Acting PP, Advocate Kholeka Gcaleka on the Phala Phala farm saga report
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 июл 2023
- There's been mixed reaction to the report by Advocate Kholeka Gcaleka into the Phala Phala farm saga. Some opposition parties have called this report a whitewash, others say it's not worth the paper it's written on. While some have welcomed it. Advocate Gcaleka announced last week that her office's investigation cleared President Cyril Ramaphosa with regard to several issues including undertaking paid work.
For more news, visit sabcnews.com and #SABCNews on all Social Media platforms.
She's doing quite well as the president spokesperson
Is she a spoke person?
The Presidents Protector is exposed. Great journalism 👏🏽
Ramaphosa tipped her first
This one is undermining our intelligence 😂😂
They think we're very dumb beyond measure
True!
Yeses o nagana gore re ditlaela this one
Intelligent people do not undermine other people intelligence only........
She always sounds like she's the spokesperson of the president, what a mess!
This lady has sold out ..one can only feel pity for the office
Great professionalism from the Journalist....❤
As part of the public i dont feel protected
You’re Not alone!!
Protected in what? Did ramapsa steal your dollars too
This one is a ramaphala protector
A lie is always exposed at the end. Kholeka your day will come. You will reap what you sow.
I wish I had someone in my corner who will defend me like this lady is defending Cyril. She is willing to risk it all. She also could not hide her hatred for Adv. Mkhwebane at the end.
She got part of the money in the sofa
When Mkhwebane resolved matters in favour of Zuma, what did you say about Ms Mkhwebane???
@@bandilemichaelncoyini9179 Wait! Was Zuma also found with millions of US$ stashed under his sofa? And even if I never said anything about Adv Mkhwebane does that mean Adv Gcaleka should shield Cyril from wrong doing and be allowed to get away with it?
When words lose their meaning, people lose their freedom.
President protector instead of public protector
Im a CEO of my company and I have staff who handle a day to day stuff but I'm still responsible for the company.
She is definitely defending Cyril way better than Vincent Magwenya he must be very careful👏👏👏👏👏
😂😂 funny but true
She seems knows everything, maybe was coached to defend ramadollar. 🤔 sounds like spokeswoman 😅😅
Did she really just say the report was done ethically without any bias!??,yoh!,this child is troubled shame!,akanamahloni!!!
I feel sorry for this women at least she is earning millions for being used by this power monger 😢
You are not sorry for her by undermining her credibility....
@@chiefer1325She did that on her own, she want that position badly and at all.costs 😂
First she claimsshe made a full scale investigation, later she peak about the limits of her investigation.
Her investigation is limited to her mandate as public protector and based on that mandate, she did a full scale investigation.. her mandate does not extend to sars, hawks, feelings or maybes.. anything else u need help with?
.....full scale investigation whose mandate is limited?
......what are smoking..😊!?
@@dilochetty9332Thank you 🙏🏾. Thing is they are just wishing she had found the opposite. They can’t accept the truth.
This journalist is a professional
THI GIRL IS APPLYING FOR A JOB TO PROTECT RAMAPUSA. WE MU ST GET THE PROTECTER OF THE PUBLIC
Really, acting PP is ridiculous, paid puppet, betrayed the office of the PP and it's mandate
Even PP Busisiwe is a paid puppet of the RET faction. Her investigation into Estina dairy farm corruption was a whitewash protecting Ace and Zwane, we shouldn't forget to mention that.
Ramaphosa tipped her first
Excellent interview, she is a liar
Yhuuu I'm shocked😂🥱
Too much 😂
She is protecting the President as if she works at PHALA PHALA
Why is a woman like this allowed to lie to the nation?
And your not directly involved in the day running of the business. 🙄🙄😂😂😂😂😂
I think its cause she is in her country, how are you allowed to comment on issues that don't concern you Hussein?!
Why not? A public protector was allowed to lie b4. That led to the so called state capture enquiry. South Africans hv bn fooled big time. Whites will soon rule SA
Cos she is getting paid millions 😂
Advocate kholekaGcaleka is confident and seems verry clear on what she is doing❤
Protecting the President?
Advocate used to be my crush. 💔 But because of phala phala report I don't feel nothing for her 😭😭😭
Wow, the public protector clearly seems captured.
We are being taken for a ride, our intelligence is being insulted here 😂
Justice must not only be done but must also be seen to be done.
Public protector for RET is gone,while Cyril 's Public protector is trying to save him.
I keep going back to this interview. Listening to this advocate I think anyone can do this job.😂😂😂
Me too!!
Here is one lawyer you can pay to have you acquitted of a murder you committed in public view. With a straight face. And she seems to have a thorough knowledge of the law, and its loopholes which one can easily dribble past.
😂😂😂😂
Great journalism
"He sells but does he physically sell?" ~ Acting PP 🙄🚮
Who pays the manager? Whose business pays the salary
This is how a journalist is supposed to conduct herself. Not these toy soldiers masquerading as Journos yet pushing paid propaganda. She was scrutinized proper. I could sense a hint of doubt that her report could stand court scrutiny
Gcaleka cleared the real criminal.
I hope Ace Magashule will also be cleared
Ace was cleared by Busisiwe when she investigated Estina dairy farm scandal
@@eliudnkuna3930 how did she cleared Ace?
@@eliudnkuna3930 oh I almost forgot
Wait I'm confused...! Is she the Public Protector or Ramaphosa's protector?
This man must be special, to still be President of our country.
How long did Zuma take after the nkandla saga?
Not special. Ke ngwana WA makgowa
She lies with a straight face, she's very dangerous this one. I don't feel protected at all
President Protector is what she is
Mkhwebane was criticized for not investigating Ace Marashule and going after Ramaphosa instead also Thuli was criticized for going after Zuma ,the question is do we need Public Protector ?
Thuli Madonsela was a captured pp. Hv u ever asked yourself why she was given a job at Stellenbosch? Up to now u can't quantify what Zuma looted
No
@@jabulanimathuthu2610 Mkhwebane was handpicked by Zuma from NIA
Much Respect to You Acting Public Protector, I'm against everyone turning to be Judges rather than taking this issue forward to the right place, to test the law interpretation.... I think the journalist must firstly know and understand the mandate of the Public Protector.
U mean captured president Protector and captured zondo judiciary
I suspect you are drunk
Double drunk😅this1
I can never take her seriously after this 😮
Law is about interpretation and judgment is about opinion
Well done Bongui!
Honestly Gcaleka is taking us for fools..in her own report if it is hers paragraph 14 Line 3 to line 4 show a clear instruction from Cyril to Mr Ndlovu.Secondly how is she expecting Cyril to run a day to day operations while being a President?
The APP is smart and intelligent and not influenced by noise but focused on evidence before her .
Speak after the report comes back from judicial review
She is a psychopath and evil...has no emotions by nature....dangerous
Very true the acting pp Very intelligent
Thank you Bongiwe for great interview.
This Gcaleka is defending rubbish, i hope they betray her and not get the permanent pp post she's been gunning for, what an embarrassment. Her integrity is out of the window with this matter.
I don't want south Africa to be come like other african country by protecting the president.
Bongiwe I like how you pose questions, I think you are becoming my Sakina Kamwendo💯👌❤
Bongi was well prepared. Very impressive honestly
Rubbish!!!
Well Done Bongiwe, always proud of you and Sakina. The Acting President protector must remember lies have short legs...but the Question that I still have is What was the President Protector investigating really?
The acting public protector is smart n knows what she is doing. Let's not forget that the suspended public protector protected politicians in the Estina diary investigation among many others of her failures.
We are not that bright a people, are we? First of a ll, she's part of a larger team made of experts. She's is not taking decisions by herself. The problem lies with you, your hate (or dislike for others) toward Cyril clouds your judgement. I don't like the ANC at large and I don't vote for them. Same towards any politician. This lady clear and leave no doubts in her responses
Gullible you are
@@banzisithole8694 very gullible amd foolish and mxm
True
Ooh wena u kleva neh🙄
Great interview!!,the Acting PP is a lier(lair).
Lair.
@@noxolotshabangu8055 sorry!!,my Bantu education is showing!,the scares of Apartheid will never fail to embarrass me!😒
Advocate - the sound bite is clear... the Advocate somehow seems to disagree with what the president told us... the nation... the president says "I sell"... seriously Advocate... the more I listen the the Advocate the more I lose respect for the young Advocate... SA, judge for yourself...
She is smart,objective,eloquent and very articulate,i love her❤❤❤❤
This woman is a puppet,
This advocate knows law, she knows that you don't go overboard when investigating.
Very true
Law dictates not feelings,Gcaleka stands her grounds🙏
She is a psychopath....fearless and evil to the core....
True
WOW! This journalist Bongo is awesome!
The acting PP dealt with the evidence provided to them by the president. And investigated that evidence.
So the CEO of a company does not profit from the company because there are managers who run the company with employees when he is at the beach or overseas.
Oh my word, this Kholeka woman is an embarrassment to the office of the Public Protector... she even twists what has been confirmed by CR.
Journalist must be protected
She lying no democry in South Africa ,those who have money get away with their crimes
I'm not ANC but we must respect the section 9 institution as some people have been preaching
Say that louder
Someone very powerful is watching this interview with a wide smile, saying you have done pretty amazing my child on representing me and you will get the outstanding ballance with no doubt😂
The assertion that being a farmer is not having a job is ludicrous.
I wish she could interrogate Mkhwebane in this way....
Great job from the interviewer!! She exposed this liar.
Rampoes why did you not declare the dollars as it is a legal requirement to report it to sars
He wasn’t there and HE doesn’t handle day to day operations, such as banking or declaring monies. Had he done what you say, you would be hauling him over the coals for breaching his code of ethics. Don’t be in such a hurry to see a black government fall that you lose all logic and reason.
"Sis BONGI Is A 'TIgress'....'The Acting PP Is 'Swimming Against The OCEAN'"
There is something in that "...however the courts will decide." 18:20
We are staring at a person who is already supplicating tainted officiators to find in favour of camp rama.
And it will agree with her in everything except for her interpretation of what constitutes "paid work"
@@GeniusLila it will agree with her on everything needed to clear ramaphosa regardless of whether it sullies the entire legal system. For example we have now a new precedent where one, if that one is sufficiently resourced, can apply to a civil court to interdict a criminal proceeding.
Ramaphosas pullet I didn't come as a shock to me was expecting this bullshit
"ACTING PUBLIC PROTECTOR" WANTS TO BE "PUBLIC PROTECTOR" !!!
Mkhwebane sent 31 questions to the president without any formal affidavit lodged by the complainant😮😮😮😮?????????????😮😮😮😮. Ai Busisiwe le yena aaikhona
strangely, non of these journalists seems concerned with that.. Busisiwe rushed the questions to ramaphosa just before she was suspended, without even waiting for an affidavit or doing any further investigation.. she just took frazers allegations as a weapon to quickly send questions to Ramaphosa.. In SA, a police van doesnt even respond to a crime scene that fast..lol
@@dilochetty9332that’s why all her reports taken on review were quashed by the courts & her competency & credentials questioned. Playing to the gallery like a populist on issues of law does not work.
@@dilochetty9332That was the plan. They wanted to discredit the President. That’s why they can’t handle Gcaleka’s findings.
@@khaltsharivist365Finally some sanity.
Why protecting President while we see for ourselves (the people) that Cyril is a mess, you can tell ever since he came to power things just went bad till today.
We no longer have a public protector but a president protector
Phala phala farmgate will be the downfall of many institutions, organizations, and careers.
But he also said his business is declared in parliament😅😅😅
Thank you. They don’t get it!!
I amazed that is never mentioned by journalist
I applaud the journalist, she exposed the liar
Can Sakina Kamwendo from SABC interview this PP please.
I have the same sentiments
I own a transport business, but I am not the one driving the vehicles. But I can still say I move people around, but that does not mean I am personally behind the wheel carrying out that activity. 🤦🏾
Do you get paid out of that Job?
@@lavhelesanirasiuba1654 day to day is different from members interest
@@lavhelesanirasiuba1654 No, I have a job that pays me a monthly salary. I don't withdraw a salary from the business. I would if I was doing the driving myself.
@@lavhelesanirasiuba1654 the business is his, therefore any profit made is made on his behalf
@@QothaBut he doesn’t work there… I’ll give you an example: Say you was a municipal worker. I take some of the money I earn every month and buy Satrix shares from Standard Bank. I earn interest on the money I invest. Am I now suddenly an employee of Standard Bank? That’s the type of interest he has in that farm. He invested in a revenue generating farm. He doesn’t work there, he’s a member, as I would be a member of Satrix.
Get it?
I just love the calmness from the Acting Public Protector, she's displaying a very strong personality in a very calm manner 👌👌👌, I just love a strong woman umthetho wam, I so wish that she gets the PP position. hayi ndiyamthanda for the position, she puts all the emotions aside and sticks on the interpretation of the law not noise making in front of the camera.
Namanga
Calm to fool you properly
She still young for the job
My fellow country man, the lady was anything but calm. If you insist that she was calm. You will be confirming your lack of knowldge of a person's demeanour. Read her body language dispassionately. Look at how she insist on finishing her clearly unintelligible argumentation.
Please relook at the interview.
😅😅😅 Ayilwisi ayixabanisi ntozakuthi, just air yo own views, mhlawumbi ke nokufunda ukuba at least we can respect isihlalo somntu xa sisoyiswa ukumnika yena intlonipho, ndafundiswa ngelohlobo kemna madoda kwi leadership sizakohluka nje kulo nkalo 😅😅, u can ask google for interpretation, cheers.
GCALEKA: We've got a collegial relationship with Adv Mkhwebane.
Oxford dictionary of Collegial: Collegial is an adjective describing a work environment where responsibility and authority is shared equally by colleagues.
Me: Adv Gcaleka uses words whose meaning she doesn't know, conversely Adv Gcaleka is deceitful and thus unqualified to be in the acting role of the PP.
I repeat Again, *IS THE PUBLIC PROTECTERS OFFICE ONLY OPEN FOR FEMALES? *
What is your point how many institutions in SA lead by men .man or woman its a paid puppet postion.
The first PP of our democratic government is male.
the 1st PP was male.. i think we have only had 4 PPs thus far
Mushwana & Baqwa - Males
Mybe if it was a men would not be afraid to speak the truth
Where is her moral compass i think she is really "acting" like actually fulfilling a role
She didn't even entertain the money Laundering alligation shame to her
We finally have public protector here..
👏👏👏 cool calm & collected APP👏👏
So proud of her.
Am also saying the same
“We must learn that passively to accept an unjust system is to cooperate with that system, and thereby to become a participant in its evil.” Martin Luther King. This woman may call or see herself a public advocate but she has clearly become a public advocate and participant for an unjust evil system. She will be remembered for this.
Great job avocate u answered at your best, Cyril never stole from state purse anyway.
SABC please invite Thuli Madonsela to comment on this report. I want to see something
Selling is not are job😂😂😂
This lady should stop doing interviews. She was terrible at Newsroom not long, she's on SABC making herself a fool. I don't know why she feels she has to do this to herself.
LOL - The president says "I sell", then Gcaleka says "no the president does not know what he's talking about, he does not sell", Oh my word!!!
She cannot even find it within herself to defend her work in front of a journalist. Weird!!
Kudos to the Presenter / host - Well done sisis!
If this case goes to court the President will not make it.
Its funny, everyone wants the pp to go according to their opinions
Miss cover-up Gcaleka, you are just fighting for your career and you will be rewarded we know
I have full respect for the pp. She is very smart and clued to what she's talking about. I wish we should all learn
1) What we must learn?
2) What makes her smart or what is smart about her?
Don't speak without facts, give us facts