I don't see any mistake. the play was perfect imo and the 11 ore rolling early for you was a huge boost. I would have traded with black to get a city 100 times out of 100. He was going to get a city sooner or later with his setup, you instead were not. Point is that black drew exactly the devs he needed. 2 vps and just 3 knights to get army and no more... that's exactly the devs you want when u're playing full ows like he was. Had he drawn 5 knights instead.... you would have won.
10 minutes in I thought this game would be the staple “perfect game”, but even with the loss I cant find anything you did explicitly wrong. Your numbers hit, and black’s devs hit exactly as they needed to
not sure why you kept blocking the wheat. The obvious block to me is the 9 ore. Black had multiple wheat spots, which only really become valuable with the ore. The wheat blocked other opponents, but your main concern was definitely black.
The thing is, Dylan takes a lot of time up even when he doesn’t have decisions to make. This is a resource and he is totally allowed to use it, but I also get frustrated when someone takes 30 seconds to pass with 1 card in hand and no devs (I didn’t see that this game but I see Dylan do it quite a bit). Now he has a good reason, he’s making content which is enhancing the games popularity, so it’s all cool in my book. But I would hate playing against it.
Dylan takes a lot of time up even when he doesn’t have decisions to make. This is a resource and he is totally allowed to use it, but I also get frustrated when someone takes 30 seconds to pass with 1 card in hand and no devs (I didn’t see that this game but I see Dylan do it quite a bit). Now he has a good reason, he’s making content which is enhancing the games popularity, so it’s all cool in my book. But I would hate playing against it.
Not seeing it in this game could easily just be a result of the editing considering how much players are talking about it. Last turn of the game he is sitting on 2 brick and writes "I think Black wins" and then there is a jump cut where black says "Only if you will pass" and he finally passes turn. Chances are that DyLighted sat there commentating the game for a bit before finally passing.
@1:39 Curious why you didn't start 3-6-9 and 3-4-8 for an opening triple brick + first turn road? Is it because you lose out on the 11 ore? I think that after you get brick port, you can swing to 4-11 ore. Is that too slow?
I feel blocking Black’s ore was more important than blocking their wheat on 5 or 6 as it hampers the other players from buying devs and gives black free way to army.
would love to see some games on the specialty boards like volcano and black forest. those make for such interesting videos and would love to see your strategies
why not settlements in 8 3 4, 6 3 9? GIves you sheep which you're lacking, access to the 3:1 port in the north, plus triple brick which is good for the south port
I understand the rationale behind citying 9411 over 843 but I was confused when you said it was 9 points of production versus 8. Did you misspeak? Also, I love how you don't address the elephant in the room which is how toxic chat gets on Colonist. I'm surprised it's so prevalent even at high ranks but maybe I shouldn't be. Also eff that guy for reporting you. I never understood this. You are allowed to take the time you are allotted. If you don't like the slow games get off ranked and play Very Fast unranked, right?
Great game! I think you did all you could to be honest. Hindsight is 20/20 so you could argue maybe you should have bought a dev card or two. But either way sometimes its just hard to outpace someone with better production like the 9/6/5
If you were worried about orange cutting you off on the 4 11 you could have pointed towards the desert instead right? I’m not sure if you aren’t allowed to settle with 0 production.
Late in the game, you rob the 6 wheat space, I would have done the 9 ore space. Black has plenty of wheat, they just need the 9 to build cities and devs.
Why were they talking about reporting you? Was it cus of you taking thinking time compared to them? The more I watch your series about this, the more the community is looking like the one in League of Legends, super toxic :P Which is surprising, for some reason I thought catan/colonist would just be happy-go-lucky people trying to win, with the occasional table talk of course, for strategy purposes.
@6:30 why wouldn't you point your road towards the 3:1 port? it defends the brick port from orange and gives you a chance to get on the 3:1 before they do
GG in my opinion. I mean I didn't really see any mistakes. There was pacing at the beginning, but but a dev over the city I think would be a mistake and so you're forced to pace fast. As for Blue reporting you, what for? Whooping their butt?
Before the "I'm reporting" comment, Blue made a lot of comments about how long Red was taking to make moves. "Can we please speed this up", etc. I assume they thought Red was taking so long just to troll/be disruptive, rather than legitimately taking that long to make moves.
@@vaibhavbiyani6145 no. I have this account for more than ten years, and I have shared my thoughts by commenting on hundreds of videos about diverse topics. Please don't try to deter people from expressing their opinion. If you think that my criticism is not constructive, explain why.
You didn't make really all that many mistakes. Your only mistake, wasn't going first, and placing YOUR settlement on that disgusting 5/6/9. That 9 ore, with the other 2 being 11's, and it kissing that ore port. Yeah you were running against the wind the entire game, even though you made up ground. It was really well played regardless!
yo wtf is with that intro though, is it edited really weirdly? ".. a brand new Catan account- And rank it up- All the way- To rank - In the World- .. " and then the rest too. It's so choppy. It's like you're constantly out of breath, or if you cut it in the middle of your sentences
Really appreciate your calm, rational analysis of your losses instead of blaming other players for being stupid and not realizing black ist a threat
Really enjoying these undercover, no chat, highly focused games. wins and loses. Loving the regular content too!
No chat isn’t really catan tho. That turns the game into a dice simulation
@@Rob-b2q8p i think he was talking about the twitch chat
I don't see any mistake. the play was perfect imo and the 11 ore rolling early for you was a huge boost. I would have traded with black to get a city 100 times out of 100. He was going to get a city sooner or later with his setup, you instead were not. Point is that black drew exactly the devs he needed. 2 vps and just 3 knights to get army and no more... that's exactly the devs you want when u're playing full ows like he was. Had he drawn 5 knights instead.... you would have won.
10 minutes in I thought this game would be the staple “perfect game”, but even with the loss I cant find anything you did explicitly wrong. Your numbers hit, and black’s devs hit exactly as they needed to
the chat in this game is hilarious, blue losing his mind over the turn times is highly entertaining yet i also sympathize with them
That blue player was really unhappy.
You should play with Obama Trump and Biden, those guys are a lot of fun
Lmfao, I’ve been loving those videos
not sure why you kept blocking the wheat. The obvious block to me is the 9 ore. Black had multiple wheat spots, which only really become valuable with the ore. The wheat blocked other opponents, but your main concern was definitely black.
Watching your videos is becoming one of my favorite parts of the day
Hi wanna say great to have you back my man. Upload everyday and we can watch you everyday. Keep it up!
"ggs red can we speed this up" -2023
Nice prediction in the end! I didnt saw that comming! And wth blue was talking about by reporting you 😂 ??
GG, almost got it
Blue just crying over him taking up a lot of time every turn.
The thing is, Dylan takes a lot of time up even when he doesn’t have decisions to make. This is a resource and he is totally allowed to use it, but I also get frustrated when someone takes 30 seconds to pass with 1 card in hand and no devs (I didn’t see that this game but I see Dylan do it quite a bit). Now he has a good reason, he’s making content which is enhancing the games popularity, so it’s all cool in my book. But I would hate playing against it.
Dylan takes a lot of time up even when he doesn’t have decisions to make. This is a resource and he is totally allowed to use it, but I also get frustrated when someone takes 30 seconds to pass with 1 card in hand and no devs (I didn’t see that this game but I see Dylan do it quite a bit). Now he has a good reason, he’s making content which is enhancing the games popularity, so it’s all cool in my book. But I would hate playing against it.
Blue was ridiculous here though, I’m just saying I see this happen in a lot of Dylan’s games.
Not seeing it in this game could easily just be a result of the editing considering how much players are talking about it. Last turn of the game he is sitting on 2 brick and writes "I think Black wins" and then there is a jump cut where black says "Only if you will pass" and he finally passes turn. Chances are that DyLighted sat there commentating the game for a bit before finally passing.
Just love this series. It's so cool. Also this fast game was really interesting to see.
started playing this game a week ago, love your content. greetz from belgium
@1:39 Curious why you didn't start 3-6-9 and 3-4-8 for an opening triple brick + first turn road?
Is it because you lose out on the 11 ore? I think that after you get brick port, you can swing to 4-11 ore.
Is that too slow?
Hey dylighted
Love ur content
Keep it up
I've never heard of or played this game but I still watched the whole video. Just amazing content!
I feel blocking Black’s ore was more important than blocking their wheat on 5 or 6 as it hampers the other players from buying devs and gives black free way to army.
great gameplay. you said that you commentate too much, but i love it
The 9 ore needed to be blocked
Yea I was curious as to why 9 ore wasnt being blocked. 6 wheat slows orange and black sure, but the 9 ore would make blacks hand unplayable
I like the 6:9:12 and then the 8:3:4 starting with a road with a goal to expand down to the wheat port.
Looked pretty clean. Only thing would be maybe highlight Black being close to Largest Army and hype them up as a big threat
Thanks for the consistency Dylan
I like that at the end the one guy wanted to report you, but then won.
Loving this series!
would love to see some games on the specialty boards like volcano and black forest. those make for such interesting videos and would love to see your strategies
Keep up the consistent uploads! Thanks
why not settlements in 8 3 4, 6 3 9? GIves you sheep which you're lacking, access to the 3:1 port in the north, plus triple brick which is good for the south port
Holy shit been loving the uploads man it's great
bro the number eleven is really popping off
I understand the rationale behind citying 9411 over 843 but I was confused when you said it was 9 points of production versus 8. Did you misspeak?
Also, I love how you don't address the elephant in the room which is how toxic chat gets on Colonist. I'm surprised it's so prevalent even at high ranks but maybe I shouldn't be.
Also eff that guy for reporting you. I never understood this. You are allowed to take the time you are allotted. If you don't like the slow games get off ranked and play Very Fast unranked, right?
12:50 look at the chat blue was so mad lmao
6 9 3 with 4 5 11 to 8 4 looks pretty good
I think u should have blocked 9 stone instead of wheat. He had tones of wheat with 5-6 but only 9 stone
I love how they’re talking about reporting you. What could they possible report you for?
this is my first catan video and I have no idea what the hell is going on but the chat is hilarious
Great game! I think you did all you could to be honest. Hindsight is 20/20 so you could argue maybe you should have bought a dev card or two. But either way sometimes its just hard to outpace someone with better production like the 9/6/5
11:50 I think u should have taken a dev at that point I think u agree too. Any dev besides a knight can help u.
Why was blue screaming to report you? 😅
If you were worried about orange cutting you off on the 4 11 you could have pointed towards the desert instead right? I’m not sure if you aren’t allowed to settle with 0 production.
He also wanted to get longest road. Pointing 2 roads toward the desert would make it so he has 2 segments of 4.
Late in the game, you rob the 6 wheat space, I would have done the 9 ore space. Black has plenty of wheat, they just need the 9 to build cities and devs.
Bro a savage giving Brick for sheep
Why were they talking about reporting you? Was it cus of you taking thinking time compared to them? The more I watch your series about this, the more the community is looking like the one in League of Legends, super toxic :P Which is surprising, for some reason I thought catan/colonist would just be happy-go-lucky people trying to win, with the occasional table talk of course, for strategy purposes.
can you show stats and the end of the video please?
@6:30 why wouldn't you point your road towards the 3:1 port? it defends the brick port from orange and gives you a chance to get on the 3:1 before they do
but the problem is random rolls , I had games where 6 rolled only 5-7 times
Algo comment, thanks for the video!
3:19 also orange has great road vs. black not
GG in my opinion. I mean I didn't really see any mistakes. There was pacing at the beginning, but but a dev over the city I think would be a mistake and so you're forced to pace fast. As for Blue reporting you, what for? Whooping their butt?
*buy
Before the "I'm reporting" comment, Blue made a lot of comments about how long Red was taking to make moves. "Can we please speed this up", etc. I assume they thought Red was taking so long just to troll/be disruptive, rather than legitimately taking that long to make moves.
8:25 you rob blue. you are still racing him to the 3-4 spot.
1:40 "This is a pretty risky setup" -- It would be risky if you pointed the road left. By pointing the road upwards you played safe.
Hmm so you created an account to just to criticize after watching every video? On every comment?
@@vaibhavbiyani6145 no. I have this account for more than ten years, and I have shared my thoughts by commenting on hundreds of videos about diverse topics. Please don't try to deter people from expressing their opinion. If you think that my criticism is not constructive, explain why.
Dude you think so fast in this game!
Nice Video, but you won't get 1st rank before me xd.
Ps: My Colonist Name is Michael23.
Interesting you are Rank 12th global?
A little bit arrogant to say that, but I like it 😅😂.
Hey do you make Gameplay as well?
@@Jannik33yeah but I will get higher in Rank for sure.
Love the confidence man! Good Luck!
You should not have let the timer run out.
I woulda bought that dev!!!
I think this game went almost perfect for u, the thing is it went better for black
Lmao those opponents were so toxic
🔥
It's kind of sad seeing how toxic a lot of players are :\
DontTradeRed - nice nick he has :D
You didn't make really all that many mistakes. Your only mistake, wasn't going first, and placing YOUR settlement on that disgusting 5/6/9. That 9 ore, with the other 2 being 11's, and it kissing that ore port. Yeah you were running against the wind the entire game, even though you made up ground. It was really well played regardless!
The chat on colonist is always so toxic. Really off putting
Blue is the worst kind of player
Fun game, lousy opponents! Seriously, I'd play Colonist 5x more if there weren't as many whingers.
Good video as always, but just want to say that calling everything "INSANE" reduces the meaning of the word. Constant use of the word normalises it.
Gotta dance to the algorithm's tune
yo wtf is with that intro though, is it edited really weirdly? ".. a brand new Catan account- And rank it up- All the way- To rank - In the World- .. " and then the rest too. It's so choppy. It's like you're constantly out of breath, or if you cut it in the middle of your sentences
first
ok dis brazy 🔥