Lack of strategic thinking defines Modi government's foreign policy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- Bottom Line with Pravin Sawhney delves into the complexities of India-China relations, dissecting the sequence of events post-Galwan killings. From the transformed foreign policy to the intricacies of the Line of Actual Control (LAC) disagreement, each segment explores critical aspects. Join us as we navigate the evolving dynamics between these two Asian giants. Subscribe for a comprehensive analysis shedding light on the challenges, hesitations, and delusional prospects of cooperation between India and China.
The DNA is typical of a faithful servant.
9:24 I agree, many Indians are still coolies of the west but not Mr Pravin.
Every Indian must visit China to see, feel, hear, touch and experience firsthand. China has a unique culture, growth & development - we Indians can learn a lot & progress forward by co-operating & co-existing with the present China as have so many others.
Unfortunately the incompetent n corrupt modi administration with their small minds n overblown egos has chosen the wrong partner who is only interested in using India as a pawn for their own imperialist ambitions
But what cost ? Learning is another thing but Asked Philippines what is the cost of friendship..
@@vividopte2190phillipines is an American vassal. India is not
Its is Communist Party causing problem not Chinese. All Indian govt Cong BJP wants peace but not dictators of China
@@vividopte2190The Philippines has always been a Western colony, until this day it’s under the USA colonialism… You should pay more attention 😂to
Mr Sawhney is an intelligent, levelled headed and down to earth man. He should be PM for India
As a Chinese, we don't even talk of India. Why Indians always want to treat China as their enemy?
A mixed of envy and fear. Instead of getting their acts together, most Indians tend to navel gaze about their potentials. Daydreaming of what they can be but not working on what they must do now.
India never existed in the far east and the west.
Because all of India’s neighbours are befriending China instead.
Ur govt is anti india , occupied our territory
Always do proxy war by puppet pakistan Maldives Nepal srilanka etc against India
Do fight keep unrest in border
And many things
They treat every country as their enemy
Playing geostrategic games with China is no cake-walk even for the imperialistic west, so it appears Jaishankar & co have dug themselves into an unfathomable hole impossible to claw out of without making major concessions….
Incompetent n corrupt leaders with their small minds n overblown egos r just some of the reasons why India has fallen so far behind China in almost every sphere of development.
By choosing to board a sinking ship, any hopes for the long suffering Indians to have a better life r sealed
Quite the opposite, India has too much strategic thinking and lacks inward Indian thinking. There are two obvious evidences. One is that India strategically benefitted between the US and Russia. Two is that India didn't make any of Mao's mistakes, not even a single one of Mao's mistakes, because India has strategically done more outside of India and less inside of India. Obviously, you make fewer or no mistakes in your house when you do more outside and less inside of your home.
India is NOT the one having trouble now, genius! India is buying weapons from BOTH Russia and the US. India is SELLING Russian oil to the West. That is how successful India's foreign policy is now!
@@yaoliang1580don't worry about us put ur nose in ur house.....MF xi bot
Thanks captain sir of Indian military for educating Pakistanis and peaceful community members.. they need more education.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
👍🏻
Blaming Modi for everyrhing maynot be correct. Coz, the one scripting the policies are Jaishankar. Or maybe he is just implementing the policies he gets forwared from the US?
And when talking about Jaishankar, it would be foolish to ignore his son, who works for the US thinktank and lives in the US, or his role & influence
Is there any other country of India's stature whose FM/policy maker's son is on US salary?
During the Galwan crisis, naturally, it was the US and Congress, as the main opposition party, who was pushing for the Indian Govt to act militarily against China.
Congress targeting the PM was understandable, because, everyone knows that a war with China will be disastrous and that it will lead to the end of political career of any sitting PM. In this case, Modi.
The only one who was pushing for a peaceful resolution to the Galwan crisis was Russia.
Apart from other reasons, they likely sensed the US gameplan of grabbing the oppertunity to initiate an Indo-China conflict, An Indo-China conflict is basically two birds in one shot for the US.
In my opinion, if there is anyone to be blamed for the Indo China relations and tensions, its not Modi, its Jaishankar. Jaishankar is the single biggest obstacle in normalisation of India China relationship and for a peaceful settlement of issues.
Do be aware that whatever decisions made by the FM has to be approved by the PM. So the PM has the final say.
This guy is a Chinese paid and lies a lot. India & China both agreed to pull back troops from Doklam just like Panag Tso. Here is the complete details:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_China%E2%80%93India_border_standoff
@yaoliang1580 problem is PM cannot understand any strategic issue, consider him Autistic in this case,
As a newbie, be grateful if u could preface via definite or anecdotal argument or point to ref. as such? (re: JS and besides well known US proxy tip) Thank you.
Yea cos you eat wumaos poo
His policy could have been dictated by his Japanese wife at the behest of her Japanese government which doesn't want India and China to cooperate because it would weaken Japan's and the US position against China.
Throughout history, wives always have the capacity to influence the man.
Any wonder why he loves a Japanese woman but not an Indian woman.
Just say it to your master that to return it's occupied Ladakh section to India and India will cooperate with them happily.
Yes, pakistan occupied Kashmir and aksai chin vacate and hand over to india. Chinese and pakistani problem solve and india will be best friend.
West plan flop😊
@@sanjoytudu3693 India need to accept that it isn't the British empire anymore. the border between China and India should follow the geographical line as agreed by the 2 newly independent government to break with the old western imperialism. that was the argument India gave for taking Lhoyu which is historically under chinese dominion, Lhoyu could not possibly belong to India if we accept the border should follow historical ownership. it is more logical for India to accept the current border as India would actually have gain territory if the current line of control is formalised as the border. it also make great scene security wise to follow the geographical divide which is why India suggested that in the first place, it easier to defend a mountain then it is to defend the historic border as if we were to return to that, China will have territory on the south side of the mountain.
@@sanjoytudu3693
Brainwashed Hindu 🤭
Yath raja tatha his foreign minister ... It is Hard to believe Mr JaiShankar qualified to serve in indian diplomatic service . Was it because of his family connections ?
The incompetent n corrupt Indian political system, which is full of cronyism and nepotism are just some of the reasons why India has fallen so far behind China in almost every sphere of development
Because, like the rest of his colleagues in Modi's ministries, he does whatever makes Modi look "tought"
@@SimonFranck100 Hiding yourself behind western name; yet you don't know how to use google translator. Pathetic, it is tough not "tought" whatever that means.
He was a professional civil servant in the Indian Foreign Service.
So, no. Not family connection.
Agreeing or not with the policy should be kept separate.
@@homeentProfessional ? Mr Jai Shankar seems to give a different meaning to the term professional !!
Dr. Sawhney, thanks for doing a realistic snapshot of the Inida-China border developments/mistrust. It seems that the Indian Ministry of External Affairs is run by a man who has a very narrow perspective, which also shows the Indian PM's inability to comprehend the challenges India has landed under his handpicked MEA, Mr Jaishankar. India can never be a counterweight to China in the next 30 years, and the game will be over for the US by that time, much sooner.
India is an excellent country of brilliant people; it can do better than what it is doing at home and abroad. The current mistrust with China will cost India two trillion dollars in the next two decades in terms of lost opportunity, useless weapons programmes and neglecting social programs and infrastructure upgrades at home to boost industrial production and improve the joblessness situation for its masses. It is mind-boggling to understand how a career diplomat can make such Foreign Policy blunders that would result in two lost decades of development and poverty eradication. If the Indian foreign policy had been in sound hands in the past 12 years, India could have had a prosperous future by now and a more viable economic future that the people of India deserve. Dr. Sawhney, I anxiously await part two of your analysis on India-Chin in the context of Mr. Jaishankar's book.
I like to thank captain sir for educating Pakistanis and peaceful community members.. they need education...
@@biswajitbordoloi8092 Absolutely and I hope the people in South Block have the brains to comprehend what Dr. Sawhney is saying.
@@zaffazad4040 do you know how tough is UPSC exam in India that leads bright Indian minds to become a top diplomats of india??? I bet Mr Sawhney couldn't even pass the preliminary round of that exam. He is Just another military man... Only Pakistani military has roles in foreign affairs not in India.... India is producing best civilian minds in every sector. From science and technology to education to foreign affairs to politics.. so chill...
@@biswajitbordoloi8092 I know quite a bit about the IAS Exams and selection procedure, and the US and Canadian federal services; Mr Jaishankar proved very shallow in his dealings on the international scene at home and abroad. Just take off your Indian lens and look around, you will find brilliant Indians that will your mind. The current Indian MEA, Interior Minister, NSA and Defence Minister are an embarrassment.
@@zaffazad4040 this is your opinion... Now Indians don't need approval from white Europeans.. during the days of previous regime many Indians who are centre to left leaning people need validation from USA or Europe.. it is not the case right now...
Very good views, Indian medias has always portrayed China to be the agressor at the border, but the India gov. is the initiator. Hope the Indian public would know the truth.
The truth will never be allowed in the main stream media just like the truth on the 1962 war. China the defender becomes the aggressor and accused as being a backstabber.
Who attacked India in 1962, 1967... This guy is a Chinese paid and lies a lot. India & China both agreed to pull back troops from Doklam just like Panag Tso. Here is the complete details:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_China%E2%80%93India_border_standoff
Why did China usurp Tibet and more than half of Mongolia? Today China is 3 times its original size and still has ambitions to grow territory. Don’t talk nonsense and smell the coffee. The only way to save yourself from China is to be prepared to take them on and show courage
Chinese agent.
What a joke, you're a small time CCP sheeps😂
Excellent analysis. India's unilateral actions were the cause of Galwan debacle. India must listen intellectuals like Pravin Sawhney.
Agreed but it won't. India is in the grip of a neo-fascist fever that has blurred its sight to what is actually in its strategic national interest.
This guy is a Chinese paid and lies a lot. India & China both agreed to pull back troops from Doklam just like Panag Tso. Here is the complete details:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_China%E2%80%93India_border_standoff
Tune Iski videos dekhi hai pehle? Mene iski videos 1 saal se dekhi Ye hamesha China ki tareef krta hai isko lagta hai China kuch galat hi nahi krta. Aur hamari Government ya Foreign Ministry ko Downplay krta hai. Iski 1 saal pehle ki Video dekho yehi sab milega same to same language Ye kabhi bhi China ke Against nahi bolta kabhi nahi.
Aur Ha Ye comments ko shadowban krta hai.
Quite the opposite, India has too much strategic thinking and lacks inward Indian thinking. There are two obvious evidences. One is that India strategically benefitted between the US and Russia. Two is that India didn't make any of Mao's mistakes, not even a single one of Mao's mistakes, because India has strategically done more outside of India and less inside of India. Obviously, you make fewer or no mistakes in your house when you do more outside and less inside of your home.
Just change one word in the “Line of Actual Control “ to “Line of Mutual Control “. Let’s agree to a neutral and demilitarized zone. With modern military, heights just meant easy attack points. Let both sides make it the zone of free trade, to truly for the uprising of both citizens.
Jaishankar is a schoolboy compared to the wise old men of China.
😂😂😂😂uyghurs r the smartest😂😂
Excellent. So insightful. Eagerly awaiting your next installment. Thank you, Mr Sawhney.
India/Modi wants to be a part of the Rules Based Order Indo-Pacific Club. Settling differences with China & extending co-operation will be looked upon unfavorably by the USA.
China - India peace & co-operation is far less 'vote-catching' in Indian elections than imagining an independent India super-power..
@@absolootely2571.... India will take many decades to crawl along to be anything super except perhaps super pooper.
Modi is an illiterate puppet of Adani
@@absolootely2571as in many other countries, the ignorant public are always taken for a ride by the lies of their corrupt leaders fake news propaganda as they lack the ability to evaluate the validity of what they are being told
Rules based order is benefiting western nations not others, and western willingness to have normal relations with dubious regimes and outright genocidal ones creates a farce that India can do well without
Just negotiate a settlement. This problem was created by the British when it arbitrarily drew the Mac Mohan line without consulting all parties. As Voltaire said " In a prolonged dispute both sides are wrong"
British and Tibet agreed on border Mc Mahon line. China after occupying Tibet dont agree. They want whole Himalaya
@@nirmalbhel3231
Nope, Snakey india knowingly use the illegal Mac Mohan line to illegal Occupy China's land and indians knows that they are gaining on China's land without legal action
Fake bots ...
@@nirmalbhel3231 British never agree. the governor of India made that agreement, it was submitted to London, but London did not ratify. in 2008 the UK government formally stated that it the mcmahon line was not a treaty line. invalidating India ability to claim that was the British border.
@@nirmalbhel3231 Tibet was colonized by Britain then. Tibet has been under China since the 1700.
However, the important to understand is that British planned traps of conflicts for India (and Pakistan) and China before it left. You are just falling into the traps.
indian think they are equal to china. but in reality they are other countries that are bigger power than india in asia like japan, s.korea, singapore, etc.. 🤣🤣
😂😂😂I'm laughing at you calling Singapore a power in Asia 😂😂😂no way japan is as strong as india neither Korea is japan has better navy rest all things are indias better
@@Shashank-g6i If you can't understand what he's saying, obviously WION is more suited for you. Watching this channel requires some education.😥😥
@@Shashank-g6i.... there's one thing I and many others knows Indians does the best.....super poopers.
@@gaosunibuWION is India's monkey channel.
Singapore?? Korea??? Have u lost your reasoning. S. Korea can't even counter one least developed adversary without US in their own backyard. India has to deal with bunch of highly developed adversaries & still managing.
China has land border with 14 nations, the most in the world.
It has settled land sputes with all its neighbors except for India and Bhutan. Bhutan is about to settle its land dispute with China, as we type.
There is no reason why the land dispute between India and China cannot not be solved.
I recently read Pravin Sawhney's book, " The Last War." Just like this video, that book is more about politics than policy. Mr. Sawhney is wrong. Congress party was in power for close to 65 years and started from Nehru none of the Congress's leaders solved any issues. Starting from Nehru, they all generated problems for our country. The party has an abysmal record on the defense and Indian security. Just like Rahul's (Pappu) speeches, Sawhney likes to defame our armed forces for political gains. Our Foreign Minister, S. Jaishanker Ji is the best foreign minister India ever had.
Are you a modi bhagt, an illiterate PM
He was a failure and more of a hack during his service years. He came from Short Service and cashing on his military service to get rich. He was the middle man for all the weapons procurement corruption in congress, had unfettered access to power corridors. Congress is and was so corrupt they were always looking for 30%. He ensured how Gand-hi's can make that money. He never talks or write about his own experience, has nothing to write about. He was "Coasting" with uniform.
China is 50 years ahead of India. In every aspect, it is mighty big force. India should be happy with mandir creation and religious toxicity among people.
India has potential to outpace China.... Its the Indian leaders that don't want to take India in that route. They want to keep the population under tight strategic control.
Love to hear your analysis, please make it like thrice or so in a week, because of the so unpredictable geo scenario. ❤ From Nepal.
As a student of geo politics I would love to meet Mr Sawhney and learn from him.
Your career aint gonna go anywhere if you learn from this hack.
Thankful for voices like you Mr Sawhney. The faster indians get off the euphoria train the better
An excellent and unbiased balance opinion from Pravin Sawhney. Only if level-headed Indians would learn to take in such advices. India need more of these balance views and opinions instead of trying to project their strengths only. Be humble and be a good neighbour. India can change friends but cannot change her neighbour. Dont be used by US to destabilise the region.
Could u expand on your comment with reference, for a noob. Thank you in advance.
This is not how you get victory
@@ChandanMishra-ql1bi what victory do India want？do you honestly believe that US will come to your aid? stop your dau dreaming.
He is a paid Chinese & Pakistani agent. He keeps praising China and Pakistan and keeps telling India and Indian policies are bad. Please note whole world is happy with India's stand. Only a few Chinese living outside of China, few Pakistani and a few Indian agents praises this guy.
US is not against neither Russia. After Galwan incident, India got better and China is declining. Only China and Pakistan are not happy with India's move. India will do what is good for India, will buy crude from Russia, refine them in India and will sell to US Europe.
@@1desboon😂level headed Indians🇮🇳 i am sure you mean seculars who depend on India but hate it and work against India 🇮🇳
As always, excellent review with insightful analysis of facts.
Haha no strategic clarity?
Cooperation is a clear strategic clarity. The current India throwing that away and treat China as a frenemy, wishy washy between colluding with the west against Asians and trying to make itself look powerful and refusing to cooperate with China to mutual benefits, is a clear lack of strategic clarity.
What do you want, India? Do you want cooperation and long term peace and development, or conflict, intransigence and war?
India is the weakest link in Asian Solidarity
Damn, this comment section do be really a Sino-Pak circlejerk
When S. Jaishankar is there in main stream of Indian government, this is obvious that its neighbours will not be kept in normal conditions, rather in tense conditions and live with bad relations like it had been in Nepal when he happened to be Indian Ambassador to Nepal. So see case of Mauritius and now burning Bangladesh..
God bless us.
Millions Chinese people invested and worked overseas ， some people claimed that Chinese people doesn't know what happen around the world
The amount of discomfort in the neighborhood is a testament of how disastrously dr S.jaishankar has led the ministry of external affairs. Not to mention, losing a highly important strategic point in the maldives.
I can feel your pain and where u r coming from and the guys in th evideo also . Burn is real
@@shivanandacademia3460 actually its the GOI that is feeling the heat. Maldives a country that you have to zoom in 3x to see in google, insulted the world's largest democracy.
Taiwan a small country just held general elections.....insulting your master CCP. Philippines too is doing the same. Yemen is insulting USA, Ukraine is insulting Russia, Niger is insulting France, the list is long....@@farissyed4564
@@farissyed4564 the muizzu guy knew where to bark that is it. India can take over the island in a day when it needs, he just sold his people to chinese for a few election points.
@@farissyed4564 How GOI feeling the heat . Infact it is a good marketing strategy for laxdeep rourism. In has nothing lose here
Why are the comments onesided and replies, presumably contrary, all removed? That surely comes out as propagandist.
I've just posted a comment, I hope they won't remove it as I've also written a genuine comment. It refutes his argument.
Yes copy the comments paste it again & again 😂😂
And I've noticed couple similar Pakistani and Chinese accounts commenting on every vid in a similar Pattern.
Indian forgot the indo china border was drawn by British empire Chinese land had been annexed by British India
As always you are full of knowledge, and brilliant analysis. Thank you Sir ❤
This guy is a Chinese paid and lies a lot. India & China both agreed to pull back troops from Doklam just like Panag Tso. Here is the complete details:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_China%E2%80%93India_border_standoff
I have watched a few of these presentations and one way to summarize the presenter's conclusion is that Indians (and their media) prefer style over substance. Indians continually claim victory but actually are losing over and over again. The Indian government understands this but obfuscates that fact for the Indian people.
Typical Chinese😂😂😂😂
Most of you guys aren't even 5ft tall but you talk like you're some big guys but you're nothing but a CCP slave 😂
i call BS on chinese foreign policy guys informing Indian foreign policy guys ,PLA won't accept if it is not termed "line of actual control" in 1993.
India need to fix himself, discrimination for minority, lot of Indian mess internal and external. 🇨🇳 is moving very fast, we are observing their progress from last 13 years personally. They will cross USA in GDP is just time, are 10 to 20 year. They need to learn a lot from USA and we are providing them all what they need but their is gap still a lot but with every passing day it is closing. As a nation 🇨🇳 is not disarray ad Indians.
Pakistan need not to fix itself. Because it is doing great with Christian Church and Hindu temples.
Please continue guys prove yourself an islamic state.😉😉😉😉
@@santhugowda7179 be on topic, genocidal behavior and supporting those nations are like slow poisoning nation that what Modi is doing with India, nations full of intelligent people but ruled by MOB and Killer unfortunately, sad story.
Paxtani ke alag chonchle😂😂
@@fakhrealam2008bsdk apne paxtan ka haal dekh, cheeni ghulami ka koi fayda nhi...arbi,turki,amreeki ghulami se koi fayda hua aaj tak?
@@fakhrealam2008genocidal behaviour is shown by pak army against its own population, thats why Balochistan,KPK and GB is up in arms
Jashankar is just an over rated foreign minister by the West and the Indians themselves. He is a smooth talker that's all.
China has foreign and defence ministers who disappear overnight. Never to be seen again. Go preach elsewhere 😂😂😂
Totally agree ! He speaks well but no substance
Not China... Japan, France, Switzerland, Nordic Nations, Italy, Spain, Germany, what the hell is this man rambling
Interesting view, well presented. Only in India, as a democratic country, you have the freedom to express such an opinion, in China, you would be serving a long term in prison.
China is intimidating all its neighbours so recognise that is how China operates and India has no option but to stand steadfast against Chinese aggression.
@monipenny408can u write xinnie the pooh on weibo 😂😂
@monipenny408 well to be frank.. Gandhi had more freedom than Chinese under mao.
One can only progress with the truth and openness. Look where China is today and where is India?
@@Capt-tn9betruth in a commie country😂😂, bro CCP is the epitome of everything opposite of truth nd what not😂
Xhina open nd truthful country😂😂😂😂
@@KKPR533 How do you know? Or you believe everything you see in the media? Do you think that makes you smart?
Sire Kudos to you. Sir we have a serous problem in our highest echelon as follows:
Modi=M, Amit=A, Devol=D -- MAD Policy Issue
(Andar Andar baat Chali Hai, Baat Chali Hai - Pata Chala Hai CHADDI PAAHAN Kay Phool Khilla Hai Phool Khilla Hai)
If your relationship with your neighbors is not good, you can't live your life in peace and harmony. Ultimately your health will be deteriorated.
bureaucrats shouldn't be made foreign minister. Jai shakar is good in giving befitting replies. Jai shakar lacks real substance
India wants a settlement on the border issue with China, but also did not want to settle the border issue. It sounds contradictory. Let me explain. India wants to settle the border issue with China on India's term. No compromises. India's term is to accept the border as drawn by an Englishman during the peak of the British Empire. ie, what belongs to India is decided by an Englishman. Period. India thinks this is the only solution.
There is no other option, that is why, if China refuses to accept this Indian term, there will be no settlement.
Would China allow its territories to be cut off by the stroke of the pen of an Englishman? This is the arrogance and delusion of India, thinking that it is a superpower more powerful than China and wanted to dictate terms with China.
China has now completely ignored India and would not want to talk to India on the border issue and let India continues with its wet dream.
In realpolitik, India at best is a third rate power! India is acting and behaving like Mickey Mouse in the cartoons, thinking that it is big and powerful and can mess around with the cat. In the real world, the cat will eat India for breakfast.
Indian has political system need something to be popular to be on the top while China has leadership system need dedication and capability to be on top..best village leader will be district leader then regency leader/mayor and all the way to the top..election only on grass root level..china like to discuss look for the best solution..others do protests just to be listen but no solution. Protest without solution is absurd. If you know the solution wiser to discuss then protest. Manner is very important...harmony very important...we are east society should be more civilized. If the leader doing good dont need to change just like great CEO.
The Indian political system is too toxic, fragmented, corrupt and is moving their country towards self destruction
in democracy, many leader also grew from the grassroot up. i feel the difference is as chinese leader get promoted, they are usually force to move to an office in another part of the country, this force them to learn and understand the problem plaguing all part of China while denying them a "political stronghold" since they will never stay in one province for over a decade. so when they reach the top, they wouldn't be bias to certain states or interest since they are exposed to all part of the country.
it remind me of how military would rotate it officers, it not only breed meritocracy but also reduce the localization of power.
@@lagrangewei also be aware that any political system whether democracy or autocratic is only as good as those who are running the show.
@@lagrangewei mostly democracy mean must obey political party..and political party must obey the elite bussinesmen/ donatours. So basicly from elites for the elites to the elites. And their media keep saying from/for/ to the peoples. In China goverment control the elites. The real meaning commounist is community ..to bring prosperity to as many peoples as possible and capitalists/western make sure that not gonna works. They educating us their version of democracy..always elect every several years so the elites can control output of election any countries they want based on their interest. Remember banana republic,regime change etc etc..
Tianmen square residents nd uyghurs r the model citizens of china😂😂
Millions Chinese people studies oversea and some people claimed Chinese people doesn't know about the world
Indian's foreign policy recently looks like in shamble.
Chinese and pakistani foreign policy is cease fire.
Please cease fire please 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@santhugowda7179China took your territory in 2020....Pakistan bombed you and captured your pilot in 2019.
You are talking nonsense.
Didn't India sign three major military agreements with the US? So what does Jaishankar think the US will do for India, that it did not do for Ukraine? What is really behind India's great craving to make the US see India as a counterweight to China?
Freedom for tibetans , uyghurs first
@@offred6013 they are doing very well, with freedom to go anywhere around the world
Indians have huge delusions of grandeur about themselves. They think the americans are going to back them in a war against China. The americans are just using the indians to fight China, the indians need to wake up and look at Ukraine. India has no friends on it's own doorstep, now why is that?... it's all because of india's own behaviour.
Indians have huge delusions of grandeur about themselves. They think the americans are going to back them in a war against China. The americans are just using the indians to fight China, the indians need to wake up and look at Ukraine. India has no friends on it's own doorstep, now why is that?... it's all because of india's own behaviour.
India hopes to gain from the revelry between China and the US.
America NEEDS India in its effort to contain China.
America never likes any #2 to get too close to itself in competitiveness.
India offers to "help".
my Question that bothers me all these time is : Where is QUAD? what happen to it? they only have 1 talk last year and never seen again.
Person who doesn't know difference between LAC and LOC shouldn't dictate geopolitics.
China is my master , it gives me my daily bread, China can never can do any wrong. China has a right to the territory of 17 nations which it claims and the South China sea belongs only to China because it has more military power. Hope everyone gets it once and for all, because the same theme gets repeated with a lot of unnecessary talk.
It would have been more understandable if you had a map with your commentary ... but great job nonetheless!
India (Republic of India) didn't exist before 1947. Italy didn't exist before 1860. Turkey didn't exist before 1922, Germany didn't exist before 1871, Saudi Arabia didn't exist before 1932 and so on. Concept of Countries was invented in Europe in the 18th century. Before the invention of the concept of countries, there were only empires and kingdoms everywhere around world. Germany, France, Italy, Austria, Denmark, Poland, Switzerland, Slovenia, Netherlands, lechesiten etc were created after fall of Holy Roman empire and subsequent kingdoms in Europe.
After the fall of the Ottomans empire in 1922, many countries were created based on their nationalities.Saudi Arabia didn't exist When Prophet Muhammad was born in Mecca.Turkey was created in 1923 and Saudi Arabia was created in 1932 after the fall of Ottomans Empire in 1922. Europe and Middle East was united under various empires and kingdoms for most of the history just like India. India was the name for the region east to river Indus. It was never a country before 1947 but a region or subcontinent where various empires and kingdoms existed just like in Europe, Middle East or other parts and continents of world.
Now the question is what is nation and nationality? A nation is a society that shares a common language, culture, and history and has shared interests. For example English, German, Italian, Turkish, French, Russian, Dutch, Spanish, Arabs, Persian, Kurds, Japanese, Korean, Punjabi, kashmiri, Marathi, Bengali, Tamil, Malyalam, Thai etc are nations and a country based on single nation or nationality or where a single nationality dominates culturally, politically, in economy and military is called a nation state. Most countries in Europe or 'civilised world' are based on single nationalities and are nation states or simply called nations.
There are dozens of nations within India and Pakistan. And hence India and Pakistan are union of nations or multinational countries. Nations are Punjab, Kashmir, sindh, Baluchistan, Gujarat, Bengal, Maharashtra, Tamilnadu etc. And in modern civilised world countries are created on basis of nationality like the countries in Europe (England, France, Germany, Poland, Norway, Sweden, Croatia etc) or in Asia (Korea, Japan, China,Thailand, Philippines etc) and Bangladesh etc are countries based on nationalities.
Among the 650 major nations in the world, the nations in the union of India are one of the largest nations in the world. After Han Chinese Mandrain, Spanish, Anglo Saxons English, and Arabic
Bengali - world's 5th largest nationality
Punjabi- 10th largest nationality in world
Marathi- 13th largest nationality in world
Hindustani- 14th largest
Telugu- 15th largest nationality
Tamil- 17th largest nationality in world
Gujarati- 24th largest nationality in world
Bhojpuri- 25th largest
Kannada- 29thth largest
Malyalam- 30th largest
Oriya- 32nd largest
Maithili- 40th largest
Awadhi- 46th largest
Assamese- 65th largest
Haryanvi, Marwari, Magahi, Deccan, etc in top 100 nationalities of world.
(Hindi, Urdu are not nationalities but artificial languages developed from Hindustani language and imposed on some nations in some regions, with only few native speakers. These regions have their own nationalities and languages. Hindustani is a nationality in western Uttar pradesh with Hindustani as native language).
Republic of India was created in 1947 out of the British Indian empire on the basis of two nations bogus theory. Two nations were assumed as Islam and hindusim. But in reality, Islam and Hinduism are not nations. India and Pakistan were not created based on nationalities but on two nation (Islam Hinduism) bogus theory. Hence, these countries are based on religions. On the other hand, Bangladesh is a nation state which was created on the basis of Bangla nationality in 1971 (5th biggest nationality in world). British empire changed ownership rights in 1947
Three predominant civilisations in Republic of India, Indo Aryans, Dravidian and Sino Tibetic ( North East nations in the Republic of India) don't share anything although the first two civilisations share religion hence religion is the biggest binding force of the country followed by Military Power which is used to occupy non Hindu nations (Punjab, Kashmir, Nagaland, Mizoram, Meghalaya) with the country. Most of Hindus in Indian subcontinent prefer religion over their nationalities unlike muslims (Kashmiri, Bangla, Baluch, Sindhi, Pashto) who identify themselves with their nationalities and even support nation states like Bangladesh.
According to research, Higher ethnic or national diversity within a country negatively affects economic growth through conflict between interests of various nations or ethnicities (Don't confuse the ethnic or national diversity with the multiculturalism in west due to migration, the migrants mix with diverse society and become part of nationality of the host country and work for the interests of the dominant nationality).
High 'nationality or ethnic' Diversity correlates with low GDP per capita.
Strong democracy correlates with ethnic or national homogeneity.
Punjab and Kashmir should be a free countries based on Punjabi and Kashmiri nationalities like Bangladesh
Very interesting data & history there. The conclusions are tenuous at best but thank you for making the effort & taking the time to share. 👏
@controversial1994 conclusion is much bigger. It's just an excerpt from the large pdf book I been writing on concept of nations and nation states.
In fact Bangladesh is a more stable nation because it possess a single identity Bengali contrast to a republic like India with many nations, languages and religion.
And may explain why Bangladesh is able to progress faster in the last 5-10 years economically as a result of it unity of people and religion.
GDP per capital of Bangladesh have surpass India's.
I understand and agree up to the point that there are several nations within India. That is why it is called Union of India.
I disagree with you to spilt Indian country or its people. India is Free democratic country. we suffer, we will change policies but we move towards better democracy. There might be situations of autocratic and ideological or religious forces take power and try to push India into one direction. But Indians should stand together with each of their individualities.
@kathirko Every nation has right to self determination.
You can stay in Union of India if you wish but you can't force others to be subservient to you. And it's not you who would decide if India is good and democratic for them. They would decide for themselves.
It's not the Pakistan that would decide if its democratic and good for bangla nation of East Pakistan, it's the bangla nation of former East Pakistan that would decide what is Pakistan for them.
You Indi*ans got 3*rd world mentality, whereby you can't tolerate right to self determination and freedom of others. You can't live in coexistence. Either you fit as sla*ves or wana ens*lave others.
Jai shankar is the Wazir who always praise his king.
His spouse is nuke mutant, so he must be contaminated too..
" Lack of strategic thinking defines Modi Government 's Foreign Policy"
Cannot agree any more!
Excellently summed up in 9 words.
Whole world is praising Modi Govt... only few guys disagree
Love for Modi defines India right now
@@SimonFranck100 He gonna Win again. We will make sure he win
Cannot agree anymore means you don't agree.
You're getting desperate and it's obvious now
"They were looking for a peaceful way out"..I am not being on the side of the Chinese!!! When were you ever on the side of India?
Jaishankar is nothing more than a translator for PM.
My respect to you for telling the truth! A hard thing to do when populism sells
If you ask most Chinese what they think of India, "opponent" or "enemy" are probably the last word they come up with. America, maybe, but still can work with. Why make enemies while you can make friends?
A nation very often must choose wisely between the leaders that make the people feel good, and the leaders actually work for the good of the people.
Ha ha Xi will degrade ur social rating😂😂😂
@monipenny408I have read most of your posted comments, and you come across as a smart, intelligent person.
Thanks for your painstaking research and unbiased analysis. If only there are more brave and honest gentlemen like you in the delusional Indian leadership, who think with their hearts instead of ther heads, India would have realized her great potentials years ago and would be a true leader of the South. Please keep up your excellent work and unbiased views. Thank you!!
Yes. Chinese bots . If anyone is delusional here chootiya Xi and his Chinese bots
Fascinating explanation of these complex events.
I don't agree with your POV, before Modi govt, the border development along the McMohan-line(which didn't exist earlier until China attacked India in 1965) was so rapidly done by China, I ask you why? And these Roads are made to move "heavy machineries"(only for peaceful act, right?), we shouldn't act like a pigeon or an ostrich which hides its face whenever there is threat. We should act quickly which the Modi govt did by developing border Roads. While doing this, China was objecting these border developments, which should not be done if it's within our territory. Therefore, People like you should stop putting the onus of this on India. If China really cares about India- China relationship then it should
1) Stop doing infrastructure projects in POK under CPEC, We don't care if China spends 50-100-200 Billion investment in Pakistan but not within India's territory.
2) Stop building military level infrastructure near the border, if you(China) don't then India will do what it needs to do.
3) We don't hate Chinese😏. But your govt doesn't share with you the historical facts. There was no India China border, China occupied the Tibet by force and now they are claiming parts of other country. Not so innocent.
Jai Shankar is doing a yes man job
How come our Military General Staff do not advise our Government on such critical issues? I personally think that our Military High Command is incompetent, and inclined to be politically involved with the BJP. And the Government has appointed heads of the three forces who fit this bill. I feel sorry for our brave troops who actually bear the consequences for such decisions.
Sir, I have been waiting for your video, where have you gone?
to china to serve his imperial master she jinping.
He is summoned to China to massage 🏀🏀 of xhitler
There is nothing wrong in Modi’s plan to divide kashmir into 2 regions including china occupied aksai chin and Pak occupied kashmir.
After declaring ladakh including aksai chin as union territory, India should had enforced defense along china front in anticipation of any misadventure by china.
But the indians let down their guard in the covid pandemic enabling the chinese easy intrusion and occupation of large areas of ladakh😂
😂😂😂Indians let down their guard 😂😂😂
Really?! 😂
@@sabtaingopinath9652 yep, they were watching katrina belly dance and stupid cricket games when chinese walk into ladakh some 10-15 km with out any resistance from indians 🤣
Great stuff as usual. Thank you.
Great talk. Really a treasure of information coupled with highly incisive analysis.
This guy is a Chinese paid and lies a lot. India & China both agreed to pull back troops from Doklam just like Panag Tso. Here is the complete details:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_China%E2%80%93India_border_standoff
I was in charge of India while I was with itt semiconductor India has certain constrains unless she can break the caste system. Her bureaucratic red tape that hindered India's efficiency and effectiveness more than China's.
You cannot compare India and China in the same breath.
India simply has to learn from the West and America to outbid China.
I do not see any co-operation with China is possible as of then and now the Chinese still view the indians with suspicion.
Who is Pravin Sawhney?
A retired newspaper hack.
He claims to know better than the PM, IFS, Dr. Jaishankar (who even did a stint in China) and the think tanks who work for them, India’s China policy
Reminds me of Rahul Gandhi claiming in a public gathering - Jaishankar doesn’t understand China very much.
Go figure!
Thanks to Mr Praveen Sawhney for his analysis and information about the events in chronological order. However, I will disagree with the notion of faulty foreign policy by India and also it is India’s steps that has caused Chinese aggression. Anyone who knows CCP will agree that this was inevitable, China was well behaved for the last 30 years as they wanted to become strong and then follow their aim or take care of unfinished business. They think that their time has come and they can take care of past disputes. India needs to act in it’s interest and cannot worry what China or Pakistan will think. India had to amend 370 which they did, it may have angered China then so be it. I will agree that in Military might and also economy China is ahead of India but that doesn’t mean india has to do things to keep China happy as it is of no use, they will pounce on you once they see an opportunity. Today it is declared that China is our number one enemy, this enables us to be better prepared for any acts of aggression that may come from China. China is friends to no one, any nation that cooperated with China does it at the cost of its economy or territory. India has unambiguously declared and also identified china as enemy number 1, this is great because before solving any problem u have to identify it. By Gods grace China’s economy is going down and ours is on an upward swing and this will give us time to catch up to China. We cannot be pussy footing now, we also don’t have to be extra belligerent but you have to call spades a spade. India China war is inevitable and I have a feeling we will do lot better then 1962 as we have identified the problem before and are better prepared.
Fyi China's economy isnt going down, in fact its the opposite. IMF n World Bank expected China's economy to grown by 5 - 6% for 2023. That has being proven true. The Western MSM and anti China bots have being predicting the collapse of China for the last 3 decades. Even now they are still predicting the collapse of china. Many of these collapse specialists are around in YT.
Even if India becomes lap dog of US , it can never win any war with China
Who knew India's mindless scrapping of article 370 chain reaction will change the whole dynamic of regional politics and landscape.... A big paradigm shift... Now india and China's border issue has gone from predictable to unpredictable... Anything can happen.
China's control of an additional 2,000sqkm of Ladakh is directly a result of India's abrogation of article 370 and her arbitrary redrawing of her northwestern borders
Actually, it's become predictable--India will lose Kashmir and much of the north east.
@@SimonFranck100In your Dreams 😴💭
Your downfall has already started and now you're getting desperate😂
@@SimonFranck100dream on😂 we only gained land😂
Thank you for this insight!
I guess Soro paid him very handsome money. It took 8 years to bring Baharat out of Congress 70yers of disaster or disaster. This guy cannot see.
When you mouth off smack (Modi) you cannot deliver, this stalemate continues
This guy is a Chinese paid and lies a lot. India & China both agreed to pull back troops from Doklam just like Panag Tso. Here is the complete details:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_China%E2%80%93India_border_standoff
From Nehru to Rajib Gandhi, Sonia, Congress was always subservient to China for 65 long years. For the first time, India is saying, It's INDIA FIRST. We will do what suits us best under Modi, buy cheaper oil from Russia, or kick chinese apps, companies out of India. Love the way China is crying now over the non availability free trade of their companies in India. Modi government says, resolve border issues and then trade. Excellent tit for tat policy
Global times spokeperson
He talks as if India had a new position with China, China has been aggressor in either cartography marking
For a long time I have been listening to Mr Swahneys distorted Geo Politics and i am not referring to any particular episode of U tube . Please note.
India China dispute long pre dates America China discord. India china dispute is independent of America China problem. Yes India needs American help to safeguard it's borders and America wants Indias help to safeguard its Super Power Status. True India and America are st the teo ends of the Globe but they have much in common. On the other hand China and Pakistan have nothing in common. The only thing common they have is their desire to keep India down
how about intrusion into arunachal pradesh...and what about Chinese superior air defence system when india misfired a missile without payload..😅..stop bullshitting..PLA has never won a war in last 50 years..even beaten up by little Vietnam 😂
Yes i like this "India must totally give up to 🇨🇳 🇵🇰 while 🇨🇳 must continue its aggressive demeanor and still it's 🇮🇳 fault " makes absolute sense 😂😂 slept well with wokes I can see 😂😂
Asia is Egypt, Turks, Arabs, Israel, Persia, India. China is the Orient. Make India Asian fair again(test tube). Sadly the Kings of Asia brought in African slavery, same as in America, South America, etc. and the sins of slavery has hurt all civilizations. Make India Asian fair again. Also have "classical" piano taught in all schools in India, especially for girls. 90% of Chinese women know classical piano because it is a easy way to communicate at a "elite" manner with the west. Israel and China have both mixed with the elite of the Europeans and gained knowledge. India needs to do the same. India needs to focus on knowledge. India's original faith was scientific. ALL the teachers of ALL the faiths are Asian because it was Asia's spiritual history, Asia's narrative. The names, stories in the Old Testament are Asian e.g. Sarai, Amir, Shemi (Indian). Yeshiva was Jesus' real Jewish Asian name, Jesus was given to assimilate with the Greek deity Zeus. The west weaponized currency and faith. You do not need a western faith e.g. Catholic, etc. to Love Asian Christ. Creation is Love and intellect. No rituals, just pure science. India's vibration has to be at that level to have full access to the power of Creation. Good values.
This man is on payroll....
Good analysis very objective and factual thanks. Looking forward to the next part.
This guy is a Chinese paid and lies a lot. India & China both agreed to pull back troops from Doklam just like Panag Tso. Here is the complete details:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_China%E2%80%93India_border_standoff
There are millions of engineers， scientists， doctors ，lawyers， scholars and more than 90％ Chinese literacy rates and you claimed that them Chinese doesn't know about the world
China is the largest trade partner with more than 180 countries and some people claimed they don't know what happen in and outside of their country
Well said.
The whole thrust of indian thinking today should be on achieving economic and military power that is credible. You ,sir, should also be thinking along these lines
Modi’s survival depends on the euphoria of division within the country and a state of boogeymanism with its neighbors. Every Indian ought to visit China
KUDOS SIR....
HAPPY 😊 AS FIRST VIEWER
THANKS FOR THESE MIGHTY EFFORTS RESTLESSLY.....
BEST ❤ WISHES.
Sir, with reference to the above book, it would be very valuable for me to know your assessment/ review of material/strategies relating to Pakistan noted in the book. Thanks.
Why thumbs up in hundreds only for such intellectually superior conversation.
He is a jf blunder aadhmi😂😂😂
Because there are fewer educated Muslims like you who will support any anti Indian rhetoric from anyone. Long live Modi and Long Live Jai Shankar.
Now Modi really seriously mental , helpless never cure , taking mental hospital ,
100 percent yes modi. Very myopic
I understand the flaws of the current gov this guy is talking about , so what should Indians do beg in front of China and sell delhi mumbai to the chinese.
Dude chinese are never peaceful ,it is sad modi govt appeases them .If they are so calm why the hell do they have conflicts with philipines malyasia japan Vietnam if they are so peaceful.
Stop acting like a ccp agent.
You are right on one point that mod8 govt panicks in front of china and appeases them .
But dont say chinas intentions are peaceful or innocent
Thank you for Factual Truth amidst a sea of geopolitical propaganda and half-truths
this joker is the henry kissinger of youtube lmfao 😅
Jummu and Kashmir is the dispute between India and Pakistan since 1947 .Independent jummu and Kashmir is the only solution for peace in the subcontinent.In this way India 🇮🇳 and Pakistan 🇵🇰 would be a good friends like Canada 🇨🇦 and USA 🇺🇸 .Free entry. No visa .
Yes, Balochistan, FATA all should be independent or allowed to join India , for peace in the sub continent
@@shivanandacademia3460tamil nadu and nagaland should be free also khalistan and assam and manipur
@@jkmcgregor7797 Oh yes. like with happened with Bangladesh :P
Entry without visa to abdols of failed state??
Have u lost it completely??
Please pay back debts to CCP, Saudi, UAE and IMF. An economically independent and self sustaines Pakistan is a great asset to the sub continent.
A very objective analysis.
this is fascinating analysis!
How come you did not speak anything about china pakistan economic corridor being build when india had reservations , as it is in disputed region. China also had reservations in we building infrastructure towards our borders for so long.
Is china posturing expansionist attitude in South china sea ?
Why are you painting china as a saint.
sir kindly attach maps representation so that I could understand easily.
Nice video, it would be nice to have an analysis on the middle east situation. Is there any roll of China and Russia in the Middle East?
Sir - You may be a guy believing in the China policy based on RG and SMG agreement with Xi.
As it stands now Geo Political needs are intertwined with economics.