Do More Wheels Get You More Places? Can-Am Defender 6x6 XT vs Honda Pioneer 1000-5 Trail

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 85

  • @shawndarter5159
    @shawndarter5159 Год назад +64

    Was hoping to see more of a comparison. This was like testing a civic and a corolla in the parking lot.

    • @Ram14250
      @Ram14250 Год назад +8

      it's seems lately the only thing on TFL is this type of video. Borrrrrrrring! What happened to the ranch and to driving tests?

    • @shanebrown2963
      @shanebrown2963 Год назад +1

      😂😂😂

    • @blammo8208
      @blammo8208 Год назад +2

      This track is no bueno hehe

    • @WW-wf8tu
      @WW-wf8tu Год назад +8

      Glad others are making these comments. Tired of pointing it out myself. While Roman is correct, these machines are very capable and would decimate their courses, the fact they did not even make the effort to show it is disappointing. Was expecting Alex and Kase and or even Tommy to be out there with these machines running them on the back lot making a bit of drama with them. Not Roman whining cause he is cold and has had enough with the boring toys. 🙄

    • @LionRunner
      @LionRunner Год назад +2

      Shawn Darter exactly..!! Love to see reviews more than family home videos type of things.

  • @col2thecar42
    @col2thecar42 Год назад +12

    2020 Defender HD10 owner here. I am pretty sure what happened at 9:20 was the Electronic Belt Protection system. When it detects slow driving, with lots of resistance going forward, (in this case going over those little ruts while creeping uphill while in hi range) the throttle is cut. This is done to help prevent the driver from putting lots of power while in hi range and blowing the belt. From my experience, it only happens in hi range. A message usually appears on the gauge telling the driver "Low range recommended".

    • @freidrichnietzsche6643
      @freidrichnietzsche6643 Год назад

      Appreciate the insight! I’m seriously looking at a defender pro for farm work (towing and hauling) and am curious if they were in low range, would this have happened? Thank you sir! 🙏
      I’m also considering aftermarket clutches for low-end grunt and to hopefully save belts. This won’t be a trail rig.

  • @juanthelawnmowerthief1641
    @juanthelawnmowerthief1641 Год назад +4

    As someone that up until recently sold Can Am the 6x6 is a beast but both rear differentials are locked making the turning radius pretty big. Better off just getting the Defender Pro with the same bed and 4x4 unless you need the extra 700 lbs in the bed. Recently drove the 2019 version of this same Honda and was very impressed!

  • @northerntoyota7584
    @northerntoyota7584 Год назад +8

    Why do you guys always run CVT equipped machines in high range when you’re testing slow speed abilities, that poor belt. Low range will give you far better throttle input response as well.

  • @maniacboy4692
    @maniacboy4692 Год назад +3

    The power dump bed is actually something everyone should have, we have a 2016 mahindra mpact 750 and it had a hydraulic dump bed but none of the major manufacturers do.

    • @jessewoody5772
      @jessewoody5772 9 месяцев назад

      The mahindra can not compete offroad with either of these machines.

  • @atvseatexchange2176
    @atvseatexchange2176 Год назад +5

    If it's too cold, get a young, healthy guy, out of the bullpen. Keep rolling Andrey.

    • @IGmeanwell
      @IGmeanwell Год назад

      Bring a puffer in one of the many compartments of the side by sides … be prepared. I guess we’ll just have to wait for the next video.

    • @IGmeanwell
      @IGmeanwell Год назад

      @@shitloveaduck Yes if you know it’s going to be cold outside or even the possibility of cold… you bring a coat.

  • @rerod650
    @rerod650 Год назад +3

    You guys could definitely do some more testing of sxs and Atvs while you have them. Other than the mule, most of the time you show them when they show up and maybe one video of lightly testing. How about you guys do a group trail ride with them, or take them along to Moab when your testing trucks.
    I also know you guys are very busy and stretched over a wide variety of content, but just seems like these machines are what usually draws the short straw and not tested much at all.

  • @northerntoyota7584
    @northerntoyota7584 Год назад +8

    The issue when you thought it lost power was you were in high range! That thing is heavy and going up a hill like that and against the berm of the trenches you were basically about to smoke the belt keeping it just at engagement. For the love of God throw it in low range

    • @concealit4800
      @concealit4800 Год назад +1

      I know rite they drive me crazy driving Cvt automatics in high up hills slow and thru mud then their like what happened 🤣

    • @richardvalitalo3670
      @richardvalitalo3670 Год назад

      Not even loaded, barely an obstacle & cutting out, pretty sad.

  • @ericmackison9517
    @ericmackison9517 Год назад +4

    That's the belt saver feature.... You should use low range if you are going that slow.

  • @1guyin10
    @1guyin10 Год назад +4

    Definitely apples and oranges. Both are good machines. The Honda is more fun, but if you were building a remote cabin in the mountains the 6x would be the ticket.

  • @alanj7306
    @alanj7306 Год назад +1

    I’m looking forward to seeing you guys really push these things. My 2wd ATV is a 04’ Polaris Magnum 330 and I would have no problems with these obstacles. I’ve been through worse with no issues. Let the real tests begin 👍

  • @beliefisnotachoice
    @beliefisnotachoice Год назад +3

    Appreciate the video but if you're going to test SxS's, then test them. Not sure what this video accomplished.

  • @32plug
    @32plug 8 месяцев назад

    You should keep it in low range when traversing obstacles and on hills. Not high like you were in. It’s recommended by the factory

  • @shmac96
    @shmac96 Год назад +3

    Roman: Get a look at all those driveshafts!
    Cameraman looks at anything but...

  • @jimhill5472
    @jimhill5472 Год назад

    All 3 trim levels of Defender 6x6 are rated 3,000 lbs towing.....not the 2,500 lbs as quoted in video. The payload is 1,700 lbs for base DPS, 1,570 lbs for the mid range XT model with a few options, and 1,200 lbs for top dog Limited well optioned enclosed cab model with heat/AC. All versions are rated 1,000 lbs bed capacity. This is right from Can Am brochure. Just thought some clarification was needed. Looking forward to more content on this beast!

  • @SLFYSH
    @SLFYSH Год назад

    Its a welcome comparison, but your course is easier than any hunting trail I’ve ever seen. Not a even a challenge for a one wheel drive golf cart. We didn’t learn anything from the course.

  • @chriscallahan5008
    @chriscallahan5008 Год назад +2

    Don't know if I've missed them but haven't seen many pioneer videos. Would like to see more and get yalls opinion on how well it has done from I yall.

    • @WW-wf8tu
      @WW-wf8tu Год назад

      Outside of it being picked up and delivered, you did not miss anything prior. 1st time I have seen it driving around at the ranch.

  • @joshc606
    @joshc606 Год назад +1

    Yay! SXS content! The Can Ams have a belt saver in the electronics…if the belts cold or you was in high gear it will limit….?

  • @OntarioBearHunter
    @OntarioBearHunter Год назад +1

    Bit lopsided... like comparing a tandem axel dump truck to a F250.
    The CanAm is purpose built for offroad construction, the Honda is a general use.
    Just like comparing the 1000-5 to the Talon would show differences that are obvious at a glance.

  • @michaelmcmullen2397
    @michaelmcmullen2397 Год назад

    Could I please get some honest opinions on these two exact rigs. I'm looking at these exact utvs. I need help determining which is the best bang for my buck. Thanks folks.

  • @joshszydel8202
    @joshszydel8202 Год назад

    Owned both. Kept the 6x6. It has been good.

  • @misterpister3702
    @misterpister3702 Год назад

    I am definitely a Honda fan but just can't get past the cab heat issue with the Pioneer. Probably will buy the Can Am Defender HD10.
    How do you like the Dual Clutch vs Belt?

    • @misterpister3702
      @misterpister3702 Год назад

      I have friends who have the 1000-3 and 1000-5 and both have cab heat issues. Great in winter but not so great in summer.
      I had a Honda Talon. Awesome machine for trail riding. Engine and DC trans great but I prefer a CVT for slow trail riding. I want a machine that's more versatile for doing trail riding and utility.

  • @jessewoody5772
    @jessewoody5772 Год назад

    The pioneer 1000 has 77 HP. And a 6sp Dual Clutch Transmission. All straight cut gear drive - No Belt

  • @MrHayabusa1299
    @MrHayabusa1299 Год назад

    I have a M35A2 6x6 and as long as there is at least 1000 pounds in the back it is pretty much unstoppable.

  • @matthewmcgahagan1452
    @matthewmcgahagan1452 Год назад +1

    You probably lost power if you were in high range, you should always run CVT’s in low range under 25mph

  • @angus42868
    @angus42868 Год назад

    Absolutely simplistic shit they put the machines thru. I have a 2023 Pioneer 1000-5 Trail and have done some damn sketchy hill climbing with it. I have been riding with friends that own Polaris Generals and Can Am Mavericks, and I have done everything they have done plus climbed hills they never attempted.

  • @raymonddurkin
    @raymonddurkin Год назад

    You should have compared the pioneer 1000-3 base, 17k vs 23k is an easy choice.

  • @ethandearborn3760
    @ethandearborn3760 Год назад +1

    I don't know why you're bitching, it's perfectly warm in my living room.

  • @ryzen397
    @ryzen397 Год назад +2

    its the price of a car. these things are so expensive.

  • @yissibiiyte
    @yissibiiyte Год назад +1

    Does that 6×6 have diff locks for all 3 axles?

    • @downbytheriver501
      @downbytheriver501 Год назад

      No. The rears are permanently locked and the front has a very janky POS visco lock that works * sometimes *

  • @JURASSICEDITS09
    @JURASSICEDITS09 Год назад +1

    Like to see test a diesel version.

  • @the_jarmel
    @the_jarmel Год назад

    👏👏👏GREAT JOB TEAM TFL 🙏...HAVE A BEAUTIFUL THURSDAY EVERYONE ✌️

  • @scottyellis3442
    @scottyellis3442 Год назад

    Y'all have a really nice & challenging course but not for these type of vehicles. Still enjoyed watching the 6×6.

  • @jimhill5472
    @jimhill5472 Год назад +2

    Come on guys.....that was dismal display of what they can do. My riding lawnmower can make it through your "ultimate torture test".......lol. Take them to Moab and climb some rocks. Ride them in the mud or snow. You did a comparison of the Defender 6x6 vs Toyota Tacoma a couple years ago and you were dragging logs, hauling hay rounds, climbing, etc at the ranch and that was great. Sorry to bust your chops as your content is usually great. I have a Defender 6x6 Limited on order and was hoping to see it really tested as $34k is a lot to convince the wife to spend on a "man toy".......lol.......could find an old Yugo that could pass this test for $150

    • @americanrambler4972
      @americanrambler4972 Год назад +1

      Find an old Yugo? It would be tougher to even find one that runs than to run it on the tumbleweed ranch course. An old functioning Yugo is now almost unobtainium.

    • @downbytheriver501
      @downbytheriver501 Год назад +1

      I have several videos of taking this thing down some technical trails in sand hollow, UT, Montana, and Colorado if you want to see how this video SHOULDVE been done. 😂

  • @regsparkes6507
    @regsparkes6507 Год назад

    Why 6 wheel,.. load capacity over rough and or soft terrain. ( I asked some guys who use them for a major utility company here where I live, and this is why they buy them, apparently.)
    I'd imagine these machines would play havoc with grassy surfaces,... i.e. don't drive them over your prized lawns. :)

  • @wellthatdidntwork
    @wellthatdidntwork Год назад

    Andrey was ready to get down and dirty but Roman was Too Told!!! U need a stunt dbl Roman!!

  • @spartanchirho
    @spartanchirho Год назад

    No way the defender suspension was a lit better. Not a Polaris fan but they do have good suspension

  • @bennyb6071
    @bennyb6071 Год назад +2

    That's a sweet Honda

  • @RC-wt7fr
    @RC-wt7fr 6 месяцев назад

    Is it just me or did watching Andre drive make you nervous?

  • @youtubecantsaveallthesnowf8601

    I currently own the identical defender 6x6 xt....THE REVERSE CHAIN IS BEYOND WEAK!!! If you are considering any defender, you are going to need to buy the reverse chain upgrade. Especially on the 6x6...other than that. Nothing can stop it.

  • @kellstat
    @kellstat Год назад

    Where's the Honda 6x6 SXS?

  • @TimeMariner
    @TimeMariner Год назад

    Boy what a grueling test!

  • @Mikebospilon
    @Mikebospilon Год назад +3

    I would go for the Honda just because of Honda reliability can’t beat a Honda

    • @gcslade7487
      @gcslade7487 Год назад +1

      I've owned a number of SxS's; I found the Honda Pioneer 1000 is the best all-around SxS for my multiple needs and uses.

    • @Mixwell1983
      @Mixwell1983 Год назад

      Thats why i went Honda for my new atvs last year. Got a recon and a rancher

  • @Ramblin_Rob
    @Ramblin_Rob Год назад

    Too bad Yamaha doesn't send you a Viking to compare. It's a reliable machine

  • @claudenormandeau9211
    @claudenormandeau9211 24 дня назад

    Wow these guys have no idea what a 6x6 can truly do. My friends wheelchair could ride on this silly test trail.

  • @MrBillsfishin
    @MrBillsfishin Год назад

    Nice way to back out Roman. Lol

  • @g576758
    @g576758 Год назад

    I had a 6x6 when I was a kid hauled alot of fence posts and wire I love to have the new model the Honda looks nice 2 they made amazing 3 wheelers lol that was my thunderbird lol

    • @HarryKuloh
      @HarryKuloh Год назад +1

      Cannot understand your comment due to poor grammar

    • @g576758
      @g576758 Год назад

      @@HarryKuloh grammar where

  • @kellstat
    @kellstat Год назад

    Need part 2...

  • @TheMutchlerchad
    @TheMutchlerchad Год назад +2

    Not really a true test or comparison.😐

  • @carlgressel574
    @carlgressel574 Год назад

    What a disappointing test. I am considering both of these machines and these guys didn't show us anything I didn't read under "Features" on the manufacturers websites.

  • @Mikebospilon
    @Mikebospilon Год назад

    I LOVE YOUR CHANNLE

  • @blammo8208
    @blammo8208 Год назад +2

    Love your content
    BUT
    this track is BORING! lets make its actually fun to watch! its trivial as is

  • @davidkallstrom4349
    @davidkallstrom4349 Год назад

    less music

  • @bradenconway9066
    @bradenconway9066 10 месяцев назад

    Can am any day, I absolutely hate Honda even if most people like them. I’ve had nothing but issues with Honda. I will take can am or polaris any day over the honda

  • @TraveladvRajanSRai
    @TraveladvRajanSRai Год назад

    Spending money it won't make much on vids

  • @pandrdoberman
    @pandrdoberman Год назад

    Most useless video 😢😢😢

  • @Ram14250
    @Ram14250 Год назад

    These vids are ok about comparing cars / vehicles and Top 10 and the weird side-by sides.... But where are the real Vehicle testing you guys excel in? These videos are getting boring!

  • @Mikebospilon
    @Mikebospilon Год назад

    NO I AY IM FIRST

  • @engir63
    @engir63 Год назад

    So I do not live in the U.S. here we can drive ATVs and side by side on the street like a car or motorcycle which you cannot (because your socialist government cannot understand what they are.) but it would be nice if you talked about top speed, can the Honda do 120kph which is 75 mph and at what RPM what is the max RPM meaning is it struggling to maintain 75 or is it cruising speed? 1000cc bike can do it easy and all day?

    • @luizbruno2010
      @luizbruno2010 Год назад +1

      Way heavier than a motorcycle

    • @stevedvorak6188
      @stevedvorak6188 Год назад

      Way heavier as mentioned above an geared lower. Places In rural US can drive them on road...

    • @downbytheriver501
      @downbytheriver501 Год назад

      I got my 6x6 up to 60 but it took a while to get there. My friend’s x3 maveric turbo RR is governed at 92 mph and gets there very quickly. We can legally drive on all roads here in Montana.

  • @dudehere340
    @dudehere340 Год назад +1

    Come on dude. Put on a warmer coat 🥶

  • @Hunt2EatWild
    @Hunt2EatWild Год назад +3

    Honda wins.