Protocol 3... I will not lose another pilot

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 335

  • @ThatGuy21872
    @ThatGuy21872 3 года назад +1555

    I actually shed a few tears when BT said "Protocol 3: I will not lose another Pilot." Think about it, he serves with Lastimosa for 3 years and then loses all that when he dies. Fast forward to here and BT, of course, due to his programming, has to "Protect the Pilot." I feel like even without protocol 3, BT would've refused to let Jack die. Losing one Pilot's gotta screw you up, even if you are an AI. Losing two, I think, would be completely unbearable.

    • @shamefuldisplay9692
      @shamefuldisplay9692 3 года назад +103

      Especially since Lastimosa chose this pilot specifically

    • @ThatGuy21872
      @ThatGuy21872 3 года назад +8

      @@shamefuldisplay9692 Well, Lastimosa didn't have a choice.

    • @shamefuldisplay9692
      @shamefuldisplay9692 3 года назад +105

      @@ThatGuy21872Lastimosa already chose Jack as pilot material, he just got moved up early.

    • @ThatGuy21872
      @ThatGuy21872 3 года назад +10

      @@shamefuldisplay9692 ah. Aight

    • @ThEShApeOfACiRcLE
      @ThEShApeOfACiRcLE 3 года назад +1

      A huge thumbs up my fellow pilot

  • @clanka7708
    @clanka7708 4 года назад +1038

    I really did not expect this at all from this game.. the depth of the story, the bond I felt with the characters, the sadness I felt at BT's death. God tbis game blew me away. Plus the multi-player is still one of the most fun out there.

    • @beastgamer7727
      @beastgamer7727 4 года назад +36

      I wish this game gets more recognition. Its underappreciated.

    • @Butter_Warrior99
      @Butter_Warrior99 3 года назад +5

      Hell yeah man

    • @chaosascendsyt
      @chaosascendsyt 3 года назад +12

      Bt death made me cry. I thought he was really really hilarious.

    • @denki3948
      @denki3948 3 года назад +9

      Don't lose hope bt might still be alive
      Remember the morse codes at the end

    • @clanka7708
      @clanka7708 3 года назад +8

      @@denki3948 yes I remember, but I fear we will never actually find out. Titanfall 3 seems less and less likely the more time goes on

  • @brodyestes2376
    @brodyestes2376 Год назад +204

    3:45
    One thing that humanizes BT so much is when he looks back and forward between jack and viper like he is struggling to figure out what to do

  • @dagkyco8152
    @dagkyco8152 4 года назад +789

    God, BT is a Good bot...

    • @heathcliffhappy2582
      @heathcliffhappy2582 4 года назад +54

      Did you know BT stands for Best Titan?

    • @taneeshajackson1817
      @taneeshajackson1817 4 года назад +6

      @@heathcliffhappy2582 it stands for Bravo-Tango Seven Two Seven Four

    • @jaydenhill9204
      @jaydenhill9204 4 года назад +39

      @@taneeshajackson1817 Ding dong your opinion is wrong

    • @taneeshajackson1817
      @taneeshajackson1817 4 года назад +5

      @@jaydenhill9204 that wasnt a opinion

    • @prodby-titan
      @prodby-titan 4 года назад +4

      Right up there next to Bumblebee and The Iron Giant

  • @lotzoh9189
    @lotzoh9189 4 года назад +856

    I’m not crying.. you’re crying

  • @deanmurphy7307
    @deanmurphy7307 3 года назад +874

    This game is criminally under rated.

    • @poggerwhite
      @poggerwhite 2 года назад +43

      It had a positive reception when it came out, the problem was the lack of marketing/very poor timing for release

    • @horse3987
      @horse3987 Год назад +7

      ​@@poggerwhite yeah, that sadly doomed the game

    • @brotrip2254
      @brotrip2254 Год назад +3

      ​@@horse3987 I wouldn't say doomed per say but it definitely caused a huge setback...and alot of people still don't even know about this beloved masterpiece

    • @horse3987
      @horse3987 Год назад +4

      @@brotrip2254 yeah true, i probably exaggerated a bit, and thankfully apex legends is shining light on titanfall 2s way.. you just gotta dig into the background story ig

    • @brotrip2254
      @brotrip2254 Год назад +2

      @@horse3987 Yea I do believe that apex legends shines light on tf2...Tho I really hope tf3 would have a better launch...and I hope it lives up to the hype and be better than it's predecessor... and we all exaggerate every now and then😁

  • @fishdinnersh
    @fishdinnersh 3 года назад +151

    4:02 I miss this level of action

  • @chaosascendsyt
    @chaosascendsyt 3 года назад +254

    I cried from this, then I swore to BT that Blisk would pay for this.

    • @ds_axe12
      @ds_axe12 3 года назад +21

      @Ghost - The Binary Code says: “Jack.”
      The code is too short for it to be: “Cooper, Are you There?”

    • @ds_axe12
      @ds_axe12 3 года назад +17

      @Ghost -
      .--- .- -.-. -.- = Jack.
      *[8 Months Later.]* - (This is Morse Code, not Binary.)(Don’t listen to this.)

    • @Ps-hi5po
      @Ps-hi5po 3 года назад +4

      Once again I’m alive my data core is fire proof so go to typhoon get in the fire get my data core go to harmony put it in a fucking vanguard class titan and then you have a bt-7274

    • @achmadfathoni3944
      @achmadfathoni3944 3 года назад +5

      Blisk gave you mercy boi

    • @Karma-un2ws
      @Karma-un2ws 3 года назад +1

      @Ghost It doesn't say that. It says "Jack?" And also it's a form of binary or ASCII according to some people. It's not Morse code.

  • @CanucktotheCore
    @CanucktotheCore 4 года назад +171

    And they say Robots cant feel emotion...

    • @Yoda_Panda
      @Yoda_Panda 2 года назад

      Halo's Cortana is also a great example

    • @chrismusiclover9893
      @chrismusiclover9893 Год назад

      ​@@Yoda_Panda she's not a fucking robot smh

    • @pure_zed
      @pure_zed Год назад +3

      @@Yoda_Panda kind of different, shes a copy of an already existing intelligence

    • @emmioglukant
      @emmioglukant 11 месяцев назад

      Still can't. Digital computers don't work like you. From the surface level, however, they could very well become indistinguishable from humans. But that will still make them mere imitations, good imitations. Rather than a silicon pieceware, if they added a synthetic or cloned human brain though... Who knows?

  • @N0411REGIS
    @N0411REGIS Год назад +99

    When BT said "I will not lose another pilot" he said it like it was personal as if he have real personality and not just a program he run with, knowing that makes me cry more

  • @Oodoos
    @Oodoos 3 года назад +350

    Viper was probably the only difficult boss in this game, you could cheese the other bosses easy, but Viper just shits on you.

    • @Terminator45845
      @Terminator45845 2 года назад +49

      Especially on Master difficulty, he shows 0 mercy.

    • @SCP-up4ot
      @SCP-up4ot Год назад +56

      completely worked with his serious nature. He never gets out of his titan to show off, because he knows that a sniper or titan could easily take him out.

    • @faffywhosmilesatdeath5953
      @faffywhosmilesatdeath5953 Год назад +18

      Bruv, when Valkyrie came out in Apex and I was watching her Stories From The Outlands video it was so awesome. Then I heard Viper's Flight Core sound and had a PTSD flashback.

    • @embrace_the_random
      @embrace_the_random Год назад +13

      As much as hes memed his backstory is so damn sad it doesn't top BTs death. But his story of a father who has to take up his mantel one last time for his family. Just hurts.

    • @efgragin
      @efgragin 10 месяцев назад

      The fact Blisk just showed up to fart on you is like…literally so much of TF2 is bad memes, “I hate you” but then the Apex Predators are just like, “huh, that got rowdy, eh?”
      Like imagine if Luke Skytalker killed his pops and General Polpotine, and in the Vader says “wow you’re crazy…we’d love to have you”

  • @lionljb
    @lionljb 3 года назад +76

    Me back then: "finally viper is down, that was a cool bossfight"
    Me now: "yo, that's.... Valkyries dad....... why you gotta do me like that Respawn?"

    • @TheCompleteMental
      @TheCompleteMental 3 года назад

      I'm still gonna teabag him

    • @AnarexicSumo
      @AnarexicSumo Год назад +10

      @@spritsfal5088Lmao that’s the most mall ninja thing I’ve read this decade.

    • @mr.wizbiz.2917
      @mr.wizbiz.2917 5 месяцев назад

      i hate valk oml i wanna get Titanfall 2 to kill em nglll
      also the game is super cool

  • @Theology.101
    @Theology.101 8 месяцев назад +7

    4:02 I love how they feel both mechanical and so very human. Look at BT - I played football for a decade and that is a linebackers stance if I’ve ever seen it.BT sprints, moves and tackles like a human. At 5:03 he stumbles and needs to catch himself on a wall.
    He may be a machine, but he’s so human.

  • @cano-2000
    @cano-2000 2 года назад +188

    5:54 when bt-7274 says "protocol 3, i will not lose another pilot" i start to cry, better than every scene in call of duty series for me, awesome game. i am waiting for titanfall 3

    • @edgarvala5929
      @edgarvala5929 Год назад +11

      You'll be waiting for very long

    • @zackdelarosa14
      @zackdelarosa14 Год назад +1

      I loved titan fall 2 but the first modern warfare Soap last stand to kill Zakaiv

    • @queeffairy
      @queeffairy Год назад +1

      Sadly we get apex. Titanfall is done for awhile sales and a hacker made sure of that.😢

    • @deucifer4170
      @deucifer4170 Год назад +1

      someone didn't play Infinite Warfare's campaign!

    • @sebastienvondoom8615
      @sebastienvondoom8615 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@deucifer4170One of the worst campaigns

  • @theempressbunny
    @theempressbunny 3 года назад +201

    Soooo for those of you who don't know, Viper has a daughter and she's an Apex Legend now.... Yeah... That's why he fought so damn hard.

    • @Lemilkovallina
      @Lemilkovallina Год назад +12

      I do the same for my daughter In that case

    • @OneBiasedOpinion
      @OneBiasedOpinion Год назад +55

      Would’ve preferred to see her in Titanfall 3, not the soulless cash-grab that supplanted it instead.

    • @chrismusiclover9893
      @chrismusiclover9893 Год назад

      ​@@OneBiasedOpinion yep fuck apex legends that game is cancer

    • @sygnetshorts
      @sygnetshorts Год назад

      Fuck apex legends

    • @sygnetshorts
      @sygnetshorts Год назад

      What an absolute shit on the Titanfall legacy

  • @willsimmonds3469
    @willsimmonds3469 Год назад +31

    Watching BT absolutely rush Viper gets me every time

  • @sharkkord
    @sharkkord 3 года назад +49

    i never though i could get so attached to a robot

  • @GreenEyedPsycho
    @GreenEyedPsycho 4 года назад +87

    The greatest FPS campaign in existence

    • @keeton7033
      @keeton7033 3 года назад +6

      definitely not but it’s up there

    • @bulldozer281
      @bulldozer281 3 года назад +22

      The best underrated campaign in video game history

    • @quadnodsarelife
      @quadnodsarelife 3 года назад +9

      @@bulldozer281 very under rated. It released when people didn’t want a futuristic shooter and it was overshadowed by BF1

    • @gwuas3604
      @gwuas3604 3 года назад

      @@quadnodsarelife Sad, I’ve always liked futuristic shooters probably more than any other fps genre.

    • @quadnodsarelife
      @quadnodsarelife 3 года назад

      @@gwuas3604 I prefer MODERN. I love our weapons, Futuristic games I don’t like the atmosphere. They feel like they’re too bland when modern yeah we see it alot. But the deserts of the middle east and middle eastern cities to the streets of Europe and america. Which is why mw3 was one of my favorite Fps along with BF4 and 3

  • @9eftez709
    @9eftez709 3 года назад +27

    Dud bt got mad dodge skills
    And how they made Cooper struggle 2 go help BT shit is full on art

  • @Monkeynuts502
    @Monkeynuts502 9 месяцев назад +4

    I just noticed, when they land back on the ship, BT swings wide when he dodges to draw Viper’s attention away from Cooper. 4:00

  • @gourmetguy5662
    @gourmetguy5662 Год назад +26

    BT was the best titan a pilot could’ve asked for and now I want titanfall 3 even more!!!

  • @linkhaus7948
    @linkhaus7948 Год назад +10

    3:45 in this moment you see BT's panic when he saw Viper is still in the air and thinking if he has time to embark Cooper.

  • @-jusesanimation-854
    @-jusesanimation-854 2 года назад +18

    "Protocol 3" "i will not lose another pilot"
    Rest in peace,leggend

  • @Tired_Em
    @Tired_Em Год назад +8

    Revisiting after few years. The way he shields Jack with the debris and himself...

  • @noobyskeletongamer3870
    @noobyskeletongamer3870 4 года назад +60

    This makes me want to get the game

    • @ArquivoLucasAM
      @ArquivoLucasAM 4 года назад +17

      You will not regret it

    • @steven-bs5ep
      @steven-bs5ep 4 года назад +12

      Fr you missin OUT 🗣

    • @iieccoii
      @iieccoii 4 года назад

      Slam

    • @cuteracecar
      @cuteracecar 4 года назад +3

      It’s a good 5 hour campaign

    • @loneassassin29
      @loneassassin29 3 года назад +1

      @@cuteracecar 2 hour long but still the best I've ever played

  • @gamertwo6263
    @gamertwo6263 Год назад +10

    Viper: what every Northstar player wishes Northstar was…

  • @Flex_seal
    @Flex_seal 3 года назад +14

    Fun fact: when lastimosa is linking you to bt he says bravo tango 7274 which is bt’s full name

    • @emmioglukant
      @emmioglukant 11 месяцев назад +1

      It's the phonetic alphabet of US military. A is alpha, b is bravo etc..

  • @Ronalcubano
    @Ronalcubano Год назад +11

    I always hope for a third part of this magnificent game

  • @showmeyourtuts3670
    @showmeyourtuts3670 Год назад +5

    Remember, BT risked the lives of billions for Jack's survival. He overcame his core programming to ensure Jack came out of that crash alive. Idc how advance an AI is there is no way BT planned that far ahead, with absolute certainty and so many unknown variables , that they could stop the UMC. He took a huge risk for his friend. If that isn't brotherhood then idk what is.

  • @crucible1084
    @crucible1084 2 года назад +3

    dude we just orphaned valkyrie lol

  • @falturheartsmusics
    @falturheartsmusics 9 месяцев назад +1

    "You hear that ringing in your ears, son?"

  • @Theology.101
    @Theology.101 8 месяцев назад +1

    It’s been six years, and when I head ‘The skies belong to me’ i still get chills
    i did insta merc him my first time running it snd when i fell off afterwards, he made me pay

  • @ayoxe
    @ayoxe 3 года назад +12

    Fun fact! If you kill Viper with a grenade his bod’s prescripted death animation will disable! Causing him to have normal rag doll physics! So you’re able to fling Viper’s body off the Draconis.

  • @Totally_not_a_Zaku
    @Totally_not_a_Zaku 3 года назад +6

    I told those invisible ninjas not to cut ome onions while im gaming

  • @Conchobhar
    @Conchobhar Год назад +3

    The villains in this game were so anime.

  • @skyguardian18
    @skyguardian18 3 года назад +13

    I swear to god, Fukuda and Alavi started from making likeable superior (Capt. Price), on of the most painful death scene (Ghost and Roach betrayal), and now the closest ally. All is done in FPS game where most the story design only made you feel good of being an hero instead of investing your emotion to the game.
    Respawn is a blessing

  • @winnoe
    @winnoe Год назад +1

    I'm not crying, you're crying.

  • @MechWarrior894
    @MechWarrior894 4 месяца назад

    BT knew loyalty as well as independence. Linking with its former pilot and losing said pilot must have sent it to a dark place to where losing another pilot is impossible. It cannot live with that probability, it would rather die than lose another pilot. I know what that is like.

  • @pvwolf1875
    @pvwolf1875 4 года назад +8

    4:04
    WATCH OUT WATCH OUT WATCH OUT, OOOOH!

  • @Notme_.e
    @Notme_.e 3 года назад +4

    i just cry at last mission idk why

  • @ItwasmeZepplin
    @ItwasmeZepplin 3 года назад +1

    You hear that ringing “ yeah that’s my missles locking onto you” 😏

  • @evomobius749
    @evomobius749 3 года назад +4

    BT was the best, this campaign is so underated 😭

  • @SteamPunk76
    @SteamPunk76 3 года назад +4

    bro i started crying when he got his arm ripped off

  • @adeptusdripstartes
    @adeptusdripstartes Год назад +2

    I wish there was an after credits scene of BT and Jack going to Wendy's. Why? Chicken sandwich.

  • @Gtrjerry73
    @Gtrjerry73 Год назад

    Still one of my fav campaigns I must have played this through a dozen times

  • @tylerstewart3181
    @tylerstewart3181 Год назад +1

    I cried.

  • @Anukii
    @Anukii 2 года назад +1

    Exactly why Titanfall 2 is my comfort game 🥺💖 If I don't got me, BT got me 🥺

  • @ax_1771
    @ax_1771 3 года назад +1

    4:04 Best than Hollywood fighting scenes

  • @shawkir35
    @shawkir35 3 года назад +1

    Brings tear to my eyes

  • @mr.h1083
    @mr.h1083 6 месяцев назад

    Protocol 3 was more than just Protect the Pilot to him. Protocol 3 was a promise to himself to let anyone else down. To not lose another pilot…

  • @bmouch1018
    @bmouch1018 Год назад

    Still makes me physically tear up to this day

  • @Thanaxe
    @Thanaxe 2 года назад +1

    Women cried at the ending of Titanic...men cried here.

    • @xXGabrielTrapXx
      @xXGabrielTrapXx 2 года назад

      Man and woman have lot of things in common, both cried at something with "titan" in the name

  • @VSN194
    @VSN194 2 года назад +3

    Titanfall is so underappreciated it makes me slightly angry, game deserves to be loved besides only apex legends.

  • @xduskashesreal
    @xduskashesreal 11 месяцев назад

    BT is honestly the realest one

  • @zefem
    @zefem Год назад

    Actually cried. BT you ate the GOAT

  • @LloydLevas-cx4fv
    @LloydLevas-cx4fv 10 месяцев назад

    Tf2 (Titanfall / 2) is the best 3 hour short campaign in gaming history!

  • @scourgedarkpaw9949
    @scourgedarkpaw9949 2 года назад +1

    I love this. But I think it could have been better if Jack and bt weren't trapped but Jack was hurt from his fall while.fighring viper and he told bt to take the ark and leave Jack behind but bt decides to disobey and protect Jack and he says "I won't lose another pilot"

  • @NotHuman012
    @NotHuman012 2 года назад +1

    I was crying when BT died :( If titan fall 3 ever come out I hope BT is there and alive

  • @wobblewaffle1588
    @wobblewaffle1588 3 года назад +3

    Lets salute for BT ( also congrats for having more subs than me I have 46 )

  • @niteshkumardutt
    @niteshkumardutt 5 месяцев назад

    Beating VIPER was the hardest fight for me in whole campaign...

  • @pechs993
    @pechs993 3 года назад +14

    Use the northstar loadout to defeat viper its alot easier

    • @justjoking5252
      @justjoking5252 3 года назад +4

      _Who has control of the skies now, B-_

    • @Ps-hi5po
      @Ps-hi5po 3 года назад

      How to snipe

  • @anonsillybear
    @anonsillybear Год назад

    This game made me feel emotions for a robot

  • @delcox8165
    @delcox8165 Год назад

    An absolute tragedy this masterpiece didn't get a sequel, because battle royale was where the money was. Rumors persist, but they're still just rumors.

  • @Ps-hi5po
    @Ps-hi5po 3 года назад +12

    6:03

  • @sherlockholmes8822
    @sherlockholmes8822 Год назад

    Damn Viper sounds almost exactly like Viper from Top Gun

  • @Pin-Din7
    @Pin-Din7 Год назад

    Very late to commenting on this but just saying, this is why I dont really get excited for another Respawn game even when its Star Wars. Not because "oh they didn't make another TitanFall boo hiss them!" But because they didn't repair server state of TitanFall2 after DDOS, left it damaged. They also clearly haven't announced like another installment is coming focusing just on Star Wars & Apex. That would be fine & if they at least repaired the damage of the DDOS.
    Not to mention they have potential for a new installment after ending here. This was a great step in the right direction for a campaign. Like full 180° than what they tried before in the 1st game.

  • @Sick3ned
    @Sick3ned Год назад +1

    Back when you didn't need a mod to play multilayer, good times

  • @leoornstein8739
    @leoornstein8739 3 года назад +2

    Wait till valkyrie see this

  • @Viper96067
    @Viper96067 3 года назад +4

    Bt 7274 was the best titan

  • @kik310
    @kik310 3 года назад

    Damn this robot make me cry

  • @fx_tr0t_actual609
    @fx_tr0t_actual609 Год назад

    To be honest, this scene scared me

  • @SENTINEL2086
    @SENTINEL2086 Год назад +2

    This is the best game I've played in years everything about it was amazing.

  • @supremejuice683
    @supremejuice683 Год назад

    this hurts even more now that Respawn has cancelled TF3

  • @brevingraham6143
    @brevingraham6143 9 месяцев назад

    BT was all hands, always wanted the smoke

  • @NevinRiley
    @NevinRiley Год назад

    I have a crush on the robot now

  • @user-mv9ec5cq3y
    @user-mv9ec5cq3y 2 года назад

    4:00 bruh BT did him dirty with the jukes

  • @BigDRandycms
    @BigDRandycms 2 года назад

    After this when people call me a bot, I see it as a compliment

  • @srayairplane5660
    @srayairplane5660 Год назад +1

    BT 😢

  • @coolguybronzedave
    @coolguybronzedave 3 года назад

    "Speed is life"

  • @abinodattil6422
    @abinodattil6422 Год назад

    man waiting for titan fall movie

  • @danielpercent5434
    @danielpercent5434 Год назад

    Wait a minute...I just realized that it took the big guy 5 punches to bust glass? 😮😅

  • @whilenoobplay2473
    @whilenoobplay2473 Год назад

    just use the damn eletric smoke

  • @Cityboyzz_
    @Cityboyzz_ Год назад

    Im not a call of duty fan but this looks good i might actually give it a try

  • @Cronama
    @Cronama Год назад

    I am afraid that Titanfall 3 will not have the same magic as 2.

  • @sneakyfloppa935
    @sneakyfloppa935 3 года назад +3

    Bt must return to titanfall 3

    • @Ps-hi5po
      @Ps-hi5po 3 года назад

      I am thetr

    • @jaredpursey3791
      @jaredpursey3791 3 года назад

      Except tf3 isn't coming 😭
      So comment and like synths videos. He's a RUclips pushing to get tf3

  • @luner-thegamer-god_1338
    @luner-thegamer-god_1338 3 года назад +3

    You die a hero or live long enough to become the villain
    Cooper is a hero while his Titian (I forgot his name) Is a BEAST

  • @The1Monty
    @The1Monty Год назад +1

    You could really argue that Titanfall 2 is the last good game EA made.

  • @usuhjargalbayaraa445
    @usuhjargalbayaraa445 2 года назад

    Protcol3 never dies. Bt:-are you sure about that

  • @Fajourd
    @Fajourd Год назад

    at the fold weapon bt rebooting him self and said the last protocol "Protocol 3 protect the pilot" jack " BT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Bt "trust me'

  • @DefiniteRicardo
    @DefiniteRicardo Год назад

    Where men cried

  • @MortSalazar
    @MortSalazar Год назад +1

    This game is legally overrated
    BT is like Ethan but large.
    Love 'em both.

  • @jeanbaptistebalago3804
    @jeanbaptistebalago3804 Год назад

    Mmmh a cloudy time here

  • @DeadeyeDurza
    @DeadeyeDurza 2 года назад

    Tackled vipers titan at the speed of mach jesus

  • @raiyanmisran1492
    @raiyanmisran1492 3 года назад

    shit, got some dust in my eyes

  • @lunytoonz3466
    @lunytoonz3466 Год назад

    Wth did i miss what game is this? This shit looks dayum good!

  • @beckhamoefinger3531
    @beckhamoefinger3531 2 года назад

    I think they should add cooper to apex legends and have valk and cooper get the same relationship as Maggie and fuse does since cooper killed balks dad it would be an amazing add on to apex

  • @nekozimo
    @nekozimo Год назад

    Most emotional moment i ha din this beautiful game

  • @Sakublud
    @Sakublud 2 года назад

    emotional stuff right there

  • @foxygamer1515
    @foxygamer1515 4 года назад +4

    sad boi hours

  • @xzavier4963
    @xzavier4963 Год назад

    I destroyed slone, and it was even more over kill for those two