now its confirmed that ending defenders are the shittiest fans a series could ever get they are so insecure that they wanna trash talk this whole project.
"Historia is a lesbian!" "Historia is in a relationship with the farmer!" I can't even with these people. They're either trolling or have dangerously poor reading comprehension.
And they're saying this isnt erens character. Like what????? No way these people read 139 and thought "yea this is eren" and then read aotnr and thought "this isn't eren"
So it's okay for yall to shit on the original ending but suddenly for us it isn't....like what do u expect, with this laughable and cringe conversations they have ofc there will be criticism
Liked armin in the anime for 3 seasons. Logical guy,caring about his friends at the same time and more brave than anyone. Armin final arc cant even think of anything,makes no sense questions and just cares about mikasa and annie and I started to hate him. After reading this I can see the real version of Armin,really liked the points he made to convince Eren.
That's why I hate r/yeagerbomb and their thinly vieled racism and misogyny (ArMONG, MANKasa), etc. The characters were truly brilliant, a few dogshit final chapters doesnt make their entire character arc and plot worthless. Why did Isayama degrade his own story so much we may neer know, but its beyond a doubt that the man had woven some of the best characters and dynamics in manga until that point.
No the original line in the original ending was much better and fits his character better all of erens dialogue in this mediocre fan ending is just biased and mediocre
Yeah i too love Armin now because of this Thank you Aotnorequiem They deserve to be loved and known lol The ending of chapter 139 traumatized me Because if their characters lol.
Ehhh respect is too far, this at least stays true to his hypocritical character. He betrayed Eren and he’s still thinking only about himself, he doesn’t want to be prospering from this terrible act so he’s trying to stop Eren. Armin honestly should just kill himself, and I mean that from the fact that his main problem isn’t even that Erens doing it, it’s that he just doesn’t want to be living good knowing that the rumbling is why he is. He basically just doesn’t want the rumbling on his conscience because it’d be like blood money. So at that point if he’s not contributing anything but his soft opinion then he should just die imo 🤷♂️. Plus even through this argument they were having, it stays true to how Armin has become selfish and hypocritical as he just completely keeps ignoring Erens points and just picks and chooses what to respond to to try and cause Eren to slip up. Armin is not right, he’s just a great arguer
The flashback with hange, eren and Historia legit felt like something out of the original manga. The setup, paneling and writing man. These guys are gods
After s3 ended I started to dislike Armin when I started reading the manga not because of his actions or personality but because of how he changed from s1. The armin we knew was the most logical person in a dangerous/preassure situation and he would put his own life to stop a cannon shot for his friends and seeing him,confronting Eren with goat arguments and willing to kill his best friend is what really makes him one of the best aot characters after reading this fan ending.
i did not expect Armin char to get rescued after how low it fell lol. That was a nice surprise. I thought it as all over but it cleaned it by like 60 percent. The failed armin still left a bad taste.
@@Zainab_Salam904 Hell Iseyama encourages fanfictions and fan manga. As far as anyone is concerned, you can consider this canon too if you really wanted to.
The excellent Eremin ideology battle and the long-awaited Erehisu convo's conclusion aside, my favorite detail's gotta be goddamned Floch being the best man in Eren and Historia's -barn- forest seggs.
I just took it as them all meeting to decide on the plan for how it would all go down. EHF is the meme trio so they probably wanted to include it just a bit, and the juxtaposition in the original chapter having the Floch scene paired with the Historia flashback is a good enough reason to do something with it here.
Look at the genuine happiness on his face when he reads this, compared to his face whenever Isayama comes out with another interview on AoT. The difference is STAGGERING
@@ashrafhakim379 look bro isayama's intention was actually this. I kinda understood the Canon ending. It is so similar to the fan ending. But the problem was isayama didn't elaborate and didn't explain it well. He used wrong choice of words that is all
@@ashrafhakim379 Actually it was the other way around. Because he was surrounded with so many people and his work wasnt a seinnen but a SHONNEN. Some years ago Isayama had planned a different ending but after some time his editors were making decisions about which character should be killed and where the story should go. After those 130 chapter they started to rush the story and thats why any person with some brain cells can see the quality of writting and dialogues decreased.
"No...No this does not absolve you!!!" THERE WE FUCKING GO!! this is Armin the commander THIS is Erwin's successor God I love this chapter so fucking much
I actually kind of sided with Armin here. I want to like Armin, and I don't want to have to call him the M-word. But he brought it on himself in the original.
@@alexvaughan1013 That was supposed to be the whole point in the canon manga, the reader was supposed to be torn between Eren and Armin, Bad side of humanity vs Good side of humanity. AOT no Requime is fantastic, it understood the tone so well.
@@Alaa-gv6ks What i meant was Eren thinks the world cannot change and people in power perpetuate the cycle of hatred for their selfish agendas. (Bad side of Humanity) Armin however believes that people can change and through coexisting may start to understand each other ending the cycle of hatred. (Good side of humanity) The truth is neither Eren nor Armin are right as explained by the line in the ed 4 "The world is easy to understand and that's what makes it so complex"
@@agrimpuriya2585 well i disagree i don't see eren as a vilian neither as hero in what he did but isyama has already explain that the cycle will never end and the other wrold will strike them eventually in the last pages you see i am not saying here that people will not change and it's clearly their are people who are against all these things sadly that just not how it does work the people who have the power and poltical will always do what benfit them and their countries nobody will care about what's hapening to the others or to the other countries and nobody can stop it and that's just the nature of humans just look at our real world and explain to me how it's easy to understand
Man..this is somehow better than Part 1. The writing, the depth given to both eren and Armin that just builds off of the last chapter. More context given to Erehisu’s development and it makes sense cause they use actual events within the OG manga. This is perfect.
@Hahaah Look , this fan made canon is not for iq less EM trash shippers. So , go and read that chapter 139 or the extra pages if you want. You don't need to examplify your brainless character for disrupting others
This is literally god tier story telling wtf? I’ve never liked fanfics cuz I thought they were corny, but this one gets a pass. This shit is absolutely beautiful and definitely should’ve been the original story. This whole thing is just perfect
Yeah but man the characters are trash and the dialogue is really bad it is to much fan service and eren and historia conversation was so bad i died of laughter i thought it was a joke but damn i was wrong
@@o_8t12 why you write "yeah" and then basically say exact opposite of what original commenter said? LoL After reading part 2 , canon 139 lines definitely look more ret@rded and cheesy than aotnr
The drawings are very nice. But narratively it doesn't really have shit to do with Isayama's story. And Eren's character was completely turned around. As a "what if" it fits. But if they think they are "fixing" the work, as they had previously written and then later cancelled... well, they haven't understood anything, because there is nothing coherent about it
EXACTLY BRO. I was a huge armin fan, he was my favorite character. Then canon ending absolutely ruined him. The fact I had to say Erwin was the better choice over armin hurt to say but it was true. Bless the aotnr team
They already are, haven’t ya seen Twitter and the r/ShingekiNoKyojin Reddit today? They’re fuming, and it’s all because this fanfic chapter is so much better than the canon ending!
@@rickchakraborty2087 I know they are, they don't give a damn that the characters were talking about things that matter for 30 pages, or the characters staying intact, all they ever give a damn about is Erehisu.
Man they gotta let go of the hate Its so simple and they are acting So violently by a fanfic, so damn crazy yo The death threats are worse, we are humans but threatening someone because of this makes you worse. Ik that we people love this franchise and cherish it for a decade but why has it come to this. AND THEY ARE STILL HOLDING ON, LET GO!!! (I had to include that last line cause i love star wars and it felt right to say it XD)
●The panel of Erwin's Ghost judging Armim ●Extended Floch conversation with Eren ●Eren practically refuting Armin at every point and Armin having no counterargument. *chef's kiss* My favorite panels in Part 2.
It's funny that AOTNR is more consistent than the canon ending of chapter 139. I'm still laughing that 139 Defenders is calling Requiem poorly written, when it makes more sense and respects the themes of Isayama original work.
I liked where the original ending was going but......they messed up eren and armin's talk,ymir story was just disgusting to read,floch and historia were wasted because rushing things and mikasa's whole character came out of nowhere after being so irrelevant during 130 chapters so.... I can say that what Isayama had planned wasnt bad but was really poorly executed. If the ending was good like all 139 defenders are saying then why so many people dislike it? A good ending gives a conclusion to the story and characters while being truth to his own plot and themes and that didnt feel really good when reading 139.
I honestly don’t even like Attack On Titan at all let alone the garbage heap that was Chapter 139. Attack On Titan altogether was one of the worst told stories I’ve ever seen in my life. I at least will give respect that The AOT No Requiem team was willing to fix and rewrite the final part of the series and make it a lot better than it was. You get no disagreement from me on this. Chapter 139 was a truly horrible chapter. AOT No Requiem which isn’t even anything canon sadly is actually somehow better than the actual story. What an utter joke. Personal high five from me my man.
Aot simps on the shit ending :"noo u can t say AotNR is better. Don t disrespect iasayamas work. U are not a real fan. The ending was a beautyfull one that people didnt understand :cryingangrydude: ) True Aot chads:cannon ending bad aotNR better work
You must be in an infinite tsukuyomi lv. Of genjutsu if you think he gives a single fu*k about anything anymore he got millions of dollar up his ass , he doesn't care.
@@Shinwicked Isayama is a creative in the end and I can guarantee he cares about how his creation is viewed. He would often look on social media sites to see if people were close to finding out his would be ending before Manga ended. Sure he has millions eventually people get used to the money and in the end the one thing that gives them real meaning the thing that fills their artist spirit is what they created because that is all you leave behind when you die. You do not take the money with you. You are immortalized through your creative projects. He DOES care what people think trust me. He spent years on this it's his baby. To say he doesn't care and it does not phase him to hear all criticisms of what he made is ignorant and untrue.
@@sourcesymbiosismetamorphis2228 well we both never met him , so we can't say for a fact , but like I don't see anyway he thought the canon ending was a good idea if he cared. But maybe he was stressed out and didn't want anymore pressure , so he did what he could best, so we should think what we want , because "WERE FREE! , since the day we were born into this World" 😅😅
@@Shinwicked no he doesn't he just likes Jean and wants him to get Mikasa that's all he doesn't care abt the fans as he know that even if he goes for a trash ending he will still earn millions
I am an Eremika shipper but I love ANR. And I think there is a misconception that every EM shipper loves the original ending. But i saw lot of Eremika shippers including myself who hate the original ending but love Anr. If we just keep the shipping thing aside I think anyone will say ANR better than the original ending.
thats what im looking for. A real argument and despute between two character with the same goal but different ways of doing it showing both their resolve and stance no matter what the outcome may be. You know like irl war and battle of ideologies. To the winner the spoils or to the smartest or strongest the spoils whatever battle it is. Both path can be right or understandable but there can only be one winner in a challenge or race. with a nice flashback and a touch of romance and memory. I like how historia remembered Ymir and Frieda with her in danger of bein alone and have to burden everything. She lost her life by becoming queen. her service is to the people. Eren and the squad too. they join the survey their life was no longer theirs. like in the army . They both faced with what they think is best for their people and ready to go through hell. Just like irl the soldiers lay down their lives and put it on the line for their country for hopes of a brighter tomorrow. Neither side is right but i can understand both side and fighting for what you believe in is always brave. Fighting against hatred, oppression, discrimination etc. Everything is a battle whether physically or mentally. Life is filled with up and downs and challenges and hard choices. Its never easy but you still get up in the morning and do what you need to to survive and live your life. Everyone has something their fighting for. They brought out points fandom ben making. especially about the lives dying for nothing. Also i think should not dwell in the past. Those lives die for the future. Its up to the ones in the present to decide how the future will be though. Keep moving forward you cant remain stagnant forever, eventually it will catch up and overtake you like a flood and you wont be able to stop it. Letting it build up with no real progress. When something doesn't work why persist. IF it worked so well then the things that happened irl wouldn't have. It took people changing how they do things when something is not working. This actually made armin character tolerable. Armin is back. This is fan made but they did Armin justice. good job.
1:54 "HE IS NOT TALKING ABOUT MIKASA!!!" Dude I was happy to see that angry reaction of Armin too! 5:13 page with ERWIN is shocking. Like Erwin was dead for nothing but Armin stayed alive. But watching the Canon chapters I was glad Erwin never happened to see what the shit would be next. And neither did Sasha
1:54 me: WWWWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! yeah baby!! that's I've been waiting for!!! that's what this is all about!! WOHOOOO!! 5:13 that panel hits hard.
I love how the team incorporated the smiling Hange panel from 130 which was never used by Isayama in canon. (Further proof Isayama retconned the ending). Btw, Armin is the definite MVP of this one. He proved himself as a man of convictions just like Eren and not just "muh we are your friends, what about Mikasa".
Imagine Isaymas being the real person behind the whole aot nr just to present the story he always wanted. Just Imagination nothing against the aot nr team. This part was masterpiece. Really waiting for part 3 with full rumbling
Every time I think I'm setting myself up for disappointment because of my insanely high expectations.. the AoTnR team blows them away anyway. What an absolutely refreshing chapter - I got mad chills. THIS is how I wanted AoT's ending to feel. Thank you AoTnR team, it was worth the wait! :D I'm glad I read the chapter with the Hype King Saint. I look forward to more content man. You're just so expressive and intellectually sharp. P.S. The dub isn't as bad as the chat was claiming.
To clear up the confusion, the Historia portion is made up of multiple flashbacks. There are actually two separate conversations at the farm. The first is when Historia and Eren have forest seggs, you can tell them apart from the more canonical "You're the worst girl in the world." portion from chapter 130 because the canon panels are not slanted while the other ones are. The Hange flashback is a callback to one of the Path Shards we see Eren have (Hange's tearful but happy expression) and gives you the basis of Eren and Historia's relationship which is connected to canon at that point. Same thing applies with the Floch conversation, it's slanted so it is a flashback from before the 130 conversation. The canonical flashback in ANR has the already pregnant Historia choose Eren over the rest of the world. Why she's pregnant is most likely because since she knew her future partners would be chosen for her by following the 50 year plan, she wanted her first child to be with the man she trusted the most. Out of the entire flashback sequence, it is the most recent of the occurrences.
@@myaparker5510 to be honest I myself am an eremika shipper but how could anyone want that keeping in mind the shit ending we got Basically , who eren ends with should be the least priority for any fan in an anime like aot which was turned into shit love story by 139
@@Kush-yk8nc I've never been interested in shipping. Focus on it is kind of a waste of energy to me but if it's good for the story I wouldn't mind. But I'm amazed how crazy people can get when they're shipped it doesn't go well. Some people only care about ship.
@@myaparker5510 exactly Ofcourse if someone asks me i would want eremika to be true But in an anime like aot thats one of my least priorities More than anything u want a good story
Imagine working on a series for years isayama at that point is basically tired and is pushing the last bit of strength he has to end the story plus there's the pressure from the honchos on his back.
To paraphrase Eren's lines from the anime version: Because he's an idiot. Just a regular idiot given the power to write a popular series. That's why 139 was the only conclusion he could come up with. But honestly, he's a good writer (we've seen it in past chapters). I think he was rushed somewhat. That's the only real conclusion I can come to. That, and the fact that he's never written an ending to a series before. His inexperience in tying things together really showed in 139. Fortunately, we have the Requiem team to help pick up the slack.
Man even the farm boy being a plot device to give Historia more time, which i still dont like as an idea, made so much sense here than the original canon! Not some random dude pops out of no where at the end and be the father just cuz, and be absolutely irrelevant. Unless I misinterpreted that panel and it was actually Eren and Historia doing it at the barn in the forest-- What matters to me is that this part of the story was given backstory on WHY it should makes sense, whether i like it or not. This really says that Hajime Isayama was absolutely pressured by the fans to rush the story and put to many plot holes while retconning some characters. edit: Reread the chapter again and saw closely that it was Zeke mostly involved going into the forest and the barn boy seems like a cover up instead. So now im interpreting this as Eren and Historia doing it themselves to make the plan real.
Soundtrack changes depending on page you're on That's quite interesting Also part1 redeemed eren , part 2 redeemed armin , i think part3 will redeem Mikasa The chapter itself was amazing. Setup is complete , now action finally begins ;D
Mikasa is just an overrated character. I dont hate her but compared to Eren and Armin's character she is just a strong/badass female and people like her bc of that. I'd prefer no love interest for eren but the whole mikasa character is literally Ereh so i dont know how are they gonna redeem her. While armin really stepped up. Aot no requiem really upgraded Eren and Armin.
@@aswadsyednaz3073 agreed. My comment was mostly based on how yams wanted to break up the trio of EMA as they got older but cucked himself and eren in the end by making them all buddies with each other. Aotnr team would need to change Mikasa somewhat to make childhood friendship like that break(like how they did with eren vs armin)
Mikasa's character is just so broken beyond repair that if they somehow able to redeem her in the next chapter, they deserve all the world's worth of respect
Man, this made me feel so much more than the original ending. I haven’t felt real happiness since the cringe ending in a long time. Saintichief, your reaction is literally mine when I read this😄
@@theswagger78. Bro if people like it, let people like it. 😩👌 If you don't like it, then just avoid it or you moved on. It ain't hurting anyone, AOTNR Isn't gonna be the anime original lmao.
@@coltwgrice lmaoo i like it too but you didnt get what i meant . The og ending is trash tbh but if they gonna make an anime original ending thats great . In the end AoTnR still just a fanfic unfortunately . I gave up on AoT since the trash ending we got at the end but im still reading the AoTnR cuz i like it and i moved on and i went to watch other animes .
The part where Eren said all those people would have died for nothing .I felt like they could have added the part where Young Eren spoke to his father before Shiganshina fell.He spoke of how the Survey corps lives shouldn't be in vain
Now I started to doubt that AotnoRequiem is a fanfiction now. More and more into this plot gives me some silly hopes of this being the anime's unannounced source material🙁
@Just_Max But it is Bad . I don't care what they have to go through Sure go ahead and appreciate the animator's effort but not the Animation . Animators may be working very hard but animation is not good .
Small detail: In the Floch scene, Floch objects because Eren couldn't sacrifice Armin to save the devil, Erwin. This was paid off when Eren says, "I don't want to fight my best friend." Despite what critics say, AnR is far from being some Eren power fantasy glorifying him as some 'heartless Chad' who fucks bitches and commits genocide. It shows that Eren is still very much human, and his plan is far from glorified.
Tbh I had given up on AoT like a great story with an irredeemable ending like GoT, but the amazing folk in the AoTnr team are still making me feel things I felt back when I still loved the canon story. The dialogue fits, characters are actually behaving the way they have been portayed over the entire story, nothing feels out of place, they are even managing to weave previously established plot points in new and interesting ways! This surpassed even my highest expectations, my brain is already treating this as canon now
This has got to be one of his greatest Livestreams. One of the greats. The passion in this man's voice. If only the actual ending would have been like this.
Bro I have no words to describe how much I loved this part. I’m so hyped for part 3 and I wish everyone who worked on this the best and hope that there was a better reception to this then part 1
From this very moment Historia's life's in danger, so eren must do nothing but kill his friends not only to save paradis but also for the sake of his wife and his child
Even though he doesn't want to kill them, he'll have to, he can't save them all. Either his friends or his family. Even though it's the morally wrong choice, it's what a father would choose, to save his family. Friendship is temporary, family is forever
Dog i swear that whoever wrote this deserves recognition, it's not even fair to compare this to the trash ending we got, even tho i'm Eren side i undertand Armin he's not talking out of his ass but bringing fair arguments, this is how it was suppose to go.
I'm gonna be honest about this... This chapter was great but it had some flaws: 1) Eren sounded like a nationalist instead of someone who strived for freedom. 2) Eren revealing that he'll just commit suicide after completing the rumbling is just way out of character in my opinion. 3) The conversation with historia felt off for some reason. Don't get me wrong, I liked the part where she reminds him to not leave her alone like everyone else did. But it felt like some unnecessary lines were forcefully inserted in some places. 4) Although Armin's dialogue here is much better than what it was in the original. He still believes that talk no jutsu is going to work on the world which is dumb. And that's actually not the team's fault. It's actually Isayama's mistake which leads to number 5. 5) Isayama pretty much wrote himself into a corner during the rumbling arc. And now the fan writers are simply trying to find the best way to get out of it and you can see that here in this chapter.
1- eren definetily is a nationalist, his love for Eldias has allways guided him. Seeing his country locked as cattle, seing all nattions planning kill his people ... That all moldes eren actions. If all he craved for was freedom he would grab his bag, left his country and travel the world like a vagabond or whatever. But no. Eren is a nationalist by his own right. 2- didnt understand your thoughts on the matter 3- About historia.... Well, " unnecessary lines were forcefully inserted " What lines ? 4 and 5 - wanst Armin always like this ? About the writters didnt showing more corpses by the rumbling... Maybe in the next part
1) I disagree, how he spoke here sounds like Eren from 123 through 133 who hasn't spoken to Historia yet. In fact Eren himself has very nationalist values at the core of his character, that isn't for the pure sake of nationalism, that's just who he is. 2) No where did Eren say he would commit suicide? Unless i read it wrong. Not expecting to come back alive is not the same as saying he would kill himself. 3) You need to give a criticism here, like a example. I agree to a degree. The overall point was to fix the awkward manner the original handled it in to fill the holes left about why Historia asked Eren that question in 130. For instance: Who the farmer is, the Floch panel with the figure in the back, Eren reacting to Hange's antagonizing, Why Eren told Historia and why she asked him his opinion etc. As for the lines themselves, not all of them line up with what is shown, but is supposed to give context over what Eren and Historia did the past 4 years, like how "paths" flashbacks operate. It's messy and confusing. 4) It is in character at least, talking isn't the solution but he can't agree that Eren is right, Armin wouldn't agree to senseless slaughter and in that case the main conflict suffers for it if he doesn't stubbornly oppose that, especially this far in. I'd definitely take that over him THANKING HIM. 5) Absolutely. But that's his own fault. I wished he had just stuck with what he set up instead of trying to please all of his audience.
Maybe a little too late to mention this, but better late than never. Some say that they kinda ruined historia's character by not showing her have any sympathy or talk about the billions of innocent lives that are about to be trampled by the rumbling. What they didn't realize is that this conversation here is not supposed to replace the canon conversation in 130, it's supposed to continue it, to conclude it, something like that. And no fools, historia is not being a submissive sheep for not doing anything to stop eren, "even if the whole world turns against us, I'll always be your ally, because we're enemies of humanity", doesn't that ring a bell? If that sounds like a person that got carried away throughout the entire scene, then I'm santa claus. After all, she's still living for herself, being selfish about it is ironically a part of her character. "Live a life you can be proud of", well i sure as hell can know if there's pride in having a baby with your childhood bully or not, historia's expression every time she's with him says it all And for God's mf'ing sake people, romance holds little to no significance in this relationship between eren and historia, it's unnecessary
Historia is a queen, the safety of her country is her only priority. I she should Care about the world outside that want to wipe out her people? Ending defenders are dumb
So, as expected, part 2 of aotnr is already getting shitted on with baseless arguments. Love the content bro, would you possibly consider making a video combatting the hate or giving your opinion of the hate towards this amazing project? Keep it up, look forward to your next video also part 2 of aotnr somehow exceeded the quality of the first part, good shit.
I'm ready to bet that this is NOT fan made, but in fact the actual ending originally planned by Isayama, without any forced censorship and controversial themes and protagonist watered down and reversed into "love" themes instead with the Mary Sue of service Mikasa turned hero of the story at the last minute.
I'm ready to bet this is NOT fan made, but in fact the actual ending originally planned by Isayama, without any forced censorship by big studios like MAPPA and controversial themes and protagonist watered down and reversed into "love" themes instead with the Mary Sue of service Mikasa turned hero of the story at the last minute. And Isayama is probably bound by contract to stay quiet about it and pretend he likes chapter 139.
I am fine with erehisu as historia does understand eren while Mikasa even after Being with him for a long time couldn't understand erens character anr what hes trying to do .. personally i think that historia would be a much greater wife for eren then Mikasa could ever be . Marley deserved to be destroyed after what they did to them and after they are paying for their deeds erens friend just go side up with enemies . Even rivals are better than these friends . Eren should kill every single one who decides to come in his way ( including Armin Mikasa ) etc
Marley deserve to be destroyed, the rest of the world no Eren is worse than Hitler by so many levels. He IS the monster that must be destroyed. As ermine said, it doesn’t matter how he justifies It. A genocide is a GENOCIDE.
If they do this then even this ending is shit for me Ships aside , eren’s core character point for me is his love for his friends , they shoudnt destroy that
@@btech5652 1) the rest of the world hated Eldia more than Marley....the only way to go to Eldia is through Marley and the walls....and there were pure titans all around, Marley even has Eldian population in them...if there were no walls and titans, Eldia would be destroyed long ago 2) Hitler did it out of disgust, Eren did it out of necessity....the German army command spread the myth that the army had not lost a war on the battlefield but because they had been betrayed. By a ‘stab in the back’, as it was called at the time. Hitler bought into the myth: Jews and communists had betrayed the country and brought a left-wing government to power and that is what made Hitler kill off Jews (just cuz of a speculation and power struggle) - www.annefrank.org/en/topics/antisemitism/why-did-hitler-hate-jews/ and this is a report taken with info from a holocaust victim - Eren saw what happened to Eldia and how they were bounded inside walls...tried to see the future with a desired outcome but found no other solution and did it....GENOCIDE IS WRONG can't be expressed when the very thing Eldia was going through as well was some sort of a genocide itself 3) Eren is a monster that was created from the hatred spread by Marley and the world...he didn't even think about rumbling until he saw everyone else cheer for the destruction of Eldia 4) that is the entire point that was supposed to happen in the original manga....them having an idealistic and realistic mindset discussion...not about Mikasa after literally 80% of the world was destroyed....Mikasa was not the topic to discuss at that point in any way
@@Kush-yk8nc for you, not the story....he said he wished his friends to live a long and peaceful lives, not the destruction of Paradis and his friends to be exiled from their homeland....were Sasha, Hange and all those in the circle not friends of Eren? and what part of Eren do you think is within character if the journey started with his mom being killed turned to him killing his mom in order to save Reiner, Bertholt? are those two more important to him than his mom? LOL
"If this is your way of showing me you've always been like this, then you're nothing but a slave to your own selfishness" I can't tell you how much this resonated with who Armin really is! That's exactly the route he was taking before 138 and 139. Not the pissant "Thankyou for committing mass murder for our sake"🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
I think the problem of this part is too much performance of love.The reaction between EH should be more deeper, it's hard to use ordinary love to describe it. I'm EH stan and glad to see the chapter coming out, but the emotion will lower its scores.
@@Philthorn lol it's nothing but fandom shipping and it's more fanservice than anything, historia in the story served no purpose other than having a kid and creating a ship out of that cause they had common goals doesn't work really, if anything i rather prefer Eren being single as he wouldn't have time for ships and stuff while his country is in great peril from the outside world
@@Layd36that could literally be a better and more relatable motivation for eren to complete his mission. "Have no time for ships and stuff", if we were given more of eren's perspective that could've been explained better, but isayama was busy making lelouch 2.0
@@Philthorn i mean even if they want to create a ship it should be believable as historia and Eren should have more scenes and communicate with each other especially in the pre time skip and even have some believable scenes where people can understand they are romantically involved, hell Eren interacts more with Mikasa where she's shown to care about Eren more than anything and it seems like a one sided love while Eren doesn't seek to bother anything about love in the scenes we are given in the story and more about saving his people and being depressed at the thought of destroying the world, i really feel bad for Eren who while his fans think of him as a Chad and all that nonsense about shipping whereas he thinks about the horrific things he will do and does in the future, even if fans want that ship to be true he would probably live like four years at max and that much short life isn't even worth having ships over, fans don't think of Eren as a character who is willing to do genocide to save his people and moves forward with pure conviction and rather think about who he is going to pipe down a baby with, it's really disappointing
@@Layd36point taken. However, that still could've been explained better, eren decided to cry like a baby in the end and to reach that point he did what he hated: put on a facade, when in fact eren is not totally emotionless, I'm telling you if we were given more of eren's perspective it would have been reasonable and properly explained, their conversation for example, we never saw the whole thing play out When the rumbling is complete, the titan course will disappear too so no 13 year time limit 🐂 💩 anymore by the way you're welcome
That is reaction genuine with happiness same as mine, and this is indeed good story telling, and I'm agree with all you said here! good job AOTNR team! 👏
By now saintitchief is the AoT character I'm most invested in. After almost all the characters let me down by horrible writing, it's such a joy to see saintitchief growing and developing. I'm so glad to be able to follow the AoT no Requiem season when he finally gets the ending he and all the other characters deserved. Thank you, AoTNR team!
now its confirmed that ending defenders are the shittiest fans a series could ever get
they are so insecure that they wanna trash talk this whole project.
"Historia is a lesbian!"
"Historia is in a relationship with the farmer!"
I can't even with these people. They're either trolling or have dangerously poor reading comprehension.
They just want to trash talk Historia 24/7 like their life depends on it.
And they're saying this isnt erens character. Like what????? No way these people read 139 and thought "yea this is eren" and then read aotnr and thought "this isn't eren"
@MrRisk yup
So it's okay for yall to shit on the original ending but suddenly for us it isn't....like what do u expect, with this laughable and cringe conversations they have ofc there will be criticism
Reading this made me realize I never hated Armin. Isayama made me hate him with the final arc.
same dude
he mada look armin like a some nerd wanting to see world, no hate :) but that's was my first impression upon reading of manga
Liked armin in the anime for 3 seasons. Logical guy,caring about his friends at the same time and more brave than anyone.
Armin final arc cant even think of anything,makes no sense questions and just cares about mikasa and annie and I started to hate him.
After reading this I can see the real version of Armin,really liked the points he made to convince Eren.
Exactly.
That's why I hate r/yeagerbomb and their thinly vieled racism and misogyny (ArMONG, MANKasa), etc. The characters were truly brilliant, a few dogshit final chapters doesnt make their entire character arc and plot worthless. Why did Isayama degrade his own story so much we may neer know, but its beyond a doubt that the man had woven some of the best characters and dynamics in manga until that point.
“I don’t want to fight my best friend” is way better than “I don’t want Mikasa to find another man”
No the original line in the original ending was much better and fits his character better all of erens dialogue in this mediocre fan ending is just biased and mediocre
@@kingeren4140 maybe give actual argument next time?
@@kingeren4140 It wasn’t biased because both Armin and Eren had their points and also Eren showing emotion here is way better than whatever is in 139
@@kingeren4140 Lol you mad bro?
@@kingeren4140 the fact u said mediocre twice in the same sentence shows you realize this is much better than the canon, and it's got you pressed lmao
Erwin Panel was just enough for me to accept this as Canon. Bro looking down on Armin like the legend he is.
Finally Armin isnt all about Annie's choochie and Mikasa's feelings. He is about saving the world and humanity.
Zeke be like “wait I’m an Uncle?!”
UNCLE MONKE!!!!!
Now I don't want Zook to die in AOTNR so he gets to meet his nephew 😭
Oh no I wanted to get zooked
Uncle zoook
@@yashmishra1212 I wonder if Zeke is jealous of his kids or Eren
@@yashmishra1212 or niece who knows lol
Armin having logical conversation with Eren during rumbling and clashing ideologies with each other is all I want is finally here!
Ending defender : what armin being logical and standing up against eren impossible
@@alphariusomegon2968 *n0 NO! THEy shOuLd Be TaLKinG ABout MiKASaaa!!*
@@TheoVad yes what part of any of this is mikasa
@@alphariusomegon2968 *THIS IS ABOUT MIKASA!! YOU'RE JUST MAD CUZ YOUR SHIP DIDN'T SAIL!!*
@@TheoVad lmao
It feels weird being able to respect Armin again. The Requiem team are working miracles!
I no longer regret buying a £20 Armin plushie at Comic Con!!
(This was in 2014 when Armin was still better Shinji)
Armong is dead long live Chad armin
@@alexvaughan1013 lmao
Yeah i too love Armin now because of this
Thank you Aotnorequiem
They deserve to be loved and known lol
The ending of chapter 139 traumatized me
Because if their characters lol.
Ehhh respect is too far, this at least stays true to his hypocritical character. He betrayed Eren and he’s still thinking only about himself, he doesn’t want to be prospering from this terrible act so he’s trying to stop Eren. Armin honestly should just kill himself, and I mean that from the fact that his main problem isn’t even that Erens doing it, it’s that he just doesn’t want to be living good knowing that the rumbling is why he is. He basically just doesn’t want the rumbling on his conscience because it’d be like blood money.
So at that point if he’s not contributing anything but his soft opinion then he should just die imo 🤷♂️. Plus even through this argument they were having, it stays true to how Armin has become selfish and hypocritical as he just completely keeps ignoring Erens points and just picks and chooses what to respond to to try and cause Eren to slip up. Armin is not right, he’s just a great arguer
The flashback with hange, eren and Historia legit felt like something out of the original manga. The setup, paneling and writing man. These guys are gods
It was mentioned by Jean that Eren and Historia were holding hands,so it’s not a asspull for them to show this flashback
It was bad writing the original aot ending was a masterpiece imagine being this dumb to like this mediocre writing
@@kingeren4140 I told you two days ago to change your name to "Simp eren" when are you gonna do it?
@@kingeren4140 Ok and? Let us enjoy Requiem lmao
@@kingeren4140 Lol ending defenders
Was not expecting Armin's character to get redeemed the way it did in this chapter. It felt the Armin I respected and liked had come back.
After s3 ended I started to dislike Armin when I started reading the manga not because of his actions or personality but because of how he changed from s1.
The armin we knew was the most logical person in a dangerous/preassure situation and he would put his own life to stop a cannon shot for his friends and seeing him,confronting Eren with goat arguments and willing to kill his best friend is what really makes him one of the best aot characters after reading this fan ending.
i did not expect Armin char to get rescued after how low it fell lol. That was a nice surprise. I thought it as all over but it cleaned it by like 60 percent. The failed armin still left a bad taste.
Armin is back
@@aswadsyednaz3073 well he still sucks cause this isn’t the canon manga so it isn’t canon but I can’t argue that this armin is goated
@@Zainab_Salam904 Hell Iseyama encourages fanfictions and fan manga. As far as anyone is concerned, you can consider this canon too if you really wanted to.
The excellent Eremin ideology battle and the long-awaited Erehisu convo's conclusion aside, my favorite detail's gotta be goddamned Floch being the best man in Eren and Historia's -barn- forest seggs.
Did Floch watch Eren and Hisu copulate?
I just took it as them all meeting to decide on the plan for how it would all go down. EHF is the meme trio so they probably wanted to include it just a bit, and the juxtaposition in the original chapter having the Floch scene paired with the Historia flashback is a good enough reason to do something with it here.
@@rambooo1771 Then whats with the conversation in 130?
@@beautifulmushroom3466 This conversation was necessary so that Historia would not eat Zeke, in order to carry out Eren's plan to launch a rumble.
@@rambooo1771 Like your birth?
Also, seethe.
Look at the genuine happiness on his face when he reads this, compared to his face whenever Isayama comes out with another interview on AoT. The difference is STAGGERING
Boy i cant wait for Isayama to come out and say he shouldn't have changed the ending. (In like 40 years when no one cares anymore)
@@pacotaco1246 as if he would ever do that
@@rickchakraborty2087 screenshotting this for if it actually happens
@@rickchakraborty2087
isayama cares more for 💴💴
or the company forced him
@@pacotaco1246 didn’t he already say he regretted it
I swear how the fuck did this group end up with such better writing then the last 4 chapters of the cannon ending combined
Passion, love for the art, no sellouts over here lmfao
@@superexclusive452 big FAX
Isayama should've ask for help if he lack in ideas like why not right?
@@ashrafhakim379 look bro isayama's intention was actually this. I kinda understood the Canon ending. It is so similar to the fan ending. But the problem was isayama didn't elaborate and didn't explain it well. He used wrong choice of words that is all
@@ashrafhakim379 Actually it was the other way around.
Because he was surrounded with so many people and his work wasnt a seinnen but a SHONNEN.
Some years ago Isayama had planned a different ending but after some time his editors were making decisions about which character should be killed and where the story should go.
After those 130 chapter they started to rush the story and thats why any person with some brain cells can see the quality of writting and dialogues decreased.
Zeke got zooked by his own brother for having seggs. Congrats Uncle Zook!
"No...No this does not absolve you!!!"
THERE WE FUCKING GO!!
this is Armin the commander THIS is Erwin's successor
God I love this chapter so fucking much
I actually kind of sided with Armin here. I want to like Armin, and I don't want to have to call him the M-word. But he brought it on himself in the original.
@@alexvaughan1013 That was supposed to be the whole point in the canon manga, the reader was supposed to be torn between Eren and Armin, Bad side of humanity vs Good side of humanity. AOT no Requime is fantastic, it understood the tone so well.
@@agrimpuriya2585 it didn‘t feel that there are a good and a Bad side
@@Alaa-gv6ks What i meant was Eren thinks the world cannot change and people in power perpetuate the cycle of hatred for their selfish agendas. (Bad side of Humanity)
Armin however believes that people can change and through coexisting may start to understand each other ending the cycle of hatred. (Good side of humanity)
The truth is neither Eren nor Armin are right as explained by the line in the ed 4
"The world is easy to understand and that's what makes it so complex"
@@agrimpuriya2585 well i disagree i don't see eren as a vilian neither as hero in what he did but isyama has already explain that the cycle will never end and the other wrold will strike them eventually in the last pages
you see i am not saying here that people will not change and it's clearly their are people who are against all these things sadly that just not how it does work the people who have the power and poltical will always do what benfit them and their countries nobody will care about what's hapening to the others or to the other countries and nobody can stop it and that's just the nature of humans just look at our real world and explain to me how it's easy to understand
Man..this is somehow better than Part 1. The writing, the depth given to both eren and Armin that just builds off of the last chapter. More context given to Erehisu’s development and it makes sense cause they use actual events within the OG manga. This is perfect.
Baens WHAT THE FUUUUUU
@@o_8t12 who are you to decide? They're using their skills to do what they want. Don't act high
@Hahaah
Look , this fan made canon is not for iq less EM trash shippers. So , go and read that chapter 139 or the extra pages if you want. You don't need to examplify your brainless character for disrupting others
@@o_8t12 and because original is something we does not want does not mean its deep either. And being too badaas is better than being too b/i/t/c/h
@@o_8t12 you know if u dont like it. U can literally re read the original or if ur only into shipping u can re read Sailor moon 😊.
my favourite part is when zook found out he's an uncle now. and that little forest scene. 🌚
Bruh i am curious of what happened there 🤣
Did they do it together or got married lol?
@@dudeguy3243 I'm not sure about the forest scene but they did the devils tango but not get married 😏
This is literally god tier story telling wtf? I’ve never liked fanfics cuz I thought they were corny, but this one gets a pass. This shit is absolutely beautiful and definitely should’ve been the original story. This whole thing is just perfect
Yeah but man the characters are trash and the dialogue is really bad it is to much fan service and eren and historia conversation was so bad i died of laughter i thought it was a joke but damn i was wrong
@@o_8t12 why you write "yeah" and then basically say exact opposite of what original commenter said? LoL
After reading part 2 , canon 139 lines definitely look more ret@rded and cheesy than aotnr
The drawings are very nice.
But narratively it doesn't really have shit to do with Isayama's story. And Eren's character was completely turned around.
As a "what if" it fits.
But if they think they are "fixing" the work, as they had previously written and then later cancelled... well, they haven't understood anything, because there is nothing coherent about it
@@jeff_sl523 who is fixing this is fanfic not a what if
@@jeff_sl523 huh? No one is fixing tho, they've already said it, aot no requiem is an alternate story telling of the last three chapters.
This was even better than part 1, man this fanfic is fantastic
Canon*
@@adrithmanvik1853 of course it's better than the canon, that was terrible lol
Yep it is , but there are still trash talkers on instagram and twitter
@@dogecoin9562 no I'm saying this IS the canon. Chapter 139 was a fever dream.
@@adrithmanvik1853 oh lol I gotchu
This chapter made me remember why Armin was my fav character, this team is fucking incredible
EXACTLY BRO. I was a huge armin fan, he was my favorite character. Then canon ending absolutely ruined him. The fact I had to say Erwin was the better choice over armin hurt to say but it was true. Bless the aotnr team
Heck yeah armin was logical and smart but at the original ending they made him a hypocrite
@@plab1151 speaking the words of the people my man 🥲
The Eremika kids and ending defenders are gonna go rabid when they see this lmao.
They are already going ham, go to this fanfic's twitter for once.
They already are, haven’t ya seen Twitter and the r/ShingekiNoKyojin Reddit today? They’re fuming, and it’s all because this fanfic chapter is so much better than the canon ending!
@@mrcrazy7865 no, it's because they are angry af that they are going with Erehisu ship, that's legit their only concern.
@@rickchakraborty2087 I know they are, they don't give a damn that the characters were talking about things that matter for 30 pages, or the characters staying intact, all they ever give a damn about is Erehisu.
Man they gotta let go of the hate
Its so simple and they are acting
So violently by a fanfic, so damn crazy yo
The death threats are worse, we are humans but threatening someone because of this makes you worse.
Ik that we people love this franchise and cherish it for a decade but why has it come to this.
AND THEY ARE STILL HOLDING ON,
LET GO!!!
(I had to include that last line cause i love star wars and it felt right to say it XD)
●The panel of Erwin's Ghost judging Armim
●Extended Floch conversation with Eren
●Eren practically refuting Armin at every point and Armin having no counterargument.
*chef's kiss*
My favorite panels in Part 2.
It's funny that AOTNR is more consistent than the canon ending of chapter 139.
I'm still laughing that 139 Defenders is calling Requiem poorly written, when it makes more sense and respects the themes of Isayama original work.
I liked where the original ending was going but......they messed up eren and armin's talk,ymir story was just disgusting to read,floch and historia were wasted because rushing things and mikasa's whole character came out of nowhere after being so irrelevant during 130 chapters so....
I can say that what Isayama had planned wasnt bad but was really poorly executed.
If the ending was good like all 139 defenders are saying then why so many people dislike it?
A good ending gives a conclusion to the story and characters while being truth to his own plot and themes and that didnt feel really good when reading 139.
@@aswadsyednaz3073 all facts
I honestly don’t even like Attack On Titan at all let alone the garbage heap that was Chapter 139. Attack On Titan altogether was one of the worst told stories I’ve ever seen in my life.
I at least will give respect that The AOT No Requiem team was willing to fix and rewrite the final part of the series and make it a lot better than it was. You get no disagreement from me on this.
Chapter 139 was a truly horrible chapter. AOT No Requiem which isn’t even anything canon sadly is actually somehow better than the actual story. What an utter joke.
Personal high five from me my man.
Aot simps on the shit ending :"noo u can t say AotNR is better. Don t disrespect iasayamas work. U are not a real fan. The ending was a beautyfull one that people didnt understand :cryingangrydude: )
True Aot chads:cannon ending bad aotNR better work
@@itzmosestone Yea because those chads prefer "Nooo Armin, you weren't meant to see that". Lmfao.
I like Eren's angry face when Armin was talking about his daughter.
Gives Eren even MORE urgency to go through with it. The stakes are higher than ever
@@superexclusive452 That my friend it's called "being a father."
How do you know its a daughter? Could be a son.
@@manwithnoname8229 I've heard it so much so I'm just assuming. But you're right it could be a boy we'll just have to see.
@@manwithnoname8229 because it's gonna be a new ymir
Isayama is going to owe a lot of people an engraved apology afterwards if the chapters keep up this level of flow.
You must be in an infinite tsukuyomi lv. Of genjutsu if you think he gives a single fu*k about anything anymore he got millions of dollar up his ass , he doesn't care.
@@Shinwicked Isayama is a creative in the end and I can guarantee he cares about how his creation is viewed. He would often look on social media sites to see if people were close to finding out his would be ending before Manga ended. Sure he has millions eventually people get used to the money and in the end the one thing that gives them real meaning the thing that fills their artist spirit is what they created because that is all you leave behind when you die. You do not take the money with you. You are immortalized through your creative projects. He DOES care what people think trust me. He spent years on this it's his baby. To say he doesn't care and it does not phase him to hear all criticisms of what he made is ignorant and untrue.
@@sourcesymbiosismetamorphis2228 well we both never met him , so we can't say for a fact , but like I don't see anyway he thought the canon ending was a good idea if he cared. But maybe he was stressed out and didn't want anymore pressure , so he did what he could best, so we should think what we want , because "WERE FREE! , since the day we were born into this World" 😅😅
@@Shinwicked no he doesn't he just likes Jean and wants him to get Mikasa that's all he doesn't care abt the fans as he know that even if he goes for a trash ending he will still earn millions
@@ektakapur7500 One question , is your name really ekta Kapoor ?? 😅😅 Kisine troll kiya kabhi??
The Virgin Colossal Titan fight vs.
the Chad Clash of Ideologies.
What a chapter
What a chapter
What a chapter
WHAT A LENGENDARY CHAPTER OF AOTNR.
Bro I hope this chapter is the one who will got an animation not the trash orginal one.
@@essecm1714 it's not trash
It's pure cringe
*Armin seeing Eren clapping Historia's cheeks*
Eren: "You weren't meant to see that"
I am an Eremika shipper but I love ANR. And I think there is a misconception that every EM shipper loves the original ending. But i saw lot of Eremika shippers including myself who hate the original ending but love Anr. If we just keep the shipping thing aside I think anyone will say ANR better than the original ending.
Finally, a good EM shipper .
Same here bro
same
Your a giga Chad finally met someone who has a decent iq, you don't have to like the ship to read the story you just need to read the story
thats what im looking for. A real argument and despute between two character with the same goal but different ways of doing it showing both their resolve and stance no matter what the outcome may be. You know like irl war and battle of ideologies. To the winner the spoils or to the smartest or strongest the spoils whatever battle it is. Both path can be right or understandable but there can only be one winner in a challenge or race. with a nice flashback and a touch of romance and memory. I like how historia remembered Ymir and Frieda with her in danger of bein alone and have to burden everything. She lost her life by becoming queen. her service is to the people. Eren and the squad too. they join the survey their life was no longer theirs. like in the army . They both faced with what they think is best for their people and ready to go through hell. Just like irl the soldiers lay down their lives and put it on the line for their country for hopes of a brighter tomorrow. Neither side is right but i can understand both side and fighting for what you believe in is always brave. Fighting against hatred, oppression, discrimination etc. Everything is a battle whether physically or mentally. Life is filled with up and downs and challenges and hard choices. Its never easy but you still get up in the morning and do what you need to to survive and live your life. Everyone has something their fighting for. They brought out points fandom ben making. especially about the lives dying for nothing. Also i think should not dwell in the past. Those lives die for the future. Its up to the ones in the present to decide how the future will be though. Keep moving forward you cant remain stagnant forever, eventually it will catch up and overtake you like a flood and you wont be able to stop it. Letting it build up with no real progress. When something doesn't work why persist. IF it worked so well then the things that happened irl wouldn't have. It took people changing how they do things when something is not working.
This actually made armin character tolerable. Armin is back. This is fan made but they did Armin justice. good job.
1:54
"HE IS NOT TALKING ABOUT MIKASA!!!"
Dude I was happy to see that angry reaction of Armin too!
5:13 page with ERWIN is shocking. Like Erwin was dead for nothing but Armin stayed alive. But watching the Canon chapters I was glad Erwin never happened to see what the shit would be next. And neither did Sasha
Me after watching the saintitchief better than eren's character development:
Happiness has returned.
That Mikasa part cracks me up.
1:54 me: WWWWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! yeah baby!! that's I've been waiting for!!! that's what this is all about!! WOHOOOO!!
5:13 that panel hits hard.
I'm already in love this versions Eren, Historia, Armin and Floch more. Plus bringing Erwin, Frieda, Ymir to develop characters in a fanfic ? Nani ?
I love how the team incorporated the smiling Hange panel from 130 which was never used by Isayama in canon. (Further proof Isayama retconned the ending). Btw, Armin is the definite MVP of this one. He proved himself as a man of convictions just like Eren and not just "muh we are your friends, what about Mikasa".
I can't find the panel you're talking about, where can I find it?
@@florasock4292 read it again
@@RainSennin_ismyAlt I couldn't find it bro 😭
Atleast Armin is being consistent. However I would give MVP to Eren for bring the topics and we all saw how AoT ends if Eren agrees to stop.
Imagine Isaymas being the real person behind the whole aot nr just to present the story he always wanted. Just Imagination nothing against the aot nr team. This part was masterpiece. Really waiting for part 3 with full rumbling
That a big brain theory like to see the haters if thats the case
What happened to him? Its like he suddenly changed at like ch 134
@@pacotaco1246 He had Armong's haircut after 139 in his latest TV appearance, LMAO.
Nah, we not gonna give that clown the credit for this hard work.
@@neonthehedgehog12 he's not a clown, without this you wouldn't even be reading this
Every time I think I'm setting myself up for disappointment because of my insanely high expectations.. the AoTnR team blows them away anyway. What an absolutely refreshing chapter - I got mad chills. THIS is how I wanted AoT's ending to feel. Thank you AoTnR team, it was worth the wait! :D
I'm glad I read the chapter with the Hype King Saint. I look forward to more content man. You're just so expressive and intellectually sharp. P.S. The dub isn't as bad as the chat was claiming.
This is what happens when there is no business- money- political correctness behind. You are truly free, and the quality shows it.
Farmer-kun isn't even a CHARACTER and AnR redeems him!
based
@@makimasupremacy9945 based?
AnR for the win
I RAN TO WATCH THIS
Masterful. Absolutely Masterful.
IM SCREAMING TOO
Eren and historia are going to get married in secret how romantic. I almost didn't realize it at first until I saw the priest.
As you should
@@myaparker5510 flochs the priest
@@myaparker5510 Just like Anakin and Padme.
@@shawnellesmith YO EREN IS ANAKIN! (DARTH VADER!!!)
To clear up the confusion, the Historia portion is made up of multiple flashbacks.
There are actually two separate conversations at the farm. The first is when Historia and Eren have forest seggs, you can tell them apart from the more canonical "You're the worst girl in the world." portion from chapter 130 because the canon panels are not slanted while the other ones are. The Hange flashback is a callback to one of the Path Shards we see Eren have (Hange's tearful but happy expression) and gives you the basis of Eren and Historia's relationship which is connected to canon at that point. Same thing applies with the Floch conversation, it's slanted so it is a flashback from before the 130 conversation.
The canonical flashback in ANR has the already pregnant Historia choose Eren over the rest of the world. Why she's pregnant is most likely because since she knew her future partners would be chosen for her by following the 50 year plan, she wanted her first child to be with the man she trusted the most. Out of the entire flashback sequence, it is the most recent of the occurrences.
i cant be bother whoes father anymore this whole manga is fireeeeeee.
Proof that ending defenders were desperately trying to keep their eremika ship afloat which eventually sunk, courtesy of Isayama himself.
It's honestly kind of scary how they act the moment anr said that eren and historia are gonna get together, boy were they mad.
meanwhile in Aotnorequiem's twitter
Aotnorequiem member:
CAP'N ITS AN ARMADA OF EREMIKA'S AND THEY ARE COMING STRAIGHT AT US!!!
INCOMING ENEMY FIRE!!!
@@myaparker5510 to be honest I myself am an eremika shipper but how could anyone want that keeping in mind the shit ending we got
Basically , who eren ends with should be the least priority for any fan in an anime like aot which was turned into shit love story by 139
@@Kush-yk8nc I've never been interested in shipping. Focus on it is kind of a waste of energy to me but if it's good for the story I wouldn't mind. But I'm amazed how crazy people can get when they're shipped it doesn't go well. Some people only care about ship.
@@myaparker5510 exactly
Ofcourse if someone asks me i would want eremika to be true
But in an anime like aot thats one of my least priorities
More than anything u want a good story
This ending will forever be canon in my head and you cant do anything about it
Say it loud say it proud, I agree this is Canon.
Neither do I want to man
You can like whatever you want 👍
Why couldn't Isayama do this?
This is brilliant!!
Only ymir knows
Plot twist : Isayama who made this, and reveal it later to troll shit taste people on Ending he make before
Imagine working on a series for years isayama at that point is basically tired and is pushing the last bit of strength he has to end the story plus there's the pressure from the honchos on his back.
To paraphrase Eren's lines from the anime version:
Because he's an idiot. Just a regular idiot given the power to write a popular series. That's why 139 was the only conclusion he could come up with.
But honestly, he's a good writer (we've seen it in past chapters). I think he was rushed somewhat. That's the only real conclusion I can come to. That, and the fact that he's never written an ending to a series before. His inexperience in tying things together really showed in 139. Fortunately, we have the Requiem team to help pick up the slack.
When you accidentally tell your (ex)best friend you got a girl pregnant:
Man even the farm boy being a plot device to give Historia more time, which i still dont like as an idea, made so much sense here than the original canon! Not some random dude pops out of no where at the end and be the father just cuz, and be absolutely irrelevant. Unless I misinterpreted that panel and it was actually Eren and Historia doing it at the barn in the forest--
What matters to me is that this part of the story was given backstory on WHY it should makes sense, whether i like it or not. This really says that Hajime Isayama was absolutely pressured by the fans to rush the story and put to many plot holes while retconning some characters.
edit: Reread the chapter again and saw closely that it was Zeke mostly involved going into the forest and the barn boy seems like a cover up instead.
So now im interpreting this as Eren and Historia doing it themselves to make the plan real.
Soundtrack changes depending on page you're on
That's quite interesting
Also part1 redeemed eren , part 2 redeemed armin , i think part3 will redeem Mikasa
The chapter itself was amazing. Setup is complete , now action finally begins ;D
Mikasa is just an overrated character.
I dont hate her but compared to Eren and Armin's character she is just a strong/badass female and people like her bc of that.
I'd prefer no love interest for eren but the whole mikasa character is literally Ereh so i dont know how are they gonna redeem her.
While armin really stepped up.
Aot no requiem really upgraded Eren and Armin.
@@aswadsyednaz3073 agreed.
My comment was mostly based on how yams wanted to break up the trio of EMA as they got older but cucked himself and eren in the end by making them all buddies with each other.
Aotnr team would need to change Mikasa somewhat to make childhood friendship like that break(like how they did with eren vs armin)
Mikasa's character is just so broken beyond repair that if they somehow able to redeem her in the next chapter, they deserve all the world's worth of respect
Look how emotional Eren is in this situation and it is far more logical than that shit with mikasa
Man, this made me feel so much more than the original ending. I haven’t felt real happiness since the cringe ending in a long time. Saintichief, your reaction is literally mine when I read this😄
This is why I still stayed in AOT 😭😭😭 I still believe in hope
You better take some hopium before going to bed tonight it's good for health.
@@theswagger78. Nah, AOTNR already help me enough.
@@coltwgrice Well its just a fanfic even if its great we should move on.. there are a lot of other animes worth watching
@@theswagger78. Bro if people like it, let people like it. 😩👌 If you don't like it, then just avoid it or you moved on.
It ain't hurting anyone, AOTNR Isn't gonna be the anime original lmao.
@@coltwgrice lmaoo i like it too but you didnt get what i meant . The og ending is trash tbh but if they gonna make an anime original ending thats great . In the end AoTnR still just a fanfic unfortunately .
I gave up on AoT since the trash ending we got at the end but im still reading the AoTnR cuz i like it and i moved on and i went to watch other animes .
Finally, that scenery..
WE BACK! I already know them Eremika fans finna flag down all these sites and videos so be careful chief!
Armin saw cabin seggs man
1:54 ur reaction is gold.
THIS! THIS IS WHAT THE FINAL CHAPTERS SHOULD HAVE FELT LIKE
Thank you AotnoRequiem team, thank you because you are here with us
The part where Eren said all those people would have died for nothing .I felt like they could have added the part where Young Eren spoke to his father before Shiganshina fell.He spoke of how the Survey corps lives shouldn't be in vain
SaintitChief redemption arc unfolded right before our very eyes
This hit me right in the feels.
Now I started to doubt that AotnoRequiem is a fanfiction now. More and more into this plot gives me some silly hopes of this being the anime's unannounced source material🙁
Bruh you making me depressed after what you said ;((
Unfortunately that wasn't the case. At least we have the AoTnR anime episode to look forward to this fall.
Nothing less than infinity out of 10 for this chapter 🌟
this is the redemption arc we all needed for the saintitchief manga
Thank you AOTnoRequiem team, you literally saved my 10 years of good memories about AOT.
Isayama Is writing this to get us Wit version So that Mappa can go to hell with CGI ending .
big brain right there
@Just_Max But it is Bad . I don't care what they have to go through Sure go ahead and appreciate the animator's effort but not the Animation . Animators may be working very hard but animation is not good .
Small detail: In the Floch scene, Floch objects because Eren couldn't sacrifice Armin to save the devil, Erwin. This was paid off when Eren says, "I don't want to fight my best friend."
Despite what critics say, AnR is far from being some Eren power fantasy glorifying him as some 'heartless Chad' who fucks bitches and commits genocide. It shows that Eren is still very much human, and his plan is far from glorified.
Saintitchief, I'm glad to see you happy. After all this Aot mess this year, you deserve it.
Tbh I had given up on AoT like a great story with an irredeemable ending like GoT, but the amazing folk in the AoTnr team are still making me feel things I felt back when I still loved the canon story. The dialogue fits, characters are actually behaving the way they have been portayed over the entire story, nothing feels out of place, they are even managing to weave previously established plot points in new and interesting ways! This surpassed even my highest expectations, my brain is already treating this as canon now
We are free to choose this as our cannon ending. People already did that with a death note one.
better than the original
This has got to be one of his greatest Livestreams. One of the greats. The passion in this man's voice. If only the actual ending would have been like this.
This is my canon
Bro I have no words to describe how much I loved this part. I’m so hyped for part 3 and I wish everyone who worked on this the best and hope that there was a better reception to this then part 1
From this very moment Historia's life's in danger, so eren must do nothing but kill his friends not only to save paradis but also for the sake of his wife and his child
Even though he doesn't want to kill them, he'll have to, he can't save them all. Either his friends or his family. Even though it's the morally wrong choice, it's what a father would choose, to save his family. Friendship is temporary, family is forever
To EM shippers - Gonna cry 😁
They already are, go to Twitter 😂
Why would they cry when they have a actual canon ship in the manga….😭😭
em shippers are literally making jokes and memes out of it have u seen them 💀💀
@@valeria-xo6gy yaaa 🤣🤣
@Capo Cañoneri ok but they were a big part of the story, also it isn't incest 💀
Armin finally getting the development he needed 🔥🔥
Dog i swear that whoever wrote this deserves recognition, it's not even fair to compare this to the trash ending we got, even tho i'm Eren side i undertand Armin he's not talking out of his ass but bringing fair arguments, this is how it was suppose to go.
I'm gonna be honest about this...
This chapter was great but it had some flaws:
1) Eren sounded like a nationalist instead of someone who strived for freedom.
2) Eren revealing that he'll just commit suicide after completing the rumbling is just way out of character in my opinion.
3) The conversation with historia felt off for some reason. Don't get me wrong, I liked the part where she reminds him to not leave her alone like everyone else did. But it felt like some unnecessary lines were forcefully inserted in some places.
4) Although Armin's dialogue here is much better than what it was in the original. He still believes that talk no jutsu is going to work on the world which is dumb. And that's actually not the team's fault. It's actually Isayama's mistake which leads to number 5.
5) Isayama pretty much wrote himself into a corner during the rumbling arc. And now the fan writers are simply trying to find the best way to get out of it and you can see that here in this chapter.
1- eren definetily is a nationalist, his love for Eldias has allways guided him. Seeing his country locked as cattle, seing all nattions planning kill his people ... That all moldes eren actions. If all he craved for was freedom he would grab his bag, left his country and travel the world like a vagabond or whatever. But no. Eren is a nationalist by his own right.
2- didnt understand your thoughts on the matter
3- About historia.... Well, " unnecessary lines were forcefully inserted " What lines ?
4 and 5 - wanst Armin always like this ? About the writters didnt showing more corpses by the rumbling... Maybe in the next part
1) I disagree, how he spoke here sounds like Eren from 123 through 133 who hasn't spoken to Historia yet. In fact Eren himself has very nationalist values at the core of his character, that isn't for the pure sake of nationalism, that's just who he is.
2) No where did Eren say he would commit suicide? Unless i read it wrong. Not expecting to come back alive is not the same as saying he would kill himself.
3) You need to give a criticism here, like a example. I agree to a degree. The overall point was to fix the awkward manner the original handled it in to fill the holes left about why Historia asked Eren that question in 130. For instance: Who the farmer is, the Floch panel with the figure in the back, Eren reacting to Hange's antagonizing, Why Eren told Historia and why she asked him his opinion etc. As for the lines themselves, not all of them line up with what is shown, but is supposed to give context over what Eren and Historia did the past 4 years, like how "paths" flashbacks operate. It's messy and confusing.
4) It is in character at least, talking isn't the solution but he can't agree that Eren is right, Armin wouldn't agree to senseless slaughter and in that case the main conflict suffers for it if he doesn't stubbornly oppose that, especially this far in. I'd definitely take that over him THANKING HIM.
5) Absolutely. But that's his own fault. I wished he had just stuck with what he set up instead of trying to please all of his audience.
Maybe a little too late to mention this, but better late than never. Some say that they kinda ruined historia's character by not showing her have any sympathy or talk about the billions of innocent lives that are about to be trampled by the rumbling. What they didn't realize is that this conversation here is not supposed to replace the canon conversation in 130, it's supposed to continue it, to conclude it, something like that. And no fools, historia is not being a submissive sheep for not doing anything to stop eren, "even if the whole world turns against us, I'll always be your ally, because we're enemies of humanity", doesn't that ring a bell? If that sounds like a person that got carried away throughout the entire scene, then I'm santa claus. After all, she's still living for herself, being selfish about it is ironically a part of her character. "Live a life you can be proud of", well i sure as hell can know if there's pride in having a baby with your childhood bully or not, historia's expression every time she's with him says it all
And for God's mf'ing sake people, romance holds little to no significance in this relationship between eren and historia, it's unnecessary
Historia is a queen, the safety of her country is her only priority. I she should Care about the world outside that want to wipe out her people?
Ending defenders are dumb
So, as expected, part 2 of aotnr is already getting shitted on with baseless arguments. Love the content bro, would you possibly consider making a video combatting the hate or giving your opinion of the hate towards this amazing project? Keep it up, look forward to your next video
also part 2 of aotnr somehow exceeded the quality of the first part, good shit.
This ending resolves so many things. Its perfect.
I think that's a priest to Eren and historia are walking over to.
its floch i think
King Floch is both the priest and best man.
Or probably its the farmer lmao, I think its a priest, he's holding a book and is wearing grasses
@@vasutiwari4187 an AnR person that wasn’t floch, they were rushing and accidentally made it look like floch but it’s a whole different person
I remember commenting in the interview video “I ship EreHisu, but holy hell people CHILL”.
Can’t believe they actually got it…
I missed the stream but hell yes 👌
Man they literally wrote this much better than isayama that's it i consider this one to be canon idc about the shitty ending isayama wrote.
I'm with you, this is definitely what would have happened next.
I'm ready to bet that this is NOT fan made, but in fact the actual ending originally planned by Isayama, without any forced censorship and controversial themes and protagonist watered down and reversed into "love" themes instead with the Mary Sue of service Mikasa turned hero of the story at the last minute.
Absolute masterpiece
I'm ready to bet this is NOT fan made, but in fact the actual ending originally planned by Isayama, without any forced censorship by big studios like MAPPA and controversial themes and protagonist watered down and reversed into "love" themes instead with the Mary Sue of service Mikasa turned hero of the story at the last minute. And Isayama is probably bound by contract to stay quiet about it and pretend he likes chapter 139.
Historia! That bitch slap nearly killed him!
Wow, i can believe this is fan's dedication. Respect to fandom.
#FamdomDrip
#FathomableStoryline
Imagine that this is the actual ending of the anime
The art of aotnr is amazing!
Thats the Armin
Not Armin with thank you for the rumbling
plot twist : the script of aot no requiem made by isayama but got rejected by editor.
I am fine with erehisu as historia does understand eren while Mikasa even after Being with him for a long time couldn't understand erens character anr what hes trying to do .. personally i think that historia would be a much greater wife for eren then Mikasa could ever be . Marley deserved to be destroyed after what they did to them and after they are paying for their deeds erens friend just go side up with enemies . Even rivals are better than these friends . Eren should kill every single one who decides to come in his way ( including Armin Mikasa ) etc
Marley deserve to be destroyed, the rest of the world no
Eren is worse than Hitler by so many levels.
He IS the monster that must be destroyed.
As ermine said, it doesn’t matter how he justifies It. A genocide is a GENOCIDE.
@@btech5652 bro after you said eren is worst than hitler gave me the chills
And your right lol
If they do this then even this ending is shit for me
Ships aside , eren’s core character point for me is his love for his friends , they shoudnt destroy that
@@btech5652
1) the rest of the world hated Eldia more than Marley....the only way to go to Eldia is through Marley and the walls....and there were pure titans all around, Marley even has Eldian population in them...if there were no walls and titans, Eldia would be destroyed long ago
2) Hitler did it out of disgust, Eren did it out of necessity....the German army command spread the myth that the army had not lost a war on the battlefield but because they had been betrayed. By a ‘stab in the back’, as it was called at the time. Hitler bought into the myth: Jews and communists had betrayed the country and brought a left-wing government to power and that is what made Hitler kill off Jews (just cuz of a speculation and power struggle) - www.annefrank.org/en/topics/antisemitism/why-did-hitler-hate-jews/ and this is a report taken with info from a holocaust victim - Eren saw what happened to Eldia and how they were bounded inside walls...tried to see the future with a desired outcome but found no other solution and did it....GENOCIDE IS WRONG can't be expressed when the very thing Eldia was going through as well was some sort of a genocide itself
3) Eren is a monster that was created from the hatred spread by Marley and the world...he didn't even think about rumbling until he saw everyone else cheer for the destruction of Eldia
4) that is the entire point that was supposed to happen in the original manga....them having an idealistic and realistic mindset discussion...not about Mikasa after literally 80% of the world was destroyed....Mikasa was not the topic to discuss at that point in any way
@@Kush-yk8nc for you, not the story....he said he wished his friends to live a long and peaceful lives, not the destruction of Paradis and his friends to be exiled from their homeland....were Sasha, Hange and all those in the circle not friends of Eren? and what part of Eren do you think is within character if the journey started with his mom being killed turned to him killing his mom in order to save Reiner, Bertholt? are those two more important to him than his mom? LOL
Yeah this damn story freaking clean!!! You said it. This is an ending we desire.
"If this is your way of showing me you've always been like this, then you're nothing but a slave to your own selfishness"
I can't tell you how much this resonated with who Armin really is! That's exactly the route he was taking before 138 and 139. Not the pissant "Thankyou for committing mass murder for our sake"🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
I think the problem of this part is too much performance of love.The reaction between EH should be more deeper, it's hard to use ordinary love to describe it.
I'm EH stan and glad to see the chapter coming out, but the emotion will lower its scores.
This was so perfect! 🥺❤️
The couple Eren and Historia is insane, anyway that's a beautiful way to explain for Historia's pregnancy.
Not just a way, the ONLY way
@@Philthorn lol it's nothing but fandom shipping and it's more fanservice than anything, historia in the story served no purpose other than having a kid and creating a ship out of that cause they had common goals doesn't work really, if anything i rather prefer Eren being single as he wouldn't have time for ships and stuff while his country is in great peril from the outside world
@@Layd36that could literally be a better and more relatable motivation for eren to complete his mission. "Have no time for ships and stuff", if we were given more of eren's perspective that could've been explained better, but isayama was busy making lelouch 2.0
@@Philthorn i mean even if they want to create a ship it should be believable as historia and Eren should have more scenes and communicate with each other especially in the pre time skip and even have some believable scenes where people can understand they are romantically involved, hell Eren interacts more with Mikasa where she's shown to care about Eren more than anything and it seems like a one sided love while Eren doesn't seek to bother anything about love in the scenes we are given in the story and more about saving his people and being depressed at the thought of destroying the world, i really feel bad for Eren who while his fans think of him as a Chad and all that nonsense about shipping whereas he thinks about the horrific things he will do and does in the future, even if fans want that ship to be true he would probably live like four years at max and that much short life isn't even worth having ships over, fans don't think of Eren as a character who is willing to do genocide to save his people and moves forward with pure conviction and rather think about who he is going to pipe down a baby with, it's really disappointing
@@Layd36point taken. However, that still could've been explained better, eren decided to cry like a baby in the end and to reach that point he did what he hated: put on a facade, when in fact eren is not totally emotionless, I'm telling you if we were given more of eren's perspective it would have been reasonable and properly explained, their conversation for example, we never saw the whole thing play out
When the rumbling is complete, the titan course will disappear too so no 13 year time limit 🐂 💩 anymore by the way you're welcome
That is reaction genuine with happiness same as mine, and this is indeed good story telling, and I'm agree with all you said here! good job AOTNR team! 👏
Love the hype you’re giving to us
Average Ackerman Fan : *whiny virgin*
Average forest seggs enjoyer : * Giga chad*
By now saintitchief is the AoT character I'm most invested in. After almost all the characters let me down by horrible writing, it's such a joy to see saintitchief growing and developing. I'm so glad to be able to follow the AoT no Requiem season when he finally gets the ending he and all the other characters deserved. Thank you, AoTNR team!