For anyone curious if Japanese sharpshooters could be accurate - during the Warring States period Oda Nobunaga suffered two gunshot wounds from a sniper.
This is a wild over exaggeration that is wrong. Korea was far more focused on cannon and Japan was far more focused on matchlocks. Saying they had zero of the other type is impossible to prove historically.
That’s incorrect information. The korea army already knew the existence of matchlocks but they didn’t utilize as it isn’t effective than theirs prior gunpowder weapons , such as chong-tong series, furthermore they thought their bow would be better than matchlocks in real battle.
한국인입니다. 한국에도 당연히 총이 있었고, 일본에도 화포가 있었습니다. 당시 일본은 전국시대를 거치며 총을 기본 무기로 발전시켰고, 유럽 전체 화약을 합친 것보다도 더 많은 양의 화약을 비축한 상황입니다. 일본은 16세기 대항해시대 유럽 포르투칼로부터 기술을 이전받아 발전시켰고, 한국은 중국의 기술을 발전시켰던 상황이었습니다. 한국의 총은 일본의 총보다 실전에서 유용하지 못했습니다. 그리고 한국의 화포 기술은 북방 민족을 방어해야 했기 때문에, 일본보다 발전하였습니다. 자세한 내용은 다음 영상에서 나옵니다. 영어 자막도 지원합니다. ruclips.net/video/FBM4JoTpv4E/видео.html
Matchlocks can be incredibly accurate. And at this point in history Japanese matchlocks were of a higher quality than European ones as the Japanese learned from the European design and improved upon it.
@@Quincy_Morris it was 1590s so the matchlock was not yet improved, but yet in the movie it accurately snipe a person one after another without missing a shot and almost got General Kim Yu Sun-shin✌️😆
박취문의 일기 중에 인조 23년 5월에 있은 한 시합에서 꼴찌였던 군관 김신의 성적은 50발 중에서 43발을 명중시킬 정도의 괜찮은 성적이었다. 12월에 군관들끼리 4명씩 편을 갈라 시합했을 때 8명의 성적이 모두 나와 있는데, 50발 명중이 2명, 49발‧48발‧47발이 각각 1명, 45발이 2명, 43발이 1명으로 꼴찌의 성적 실제 조선시대 장수들 활 실력을 보면 100m 에서 감귤을 과녁으로 해서 50발중에 43발 명중이 최하위 였다 당시 사람들의 실력으로 화살로 사람의 눈에 꼽는건 매우 쉬운일이었다
I don't know about the matchlock gun the Japanese were using but you can visit the island where Admiral Yi stayed and developed the Turtle Ship in Korea. It's a craggy, beautiful place that has temples and is all nicely made up. You can visit the shooting range where Admiral Yi used to practice his archery. It's pretty goddamn far. I think we'd be surprised at proficiency of soldiers and their ancient weapons if we were to go back. Imagine a world where you kill or get killed depending on how good you are with your weapon. That's something we can't imagine.
if you actually know anything about archery you'll know that muskets are more accurate than arrows, historical accounts from europeans, japanese, koreans, chinese all agreed that matchlock arquebuses have superior range and accuracy to bow and arrows.
you guys must no understanding matchlocks or naval war date very well if you think matchlocks couldn't be accurate, obviously not to the point of early modern rifles even but still accurate. and they're positioned up high so they have a better angle. no point in hiding on a ship cause there's only so many places you can be
Its unfortunate they didnt have any larger Japenese names for the Japanese army- I know the movie is a bit of a bragging piece and nationalistic for the Koreans, but I really felt they made the Japanese not look too bad in this movie. Sure they are absolutely the bad guys, but they at least look badass and competent too. I never feel they come off as weak, and they look like great fighters as well.
This movie was weird It was super gritty and had amazing costumes. While on the other hand. It was sometimes unrealistic to like shonen anime levels of unrealistic.
You probably just don’t understand korean history, but that’s ok. There’s a series depicting Yi Sun Shin’s history on a RUclips channel called extra credit history, and you can actually make some parallels between the videos and this movie, like where the flagship actually fought by itself for a while. But, you don’t have to believe me. You can always just believe that the Koreans aren’t as resilient as they were depicted, and should have been under Japanese rule to spread their anime influence along with their asscheeks before their rightful masters. Have a nice day! ☺️
It didn’t really beat him, the sniper just didn’t expect it. Of course if it was a one on one battle, the sniper would have one because it was simply a better weapon.
Bows are incredibly more accurate during the time period this is set in the thing im most impressed by though is that musket was even able to hit that accurate
@@neptunum21.29 highly doubt shooting bow at such angle would perform any better than a musket and arrows were more affected by winds than bullets so no they weren’t
It's not a rifle because it won't have rifling. During the 17th century Joseon fought against some Russians and the Joseon shooters used pretty much the same gun to snipe the Russians. If you study etymology the origin of the word 'sniper' came from a small but agile bird species called snipe. An excellent shooter back then would have been able to shoot and kill this bird with a musket. That's where the word snipe came from. You really shouldn't be surprised at all. Muskets were fairly accurate. Getting someone with a bow and a arrow is much harder than using a musket.
@@Hayan_Yeou muskets were not accurate. Rifles were accurate. Now I wonder if the tanegashima had rifled bores, there is no way they had minie balls that was too far in the future.
@@undrgrnd734 You seem to be ignoring the human factor, some are just so talented and experience that they can fire a musket with such accuracy that its almost a myth... It's a movie so it's guaranteed to be exaggerated but people from around the world have been making amazing shots from a bow and arrow. I'm not an archer so I'm not gonna say that's possible or impossible but reading historical accounts of feats of marksmanship, and seening some unbelievable shots from a bow in real life made me realize how human factors are underrated. So its not that difficult to imagine someone trained and blessed with talent making shots that can land a world record.
@@whoever7033 Back in the days our primary weapons were the bows and arrow. Pretty much everyone in Joseon was able to shoot an arrow out of a bow and knew how to use them. Even kings and scholars knew how to use a bow and an arrow. Archery was considered to be a social norm. Ancient archers were very accurate and agile.
@@Hayan_Yeou i understand that they were skilled , but for that distance and for a moving target -by the waves- and considering the wind speed and all it's just impossible . But , for the sake of peace : Maybe it isn't
@@whoever7033 who says? I mean, the distance is a bit emphasized (it's a movie) but can you see the wind on sight in real time? Korea was a country that used a lot of bows for generations. It comes out in our bedtime stories and legends too. I'm not an archer so I'm not gonna say that's possible or impossible but the reality is that's what they had to do. Maybe in shorter distance but doable. The military exam in that era involved shooting from 145m, shooting from a horse back and shooting moving targets. Naval soldiers were specialised to shoot on the ship as well. Gakgung or Korean warbow has range of around 300 to 340m. So as I said, maybe shorter distance but it would have been possible. One thing that modern people think is that archery is inaccurate and slow but it was never the case. In many cases, swords were used as a secondary where was bows were the primary weapons during the Joseon dynasty. Archery was important, even scholars knew how to use a bow and it was considered to be a 'must do' for anyone who calls himself a scholar or a noble. Pretty sure they knew how to calculate wind like they do in modern archery.
For anyone curious if Japanese sharpshooters could be accurate - during the Warring States period Oda Nobunaga suffered two gunshot wounds from a sniper.
And survived meanwhile one of Nobunaga’s biggest rivals Takeda Shingen was one shotted by some random sniper and some random siege
Reportedly didn't he take at least one round that was stopped by his armor?
Me: "O she's kinda fine-"
*arrow hits*
MANLY SCREEAM
Me: 👁️👄👁️
If there’s a hole, there’s a goal my friend
@@cockdepartment6610 🤢
Yea I find her kinda good looking, especially very beautiful eyes... until I hear that scream, lol.
"Is that Frost?"
Every Korean knows that Japanese invaders are effeminate prissy princess with thick eyeliners and blush ons.
Or as we know it today, K-pop boyband.
At that time, the Korean army had cannons but no matchlocks (for defending pirates); the Japanese army had matchlocks but no cannons (for army). Fun
This is a wild over exaggeration that is wrong.
Korea was far more focused on cannon and Japan was far more focused on matchlocks.
Saying they had zero of the other type is impossible to prove historically.
That’s incorrect information. The korea army already knew the existence of matchlocks but they didn’t utilize as it isn’t effective than theirs prior gunpowder weapons , such as chong-tong series, furthermore they thought their bow would be better than matchlocks in real battle.
Uchiha Itachi!!
@@Quincy_Morris we focus on killing the sanke!!
한국인입니다. 한국에도 당연히 총이 있었고, 일본에도 화포가 있었습니다.
당시 일본은 전국시대를 거치며 총을 기본 무기로 발전시켰고, 유럽 전체 화약을 합친 것보다도 더 많은 양의 화약을 비축한 상황입니다.
일본은 16세기 대항해시대 유럽 포르투칼로부터 기술을 이전받아 발전시켰고, 한국은 중국의 기술을 발전시켰던 상황이었습니다.
한국의 총은 일본의 총보다 실전에서 유용하지 못했습니다. 그리고 한국의 화포 기술은 북방 민족을 방어해야 했기 때문에, 일본보다 발전하였습니다.
자세한 내용은 다음 영상에서 나옵니다. 영어 자막도 지원합니다.
ruclips.net/video/FBM4JoTpv4E/видео.html
2:10 that was amazing shot😉
It s very badass
Yes!!!!
The sniper, she has quite beautiful eyes tho...
Wait...
Noooooo !!! The sniper is Man. HE is famous musician & actor. He is very beautiful and hansome. His name is (No Minue).
Lol is that really a matchlock?!! It's too damn accurate 😅😆😂
There were actually accurate shooters in the past much more accurate than the shooters these days.
@@qaydenstephens5783 bow and arrow are more accurate, unlike the matchlock you need to spray and pray to hit😆
Matchlocks can be incredibly accurate. And at this point in history Japanese matchlocks were of a higher quality than European ones as the Japanese learned from the European design and improved upon it.
@@Quincy_Morris it was 1590s so the matchlock was not yet improved, but yet in the movie it accurately snipe a person one after another without missing a shot and almost got General Kim Yu Sun-shin✌️😆
@Deus vult meme intensifies Search Kings and General as well as Metatron video on that battle and they will say that it's a load of BS.
박취문의 일기 중에 인조 23년 5월에 있은 한 시합에서 꼴찌였던 군관 김신의 성적은
50발 중에서 43발을 명중시킬 정도의 괜찮은 성적이었다.
12월에 군관들끼리 4명씩 편을 갈라 시합했을 때 8명의 성적이 모두 나와 있는데, 50발
명중이 2명, 49발‧48발‧47발이 각각 1명, 45발이 2명, 43발이 1명으로 꼴찌의 성적
실제 조선시대 장수들 활 실력을 보면 100m 에서 감귤을 과녁으로 해서 50발중에 43발 명중이 최하위 였다 당시 사람들의 실력으로
화살로 사람의 눈에 꼽는건 매우 쉬운일이었다
무과 합격하려면 활을 잘쏴야 합격이니까 장수들은 기본적으로 다 잘했을거임
활 dna 하나는 못 까지
Until the scream I really though the sniper was a woman
I don't know about the matchlock gun the Japanese were using but you can visit the island where Admiral Yi stayed and developed the Turtle Ship in Korea. It's a craggy, beautiful place that has temples and is all nicely made up. You can visit the shooting range where Admiral Yi used to practice his archery. It's pretty goddamn far. I think we'd be surprised at proficiency of soldiers and their ancient weapons if we were to go back. Imagine a world where you kill or get killed depending on how good you are with your weapon. That's something we can't imagine.
Same
that sniper is probably a former onnagata in kabuki
Me too, he looked like a Japanese Rosamund Pike.
@@trex1448 They were using Tanegashima rifle.
I've been searching for this movie !!
ruclips.net/video/7pbk5knVPUs/видео.html
At that time arrows was more accurate than musket
Hehe yeah its a bit silly.
and still is. if you don't aknow anything about Archery that's that type of comment you'll make lol.
if you actually know anything about archery you'll know that muskets are more accurate than arrows, historical accounts from europeans, japanese, koreans, chinese all agreed that matchlock arquebuses have superior range and accuracy to bow and arrows.
you guys must no understanding matchlocks or naval war date very well if you think matchlocks couldn't be accurate, obviously not to the point of early modern rifles even but still accurate. and they're positioned up high so they have a better angle. no point in hiding on a ship cause there's only so many places you can be
When I saw the snipers female facial look: Oh that chick looking fine as
When the arrow hits her and didn’t know it was a man the whole time: 💀💥🔫
And while this is Happening, a Ashin is in Chupajin is unleashing Zombies throughout the Military Base and Killing everyone~
This sniper doesn’t hide like the Codm snipers lmao
The man who shot the arrow is Anwi !
that musket's effective kill zone no more than 200 m. and its extremely inaccurate. Those ships at least 1 km away from each other.
Go raise the flag-a!
The Shinobi has been slain
Its unfortunate they didnt have any larger Japenese names for the Japanese army- I know the movie is a bit of a bragging piece and nationalistic for the Koreans, but I really felt they made the Japanese not look too bad in this movie. Sure they are absolutely the bad guys, but they at least look badass and competent too. I never feel they come off as weak, and they look like great fighters as well.
anyone know the name of the ost/music that begins right when the sniper is hit in the eye
Those ancient weapon were really acurate
Yeah, weird that a movie that has amazing battle scenes and accurate costumes but have some cheesy moments
This movie was weird
It was super gritty and had amazing costumes.
While on the other hand. It was sometimes unrealistic to like shonen anime levels of unrealistic.
Yeah, some parts were cheesy, but ignoring all of those. The battle scenes were absolutely amazing and the costumes were on point
@@cakeboy7782 yeah. My boy Yi Sun Sin wrecking the Japanese fleet hehehe
They actually made Yi less OP in this movie than he was in real life.
You probably just don’t understand korean history, but that’s ok. There’s a series depicting Yi Sun Shin’s history on a RUclips channel called extra credit history, and you can actually make some parallels between the videos and this movie, like where the flagship actually fought by itself for a while. But, you don’t have to believe me. You can always just believe that the Koreans aren’t as resilient as they were depicted, and should have been under Japanese rule to spread their anime influence along with their asscheeks before their rightful masters.
Have a nice day! ☺️
It’s usually because people don’t realise this movie is based on real historical facts.
Snipers are supposed to hide and attack, but they've gone up on the roof and exposed themselves defensively, so it's no wonder they're being attacked
where else he gonna go? he needs an angle to shoot, sure it's unconventional and a bit weird but an angle is an angle. there are watch towers
@@Yeongboemkim365 while making the gun they should use any shiny metals for decor💀
@@provedevilwrong Stop trying to push this they/them stuff. That’s a he and we non-Americans will never accept your pronoun nonsense.
What kind of eyesight would you need to make shots like that?
all you gotta do is eat a lot of carrots
Face a sniper, replies with a cannon. Seems, accurate enougth….
Sharingan!!!!
The fek why is that gun have a very long range?
Where I can watch the full.movie of this?
ruclips.net/video/7pbk5knVPUs/видео.html
The truth [get to work zone for holiday and I'm just 👇
konohamoro coseplay
The bow beat the musket....?
My thought exactly
It didn’t really beat him, the sniper just didn’t expect it. Of course if it was a one on one battle, the sniper would have one because it was simply a better weapon.
The musket didnt pay attention. Thats why he loss
Bows are incredibly more accurate during the time period this is set in the thing im most impressed by though is that musket was even able to hit that accurate
@@neptunum21.29 highly doubt shooting bow at such angle would perform any better than a musket and arrows were more affected by winds than bullets so no they weren’t
T you for joining NN you j and of itself to get the first#weruo
The and you can#@tyoiip#GTA
Really? Musket sniper rifle?
Really. Why are you surprised?
Arquebus you uncultured swine.
It's not a rifle because it won't have rifling.
During the 17th century Joseon fought against some Russians and the Joseon shooters used pretty much the same gun to snipe the Russians.
If you study etymology the origin of the word 'sniper' came from a small but agile bird species called snipe.
An excellent shooter back then would have been able to shoot and kill this bird with a musket.
That's where the word snipe came from.
You really shouldn't be surprised at all. Muskets were fairly accurate.
Getting someone with a bow and a arrow is much harder than using a musket.
@@Hayan_Yeou muskets were not accurate. Rifles were accurate. Now I wonder if the tanegashima had rifled bores, there is no way they had minie balls that was too far in the future.
@@undrgrnd734 You seem to be ignoring the human factor, some are just so talented and experience that they can fire a musket with such accuracy that its almost a myth... It's a movie so it's guaranteed to be exaggerated but people from around the world have been making amazing shots from a bow and arrow.
I'm not an archer so I'm not gonna say that's possible or impossible but reading historical accounts of feats of marksmanship, and seening some unbelievable shots from a bow in real life made me realize how human factors are underrated.
So its not that difficult to imagine someone trained and blessed with talent making shots that can land a world record.
.
普通に作品としてもとても楽しめるな
왜? 너희가 패배한 전쟁이라서?
일본 역사서와 중국 역사서를 확인하세요. 거의 동일하게 기재되어 있습니다.
@@user-fp2pj4ph5l 근데 실제 역사에서는 일본배는 전투력이 거의 없고 내구성 낮은 기동력 위주의 보급선이라 픽션이 좀 첨가된거긴함
@@user-fp2pj4ph5l 아니 갑자기 직격타 날리지 말라고ㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-iv3pi3rx5h 그건 세키부네중에서도 작은배들임 안택선이 지휘 군선이었고 안택선 규모야 말할 필요없고
Should have sent sekiro
That's impossible
Not for Admiral Yi.
@@whoever7033 Back in the days our primary weapons were the bows and arrow.
Pretty much everyone in Joseon was able to shoot an arrow out of a bow and knew how to use them. Even kings and scholars knew how to use a bow and an arrow.
Archery was considered to be a social norm.
Ancient archers were very accurate and agile.
@@Hayan_Yeou i understand that they were skilled , but for that distance and for a moving target -by the waves- and considering the wind speed and all it's just impossible .
But , for the sake of peace :
Maybe it isn't
@@whoever7033 who says? I mean, the distance is a bit emphasized (it's a movie) but can you see the wind on sight in real time? Korea was a country that used a lot of bows for generations. It comes out in our bedtime stories and legends too. I'm not an archer so I'm not gonna say that's possible or impossible but the reality is that's what they had to do. Maybe in shorter distance but doable.
The military exam in that era involved shooting from 145m, shooting from a horse back and shooting moving targets. Naval soldiers were specialised to shoot on the ship as well. Gakgung or Korean warbow has range of around 300 to 340m.
So as I said, maybe shorter distance but it would have been possible.
One thing that modern people think is that archery is inaccurate and slow but it was never the case.
In many cases, swords were used as a secondary where was bows were the primary weapons during the Joseon dynasty. Archery was important, even scholars knew how to use a bow and it was considered to be a 'must do' for anyone who calls himself a scholar or a noble.
Pretty sure they knew how to calculate wind like they do in modern archery.
@@Hayan_Yeou
I see
Bullseye
¹
Dubbing alert
Damn I thought that was a chick until I heard him 🥲