honestly whatever content you put out we'll love. both playing live (even if you get emotional) doing post game commentary on recorded games is great content imho. so maybe do a live game once in a while and commentary games in between? either way, you should do what makes you happy and works best for you!
0:47 the amount of people you showed catan to and also taught how to play is insane, other catan youtubers wouldnt have an audience if it weren’t for u! Loving the daily uploads from everyone!!
Agreed. EZ solution here is to put a 30sec voice over at the beginning or end explaining why ore wheat sheep destroys new players. Then the title would be justified. But if it gets him more clicks & views he's incentivized to do it, even if it makes him look like a grifter.
Definitely love the post game commentary, but the live gameplay is great! Love seeing your genuine reactions while playing. I bet both kinds of content have a place on the channel.
You’re correct about people getting invested in the game, I watch like 8 Catan creators every day, and play 2 games a day. I’m obsessed because of my friends and your content 😂
we like you live commenting games, but u can also be more concentrated and if needed add post-game commentaries. also, we're ok with u being undercover.
I think your comment in the start is true about you bringing people in, and you could view youtube as a whole as a kind of zero sum game, where you divert people on the platform away from other videos, and at your level, the zero-sum is at that level, but for giga creators, and youtube as a whole, the zero sum game is more cross-platform.
Loving this upload schedule of videos. Also, some of us actually prefer you being undercover so that the opponents are not aware of who you are and that makes it more interesting, for me at least. Great job Dylan.
5 (Ore), 9 (Wheat), and 10 (Sheep) were literally the highest numbers rolled besides 7, and it wasn't even close, lol. Love the content though, and love the commentary!
@@-ZH i understand but you also make progress towards road. I'd have to rewatch but I'm pretty sure he had a brick or two he wantsd to give away and a lot of sheep he could trade
This is so inefficient. It takes more cards per point to build 2 roads and a settle than it does to spend cards on devs and cities. Roads and settles are more inefficient when you don't have to 3 for 1 for them, and he has to 3 for 1 several times over. Also, unless he places both roads in one turn he creates an incentive for his opponents to work together to cut him off and how is he going to get 2 wood and 2 brick on the same turn?
Why not be insane and go for 8410 sheep and 369 wheat? I'd love to try that game out! Just 4:1ing ore and buying devs and nothing else! It would be so much fun, even though subbing 4510 for 8410 would be definitely better.
I wonder why you didn't take the 3-6-9 instead of the 2-9-10... it's much better production, and while it would make your ore more blockable, it would make your wheat less blockable, so perhaps it balances out.
He was expecting to get the 2-6 to balance out his wheat production. Taking the 3-6-9 would flood his hand with wheat early in the game while making it harder to make it to the 3:1 port without the wood. Also, there is less ore on the board, making it more value able for trades.
On the last turn, why didn’t you use both year of plenties for 2 roads and then 3for1 all your cards for a third road? Looks like you missed a guaranteed win
Why don’t people use card stack for competitive play instead of dice? Feel like it makes the game more about luck than skill. Like for instance a single 3 didn’t get rolled in this game.
I could take this classic ore wheat sheep position over here, it's not bad just do classic ore wheat sheep. it's ok do classic our wheat sheep. CLASSIC ORE WHEAT SHEEP
black could easily take 6:3, build to the 8 sheep get the best wheat, the best sheep and also be the ONLY one able to build roads having wood and brick, but instead he took the abysmal 6-3-11 and decided to stay the whole game without both sheep and wheat. Then he proceeded to trade his precious wood for trash. Why do people play tournaments if they don't even know the basics ?
I like it when you yell at the computer; it's funny. And to some extent it is a zero-sum game. Now I just want Drew and Dylan since y'all have been uploading. Used to watch Phantom and Elly, but now I don't cuz it's like... I can't/don't want to spend two hours a day watching Catan lol... I have more important things.
honestly whatever content you put out we'll love. both playing live (even if you get emotional) doing post game commentary on recorded games is great content imho. so maybe do a live game once in a while and commentary games in between? either way, you should do what makes you happy and works best for you!
0:47 the amount of people you showed catan to and also taught how to play is insane, other catan youtubers wouldnt have an audience if it weren’t for u! Loving the daily uploads from everyone!!
Love the videos! Absolutely despise your video titles. It makes me feel like I’m trapping into some clickbait every time 😢
Agreed. EZ solution here is to put a 30sec voice over at the beginning or end explaining why ore wheat sheep destroys new players. Then the title would be justified. But if it gets him more clicks & views he's incentivized to do it, even if it makes him look like a grifter.
Homie put DESTROYS in all caps and y’all acting like he’s scamming you. Relax.
It's a fact that no-one watches videos without clickbait titles. Like, literally half the viewership. Don't hate the player, hate the game.
?
Title Hack That DESTROYS The RUclips Algorithm
Definitely love the post game commentary, but the live gameplay is great! Love seeing your genuine reactions while playing. I bet both kinds of content have a place on the channel.
You’re correct about people getting invested in the game, I watch like 8 Catan creators every day, and play 2 games a day. I’m obsessed because of my friends and your content 😂
Haha yeah Dandy and Dylighted are insta-clicks
emotional screaming at computer is good content fr
You bring such great energy to this game, keep at it, you'll hit #1 for sure. Been watching you for a long time!
Your content is like a ray of sunshine (and so mentally stimulated) everyday.
I like you being emotional and yelling at the computer :)
we like you live commenting games, but u can also be more concentrated and if needed add post-game commentaries. also, we're ok with u being undercover.
Will do this more, thanks for the feedback
I agree, but there is something satisfying about Dylan being emotional and yelling at the computer.
You inspired me to try my first ranked match ever and I won! Keep up the great content
your channel notifications makes me happy for a unknown reason. gg!!
Your videos fr help me keep going. Keep it up. No pressure ;)
Best catan creator! You keep it light and fun!
8:11 I hope your neighbours didn't hear that xD
thx for making these :)
You get so funny at the end lol
I think your comment in the start is true about you bringing people in, and you could view youtube as a whole as a kind of zero sum game, where you divert people on the platform away from other videos, and at your level, the zero-sum is at that level, but for giga creators, and youtube as a whole, the zero sum game is more cross-platform.
"This position is sooo bad" "This position is so cursed"
Still waiting on that expansion video Dylan!! 😤
Those dice statistics are nasty
Does it matter if you get 11 points for rank?
Loving this upload schedule of videos.
Also, some of us actually prefer you being undercover so that the opponents are not aware of who you are and that makes it more interesting, for me at least.
Great job Dylan.
great plays great rolls. gj 🎉
Red made the worst second settlement placement I have ever seen
red taking 6/2 over 8/10 is the HEIGHT of stupidity.
Man if red takes 6-3 then 8-3 I think they have a very very good chance of winning this.
Why did you edit out your reaction on the 7? Channel needs MORE emotion :)
5 (Ore), 9 (Wheat), and 10 (Sheep) were literally the highest numbers rolled besides 7, and it wasn't even close, lol. Love the content though, and love the commentary!
Yeah it's easy to win when your numbers roll constantly.
He doubled their production.
Showed my friend catan and he found your channel lmao
Why didn't you go for a settle on the 8 sheep? Would've been really good with your high sheep, 3-1 port.
So… your plan is to get 3 more brick and 3 more wood while only having access to 1 pip of wood production?
@@-ZH i understand but you also make progress towards road. I'd have to rewatch but I'm pretty sure he had a brick or two he wantsd to give away and a lot of sheep he could trade
This is so inefficient. It takes more cards per point to build 2 roads and a settle than it does to spend cards on devs and cities. Roads and settles are more inefficient when you don't have to 3 for 1 for them, and he has to 3 for 1 several times over. Also, unless he places both roads in one turn he creates an incentive for his opponents to work together to cut him off and how is he going to get 2 wood and 2 brick on the same turn?
Why not be insane and go for 8410 sheep and 369 wheat? I'd love to try that game out! Just 4:1ing ore and buying devs and nothing else! It would be so much fun, even though subbing 4510 for 8410 would be definitely better.
I wonder why you didn't take the 3-6-9 instead of the 2-9-10... it's much better production, and while it would make your ore more blockable, it would make your wheat less blockable, so perhaps it balances out.
He was expecting to get the 2-6 to balance out his wheat production. Taking the 3-6-9 would flood his hand with wheat early in the game while making it harder to make it to the 3:1 port without the wood.
Also, there is less ore on the board, making it more value able for trades.
On the last turn, why didn’t you use both year of plenties for 2 roads and then 3for1 all your cards for a third road? Looks like you missed a guaranteed win
You can only play one dev per turn
@@steve_watches_videos oh yeah, my bad. I played on tabletop for a few years with friends and only just realized that this is a rule
Why don’t people use card stack for competitive play instead of dice? Feel like it makes the game more about luck than skill. Like for instance a single 3 didn’t get rolled in this game.
The 10s showed up!
Hey Dustin, stop watching this. It won’t help you win
why not go for road when u got to 8?
edit: oh you did consider it later
Personally like you getting emotional at your computer 😂
RUclips is definitely not a zero sum game. Poker RUclipsrs have made their own economy for instance, and chess etc.
Exposure is good for everyone
cmon man quadruple wheat with wheat port
I could take this classic ore wheat sheep position over here, it's not bad just do classic ore wheat sheep. it's ok do classic our wheat sheep. CLASSIC ORE WHEAT SHEEP
Why don't you play Cities & Knights? It's much more interesting game and Catan originally was developed as it is in C&K.
black could easily take 6:3, build to the 8 sheep get the best wheat, the best sheep and also be the ONLY one able to build roads having wood and brick, but instead he took the abysmal 6-3-11 and decided to stay the whole game without both sheep and wheat. Then he proceeded to trade his precious wood for trash. Why do people play tournaments if they don't even know the basics ?
Skill diff
I like it when you yell at the computer; it's funny. And to some extent it is a zero-sum game. Now I just want Drew and Dylan since y'all have been uploading. Used to watch Phantom and Elly, but now I don't cuz it's like... I can't/don't want to spend two hours a day watching Catan lol... I have more important things.
I enjoy the Catan commentary, but consider speaking a bit slower. I usually have to change the speed to 0.75x to understand everything.
Yeah, I also need to slow it down to only 1.5x
@@NickolasShely same lol :D 1.4 - 1.7
Please keep being emotional and yelling at the computer for us ❤
emotional man screaming at screen is why I watch you over dandy. don't stop the hype.
It’s not a zero sum game. I don’t pick one Catan guy to watch for the day and that’s it.
Haha live emotional Dylan is definitely more entertaining than post commentary
never be nice
Not true for me, since you and dandy started uploading i stopped watching wanderer and phantom lol
Yeah your biggest kryptonite Dylan is talking too much and timing out lol
The clickbait is getting a little out of hand lately
Red should have 6 3 and gone 8 3, but I bet part of it was the influencer effect, where they play different when they recognize someone