7 Key Moments from Alex Murdaugh’s Heated Cross-Examination in Family Murders Trial
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 фев 2023
- Prosecutor Creighton Waters cross-examined disgraced lawyer Alex Murdaugh Thursday and Friday after he took the stand in his family murders trial. Waters pressed Murdaugh on several occasions over the lies he’s told and the financial crimes he’s committed. The Law&Crime Network’s Angenette Levy breaks down seven key moments from Alex Murdaugh’s heated cross-examination.
Listen to Law&Crime's Sidebar Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3wMgRgB
Spotify: spoti.fi/3wITe7b
Hosts:
Jesse Weber: / jessecordweber
Angenette Levy: / angenette5
LAW&CRIME SIDEBAR PRODUCTION:
RUclips Management - Bobby Szoke
Podcasting - Sam Goldberg
Video Editing - Michael Deininger
Guest Booking - Alyssa Fisher
Social Media Management - Kiera Bronson
#AlexMurdaugh #MurdaughMurders #LawAndCrime
STAY UP-TO-DATE WITH THE LAW&CRIME NETWORK:
Watch Law&Crime Network on RUclipsTV: bit.ly/3td2e3y
Where To Watch Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3akxLK5
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter: bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Read Fascinating Articles From Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3td2Iqo
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK RUclips CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Law&Crime Shorts: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel B: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel C: / @lawandcrimebodycam 
Развлечения
Him muscling his way into people's hospital rooms,even though his son is the sole cause of the accident, is pretty scary.
has his badge exposed to intimidate hospital staff and others. Hey I'm LE
@@Redtopper02 EXACTLY! He lied about how he was using that badge. Of course, he LIES about everything.
Wait so the badge was used in the hospital that’s why he had it w him?
@@lstruggy yup! He barged into the room of Paul's girlfriend *while the doctors were operating on her hand! *
That’s what’s truly so sad about all of this… this situation and the way things operate in this town is not unique or uncommon. It’s more so the normal in these small towns. Imagine the lives destroyed. Jarring and truly infuriating.
He is disgusting and vile. I hope the jury isn’t buying his folksy, down home, persona. Paw paw! pleeeeeze
He is. He lied, stole, deceived and swindled people out of millions of dollars. However that doesn't automatically mean he killed his family
They are. Trust me. He’s walking or at most hung jury
You're buying the tempest in a teapot the prosecutor has created. "Let's all hang Alex"
@@psfanboy79 remarkable insight. I agree
I too worried about that, but I did notice the judge is not, I repeat, not ,messing around, gotta love that👍🏻✌🏻
Every ounce of respect people had for him flew out the window the night he tried to intimidate those teens into lying about his fuckup of a kid driving that boat. The balls on this man to think ANYONE would believe a single word he says is just astonishing.
Oh my goodness can’t believe a father would go that far to protect his son…😡 As much as I love and adore my sons if they were in anyway responsible for any crime they would admit their wrong doings, and most certainly would not accept me trying to get them off said crime!! Not that it would even enter my train if thoughts….Alex was a father trying to defend his sons actions because of duty love and twisted kind of respect, I don’t hear him think of how Mallory’s Parents felt…💔💔 did the other young people in the boat accident give testimony in either this trial or the actual boat trial? Thank you watching from UK 🇬🇧
You most certainly would if it meant you losing millions of dollars in a lawsuit.
@@KrolKaz
Whatever you say…
@@KrolKaz Maybe true. Tendacy shows one's integrity does indeed get more difficult to keep with the more money you make. Guess that was what the whole eye of the needle thing was about.
@@marieparrott7944I Was Done With Alex When He Said What He Said To Mallory’s Mom. “Oh We Know How That Story Is Ending” Like What?! Why Would You Say That To A Missing Girl’s Mom?! Then Kept Mallory’s Parents Out The Loop But The Murdaugh’s Was Able To Stomp All Through The Crime Scene
It's one of the few times we the public see lawyer's being absolutely disgusted with a fellow lawyer.
He said "hurting Maggie and Paul" not killing Maggie and Paul - trying to distance himself by minimizing what happened.
He is sickening,menacing even sitting there ,he's a monster !!!
He's not minimizing killing them. He's flat-out denying it.
I thought it was Paw paw and Mags?
@@richardbetts816 they way he kept calling them that on the stand was making my skin crawl. Using pet names doesn’t make us believe you didn’t kill your family. 🙄
@@richardbetts816haha me too, it’s there accent, I’m British
He harmed those people that he stole from. Disabled or grieving, people needing that money for care. For the roof over their head. He didn’t just “steal their money”.
And from his best friend. He literally doesn’t care about anyone else.
The Satterfield boys lost their home to foreclose. That wouldn't have happened if they would have received the money
Horrible financial crimes. Deserves all he’s got coming and then some. But how do you from there to murdering your wife and son? Crime of passion or hate makes sense but no impression from state and defense witnesses that testified made me think that was the case
Did he say if he felt sorry for harming all those people?
Such an important point...
Did anyone catch when Alex said, “Maggie asked me to LEAVE” before quickly correcting himself saying, “Maggie asked me to come to kennel…”. MOTIVE!!!! She had enough!!
As a juror, it would be so obvious this guy is trying to be slick
Liars often repeat a question nearly verbatim as a stalling tactic to give themselves time to formulate an answer. For example, if you ask someone, "Did you do it?" and they answer, "Did I do it? Of course not!" there's a good chance they're covering something up.
And he kept shaking his head yes. Guilty guilty guilty and for him to be able to murder his family like that is just unbelievable. Hope he gets the death penalty
Or they pretend to not understand the question and will give an irrelevant answer or ask for clarification. Sometimes they answer partially, while concentrating on something that has nothing to do w the question eg the Depp v Heard case when Heard was telling the jury that she needs the metadata from the picture to be able to answer the question. Camille shut her down quickly, which was hysterical.
CORRECT!!! He is painfully deceitful !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
And he applied this tactic to 95% of the questions
I’m from Allendale about an half an hour away. I’ve got to say while I think he’s guilty I really think it’s going to be a hung jury.
How did people spend any time with this man? His lies are so obvious and exhausting. I can't imagine spending 30 minutes around him, let alone working or socializing with him.
He is exhausting.
😂 exactly! Thought the same, not even mentioning being married for decades to such a trash
RIGHT !!!!
He talks like he's doing coke, a mile a minute, imagine all the people who believed this crap he sold them for all these years? I can't believe he got away with it so long, the guy's life was all a lie, he flew on his father's and their fathers prominent wings for far too long.
i watched the hbo documentary and i believe it was connor’s (paul’s friend) parents said that you had to be careful with Alex bc you could always tell that he was lying
He appears to have no shock that someone slipped in, killed his family, and slipped away totally undetected, all within 5 minutes of being in their company.
The paw paw thing makes me sick , he’s trying to use an affectionate term . He said both relationships were “wonderful”, but also followed with “as good as they could be.” What!
Half Paul's head missing, but he checked his pulse
Spot on.
Exactly.
😂
When being questioned by his defense team, the answers were short and mostly yes and no. Being questioned by the prosecution his answers were long and mostly word salad.
when he went on and on about the dog and the ducks and such, he was having a GOOD TIME. he was legit enjoying himself, i wanted to slap him. I bet that rubbed a few jurors who had to look at the pictures of the bodies the wrong way.
He has to tread carefully to cover all the LIES he has already told...that's why he restates the questions and acts like he doesn't hear or understand. So cunning!
I pray the Jury is swayed by FACTS not Emotion
Yes, I noticed that. He can't even answer questions as a professional lawyer should. Personally, he talks waaaay too much!
@@marrianner.1682 he is playing pros like violin imo. law school 101 - don't ask questions you don't know the answer to first and certainly don't ask/let defendants spin in their own way. IF he gets aquitted of hung jury, it's this cross exam. that made it happened. I am not stating opinion on guilt/innocence. I am stating what the pros./def is actually doing in court.
I was rewatching testimony about crime scene contamination and thinking well, yes, there were people all over the crime scene because Alec called everyone in his contacts list to come over there to create that chaos.
I’ll bet he’s so surprised to be held accountable for his actions. Must be a new experience for him.
We’re supposed to believe a man can’t remember the details of the last conversation he had with his wife and son before they were murdered? Innocent people would be replaying those conversations in their head over and over after finding out their loved ones were killed. Alex can’t remember the conversations because they didn’t happen.
Absolutely. Look up "trauma"
keeping in mind that the last conversation would have been right before he killed them, and who wants to remember all that begging?
Obviously some kind of conversations did happen, but Alex is too busy trying to sort through all his lies that he cant remember what he said he said, and/or to whom he said it. There did not seem to be any arguing in the video that Paul took where you can hear all 3 Murdaughs talking calmly.
Yes. 60 pills daily? I don't believe he was addicted. He's full of hockey. Despicable human.
Oh conversations happened that lead to their death. He was withdrawing and had a huge drug addiction. My adult child has a drug addiction and I am scared of her when she is coming off or using. Drug addiction ruins lives.
I hope the jury was as irritated as I was by his repeating EVERY SINGLE QUESTION
He admits to stealing from a teenager as if he had merely squashed a fly.
The top moment was when he was asked if he is a "family annihilator." After his answer, he takes a deep, focused breath and there is a rage in his eyes that you rarely see in real life.
Alex doesn’t answer any questions definitively, he leaves enough wiggle room to change his answer if the prosecutors try to trap him in a lie. I hope the jury can pick up on this.
Agree totally. It’s a tactic. He went in with the idea that he’d muddy all questions with vague answers, replying with lots of words, never admitting guilt except for financial crimes which he’s quite willing to hold his hands up about…..but in my opinion only to evade punishment for the double murder.
The whole family is rotten to the core. Siblings, parents, etc. Vile people.
Thank you.
generational, corruption
This isn’t the only family set up like this think about the ones we don’t know about that’s been getting away with stuff like this
💯
Funny how everyone is an expert and totally live a perfect life.
He also says he did not see himself as a big shot, yet places a lawyer badge on his dash! Just shocking!
Creighton Waters sounds like the name of a lawyer from a John Grisham book.
From I didn't consider myself law enforcement to "other law enforcement " I really hope the jury paid close attention to his lies & contradictory testimony.
Don’t forget he put blue lights in his car.
@Karen Mahoney 💩completely forgot to include that tid-bit of information.
@@Onepinkflamingo I knew you just forgot that part, oh and what about that whole badge hanging out of his pocket thing?
I spent a whole career based on forensic evidence and followed facts. This guy is a tell at every turn!
Luckily for him, I’m not in the jury box.
He looked very annoyed when they brought up that badge. That man has lived a whole lifetime of calling the shots and never being questioned.
It’s been extensively demonstrated that he’s a liar. That doesn’t make him a murderer
He changes everything to fit his story. EVERYTHING. Paw Paw wasnt supposed to be there. OMG THIS IS A HIDEOUS PERSON. LIED ABOUT EVERYTHING, BLAMES HIS ADDICTION, BLAMES THE BOAT ACCIDENT AND PEOPLE INVOLVED, BLAMES HIS PARANOIA, BLAMES SLED, BLAMES DIFFERENT LE, BLAMES HIS LAW FIRM, BLAMES HIS COUSIN EDDIE..BLAMES HIS FAMILY EVERYONE BUT HIMSELF
HE'S THE POSTER BOY FOR A PIECE OF TRASH
BLAMES the witnesses. Throws his own deceased son under the bus!
Just blame it on the boogy
How did the killers get the guns that belonged to the Murdaughs
The only time he took somewhat responsibility was about stealing money but that was like pulling teeth!!!
Taking the time to focus on the badge issue and tracking down the photo of him wearing it around the hospital is pure genius on part of the prosecution team! A visual like that is excellent along with the time line in depth. I'm watching this from the UK and he screams of guilt this end but I just hope it translates to the jury. The victims need peace along with the many other victims yet to be discovered. The amazing high standard of open honest witnesses for the prosecution has been remarkable to watch and just shows this manipulative coward for what he is.
I agree I said once if looking guilty was a legit tool in the legal system he fits the picture.😊
Prosecutor did a great job
@St. Therese 😉👍😊
Spot on! (as you would say in the UK). 😊
It is unbelievable the path of destruction. The prosecution is a force of common sense and immensely hard work. They are awesome to watch.
Those dogs living in that nasty, sad, depressing, dank kennel is DISGUSTING.
Hopefully not anymore, I know Blanca took Bubba.
@@sherielowe4256 Good. Maybe Buster took Grady since it was his dog.
If you look at aerial photos of the huge Murdaugh property, the dog kennels are as far away as they can be from the Murdaugh home without being in the woods surrounding their property. To me, a serious dog lover who's disappointed when my dog doesn't sleep in my bed with me, that says it all about the Murdaugh family and why Alex Murdaugh would choose that location to commit the murders: Disassociation.
@@craigfinnegan8534 Nailed it!
@@craigfinnegan8534 Don‘t forget that one of the dogs, was supposed to have pushed their first housekeeper down the house step's in a freak accident, and she died a few weeks later… But Alec then received 4.8 million in insurance monies for her death…. Stringing along both her sons (one being disabled). That their claim was complicated, and could take years… Such a disgusting excuse for a human being, with his okey dokey accent…
You can literally tell that he is a lawyer. The way he admits things in such a backwards way is astonishing
Does he admit to things in a backwards way that might astonish some people? I mean, I dunno for a fact but if some people felt that way , though I suppose that some people might have found his way around conversation exhausting, though if thet did they certainly never told him about it. He tries to be as clear and consice as possible but if others didn't take it that way then there's no changing thier minds. Yall.
@@KrolKaz you had me lol
A. O😊o😊
-Come over an see Johnny Depp pursuing Amber
Heard with a blade as she begs him to stop, a recording played at trial that I transcribed and loudened
He’s just a narcissist my ex is just like this
He said he was positive there was nobody else around the kennels that night
I would like to remind you Mr. Murdaugh that you are under oath?!!
What a despicable person. He answered yes or no to his team , the prosecutor was given long word salad, using Mr Waters name so many times I wanted to puke . Guilty 100%
Him repeating every question Creighton asks him is so aggravating
Doesn’t make him guilty though.
Letting Mudaugh talk was good I think. Liars always like to talk too much and give all of these reasons for this and that. He can't stop answering a question because he wants to be friendly and folksy but it's clear he's con artist. He trying to find his way to something that makes sense.
@@CoachEgg no but anyone with an ounce of common sense can see he's guilty imo anyway.
@@robinking6342 stalling tactics he's doing it because he's such a liar and always has been that it's his way of giving himself as much time as possible to consider his answers to the questions being asked.
My partner died 4 months ago. I replay our last day over and over in my mind. There is no way someone would be confused about last conversations
So sorry 🙏🏼
I understand that pain and I'm sorry for your loss. I, too, replay that conversation. Every word. Every expression. Every inflection.
A pathological liar can barely remember their last sentence because they are too busy trying to remember which lie is involved. AM was not able to remember what he said he had said and when or if he said he said it. Lots of pathological liars in our midst, how many of them are also murderers of their own family? I would love to know some statistics on that.
Please accept my condolences.
I’m sorry, friend. What a loss, I feel for you.
Prime example why as a defendant you should NEVER take the stand.....he knew better
He may be one of the worst human beings to have ever lived.
Whether he’s found guilty or not guilty, I sincerely hope that investigators and law enforcement continue to investigate this case. Him spending up to 50000 dollars per week on drugs doesn’t make sense. There’s more to this.
Yeah, that is his lawyer money. He laundered that money, and now probably is using that stolen money to pay the defense. They are making it out to be drug money so they can get paid with it. If they were to declare it exists and call it what it really is, they would lose their million dollar payment for defending him.
Agree. That kind of money doesn’t just disappear. Would’ve been interested to hear an addiction specialist confirm what THAT level of addiction would look like. The money went somewhere..?..
I agree. I have never been a drug addict, so I would be interested to know the approximate street value of the amount of drugs he was using. Was he sell drugs as well? If so, where is the money stashed away? Who will pay for his son’s law school tuition?
My thoughts exactly. I’ve unfortunately known people with addictions. A couple with plenty of money. If this guy (with the way he obviously consumes alcohol) was taking 20K to 50K in oxy’s solely alone every 5-7 days he would have been deceased long ago. He was up to something else 💯
Oh I bet if sled or anyone else can dig deeper, they're going to find that there's sooo much more to all of this. The millions, the insane amount of dead people around this family, etc. I think there were other people there that night, and AM is terrified to speak up. I really really doubt AM would sacrifice his family over secrets. I'm sure the entire family were in on GS and SS deaths-
Only reason you lie is if you’re hiding something 🤷🏻♀️
Problem is, that theory is also circular. He was clearly hiding a lot. Doesn't prove he was hiding murder.
The last minute of this video he admits his guilt. Who would not remember photographically the last words you had with a loved one. Every person I know would play that over and over continuously on a loop in their head. His lack of this memory is so telling and should be brought to the jury’s attention.
This is EXACTLY how a narcissist testifies. Always has another lie to try to explain another lie.
👍
Sociopaths will talk and talk around the question. They over talk, trying to confuse and convince.
@@oneaboveall1895 but not in this case.
@@sam8404 it is in that case. people just dont know what a narcissist is. If you believe this sad hopeless creature is a narcist, than you might take a look how a real narcist would look like and watch the ted bundy court files
Just a Narcissist? AND, a machievellian, AND a psychopath. A dark triad. A guilty convicted and sentenced dark triad.
If your family member dies don't you usually remember the last conversation you had with them....
YES YOU WANNA REMEMBER EVERY WORD IF YOU CAN
Paul, the little detective, solved his own crime with the kennel tape. Praying the jury sees the truth.
All sociopaths have a superficial charm that fools many.
He is the true definition of a narcissist. Guilty.
He’s literally lying under oath but knows what he says can’t be confirmed as perjury. Guy is a sociopath and a serial liar.
Also he is saying things like he would never hurt his family instead of kill.
Once a sociopath turns proven criminal offender, they have reached the literal textbook definition of a psychopath.
@@DAdelson did that make you feel better?
@@jamesclough7656 yes, it made him feel better... litteraly.
Why would he lie about being at the kennels if he's innocent
Because it places him at the scene. The rest is circumstantial, but it's obvious why anyone would lie about being at the scene of a crime shortly before it took place... even if they left.
My exact question, too! Why so many lies and trying to get others to lie on his behalf? He is GUILTY!
Exactly.
When he uses the words to the prosecutor that they charged him for “hurting maggie and Paul” it shows that he’s trying to distance himself from the crime and he can’t even say kill or murder because he’s guilty af.
please don't forget that this guy lied throughout probably his whole life, he lied on a daily basis in his professional environment and also at home with his family. He is an absolute *pro* at lying, manipulating and reading people and at playing the victim. He knows how to get what he wants. Please remember his assistant's testimony that he was thriving at his job not because of his skills as a lawyer but because he was good at manipulating people. He is trying to make the jury believe that he is an honest man by telling them in their face that for decades he has been nothing *but* an honest man. Why should he be honest now?
Can’t forget the Lead investigator for SLED lied a handful of times to the grand and state juries and used false accusations to indict a man for murder
Guilty
I don't know that they have enough evidence to convict.... but he's clearly guilty.
💯 percent!
does that makke him a killer ?after countlless witnesses and son say he is not a historical angry person happy, has happy marriage and relationships.
He stole money, lied, mislead, deceived everyone. If he didn't kill Maggie and Paul who did? How was he there minutes before but escaped the same tragic end.
Yes, like OJ, if he didn't kill Brown, then who?? Did Murdaugh not hear the gun fire? I don't know how many shots the victims received.
The prosecution should’ve said “so you don’t recall the last words you ever said to your wife?” Who tf doesn’t know their last words to a dead family member
If the jury can't see through him God help us!
Waters' posture, moving aroung, and staring is openly disrespecting Murtaugh, which is really bothering Alex - which is exactly why Waters is doing it. Gotta love that tactic.
His wife met him in college.. He was brought up to be a oily snake lawyer like his father.. Every time Paul got in trouble he called his grandfather if Dad was not available. So they corralled around the boat issue and tried to blame another friend on the boat.. Nice values learned by Alex and then his son Paul and Buster..
You are exactly right! It's a generational "evil" thing.
Very true
I am caring and giving. It is difficult for me to comprehend this kind of person, but I believe Murdaugh would be the way he is regardless of his wealth. The new book, UNSCRIPTED about Sumner Redstone portrays him, his family, and associates the same way though. Cold, ruthless, heartless.
At 20:01, when he asks "Did I say goodbye?" That smirk during his explanation is easily the most chilling part of this whole thing. I've watched hours of this trial and that smirk scared the crap out of me.
His little southern talkie talkie is a game. He went to friggin law school. He’s tryin to play the jury
I’m a liar& an addict ,I’m a liar& a conman& I’m a liar& a scammer ,, but not a killer( that I remember!
AM ‘s chatting up on stand today…
You forgot he's also a thief
He wants to profess his guilt about the stolen money 🤣than admit he killed his family.
I’m a career liar but I’m telling the truth now!!! Smh
You can be all of those things and not be a murderer, I suppose. Lots of people are rotten human beings, without being murderers. Look at government officials! Most aren’t murderers……Clintons, maybe. Lol.
@@stephaniehooper386 “scammer” covers thief. You only scam someone to obtain something under a false premise, ie….steal.
I get that he has a right to testify. But as a juror, I would be angry with him for attempting to pull the wool over my eyes.
Southern justice is on full display. This guy is the tiger king of lawyers.
he admitted to driving the golf cart and if that's the same golf cart that ran over Maggie, that is pretty damning.
I had not thought of that but you are exactly right! Good point!
I thought the very same thing. He ran over her leg with that golf cart! They need to re-examine the prints and evidence on this!
What I find particularly disgusting is his continual assertion that he loved, and STILL cares for and LOVES the people he stole from. The ultimate in gaslighting.
yeah I hate that too
The word "Gaslighting" is really getting on my nerves! It's the nice word of saying what you really mean. And I don't go for that! We should use the words we mean! No nice words about it! And I will leave it at that!
Hey it worked for Casey Anthony
idk I’ve hurt people I loved. Especially in addiction. not saying my situation fits his but u can hurt ppl you love
This dude doesn’t realize how bad he looks arguing over the way to phrase how he screwed over a child that entrusted him to defend her shows just how heartless his actions have shown him to be.
It’s inconceivable to me that you would not remember the last word you said to someone you loved right before they died. You would remember everything you said, and everything you wish you’d said. This dude he’s lying.
When the boat accident happened Alex was able to get to the bridge site with that badge I bet , when no other family members could even get there , not even the one who’s daughter was missing😢
That's true. He and Maggie were allowed to go to that site, but Mallory's parents were kept away. That was a VERY dirty deal they tried to pull to charge an innocent victim with that boating crime. All of the videos and documentaries are shocking! PAUL was the drunkest one...and HE was driving that boat!
That what they said. Her mother was refused only to watch the murdaughs show up and they were admitted to the scene and then the hospital to tell the kids not to talk to police what corrupt dirty scum bag
What kind of badge does he have? Why is he displaying a badge?
@@rhahnda his fathers friend gave him a badge looks like a detective badge had blue lights on his vehicle but Denys using them another lie
I seen that and CRIED! People need to see the Netflix documentary because so many other videos are on it and information about the family
The fact he changed his story the day before has got to make every juror very suspicious indeed. I thought prosecutor's final point during cross was a killer too. Murdaugh had just spent an hour telling everyone he lied because he didn't trust the detectives. Turned out he used that same lie to the officer responding!
Heied to the operator on 911,too.
Do the jurors come from the same town?
If so he will get off
it was only after the tape proving his location right about the time of the murder did he admit to being at the kennels. Dogs not barking at anyone suspicious at the time he admits…coincidence?
What do you mean he changed his story the day before? Can you explain, please? I think I missed something.
“I stole money that was not MY money.” How do you steal money that is your own?
Most of the time, when someone carries bags of pills ,it's drug dealing, not drug use. He's a liar!
Always having his phone on him.
I have to say. After my Mum, Dad and Sister died, I remember to this day, 13 years later, my exact last conversation was with them. There are things you cling on to. I wouldnt dare think what the last sounds would be that the killed pair would have uttered as they realised who was behind the gun.
30 years later I can tell you everything about the day my dad died.
Exactly!!! I remember EVERY SINGLE DETAIL from the day my sister passed away.
Exactly, sorry for your loss. I remember me and my dad's last day together and conversation. You just don't forget, unless you want to.
@@nancyc9543 . As can I the day my whole family were taken
Not only can I tell you the exact things said in the last conversation I had with love ones I’ve lost, I can even tell you about the last interactions I had with pets I’ve lost!!
I like how the prosecution lawyer is firing quick sharp questions at him, he can’t think straight to get his lies in order. He’s guilty.
While he is sitting testifying, point out the distance from the floor to his shoulder is approximately 12 inches less tha his standing height (about 5’4”).
Then point out it would be similar height as when he sat on the golf cart
3:05 at first I thought AM said that showing his badge like that (when he arrived at the hospital after the boat tragedy)..."a badge has a warming effect with other law enforcement..". I obviously misheard...
The scary part of true narcissism is that there is not accountability, no remorse. The scary thing is many are very successful because they can step on others and not feel bad about it. Many CEO’s are narcissists. He’s been raised this way and he CANNOT change. Just know that they NEVER feel remorse. It’s all about them and nobody else matters over their own needs and wants.
You're mostly right, of course. But what you describe is passing the threshold of narcissism & sociopathy and into textbook psychopathy as the sociopath turns criminal.
Are you a psychologist? Narcissists are not good parents or partners/husbands/wives and sorry to say that but from what I heard and saw he was& looked after his family well🙄 He just loved the money and the lifestyle too much
You just described politicians in a nutshell.
You can tell he has no remorse, the only remorse he may have is that he got caught 😅
@@kasiab4247 you might want to do some more research if you think this guy was a good husband/father.
I can’t believe he doesn’t remember the last thing he said to his Megs and paw paw .. Guilty
Probably because "paw paw" was made up
I find it infuriating to watch him answer every single question with a question and refuse to give a proper statement.
I hope the jury can see through his lies and see him for what he is, - a very dangerous, manipulative thief and murderer.
Hurting Maggie & Paul he says. Disgusting how he minimises what he did
Liars sure know how to play w semantics 🙄
Watching the reactions of his defense attorneys was the best part. Harpootlian looked so green around the gills that I thought he was going to start vomiting.
@susie actually I thought he looked pleased 🫤😔
For a real belly laugh, go back and look at videos of famed South Carolina political office holder and Murdaugh lead defense attorney before the trial started compared to his face now. The guy's been drinking entire bottles of liquor every single day.
waters is making him comfortable and at the same time he is getting his point across to the jury. 👍👍 great work. He is guilty 💯guilty 👍
"Stealing money that I shouldn't have."
Wow...As opposed to stealing money that he SHOULD have?
Admitt what he can't deny. And hope that truth carries over to the rest of his testimony
AM'S testimony simply does not add up. He is a monster. Put him away.
He doesn’t even want to agree with things that are facts that are right in his face like the text messages. It almost pains him to simply agree with the lawyer. This is crazy.
You are correct. I have family like him and it literally looks painful for them to listen and respect the truth of how they impact others. They care more about how they feel and would rather I lie and say thank you and make them feel good as I suffer more. It is painful until you realize you can cut family out and block them if they harm your health. It doesn’t matter if that makes them mad, My HEALTH is more important than their weak ego that doesn’t want to mature and be an adult. Thank god I don’t believe the gaslighting. When raised by people like him its horrific and people need to learn more about how they work which is what my next chapter of content is all about. Sharing what I learned loving and dating people that are killers by neglect and one that enjoyed it. That was when I stopped dating and worked on healing it all. Now is the time to rip the power from these people so we can LIVE again!
@@JessicaPradoHanson It sounds like you grew up in the same family I did. Just remember, you take the power back within yourself more than anywhere outside yourself. But I also agree with you that our better inner world should be in the company of a better outer world.
He did agree that he stole the money.
It's court.. He's in a trial, trying to fight a charge? Of course he's lying.
I feel like his answers are inte totally vague in order to keep beyond a reasonable doubt in question. He's lawyer he knows how to word things so that he answers it without a yes or no."if it shows that then I agree with it" is a perfect example
Imagine. He just cant remember the LAST WORDS he said to his ever loving wife or son.
I thought it very telling that every time he answered with a “no”, he was nodding his head yes.
They talk like Bubba the dog was a crazy, wild and stubborn animal. Why didn't Bubba, Grady and Cash (the dogs) bark like crazy when a "stranger" came and shot two people? Because it wasn't a stranger it was Alex.
Spot on , Alex is a cold blooded lier, and he loves his family sniffle snuffle!
Motive- Wife was sick of his drug use- financial issues wanted divorce- she wants to file for divorce- In divorce proceedings finances are an issue- if and when that happens all financial crimes come to light, (can't have that) He also kills son because that gives reasonable doubt-(alleged threats after boating incident) why else would he tells police all that when they first question him and times thereafter.
One of the things that bugs me the most is that when Alex is asked if he killed Maggie and Paul he says, "no, I'd never hurt Maggie or Paul." Completely begging the question of whether or not he murdered them which was what he was asked. And what they suffered. Maybe he would never "hurt" them but I think that he murdered them. I believe that he thought about it for a very very long time just like he told Maggie's sister that the murderer must have done. I think he planned it out a lot, to the detail, so that he was able to cleanup, change clothes and dispose of or hide some things including Maggie's phone within 20 minutes before leaving for Alameda.
And I think that a lot of the “atrocious “ Social media attacks on Paul were probably orchestrated by him which creates some evidence of an alibi for him!. I wonder if they ever checked his computers
You can tell through body language that every allegation he is presented, hits him like a freight train. He carefully chooses his words before he says them.
Ironic how he goes from clarity to completely confusion with no memory of anything in a flash.
Same as the “crying”. Sobbing to straight face and easy talking.
Murdaugh changed his entire story, when the timeline became available through the court. He altered his testimony to fit the cell phone records, & Onstar vehicle tracking. That data placed him at the scene of the crime during the murders., which earlier he denied. How any Juror would perceive Alex as innocent is beyond me. The Snapchat video was damning.
He did not even tell his Attorney Mr Griffin about the Lies of the kennels. Withholding to someone trying to help him beat this charge. No wonder he looked so deflated yesterday,and the fact he did not ask many questions after Mr Waters is very telling.
Great analysis.
Very true. He changed several important parts, not only the time he spent at the kennels instead of laying on the couch. He also changed his story of getting there later, now no longer alleging : ran to Paul, checked them, tried to turn paul over, took the phone and put it down, felt for pulse, ran to Maggie, checked for pulse, ran back to car and called 911 all under 18 seconds... He now ran out, saw them, ran back to car, called 911 and THEN went back to the bodies to do all this stuff. That's not what it sounds like on the phone. The exact opposite of what he had told. He also changed his story about what he did getting to the Almeda property. And he had small details added with old Barbara (still working for him) changing her story about a phone call on June 7th and Buster changing his testimony about where they all used to park (on the grass behind the house).
Very true, however, they have no physical evidence tying him to the crimes. I'm not defending the guy. I think he's a lying, thieving, drug addict and that he definitely had sumn to do with it. I just don't rhink he actually pulled the trigger...and theres no physical evidence that indicates that hes the one who murdered them. It sucks but that's how our justice system works. They have to be able to prove it beyond the shadow of a reasonable doubt. Maggie had an unknown mans DNA under her finger nails, he had no blood on him, no clothes were found with blood, no murder weapons. Him being a lying, thieving, drug addict p.o.s. and even him being there just isn't enough. I happen to believe that he hired his drug dealers to kill them.
"How any Juror would perceive Alex as innocent is beyond me." - I said the same thing about the OJ Simpson jury in 1996.
How could the jury believe anything he says
19:55 "Did you say goodbye?"
Alex seems to be amused by this question. Why is he not saying: "I wish I'd said goodbye, but how could have I know there was a need to?! Now I wish I did"
He should be showing some emotion here (and not amusement!) When you lose your loved one you always regret not to say properly goodbye to them.
Prosecutors should ask if it would be possible, he killed his family but doesn’t remember because he was high. He blames so much on his “pills”
I think that they didn’t asked it on purpose bc they don’t want to give him any excuse for his murderers, as being out of his capacity or similar. They want to nail him on premeditation.
@@clocloww1622 makes sense. It seems very premeditated. This case is so hard for me to watch. I’m a mother and I would love to see concrete evidence he didn’t do it… I want to still have faith in humanity and for a father to do this is so crushing. OMG!
@@AnastasiaBeverhousen Unfortunately, "concrete evidence" is required the other way around -- to prove it, not to _disprove_ it.
@@mvpfocus it’s just sad 😞
i believe drugs definitely poison his mind committing those murders
What this is telling the jury is, and he bragged about it in his answer is, l am good at lying to people and making them believe me. I lied to my clients, stole their money, and they never knew it. So the inference is, I am lying about Maggie and Paul and I think you won’t know I’m lying. And, I lie so much I don’t even remember who I lied to and about what.
Classic narcissist and pathological liar!
If He is this much of a LIAR then Buster Is a LIAR too. It is called learned behavior.
Praying for discernment for the jurors.
Excellent comment
I NEED this investigation to include the LAWFIRM and the BANK. This man did not reign alone.....
The bank has already been investigated and Russell Lafitte was charged and convicted
That is true. Impossible to steal from all the clients, for years, without his law partners knowing. Same thing with banks.
There are cases and the bank guy has .
I think so too!
The bank man Lafitte has been found guilty
Did Maggie have golf cart tire track marks on her leg???? Anyone recall that?
You can't have it both ways! He's claiming he doesn't trust SLED but carries a badge with him when he thinks it will help him in a different situation. He's just had a lifetime of getting what he wants by any means necessary.
He's not doing himself any favors by testifying in my opinion
Is it Herschel Walker's badge?
Well said!
Very true, but another comment above was it is his way of "talking" to the jury personally. He thinks he is so good at gaslighting people he can get out of it. He didn't count on the new evidence, ON STAR data, kennel video-oops.
Out of all the non-violent offenses, nothing is more disgusting than an advocate stealing from their own client
Where are the clothes he originally had on?
Alex did more than lie and steal perpetually. He repeatedly affected the quality of his clients lives. His story doesn't add up. The fact he had no blood on him with the hour and twenty mins he had to do the deed AND him being placed at the scene . That's enough.
Exactly
Waters could ask a lot more questions! He didn't ask about how his hands were so clean after touching the victims. He didn't ask where were the dogs when he left the kennels and where they were when he got back. He could ask him to show how exactly he talked to 911 and in the same time check their pulses and all he did. I would give him some phone and asked him to recreate it.
The last thing the prosecution wants to talk about is Alec's clean hands, believe me the defense will be talking all about Alec's clean hands during closing arguments.
I would like to know how his shoes remained free of blood and or bodily matter. Did he slip his shoes off to check their pulse??
Maybe he'll still ask those questions... I hope he does!
I wish he would have asked him what happened to the 3 bags of pills his wife and son discovered. How many pills were in the bags what types they were.
@@meichelle2000 waters rested today right? His cross examination was over