The lines : “If I had arms, I could kill myself. If I had legs, I could run away. If I had a voice, I could be some sort of company for myself.” They just hit hard.
@@frankiek2269 Yeah, the movie name is Johnny Got His Gun, sort of a tongue in cheek reference to the original Johnny Get Your Gun. And yes, they bought the rights to the movie so they didn’t have to pay royalties. Seeing how obscure the movie is, I’m sure the rights weren’t all that expensive. Especially since they still really weren’t very wealthy when AJFA and the video for One came out. It wasn’t until after they headlined their Damaged Justice tour, and especially after they toured for 2 1/2 years straight for the Black album, that they really got stupidly wealthy.
I think in every reaction video I've seen the reviewer sits stunned into silence and then says something like, "Wow" or "holy shit". And yes, I have the same reaction as you.
This song came out when I was a Teenager in the late '80s......I was no metal fan but became one after listening to the first 4 Albums made by Metallica....Masterpieces...each and every one of them!!!
The best thing about Metallica in the 80s is they let the instruments do the talking with is a tragedy you don't really hear songs like For Whom The Bell Toll, Disposable Heroes, and One anymore
I was 17 when killem all dropped! I agree best 4 albums! Cliff was imo the glue to Metallica, rip Cliff 🙏 they just weren't the same after! The Black album is okay, but totally different then the first 4 Albums. I do love Nothing else matters, Sad but true & a couple more. I've been lucky seen them 5x with and without Cliff, although I love ❤️ Jason, Cliff was the Conductor in my opinion. Forever missed 🙏 🎼🤘❤️🔥🖤
Me too. Clearly Metallica’s best work is anything with Cliff Burton. Even if he died before the Justice album, his replacements work on said album is non-existent.
Ms. Aileen, you were nearly in tears at the conclusion of this song. That means you're very emotionally receptive to the art. That is beautiful. Happy Holidays!
Her father if i recall, served for a while so she can connect to the imagery shown. Same for when she reacted to a few Five Finger Death Punch songs. If you are an Empath, or can connect, it hits you pretty hard. I myself look at this(and many other military related songs) differently since i joined. Just hits different now.
This is actually my favorite Metallica song of all time, from my favorite Metallica album. The video clips you're seeing were from a 1971 movie called Johnny Got His Gun. A few months ago I finally saw it for the first time after hearing about it for decades. I'm man enough to say that I cried like a baby at the end of the movie. The end result for the main character (the one in the hospital bed) is truly horrifying and hopeless. It shook me for months.
I've been meaning to watch the movie since the cool new kid came to school and told a few of us about it. Maybe I'll make a point of watching it over the holidays(finally)
Some people are so fool, they thing that if you play faster then all you are better , for example , pantera , dont mean shit to me , their music got no message and got no soul , lars did and doing his job , being part of best band ever , playing real music which is international
The "Goodbye Father" line will never cease to get me in the feels. The delivery of it sounds like a man who finally has closure and peace after suffering for so so long.
My Grandpa's younger brother, Arnold, fought in WWII and Korea. He came back from both wars in one piece. In 1978 he had a work accident where a whole bunch of stacked doors fell on top of him, which gave him brain damage and left him in a coma. He was in that state for 10 months and the doctors told our family he probably would never wake up. I was five years old. My Grandpa decided to pull the life support plug shortly after. I remember sitting on this man's lap feeding him grapes when I was four, then months later I was at the hospital in the waiting room not understanding what was going on and not understanding why I couldn't go see him. Ten years later this song and this video came out, and it reminds me of my uncle Arnold every time I watch the video. The ...And Justice for All tour was my first time going to see Metallica live in concert. The raw power and emotion of "One" when they played it on stage, I can't really even explain it, but it was beautiful and sad all at the same time.
I’ve said this in different One reactions before, but I was playing One on my stereo when my grandfather walked in. ‘Hon,’ he said. ‘It sounds like yours friends were in a war.’ My grandfather had served in World War II and he just opened up to me about his experiences after hearing this song. It was truly beautiful. Their symphonic concert was his favorite after that ♥️
Thank you for covering this. It hits hard being a military wife and having to try to keep those visuals out of my head when my husband is deployed. It really puts things into perspective and I hope more people can appreciate what our troops and their families are sacrificing.
Thank you for for your and your husband's struggle for our country. A lot of us may say little to nothing at all, but I promise it doesn't go unnoticed. God bless ya.
This video has ALWAYS had a MAJOR impact on me since i am a veteran and exactly like you said, when you really watch and listen to it,it puts you in the dynamics of what that poor guy is going through. I've literally seen this video HUNDREDS of times and it hits me EVERY time. Of course the song musically is just so BADASS too! Thanks for the great and sincere reaction to this.
I remember in jr high school I had to read a poem in front of the class. I read the corus lines and the whole class was stunned God bless our veterans.
It is by far hands down the most beautifully haunting song and video combos of all time it's literally almost like it's 2 completely different songs with and without the video.
No matter how many times I watch this video, it's still very disturbing for it shows the horrors of war! It gives you a deep feeling that you appreciate the freedom that we enjoy because others laid their lives on the line for us! Thank you for reviewing it! 🤘🎸🇺🇸
I will venture a guess that you are from the United States or a very patriotic country? Im sorry but its not about freedom, almost ever. Most of the time its about ressources others have. I respect the people who fight a lot even though they bought the bullshit they are being sold. "freedom" is an illusion. If you are from the united states. If you don't have money, you aren't free to do anything you want. It shouldn't be that way.
_"One"_ is a song that you will headbang to in the car or in the club, but no one actually understands it until they see the video. The background movie is _Johnny Got His Gun (1971),_ which along with _All Quiet On The Western Front (1979),_ is one of the most impactful anti-war films ever made....This song is one of the reasons why 1975-1990 is probably the best 15 years of American music.
@@AileenSenpai Metallica bought the rights to the movie Johnny Got His Gun so they could use the scenes from it in the video, it was cheaper that way, they would have ended up paying out of pocket every time the music video aired if they hadn't
This version is a strong emotional statement!!!!!!!With the video and story if it doesn't hit your heart ♥ your not alive. Great reaction you kept it real 💯
You are correct. The movie these clips are from is called "Johnny Got His Gun" which is an anti-war film based off of the novel of the same name written by Dalton Trumbo. The story follows the injured man Joe Bonham and his experience with being trapped inside his own head with no way of communicating with the outside world. The main moral conflict being whether to keep him alive, living in his own hell or to grant him the gift of death. He eventually communicates with the doctors using the Morse Code and asks for them to kill him, but they end up ignoring his requests and forced him to remain alive... It is truly some disturbing but very powerful stuff. Highly recommend both the film and the novel
Nope you're not wrong. This was their very first video. The movie scenes are from Johnny Got A Gun. It was really groundbreaking both for the storytelling and for the fact it was really the first time a seriously heavy metal band made a production music video on a grand scale. Great reaction!
The video, when it was first released, was a real smack in the face. The setting for the band, the choice of the video being almost all monochromatic, the jarring film clips scattered through the video, this video was truly one in a million. And still is, from when it was released back in 1989 to today. I didn't care much for the whole album to be honest, its sound was missing something (turns out it was the bass guitar that was toned down in the mix for some reason), but this track stood out. There's another react video to this song on RUclips, and one of the reactors(?) laughed all through the video. The guy had no grasp on why there's film footage throughout the video, and couldn't understand why it's one of Metallicas greatest tracks, saying that it took ages to 'get going'. It takes all sorts, I suppose.
One tidbit I love about this whole song is that Metallica actually bought the rights to johnny got his gun just to make this video, and they nailed the entire feel and helplessness of the mood.
My senior year of HS, in history class, our teacher made us watch this. Course, I was already a huge fan and knew the song and video well. But the level of shock on my classmate’s faces was unreal. Several girls were crying outloud
I have to give you praise for actually paying attention. I've seen a few reactions to this where they are just clueless, and continue to try and bob their head to the beat and act like they get it. You 100% understand the story, so much respect to you!
One of the most respectful reactions I've seen in a long time. Truly, you understand exactly that they're not just a metal band like the rest of us understand them to be
Girl I would never consider telling you to shut up, no matter what you're listening to. You always go into a zone emotionally feeling what the artist intended you to feel and respect not just the instruments and lyrics but the message behind all of it together. You appreciate music so much and I appreciate experiencing your journey with you
Metallica's ONE is an absolute masterpiece. Real Art is to make you think, make you feel, and be subject of conversation. Art can just take you places within yourself, to change you, to help you grow as a human being. ONE LOVE.
I'm older and this song hit me hard many years ago and STILL hits me. Love your reactions. Your silent lucidity one for sure. Btw, You are beautiful inside AND out.
I love this song & the movie references they did for this song giving this a chilling backstory. I love your music reaction to these keep up the great work, I’m looking forward to the next one😊🖤🔥🤘
There are somethings in this world worse than DEATH, sometimes surviving is the worst thing of all. Remember the pain and sacrifice for the freedoms we have today.
This was the song that got me into Metallica. This was the song that taught me that music can tell a story. That musical instruments can tell a story without lyrics. Incredible
I was 16 when this came out. It was their first ever video and it was kinda a game changer. So much different than all the other videos in 1988. Bunch of glam rock and pop. Such a great video! Thanks for the reaction.
I’m 26 and I remember hearing this when I was 15 and my step dad (big Metallica fan) told me people were pissed when Metallica came out with a video for a song and that baffles me because this video makes this song hit so much harder ❤️
Thank you for this, I heard this some 30+ years ago and to hear someone from a younger generation feeling so much from it really hits me hard in a good way. This is just one of those songs and I agree having the video tied in adds so much to it. Not sure there are words that could encompass what this song is saying but sometimes sharing the lack of words is what brings people together. Be well.
I would never tell you to shut up! You are definitely my favorite reactor on RUclips because you feel the music so deeply. I really love and appreciate your reactions and how you make so much effort to understand them. It's great to watch!
Love the reaction vid Aileen. Pure feels! You don't have to apologize for talking over the video. It's why we are here, and why we enjoy the videos. This video always get me, and it was worth it seeing your reaction. Rock on Aileen, keep up the great work.!!
I have a full signed “master of puppets” album from these guys. One of my close relatives was a roadie for Metallica from the start and they gave him the album. It ended up in a small shed we were about to burn when we decided to go inside to see if anything valuable was in there. So glad my dad thought to check. Plays like new.
I still have my MOP vinyl that was signed in ‘86, a week before Cliff’s death. I treasure that vinyl to this day- I feel proud to have Cliff’s autograph, along with the other band members autograph. Cliff was a legend.
This was the first song by Metallica I heard, back in the 80's. I was into Poison, Guns N' Roses, Motley Crue, Cinderella, Tesla, White Lion etc etc etc. But then one day, on the Much Music Power Hour, with our host JD Roberts. The Canadian Premiere of Metallica's FIRST official video. They had never made videos up until that point. I was intrigued. So, I watched. It was heavier than what I usually listened to. But I FREAKIN' LOVED IT! The song itself, was kinda dark, damn right depressing. But the musicianship that was displayed to me? Amazing! Next day, I went to Sam The Record Man and bought all 4 of their albums. The rest as they say is history. I enjoyed your reaction, your analysis was spot on. This song hits hard to begin with. But it definitely hits "different" with the video behind it. Keep up the GREAT work and ROCK ON! 🤘🤘🤘
Before this Metallica did not make music videos. A lot of fans called them sell outs at this point. However, this song and the use of 'Johnny Got His Gun' clips made this one of the most powerful videos of all time! The video gives the song much more context.
I understand there was no way in hell for a metal band to get permission to use the movie, so they just bought all rights to the whole movie. It was a 1970s flick, and not that much of a blockbuster, so I assume it was not *that* expensive.
I love how you reacted to this very powerful and emotional Metallica production - not just isolating your reaction to the instrumental or vocal aspects...you experienced the music and video as a complete unified experience - and went on the journey. You totally got it...AWESOME! 😊💖🎶
If I meet a woman who does not respond emotionally, in a profound and clear manner, to this song, then I know I have met a woman who is not worth knowing. Don't change, Aileen, you are one of the good ones.
Aileen I so love you. You feel the music. Very refreshing. Metallica was my favorite band back in the 80's along with Megadeth, Iron maiden, Black Sabbath, The Who, Scorpions, Ratt.
Definitely a very traumatizing experience! The perception of WAR the realities of WAR the misconceptions of WAR and a Hellish nightmare that would be hard for anyone other than infantry men in WAR to know the possibilities of this actually occurring! Grabs me by the throat everytime I hear it and sends chills up my spine and breaks my heart 💔💔💔
And the actual video is shot in black and white too. Adds to the effect. I have to say I absolutely LOVE your reviews- LOVE- this is something we need! You keep on keeping on!!! 🤘
I am a US Veteran. This is one of my most favorite videos of all time. The video made me realize how many military people have felt during any war. I was fortunate enough that I had nothing like that experience happen to me. That being said i love your reaction to this video. And was wondering how could I start in doing a reaction to music videos like you. Thanks again. New subscriber to your page
Powerful track, especially in the way it addresses PTSD and the physical trauma war can cause. The extended instrumental at the end undercuts some of the tension in my opinion, but it's still a great song.
Great reaction. I was 17 or 18 when this came out. I remember watching the premiere of this video on MTV. Ironically I had a friend who saw the movie then read the book Johnny Got His Gun this is based on. So I understood how they turn a song into such a powerful story. And this was Metallica's first music video. Another powerful video that tells a story is their cover of Turn The Page originally by Bob Seger. That one really caught me off guard. Thanks for doing this song. Keep Talkin. Never shut up.
Great reaction as usual Aileen. I actually wanted to comment on what you said about how people want you to stop talking or whatever. I know for reaction channels it can get annoying when people pause the music and talk. I know why you guys have to do it for copyright sake, but for you in particular, at least for me, I like when you pause share your thoughts and your feelings about what you're listening to. ESPECIALLY when it's more of a darker song like this or Lornas Pain Remains or Korns Daddy etc. The way you speak and the things you're feeling you can really tell come right from your heart in response to what you're feeling at the time. It's genuine, its real and I really respect and appreciate that. Play on girl🙏
Thankyou Aileen, Another supreme reaction!! Thanks MetallicA, ONE of your greatest!! Seeing you watch it for the first time, was giving me CHILLS.... I KID U NOT!! HaHaHa. 😊🤘🎶♥️🇭🇲🇭🇲
In case you do not post another video, may you and yours be blessed during this holiday season. Just like this video shows, please remember to help those that need even the littlest of help.
The lines :
“If I had arms, I could kill myself. If I had legs, I could run away. If I had a voice, I could be some sort of company for myself.”
They just hit hard.
things can always be worse than you might think
@@frankiek2269 Yeah, the movie name is Johnny Got His Gun, sort of a tongue in cheek reference to the original Johnny Get Your Gun. And yes, they bought the rights to the movie so they didn’t have to pay royalties. Seeing how obscure the movie is, I’m sure the rights weren’t all that expensive. Especially since they still really weren’t very wealthy when AJFA and the video for One came out. It wasn’t until after they headlined their Damaged Justice tour, and especially after they toured for 2 1/2 years straight for the Black album, that they really got stupidly wealthy.
❤
Hell is the unimaginable suffering one can feel. That is the essence of One.
“I could yell for help… but nobody would help me.”
I have watched 2 dozen reactions to this song and every god damn time I break and cry! The video is so strong
Damn!! Same as me
Totally agree . Breaks me down !
I think in every reaction video I've seen the reviewer sits stunned into silence and then says something like, "Wow" or "holy shit".
And yes, I have the same reaction as you.
Same
Read the book, it's so much worse
This song came out when I was a Teenager in the late '80s......I was no metal fan but became one after listening to the first 4 Albums made by Metallica....Masterpieces...each and every one of them!!!
"One" is Metallica's best video (and guitar solo) , in my opinion 🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
The best thing about Metallica in the 80s is they let the instruments do the talking with is a tragedy you don't really hear songs like For Whom The Bell Toll, Disposable Heroes, and One anymore
80s Metallica is my favorite metal
I was 17 when killem all dropped! I agree best 4 albums! Cliff was imo the glue to Metallica, rip Cliff 🙏 they just weren't the same after! The Black album is okay, but totally different then the first 4 Albums. I do love Nothing else matters, Sad but true & a couple more. I've been lucky seen them 5x with and without Cliff, although I love ❤️ Jason, Cliff was the Conductor in my opinion. Forever missed 🙏 🎼🤘❤️🔥🖤
Me too. Clearly Metallica’s best work is anything with Cliff Burton. Even if he died before the Justice album, his replacements work on said album is non-existent.
Ms. Aileen, you were nearly in tears at the conclusion of this song. That means you're very emotionally receptive to the art. That is beautiful. Happy Holidays!
Her father if i recall, served for a while so she can connect to the imagery shown. Same for when she reacted to a few Five Finger Death Punch songs. If you are an Empath, or can connect, it hits you pretty hard. I myself look at this(and many other military related songs) differently since i joined. Just hits different now.
Don't let anyone try to silence you!!!! You got the feeling of this song 100%
"Holy shit" is right. This song with the video is a masterpiece. Thank you for this reaction...beautifully done.
This nurse in this is my hero, she wanted to do the right thing
sucks that she didn't succeed
This is actually my favorite Metallica song of all time, from my favorite Metallica album. The video clips you're seeing were from a 1971 movie called Johnny Got His Gun. A few months ago I finally saw it for the first time after hearing about it for decades. I'm man enough to say that I cried like a baby at the end of the movie. The end result for the main character (the one in the hospital bed) is truly horrifying and hopeless. It shook me for months.
I watched the film once back in the early 90's and I don't think I'll ever watch it again. It is a heart wrenching movie. I cried a lot as well.
Jason Robards is good in it. It's one of those movies that's almost forgotten but shouldn't be.
I've been meaning to watch the movie since the cool new kid came to school and told a few of us about it.
Maybe I'll make a point of watching it over the holidays(finally)
I watched it about a year ago. God bless that nurse!
Johnny got his Gun is beautiful, sad, desperate, fantastic, and absolutely horrifying. I've watched it many times and it still makes me feel hopeless.
Don't care what people say, Lars is an amazing drummer... Off beat bass drum is insane
He may not be greatest in a technical sense, but he is definitely a master of serving the song and putting songs together.
@@lewe666 In the 80s he was on top (and ahead) of the game, but he got lazy later on.
It's off kinda off beat but what's incredible is how he merges gradually ON the fuckin beat. Same with Blackened.
To be fair, people never say this about Lars' first 10 years. Its about everything after the mid 90s.
Some people are so fool, they thing that if you play faster then all you are better , for example , pantera , dont mean shit to me , their music got no message and got no soul , lars did and doing his job , being part of best band ever , playing real music which is international
The "Goodbye Father" line will never cease to get me in the feels. The delivery of it sounds like a man who finally has closure and peace after suffering for so so long.
Not closure, just resignation to his fate. He realizes no one is coming to help him.
My Grandpa's younger brother, Arnold, fought in WWII and Korea. He came back from both wars in one piece. In 1978 he had a work accident where a whole bunch of stacked doors fell on top of him, which gave him brain damage and left him in a coma. He was in that state for 10 months and the doctors told our family he probably would never wake up. I was five years old. My Grandpa decided to pull the life support plug shortly after. I remember sitting on this man's lap feeding him grapes when I was four, then months later I was at the hospital in the waiting room not understanding what was going on and not understanding why I couldn't go see him.
Ten years later this song and this video came out, and it reminds me of my uncle Arnold every time I watch the video. The ...And Justice for All tour was my first time going to see Metallica live in concert. The raw power and emotion of "One" when they played it on stage, I can't really even explain it, but it was beautiful and sad all at the same time.
I’ve said this in different One reactions before, but I was playing One on my stereo when my grandfather walked in. ‘Hon,’ he said. ‘It sounds like yours friends were in a war.’ My grandfather had served in World War II and he just opened up to me about his experiences after hearing this song. It was truly beautiful. Their symphonic concert was his favorite after that ♥️
One came out when I was 13. I'm 48 years old now. I just celebrated 20 months clean and sober on Saturday.
Thank you for covering this. It hits hard being a military wife and having to try to keep those visuals out of my head when my husband is deployed. It really puts things into perspective and I hope more people can appreciate what our troops and their families are sacrificing.
Thank you for for your and your husband's struggle for our country. A lot of us may say little to nothing at all, but I promise it doesn't go unnoticed. God bless ya.
A thank you is not enough
This video has ALWAYS had a MAJOR impact on me since i am a veteran and exactly like you said, when you really watch and listen to it,it puts you in the dynamics of what that poor guy is going through. I've literally seen this video HUNDREDS of times and it hits me EVERY time. Of course the song musically is just so BADASS too! Thanks for the great and sincere reaction to this.
Cannot be better said!
I remember in jr high school I had to read a poem in front of the class. I read the corus lines and the whole class was stunned
God bless our veterans.
I bet...such a gut wrenching song...
It is by far hands down the most beautifully haunting song and video combos of all time it's literally almost like it's 2 completely different songs with and without the video.
No matter how many times I watch this video, it's still very disturbing for it shows the horrors of war! It gives you a deep feeling that you appreciate the freedom that we enjoy because others laid their lives on the line for us! Thank you for reviewing it! 🤘🎸🇺🇸
I will venture a guess that you are from the United States or a very patriotic country? Im sorry but its not about freedom, almost ever. Most of the time its about ressources others have. I respect the people who fight a lot even though they bought the bullshit they are being sold. "freedom" is an illusion. If you are from the united states. If you don't have money, you aren't free to do anything you want. It shouldn't be that way.
lmao
This is a joke after all the war crimes your country has committed
@@miajaimson5862 the fuck?
_"One"_ is a song that you will headbang to in the car or in the club, but no one actually understands it until they see the video. The background movie is _Johnny Got His Gun (1971),_ which along with _All Quiet On The Western Front (1979),_ is one of the most impactful anti-war films ever made....This song is one of the reasons why 1975-1990 is probably the best 15 years of American music.
The 1930 original All Quiet on the Western Front hits me so much harder. Although the 1979 version is great as well.
One of the greatest and most impactful music videos ever done. An absolute masterpiece in every way!
this is the video that changed my world
Your reaction was amazing, as always. My favorite part was at the end with a surprise cameo by your doggy peeking out by your tree. Made me smile
she wanted to be a part of the video
Great reaction video,always interesting content,getting emotional Your beautiful inside and out,great stuff aileen,have a fantastic Christmas 🎄
@@AileenSenpai Metallica bought the rights to the movie Johnny Got His Gun so they could use the scenes from it in the video, it was cheaper that way, they would have ended up paying out of pocket every time the music video aired if they hadn't
This version is a strong emotional statement!!!!!!!With the video and story if it doesn't hit your heart ♥ your not alive. Great reaction you kept it real 💯
You are correct. The movie these clips are from is called "Johnny Got His Gun" which is an anti-war film based off of the novel of the same name written by Dalton Trumbo. The story follows the injured man Joe Bonham and his experience with being trapped inside his own head with no way of communicating with the outside world. The main moral conflict being whether to keep him alive, living in his own hell or to grant him the gift of death. He eventually communicates with the doctors using the Morse Code and asks for them to kill him, but they end up ignoring his requests and forced him to remain alive... It is truly some disturbing but very powerful stuff. Highly recommend both the film and the novel
you can hear that Lars is doing the morse code for "kill me" aswell
I have that book.
Nope you're not wrong. This was their very first video. The movie scenes are from Johnny Got A Gun. It was really groundbreaking both for the storytelling and for the fact it was really the first time a seriously heavy metal band made a production music video on a grand scale. Great reaction!
The video, when it was first released, was a real smack in the face. The setting for the band, the choice of the video being almost all monochromatic, the jarring film clips scattered through the video, this video was truly one in a million. And still is, from when it was released back in 1989 to today. I didn't care much for the whole album to be honest, its sound was missing something (turns out it was the bass guitar that was toned down in the mix for some reason), but this track stood out.
There's another react video to this song on RUclips, and one of the reactors(?) laughed all through the video. The guy had no grasp on why there's film footage throughout the video, and couldn't understand why it's one of Metallicas greatest tracks, saying that it took ages to 'get going'. It takes all sorts, I suppose.
One tidbit I love about this whole song is that Metallica actually bought the rights to johnny got his gun just to make this video, and they nailed the entire feel and helplessness of the mood.
My senior year of HS, in history class, our teacher made us watch this. Course, I was already a huge fan and knew the song and video well. But the level of shock on my classmate’s faces was unreal. Several girls were crying outloud
I have to give you praise for actually paying attention. I've seen a few reactions to this where they are just clueless, and continue to try and bob their head to the beat and act like they get it. You 100% understand the story, so much respect to you!
You never have to apologise for being yourself Aileen
You are awesome ❤️
This is my favorite song of all time. Dont know why I can not explain it. I just love this song
"Help me mother, I'm having a nightmare and I can't wake up!" Just fills me with dread.
One of the most respectful reactions I've seen in a long time. Truly, you understand exactly that they're not just a metal band like the rest of us understand them to be
song & video is a masterpiece
Girl I would never consider telling you to shut up, no matter what you're listening to. You always go into a zone emotionally feeling what the artist intended you to feel and respect not just the instruments and lyrics but the message behind all of it together. You appreciate music so much and I appreciate experiencing your journey with you
Metallica's ONE is an absolute masterpiece. Real Art is to make you think, make you feel, and be subject of conversation. Art can just take you places within yourself, to change you, to help you grow as a human being. ONE LOVE.
I love your reaction you explained exactly what others feel after hearing it. Hope your having a good day otherwise and happy holidays!!
I'm older and this song hit me hard many years ago and STILL hits me. Love your reactions. Your silent lucidity one for sure. Btw, You are beautiful inside AND out.
Much love to you! ♥️
when i realized what the song and story was about, it was a game changer, i have never cried to metal before xD
Wow! Was my comment upon first completing watching this epic and classic clip. "Holy shit" , very American, but equally as expressive ! 👍🤘
The end of this video rocks my soul every time. The “keep the home fires burning” part.
It’s so f**king dark…
I went to there very first tour in the 80's. They have always been one of my favorites.
I love this song & the movie references they did for this song giving this a chilling backstory. I love your music reaction to these keep up the great work, I’m looking forward to the next one😊🖤🔥🤘
There are somethings in this world worse than DEATH, sometimes surviving is the worst thing of all.
Remember the pain and sacrifice for the freedoms we have today.
Metallica new and old songs are classics and I love listening to them all, so glad you reacted to this one 🖤🤘
Absolutely love listening to you while you’re analysing songs. Greetings from Sweden🙋🏻♂️🇸🇪
This was the song that got me into Metallica. This was the song that taught me that music can tell a story. That musical instruments can tell a story without lyrics. Incredible
Man, this video really kicks you in the gut no matter how many times I watch it. Cheers for watching/analysing this song.
I was 16 when this came out. It was their first ever video and it was kinda a game changer. So much different than all the other videos in 1988. Bunch of glam rock and pop. Such a great video! Thanks for the reaction.
yeah I mean I love that stuff too, but this makes it all seem shallow, this is an art film. deeply powerful.
Song with the video hits so hard
I’m 26 and I remember hearing this when I was 15 and my step dad (big Metallica fan) told me people were pissed when Metallica came out with a video for a song and that baffles me because this video makes this song hit so much harder ❤️
you must be so inteligent person!!! I love your reactions and your insights. You're doing great job
Thank you for this, I heard this some 30+ years ago and to hear someone from a younger generation feeling so much from it really hits me hard in a good way. This is just one of those songs and I agree having the video tied in adds so much to it. Not sure there are words that could encompass what this song is saying but sometimes sharing the lack of words is what brings people together. Be well.
Great reaction, liked taking this journey w/ you
A great song on its own, but watching the video def adds a new level to it. Great reaction!
Love the review! The heart rate monitor is a unique touch.
Another excellent choice 👌 love your vids keep them coming
More to come!
@@AileenSenpai you should check out no leaf clover live with the sanfansico orchestra
Thanks for a great reaction. Your honesty is appreciated. Cheers
I remember watching the video on MTV when it premiered! 🤘🏽🤘🏽🤘🏽🤘🏽
I would never tell you to shut up! You are definitely my favorite reactor on RUclips because you feel the music so deeply. I really love and appreciate your reactions and how you make so much effort to understand them. It's great to watch!
Love the reaction vid Aileen. Pure feels!
You don't have to apologize for talking over the video. It's why we are here, and why we enjoy the videos.
This video always get me, and it was worth it seeing your reaction. Rock on Aileen, keep up the great work.!!
I have a full signed “master of puppets” album from these guys. One of my close relatives was a roadie for Metallica from the start and they gave him the album. It ended up in a small shed we were about to burn when we decided to go inside to see if anything valuable was in there. So glad my dad thought to check. Plays like new.
You have a deal mister how much ?
I still have my MOP vinyl that was signed in ‘86, a week before Cliff’s death. I treasure that vinyl to this day- I feel proud to have Cliff’s autograph, along with the other band members autograph. Cliff was a legend.
First time on this Channel. Really appreciated you're honesty. No playing to the galleries. Thank you
Great song , instrumental and lyrically !
I love that you feel it and can empathize with what they were able to get it and understand it
Yes it does make your eyes swell and a lump in your throat. A Master Piece🤘
Truly, an important video. One of the greatest moments in Metal. Thank you for doing it.
This song is going on 35 years old and it’s no doubt a masterpiece.
This was the first song by Metallica I heard, back in the 80's. I was into Poison, Guns N' Roses, Motley Crue, Cinderella, Tesla, White Lion etc etc etc. But then one day, on the Much Music Power Hour, with our host JD Roberts. The Canadian Premiere of Metallica's FIRST official video. They had never made videos up until that point. I was intrigued. So, I watched. It was heavier than what I usually listened to. But I FREAKIN' LOVED IT! The song itself, was kinda dark, damn right depressing. But the musicianship that was displayed to me? Amazing! Next day, I went to Sam The Record Man and bought all 4 of their albums. The rest as they say is history. I enjoyed your reaction, your analysis was spot on. This song hits hard to begin with. But it definitely hits "different" with the video behind it. Keep up the GREAT work and ROCK ON! 🤘🤘🤘
Before this Metallica did not make music videos. A lot of fans called them sell outs at this point. However, this song and the use of 'Johnny Got His Gun' clips made this one of the most powerful videos of all time! The video gives the song much more context.
I understand there was no way in hell for a metal band to get permission to use the movie, so they just bought all rights to the whole movie.
It was a 1970s flick, and not that much of a blockbuster, so I assume it was not *that* expensive.
Thank you for your very touching reaction. I love watching you in all your reactions.
only the nurse had the balls to give him his last wish and take his pain .
I love how you reacted to this very powerful and emotional Metallica production - not just isolating your reaction to the instrumental or vocal aspects...you experienced the music
and video as a complete unified experience - and went on the journey.
You totally got it...AWESOME! 😊💖🎶
If I meet a woman who does not respond emotionally, in a profound and clear manner, to this song, then I know I have met a woman who is not worth knowing. Don't change, Aileen, you are one of the good ones.
Aileen I so love you. You feel the music. Very refreshing. Metallica was my favorite band back in the 80's along with Megadeth, Iron maiden, Black Sabbath, The Who, Scorpions, Ratt.
I'm not a GRAMMYs fan but, this one deserved every single nomination and vote it got.
unfortunately jethro trull had to exist back then....
@@felipegiraldo8100 This song was so strong it fostered the creation of an entirely new Grammy's category. Think of it that way.
Great reaction! Love that you feel the music and the message.
Pure of heart you are.
Definitely a very traumatizing experience! The perception of WAR the realities of WAR the misconceptions of WAR and a Hellish nightmare that would be hard for anyone other than infantry men in WAR to know the possibilities of this actually occurring! Grabs me by the throat everytime I hear it and sends chills up my spine and breaks my heart 💔💔💔
I want to thank you for taking the time to review this song for it so absolutely powerful and meaningful to so many people.
Amazing song this super deep and upsetting, all feels at once. Absolute banger. Have a merry yule beautiful
And the actual video is shot in black and white too. Adds to the effect. I have to say I absolutely LOVE your reviews- LOVE- this is something we need! You keep on keeping on!!! 🤘
In combination with the video this song hits harder, than what it would on is own (in a good way) 😢
I am a US Veteran. This is one of my most favorite videos of all time. The video made me realize how many military people have felt during any war. I was fortunate enough that I had nothing like that experience happen to me.
That being said i love your reaction to this video. And was wondering how could I start in doing a reaction to music videos like you. Thanks again. New subscriber to your page
Powerful track, especially in the way it addresses PTSD and the physical trauma war can cause. The extended instrumental at the end undercuts some of the tension in my opinion, but it's still a great song.
Watching your reaction for the 23rd time, I Love You and Your Reactions because you show every emotion that I love ❤️
Trump said " I just want people to stop dying." If that is not love, what is?
You are such a beautiful soul lady. Thanks for honoring all the soldiers who died during wars.
I can tell your reaction is legit. Good you you! You got this video for what it is. Long live Metallica! I love you!
10:49 exactly.
Great reaction. I was 17 or 18 when this came out. I remember watching the premiere of this video on MTV. Ironically I had a friend who saw the movie then read the book Johnny Got His Gun this is based on. So I understood how they turn a song into such a powerful story. And this was Metallica's first music video. Another powerful video that tells a story is their cover of Turn The Page originally by Bob Seger. That one really caught me off guard. Thanks for doing this song.
Keep Talkin. Never shut up.
Truth. Storytelling through song is what makes these classics on another level.
I Love hearing your perspective on tunes I grew up listening to,good job Aileen,Rock on younglady
It’s been a long time since I’ve seen you so shaken by a song that your stutter comes back.
It really hits hard…
This song is by far the most deep lyrical feel. I see how you reacted. Even your beautiful face wanted to shed tears
A masterpiece of a song,a very powerful video,my favorite Metallica song.
Great reaction as usual Aileen. I actually wanted to comment on what you said about how people want you to stop talking or whatever. I know for reaction channels it can get annoying when people pause the music and talk. I know why you guys have to do it for copyright sake, but for you in particular, at least for me, I like when you pause share your thoughts and your feelings about what you're listening to. ESPECIALLY when it's more of a darker song like this or Lornas Pain Remains or Korns Daddy etc. The way you speak and the things you're feeling you can really tell come right from your heart in response to what you're feeling at the time. It's genuine, its real and I really respect and appreciate that. Play on girl🙏
Thank you so much for this ♥️♥️
@@AileenSenpai You are very welcome💖 Thank YOU for the great videos 🤗🤘🤘
Thankyou Aileen,
Another supreme reaction!!
Thanks MetallicA,
ONE of your greatest!!
Seeing you watch it for the first time, was giving me CHILLS.... I KID U NOT!!
HaHaHa. 😊🤘🎶♥️🇭🇲🇭🇲
You know just yesterday I was looking for metallica reacts on your channel. I love your reacts I just throw em on when I'm doing my art work
In case you do not post another video, may you and yours be blessed during this holiday season. Just like this video shows, please remember to help those that need even the littlest of help.
sounds so fukn good when they go up a level metal bliss, I grew up with great 80's metal and music in general. underrated era the 80's 90's