The Evolution of Early Outs on Drag Race
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июн 2024
- Podcast: thedragdetective.buzzsprout.com
Instagram: / thedragdetective
Twitter: / dragdetective
Patreon: / thedragdetective
Tiktok: tiktok.com/@thedragdetective
Someone's gotta go home first...and second, and third. But those dreaded 2nd and 3rd out spots are notoriously the worst spots to go out in on RuPaul's Drag Race. Not remembered for being the first eliminated, not in enough episodes to make a lasting impression. Many queens who have gotten these placements have been mostly forgotten or under appreciated by the fandom as a whole....that is until Season 16.
With 2 back to back shocking eliminations of fan favorites this early, it's time to look at how being an early out has changed throughout the years, and if there is a new trend in recent seasons. Are Amanda Tori Meating and Mirage outliers or the start of a new trend? We'll break it all down.
INTRO 0:00
EARLY SEASONS 4:01
MIDDLE SEASONS 11:27
NEW SEASONS 19:22
MIRAGE 25:57
AMANDA TORI MEATING 27:52
FINAL THOUGHTS 33:30 
Развлечения
This season is yet another example why split premieres with one or zero non-eliminations after are the best format for the show. And I mean true splits: 1 whole episode with 1 group, 1 whole episode with another group, and then start eliminating queens without any saves. It's why those early queens are so beloved. That extra time gives people more time to enjoy those queens and stan them.
Not sure if so many have fallen in love with hershii the snack jete or miragini
the world completely erupted when mirage was eliminated wdym @@kev7600
Ngl I hate the split premieres when it’s two groups of queens. I’d prefer a premiere episode with all the queens split over two episodes (if that makes sense), but still with no eliminations for the first challenge.
@@kev7600 not miragini 😭
@@vinaamii3915that's how we know they forget them
Mirage “She’s Such A Bitch” just hit 2 million streams on Spotify already. THE QUEEN OF STREAMS *insert her evil laugh*
I hope she's making some coin out of it, I'm streaming basically everyday!!!
It autoplays after playing drag songs and I'm not mad about it.
@@allanteles8771im pretty sure world of wonder owns the queens songs once they use them on the show
not from spotify, that's all mirage !@@grantmegan91
3 million already!!!!
I genuinely don't think we've seen a drag race community reaction to an elimination this extreme since Valentina's back on season 9. For Mirage to make that kind of impact in just 3 episodes is insane!
Completely thought of this when Amanda went home. Her and Mirage will be remembered more than some of those queens that are still there.
I’m only on the RUclips highlights, which ones do you mean? (From the highlights my guesses are Morphine and Megami)
I'm struggling to think of who is even still there🤔
@@Furrito_272 Morephine will be remembered a lot with her personality
@@thegaminghandsome3331more than miami girl #2 at least
@@thegaminghandsome3331 ah. Thanks. Sadly haven’t seen the confessionals, but the “here look at my ass” style isn’t as fun for me as any of the others this season.
It’s crazy that Lashauwn is still forgotten after giving us THE MOST referenced line in the show’s history. It’s referenced so many times with so many iterations that most people forgot the queen that originated it lol
Which line?
@@madeleinewitt9901 “This is not RuPaul’s best friends race” in her fight with Jiggly
@@madeleinewitt9901 hot potato couture
@@nana-cr1vcholy shit they weren’t kidding
I only really remember The Princess as the girl who got sent home by Dida Ritz in one of the best lipsyncs of all time
I wish mirage didnt go so early, i loved her
She was my pick for winner
Princess Poppy is cursed and a curse on us
you mean a blessing??
If there was an early outs season my dream cast you be: April Carrion, Tempest Dejour, Kahmora Hall, Layla Mcqueen, June Jumbalaya, Mirage, Princess Poppy, Irene Dubois, Kelly Mantle, Dahlia Sin, Rock M Sakura, Maddy Morphosis, Honey Davenport
Does Maddy count as an early out?
Top 3 of this cast - Kelly, Maddie and Irene. Winner - Kelly.
Please lord make it happen😭😭😭☺️☺️☺️
Nicky was the second most followed queen as season 12 aired. She was never cursed
Nicki Doll is one of the queens that I feel is underrated. The reason she flopped on her season was the comedy challenges, but it is so hard to do humor in your second language. I am fully bilingual in English and French, but French humor is so different from English humor, and I struggle to make jokes in French. If she could have competed in French, she would have slayed.
Yessss just like she's been slaying on Drag Race France!
Idk. I think Layla being a emmy winner leaves her decidedly out of the cursed category.
new video idea: contestants who won their lip sync but were sent home because of production riggory (amanda, trixie, alyssa)
I thought you meant Alyssa Edwards at first and was about to go full Coco Defence Squad
Coco won that lipsync
@@Ronnoc0421alyssa hunter
@@Ronnoc0421they mean Alyssa Hunter
Elektra on RPDRDU1 (That season was wild af😂), but with all the controversies surrounding the other queens, Elektra would have won the season.
In the words of Vivacious, ’Mother has arrived!!’
"Nicole Page Brooks... Is from Atlanta, Georgia." 😂😂😂 The obvious thing to say but it still killed me
It took me forever to realize why she says from Atlanta ga 😂
MIRAGE is one i can see coming back next season or in the future ...shes so lovely and tbf ... I wasn't expecting her to leave this soon
Mirage is coming back for the next season material and they're totally putting Amanda and Plane Jane in an All Stars together. I honestly can't wait.
@@natsby4life842 We might see Amanda again in 2030 or 2040 as I think her season is too new for her to be put on All-Stars anytime soon. That's if she is interested in returning though. Since with All-Stars when they do pick Early Outs its usually every handful of seasons and I can see them wanting to use Queens who placed higher first. But she won't be back anytime soon I will admit to thinking.
@@Goldenrod636the way they’ve been putting g queens on all stars only a year after their season, i’m sure she’ll be back in 2 years if she’s not on as10.
the new belak boy curse is Derek and kayla saying that they see a queen going far and them being eliminated the next episode (or the opposite)
Mirage, Amanda and even saying mihya would go soon and she won
She got a 1/4 of a win 😂
The Belak Boy Curse 2.0 (electric boogaloo now with more men) was RunnerEye jinxing Mirage to shreds one week to the other
The Belak Boy Curse 3.0 is Derek & Kayla
@@zoeisonline I think they were just quoting dawn. In the episode preview on yt, Dan said the exact same thing.
Mirage was so interesting to me, after the MTQ I had put her in my "Early Outs" category, but after the premiere I was blown away because it was *so* strong for her, so I bumped her up to a mid-out. Turns out my initial reaction was correct lol. Amanda is personally not for me, but I hope she gets all the success post-Drag Race. I think she'll have a Tia Kofi-like glow-up once she has access to better resources for her drag, she has the creativity and talent to make it.
I asked my sister and mum (they have watched seasons 1-16) who they thought was the least memorable queen. After listing off a few first/second outs, I asked if they remembered Alisa Summers. And genuinely they thought I was just making up a fake name. I put forth that she is truly the most 'cursed' Rugirl, regardless of her placement.
Penny Tration is messy! I booked her for a drag show at Youngstown State University and then like a month before she was like “oh sorry I’m in a wedding that weekend and can’t go :)” after advertising it for months! So mad.
what was her number? Party in the usa? 🇺🇸
Used the same excuse for a friend of mine at Penn State
wtf lol like i kinda get it if you‘re a more well known queen but for one who isn’t to pull that????
UNprofessional
31:00 or yknow...the fact that people, myself included, think that she fully won the lip-sync against Q....but then went home 😭 so theres the "robbed" factor in there helping her aswell i think
For me, I feel like Amanda's personality was so bright and bubbly and she was so willing to look silly and have fun and join in with the other queens that it made it easy for the producers to give her a little mini storyline. She meshed so well with everyone and was so willing to participate that you just had to love her. Likewise for Mirage even though she didn't really have a story brewing. (Hershii had that kind of personality as well!)
I honestly feel the same way about the twins last season. They just have that lovable personality. Like even though you know they're not gonna win or make it to the top half... you enjoy seeing them succeed and root for them.
VERY that on the edit. When Mirage cried I immediately thought of Rock M - and production trying o console her by promising her a good edit - and clearly they've learned and kept that up. I'd love to see a "director's cut" of S15 with full length episodes, but they're definitely making up for it now.
i think Q got screwed over by sending amanda home after losing the lip sync
TWO drag race videos mentioning the winner of the show herself, Yuhua, in one day? ICONIC
I would kill a man for Amanda tori meeting to have 5 more episodes
Thank you for addressing the delusion around Mirage's elimination. I liked her too but her elimination was very fair. Tbh I don't think there's been an unfair elimination yet this season.
Getting to know Amanda and mirage was exactly why split premiers with no sashay works. It’s more fair to early outs.
Lmao hershi looking at this video like 👁️👄👁️
She s got kids to take care of
lol same for Kahmora Hall😂
And June Jumbalaya lol
The 2nd out is really the worst for me bc usually your fall is set up from the 1st ep meanwhile the 1st out has at least (nowadays) its moment to shine/emotional moment on their episode
Amanda wouldn’t have been so loved if she went home episode 1 compared to the episode she was actually eliminated on since her beef with Plane gave the fans someone to root for. Also wha I noticed this season is the 3 ppl eliminated so far have been the nicer people of the cast while the queens who can be shady stayed. Megami might go next cause she’s pretty nice.
Not Megami 😢
So that means dawns shady ass is going far I guess
@@Bazibishopi got whiplash from seeing how shady and high school clique Dawn was (wanting to do the skit with only her girls and pushing Plamas out of the equation) ?? I guess her elf/fairy aesthetic gave me the wrong idea
Ohmygod Jeff the Killer as magnolia I'm screaming
I already can't wait for the Amanda tori reading at the reunion!!
This is about Dragula instead of Drag Race, but I’ve noticed a few early outs seem to do pretty well for themselves since the show, and have even come back for All-Stars seasons. Second-outs like SAINT and Astrud Aurelia came back for either the next season or the Titans season (in Astrud’s case, she had a VERY strong start, but had a hard drop-off when she was the second boot). And then third-outs like KoCo Caine, Jarvis Hammer, and Kendra Onixxx have become some of the biggest stars of the franchise.
In the case of the Dragula , staying longer but not winning might be the curse. The Boulets really suck at crafting storylines, the only discussion they left in the episodes are pitiful overproduced dramas, probably because the season is not “designed” ahead of time. I’m also part of that fandom and I’ve seen how fans end up creating the “storyline” online. The more the ghouls stay, the more likely they’ll get a target on their back for whatever the fans may not have liked.
In the case of RPDR, the queens joke around, tell their story etc, some event or people are showcased (Lady Bunny, TS Madison…), Ru, Michelle, Carlson and Ross and even some RuGirls come around regularly. Usually RPDR has a proper pace, it’s produced by TV people used to making TV.
Hey, just so you know since her time on drag race, Honey Davenport has released multiple EP's, has an entire RUclips series which was picked up by out tv , is guest starring in other series, and was on binge Queens for UK versus the world. she is actually putting out more content than a lot of peoples faves and it's not talked about enough. She is honestly a pillar in the Los Angeles Drag scene. She most recently came out with a single that featured Alaska.
Honeys music Is garbage as fuck
Amanda has HUGE early out energy
going home second-fourth has to be way worse than first
Lashauwn is an UNDERRATED seamstress.
I feel like amanda is like tia from uk like she was great in challanges but the runways always held them back and once they have the budget and time to hone their fashion and skills they could easily come back and kill an allstars
I honestly think Amanda would be the perfect candidate for coming back this season.
I think Mirage could too
I don't see a come back, but I'd live for it. In a few years, I can see Amanda winning All Stars.
It just seems like such a wasted opportunity to throw away her and plane's storyline so soon??
@@magickaldust1213right bc eliminating q would be such a gag and imagine how plane would’ve reacted to amanda staying
I wanna see both of them on all-stars. Mirage because she’s just iconic (maybe an assassin first?) and Amanda could probably go far if not win with a little more time
I ran into Akashia at her job, she's such a sweetheart!
when you said milk the fruit at 2:21 I immediately thought about Nymphia with her leche and her bananas :')
I mean the problem with Amanda was her being in the bottom with Q. Like yeah there was no way they would have let her stay over Q who gives obvious finalist energy imo. If she was paired with any other queen apart from sapphira, nymphia, plane the other probably would have gone home. And production probably wanted to save their double shantay for later. So yeah. Personally I also thought she was going to leave later, maybe as the 8th queen. But production saw both of them in the bottom, they saw that the Jane Amanda thing could easily be changing to Q and plane (which maybe I’m alone with that theory) so I think they didn’t even need her that much narrative wise anymore or were more comfortable in letting her go. At least that’s how I explained it. Bc I personally kinda thought that Jane herself was slowly moving on from Amanda to Q in a way with shading her after she was in her feels after the acting challenge. And it makes sense. Start drama with a queen that will go far rather than a queen that probably won’t go as far. Don’t know whether Jane thinks of all that but I could imagine that she does.
Plane Jane is a smart bitch, I can see her starting drama just to stay in the production favours, and her changing from Amanda to Q for this reason makes complete sense. I think Amanda wasn’t even that bad in this episode though, so the could have easily judged the challenge individually if they wanted to save her, cuz the winning group, apart from Nymphia, was the most forgettable, and Geneva could have easily been put in the bottom and sent home in her third lipsync. Maybe they expect some more drama from Plane and Q that they didn’t need Amanda anymore
Rock's tetherball look is hands-down one of my favorite looks... it's underrated!
if you guys google it there is already a video pre-drag race that shows Mimi picking up a queen at a local bar, on top of her shoulders, and spinning around. I think the documentary is Queens of NY which also features Acid Betty, Peppermint, some cameos of Bianca, and lesser known non-RPDR queens like Epiphany Getspaid, etc. Point being, that Mimi wrestling move was already planned and done--but RPDR made it iconic and pretended it wasn't premeditated.
Mirage & Amanda Tori Meating are beloved by fans!
Great video but my favourite thing to come out of it is looking up the Dax! beef and seeing her use the term “RuPaul Industrial Complex”. The fact that’s my favourite quote from her proves your point but it’s a great one 😂
Ugh, I miss Mirage so much 😭 😭 😭 I can't enjoy the season now despite all the talent in the remaining cast 😭 totally agree, hoping she now sees how perfect and beautiful and charismatic she is, it really seemed like she didn't see that ❤❤❤
I don’t think that Amanda would have been loved as much or had as much screen time if Plane hadn’t come for her
When Mirage got eliminated, I immediately hoped they bring back the twist of bringing a previously eliminated queen, like they brought back the immunity twist, just to get Mirage back but I don't think it will happen
"Sugar's fine. She's on GITM straight. That's all that matters." lmao I was wheezing!!!
Mirage’s talent and placement is so perfect because it makes us want to see more of her. When the Lalaparuza episode came out, I saw a lot of fans saying they were excited to see Mirage again on their screens. I would also like to add that watching this video again post-drag race, I think this is also the reason why Mirage is booked! People just want to see more of her. She’s so charismatic and such an amazing performer. She recently did a solo tour in Australia and is coming to Asia in May and June, which is so impressive for an “early out”.
if plane doesn’t win then an all stars with her, amanda, and mirage would be TOP TIER
I feel like th most succesful first out is Shangela by far but usually it s the mid outs that have the weirdest trajectories eventually. You re either first out or winner to maximise your success potential😂😂😂
Really a shame Shangela, one of the most successful ru girls, has multiple r@pe allegations against them.
I feel like if Mirage didn’t go home that episode she could have given Trinity k Bonet in season 6 “what do you do well” moments and sort of soured our view of her. Instead she was beloved and remember for being amazing in that talent show.
You know what I'd love to see a video of? The curse of East Asian contestants in both U.S and UK drag race. Excluding Raja, Manilla (who I realize is only half), Kimchi, and JuJu, it is this thing that a lot of talented East Asian queens go home early (specifically around Snatch Game). Off the top of my head I can think of Sum Ting Wong, Le fil, Gia Gunn, Kimora Blac, Yuhua, Jiggly, Ongina, Plastique Tiara, Rock M. Sakura. And that is just off the top of my head. It's just something I've noticed over the years. I also know I'm 1) missing people, 2) included Pilipino people because there are not only Chinese-Filipinos but they are literally in the southeast.
It would just be an interesting topic. Especially since we haven't had an Asian winner in MOST of the franchises. Another aspect that may be at play for snatch game is frame of reference--but I just don't buy it.
ANYWAY, food for thought.
How are you feeling now that the curse is broken? 🍌 🍌🍌
Season 16 seems so ripe to do a challenge like on Season 7, where they bring the eliminated queens back & pair them up with the remaining competitors, and one queen gets resurrected. That would be a gag
Miss plane Jane kinda helped Amanda get fan love tbh
Layla Mcqueen has an Emmy tho
To me the most forgotten queen of the entire franchise is Alissa Summers from season 4 and the fact that you didnt even mention her proves my point
Dude I’m so glad you made this video ! I’ve been thinking so much about it ! Like the “forgotten queens” of drag race ! Loved this video !
I still love many of those queens tbh ! I like to go see them and buy their merch to show them support !❤️
what a creative video concept!!! love all of the things you talked about - would've enjoyed a dahlia sin mention, since i feel like i never see her talked about online, but otherwise, i fully enjoyed this
Watching a season unspoiled is the best!
Love this video, great content ❤ saludos desde Guatemala.
Love all your videos Derek and loved drag duel
thank you so much!
When you mentioned early out energy, for this season the Thiccs from that one girl group were that for me. No personalities and weak runways (Amanda included, but for her its kinda what you expect then you warm up to it)
Amanda and Mirage in my delusion felt the 6th and 5th placer for S16
I am not a fan of megami, or maiya
wait you're in Cleveland!?!?!? how am I just now finding this out!!?!?!? def gotta have a watch party or two now lol
Also this season everyone is so entertaining! it’s giving season 6 vibes with all the personality
Good job on this video!
imagine not mentioning that Laila has won an emmy.. xD
I remember watching Muniz's ruprises and since he is brazilian he has Portuguese subtitles that instead of just translating things exactly he made the jokes fit the language, he changed names like sasha and kerri were the Kombis, and tamisha was changed to "sister tamisha" and he changed her tamisha iman is coming for you to "sister tamisha will convert you" and that is just legendary for me
Nicky Doll is hands down best of ALL drag race franchise hosts. No arguments.
She really is, and I’m very glad she got this moment to shine. Even on all stars 8, she wasn’t bad as a LSA
pls post more consistently i love ur vids ☹️💞
i was genuinely shocked when amanda went home, like ignoring her amazing performance in the challenge and lip sync, i had this thought halfway through the episode that amanda was going to stay around for a long time because of her storyline with plane jane. and then she was gone the same episode?....???
I was so sad to see mirage leave so soon, then i was just shocked to see amanda go home so early.
26:30: girl you’re delusional if you think everyone agrees with Mirage going home. The amount of comments about how she didn’t even deserve to be in the bottom is unreal.
Imo it doesn't matter if she deserved to be in the bottom or not, she was and didn't know the words. I was disappointed because I liked her but that's how the game goes.
@@korie4198 oh absolutely, she fully deserved her elimination. I like her but there was no way mama ru was going to let her stay after messing up the words of a Cher song.
I would say most agreed but yeah I’ve seen quite some ppl saying she didn’t deserve bottom and even a few that were like she didn’t deserve to go home. Like they are ready to throw the robbed queen label at her. I knew that would happen since the promo but I didn’t know that it would happen this fast (and tbh undeservedly - bc she’s not robbed nor was either decision with bottom and elimination rigged). And I mean she’s crazy talented but I wouldn’t be surprised if her breakdown was even harder bc she knew it was like her own fault tbh. Like she can’t even blame a team mate or riggers, when she fought for the *host role* (stupid decision tbh) and then didn’t deliver at all, which makes it worse. And then didn’t know the lyrics to a lipsync she literally ate up otherwise. No need to attack the other queens for that. She could be a fitting queen for next season as a recast tbh.
I didn’t know you’re from Cleveland! Me too!!!!! You’re my favorite drag race videos to watch!
That picture that you chose for Serena ChaCha is CRIMINAL 💀
You should do a Video looking back at old spoiler videos. Like I remember seeing a season 7 one where Violet was out super early and I find those interesting
I think they really hit the sweet spot with editing and pacing this season. I was kinda worried at the beginning for how rigged this season could be, but after them rightfully giving the win to Magami’s group last week I have much more faith.
I can't stip looking at Mirage's makeup and het face! She's so gorgeous 🤩🤩🤩
dax exclamationpoint being referred to as dax questionmark since the attack on maddy is so fuckin funny
S13 & S15 probably had the best early outs. I find them much more memorable & talked about than a lot of their season’s mid outs. I can’t think of Joey Jay or Princess Poppy as cursed bc they brought legacy 2 the show.
Obviously this season’s following trend.
I think rumours about "The Video" also maybe helped keep Rock M. Sakura in people's minds as well *eyebrow waggle*.
You nailed it on the head with Nicky Doll! I LIVED for her Instagram live during the pandemic. Nicky kept me busy! I don't care if she has her own franchise I want her to be on an All Stars season.
Plane Jane catapulted Amanda Tori Meeting, and this is WHY we need REAL contestants to shake others and give them spotlight or they simply blend into the back.
You should do this for UK, DU and Canada too!
Lmaoo not Kahmora Hall, the Mackie Doll not being mentioned🤭
As a fellow Clevelander, I also knew Akashia as well. I used to run into her at Bounce years back when Id go sometimes for karaoke with a friend who she had a crush on.
27:20 Hershii LiqCour-Jete' texting Derek like "....tf you just say?!" 😆
i NEED another all stars prediction video
Omg I live in Cleveland too!
vivacious was at nyc pride last year for house of love and i got to meet her! she's definitely making a comeback
Nicole Paige Brooks is still in Atlanta. She works here regularly. She’s often a part of the Wussy Magazine Bottoms Up Drag Brunches at City Winery. She is one of my favorite people on this planet.
Fellow Ohioan and former Clevelander, that’s so cool you got to work with Akasha
Tamisha is doing drag in Vegas! At a bar with Eliiott(with two T’s) and Jade Jolie! I saw them at a brunch a couple months ago. It was an amazing show.
Amanda Tori has no story line except for the one Plane Jane gave her. Period. She should thank P.J. I hope in the future she says she wants to be known for more than just being enemies with Plane Jane.
Just like how Mimi ImFurst said she wants to be know for more than just picking up India Ferra.
I think you would do yourself a service to set your camera further back and zoom in to get the same framing that you currently have.
The camera being so close blows out the features in the centre of your face and shrinks the ones on the periphery. Setting it further back will be more flattering.
Interesting video, though. :)
I still feel like sugar and spice guest starred of drag race. Like they were some of if not the most famous queens going into their season and while their fame did grow they absolutely did not need drag race like most other queens who go on drag race do. If anything having the twins on introduced alot of younger people to drag race.
They were known but their reputation was nowhere near Sasha’s lol
I want mystique to come back so badly