A lot that makes a great coach throughout all professional sports in my opinion, is the ones that can bring that superstar talent together into a cohesive unit serving a common goal. I could put some examples of this but you have countless superstar teams in the past 2 pre-COVID years to prove this.
As a Bears was shocked to see Ditka. He revitalized the Bears and turned them into winners. I am not saying he was one of the greatest to win a Super Bowl one of those Bears fans, i.e. SNL Superfans, but they were a contender for most of his tenure. Now if they could have kept McMahon healthy they would have at least one more Super Bowl.
Those who hold Ditka is such high esteem will also have to explain away his tenure with the New Orleans Saints. By any measurement an absolute disaster.
Ah yes Mike McCarthy, basically no different than Chick Hicks from “Cars”. Green, finish in 2nd place a lot, and only won it all once cause the blue guy was battered.
Disagree about Kubiak. He took over a bad Texans team and made them relevant for the first time ever. And he managed to deliver a Super Bowl despite the Broncos' window already in the process of closing.
Yeah I never understood the hate for Kubiak. In Houston he went 10-6 and 11-5 in back to back years with Matt Schaub and TJ Yates at QB and they won a playoff game both years. Then he won a super bowl with noodle arm Manning and he even went 9-7 with Trevor Siemian. He probably would still be coaching the Broncos if it wasn’t for the health issues.
Don Shula had 15 years with Dan Marino, 10 years with Bob Griese, 10 years with Johnny Unitas, plus a year with MVP QB Earl Morral, and the only thing he got was back to back SBs in the early 70s when he had one of the greatest defenses of all time.
Yes, the Eagles fired Pederson. That team has been suffering the worst Super Bowl hangover lasting at least the last 3 years. And it's been a ground up hangover. So the jury is still out on Pederson for qualifying for the list. And I say that as an Eagles fan.
When talking about Jon Gruden, it's worth mentioning the other advantages that he had in Tampa. He inherited a team that have been revitalized by Tony Dungy and Rich McKay with an excellent defense coached by Monte Kiffin.
@@brianthomas2434 I would hope so, considering that the picks went to Washington. That being said, Washington didn’t do shit with all of those picks, either.
@@treymagathan847 wow, sorry. Why did I think it was Minnesota? I suppose this was just another instance of things going wrong in the Snyder era of misrule. NEXT TIME I check before I comment!
Carroll has only missed the playoffs twice in 11 seasons with the Seahawks and he was the coach that built the LOB. He's certainly not an all time great, but he doesn't belong on that list.
TBF i think Tomlin should be on the list. He's guilty of the same crime as McCarthy where he's been an average coach his entire career and has been bailed out by the sheer amount of elite talent he happened to have on the team. How you can have prime Ben, AB, Leveon and Shazier and have literally nothing to show for it is amazing
@@LASVEGASRAIDERS21 Yes because the Bengals and Browns have been elite football teams in his tenure. Every other week the steelers underperform and play down to competition only for elite talent to bail Tomlin out. He's an average coach and probably one of the worst in the AFC
@@LASVEGASRAIDERS21 Browns and Bengals have been among the 5 worst teams in the league year in year out during his tenure, literally the bottom of the barrel. The only thing Tomlin had to worry about is the ravens and managing the ~12 pro-bowlers his future HOF GM gave him every year.
Marty Shot is a my favourite coach to never win a SB. You know you’re unlucky when you get fired after a 14-2 record and the main reason you lost in the playoffs was an interception that was then fumbled 🤦♂️
Mike Tomlin should have been in this video-he won his only Super Bowl with a group of core players drafted under Bill Cowher and since 2010, his teams have been chronic underachievers.
HE shouldn't be. The video creator is absolutely clueless. McCarthy developed ROdgers into the HOF QB he is and then got to the Super Bowl as the 6th seed after having to win the final two games of the regular season just to get in while having 15 guys on IR and pulling warm bodies off the street to play. That alone disqualifies him from being the worst coach to win a Super Bowl.
I'm surprised they didn't mention Don McCafferty. He won Super Bowl V with the Baltimore Colts riding the coattails of Don Shula's team. He was fired halfway through the season two years later.
Yea, I don’t like that firing. That’s like The Cubs firing Madden. I don’t like it. Both Coaches made History with & for your Franchise, show some respect, lets ride , LETS F’n RIDE. They should be rider or die with those Coaches, I feel like they earned a decade with those Championships for those teams whom NEVER had a Championship in their sport prior to and it’s still their only 1 @tm. Madden especially is far too Great of a Manager to go out like that and after breaking a curse. C’MON MAN!!!
@@CSDonohue11 Doug is overrated him getting fired after just winning a super bowl proves it. Bad game plans,makes no adjustments during games and a losing record after byes. Coaches wit Super bowls get more leeway, Lurie gave Andy Reid more time and he blew 3 NFC championship games. All that proves they didn't see things getting better wit Doug
Kubiak was pretty good in Houston and then won a SB with Denver, I don't know how I feel about that. I guess I can't think of many horrible coaches that won, though. So someone has to make the list.
Every decade, there's that one coach where we go "He won the Super Bowl?!" In the 70s, it was Don McCafferty who won in Baltimore. In the 80s, it was Ditka. In the 90s, it was Switzer. In the aughts, it was definitely Billick (Gruden was a good coach and if he had one more year in Oakland, he's winning a Super Bowl anyways). And now, the 2010s, it was easily Dougie P. McCarthy lost because Brett Favre threw a bonehead pick and Bostick got hands of rock.
You forgot to put Bill Belichick on the list of coaches that never won a super bowl. He had an ok team but he just needed a franchise quarterback. Sad to see such a legend never win the big game. 😞
Really? George Seifert? Guy rode Bill’s coattails with a legendary offense and an underrated defense and then played placeholder after ownership forced Bill out.
He won 2 SB's. You can say 89 was Walsh's team, but 94 was mostly it's own creation with free agency. Seifert isn't an all-time great, but he was a decent coach in the Levy and Grant and Reeves level.
@@HugeStan920 MM didn't do it alone. He also has help from Ted Thompson reach strategy in the draft and horrible FA moves landing starting WRs like Taco Wallace.
@@kershekfamily Who dishonest BS, Taco Wallace was not drafted and he wasn't brought into start either. He had to start because of all the injuries. Get your facts straight.
Mike Tomlin can somehow win a super bowl but can't beat Tim Tebow, Mike Glennon, and Ryan Finley. 3 playoff wins in the last 10 years. Let that sink in. I'm a Steelers fan so you know that I'm not biased
The only people who believe Mike Tomlin is bad are a small portion of Steelers fans. He literally has had just as much success as Bill Cowher. In fact, on average Tomlin wins MORE games than Cowher.
@@TheTorridestCheese Tomlin has had great offenses and defenses year in and year out. Cowher did not. Cowher did not make close games with 4th string QBs and injury riddled teams. Tomlin has won 3 playoff wins in 6 appearances in the last 10 years. To put that into perspective, Cowher won 7 playoff games and a super bowl in 6 appearances in his final 10 years with significantly less talented rosters. Tomlin always throws other people under the bus. He's gotten rid of our last 3 OC's because he didn't like them as a person
See, I didn't think McCarthy was that bad, but now since Matt Lafleur we have went 13-3 twice in a row and it is his first years coaching I think it i safe to say Mike was terrible.
coaches defeated by the 2015 Denver Broncos: Jon Harbaugh, Andy Reid, Mike Tomlin, Bill Belichick (twice), Ron Rivera in the Super Bowl, etc. you need to put some respeck on Gary Kubiak's name
So glad to see you calling out Jon Gruden. His Raiders were good, but never got there. He goes to Tampa, wins with a team he didn't build, but the cracks were already starting to form. He already started butting heads with the GM and players... bad enough that Emmitt Smith wanted no part of that situation. He chased off most of his best players, and the team collapsed around him.
Another factor was the Dikta coached teams ran into the 49ers in 2 NFC Championship games. The one time they got to the Super Bowl, the 9ers got beat in the Wild Card round. The 9ers were the Bears kryptonite. In fact they lost 24-0 and 20-0 in both NFC Championship games to the 9ers.
Unless I am missing something, Mike Ditka was signed by and played for the Bears in the 60's under Halas and even won a national championship during that time. Meaning Gary Kubiak isn't the only coach to win it all with the same team he played for.
Don McCafferty inherited a great Colts team from Don Shula in 1970, won that year's Super Bowl, lost next year's AFC Conference Championship, was fired after starting 1-4 in 1972, coached the Lions to a 6-7-1 record in 1973 and dropped dead just before training camp in 1974 with 28 career coaching wins.
Don’t forget Gruden after winning the Super Bowl with Tampa he only made the playoffs twice and he was one and done both times. Let’s not forget him and Bruce Allen got rid of the good defensive players like Lynch and Sapp to try and rebuild their offense and the QBs Gruden went with are Brian Griese and ... Chris Simms. Sure he eventually got Jeff Garcia and still had guys like Derrick Brooks and Ronde Barber but still failed and got fired after going 9-7 after starting 9-3.
How is Gruden overrated for winning wit a defense he didn't construct and washed QB. What does that say about Tony Dungy? Gruden had the Raiders contending but ran into the 2000 Raven defense,Tuck rule and Al Davis not liking him.
Barry Switzer was the ultimate college coach. His recruiting ability was second to none. Once he fielded superior talent, he just had to make sure that morale was good and the playcalling wasn't attrocious. You can't coach that way in the NFL
Goes to show that great players matter more than a great coach. Since coaches are more expendable as well as the fact that theyre not in the line of fire so to speak.
Great video as always! Just a quick note I noticed: Unless you meant that Kubiak only ever played for the team he coached in the Broncos, you left Mike Ditka out of the conversation. He played on the 1963 NFL Champion Bears, leading the team in receptions that year. Keep up the great vids!
I dont really agree with doug pederson because while the entire team was on ir he was able to get practice squad guys into the playoffs and was one catch away from the nfc championship game in 2018. Reich was a huge factor in the sb win but I truly think that pederson could do it again. Also with all the fun drama around the eagles its becoming more apparent that pederson really never had control over personel which is also interesting. I guess we'll see what happens with his next team
Correction, chemical dependency of marijuana does exist. It’s estimated around 9% of heavy users develop a chemical dependency. That’s not meant to demonize marijuana, but I grow tired of people incorrectly stating that you can’t become addicted to it. I haven’t done the leg work into if studies were done on weaker strains or if chemical dependency was as prevalent decades ago when marijuana wasn’t as potent.
Mike Tomlin belongs on this list. The guy has gone 3-7 in the last 10 years in the post season. He constantly drops games to terrible opponents they should beat easily. He regularly shoots his team in the foot by making terrible decisions like going for 2 in the wrong situation or punting when he shouldn't. Honestly if he was the HC of any other team he probably would have been fired years ago.
I'd put Tomlin on here for the simple fact that he creates a culture that leads to a bunch of divas creating a circus, it never fails every year someone does something off the field to create a circus
He is what Marvin Lewis dreamed of. I give Marvin credit for rebirthing the Bengals to a point but along the way he lost control of his team's more troubled characters and just became the uncle at the BBQ, not the COACH
My Analysis On 5PV's Video and My Opinions On These Coaches: Gary Kubiak: Won 2 Super Bowls as Mike Shanahan's OC (didn't call plays). Best HC Houston ever had even if it was because of JJ Watt. I wouldn't say he was a bad coach in any way but the 2015 Broncos were definitely carried by their defense. Brian Billick: Playcaller of the 1998 Vikings, one of the greatest offenses in NFL history. He wasn't really a bad coach during his time in Baltimore, but the majority of the credit for the 2000 run definitely goes to Marvin Lewis, Ray Lewis, and Ed Reed. It also didn't help that Billick never had a good QB during his time in Baltimore. Mike Ditka: Even if the 85 Bears Super Bowl was mostly thanks to Buddy Ryan, Ditka to this day has a big impact on the Bears and Chicago as a whole. Iron Mike had some good years before and after 85 as well, so I believe that success shouldn't be measured in how many Super Bowls you make. Jon Gruden: I'm not gonna talk about that racist, sexist, homophobic piece of #$%@. Mike McCarthy: The biggest talent waster in football history. If I had a dollar for every time I heard "Aaron Rodgers is the real HC of the Packers", I'd be pretty rich. Doug Pederson: The ineptitude that plagued Philly for years after SB52 wasn't his fault. Countless bad decisions from the front office were the main cause of their downfall. Also, Reich only called plays once he was hired as the Colts' HC. Barry Switzer: He was basically Mike McCarthy before Mike McCarthy. Honestly, he was notorious for many unspeakable things throughout the 90s. Thoughts on what I have to say?
Gruden is only human, cancel him if you want, but he has respect from those who know him far better than us. White knights of keyboardia, I ask you how truly tolerant of diversity are you when fail to tolerate the (percieved) intolerant then by those actions you prove yourself to be amongst their ranks. We all fall short of perfection and we all have shameful moments that may not be made public, I don't like the things he said or wrote but I don't think of him as less than equal to human. Forgiveness and a willingness to move on in a world where our biggest challenge is the decline of analytical skills and a Hitlerization of anyone not PC in all forms of media.
Haven’t watched the vid yet, but here are my picks: Doug Pederson ✅ Mike McCarthey ✅ Mike Ditka ✅ Mike Tomlin ❌ Jon Gruden ✅ And if we’re counting coordinators too, then: Adam Gase ❌ Matt Patrica ❌ Bill O Brien ❌
Tomlin is a bit overrated, but he doesn't belong on that list considering his 14 years streak of winning seasons and how he never had a losing season yet. The rest of the people on that list wouldn't come close to that.
You know who'll never win won? Coach/Owner Jerry Jones! (Those were Jimmie johnson teams) Lol. Next Al Davis. Calling plays from the skybox. "Tell em to go long!"
Everybody rags on Berry at Dallas but the fact is he ran a good team until Jeruh managed to micro manage it to death....as he does to this day. The proof is the Cowheads suckage ever since.
Yeah. Switzer was retired when Jerry called him to replace Jimmy Johnson. And the discipline of that team was awful. Aikman was furious at Switzer for that, as he knew him from collage.
As a Packers fan I hate that you put up McCarthy, but think it is fair. Biggest indictment is the Seattle game. Losing that was inexcusable, and I think it had to with the team mentality. We should have been out for blood, wanting revenge for the Fail Mary. If we had that cutt throat attitude, no way Morgan Burnett would have gone down. We had a chance to not just beat the Seahawks and their insufferable fans, but instead we were the ones humiliated. Compare and contrast that with the Ravens stomping on the Titans logo. I still think the team and fans lack that sort of mentality, and it is very much to our detriment. Teams do not recover from those sorts of losses. See eg Falcons collapse against the hated, cheating Patriots. When that happens you just have to move on then and there. I think McCarthy was a good coach until after the Super Bowl. he was excactly what we needed to bring Rodgers in and stand up to Berty Judas and his antics. Somewhere along the way Mac stopped being a good coach. Hopefully, LaFleur can redeem us with not just one but two titles before the windows close. I want to match the Cheatrots in SB titles, without the asterisk, and with beautiful, classical uniforms, as opposed to those ugly digs with that stupid Flyng Elvis.
Gary Kubiak is NOT the only coach who won a Super Bowl with the team he played for. Tom Flores played quarterback for the Raiders in the early 60s before winning two Super Bowls with them as head coach in the 80s, eventually getting inducted in the Hall of Fame. He also won rings as a player (with Kansas City) and an assistant (another one with the Raiders).
Being a native Texan who is a Packers fan (my family was from Wisconsin) and constantly surrounded by Cowboys fans (25 years of mediocrity and counting), I could go off on a whole tangent on Jerrah right now (with Switzer and McCarthy being a BIG part of it...on the latter, like I said...Packer fan). But I'll be the bigger man and let it go. Can you say 26 years of mediocrity and counting??
no greater proof of luck and gruden than the dumpster fire that is the team formerly the oakland raiders (never call them the other city) 100 million, the mack trade and all those picks later and we are still mediocre at best
2017 was that year when a mediocre coach and a terrible quarterback teamed up with an average defense and a subpar defensive coordinator to dominate the NFL. Then they were all lead to the promise land of winning the first Super Bowl in franchise history by a backup quarterback who had so little confidence in himself that he almost quit the game entirely before the season.
George Seifert should get an honorable mention here even though he did win 2 Super Bowls. He was extremely fortunate to inherit a team with both Joe Montana and Steve Young (not to mention GOAT wide receiver Jerry Rice). Despite all the talent that was already stockpiled with the 49ers, he still lost 3 playoff games at home, two of which were by double digits. When he moved on to a different team without all that talent, Seifert only won 33.3% of his games.
As a Buccaneers fan, I can promise you none of us think of Gruden as a great coach. He won the Super Bowl against his former team with a team built by Tony Dungy. He then proceeded to dismantle that team and never win a playoff game again.
After seeing Mike McCarthy on the Cowboys, everyone should realize how much of a testament it is to Aaron Rodgers that the Packers were as good as they were this past decade.
I wouldn't put Doug Pederson on this list. Despite what has happened since, he did push all the right buttons in 2017. He got the most out of his players, adjusted incredibly well, and was really humble about his limitations. If the current reports are true (that he squabbled too much with management), then it's likely that winning it all made him big-headed.
Switzer winning it all is why the Cowboys haven't done squat since. Switzer's win convinced Jerry Jones that he was right and inflated his ego beyond anything anyone could deflate.
Poor Marv. That man had a stacked team but ran into multiple teams that were even more stacked in 3 of those years, and a bit of bad luck against the Giants.
Have you ever thought about having Weregonnalose on the Dumpsterfire podcast? I just watched a video with you and David Land on with the iRacing Indy 500, and you guys were laughing up a storm about his funny ass videos
Fun story about Barry Switzer is that Troy Aikman hated him and is the reason Troy went to UCLA instead of Oklahoma out of high school. Allegedly, he was pissed when Jerry hired Switzer and almost retired because of it.
Also there was huge drama/beef between Switzer and Aikman that dates back to when Switzer coached at Oklahoma they were QB and coach for a short time and then Aikman transferred.
IMO, Mike was a good head coach. He built good teams when Favre was there and when Rodgers took over. I think the disappointment came after the 2014 season, although making the title game in 2017, Mike was on the decline. I believe he just got tired of the game and wanted away. I think he can turn Dallas around as the season wasnt his fault, the team needed a culture like.. seriously needed change after Jason Garrett
Unpopular choice: Tony Dungy. Only got over the hump due to an off game from Brady and playing Rex Grossman in the Super Bowl. His Colts and Bucs always choked in the big playoff games.
"McCarthy can only muster 1 ring with that QB excellency" Just to play devil's advocate... So does that "excellent" QB, but hey, there's always next year... Maybe
Ditka is only on here because of new Orleans. When he showed up in Chicago he told the players that they would win the super bowl by their third year together. He knew what he was doing. He lost to two teams that won super bowls and were pretty dominate
![Megan Thee Stallion - Bigger In Texas [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QxTkZTLWdo4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Quando Rondo - Life Goes On [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eIf3fhMXAow/mqdefault.jpg)
Ravens w the most “Murderous defenses of all time..” lollll
Man, no one knows about the 79 falcons and it shows sometimes lol
It’s not about the best defense it’s about the whole ray lewis murdered lol
@@mikefladland7408 *77
As a ravens fan the 77 falcons where the best.
@@mikefladland7408 joke went over your head lol
The winning wasn't thank to ditka, but he got everything out of his players he could. They were great because of him too
I think it was a lot because they could buy in to what he was saying because he was a former player. Just my opinion.
A lot that makes a great coach throughout all professional sports in my opinion, is the ones that can bring that superstar talent together into a cohesive unit serving a common goal. I could put some examples of this but you have countless superstar teams in the past 2 pre-COVID years to prove this.
Let me clarify, I am not referring to Ditka but to the comment as a whole
As a Bears was shocked to see Ditka. He revitalized the Bears and turned them into winners. I am not saying he was one of the greatest to win a Super Bowl one of those Bears fans, i.e. SNL Superfans, but they were a contender for most of his tenure. Now if they could have kept McMahon healthy they would have at least one more Super Bowl.
Those who hold Ditka is such high esteem will also have to explain away his tenure with the New Orleans Saints. By any measurement an absolute disaster.
Ah yes Mike McCarthy, basically no different than Chick Hicks from “Cars”. Green, finish in 2nd place a lot, and only won it all once cause the blue guy was battered.
@Tanimation Thanks
Consumes gasoline
I'm starting to wonder why cowboys fans were confident in McCarthy at the start of the season.
@@h.m.325 when you have le clap and smile man for so long, everything looks better.
@@mikevismyelement I can understand that, but did they not see how he made the packers like shit for those 2 years.
Disagree about Kubiak. He took over a bad Texans team and made them relevant for the first time ever. And he managed to deliver a Super Bowl despite the Broncos' window already in the process of closing.
He would've had sustained success if it wasn't for his health issues
call me crazy but I feel like winning a Super Bowl your first year as a team's HC should help your legacy rather than hurt it.....
Yeah I never understood the hate for Kubiak. In Houston he went 10-6 and 11-5 in back to back years with Matt Schaub and TJ Yates at QB and they won a playoff game both years. Then he won a super bowl with noodle arm Manning and he even went 9-7 with Trevor Siemian. He probably would still be coaching the Broncos if it wasn’t for the health issues.
Yep kubiak is an awesome coach, I wish he was still coaching they Texans. Him and Watson would be one hell of a duo
One year as offense coach with the Ravens and we become a pretty good offense. Flacco had a career year with Kubiak.
There is a Imposter Among Us...
The Coach Was The Imposter
There are 0 Imposters remaining.
It should be illegal to waste 10 years of elite QBing.
Stafford
LiONS!
ThA MAN C MAcK p
Rodgers......
See: Pittsburgh
Rodgers, Brees, Stafford. At least the first 2 have had SOME post season success.
Don Shula had 15 years with Dan Marino, 10 years with Bob Griese, 10 years with Johnny Unitas, plus a year with MVP QB Earl Morral, and the only thing he got was back to back SBs in the early 70s when he had one of the greatest defenses of all time.
He seemed to forget a running game is important too
He at least made it to a couple more
Doug Pederson
Mike McCarthy
Those people immediately come to mind.
Ik Pederson isn't the same coach now but idk if I can call the guy who beat the greatest head coach and qb combo with nick foles
nice to have Aaron Rodgers and Frank 4th Reich on your team it seems
Yes, the Eagles fired Pederson. That team has been suffering the worst Super Bowl hangover lasting at least the last 3 years. And it's been a ground up hangover. So the jury is still out on Pederson for qualifying for the list.
And I say that as an Eagles fan.
@@ReinSouls idk the broncos haven’t made the playoffs since SB50 -Broncos fan 😔
@@lamar3097 I gotta stroke John Elway's ego. There is no problem in Denver John.
When talking about Jon Gruden, it's worth mentioning the other advantages that he had in Tampa. He inherited a team that have been revitalized by Tony Dungy and Rich McKay with an excellent defense coached by Monte Kiffin.
Marv Levy is the greatest coach to never win one right? Go bills.
Yes he never won one, but he came close to winning the first one, but thanks to their kicker missing a 47 yard field goal at the end and lost 20 to 19
Him or Bud Grant
@@JahNuhThunDeeTheOneAndOnly yep
Marty shottehimer as well
Nah thats bud grant
Nothing says "I'm the greatest" like trading 9 draft picks away including a whole year's supply if it means you get the first overall pick.
That’s the worst part. Ricky Williams wasn’t even the 1st overall pick!
And P.S. even with all of New Orleans' picks, the Vikings hardly set the NFL on fire.
@@brianthomas2434
I would hope so, considering that the picks went to Washington. That being said, Washington didn’t do shit with all of those picks, either.
@@treymagathan847 ....which, of course, was my point. Thanks for restating it, since I apparently didn't make myself clear.
@@treymagathan847 wow, sorry. Why did I think it was Minnesota? I suppose this was just another instance of things going wrong in the Snyder era of misrule. NEXT TIME I check before I comment!
3:09
Oooooo some bears fans might fight you Fivepoints
Funniest thing is that the last 2 are both coaches for the Cowboys (Past and Present)
Bud Grant won 4 Grey Cups and an NFL championship. Also still alive at 93 years old.
Pete Carroll lived off the Legion of Boom and still thinks he has them.
Agreed. Also if it hadn’t been Jim Harbaugh (who Pete knew inside-out) coaching the 49ers, Seattle doesn’t win the SB, SF wins 1 or 2 instead.
Carroll has only missed the playoffs twice in 11 seasons with the Seahawks and he was the coach that built the LOB. He's certainly not an all time great, but he doesn't belong on that list.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 whyyyyyyy
Go Hawks
@@WillJM81280 ?
He didn’t Coach against Jim Harbaugh in The SuperB-owl.
@@CSDonohue11 in the nfc championship they did ya dummy
TBF i think Tomlin should be on the list. He's guilty of the same crime as McCarthy where he's been an average coach his entire career and has been bailed out by the sheer amount of elite talent he happened to have on the team. How you can have prime Ben, AB, Leveon and Shazier and have literally nothing to show for it is amazing
Stop it. The AFC North is one of the toughest divisions in football (and has been since the conference was created)
@@LASVEGASRAIDERS21 Yes because the Bengals and Browns have been elite football teams in his tenure. Every other week the steelers underperform and play down to competition only for elite talent to bail Tomlin out. He's an average coach and probably one of the worst in the AFC
Never had a losing season and went 8.8 with Hodges and Rudolph
@@LASVEGASRAIDERS21 Browns and Bengals have been among the 5 worst teams in the league year in year out during his tenure, literally the bottom of the barrel. The only thing Tomlin had to worry about is the ravens and managing the ~12 pro-bowlers his future HOF GM gave him every year.
@@pointyheadYT disagree on the bengals. They made the playoffs 5 times last decade. Puts them in the top half of the league. Not “bottom 5 worst”
You know ... it’s really amazing how much The Players matter.
I'm super hyped to see where LeFleur will go with the pack
2:14 This man's savage sharpness of Ray Lewis knows no knife edge.
Marty Shot is a my favourite coach to never win a SB. You know you’re unlucky when you get fired after a 14-2 record and the main reason you lost in the playoffs was an interception that was then fumbled 🤦♂️
That Chucky-Gruden comparison was funny as all hell
That's been a thing since the 90s....
@@Buttington_Headerson yeah but when is that never funny bruh
Mike Tomlin should have been in this video-he won his only Super Bowl with a group of core players drafted under Bill Cowher and since 2010, his teams have been chronic underachievers.
that is the same players that went 8-8 in 2006
SOMEBODY FINALLY SAID IT!
I think he should at least get a honorable mention.
Urinating Tree going undercover to comment on a FivePoints vid...
He has literally never had a losing season, he doesn't belong on the list despite his deficiencies when it comes to discipline
As a packers fan, I didn't need to see the thumbnail to know McCarthy was going to be on here
Mike cant hurt us anymore. We're back and better than ever. Now let's just hope the bad luck of home games in the playoffs won't screw us.
@@crapwithanopinion2919 you jinxed us 😔😔
@@calebangell77 I must apologize to the pack. Tom Brady's luck knows no bounds.
The constant enraging pain has officially come to the NFC
HE shouldn't be. The video creator is absolutely clueless. McCarthy developed ROdgers into the HOF QB he is and then got to the Super Bowl as the 6th seed after having to win the final two games of the regular season just to get in while having 15 guys on IR and pulling warm bodies off the street to play. That alone disqualifies him from being the worst coach to win a Super Bowl.
I'm surprised they didn't mention Don McCafferty. He won Super Bowl V with the Baltimore Colts riding the coattails of Don Shula's team. He was fired halfway through the season two years later.
In the 7 seasons Ditka coached the Bears without Buddy Ryan he had 5 seasons with 10+ wins, including a 14-2 season in 86.
He then was a bad coach in New Orleans where nobody in American history has succeeded besides Sean Payton. He was a good coach, a bad GM.
Doug is the top of my mind. Literally came out of nowhere, then got fired 3 years later after tanking the last game.
He beat Brady and Bellichek with Nick Foles tho, most of these coachs we carried to the sb Doug's offense was the reason they won
@@treventallent4916 that's true.
@@treventallent4916 Frank Reich offense reasons they look like shit after he left
Yea, I don’t like that firing.
That’s like The Cubs firing Madden.
I don’t like it.
Both Coaches made History with & for your Franchise, show some respect, lets ride , LETS F’n RIDE.
They should be rider or die with those Coaches, I feel like they earned a decade with those Championships for those teams whom NEVER had a Championship in their sport prior to and it’s still their only 1 @tm.
Madden especially is far too Great of a Manager to go out like that and after breaking a curse.
C’MON MAN!!!
@@CSDonohue11 Doug is overrated him getting fired after just winning a super bowl proves it. Bad game plans,makes no adjustments during games and a losing record after byes. Coaches wit Super bowls get more leeway, Lurie gave Andy Reid more time and he blew 3 NFC championship games. All that proves they didn't see things getting better wit Doug
Kubiak was pretty good in Houston and then won a SB with Denver, I don't know how I feel about that. I guess I can't think of many horrible coaches that won, though. So someone has to make the list.
Murderous Ravens defense....well played sir.
Every decade, there's that one coach where we go "He won the Super Bowl?!" In the 70s, it was Don McCafferty who won in Baltimore. In the 80s, it was Ditka. In the 90s, it was Switzer. In the aughts, it was definitely Billick (Gruden was a good coach and if he had one more year in Oakland, he's winning a Super Bowl anyways). And now, the 2010s, it was easily Dougie P. McCarthy lost because Brett Favre threw a bonehead pick and Bostick got hands of rock.
You forgot to put Bill Belichick on the list of coaches that never won a super bowl. He had an ok team but he just needed a franchise quarterback. Sad to see such a legend never win the big game. 😞
Seifert ?! The guy was offered a superbowl team then trashed the Panthers
Really? George Seifert? Guy rode Bill’s coattails with a legendary offense and an underrated defense and then played placeholder after ownership forced Bill out.
Absolutely. Check out Seifert's amazing work with Carolina when he went 1 - 15.
He won 2 SB's. You can say 89 was Walsh's team, but 94 was mostly it's own creation with free agency. Seifert isn't an all-time great, but he was a decent coach in the Levy and Grant and Reeves level.
If mike McCarthy isn’t on this list
Edit: he is, what a waste of talent
He’s on the thumbnail. 6:50
@@HugeStan920 MM didn't do it alone. He also has help from Ted Thompson reach strategy in the draft and horrible FA moves landing starting WRs like Taco Wallace.
@@kershekfamily Who dishonest BS, Taco Wallace was not drafted and he wasn't brought into start either. He had to start because of all the injuries. Get your facts straight.
Mike McCarthy it’s 4 and 10 on your own 20 your team is only down 3 pts with 8 mins left what do u do?
McCarthy: “Fake punt”
Fivepoints is a weird paradox, his video titles and thumbnails are like clickbait, but unlike clickbait, he actually delivers
Mike Tomlin can somehow win a super bowl but can't beat Tim Tebow, Mike Glennon, and Ryan Finley. 3 playoff wins in the last 10 years. Let that sink in. I'm a Steelers fan so you know that I'm not biased
well i mean in the past 10 years when it was the 3 bs prime they didnt have a defense
@@unpricedhydra3492 And that's in large part due to Tomlin.
The only people who believe Mike Tomlin is bad are a small portion of Steelers fans.
He literally has had just as much success as Bill Cowher. In fact, on average Tomlin wins MORE games than Cowher.
@@TheTorridestCheese Tomlin has had great offenses and defenses year in and year out. Cowher did not. Cowher did not make close games with 4th string QBs and injury riddled teams. Tomlin has won 3 playoff wins in 6 appearances in the last 10 years. To put that into perspective, Cowher won 7 playoff games and a super bowl in 6 appearances in his final 10 years with significantly less talented rosters. Tomlin always throws other people under the bus. He's gotten rid of our last 3 OC's because he didn't like them as a person
@@chuckyjamesamartin1968 What? Cowher frequently blew it to lesser teams.
See, I didn't think McCarthy was that bad, but now since Matt Lafleur we have went 13-3 twice in a row and it is his first years coaching I think it i safe to say Mike was terrible.
coaches defeated by the 2015 Denver Broncos: Jon Harbaugh, Andy Reid, Mike Tomlin, Bill Belichick (twice), Ron Rivera in the Super Bowl, etc. you need to put some respeck on Gary Kubiak's name
So glad to see you calling out Jon Gruden. His Raiders were good, but never got there. He goes to Tampa, wins with a team he didn't build, but the cracks were already starting to form. He already started butting heads with the GM and players... bad enough that Emmitt Smith wanted no part of that situation. He chased off most of his best players, and the team collapsed around him.
Make a super bowl would be interesting video too. Lovie Smith, Ken Whisenhunt, Jim Caldwell etc
Feel like you're not giving Kubiak enough credit for making Osweiler look good enough to ruin the Texans franchise
Another factor was the Dikta coached teams ran into the 49ers in 2 NFC Championship games. The one time they got to the Super Bowl, the 9ers got beat in the Wild Card round. The 9ers were the Bears kryptonite. In fact they lost 24-0 and 20-0 in both NFC Championship games to the 9ers.
Unless I am missing something, Mike Ditka was signed by and played for the Bears in the 60's under Halas and even won a national championship during that time. Meaning Gary Kubiak isn't the only coach to win it all with the same team he played for.
Don McCafferty inherited a great Colts team from Don Shula in 1970, won that year's Super Bowl, lost next year's AFC Conference Championship, was fired after starting 1-4 in 1972, coached the Lions to a 6-7-1 record in 1973 and dropped dead just before training camp in 1974 with 28 career coaching wins.
I love Gary Kubiak and Brian Billick. Brian gave the Ravens identity. I'm glad John replaced him but I'll always be grateful for Billick
The first person that came to my mind is Doug Peterson
Doug was good when he won but after that season he fell off
@@nflnightmare6393 Once Doug held the Lombardi, he gave up and laid down with it.
Doug Pederson better be here. Dude got hard carried by Frank Reich
The only think skip Bayless ever was correct on was calling him Kyle “should have been a” Boller
The problem was McCarthy just never evolved after 2010. He was a good coach at first.
Marty Schottenheimer comes to mind when I think of coaches who won the most regular season games, but couldn't translate it to the playoffs
I'm really disappointed Mike McCarthy wasn't #1, but bonus points for putting him on the thumbnail! 😆
Don’t forget Gruden after winning the Super Bowl with Tampa he only made the playoffs twice and he was one and done both times. Let’s not forget him and Bruce Allen got rid of the good defensive players like Lynch and Sapp to try and rebuild their offense and the QBs Gruden went with are Brian Griese and ... Chris Simms. Sure he eventually got Jeff Garcia and still had guys like Derrick Brooks and Ronde Barber but still failed and got fired after going 9-7 after starting 9-3.
All of Chicago gasped when Ditka appeared
Bud Grant did get an NFL championship and 4 Grey Cups so he got something
Jon Gruden. Won with a hall-of-fame defense he had no part in constructing and has been overrated ever since
he’s improved the raiders a lot. with a bit of better luck this season they’re probably in the playoffs
Yep! Glad Tony Dungy got his ring regardless
@@bigpimp72 "Jon Gruden isn't overrated, he almost made it to the play-offs"
GRUDEN IS THE MAN!
FootBall Savant.
Players still matter.
How is Gruden overrated for winning wit a defense he didn't construct and washed QB. What does that say about Tony Dungy? Gruden had the Raiders contending but ran into the 2000 Raven defense,Tuck rule and Al Davis not liking him.
Wow, these stats are sad. Thanks for reality check.
Barry Switzer was the ultimate college coach. His recruiting ability was second to none. Once he fielded superior talent, he just had to make sure that morale was good and the playcalling wasn't attrocious. You can't coach that way in the NFL
Doug played for the Eagles
He didn't win one as a player in Philly though.
"Mitch Trubisky isn't good" "But he won NVP"
Goes to show that great players matter more than a great coach. Since coaches are more expendable as well as the fact that theyre not in the line of fire so to speak.
Great video as always!
Just a quick note I noticed: Unless you meant that Kubiak only ever played for the team he coached in the Broncos, you left Mike Ditka out of the conversation. He played on the 1963 NFL Champion Bears, leading the team in receptions that year.
Keep up the great vids!
The “Dirty Bird”??? Wow! That’s a blast from the past. :)
I dont really agree with doug pederson because while the entire team was on ir he was able to get practice squad guys into the playoffs and was one catch away from the nfc championship game in 2018. Reich was a huge factor in the sb win but I truly think that pederson could do it again. Also with all the fun drama around the eagles its becoming more apparent that pederson really never had control over personel which is also interesting. I guess we'll see what happens with his next team
Correction, chemical dependency of marijuana does exist. It’s estimated around 9% of heavy users develop a chemical dependency. That’s not meant to demonize marijuana, but I grow tired of people incorrectly stating that you can’t become addicted to it. I haven’t done the leg work into if studies were done on weaker strains or if chemical dependency was as prevalent decades ago when marijuana wasn’t as potent.
Good video otherwise.
Mike Tomlin belongs on this list. The guy has gone 3-7 in the last 10 years in the post season. He constantly drops games to terrible opponents they should beat easily. He regularly shoots his team in the foot by making terrible decisions like going for 2 in the wrong situation or punting when he shouldn't. Honestly if he was the HC of any other team he probably would have been fired years ago.
I'd put Tomlin on here for the simple fact that he creates a culture that leads to a bunch of divas creating a circus, it never fails every year someone does something off the field to create a circus
He is what Marvin Lewis dreamed of. I give Marvin credit for rebirthing the Bengals to a point but along the way he lost control of his team's more troubled characters and just became the uncle at the BBQ, not the COACH
My Analysis On 5PV's Video and My Opinions On These Coaches:
Gary Kubiak: Won 2 Super Bowls as Mike Shanahan's OC (didn't call plays). Best HC Houston ever had even if it was because of JJ Watt. I wouldn't say he was a bad coach in any way but the 2015 Broncos were definitely carried by their defense.
Brian Billick: Playcaller of the 1998 Vikings, one of the greatest offenses in NFL history. He wasn't really a bad coach during his time in Baltimore, but the majority of the credit for the 2000 run definitely goes to Marvin Lewis, Ray Lewis, and Ed Reed. It also didn't help that Billick never had a good QB during his time in Baltimore.
Mike Ditka: Even if the 85 Bears Super Bowl was mostly thanks to Buddy Ryan, Ditka to this day has a big impact on the Bears and Chicago as a whole. Iron Mike had some good years before and after 85 as well, so I believe that success shouldn't be measured in how many Super Bowls you make.
Jon Gruden: I'm not gonna talk about that racist, sexist, homophobic piece of #$%@.
Mike McCarthy: The biggest talent waster in football history. If I had a dollar for every time I heard "Aaron Rodgers is the real HC of the Packers", I'd be pretty rich.
Doug Pederson: The ineptitude that plagued Philly for years after SB52 wasn't his fault. Countless bad decisions from the front office were the main cause of their downfall. Also, Reich only called plays once he was hired as the Colts' HC.
Barry Switzer: He was basically Mike McCarthy before Mike McCarthy. Honestly, he was notorious for many unspeakable things throughout the 90s.
Thoughts on what I have to say?
Good analysis!
@@FivePointsVids Thanks. I've been doing this all my life. ;)
Gruden is only human, cancel him if you want, but he has respect from those who know him far better than us. White knights of keyboardia, I ask you how truly tolerant of diversity are you when fail to tolerate the (percieved) intolerant then by those actions you prove yourself to be amongst their ranks. We all fall short of perfection and we all have shameful moments that may not be made public, I don't like the things he said or wrote but I don't think of him as less than equal to human. Forgiveness and a willingness to move on in a world where our biggest challenge is the decline of analytical skills and a Hitlerization of anyone not PC in all forms of media.
The head coach of the '70-'71 Baltimore Colts. That's right, I couldn't tell you his name either.
Haven’t watched the vid yet, but here are my picks:
Doug Pederson ✅
Mike McCarthey ✅
Mike Ditka ✅
Mike Tomlin ❌
Jon Gruden ✅
And if we’re counting coordinators too, then:
Adam Gase ❌
Matt Patrica ❌
Bill O Brien ❌
Tomlin is a bit overrated, but he doesn't belong on that list considering his 14 years streak of winning seasons and how he never had a losing season yet. The rest of the people on that list wouldn't come close to that.
Pete Carroll: 1-1 Super Bowl record for the Seahawks.
This is great. Surprised it doesn't have more views
You know who'll never win won? Coach/Owner Jerry Jones! (Those were Jimmie johnson teams) Lol. Next Al Davis. Calling plays from the skybox. "Tell em to go long!"
Also traded the Patriots a 1st to get Boller which we used for Vince Wilfork so thanks Billck
You won’t find to many Bears fans crediting the ‘85 SB to the genius of Ditka’s coaching magic.
Everybody rags on Berry at Dallas but the fact is he ran a good team until Jeruh managed to micro manage it to death....as he does to this day.
The proof is the Cowheads suckage ever since.
Yeah. Switzer was retired when Jerry called him to replace Jimmy Johnson. And the discipline of that team was awful. Aikman was furious at Switzer for that, as he knew him from collage.
As a Packers fan I hate that you put up McCarthy, but think it is fair. Biggest indictment is the Seattle game. Losing that was inexcusable, and I think it had to with the team mentality. We should have been out for blood, wanting revenge for the Fail Mary. If we had that cutt throat attitude, no way Morgan Burnett would have gone down. We had a chance to not just beat the Seahawks and their insufferable fans, but instead we were the ones humiliated. Compare and contrast that with the Ravens stomping on the Titans logo. I still think the team and fans lack that sort of mentality, and it is very much to our detriment.
Teams do not recover from those sorts of losses. See eg Falcons collapse against the hated, cheating Patriots. When that happens you just have to move on then and there.
I think McCarthy was a good coach until after the Super Bowl. he was excactly what we needed to bring Rodgers in and stand up to Berty Judas and his antics. Somewhere along the way Mac stopped being a good coach.
Hopefully, LaFleur can redeem us with not just one but two titles before the windows close. I want to match the Cheatrots in SB titles, without the asterisk, and with beautiful, classical uniforms, as opposed to those ugly digs with that stupid Flyng Elvis.
Gary Kubiak is NOT the only coach who won a Super Bowl with the team he played for.
Tom Flores played quarterback for the Raiders in the early 60s before winning two Super Bowls with them as head coach in the 80s, eventually getting inducted in the Hall of Fame. He also won rings as a player (with Kansas City) and an assistant (another one with the Raiders).
Being a native Texan who is a Packers fan (my family was from Wisconsin) and constantly surrounded by Cowboys fans (25 years of mediocrity and counting), I could go off on a whole tangent on Jerrah right now (with Switzer and McCarthy being a BIG part of it...on the latter, like I said...Packer fan). But I'll be the bigger man and let it go. Can you say 26 years of mediocrity and counting??
In Barry Switzer's defense (I hate the Cowboys), you should do a "WORST NFL OWNERS" list.
2nd and probably Brian billick would be my pick. Along with Doug Peterson next.
Nah, the worst is definitely Switzer. Everyone else is vying for 2nd.
@@matthewmazzatto8003 Switzer was retired when Jerry called him in for Jimmy Johnson. He didn't even saw all of his 5-year contract out.
no greater proof of luck and gruden than the dumpster fire that is the team formerly the oakland raiders (never call them the other city) 100 million, the mack trade and all those picks later and we are still mediocre at best
Would’ve been better off just paying Mack
2017 was that year when a mediocre coach and a terrible quarterback teamed up with an average defense and a subpar defensive coordinator to dominate the NFL. Then they were all lead to the promise land of winning the first Super Bowl in franchise history by a backup quarterback who had so little confidence in himself that he almost quit the game entirely before the season.
George Seifert should get an honorable mention here even though he did win 2 Super Bowls. He was extremely fortunate to inherit a team with both Joe Montana and Steve Young (not to mention GOAT wide receiver Jerry Rice). Despite all the talent that was already stockpiled with the 49ers, he still lost 3 playoff games at home, two of which were by double digits. When he moved on to a different team without all that talent, Seifert only won 33.3% of his games.
How about one hit wonder Nfl players or something. Funny ass video, ur jokes are amazing. Keep it up
Your content is more interesting to me than other content creators.
Thanks Rob!
As a Buccaneers fan, I can promise you none of us think of Gruden as a great coach. He won the Super Bowl against his former team with a team built by Tony Dungy. He then proceeded to dismantle that team and never win a playoff game again.
He was a good coach for that era. The Game has passed him by though
Im a Bears fan and seeing Mike Ditka in the list was made easier seeing that Mike McCarthy was higher.
After seeing Mike McCarthy on the Cowboys, everyone should realize how much of a testament it is to Aaron Rodgers that the Packers were as good as they were this past decade.
I wouldn't put Doug Pederson on this list. Despite what has happened since, he did push all the right buttons in 2017. He got the most out of his players, adjusted incredibly well, and was really humble about his limitations. If the current reports are true (that he squabbled too much with management), then it's likely that winning it all made him big-headed.
Switzer was chosen by Jones to stick it to JJ. Won a ring in spite of himself. But Ditka takes the prize
Switzer winning it all is why the Cowboys haven't done squat since. Switzer's win convinced Jerry Jones that he was right and inflated his ego beyond anything anyone could deflate.
Poor Marv. That man had a stacked team but ran into multiple teams that were even more stacked in 3 of those years, and a bit of bad luck against the Giants.
Mike Tomlin won't be on this list but he should be.
Wonder why.
I clicked on this to see if Tomlin would be on it
Rite?
The Steelers have never fired a coach in my lifetime.
Next question.
Have you ever thought about having Weregonnalose on the Dumpsterfire podcast? I just watched a video with you and David Land on with the iRacing Indy 500, and you guys were laughing up a storm about his funny ass videos
Fun story about Barry Switzer is that Troy Aikman hated him and is the reason Troy went to UCLA instead of Oklahoma out of high school. Allegedly, he was pissed when Jerry hired Switzer and almost retired because of it.
Also there was huge drama/beef between Switzer and Aikman that dates back to when Switzer coached at Oklahoma they were QB and coach for a short time and then Aikman transferred.
IMO, Mike was a good head coach. He built good teams when Favre was there and when Rodgers took over. I think the disappointment came after the 2014 season, although making the title game in 2017, Mike was on the decline. I believe he just got tired of the game and wanted away. I think he can turn Dallas around as the season wasnt his fault, the team needed a culture like.. seriously needed change after Jason Garrett
this production was brought to you by the firing of Doug Pederson
If your are ever feeling useless just remember that Adam gase has a Super Bowl ring
No he doesn’t
Unpopular choice: Tony Dungy. Only got over the hump due to an off game from Brady and playing Rex Grossman in the Super Bowl. His Colts and Bucs always choked in the big playoff games.
"McCarthy can only muster 1 ring with that QB excellency"
Just to play devil's advocate... So does that "excellent" QB, but hey, there's always next year... Maybe
I don't like how two of these coaches beat the Steelers in their only super bowl win lol
Tomlin should've also been on this list.
@@pointyheadYTno
Ditka is only on here because of new Orleans. When he showed up in Chicago he told the players that they would win the super bowl by their third year together. He knew what he was doing. He lost to two teams that won super bowls and were pretty dominate