balochistan would be a free nation . Just show me a day when pakistani soldiers have not been killed in the western front. At this rate the nuclear facilities of the khaibar pakhtunwa could be fall against them in the future . In that case pakistan would be in front of the scenario of a domestic nuclear war
Since you're too aged you must be knowing the full history behind India & Pakistan animosity.
A very insightful analysis by a honest and a highly intelligent indian retired army officer. Lets give peace a chance, before its too late.
You want to give peace a chance, then dismantle your terror infrastructure and stop your terror activities across the border.
He appears to be a Pakistani spokesman rather than an Indian analyst, absolutely detestable 😢
This means Pakistan can kick India's ass in case of war
@@behtreen6747 as in 1971 ?
@@satishghatpande no just like they kicked 2 years ago in swift retort and gave fantastic tea to abhinandan
@@satishghatpande1971 will happen to India.
‼️Coconut - Green chilli - Lemon Defence minister ‼️He disappeared when China occupied 4000 Sqkm of Indian land in Ladakh region ‼️
More rational voices like yours are needed in India and this world!
What an eye opener analysis .All shere s and dimensions have been identified and discussed rationally...Presence of such human is a blessing for subcontinent but if someone heed to it....Thank you Mr Sawhney...
Very honest remarks by Mr. Pravin. His analysis has been always based upon truth and reality.
If the United opposition in India in next elections makes BJP anxious about victory then this war scenario is most probable!!
Ye to phir aapke khatme ka nyota hai na fir? Phat bhi rahi hai aur burnol bhi nahi lagana… always victim card.
Well said, another balakot or worse comming in 2024
Lol those cr00ks got United in 2019 general election as well..
Result.. Couldn't get even 10 percent seats🤣🤣🤣
Modi led NDA got 343 seats and pappu led UPA got 51 seats.
Modi doesn't need it.. He is gonna win anyway.
What a wonderful man. I never came across such an Honest Defence Analyst from India. Respect from Pakistan
Wish our 2 countries spent more efforts and finances in lifting peoples poverty instead of perpetual hostilities which were inbuilt by partioner/s
Mr. Pravin always provide a true analysis of the situation. Excellent, Sir.
My question to you sir, is what will be the impact on Pak Army of the current disengagement of people's support and the hostile sentiments of people with the country's military leadership. Further to what extent China will come to aid Pakistan when now Pakistan clearly signaling its alliance with the US?
I urge Modi government stop provoking pakistan. There is limit in pakistan patience.
Indians should remember pak nukes
India is fortunate to have Pravin, but unfortunately there is very few people like Pravin who not only see the truth and fact, but also speak out in public
Among those “few” former PM of Pak Imran Khan also threatened the whole world at UN with Nuclear war consequences if the K issue was not settled as per Pak terms !!!
@@Indu-uw3nz2rt9ihe didn’t threaten . Why do u lie by omission ? He said if india attacks pakistan and if pakistan is cornered against the wall (basically admitting india in conventionally better than pakistan ) then pakistan could end up using nukes . And india tends not to
Attack , so that point is mute
Haha brainwash Indian keyboard warrior on comments 😂😂😂
Great analysis sir!
Round of applauds ,hope for all Indians to sanity
I am convinced that if they have an ounce of sanity in their heads - none of the leaders on either side would be dumb enough to attempt to destroy each other. I also know that they know, they have better things to do for their people, and therefore should stop barking at each other. 🙄
Superb vlog ,Sir, as always!
The statement by Mr. Rajnath Singh, is sure to ratchet up things. It also may happen at a time when the 2024 general election in India is less than a year away. Even a child can tell us that this statement is an out-of-turn one.
Both Mr.Modi and Mr.Rajnath Singh are fully aware of our forces' war preparedess and overall condition. They are also aware of the geo-strategics of Asia as well as Europe, as they happen to be at the moment.
These gentlemen have chosen to give ballistic statements which can only exacerbate things. It means they are being handled by someone behind them, who doesn't care much about scruples.
Since such things always had precedents in our country, these gentlemen are fully aware that they can get away from it all without being accountable to anyone. The most spectacular precedent to it is the Himalayan Blunder of the sixties, from which we never recovered.
Today, the status of these gentlemen reminds us of Zelinsky of Ukraine, who is being manipulated in a wholesale slaughter of his countrymen, just to appease those whose Russophobia needs some appeasement.
Are we Indians being set up to a similar fate, now that both Pakistan and China have set up a unified reinforced front against us? It is well and truly clear that the "player" who set us up on the Himalayan blunder, is quite up to his task again. Since on the geo-strategic level, both China and Russia have a tacit, reinforced front against this player. It is anybody's guess that after the curtains are drawn on the Ukraine theater, China is sure to raise the curtains on Taiwan.
Let us hope and pray, for sanity's sake, that we do not end up tangling ourselves into something from which we may never get out again.
Modi, Shah, and Rajnath Singh and the Indian polity in general are fully aware of the possible outcomes that you Pakis are ranting about.
It is not India but Pakistan that has set the war tone since 1947. That is due to its muslim psyche that considers slapping Kafir hindus once in a while directly as in 1947, 65, 71, & Kargil and indirectly thru its terrorists, sleeper cells. Its hatred for Hindus specifically bred thru its school curriculums leaves no space for reconcilliation and peace.
We have no enemity with China generally, except that IT CHOOSES to be opponent of India for factors of dominance.
But Pakistan is enemy of all non muslims, specifically Hindus in India and will never rest till it destroys. HENCE the need for us to be prepared for total war with it at all times and not baulk or cringe when push comes to shove.
Thank God some sane minds are present in India. Appreciate your well thought out comment and rational analysis encompassing any future disturbances between two nuclear armed nations. The "filmy dialogues" would not do any service to either of the country. Stay blessed Sir. Respect from Pakistan.
India has this sane voice but does Pakistan have an equivalence????? You indulge in terrorism and when India retaliates you take up the Nuclear card. You are much smaller so your destruction will be more comprehensive and complete. Balakot was in response to Phulwama. Always remember, India has always been preparing for a 2 1/2 front war. China, Pakistan and Jihadi terrorists. And every Passing day this preparedness grows stronger.
Sir PS ! I respect you
Your analysis always very strong and near to the real situation
You have assumed that India and world will be only spectators in case of the involvement of Chinese in Indo- Pak war.
Very incisive analysis indeed....INDIA SHOULD HAVE NO DOUBT.
We and western countries doubt that pakistan has nuclear weapons or not.😉😉😉
India when she will come, will come to kill . Like we did in 71. Did the US (or for that matter China) save you?
@@santhugowda7179You see INDIAN COMMENTS HERE. WESTERN COUNTRIES SHALL BAN HATERS
Teachers should explain that to the kids in school
Sir you are doing great job to stop war❤❤❤❤
Absolute pleasure listening to you
I wish you could Analyze Russian war in Ukraine and its implications
The election rhetoric has commenced. But how many times will Modi cry wolf? At our weakest in 71, we held India back. That was on 1-10 DISparity. Still is.
That's why 93000 pakistani soldiers surrendered against the 3000 Indian soldiers encircling the dhaaka city . India is the world's 4 th largest military power . According to the news x reports two divisions of the pakistan army have surrendered against the houthi rebels of the Yemen .
3000 soldiers in the city but lakhs around the border...why forget that?
@@jioboy2676 There is a difference between the having lakhs of soldiers in the border and lakhs of soldiers in the gate of Dhaaka . Mughal badshah Akbar's attempts to win east Bengal was failing for decades because supplying to a large army amidst so many rivers was not possible without a robust naval fleet and the maharaja Raja pratapaditya have very robust naval fleet . Even during the second word war Britishers sieged all boats from the area to stop a possible Japanese invasion from Burma to Kolkata . supplying food grains in to those areas were not possible from other parts of the country without the boats and that's how the whole tragedy of the great famine of Bengal was happened
@@jioboy2676 Even today Bangladesh have more than 400 rivers including 26 international rivers
@@amalchakrabarti2357 you have fallen in propaganda
There were 3 corps of Indians army ,one Corp of Pakistan army with 3 understrength and ill supplied army with around 40000 troops ,mukhti bahini numbered more than a lakh who were trained by Indians ,the Pakistan military was exhausted there ,there were around 150000 indian troops who attacked from all sides, your indian Congress man also stated that . US also has clarified it,only your media is lying.
Pakistan very fragile with crippling economy at present, thanks to Army Generals. Indian doesn't need to launch full fledge war against $$$ begging nation, but to strangle them economically.
How will non nuclear wapons of mass destruction will change things
Listening to Mr.Swahney one gets an impression that he only talks about the enemy’s strengths & our weakness. No where dose he talk about the measures to be taken by us( or taken by us ) to overcome these vulnerabilities !
Because he is an ISI agent
You are right. Either he is playing into the Chinese or Pakistani hands or he is seeking popularity among the India's enemies where ever they are scattered in the world. He calls Pakistan a responsible state and India a war monger. He always proves that in case of India's war with any of its two adversarial neighbors, India will be a sitting duck. Indian army is one of the best professional armies in the world. He has been in the Indian army. Is it not shocking? He only demoralizes the Indian army? I think he has some grudge against the Indian army.
All।this is psychological war
Nothing more and nothing less
I don't attach any importance to Raj Nath Singh's declamations
As of now I don't think the Indian military forces would cross the LOC
It may do so only in a situation when it's adversaries have become excessively weak
It is the fact the the USSR was not decimated in to 17 independent countries after loosing any major war .
@@amalchakrabarti2357 its a fact that it did AFTER loosing Afghan war! by the hands of Pakistan and US.
@@Blackbirdz2000 no how would fighting in afghanistan can disintegrate them they were fighting in others territory . It was USSR poor economic and social policies that cause the fall . Pakistan lives in its own bubble
@@VickyNaveen92 🤣keep believing that...same thing btw is happening with US right now.
Numerous outstanding videos by Mr. Sawhney each a honest analysis of India Pakistan situation. Indian big headed politicians can make the stupid mistake as elections loom there.
Sir the PAF only acquired the J10 in small numbers to train a greater number of pilots in case of a war the Pak government can approach the Chinese for more supplies of J10 aircraft.
Probably imf bail out packages are not meant for more j10 purchase . In the past they have cleared out that the money from imf bail out packages can't be used for the repayment of the Chinese loans .
According to the media reports j10 fighters cost around 45 million dollar per aircraft . According to the gen Mark Milly 20 f16 costs around 2 billion dollar or 100 million dollar per aircraft . According to the Dr quamar Cheema Chinese products are not the top of the line. Radar , electronic warfare systems and the weapons package of the Tejas mark 1a air craft is obtained from the Israeli f16 s
@@amalchakrabarti2357oye army k pas 1 trillion se zda undeclared economy hai yaha sara kuch un k pas hai,,ye discussion rubbish hai army pasya kayse pay kare ga,,
@@amalchakrabarti2357vo tab se drone manufactur kar rhe hai jab tera army soo rha tha around 2015
@@Shams-CA-WALA-LARKANo need to tell everything to Indians. Emotional na bano...calm down. Har baat sabko batayi nhi jati
I am Pakistani living at Islamabad having lot of respect for you being a realistic Analyst for strategic issues between Pakistan and India which must be considered by Indian Government. Furthermore , Modi PM and his colleagues are very by giving INDIAN PORTS TO USA during conflict between China and USA but it will further provoke China. Your assessment and research regarding current regional strategics among China, Pakistan and India are very appropriate. Thank you. I regularly watch your channel Foerce because of realistic Analyst.
We give about zero Fs if China gets provoked. Praveen Swamy is an entertainer who has developed a fan base by saying contrarian things. Off course Pakistanis love him.
I think his point is that an Indo-Pak war will in effect become US- China proxy war; if it happens Pakistan will still lose it by a very wide margin. Pakistan can expect some action in PoK after Modi comes to power in 2024.
@@suvrajyotigupta2368 will happen this year....or early next year
Irshad tumhare jaise gadho liye hi ye stooge khada kiya hai humne 😃
@DrRashidQurash-ds8re Bharat never has, and never will become the first to attack Pak or any other country. Pakistanis are unable to manage their internal affairs. Bharat needs to intervene and FIX Pakistan economically, so that Pakistanis can never repeat a Kargil or 26/11 type of attack on Bharat's soil.
@DrRashidQurash-ds8rePakistan deserves no mercy for what it's doing in Kashmir for decades and doing even now on daily basis where it's killing Hindus in Kashmir, sending arms through drones. It is a country that could have been eliminated long back.
Very very learned person
Thanks ,3cheers for calling *A Spade ;A Spade".
Provocations invite unnecessary risks, and create dubious hidden planning to inflict injuries in collaboration with Principal adversaries; rational approach doesn’t cost but it pays. He’s reasonably well presented his argument in this respect. Power needs to be preserved and used when necessary; and it doesn’t require verbal rhetoric.
I want to understand if nukes are kept assembled in ready to use state or they are dissembled and parts are kept in different places to prevent accidental use or as multiple layered safety and security measures?
Sir, I wonder what would be the policy/approach/response of US government on such action/or even plan of such action by India. Is it in US interest to have Pakistan, say, clearly defeated by India, or is it also in US interest to keep Pakistan strong enough (and not be defeated clearly on LoC) and use it as a credible risk factor for India to benefit in US dealings with India. Your analysis does not include US or Russia playing any role at all, are these two countries insignificant in this context??
At this point...US would support India...because it needs India for a long time.
So Dont expect anything from US
U.S./NATO support for Ukraine did not help Ukraine to win against Russia. India sandwiched between Pakistan and China will have a hard time gaining.
Excellent analysis by you!
Pakistan should not be taken so seriously till Pakistan army is in driver seat.... only Pakistanis who knows that Pakistan has no option to defeat India in conventional warfare are Pakistan army....any event of using nukes Pakistan will be disintegrated in many ethical States .
@@adamharris1406 Before the war the total defence budget of the Ukraine was just 3 billion dollars . Russia is always among the top 4 defence budget holders like india and the russia
A analysis by coward who want to silander infront of his opponent will give arguments like this....
Nuclear bluf will not work, only congress listen this bluf, if our any shoulder got injured by nuclear then we will destroy everything in Pakistan.
"Shoulder"... you really are a deluded fool. This is the problem with indians like you and all hindutva / bjp you talk a tough game but when the time comes you will be no where to be seen. Ask yourself this question if india really could take any territory then why has China taken 2000 sq klm of india. Your modi is the biggest coward and liar, "no territory has been taken". Why has india not taken kashmir, you have been shouting your filthy mouths for decades.what are you waiting for ?
Then whole of india will also be destroyed. It would be great for Bangladesh 😁
The Tambis especially that Tambi Muti was thinking that when they provoke the dragon, they can get away with it, without their ass issuing out smoke. Then they thought they too can provoke the oakis. One very important issue, the dragon may not make their butts smother, is because the dragon is humble & humane. The snake thought then they can start hissing : start showing their fangs about. When the dragon do react, even their ass won't be able to protect them.
Only 1 message to Indian nation, Modi and Indian army live with peace and let us Pakistanis live with Peace don't even think to put 1.70 Billion people lives in Danger..thankyou !
For you too message, focus on economy and people, forget about old issues of Kashmir. You have enough part of it. Also please pay attention to the Radical threat from all tanzeems who have all guns and no adversary to fight.
@@ajayrawat-bf9pc whatever they have...we'll take it one or the other way
Seems like , sir is very much concern about happiness of Pakistan and China Instead of INDIA .. you want INDIAN should bow on knees to Pakistan and China to fulfill their happiness. WOW ..👏👏👏
Clear you're too brainwashed that you didn't hear a word he said. He's an Indian patriot who actually is concerned about politicians turning the Indian army into a weak political force.
Plz make the same statement against China … And let’s see how brave you really are
Looks like all most all comments are from either Pakistan or China ..😂
Ofcourde cuz indians don't like to listen to he truth they follow youtubers who talk with emotions only and abuse nothing else
Best analysis as ever.
First You clear, you are side of india , Or side of Pakistan
India has crossed LOC, captured and returned Pak territory in past when Indian Army was not so strong.
Sir take care,stay blessed & safe
Immature,unreasonable and needless statements by Indian Ministers,Politicians and Generals; help the Pakistanis to better appreciate the inanity of its adversary and take suitable counter measures.
With each of Indian strategic development and bragging; Pakistanis,gradually and surely responded with effective counter developments.
Recall the broohaha created by the Cold Start Doctrine, the cool and determined pak strategist,countered them by tactical nuclear weapons.
Regardless of the political issues which the country is currently embroiled in,any misadventure on the part of Indians will be met with a response,the Indians will regret.
I congratulate Sawhney for an objective analysis of the situation and for trying to put sense in the puny heads of Indian strategists.
Dismantling Pakistan has ALWAYS been the dream of Indian govt and Indian Deep state. Do u know that or not?
And what if currently Indian govt n Indian Army has some other doctrine other than cold start...but they have kept it secret !! If they do war with the New doctrine strategy then it would be difficult for Pak to fight. Isn't it??
And pls be very careful...India may use Nukes this time..if both countries go to war and America wont support Pakistan this time...because America needs India for a very long time. Am saying this as an Indian.
What's your views on this?
I'm a staunch BJP supporter and admirer of PM Modi. But also respect your learned opinion Sir I salute your intellect and ask that Defense Ministry take this feedback very very seriously, If India is triggering Pakistani aggression, and using the Military as its vessel, then the least it can do is make sure the Military is ready to face the consequences of their actions. The fact the Indian army and the Indian government haven't been able to strategically mitigate and neutralize all threats in Jammu Kashmir is very concerning. This brings into question India's combat capability. Jai Hind!
Indians have nothing to worry about Pakistan army. It’s too busy in politics. So chill
Something to think about.
Sir, always good to see you.
A dispassionate analysis. India must listen to this gentleman and don't think of any misadventure.
All this analysis is meaningless if America strikes China with tactical nukes, which it will. America is not going to take a conventional route with China. How much support could China give Pakistan when it's busy trying to defend itself from US&Company. Is India doing anything RIGHT, why doesn't this guy talk about the capabilities of India. Government of India should look into the funding of this man.
He is communist.
He knows he is safe in India.
Salaam Sir.
I have a question.
Plz .what you thing in Near future Is there Possibility a short or Long War bt India and Pakistan if yes then why China Just quit on it.?
Mr. Rajnath Singh is a threat to the security of the region. PM Modi should ask for his resignation.
I am overseas Pakistani . If india this time start any adventure I will on field till my shahadat or till Delhi ,
Ask your hizda force to take on India,,,,Bajwa ke perr kaamp rahe the aur naathe par pasina tha ,,,,Ayaz sadik ne tumhari parliament me yahi kaha tha naa,,,,Bajwa has admitted on record that Pakistan can not indulge in war with India,,,,BTW you are invited to Indian border with coffin,,,
Brrrrrriliant always well done ✅ u 👍
...any way SAWHNEY SIR :
-----jaako PRABHU daarun dukh dehi....
....waaki matee pehle har layee....😮😢😮...!!!
[ ....again KUDOS for YOUR restless efforts...!!! ]
I don't understand how this Joker even got selected in Indian Army
It is emotional Indians like you that have brought Modi to power and peace at risk
@@huanghermann5207
With Pakistan as neighbour, peace was always at Risk
A wonderful and realistic analysis. You are absolutely right in saying that the BJP government must not involve the army or airforce into surgical strikes for political objectives . The assumption that Pakistan would not respond to any surgical strike would be just wishful thinking. Any strike is fraught the danger of serious escalation which can slip into full scale war ! It won’t be neither in the interest of Pakistan nor India . Surgical strikes with political objectives
can also go against BJP elections in 2024! It would be up to senior military commanders to stop Rajnath Singh from making provocative statements and not to go for any misadventure not designed for delivering any strategic results !.
We love your unbiased, balanced and pragmatic analysis. Godspeed
Pakistan and India shouldn't fight other power's war.( America and China)
NO party would be a winner, Pakistan and India should sit down and resolve there issues peacefully.
MAKE kashmir independent to resolve the kashmir issue.
Then why does India has Nuclear bombs? It is not for just show off. Those are real bombs Mr Pravin sawney. If Pak uses its first nuclear bomb it will be the last bomb it will ever use.
Strategic Arms Limitation Talks is a compelling need !
Excellent... Explanation... Sir... ❤🙏❤
Mr. Sawhney has over time built the following case : (1) that Pakistan is fully prepared to meet any war with India and that Pakistan has never really lost any war with us.(2) While deliberately omitting to state the fact the Pakistani bomb is nothing but a Chinese one and the battered Pakistani defence establishment is running on Chinese steam , he gives elaborate respect to the professionalism of Pakistan's defence forces and their strict decoupling of the nuclear system. This is such a dreadful claim. He has openly accused his own nation and govt for having retaliated to Pakistani terrorist istrikes by our Balakot ones , purely owing to BJP's political vote banks. He even hints that the " Modi Govt " ( not an elected Indian govt ) is likely to put us all to risk just for winning elections. And that Pakistan is right in warning us against such misadventure. If there is any moral low that Mr Sawhney has stooped to, this is it. His solution for Chinese aggression was equally untenable. He also says that the U.S. will exploit us badly. In short his refrain is that we are lost , destroyed and hopeless. Lets just bide our time, sue for peace and never hope to be self sufficient in defending ourselves. Mr Sawhney probably says " Submit to China , get teased and tossed around by its vassal state Pakistan at its master's behest , ignore their terrorist provocations, toe the China line in SCO, remain aligned to the Russians and get slapped around in public . Quad and Indo Pacific will rile the mighty Chinese mood. So stay away. Smoke the peace pipe and show that we are harmless idiots , so please don't hurt us.... May be Mr. Sawhney is right after all.. After all what could a nation of 1.40 bio do ? It is just a number you see. .. Great video. Really.
Fantastic analysis Col Saheb
As always great to watch the vlog excellent analysis of the subject. Thank you for this vlog.
War is madness and we need leaders who are not mad. Using nationalistic jingoism as a vote getting ploy is one thing to let such talk swing your cranial balance towards indiscreet action is another. Most wars were started by unrealistically overconfident leadership on one side underestimating the other. As examples I will cite WWI and Hitler's folly of attacking the USSR. Pakistan internally has many strengths which it has failed to acknowledge or utilize.
Mr. Sawhney yours is the voice of reason which should knock sense into decision making minds but unfortunately it is the Goswamis and the Bakhshis and vote seeking politicians whose oral nonsense holds sway - A dangerous trend.
It is in best interest of india to normalize relations with Pakistan. Forget that India can have walk over pakistan. This is different pakistan with battle hardened armed forces.
Why would PRC get in the middle of a war between India and Pakistan, unless the latter is losing badly and in danger of total collapse? The war in Ukraine is instructive in that Beijing has thus far walked a tight line in primarily backstopping Russia's economy but no massive support of the Russian military. Wouldn't that also be the case with Pakistan?
Conventional Military difference between India and Pakistan is huge. So to maintain balance in case of a war...China should help.
If during Pakistan's crisis times...China wont help...then is China Opportunistic friend?? Because a friend in need is a friend Indeed.
@@jioboy2676 Yes that's the case, if Russia was losing and close to a visible defeat, China would definitely step in as it cant afford to lose strategic ally. Similarly Pakistan is natural ally of China and CPEC has cemented this position. Plus India is continually drifting towards a US led Asian Nato directed at containing China, thus India has already positioned itself as a hostile force to China.
In Russia Ukrain case ..yes Russia was an ally just like Pakistan but Ukrain is not an enemy or serious threat foe china ...like India
In India -Pak case the enemy of Chinese ally is also the enemy of China itself ..and its in its backyard, US ally and a threat ..who is actively imvolved in US backed plan of China containment ...so China cannot afford to lost its ally and a pathway to indian ocean through CPEC and at the same time the strengthening of India.... A US backed china's enemy
...bcz if this happen Next target will be China, and US with the help of India will pose a serious threat to China's security as well as cantain it specialy in Indian ocean ....
India in Chinese Nackyard is the strongest card US have,and it can play to contain China ..
Pakistan is no ally bt a puppet pawn of China.. Which China would happily sacrifice.. for assurance from India's non involvement on western border when China invade taiwan🥱🥱🥱
Pakistan will never lose badly. It is capable of inflicting enough damage to dissuade India from attacking it.
What is unnecessary provocation? Militant inflation is not a provocation. I hear your thoughts but I not agree with you I feel you have......
And the terrorist attacks that India has been behind in Pakistan? Don't play all innocent when it's already been proved.
So, India had a lollypop army and digested ultra-provocation: 2008 attack in Mumbai!
Excellent analysis sir....
Sir. Ur analysis is honestly true. Every point u touched is 100% right. India has huge Military buildup but lacks Good Leadership. High commands are just holding positions like govt. Jobs duty. Poor Strategists. Shortsightedness leadership along with Politician poor thinking. Result is Kashmir.
Dear General, I follow you sir. In war nobody is winner..Afghanistan has suffered long enough..All of us should learn from two world wars. I disagree that China will help Pakistan. My dear GENERAL,,, it's a cruel reality,, nobody helps nobody, unless it is unavoidable in their own favour. Simple. India and Pakistan should follow give and take policy. Countries who sell arms to subcontinent,, DO NOT WANT PEACE between India and Pakistan.
China may support Pakistan through weapons m Intelligence but wont come to war directly.
And this time India may use Nukes to defeat Pakistan and de-moralize its people for many many years.
Allah se dua he ke aisa kuchh na ho..pls😢
Sir...Thanks..highjlighting..Reality.
Nukes should never be used, never never ever... May sanity prevail always..
Why?
@@pisablavatsky-cb3dd because I don't want you to be vaporized in a second
War is not good for both countries. Thanks for raising red flag for preventing stupidity under the influence of EGOS.
PLA restarting and gearing up work on its road / economic zones and ofcourse don't allow any interruptions on way to Gilgit baltistan area are close to it. Pakistan has given assurance for timely completion of the project. Pakistan is not a piece of pizza that can be eaten. Wise man is worried at metel level of Mudi who don't understand and don't think hazards of war.
Sorry don't underestimate NATO's strategy. Modi Biden meeting isn't normal meeting. I think that Modi gets support from West, especially USA . In India's so called neutral policy, they don't announce it publically.
Thank you
Thank you sir for meaning full information for Gover eating people’s
Can some one give raj nath a nudge n send him over the LOC asap n yes whole endian army is welcome to cross the border as this time more than fantastic tea is readily waiting for all visitors from endian especialy rafale riders👍
And in the face of such capability,india has no capability according to Parvin,it would seem.
10:04 they have identical war concepts because their senior leaders were products of the British Indian Military Academy.