Milwaukee VS Makita Impact Driver | M18 Fuel 2953 vs XGT GDT01
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 мар 2023
- Milwaukee vs Makita, two powerhouses in the power tool industry, and we've got their flagship impact drivers putting them head to head. Who do you think will win this matchup between the Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2953 and the Makita XGT GDT01?
Also, who do you want to see go head to head in the future? We've got plans for additional models from Flex, DeWalt, Ryobi, Hilti, Metabo HPT, Ridgid, Craftsman and more. Leave a comment down below on what brands, and what tools you'd like to see go toe-to-toe!
BUY HERE
Milwaukee M18 Fuel Impact Driver: bit.ly/3FPMCZU
Makita XGT Impact Driver: bit.ly/3K3ST6S
READ MORE
www.protoolreviews.com/best-i...
Subscribe and click on the bell to see new videos weekly: bit.ly/3cZUQzi
► Give us a like on Facebook! / protoolreviews
► Follow us on Instagram! / protoolreviews 
Авто/Мото
My father did construction his entire life and recently retired. He bought his makita tools in the 1980s and they all still work never broken down on him and he used and abused them to the max and theyre still running strong 💪 epic lol
They arent like that anymore sadly
" HILTI " - same , still strong ....👍 ( особенно перфораторы и отбойники , - " пашут ,как медные котелки " , только у меня из середины 90 - х ...🤗 ) 🦾💪👍
I am a big Makita fan, but it appears that the 40v XGT impact is somewhat of a dud. I think they just fit a 36v batter onto a XDT19. I hope they have something better in the works.
As to the torque result, I think Milwaukee is the king for pure power. But power isn't everything.
I still have my brushed impact Makita from 2007 and it still runs on common Makita batteries. It's driven way over a million screws, been dropped a bunch. All the aesthetic trim pieces are gone and is worn to the point where it looks like I dragged it behind my truck. Still runs great! Makita is the Toyota of tools. Not flashy, but lasts and lasts.
This Makita is already 2 generations old. They have the TD002G with the 4 lights, and the newest one with the light ring
Not a dud. These tests aren't things you'd use an impact for. They're to see what the limits are. You wouldn't use an impact to drive a 10 in lag, you would use a drill so it's not really relevant.
@@lk7195 I bought my first Makita impact driver in 2007 for professional use. I’ve stuck with the brand ever since. I’ve driven a lot of lags and I’ve always used my impact drivers. The only screw I don’t use my impacts with are tapcons.
@@SkilletsUSMC I use a drill for anything that would strain an impact. It's much faster.
@@histguy101 the TD002G is the best impact I've ever used, the trigger is smooth as hell and it rarely gets hot thanks to the 40v.
Lifetime Makita user. Sure has made my life better.
With Makita having a much more balanced rpm, it’s definitely smoother impact. Milwaukee however with its higher rpm and torque makes it more rougher to handle and less smooth but definitely stronger. I will say Milwaukee’s biggest design flaw is the rear fan vent. That thing will slap you with some small rocks and sand.
Facts facts facts. That vent on the Milwaukee 👎👎
You princess or what
Always wear your safety glasses 🤓
@@greysonanthou7568that thing really blows
made zero damn sense..wtf is balanced rpm please explain and how is it better
The real test unfortunately will take about 6-7 yrs to see the durability aspects. I can only speak anecdotally to the reliability of Makita vs Milwaukee especially on their high end line. Makita just will last longer and I noticed that wobble at 1:50. That really bothers me on impacts when you're in a precarious position and only have one hand to steady the driver. There's more to performance than just specs and having an extra second quickness. The philosophy almost perfectly compares to boring Toyotas (detuned, lower performance but well within spec) vs maxxed out half-baked Jeeps/Dodges. The lots are empty on one with no discounts, the other is stacked with incentives.
i cant say between makita and milwaukee, but from experience at work we went through 3 dewalt xr drivers within the span of 6 months, the chuck came completely loose on one, the battery slot on one of them snapped off, after falling 4 feet from a ladder onto osb flooring, and the newest one already has signifcant chuck wobble even when not under load, making it almost impossible to do any sheet metal work in a timely manner
id choose anything but dewalt at this point
@@coolerthanyou9548 ya, i've noticed that too a lot of dewalts feel 'loose' after awhile
@coolerthanyou yeah dewalts don't last me either so I switched to milwaukee and stayed with them. I bought a drill and Impact of the m18 brushed line back in 2008 and used them pretty much every day. Last year the brushes went in the Impact so I replaced them. It now works greT again. The drill still works and so does both the 4ah batteries. So I'd say 14 years if great to get out of a tool
Makita batteries will last half than Milwaukee's.
that's wild ive thrown my dewalt off 2 stories twice already, used it all winter last year in our rain season had it in the water/mud@@coolerthanyou9548
In Australia Makita and Toyota are King ! Both are slightly detuned over the competition but are by far the most reliable. We live in tough conditions with extreme remote areas and reliability is everything!
Milwaukee is cheaper, has more ass, and better warranty. I have a 8 year old makita and it's still going strong but if it broke I might switch.
on the job sites i’ve been on most pol run milwaukee or dewalt
Na, not really… dummy
Makita ergonomics and trigger are far superior. It isnt all about power.
I run both Makita (since 2011) and Milwaukee (Started buying M12 & M18 last 3 years)
Ive only had 1 makita tool break and they warrantied it. Had it back the next day fixed.
Ive had to warranty 5 or 6 Milwaukee tools at this point. They definitely dont last but their warranty is super. Never waited more then a week and had a brand new tool returned from my local repair center.
I do have to say though, other the the grip on the M12s due to battery design, i do love that line up of 12V. Theyve got everyone else beat there hands down.
interesting been running a mix of Milwaukee and DeWalt tools for a little over 9 years now, and i think i've maybe warrantied 2 Milwaukee items total, both where replaced instantly at the counter no questions asked, DeWalt is another story tryna get rid of those little nightmares slowly, but the only guy I know with Makita can't keep them running in cold weather as the batterys quit on him or won't recharge for a while afterwards, and he seems to always be having issues with his Hammer Drill chuck.
@@TheTemplarnight Well I live in Canada and both my brands of tools work just fine in -30C when I leave them in my work truck.
No lithium batteries from any company charge if they're too cold. They all have a temperature cutoff at 0C.
@@evictioncarpentry2628 I'm Canadian as well, and i disagree here, i've had my Milwaukees charging outside on -8C days and they charged up, slower but they still did it.
@@TheTemplarnight The batteries literally have a temperature sensor inside to cut off charging below 0C because it damages lithium cells when charged below freezing. Go look up the spec sheet on everyone's batteries.
If yours do, all that means is you're killing the cells. None of my makita or Milwaukee Batts will charge at those Temps. They will both give the blinking light on temperature.
@@evictioncarpentry2628 Dunno what to tell you, but all my by now ancient 5.0s and 1.0s charge at pretty cold temps, have yet to test my new high output 6.0, 8.0 or 12.0s yet. but thus far those 5.0 and 1.0s have lived at least 9 years of their life charging in -1C - -8C days and they're still trucking.
Why not test them doing things they're actually designed for? If I was running lags that size I would use a drill instead and if I have nuts or bolts over 1/2 inch I'm grabbing my impact wrench.
That's dumb
Makita, Japanese engineering vs Milwaukee, wonder which one is going to last the longest 🤔
The Toyota 4Runner is not the best in towing, horse power, size, price, technology, comfort, mpg etc etc etc but it will last 400,000-500,000 miles, 2-6x longer than the competition ❤❤❤ I'll take the 4Runner every day.
Exactamente . Una 4runner nunca se les ve en un taller ..solamente se les ve ..cuando le hacen un servicio simple.
👍
4Runners suck! They’re made for little Japanese people! My 13 year old son didn’t have headroom in the back of our rental. The 4Runner is reliable but it’s an overpriced, cramped, slow piece of Pooh.
I can show you 400k gm and Ford trucks all day long. Literally dozens for sale every week in our area. Don't believe the hype. Everyone makes a good truck. That's the point of a truck; build it tougher than its job. Not many Tundra's on the construction sites. They are great trucks, but not comparable in a hard work environment. Toyota doesn't evenmake a commercial grade vehicle to even compare.
my next-door neighbor's Dodge Ram was over 300,000 miles before he got rid of it
I just bought replacements of my Makita tools that are still running strong from 2010 lol. I bought new ones simply because there was a sale. I had a split second where I regretted not switching to Milwaukee as everyone asks me why but I much prefer to sacrifice a second than the longevity of a tool and how easy they are to handle (ya it’s cause I’m a woman 😂)
I bought a Milwaukee set just to see what the hype is about... I was rather disappointed honestly, the trigger isn't as easy to control and it's overall not as precise... I'll stick to Makita
@@trentonhay3552 same for my dad after getting the fuel a few months after I switched from dewalt to makita. It works fine, but the makita is very ergonomic.
Not about power. I do Solar and banging out lags all day long, I’ve had to replace Milwaukee about 4 times in 2 years. Makita, not even once. No brainer
That’s really interesting actually, now I have to ask was it Japanese Makita or Chinese made? I’ve heard a lot of good things about the Japanese stuff but it’s hard to get a hold of in the states.
@@tylerswain7103All of my Chinese made makita products have been very reliable. My Chinese made Milwaukee has not been so tough though.
The comparison test was great what if I just need a drill for simple house work and our jobs? With Makita be an OK choice
I hope I get to your level one day. you videos are amazing!
All of my chordless tools are milwaukee and they are amazing. But I tried my coworkers makita impact drivers a few times and I've gotta say those things are the smoothest and most comfortable impacts I've ever used. The speed and power isn't quite as good as milwaukee but if I had to use one or the other I'd choose makita. Only reason I don't own one is becuase I prefer to stick to one type of battery and I like more of the tools in milwaukees line than makitas. But makitas impact driver definetly beats milwaukees
Although the milwaukee is shorter, it has a wider head. I prefer the makitas narrower design. You can get into tighter corners. Milwaukee always has the most power. In my opinion makita is my favorite for ergonomics
I run both batteries... Honestly I love the Makita trigger they are easier to control the speed but at the end of the day I use Milwaukee most of the time
Always using the Makita Impact at an angle.
Always excuses
Both fantastic tools no doubt
Surprised NO reviewers seem to test trigger control of all the impacts, especially given Milwaukee made such a big deal of the Gen 4 trigger refinements.
The only person I've seen focus on this is Doc of Last Best Tool, and he specifically commends the Surge line for much finer control.
PTR:
Request for a trigger sensitivity (inc speed steps) test including:
Flex QE
Makita TD002
M18 Gen 4
Metabo SSD 18 LTX 200
Festool TID 18
Hercules (new)
Kobalt XTR
Just got the gen 4 Milwaukee today. Never used Makita so I can't compare, but I love my M12 and M18 systems all the way around.
Love both the 18 and 40 volt makita. Used fuel tools in the past. They are comparable depending on models. But the ergo is much better on the makita IMO
@@thorinbaneyou can just see and feel how better built they are. No disrespect to Milwaukee, had their tools for years and they are very good. But since using Makita I won’t go back
I’d buy Makita every time and I’ve used them both. Because the Makita is better built and feels so much better in my hand.
This was created for Milwaukee obviously. Let's not give Milwaukee free insite
Na, not really
@@trentroberdeau1462how are you telling him how it feels in his hand smh
I saw the Makit 40v Kit with the Impact and Hammer Drill for $449 at Home Depot , so to Pay $429 just for the Impact Kit Driver is Insane 😂🤣😂
Just bought the makita kit for 350$ and a free battery lol
you can get it for $350 right now even, so its cheaper than the milwaukee! I got both and am probably going to return the milwaukee kit this weekend. The impact definitely seems superior, but I feel like its just a matter of time for Makita to update their impact with a ring light (like the new LXT) and a little beefier motor.
@@movek408 Where ???
@@panzerkiller13 Where at ??
@@brianf9619 I got mine from toolsplus!
I personally own Makita Impact drivers, a Makita cordless drill, and a corded Makita drill from 1990, and they all run great. I am loyal to the Makita brand. I have friends who are die-hard Milwaukee owners. I have to admit, Milwaukee makes really dam good power tools. I'm a loyalist, so I will only buy Makita products with my money, but if someone bought me a Milwaukee power tool for Christmas, I would be happy. I don't think you could go wrong with either brand, just pick the one you want to bond with for the rest of your life cause that's what most power tool owners do is start a tool collection without even knowing it. Great review sir, excellent stuff ! 🚀🚀
Had both, Makita is way better, Milwaukee only beats it in power.
We’ve used Makita and now Milwaukee at work, I’ve been blown away by Milwaukee. Nothing against Makita but Milwaukee just seems better. The lineup is better at HD too.
Do both batteries use the same 18650 cells?
What I like about Makita impact drivers is they don’t beat you to death when you run them all day. Milwaukee and Hercules impact drivers Will fatigue you far more than Makita
rip makita
@@EpicBadTeams Personally if I wasn’t driving lags I would use the Makita over the Milwaukee
just a note milwaukee Fuel tools are supposed to be using the High Output battier XC 3.0, 6.0, 8.0 and 12.0 because the tool gets an extra 30% boost from the battery for the m18 fuel line
He used the batteries that come in the kits, which also happen to be the fair comparison
M18 5.0ah-72 watt hours
XGT 40v 2.5ah-72 watt hours
Makita also has larger, high output batteries, but they don't come it the kit
as a milwaukee guy, i use mostly m18 and i use a old 2nd gen so i would love to try the new 4 gen!
It probably didn’t make a 4 second difference, but the person driving lags with the Makita should drive them straight, not at an angle.
Also, I concur with not being sucked into one line of tools. There are adapters for every line (or virtually every line) to every other line.
I never understand the lag driving competitions… wouldn’t it be quicker to pre-drill appropriately and then sink your lag?
Then you can't brag about the POWAH! LOL
Quality, features, and control are all things the Milwaukee doesn't come close to Makita on. Surprised you never included at least the features in this.
Yeah old school Makita not new school . Milwaukee is the better option in the presence for warranty price and quality imo
@@wayevs Toss up, pick a colour, or stay on what ever you have. Either impact will destroy the bits and drive the fastener.
@@wayevsSpent a week using a Makita you will convert
What about the durability of the trigger and the chuck on the Milwaukee? Is the battery movement any better than previously? What about chuck movement comparison? I have both and they each have their place
When you are driving screws all day the Makita wins. So much easier on the body, it does not shake, rattle or turn your wrist even when your dead exhausted. That Milwaukee would be sweet for small jobs that need a lot of power
I own the Milwaukee g4 .. kinda love it but not sure if it's $255 love. Better than the $279-$320 price it can carry
I love Milwaukee and out here I'm the small towns of the midwest there are typically dewault and Milwaukee around and the few makitas I have use have been butter really smooth and the smoothness stays for the life of the tool Milwaukee is robust but it clunks and is very usable after awhile but the clunking gets rougher and an old 6yr makita still is smooth less heat too idk
Can you test the new 4 mode impact driver from Ridgid, seems to be passing most of the other competition
Ridgid ? Milwaukee blows out Ridgid in general with quality & durability. Can’t compare those two brands one is way better , does cost a lot more for Milwaukee but once you start a collection of batteries it’s a great investment to stick with one brand the warranty is great . Plus the batteries work on almost every tool , our workers prefer Milwaukee we just hate the cost
ive used them and they are completly crap, ive used sub compact makitas and even 10 year old hitachis with more power
I always use Milwaukee for drills and Makita for everything else, Makita saws are levels above Milwaukee IMO
Sorry did I miss the saw comparison?😂
No mention of ergonomics and vibration. I like my Makita better than the Milwaukee I have used. Less fatigue over time.
Also not mentioned is 4th generation vs 1st gen on a brand new platform that has lower heat output. One is close to being retired, the other is just getting started. All that being said the fuel performed really well.
Makita remind me of HTC always behind but charging a premium on the value of their name. Any idiot would see that Milwaukee kills it in this impact driver tool
@@wayevs any idiot would see that milwaukees end up in landfills to fulfil that power. Vibrations=loose parts and repairs down the road. But maybe you don't care and can throw your money in the trash by buying the same tool while the makita lasts.
@@wayevsHow are they behind when they're already on the 3rd gen Makita and this is the 1st gen? They're comparing an older model Makita(from 2020)to the latest Milwaukee. This 1st gen Makita 40v was simply an adaption of the 18v model to the new battery line, but they've since come out with 2 impact drivers uniquely made for the 40v line.
This comment is for all of those who use tools like this and understand them:
Take videos and reviews like this with a grain of salt. I use (and own) Milwaukee, Makita, and DeWalt (Plus much more that is to long to list here). They each have their own strengths and weaknesses. Ryobi, Bosch. etc. are also worth considering. This is not a scientific experiment.
Don't subject yourself to brand loyalty. Buy the tools you like and want. If Milwaukee has the best impact wrench, I'll use that, then. If DeWalt had the best orbital sanders, belt sanders,
planers, I'll use that. If Makita has a bit more precision and comfort and feel for drilling a hole or slapping in a lag screw with more accuracy I'll use that.
Cosider the task at hand and what needs to be done. You can have all of these tools. Don't be tricked into thinking you MUST go with one brand forever. Get the best you can from all of them.
"you can't have the best of both worlds." , B.S. I have the best of 3 worlds., and counting. Exapnd your lineup wisely between brands, not just the tools.
im surprised that milwaukee lasted the entire video without going up in smoke lol
They claim it's protected by electronics, but I have proof positive the M18 2903/4 burn up. More than one.
So do you guys recommend the makita over the Milwaukee?
@@iosonoi.7132I’ve used the same batteries and tools from Makita for 8yrs now. I love the LXT lineup. If I ever need more power they usually have a 36volt option but I only need it for some saws, grinders or SDS drills. Other than that the 18v has been enough to perform the job. My 18v 6 1/2” saw gets used 10:1 over my 36v rear handle saw
I ran Milwaukee for years. The makita is a far finer and more refined tool. It doesn’t have the power, but the power doesn’t matter. The makita trigger control is leagues better than Milwaukee. The speed control is FAR better. Makita is designed for fine work
I have the gen 4 and use it over the gen 3 for the noticeable trigger control @ low speed which seems to deliver necessary torque to still fasten snug without fully depressing the trigger. no more over fastening…. Love it! So if you claim the makita does a better job @ that, its worth me finding out!
If the power does not matter, why would you control speed with the trigger? It has 1,2 and 3rd speed control 🕹️
@@YiZuSc if you don’t understand, then you don’t do fine work.
Completely agree as someone who is on both platforms. Makita drills & impacts are the best.
Power is important that's just a fanboy comment , a telescope which has 1000x zoom will be better than one with 500x it's the same with power and torque and that comment sounds like a fanboy Makita comment
I have the Makita and on full power it will regularly brake pz2 bits using 4 inch wood screws in 4by2 timbers so more power is not needed in my opinion the trigger control is great very happy with it I do have Milwaukee tools as well and want to get this Milwaukee impact driver as I have the batteries and charger for it not sold on yet though…..
I am very hard on my tools. Work them to death, except they will not die. I run Makita. They have never failed me. Some I have had since 2005 when the first 18 volt lithium ion were offered. Other brands may outperform Makita on tests. But in the real world, they can't be beat.
The Milwaukee is great I just switched platforms because they make more plumbing tools .. that being said I think makitas qc is a lot better mine have lasted 10 years plus
Makita does have some tools that are awful. The angle grinders I have are crap. Ended up buying a bauer from harbor freight and it’s actually awesome and way smoother. Same with Makita’s multi tool. It sucks and is a huge reason I switched to Milwaukee. They just have better tools across the board. Dewalt is stepping it up too. I never liked their tools cause they felt poor quality but now I’d consider buying them. I don’t see myself going back to Makita any time soon simply because they are way too much money for the performance you get. Their circular saws are the only thing I miss and milwaukee’s circ saws get the job done.
Yep makita build houses most in the would actualy its a mans too blue is for manl, milwakee fits them out like a dress maker would do as a fashion statement..
They just came out with the compact saw zaw
Would like to see the Makita jp dgt 40v.
Get your hands on the Milwaukee M18 top handle saw.
Personally i think makita have slipped downwards they used to be the brand to beat but not anymore this Milwaukee impact is awesome and unbeatable value for performance and warrenty good job Milwaukee
The new Japanese 173(18), and 002(40) impacts still retain the smoothness of makita and are now giving the same results as the milwaukee.
I’m Makita user and have all form the 18 volt line it will cost me to much money to go millwake between my 10 5.0 batteries and all the tools I have but I like Millwake a lot and is cheaper is hats off to millwake
I like the surge Milwaukee. It has a bit less power, but it's hydraulic construction gives half the noise, so that I won't go as deaf as my Dad got from using noisy tools.
Love Milwaukee tools...
I used the Milwaukee gen 4 impact for steel framing and it flunked out on me 3 times
I love the surge m18
I've had mine since 2016 and will never touch a traditional impact again
@@jps101574 unless you need to drive something that requires more than about 50nm... Otherwise, they are great 👌
@@bourkey07 I do have a 3/8" impact wrench for the big stuff.
Would have liked to see them use the 18v 5ahm version of the Makita ..everything else has been stated clearly here by other people ..going from the comment im not the only journeyman construction worker who prefers Makita.
You don't get a 5 year warranty with registration for Makita in the states? Interesting. Also, one more thing to consider if buying into one of these platforms is other tools that are available. The M18 range is absolutely incredible, but the Makita 40v has some tools available that you will never see on an 18v platform. Food for thought.
Great video though.
So true on the other tools aspect! Both these platforms have an extensive lineup which makes it hard to decide! If you can swing and or stand having more than one platform get them both…lol! The Makita handheld compact blower that is now finally on the LXT platform is a reason for me to jump on board with Makita for another brand!
Chicom Milwaukee 5 year warranty is a JOKE!! It 'coverage is for manufacture defects. Chicom Milwaukee won't cover broken cases or if water entered the tool.
Makita warranty covers it ALL!!
I have 200 end users and Makita warranty coverage has been vastly superior.
My personal thoughts are makita is better for fine finish work .for framing Milwaukee is good. I have some of both in my tool arsenal
Which one is more reliable tool in long-term(Makita Vs Milwaukee)?
Maikita.
nice review. Im Bangladeshi
Would the Milwaukee handle removing lug nuts from a Honda Accord ?
I’ve been using makita, Milwaukee and DEWALT for years. If you want to quality tools. I would say makita. They are perfect for fine job.
Ergonomics and ease of use?
Put the Xdt19 to this test
Power is not always a good thing, too much power can strip bolts, break screws and attachments. Theyre both great tools.
milwaukee have volume
@@andersonlandon4218like they're loud?
I would still buy the Makita
So you’d buy a drill that is inferior to the Milwaukee
And one that’s more expensive and doesn’t do a better job? Spending less on the overall better drill would just be dumb
Got both of em, would sell the Milwaukee first. It's a powerhouse, but just about anything else the Makita does better except the lighting. The Tri-LED is nice.
@@joshuamiller3865 Power ain’t everything. I used to be about it myself and I have all gens of milwaukee. In the real
World nobody times drills on the jobs and can notice a few seconds of a difference. Especially small screws. Not only will that Makita outlast that milwaukee, it’s more comfortable to use and performs smoother. But don’t get me wrong who doesn’t like seeing a milwaukee sink a giant lag lol
I have every m12 and m18 impact driver and Surge models. I 100% agree that makita is my go-to impact driver for every task, except driving screws inside, I go for the m18 surge.
Use the makita with a 5 amp battery
The amp hours do not matter. They have the same watt hours.
Use the high output battery for the milwaukee then lol it makes a huge difference
I was almost lured into the cool innovative ways of Makita and they have some speedy powerful fun stuff. But as Makita is raising their prices and showing off I have come to realize that Milwaukee makes strong and tough tools that stand the test of time. Maybe not always first on the ball, but when they make something they make it good.
They also have better synergy with the batteries, that can be used across the machines. Makita splits up into 18v and 40v on the bigger machines. I don't like that. Only complaint I have is the awkward start and stop buttons on the jigsaw. Maybe I'm doing it wrong, but I can't get comfortable with it. I'd like a thumb on/off switch at the top.
But I'm very happy with the machines from Milwaukee.
Makita has a full range of 18 volt and 18X2 (36V) tools for higher demand tools. You dont have to buy the XGT to use the higher performance 40 volt and newer batteries, but it helps. Anything milwaukee can do at 18 volt the makita will be in the same range and last a long time.
@@thorinbane you can’t use the 40v batteries in the 18v tools and that goes the other way too. They don't even have the same shape to fit. Now they sell a charger (freakin huge) that has 2 slots that has one slot for each. But that's it. You’ll need to split your machines in 2 groups. And that makes 3 groups with the 12v. And I don't like it. Pure and simple.
@@thorinbane And Makita puts the future in the XGT line. So you have to consider that if you go 18v.
I know taking the volts into consideration might let you say its an even test but the battery power used in the milwaukee is so much more. Hardly a fair comparison. Why you couldn't just compare apples with apples I'll never know. I'm a De Walt guy so no I don't have a preference. Pity.
How about testing the new Hercules impact against these two beasts? I’d like to see that head to head!!
Think I will stick with Makita . Yeah there slower but they just perform better overall. In my experience Milwaukee is tough but Makita I think is tougher.
Perform better overall how?
@@joshuamiller3865exactly they have no real reason even though the Makita is clearly inferior in performance price and warranty , they are just fanboys stuck in the past with Makita
@@joshuamiller3865 They are smoother tool with less vibration and are more than enough to get the job done. I work in an industrial setting and they are very rugged and last a long time. There are still functional 7.2V makita drills out there from the 90s.
@@wayevsless vibration, quieter, chuck/collet spins straight and true with no wobble. They're much more comfortable in the hand. The grip is narrower and more formed. Milwaukee grips are too fat.
They're better balanced. You can flip a Makita in the air and a Milwaukee and see exactly what I mean.
Makita are rich in features. They have 11-19 modes, depending on which 40v model(the video is on the 1st gen), plus the Bluetooth/app settings/ customization.
The Makita has a more sensitive and comfortable trigger control.
It's 36/40v and will run cooler, last longer
The Milwaukee has 225Nm of torque. The Makita has 215Nm of torque. That's comparable. Most brands keep their high end impacts in that 200-215Nm range. Do you think they're not capable of giving them more raw power or is there a more logical reason for it?
"Stuck in the past." There's no such thing. Makita already has newer models out. Power tool companies wax and wane all the time. Makita is one the largest tool companies in the world, and probably the most used tool worldwide
I have found that the bigger battery makes the difference.
its like the Kawasaki kx450 vs the Yamaha 450. do you want all power or manageable power
tbh i like the color of makita and i have A company card so i just bough the 7 tool kit
I own Milwaukee but always bat an eye at the makitas my co workers use
Milwaukee might perform better on each test if you were running their newer HO 6.0 batteries
Should the Makita then also get a high output battery?
i love watching videos about tools. m18 tools malakas sa rpm its a beast. Bosch at Makita mahina ang rpm. Pagdating sa durability bosch germany and makita japan. ito ang mga tools na unang dumating sa pilipinas 😊
Difinitiva mente Millwauke es de lo mejor! es de otro planeta! viva millwaukee
ref previous comment : Ive used black n decker ... then elu... dewalt ... makita... millwauki .. hilti blah bleeding blah .. 9
Quality over quantity
Packs a punch for its size
Thanks for watching! Have a great day!
Japanese makita just waiting for its chance to show its control and crazy power in this fight
M18 2953 is so powerfull and cheaper... It'll be good choice... It's time for the Red 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼😊
Thanks for watching!
Makita more refined and less vibration. He’s just a Milwaukee fanboy! Plus he doesn’t use the newest model of Makita, but he uses the newest model of Milwaukee. Notice yet to put two hands on the impact driver at first because there’s a lot of cam out with Milwaukee.
I have both and I think you're rpm tac was off
Who not have both :)😊
Milwaukee is shaking so bad ,which means you have to hold it harder.
DIAMOND 💎 JEWELER........... support your boy......
The milwaukee drill doesn't look the same after i watched Netflx..
I understand people love their Makita, but man this wasnt even close ..
Needs to be up against the makita TD173.
I still own and use the very first LXT IMPACT MAKITA made I only use milwalkie m12 for light duty work my opinion makita will by far out last milwalkie
I have all Milwaukee , however used makita lately , by far better , better ergonomically balanced , smoother , lighter
considering to change over if Milwaukee doesn't lift their game
To me looks like you have a stronger battery on Milwaukee 5.0 & a 2.5 on Makita !
40v uses less amps to create the same amount of power. Therefore this is the most accurate comparison. As said in the video, the watt-hour ratings are about the same
Well ... I wasn't in the market for one of these, but if I get into the market ... the choice is ultra clear! Milwaukee all the way.
as silly as it sounds, harbor freights hercules brand impact has been tested and its the only driver that kept up to the milwaukee in any fashion
only $70 too, i was considering getting the hercules stuff for home so i can keep all my milwaukee at work
@coolerthanyou9548 Except the Flex which has more power.
But honestly, these all have more torque than you need in an impact driver. And if all you care about is raw speed, you should just be using a drill driver anyway as they will do these tasks faster.
@@reginalb124 the flex gets insanely hot tho, and for the price id stick with my gen 4 milwaukee.
ime, on the jobsite drivers are faster and less cumbersome, at least for doing 90% of residential HVAC jobs
@@coolerthanyou9548 I haven't seen the flex beat out a milwaukee its always the other way around
@@coolerthanyou9548 yeah it's crazy how much power Hercules makes. I wonder how reliable they are .
Makita batteries die so fast but they do last long , I have some makita batteries from 2012 but I’m definitely a Milwaukee and Festool kind of guy but love my makita saws
We all know Milwaukee is the king of the hill, I've had makita for years and still using it now, hell I'm still running dtd 171, don't need all that power, the way it feels in the hand and the finesse it offers with the different modes, all good with me, makita all the way.
We ain't in the 1990s now buddy. Milwaukee has a superior product learn to live with it instead of being a fan boy . It's the same apple v Google debate and Google are way past apple nowadays ,.wake up son
@@wayevsit's Android vs Apple lol. Google still has a way to go to even beat Samsung, let alone Apple lol.
He’s not pushing hard on Mikita when he’s screwing down
You forgot to test harsh environments. Working in -40C I was the only one on the jobsite with a working makita all the other contractor had there milwaukee batteries die on them
Environments that harsh are a bit out of our reach here in Central FL 🤣 where in the world are you working that gets down to -40?
@Protoolreviews fair play 😄. I work out of the mines in Northwest Territory, Canada
I love how all the fan boys cry when milwaukee beats them. Both tools are great just go with the platform you already have.
Yeah exactly I have no dog in the fight but it's obvious to see which is the better tool overall for performance price and warranty . I've only ever seen this type of fanboyism with apple lol😅
Makita is a MUCH better tool company, theyre japanese so theyre built with the same morals as a Toyota. Not flashy, but extremely well put together and refined. Milwaukee is a high school jock brand & makita is the quiet smart kid. Heres a real test, give the two impacts to some girls and ask them which one theyd prefer to use 😄
Grow up and get with the times and technology
@@wayevs lol it's all fun and games when we're young but when you're older and your joints ache because of years of flexing on how fast your tools is that's when you'll think back at this point in time 😄
Milwaukee being the jock would definitely explain why it's faster and more powerful.
But next time im going out to a bar trivia night, ill make sure i get a Makita drill to be on my team
@@mikethered4864 again faster and more powerful at the expense of comfort. You must not be old enough to understand what it's doing to your body yet
@@wayevs what tech? You mean that 10% MO POWAH?
You toenailed with the makita…
2:21 just put the svrew in straight ffs
Wow and that’s with the shitty old Milwaukee batteries too…