@@djbernadotte9768 because Tommy is a white character. Ethnicity wise it's still incorrect because the Miller brothers are canonically Germanic and not Mediterranean
As great as the TV show is and generally have been very pleased and extremely surprised! It has also made me even more certain that the game is one of the greatest masterpieces ever created!
@@riradd92 those are just the typical Nostalgia fucktards, probably saying that Tobey’s interpretation of Spider-Man is the best only because he was their childhood and nothing else🙄🙄
Same, but realistically they haven’t tried to adapt much of the game play into the show, so it’s been constant. Plus Joel’s fall is unrealistic for real world physics.
Personally find myself loving the show representation more than the game. Either way, it’s fine to like what you like. No need for all the negativity, this is the best adaptation of a game ever and people are still complaining.
You become more connected to the characters. It's like walking in their shoes, seeing the world from their eyes. No show or movie can give your that experience.
One slight gripe... in the game he fell on the spike and had to be pulled out from it since he had no choice... in the show I'm... not really sure why he pulled it out there and then. Best to have waited or... maybe they could have had it so as he retreated on the horse it fell off?
He was going to be riding on a horse, bucking up and down. Leaving it inside would have scrambled his guts - this is probably the only time it would have been acceptable to remove it lol.
@@morty7705 story aside, they could hide somewhere at the uni and got him patched up, not ride anywhere. There was some medical equipment, so it would be reasonable to do so. At least would make more sense than pull it out and risk bleeding out.
@Rocka then why the hell are you on a RUclips page which involves a screen to do so on a channel which is based off everything that involves screens? A
Yeah that really threw me off, thought they were going to start shifting round the timeline this episode but had forgotten how different Jackson looks in the first game
@@Scorpio-- it isnt a prop. it was confirmed to be the real horse its just trained really well. u can also see the head and ears slightly moving if u watch carefully
@@gigazilla1118People watching on their small phones have only themselves to blame. All the small intricate detalils are totally missed. A show like this demands a big screen.
There's no need for overrating a certain form of art. What we need to consider is looking this adaptation through its current form and how it incorporated the transferable artistic aspect of the former medium to the newest one, just my opinion.
@@Zakethehero comparison videos like this one encourage opposing dialogue to come together and express different opinions. Nothing wrong with polarizing critiques. Don’t be that guy
Know they can't put everything from the game into the show but does feel very hurried at times. Funny they made the effort to have some actors look very similar to their game counterparts and others look nothing like them.
@@berang2mobatv We don't need the games to have great stories. We need them to be true to what made the games successful like the horror, the corniness and the characters
disappointed by this episode tbh, wasn't a fan of the changes to Joel's dialogue in the bedroom scene. in general the scene is more powerful in the game
Zombies are like an afterthought in the show, not to mention how they keep changing characters around and their entire story from what it was in the game that make the show bland in comparison.
Well, (and as someone that does not like the show nearly as much as the game) the game was not about the "zombies" either. The infected are just an interesting way to explain why humans are put into that situation, and it helps for variety in gameplay.
@@mrchiledonut The game literally about a thug who escorts girl who has a the vaccine for the whole outbreak in her and he selfishly takes her in as his daughter lol The show feels rushed cause they are trying to fit 12 chapters of the game and a DLC into 9 episodes. Why not just make it 13 episodes?
@@justsomegirlwithoutamustache there's only one reason.. To push more diversity for the sake of it, imagine being a black actor and getting cast because of the colour of your skin..
Why not? The casting department probably felt the actress was the best available actress fit for the role. Remember, this is a TV show intended to be enjoyed/consumed not only by fans of TLOU video game, but also lots of viewers who never played (or had even heard about) the video game.
I'll send profane-free thoughts and prayers to whoever is able to explain to me why profanity is being censored in a video covering a show that is (strangely enough) more brutal than the use of words relating to reproduction and digestion.
@@akashambrose You know that the actors in the series fake emotions exactly the same way the mo-cap actors did in the game? Only Ashley Johnson did a better job in showing emotion in her voice than Bella, especially in the bedroom scene.
Was hoping they would've had, "You are treading on some mighty thin ice." in the show
Same 😂😂😂
same!
Yeah, for some reason, Joe is a lot less southern in the show💀💀💀
Somehow Pedro's "No" is way more powerful while being just one word. The rest is done with his face.
YEAAAAH but tbf you cant beat Bakers delivery so that remains untouched
It's cool the way Gabriel Luna managed to do his own take on Tommy while still resembling Tommy so much it's uncanny.
And he actually passes as white, didn't look like that when they originally revealed the casting choices.
@@imwinningthisone7613 ok but why does that matter?
@@djbernadotte9768 because Tommy is a white character. Ethnicity wise it's still incorrect because the Miller brothers are canonically Germanic and not Mediterranean
@@imwinningthisone7613 ok bro, ok
@@imwinningthisone7613 This is one of those instances where ethnicity really doesn't matter
The best thing about this episode was that they used exactly the same song/tune omg, it was great!
Exactly, the thing that they took exactly from the game is the best part of the episode. Wish they would feature more of the music in the show.
As great as the TV show is and generally have been very pleased and extremely surprised! It has also made me even more certain that the game is one of the greatest masterpieces ever created!
The actor for Tommy is damn amazing, his face tells you everything while saying not much. Perfect casting, can't wait to see him in Season 2.
They might replace him with Terry Crews bro😂
@@astrothundert19 He was great in Expendables 2 or 3, I won't be mad at this.
Played an amazing Ghost Rider in Agents of Shield as well
@@blitz1904 the guy that played Tommy also played the rev-9 terminator in terminator dark fate
in season 2?? uhmmm, about that 😅😅🥲🤐
dude the actor who plays tommy in the show MY LORD HE SOUNDS JUSY LIKE THE GAME like spot on
Fun fact, the voice actor for game Tommy was in the HBO show as Percy, the guy who had his head ripped off in episode 5 by the Bloater
Troy baker is in the show as James for an episode.
@@crackerjackrappr what episode?
@@rainfall2880 We don't know, it hasn't aired yet ;-)
@@rainfall2880 8
If only The Witcher handled by HBO 😢
The Witcher on Netflix is great.
@@dan5k87 1st Season was Great. NGL.
@@AvinashPawar_CGlighter Yes, but season 2 was a clusterfuck.
@@dan5k87 only the 1st season
@@dan5k87 not anymore since Cavill left.
Can’t deny that remake looks amazing. You can really see the details in their expressions.
still alot of them said that the OG is better, lol
@@riradd92 them?
@@riradd92 those are just the typical Nostalgia fucktards, probably saying that Tobey’s interpretation of Spider-Man is the best only because he was their childhood and nothing else🙄🙄
@@bjrales you got the point
@@salforever1174 Them = The Planet Earth
Still prefer the game for the bedroom scene
same, more emotion
Yeah, great episode overall, but moments like that are just magic that were always gonna be hard to recreate
Henry in the show was way better however
Joel's monologue, though.
It was incredible, really important for the story, and there's nothing quite like it in the game.
Say what you will, but the production designers and location scouts did their thing.
This Episode was fantastic.
No it was not. It was Druckman (the director if you didnt know) atoning for his SINS for his straight white maleness.
@@saturnlight7985 Why r u talking about r44ce black boy?
@@saturnlight7985 Just shut up and be grateful already.
@@saturnlight7985 get a life.
@@saturnlight7985 WTH? 🤨 It’s practically a shot-for-shot from the game till Joel’s injury
The fact that the director did not want the actors to play the game and yet they still deliver an amazing performance blows my mind
almost like actors know how to act.
amazing
Lol! Never been more bored ! What performance? It’s crap compared to the game.
@@AlbertVicol the fact that no one here agrees with you says it all
@@AlbertVicol lol cry more.
if they had played the game this show would have been much better.
Great episode but honestly expected a bit more action on the Uni part.
Same, but realistically they haven’t tried to adapt much of the game play into the show, so it’s been constant. Plus Joel’s fall is unrealistic for real world physics.
Huge budget cuts, probably saving for last episode
Same
@@thebomb1393 how is it unrealistic? Srs question
@@firemaxo No one can survive that fall irl lol
Personally find myself loving the show representation more than the game. Either way, it’s fine to like what you like. No need for all the negativity, this is the best adaptation of a game ever and people are still complaining.
The production designers and location scouts did their thing.
Exactly
People love to complain to make themselves feel better
You need to watch arcane. Absolutely the best thing i've ever watched
elitists will be elitist
I’ve not played the game, so this is just brilliant all round.
if you make side-to-side comparisons please give a sound icon, so people can know the sound is from a movie or game
The bedroom scene in the show felt too rushed. Didn’t feel emotional enough considering in the game it’s one of the biggest moments in my opinion
Only wish the series was longer tbh
Now I’m very certain that nothing can beat video games. Video games can give you something that you can’t get anywhere else.
You become more connected to the characters. It's like walking in their shoes, seeing the world from their eyes. No show or movie can give your that experience.
@@Bellas61 Exactly.
Don't get me wrong, Pedro & Bella are doing great...but Troy & Ashley cannot and will not be outdone.
They just did! That's why the show is top tier
Yeah the show is barely coming close to their facial expressions in game.
i've played the game dozen of times and now it's all about the goosebumps.
was hoping they would say the line "You are treading on some mighty thin ice here"
One slight gripe... in the game he fell on the spike and had to be pulled out from it since he had no choice... in the show I'm... not really sure why he pulled it out there and then. Best to have waited or... maybe they could have had it so as he retreated on the horse it fell off?
We were screaming at him not to pull it out!
He was going to be riding on a horse, bucking up and down. Leaving it inside would have scrambled his guts - this is probably the only time it would have been acceptable to remove it lol.
@@morty7705 Fair enough.
@@morty7705good point
@@morty7705 story aside, they could hide somewhere at the uni and got him patched up, not ride anywhere. There was some medical equipment, so it would be reasonable to do so. At least would make more sense than pull it out and risk bleeding out.
The characters in the game will always be superior🐐🤟🏻.
Agreed
that bedroom scene game version was way too emotional than the tv version, just sayin
Finally someone said it, been staying away from saying it as the Bella stans will whine.
They took away the physicality of both performances.
@@Frankcohle exactly
But Joel's monologue in the show was much much better.... Pedro is a genius actor !
@@ryancarling123 She's just a kid and very talented.
The scene of the discussion in the bedroom managed to move me. 🦊🎤🤘🏻🏳⚧🏳🌈🇧🇷
Another great episode!
The actors in the game actually does better at some scenes. Amazing!
Yeah the casitng for tommy wasnt right
Acting of most the scenes was better in the game...just sayin
@@MACAstroGuitaristyup agreed
@@MACAstroGuitarist No the actors in the show are very talented.
Tommy and Joels reunion was almost like Sansa and Jon's reunion.
3:13 Scene was so much better in the game 🔥
This just makes me realize how truly unmatchable Ashley’s performance is.
Why would you say something so controversial yet so brave?
Bella exceeds Ashley in some scenes (Henry's death) and Asley stays the best in others. Both are delivering an incredible performance.
lol some of you are insane.
@@BlackParade01 same on David's death scene. Bella did it quite better
They both were outstanding.
Next episode will based on the Left Behind DLC
A little on the nose with the title of the ep literally being left behind lmao
At least it will be more relevant to the show than episode 3
Yea, the game is still the best option to experience this.
Finally someone with sense.
Sure, but not everyone plays games, so it's nice this exists for them.
And so? Who asking you?
@Rocka yer those same people are still sat in the same place staring at a tv which is doing the same thing in the same spot
@Rocka then why the hell are you on a RUclips page which involves a screen to do so on a channel which is based off everything that involves screens? A
The Jackson Town was inspired by the Last of Us PT2
Yeah that really threw me off, thought they were going to start shifting round the timeline this episode but had forgotten how different Jackson looks in the first game
@@pendodigy well, we never went inside the settlement in the first game, we just visited the Dam and saw the settlement from a distance.
Inspired? They fleshed the story out more. And they cant be inspired cause the same writer/director is working on this show too
Bedroom scene was Awesome in show! They killed it!
The last scene of the episode, the frozen horse on the train tracks took me out of the moment
Really? lmao
its a prop
Yea thought it looked weird lmao
@@Scorpio-- it isnt a prop. it was confirmed to be the real horse its just trained really well. u can also see the head and ears slightly moving if u watch carefully
@@gigazilla1118People watching on their small phones have only themselves to blame. All the small intricate detalils are totally missed. A show like this demands a big screen.
This series is really setting in stone how The game is just better and a denser artform and medium
And full of filler content and contradictions between story and gameplay...
@@TheGoncas2 you mean the sequel game. Fixed it for you
@@krazygreekguy nope, both games. Most narrative games, in fact.
Say what you will, but the production designers and location scouts did their thing.
Cannot disagree with you more for this moronic comment
This was amazing
2:56 Bella's accent slipping out on that "everybody" lol
It slips a lot in many scenes.
most of these brits play mediocre american accents. sam worthington in avatar is lol
@@jeremyburgos6507 Sam is an Aussie.
Ya missed the parts about them talking about how football works 🏈
what a fantastic series with 2 fantastic protagonists
They changed a few things. But it still worked
Bella nailed this episode - quality acting
😂😂😂
@@juleswinnfield1246 What's funny?
There's no need for overrating a certain form of art. What we need to consider is looking this adaptation through its current form and how it incorporated the transferable artistic aspect of the former medium to the newest one, just my opinion.
English please
@@dan5k87hahahahaha
holy moly this level of english
What?
is there the “jesus BOY” in the tv show?
The tv show version is tough keep it coming 🔥🔥💯
Game is way better and has more emotion!
It's not that much better
Animations can’t give you the same emotions real humans can.
Say what you will, but the production designers and location scouts did their thing.
Or... we can all just stop arguing which is better and just enjoy both?
Game feels better because we attached to it for hours and experienced every scene ourself, but if it is made into tv show that is the best we got.
@@Zakethehero comparison videos like this one encourage opposing dialogue to come together and express different opinions. Nothing wrong with polarizing critiques. Don’t be that guy
her accent definitely slipped when she said "I'm not her you know" lol
HBO Need to to the RDR SHOW.
Know they can't put everything from the game into the show but does feel very hurried at times. Funny they made the effort to have some actors look very similar to their game counterparts and others look nothing like them.
Maria 😡
Pascal rating as an actor out of 10 ?
My 10000000/10
The episode and pascal is fantastic
Estava esperando por esse video.. obrigada 😃
Imo, the reunion of the brothers was better in the game. Plus those note strings made it more emotional and wholesome
Resident evil can learn a lot from this whenever they decide they want to remake another series of movie from their franchise.
Resident Evil needs to be handled by HBO
Nah, RE games weren't known as games with great stories. That's why they failed the movies
@@berang2mobatv We don't need the games to have great stories. We need them to be true to what made the games successful like the horror, the corniness and the characters
@@sheriffsaliu9872 so terrible writing and acting mixed with inventory management?
Resident Evil has always been cheesy nonsense, no way would HBO have any interest
Game version has more emotions...
sorry, but the game still superior experience
Nobody wants your apology bro
@@charlieparklaws I'll accept his apology
Why did you even bother commenting you game nerd
The game is better, true, but my Dad (non Gamer) loves it, so win-win to all..
of course its a better experience, its interactive.
Amazing accurate episode.
Despite all its similarities, what reminds me of the game while watching the show is always the enemy shouting in the background: "mother*ker!"
The tv show felt forced and there was no emotion. Definitely prefer the game.
No emption? What have you been watching?
Que brutal! Love it!
disappointed by this episode tbh, wasn't a fan of the changes to Joel's dialogue in the bedroom scene. in general the scene is more powerful in the game
definitely gives awards to the actor that plays tommy very accurate and great job.
The actor looked nothing like the Tommy in the game, until he gets the mustache. It's Tommy!
Game voices way better than show
Because the characters are played by different actors from the game
People like u don't deserve nothing
Stop complaining unless you can do better...🤷...
@@darkmoon0219 stop riding
It's almost as if different voices come out of different human beings.
im still wondering if they have anything agains blondes , since every major blonde in the game are black
Yeah, it pisses me off
Cant wait to see the next episode cause shiz is about to go down
Druckman is a great storyteller - the show deviates from the game perfectly, and gut-wrenchingly
Brilliant episode !
Sem palavras cara, apenas sensacional
sopa do macaco
@@Yodoneitor99 já tomou uma ?
I'm going to say this
The last of us might be the best show of all time for sure top 3
Yikes
Perfect adaption
I'm not crying. YOU are crying!
Zombies are like an afterthought in the show, not to mention how they keep changing characters around and their entire story from what it was in the game that make the show bland in comparison.
Well, (and as someone that does not like the show nearly as much as the game) the game was not about the "zombies" either. The infected are just an interesting way to explain why humans are put into that situation, and it helps for variety in gameplay.
@@mrchiledonut The game literally about a thug who escorts girl who has a the vaccine for the whole outbreak in her and he selfishly takes her in as his daughter lol
The show feels rushed cause they are trying to fit 12 chapters of the game and a DLC into 9 episodes. Why not just make it 13 episodes?
@@petermj1098notice how your sentence only mentioned infected as the reason for why they’re put in that situation lol
Bella's performance in the bedroom scene was excellent.
Lol! Was crap! Even a 3d motion capture had better acting that her lol
She's been absolutely phenomenal
@@IAmABoss2 absolutely horrible
@@juleswinnfield1246 Quit whining.
@@IAmABoss2she's average at best to be fair
YOU ARE ON MIGHTY THIN ICE
They should of kept that in the show
Why they turn maria black in the series? Like why?
Really not that big of a deal.
@@ayespenzo358 But we all know people would be singing a different tune if Henry and Sam were race swapped.
The double standards is painful.
@@ayespenzo358 Sure it's not the end of the world, but what was the reason? And like the above comment stated, it's a double standard
@@justsomegirlwithoutamustache there's only one reason.. To push more diversity for the sake of it, imagine being a black actor and getting cast because of the colour of your skin..
Why not? The casting department probably felt the actress was the best available actress fit for the role.
Remember, this is a TV show intended to be enjoyed/consumed not only by fans of TLOU video game, but also lots of viewers who never played (or had even heard about) the video game.
I'll send profane-free thoughts and prayers to whoever is able to explain to me why profanity is being censored in a video covering a show that is (strangely enough) more brutal than the use of words relating to reproduction and digestion.
It allows them to get more views and likes
Girl in the game much better person .
Came for the might thin ice, left disappointed :(
they have change alot of things
Bravo Neil, bravo!
Damn it hurts right in the meow meow
Me too right here in the woof woof
Me too right here in the Roar Roar
show is better than the game, storywise. dialogue is tighter, characters have more nuance, the drama is more heartfelt.
Ew no
Either none of your senses work, or you’ve never played the game
Pov you actually follow the source material
lol the game character shows more emotion than the real life movie, imagine
Fake emotion vs real emotion
Facts and all these bots is saying it’s better than the game. I’m like you must’ve forgot how great the game was.
@@akashambrose You know that the actors in the series fake emotions exactly the same way the mo-cap actors did in the game? Only Ashley Johnson did a better job in showing emotion in her voice than Bella, especially in the bedroom scene.
The actors are all super talented. Calm down edgelord.
thumbnail has a spoiler guys. wtf.
Every man think that their burden is the heaviest
Can’t just be me who’s noticed that Joels has been made deeper in this video
Why so much less action and infected :( ?
The show is centered around people, love, relationships. That is the theme, presence of infected is the setting
Infected don’t talk or rarely progress the plot
@@SourFilms so it’s terrible
@@callmemarvel298bruh this is supposed to be about survival not some love themed thriller
@@xx1its___me1xx13 Yes it is about survival. The show is about that too.
Only im swe a difrent on Tommy wife ?🤔🤷♂️
why censoring the dirty-words? Weird...
Tommy looks weird and goofy, like cartoonish Luigi
Hadn’t seen the show but based on the thumbnail the actors look too clean… wtf is that
because they took a shower in jackson town??
another awesome episode
"Deciding which Schirt goes with which Shkirt"
Yes, that’s called an accent.
perfection.
everything was done better in the game lol
Oh stop whinnying.
@@waymilky442 it’s commentary, you stop whining about my whining moron
There's nothing to compare, they changed just about everything lol
No they didn't. Literally the same. Stop whinnying.
Not accurate enough, theres a pimple on Tommys face which doesnt match the game. They botched this adaption big time
The game had far better action scenes. No money for stuntman? Jesus.