Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RUclips channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ruclips.net/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
in 45-46 election more than 90 % ( approx) of mmoslim constituency voted for m. league still no popul. xchange took place, congress is a gaaddar party....
It's common sense... Look around!!! Infra building at good pace, companies eager to invest even in UP, Defence acquiring some decent weaponry, Pak made to squabble. Anyone still want to get back to UPA???
Credit cannot be just given to current government alone. It was Jawaharlal Nehru, who initiated the developmental path, whereas initial governments in Pakistan may have failed to do that work. Also , all the governments further have worked towards development. Pakistan's failure is also an example for taking terrorism in hand in the name of religion. India had never taken such a stand right from Independence and should not take that in future also. The current Government should keep that in mind. It's true that the current government has made the world to look upon India. But Is it transparent ? We do not know.... As Shekar Gupta said , if you are patriotic, You should not hesitate to raise voice against detrimental ideologies. If you are living in a BJP ruled state , everything may look fine. But most of the NON-BJP ruled states are suppressed by the government and not allowing the democratically selected government to act properly. Positioning India in front of the world is fine .... if your fundas are strong right back in your country.... Statistics are not transparent in this government. We people should be always alert and keep questioning instead of idol worship....!! Do not get into idol worship of any politician.
Only if he has full majority. Remember Hindus have no gratitude. Opposition still gets 45 percent vote from Hindus. We are not like Muslims. India needs a Hindu vote bank but impossible due to ingratitude
We finally have a Hindu pm with Hindu backbone. How many of us appreciate him? We make statements like question politician, do not idol worship politicians etc. when do these people learn that idol worship now will accelerate progress. Doubting thomases will hinder god given opportunities through someone like Modiji.
There are 52 Muslim countries. There are over 100 Christian countries. Hindus only have this one….Bharat. So in my opinion hindhutva is not only necessary but essential for our thousands of year old civilization.
Nepal, Mauritius have Hindu majority too. Besides as time is progressing religion effects on society is drastically decreasing. if you will just look back 50 years back, religion had much much more effect on society. 50 years in the future religion will lose its relevance even more.
@@PK-tt5kk for the west religion is declining but eastern and middle eastern are still very religious. Look at what happened to the Jewish people in Germany when they didn’t have their own country. Nepal and Mauritius are too small to hold all the Hindus if they’re ever persecuted.
@@PK-tt5kk Can you fit billion Hindus in Nepal and Mauritius? Don't live under a rock and think religion is not relevant. Besides Eastern religions are infinitely far more better than middle eastern cults.
@@patelaakash267 Israel is formally a secular democracy where Judaism is privileged. It doesn't have an official state religion. Most Indians talking of Israeli example are unaware of this. And they think Israel is a theocratic Jew country, and that is their vision for India as well with Hindu State. Also, Jewish people in Germany and Europe were in minority vis-a-vis Christians when that persecution happened. Therefore a similar comparison for Hindus in India is not possible (being a majority population). Homelands based on religion is an idea of Abrahamic faiths who at their heart are all about 'centralized' existence with One God, One Book, One this and that. Over centuries, they've all realised that such restrictive principle of non-diverse centralized worship and Statehood doesn't yield much. In it, the social structure and then the State becomes power-centric around religion and tends to handover everything including economic governance as a matter to be interpreted and vetted through a religious prism. That is where downfall besets.. eg: Islam comes in conflict with capitalist interest based banking system, Christianity came in conflict with technology that challenged biblical beliefs, Orthodox Jews are in conflict with the theory evolution etc. That's why religion lost its relevance in Europe and even the Jewish state is so far able to be itself because in a historical timeline their persecution in Germany is still recent (75yrs back). Even then, it is already visible that the Statehood in Israel is overall detaching from religious identity. There isn't any such persecution parallel in India for Hindus, and thankfully so, in the recent history of at least 300years (post-death of Aurangzeb). It is therefore irrelevant to call for a Hindu state today, all the worse by citing the so-called 56 Islamic countries - none of which have any wish to take in other Muslims and none of which have known religious freedom and diverse cultural living. India has no parallel with of all these Abrahamic faiths' stinging issues. Therefore its a flawed logic to try and base the future Statehood of a strong and prosperous society and economy like India, on any religion.
@@denizoran every example you gave is based in your confirmation bias. Throughout history any religious group or culture that didn’t have its own land and geography has had to face threats of invasions from outside and inside. Irregardless of what the white countries did or are doing the Hindu community has had hundreds of years of oppression and the best way to avoid that again is having their own land.
India, USA and yes unfortunately CCP China. Rooting for India, a strong India I believe means a more peaceful world...as an American, also looking into ways to invest in equities from India or strong ties with India. Betting on you guys long term 👍🇮🇳🇮🇳🇺🇲
Gain India's trust, no country will regret in the long term. Right now India's focus is getting rid of poverty. Geopolitically, India's stated position is a that India wants a multipolar world where all the major powers has atleast a working relationship. So, India ever grows like China (which is very likely) it won't follow a hegemonic policy competing with existing powers. We will find our space but not at the expense of others unlike china who aspire to dethrone US.
Here is what a common Indian thinks: We may never recover Pakistan occupied Kashmir or the Northern Territories of Gilgit and Baltistan, but that is perfectly okay. We will Keep POK on our Maps for now and wait for a century or two. Afterall, we are a civilisation and we need to measure time in hundreds of centuries.
If Pakistan knew Bin Laden was hiding there then it’s a rouge state and if Pakistan didn’t know Bin Laden was hiding there then it’s a failed state.😂😂 -Unknown
Such a fantastic content, true meaning of patriotism doesn't mean one should praise only but to hold mirror.Our intellectuals are also trying to do the same thing like shahzad . Thankyou for bringing such nice content. I wish good health for you Sir.
Hi Shekar - great content, and thanks for sharing your observations from Pakistan's press! However, the de-hyphenation will not be complete until we stop celebrating Pak's downfall. There is no need to compare with Pak. With significantly more natural resources, bigger size, bigger population etc we should have grown significantly more, and we still lag behind China - which is a more appropriate comparison.
This is not a comparison with Pakistan, but analysis on deteriorating relationship. With respect to china, yes we lag behind financially but far better off in terms of morality and international trust !!
Finally a sensible person off all dimwits who started to compare to already a failed state...it's like US comparing to Mexico...our guys also effing it up on many levels especially social issues and we always can't be China downfall is our fortune in future...thats not a good strategy!
Why should we really bother ? The answer lies in the fact that Pakistan will ensure that fall out comes to India also . We have to ensure that it should not happen that way . My analysis . ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
Bigger population and more diversity was always the issue due to which our progress was slow. We have succeeded despite that. But yes China should be our target rn and you're completely right there
You see the problem with a left leaning journalist like Shekhar is that even though they desperately try to hide the frustrated leftist in them, it sort of seeps out. And whenever it does, it as always is never in their own country's benifit , unfortunately. It eerely resembles how the left media here in the West as well deals with similar issues. Maybe that's why i sensed his BS fairly quickly. In this video for instance which is supposedly made in praise of India and how it under Modi(clearly not his most favorite guy to hold the highest office in government) has done a better job at the international front compared to Pakistan. He starts off his analysis by mentioning how India played its cards well on the Russia-Ukraine conflict and how it has favoured India's economy. Now here instead of keeping it simple enough ,the implicit understanding of how Russia "the established villain internationally" benefits highly from such an arrangement he sees the necessity to mention it not once but twice and beyond just that, he strategically placed those observations in his opening statement at the very beginning of the video so that when someone like me who resides in the West( or anyone curious and unbiased for that matter) decide to check out such an analysis, those statements pop out and establish an initial impression of India as an entity that helps the bad guy in war. Being well aware of how important the initial statements are to set the tone of an article, This is a classic move that all of these experienced left leaning journalists make when they have to deal with a situation where the country that they represent does well under a policy and a government that they can never accept. Given i sensed this, i checked Shekar's background and his past analysis on India's stand on the issue and well and behold i was on point. It's time intelligent Indians see through the subtle BS propaganda these leftist media cells propagate and call them out for who they really are.
You are quite spot on Joanna, about a month ago, An American sociologist called Salvatore Babones attended the India today conclave. He quite literally exposed the left-liberal gang. As to how in the pursuit of hating Modi, the so-called intellectual class has become anti-india. Shekhar Gupta and his leftist pseudo liberals gang took it so much to heart and he even ran a whole episode of cut the clutter.
Pakistan topic still gets viewership as compared to Sri Lanka, Nepal, Bangladesh and Myanmar! Wish we could turn that aspect also into a footnote. We are hostage of our own minds. India could become a truly a modern democracy and stupid religious polarisation will end - if we just did not talk of Pakistan and “Ummah”. It provokes reactionary forces in India. Evil brings out evil in us.
Rightly pointed out ... I have been pondering over that aspect of Indo-Pak relations for quiet some time. The rise of right wing politics in India has also something to do with those frequent acerbic episodes with Pakistan.Time to retreat back from that mindset and believe me we are right on that track.
World is not that idealist . Of course , Pakistan has lost relevance for India but not its stupidity . Rest assure ..Imran khan will come back and ensure that Pakistan suffers ? ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
Totally agree with you Shekhar, we definitely need to change the dominant ideology of the country... And that is the leftist-marxist ideology. They can't seem to have one decent conversation that differs from their 'opinion'. You just can't debate them without being called 'bhakt', 'sanghi', 'saffron terrorists ', 'Godi media', 'uneducated right wingers' etc etc. So yes, we definitely must challenge the dominant ideology of the left and west which is eating away India.
It's not as if the many of the epithets of the right are a source of much joy. Marxist views certainly have their flaws. One of them might be the way they have distorted the essentially nationalistic approach of leaders such as Pt. Nehru.
What Shekhar Gupta like many other like-minded, self-styled seculars refuse to admit is that HInduism is the cement that holds India together. When you are imbibed with an ideology from birth of "live and let live", "people are the same everywhere", "my religion is not the ", "God manifests himself in multiple ways", etc, all of which promote diversity in thought and a more than expressed willingness to accept the other man as he is instead of wanting to convert him to your religion, to speak your language, wear your kind of clothes or eat the food you eat, then you know what the meaning of coexistence is. Despite all the differences found in India, the fact that the practising Hindu accepts others' differences as minor details is why India is one and progresses as one. The real reason is Hindu thought, our Sanatana Dharma.
So , what should be done ...Change the political system or be more efficient in existing system ? Do you expect that democracy will be unlike democracy ? ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
It is because China is a police state/ dictatorship. China is also corrupt. India will shine without corruption but it will not reach China. China is ahead and is 3 times as big as India.
There's no point or rationale for an average Indian or India as a whole to celebrate our hostile neighbour's downfall. On the contrary we need to increase our focus on our own development and protect our interests in the global arena keeping in mind our ambition to become a super power. More attention to the weak areas amd work on them. The World is going through a serious phase of crisis,say economic ,political or environmental crisis. We are standing on a tremendously volatile juncture. Our present decisions will decide and shape our trajectory for years to come. Like a wiser person learns from the mistakes of others , India needs to learn in the same line from the economic crisis in our neighborhood, first in Srilanka and now in Pakistan and act preemptively. As the saying goes, "To make one's 'line' appear longer than the other's, one needs to draw a bigger line instead of erasing the other's line". That has been and should remain the collective effort of all indians and India, among other things. Simply celebrating at enemy's failure won't contribute anything to one's growth and prosperity. Words and actions resulting from mere blind Jingoism has not served and will never serve any purpose.
Yes I agree, we cannot get POK back unless Pakistan collapses and itself comes back to India. Which most Indians will agree we donot want it. We donot want radicalised population of Pakistan. No Pakistan splintering will not bring back POK. Infact it will make China's case better. Then can maneuver POk to be independent and make that govt client state like Laos, Pakistan etc
Pakistan is such a compelling subject that you can not avoid, and you picked one sense over a million nonsense. Kudos to you . Is this the start of the programs अमन की आशा and Jashn E Riwaz roll out ?
This is like when our parents say, "Sharmaji ka ladka top Kiya, doctor ban gaya and Tum Yaha RUclips Dekhte reh gaye " Won't be surprised if Shahzad Chaudhry joins Pakistan politics soon and fight for highest chair
@@ppadiya I am surprised that you are unaware about 'Project Imran' and how he was launched by the establishment to the exclusion of all mainstream parties. It was in the making for more than a decade.
So, what we have to do? Send billions to Pak to prevent it from collapse?? Or handover Kashmir to them because of fear that they might use Nukes? As the person above my comment said, if we r afraid of enemies losing then we should lose to them...
Agree a poor failing neighbour is not good for india it will always be a security threat. Example Singapore invest a lot in its neighbourhood to prevent it and we welcome workers from neighbouring country which help build trust and ties.
Shekhar ji has gone nuts i guess shahzad Chowdary just wrote this as a gut feeling musings. We should not go gung ho and celebrate by jumping in air because of this praise
I cant believe that Shekargi is praising so much to a pakistani retired airfirce officer for nearly 9 minutes. In one sentence he applauded PM who brought the country foreign reserve to 600 billion in 8 years.
Mr gupta your attempt at trying to be a serious journalist is most appreciated! Still in the end your old Congressman loyalty does shine through in the opinions that you hold ! News need not be opinionated!
Nice article and video. The singular action that will save Pakistan is too drop all sanctions on Indian goods unconditionally. Trade with India and tariff free access to all Indian goods is the only salvation for Pakistan, not IMF bailouts.
Haha. Good one. Only they can't pay and our trading community isn't expected to do charity to them. Forget Pakistan, or their salvation. Not India's problem or duty. It is however our sworn duty to make sure of our own security - and if that means paying them back in their own coin - and doing whatever is needed in splintering Pakistan and China (yes both continually trying it since 75 years) then so be it. India should strengthen itself and pay these evil nations back. We shouldn't be in debt to any one - not even in karma. Karma works but it does need its karmi - India can be so.
Excellent one by Shekhar, On a foot note :) , the number of "cut the clutters on pakistan" in the last 12 months is simpl overwhelming and undeserving, it it because of some Punjabi love ? :)
its our neighbor whose population may rise to 400M within a decade or 2. Pak is in pretty bad shape but if it get its act right can become a very powerful country.
Relevance is not an attribute. What India has is a functioning democracy. Two countries created together and while one struggles to maintain a democratic system, the other struggles to maintain a military dictatorship.
Mr Gupta, please do a follow on of this cut the clutter episode enlightening your viewers about the gap between India and China, whether India-China gap can be bridged? And if so, how? And by when?
He already did please check…We Indians know our weakness…because we have South Indians are the most analytical minded unlike Punjabis who are emotional and animalistic
I am a Pakistani, British, Canadian (despite being in the west), i do sincerely hope india and China settle their disputes, likely chances are that may help to let pakistan and india solve their conflict. I personally think conflict reolution between India and china would be a great game changer and would be the actual indicator where we can say that it is the century for the east. Hopefully we see it in our life time.
India-China dispute can only be solved when India's economy is of comparable size to that of China and when China sees India as an equal. And I agree, India-Pakistan issues will be sorted only after India-China is sorted out.
Mr Shekhar Gupta, it’s nice to see you on the right of Center. It’s not you who have shifted, it’s just the Center has moved too far on the left. Keep ot up, you are doing a good job which, sadly, NDTV isn’t doing.
If you don't press forward claims of your territory, Then others will start pressing claims on your territory. Many Media started showing only Indian Kashmir is reason of conflicted, not POK and Aksai chin. Never leave your claim.
Peninsula is completely India bro, which is doing quite good for now. Peninsula is a Land mass surrounded on 3 sides by water (in this case the Deccan and Southern India). The wider Subcontinent in where Pakistan comes into the picture, and let's just say with cases like Sri Lanka, Nepal and to some extent Bangladesh, things might not be so Golden after all.
India should have a look north and west policy. All countries should sign a treaty with india acknowledging Tibet and POK, and Gillgit baltistan are integral part of India.
I think it'll be very nice of you to write a book on your life sir! You have such long experience covering events for decades. It'll be very enlightening to read about your experiences.
Kashmir is a stalemate. There is no solution to it other than the prevalent status quo. Both Countries need to move forward and work on confidence building measures like cultural exchange, students exchange program, trade, sports etc. This is the only way this region can pull its people out of poverty, specially Pakistan.
13:23 What realistic? What humbleness? we'd rather have better trade with the middle east than Pakistan. A land trade route would always be very expensive considering the first two countries are Afghan and Pakistan. Iran and onwards we should renew our ties. A lot of potential there. We would rather be happy with Turkey and gang than with Pakistan. Dictatorships are outdated they should go ultimately. If any consensus is needed is with Pakistan-India-Nepal-Bangla-SriLanka. China is beyond Himalayas, It would be a grave error to bring Pakistan into the table with China-India Relationship. Please be a little more exhaustive Sir.
SG, you can disagree with the govt policies if the disagreement has merit. And in that case people will listen to you and not label you anti-national. What you and your cabal are doing is criticism of govt policies without merit. And common people can see through this. This is why they question your patriotism
India's current policy of NO WAR, NO PEACE with Pakistan may appear desirable to Nee Delhi, but it is not sustainable. An unstable and impoverished Pak is a greater and much more severe threat than a politically stable and reasonably solvent one. Indian planners must engage in a policy targeted to limit and maintain Pakistan's current situation in a way that it neither gets worse nor gets better. Sounds heartless and vicious but inevitably that would be the only option for New Delhi. They neither want a rich Pakistan nor an impoverished one.
Great analysis. Just one suggestion - Indians still claiming to get back Aksai Chin in future is not the same as Pak getting back J&K. They are not the same due to different circumstances of India and Pak at present.
Comparing with Pak all the time is like flogging a dead horse. Waste of TIME! Need to compare India now to China to catch up with them or we will be far more behind China.
We respect india and question government also and appreciate when required. Problem with opposition they converted hate towards modi to hate towards government and india,Any one hating or bashing India wont be spared by commoner. Many times these party's blame entire nation and religion for wrong instances which we condemn too , but when a common man was attacked or a solider attacked none of these party's bother. They want votes of specific group only , thats what hitting the opposition.
@@gyanibrown3638 iindians r the one of dumbest people in the world for example in 45' 46' election more than 90% mmoslim constituency voted for m. league still this dumb iindian people didnot do popul. xchange ... bbloody iidiots
India should be diplomatic with Pak and take the lessons learnt in the past and continue the current run and focus on the global goal which is more important than a tiny Neighboring country which is now reeling with the terror they schooled. If it falls ..just help when needed .
Why are we celebrating downfall of Pakistan, is it to get more views? I would like to say, I support your journalism but this seems a negative one, daily you post one content where you talk about the gap between India and Pakistan. Let's make India number 1 not by comparing to who is behind but who is ahead and how can we go ahead of them. Let's discuss those policies.
A jo column likha hai ,ho skta hai pakistan main ya turkey ke writer ne likha hai main is pain bhi yakeen krta, lakin agr koi bole ki ye "shekhar Gupta" ne likha hai to mujhe kabhi yakeen nahi hota. Shame on u shekhar Gupta.
Most jinjoistic military experts also will agree that getting PoK back on current status is impossible The problem here is lack of objectivity from Indian intellectuals
What he doesn't represent 1.4 billion people Also he is explaining an article by a pakistani so It shows Pakistan's obsession with india continues You gotta get your mindset checked🤕
@SG and @print I remember you had one more video which says to leave PAK to itself. I don't agree. I think it's highly needed to support Pakistan and take them away from china. It might be cruel to say this I think it would be a historic victory of the Indian government (both BJP and the next government (if any)) to think of bringing Pakistan towards India. I believe both Indians and pak need to get over their obsession with POK or Indian Kashmir out may be kept to the next generations. and try to pull pak towards India than china. I am a BJP supporter.In some of the articles, I get a feeling that your views are left-inclined. I might not agree with that. but thanks for your information
Previously Pakistan was happy has India was also bad and equally useless. But after Modi came things are changing for India in a big way and now India looks like a Super power .As pakistan follows India in every way they want to change their course will it happen.
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RUclips channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ruclips.net/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
in 45-46 election more than 90 % ( approx) of mmoslim constituency voted for m. league still no popul. xchange took place, congress is a gaaddar party....
Islamists destroyed each and every thing not just ancient temples, structures but united india also
Sudan also
Kashmir also
Afghanistan also
Modi ji is direly needed for India as PM for 2024 also. This certainly makes a lot of difference in positioning India in the world and development
True
It's common sense...
Look around!!! Infra building at good pace, companies eager to invest even in UP, Defence acquiring some decent weaponry, Pak made to squabble.
Anyone still want to get back to UPA???
Credit cannot be just given to current government alone. It was Jawaharlal Nehru, who initiated the developmental path, whereas initial governments in Pakistan may have failed to do that work. Also , all the governments further have worked towards development.
Pakistan's failure is also an example for taking terrorism in hand in the name of religion. India had never taken such a stand right from Independence and should not take that in future also. The current Government should keep that in mind.
It's true that the current government has made the world to look upon India. But Is it transparent ? We do not know.... As Shekar Gupta said , if you are patriotic, You should not hesitate to raise voice against detrimental ideologies. If you are living in a BJP ruled state , everything may look fine. But most of the NON-BJP ruled states are suppressed by the government and not allowing the democratically selected government to act properly.
Positioning India in front of the world is fine .... if your fundas are strong right back in your country.... Statistics are not transparent in this government. We people should be always alert and keep questioning instead of idol worship....!! Do not get into idol worship of any politician.
Only if he has full majority. Remember Hindus have no gratitude. Opposition still gets 45 percent vote from Hindus. We are not like Muslims. India needs a Hindu vote bank but impossible due to ingratitude
We finally have a Hindu pm with Hindu backbone. How many of us appreciate him? We make statements like question politician, do not idol worship politicians etc. when do these people learn that idol worship now will accelerate progress. Doubting thomases will hinder god given opportunities through someone like Modiji.
Q: *How is ISLAMIC Republic of Pakistan doing?*
A. *Failed State*
B. *Terror State*
C. *Beggar State*
D. *All of the above*
*Click like for option D.*
All of the above. Always all of the above 😂
D
D. All Of The Above
D ..
ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
More options can be added in future and still the last option will fetch good marks
There are 52 Muslim countries. There are over 100 Christian countries. Hindus only have this one….Bharat. So in my opinion hindhutva is not only necessary but essential for our thousands of year old civilization.
Nepal, Mauritius have Hindu majority too. Besides as time is progressing religion effects on society is drastically decreasing.
if you will just look back 50 years back, religion had much much more effect on society. 50 years in the future religion will lose its relevance even more.
@@PK-tt5kk for the west religion is declining but eastern and middle eastern are still very religious. Look at what happened to the Jewish people in Germany when they didn’t have their own country. Nepal and Mauritius are too small to hold all the Hindus if they’re ever persecuted.
@@PK-tt5kk Can you fit billion Hindus in Nepal and Mauritius? Don't live under a rock and think religion is not relevant. Besides Eastern religions are infinitely far more better than middle eastern cults.
@@patelaakash267 Israel is formally a secular democracy where Judaism is privileged. It doesn't have an official state religion. Most Indians talking of Israeli example are unaware of this. And they think Israel is a theocratic Jew country, and that is their vision for India as well with Hindu State. Also, Jewish people in Germany and Europe were in minority vis-a-vis Christians when that persecution happened. Therefore a similar comparison for Hindus in India is not possible (being a majority population). Homelands based on religion is an idea of Abrahamic faiths who at their heart are all about 'centralized' existence with One God, One Book, One this and that. Over centuries, they've all realised that such restrictive principle of non-diverse centralized worship and Statehood doesn't yield much. In it, the social structure and then the State becomes power-centric around religion and tends to handover everything including economic governance as a matter to be interpreted and vetted through a religious prism. That is where downfall besets.. eg: Islam comes in conflict with capitalist interest based banking system, Christianity came in conflict with technology that challenged biblical beliefs, Orthodox Jews are in conflict with the theory evolution etc. That's why religion lost its relevance in Europe and even the Jewish state is so far able to be itself because in a historical timeline their persecution in Germany is still recent (75yrs back). Even then, it is already visible that the Statehood in Israel is overall detaching from religious identity. There isn't any such persecution parallel in India for Hindus, and thankfully so, in the recent history of at least 300years (post-death of Aurangzeb). It is therefore irrelevant to call for a Hindu state today, all the worse by citing the so-called 56 Islamic countries - none of which have any wish to take in other Muslims and none of which have known religious freedom and diverse cultural living. India has no parallel with of all these Abrahamic faiths' stinging issues. Therefore its a flawed logic to try and base the future Statehood of a strong and prosperous society and economy like India, on any religion.
@@denizoran every example you gave is based in your confirmation bias. Throughout history any religious group or culture that didn’t have its own land and geography has had to face threats of invasions from outside and inside. Irregardless of what the white countries did or are doing the Hindu community has had hundreds of years of oppression and the best way to avoid that again is having their own land.
India, USA and yes unfortunately CCP China. Rooting for India, a strong India I believe means a more peaceful world...as an American, also looking into ways to invest in equities from India or strong ties with India. Betting on you guys long term 👍🇮🇳🇮🇳🇺🇲
Gain India's trust, no country will regret in the long term. Right now India's focus is getting rid of poverty. Geopolitically, India's stated position is a that India wants a multipolar world where all the major powers has atleast a working relationship. So, India ever grows like China (which is very likely) it won't follow a hegemonic policy competing with existing powers. We will find our space but not at the expense of others unlike china who aspire to dethrone US.
@@hpremjit very well put, I have taken keen interest in India and see a bright future for them...and the world if they can keep growing.👍
Yes I would bet my last dollar on India than the failed state of Pakistan or the fake state of China.
Yeah I'm sure if we feel you're our friend we'll not let you down for sure
Here is what a common Indian thinks: We may never recover Pakistan occupied Kashmir or the Northern Territories of Gilgit and Baltistan, but that is perfectly okay.
We will Keep POK on our Maps for now and wait for a century or two. Afterall, we are a civilisation and we need to measure time in hundreds of centuries.
nice try beijing
In the long term, we are all de-ad
We would recover gilgit baltistan and pok only when India’s gdp hits 10 trillion
Pakistan will disintegrate in the next decade or two
Are you actually thinking our army is not capable of doing that 🤡🤡🤡🤡 we already captured siachen and turtok about 4000sqkm of pok land
If Pakistan knew Bin Laden was hiding there then it’s a rouge state and if Pakistan didn’t know Bin Laden was hiding there then it’s a failed state.😂😂
-Unknown
That comment is by alvi surosh of vice
Michael - There is a satire -if Pakistan want to get dollars from west , it must reinvent Al Quida ...
ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
If America don't know about 9/11 then its a failed state and if they knew about the attack then it is a rogue state which kills its own citizen
Such a fantastic content, true meaning of patriotism doesn't mean one should praise only but to hold mirror.Our intellectuals are also trying to do the same thing like shahzad .
Thankyou for bringing such nice content.
I wish good health for you Sir.
Hi Shekar - great content, and thanks for sharing your observations from Pakistan's press! However, the de-hyphenation will not be complete until we stop celebrating Pak's downfall. There is no need to compare with Pak. With significantly more natural resources, bigger size, bigger population etc we should have grown significantly more, and we still lag behind China - which is a more appropriate comparison.
This is not a comparison with Pakistan, but analysis on deteriorating relationship. With respect to china, yes we lag behind financially but far better off in terms of morality and international trust !!
Finally a sensible person off all dimwits who started to compare to already a failed state...it's like US comparing to Mexico...our guys also effing it up on many levels especially social issues and we always can't be China downfall is our fortune in future...thats not a good strategy!
Sekhar does compare India with china as well.
Why should we really bother ? The answer lies in the fact that Pakistan will ensure that fall out comes to India also . We have to ensure that it should not happen that way . My analysis .
ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
Bigger population and more diversity was always the issue due to which our progress was slow. We have succeeded despite that. But yes China should be our target rn and you're completely right there
I thought i was a time traveler! Like i actually saw this before it released 😅
Me too 😅
Same here
They reupload after a twitter user correct few things.
Mee to
Same here
You see the problem with a left leaning journalist like Shekhar is that even though they desperately try to hide the frustrated leftist in them, it sort of seeps out. And whenever it does, it as always is never in their own country's benifit , unfortunately.
It eerely resembles how the left media here in the West as well deals with similar issues.
Maybe that's why i sensed his BS fairly quickly.
In this video for instance which is supposedly made in praise of India and how it under Modi(clearly not his most favorite guy to hold the highest office in government) has done a better job at the international front compared to Pakistan. He starts off his analysis by mentioning how India played its cards well on the Russia-Ukraine conflict and how it has favoured India's economy. Now here instead of keeping it simple enough ,the implicit understanding of how Russia "the established villain internationally" benefits highly from such an arrangement he sees the necessity to mention it not once but twice and beyond just that, he strategically placed those observations in his opening statement at the very beginning of the video so that when someone like me who resides in the West( or anyone curious and unbiased for that matter) decide to check out such an analysis,
those statements pop out and establish an initial impression of India as an entity that helps the bad guy in war.
Being well aware of how important the initial statements are to set the tone of an article, This is a classic move that all of these experienced left leaning journalists make when they have to deal with a situation where the country that they represent does well under a policy and a government that they can never accept.
Given i sensed this, i checked Shekar's background and his past analysis on India's stand on the issue and well and behold i was on point.
It's time intelligent Indians see through the subtle BS propaganda these leftist media cells propagate and call them out for who they really are.
We already know Shekhar’s duplicity. As and when india grows economically all these idiotic voices will get suppressed
You are quite spot on Joanna, about a month ago, An American sociologist called Salvatore Babones attended the India today conclave. He quite literally exposed the left-liberal gang. As to how in the pursuit of hating Modi, the so-called intellectual class has become anti-india. Shekhar Gupta and his leftist pseudo liberals gang took it so much to heart and he even ran a whole episode of cut the clutter.
Absolutely true Joanna. You hit the nail on the head.
Wow that's thoughtful how did u acquire this level of analysis
Shekhar keeps both sides of his bread buttered, but he only actually has a preference for one side.
Wasn't this published a few days ago? I remember watching it somewhere
Yes
Exactly my thought! I remember watching it before but cant find it in my history no more! Must've deleted and reuploaded.
Pakistan topic still gets viewership as compared to Sri Lanka, Nepal, Bangladesh and Myanmar! Wish we could turn that aspect also into a footnote. We are hostage of our own minds.
India could become a truly a modern democracy and stupid religious polarisation will end - if we just did not talk of Pakistan and “Ummah”. It provokes reactionary forces in India. Evil brings out evil in us.
Rightly pointed out ... I have been pondering over that aspect of Indo-Pak relations for quiet some time. The rise of right wing politics in India has also something to do with those frequent acerbic episodes with Pakistan.Time to retreat back from that mindset and believe me we are right on that track.
World is not that idealist . Of course , Pakistan has lost relevance for India but not its stupidity . Rest assure ..Imran khan will come back and ensure that Pakistan suffers ?
ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
Pakistan remains a topic in Indian mind because that is a cívilisational enemy because of the concept of two nation theory
Closing your senses is not gonna make your enemies disappear. You need to prepare for the worst by studying them
Yeah dude we should not talk about a hostile country on mission to bleed India by a thousand cuts.
Astonished that these are from shahzad chaudhry, equally astonished this is from Shekar Gupta..
Appreciate this
😅💯
Totally agree with you Shekhar, we definitely need to change the dominant ideology of the country... And that is the leftist-marxist ideology. They can't seem to have one decent conversation that differs from their 'opinion'. You just can't debate them without being called 'bhakt', 'sanghi', 'saffron terrorists ', 'Godi media', 'uneducated right wingers' etc etc. So yes, we definitely must challenge the dominant ideology of the left and west which is eating away India.
They’re a small minority losing relevance by the day. Best to ignore them. They’ll die their own death.
True...
It's not as if the many of the epithets of the right are a source of much joy. Marxist views certainly have their flaws. One of them might be the way they have distorted the essentially nationalistic approach of leaders such as Pt. Nehru.
What Shekhar Gupta like many other like-minded, self-styled seculars refuse to admit is that HInduism is the cement that holds India together. When you are imbibed with an ideology from birth of "live and let live", "people are the same everywhere", "my religion is not the ", "God manifests himself in multiple ways", etc, all of which promote diversity in thought and a more than expressed willingness to accept the other man as he is instead of wanting to convert him to your religion, to speak your language, wear your kind of clothes or eat the food you eat, then you know what the meaning of coexistence is. Despite all the differences found in India, the fact that the practising Hindu accepts others' differences as minor details is why India is one and progresses as one. The real reason is Hindu thought, our Sanatana Dharma.
@@Jay-gq3yk Exactly
Why repost?
I was wondering the same
@@samarthdixit3817 Ah ok, they should probably mention changes in the description box
Gap between India and China is also unbridgable unless our bureaucracy and politicians change their ways.
So , what should be done ...Change the political system or be more efficient in existing system ? Do you expect that democracy will be unlike democracy ?
ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
It is because China is a police state/ dictatorship. China is also corrupt. India will shine without corruption but it will not reach China. China is ahead and is 3 times as big as India.
They will. It's inevitable. The newer generation is always better..and I don't mean RG.
There's no point or rationale for an average Indian or India as a whole to celebrate our hostile neighbour's downfall.
On the contrary we need to increase our focus on our own development and protect our interests in the global arena keeping in mind our ambition to become a super power. More attention to the weak areas amd work on them.
The World is going through a serious phase of crisis,say economic ,political or environmental crisis. We are standing on a tremendously volatile juncture. Our present decisions will decide and shape our trajectory for years to come. Like a wiser person learns from the mistakes of others , India needs to learn in the same line from the economic crisis in our neighborhood, first in Srilanka and now in Pakistan and act preemptively.
As the saying goes, "To make one's 'line' appear longer than the other's, one needs to draw a bigger line instead of erasing the other's line". That has been and should remain the collective effort of all indians and India, among other things. Simply celebrating at enemy's failure won't contribute anything to one's growth and prosperity.
Words and actions resulting from mere blind Jingoism has not served and will never serve any purpose.
"Super power " ? ...we are far far from that. India needs at least 2-3 decades of steady growth before India enters the conversation.
Yes I agree, we cannot get POK back unless Pakistan collapses and itself comes back to India. Which most Indians will agree we donot want it.
We donot want radicalised population of Pakistan.
No Pakistan splintering will not bring back POK. Infact it will make China's case better. Then can maneuver POk to be independent and make that govt client state like Laos, Pakistan etc
excellent analysis gupta jee. from ur follower in pak
Pakistan is such a compelling subject that you can not avoid, and you picked one sense over a million nonsense. Kudos to you . Is this the start of the programs अमन की आशा and Jashn E Riwaz roll out ?
Forget Pakistan ! It's time to take up steps to catch up not only China but also US 😊
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
First take over China
@@ghazanhussain2070 Don't worry bro..India will achieve both. Time is the factor. We true Indians are optimists 👍
@@mohanmakli5791 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@mohanmakli5791 You are delusional. I know never read a serious book otherwise your thinking capacity wouldn't be that low.
This is like when our parents say, "Sharmaji ka ladka top Kiya, doctor ban gaya and Tum Yaha RUclips Dekhte reh gaye "
Won't be surprised if Shahzad Chaudhry joins Pakistan politics soon and fight for highest chair
Again, he'll need Army's help....
@@Agnosticcc-x3m he is ex-defence so getting military support might be slightly easier (compared to Imran Khan who had no defence background)
@@ppadiya I am surprised that you are unaware about 'Project Imran' and how he was launched by the establishment to the exclusion of all mainstream parties. It was in the making for more than a decade.
😂😂
What is this feeling? deja Vu...?
A Footnote with Nukes….never let your enemies to reach a stage where they have nothing to lose.
Soonpoh Tay
to win a chess match you need to do check mate only .
if your afraid of your enemy loseing then perhaps your not suted to play the game .
So, what we have to do? Send billions to Pak to prevent it from collapse?? Or handover Kashmir to them because of fear that they might use Nukes? As the person above my comment said, if we r afraid of enemies losing then we should lose to them...
Very good point . But they will lose internally only . We just have to take care against fall out .
ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
@@Agnosticcc-x3m We have to be internally strong . Rest is easy .
ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
Agree a poor failing neighbour is not good for india it will always be a security threat. Example Singapore invest a lot in its neighbourhood to prevent it and we welcome workers from neighbouring country which help build trust and ties.
Shekhar ji has gone nuts i guess shahzad Chowdary just wrote this as a gut feeling musings. We should not go gung ho and celebrate by jumping in air because of this praise
It was not an appraisal of India, but rather a sad and sobering acknowledgement of how fked up Pakistani situation actually is.
I cant believe that Shekargi is praising so much to a pakistani retired airfirce officer for nearly 9 minutes. In one sentence he applauded PM who brought the country foreign reserve to 600 billion in 8 years.
They are all basically one people, Only GAWD different.
True ...wtf the video must be titled shekarji praising pak officer
It takes courage for people to be realistic & level headed...especially being Army general.
Mr gupta your attempt at trying to be a serious journalist is most appreciated! Still in the end your old Congressman loyalty does shine through in the opinions that you hold ! News need not be opinionated!
Nice article and video.
The singular action that will save Pakistan is too drop all sanctions on Indian goods unconditionally. Trade with India and tariff free access to all Indian goods is the only salvation for Pakistan, not IMF bailouts.
It will not happen and should not happen .
ruclips.net/video/Xqb8LA9Ub_A/видео.html
Haha. Good one. Only they can't pay and our trading community isn't expected to do charity to them. Forget Pakistan, or their salvation. Not India's problem or duty.
It is however our sworn duty to make sure of our own security - and if that means paying them back in their own coin - and doing whatever is needed in splintering Pakistan and China (yes both continually trying it since 75 years) then so be it. India should strengthen itself and pay these evil nations back. We shouldn't be in debt to any one - not even in karma. Karma works but it does need its karmi - India can be so.
Excellent one by Shekhar, On a foot note :) , the number of "cut the clutters on pakistan" in the last 12 months is simpl overwhelming and undeserving, it it because of some Punjabi love ? :)
Gupta ji, why the re-upload?
They corrected few things , regarding pakistan writer
Content from 17:00 onwards is added I think
@@poorvasharma8807 thank you, you're correct
"Respect to your work sir and keep it up"
Pakistan
Sir, stop giving so much screen time for Pakistan or Pakistan originated story. Its hardly of anyone’s interest what they think of India.
its our neighbor whose population may rise to 400M within a decade or 2. Pak is in pretty bad shape but if it get its act right can become a very powerful country.
Shekhar is my Dose of Knowledge 🎈
change quickly else after some time you will have only counter view and no view.
Whenever there is trouble in Pakistan they buy time to recover using Aman Ki Asha, India should not take these comments seriously.
Relevance is not an attribute. What India has is a functioning democracy. Two countries created together and while one struggles to maintain a democratic system, the other struggles to maintain a military dictatorship.
Mr Gupta, please do a follow on of this cut the clutter episode enlightening your viewers about the gap between India and China, whether India-China gap can be bridged? And if so, how? And by when?
He already did please check…We Indians know our weakness…because we have South Indians are the most analytical minded unlike Punjabis who are emotional and animalistic
I am a Pakistani, British, Canadian (despite being in the west), i do sincerely hope india and China settle their disputes, likely chances are that may help to let pakistan and india solve their conflict. I personally think conflict reolution between India and china would be a great game changer and would be the actual indicator where we can say that it is the century for the east. Hopefully we see it in our life time.
India-China dispute can only be solved when India's economy is of comparable size to that of China and when China sees India as an equal. And I agree, India-Pakistan issues will be sorted only after India-China is sorted out.
It took a Pakistani article for us to make this content? And we own the exclusive rights of identifying and labeling 'true' patriots, btw.
BJP brought new confidence to India.
Pakistan will be history
Let us not even talk about them
Somalia is richer than pakistan
prithiviraj chohan also use to think like that but what happen to him everybody knows......
By what logic is Shekhar suggesting that PoK is not part of India?
A weak neighbor is your greatest security threat. Think about it, biases and emotions aside. Think.
I thought I was having a deja vu. Anyways, excellent episode as usual.
Having a very poor country beside india is dangerous. Both need to make ammend.
This is not backed by any data.
Sir, I like to listen to your videos, which is full of your experiences and historical facts. Thanks for taking it to us.
Mr Shekhar Gupta, it’s nice to see you on the right of Center. It’s not you who have shifted, it’s just the Center has moved too far on the left. Keep ot up, you are doing a good job which, sadly, NDTV isn’t doing.
Now a days India fans are growing in Pakistan. This is a cute 😍 good feeling.
Repeated Episode! It was uploaded just 2-3 days earlier!
Spend less time on Pakistan..a basket case...and more on other countries that we can collaborate to achieve economic growth.
If you don't press forward claims of your territory, Then others will start pressing claims on your territory.
Many Media started showing only Indian Kashmir is reason of conflicted, not POK and Aksai chin.
Never leave your claim.
Would love to hear about passed stories you have covered sir👍
Thankyou for such great content everytime!
Subhah ka bhoola jab shaam ko ghar waapas aata hai, to useh bhoola nahi kehte. Hope this is a new beginning to a golden Era for the peninsula.
Peninsula is completely India bro, which is doing quite good for now. Peninsula is a Land mass surrounded on 3 sides by water (in this case the Deccan and Southern India).
The wider Subcontinent in where Pakistan comes into the picture, and let's just say with cases like Sri Lanka, Nepal and to some extent Bangladesh, things might not be so Golden after all.
GAP with India?
They should be worrying about the gap between them and the deep dark economic abyss into which their country can disappear.
India should have a look north and west policy. All countries should sign a treaty with india acknowledging Tibet and POK, and Gillgit baltistan are integral part of India.
Time will come when india will capture pok without a fight and that time will come when it’s gdp hits 10 trillion dollars
WASTE OF ENTIRE universe's time to compare the two countries
Can I remind you again that I am not bothered about Pakistan. My concern is India and the spate of its Democracy.
Please don't compare Pakistan with India. It's embarrassing.
So many praises for Modi?? Pappu will not call SG for his Birthday Party at Appu Ghar
The deficit with China is mainly due to Indian economic growth
I think it'll be very nice of you to write a book on your life sir! You have such long experience covering events for decades. It'll be very enlightening to read about your experiences.
Kashmir is a stalemate. There is no solution to it other than the prevalent status quo. Both Countries need to move forward and work on confidence building measures like cultural exchange, students exchange program, trade, sports etc. This is the only way this region can pull its people out of poverty, specially Pakistan.
13:23 What realistic? What humbleness? we'd rather have better trade with the middle east than Pakistan. A land trade route would always be very expensive considering the first two countries are Afghan and Pakistan. Iran and onwards we should renew our ties. A lot of potential there. We would rather be happy with Turkey and gang than with Pakistan. Dictatorships are outdated they should go ultimately. If any consensus is needed is with Pakistan-India-Nepal-Bangla-SriLanka.
China is beyond Himalayas, It would be a grave error to bring Pakistan into the table with China-India Relationship. Please be a little more exhaustive Sir.
भारत सहित किसी भी देश ने अभी तक पाव पाव भर के परमाणु बम नही बना पाये है। पाकिस्तान की बराबरी कोई नही कर पाया अभी तक!
SG, you can disagree with the govt policies if the disagreement has merit. And in that case people will listen to you and not label you anti-national. What you and your cabal are doing is criticism of govt policies without merit. And common people can see through this. This is why they question your patriotism
India's current policy of NO WAR, NO PEACE with Pakistan may appear desirable to Nee Delhi, but it is not sustainable. An unstable and impoverished Pak is a greater and much more severe threat than a politically stable and reasonably solvent one. Indian planners must engage in a policy targeted to limit and maintain Pakistan's current situation in a way that it neither gets worse nor gets better. Sounds heartless and vicious but inevitably that would be the only option for New Delhi. They neither want a rich Pakistan nor an impoverished one.
We are surely looking at 95%
Is this episode reposted again?
Yes this is repeated.
Great analysis. Just one suggestion - Indians still claiming to get back Aksai Chin in future is not the same as Pak getting back J&K. They are not the same due to different circumstances of India and Pak at present.
Why ?? both the ideas are quite delusional. Tell me one realistic scenario where China will give back Aksai Chin ?
Not possible without establishing control on Tibet.
What’s happening? This is a re upload
Audio level is less in this video. Try to keep lapel mike closer at top shirt button
Episode on Chip War between US and China.Taiwan and Denmark have become US satellite countries because of ASML and TSMC
Battle of Asal Uttar - The greatest tank battle since World War II
ruclips.net/video/QnoXxKb0gmI/видео.html
Comparing with Pak all the time is like flogging a dead horse. Waste of TIME!
Need to compare India now to China to catch up with them or we will be far more behind China.
love from west bengal
Great knowledge sir 👍
We respect india and question government also and appreciate when required. Problem with opposition they converted hate towards modi to hate towards government and india,Any one hating or bashing India wont be spared by commoner. Many times these party's blame entire nation and religion for wrong instances which we condemn too , but when a common man was attacked or a solider attacked none of these party's bother. They want votes of specific group only , thats what hitting the opposition.
Why repost
To educate people like you.
@@gyanibrown3638 iindians r the one of dumbest people in the world for example in 45' 46' election more than 90% mmoslim constituency voted for m. league still this dumb iindian people didnot do popul. xchange ... bbloody iidiots
World should officially recognised Kashmir as part of PAKISTAN
price of living in religious fundamentalism. a lesson for everyone.
not rreligious fundamentalism it is iislamic way ...... don't bring other rreligion into this???????
India should be diplomatic with Pak and take the lessons learnt in the past and continue the current run and focus on the global goal which is more important than a tiny Neighboring country which is now reeling with the terror they schooled. If it falls ..just help when needed .
❤️❤️
30 odd farmers commit sueside daily.... Shame india
Why are we celebrating downfall of Pakistan, is it to get more views? I would like to say, I support your journalism but this seems a negative one, daily you post one content where you talk about the gap between India and Pakistan.
Let's make India number 1 not by comparing to who is behind but who is ahead and how can we go ahead of them.
Let's discuss those policies.
factos
If we have the production capacity and stuff gets less costly over a period of time
A jo column likha hai ,ho skta hai pakistan main ya turkey ke writer ne likha hai main is pain bhi yakeen krta, lakin agr koi bole ki ye "shekhar Gupta" ne likha hai to mujhe kabhi yakeen nahi hota.
Shame on u shekhar Gupta.
Most jinjoistic military experts also will agree that getting PoK back on current status is impossible
The problem here is lack of objectivity from Indian intellectuals
There are no Indian Intellectuals who believe getting PoK back is a possibility or a necessity.
Well done India
UAE is investing 72 billion $ in India
Should hold back a little the condensation in your tone.
Am i insane or have have seen this before
This video is all about Pakistan. Which shows India's obsession with Pakistan and Bangladesh continues.
What he doesn't represent 1.4 billion people
Also he is explaining an article by a pakistani so
It shows Pakistan's obsession with india continues
You gotta get your mindset checked🤕
frankly such content is not useful. India should be compared against top economies, not with neighbourhoods.
#Shekhar, do you now want to re-evaluate your opinion about DeMo?
Now that India and Russia are one
Full episode ki jarurat hi nahi thi, first line ko he loop main chala dena tha.
@SG and @print I remember you had one more video which says to leave PAK to itself. I don't agree. I think it's highly needed to support Pakistan and take them away from china. It might be cruel to say this I think it would be a historic victory of the Indian government (both BJP and the next government (if any)) to think of bringing Pakistan towards India. I believe both Indians and pak need to get over their obsession with POK or Indian Kashmir out may be kept to the next generations. and try to pull pak towards India than china.
I am a BJP supporter.In some of the articles, I get a feeling that your views are left-inclined. I might not agree with that.
but thanks for your information
Excellent
Previously Pakistan was happy has India was also bad and equally useless. But after Modi came things are changing for India in a big way and now India looks like a Super power .As pakistan follows India in every way they want to change their course will it happen.
Pranam Sir 🙏🙏. Great pragmatic discussion 👍👍