Is Everyone Wrong About Matte Screen OLEDs? | Samsung S95D vs LG G4 Picture Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 июл 2024
- We compare 2 of the best 2024 TVs to see what the benefits of a Matte screen QD-OLED vs a Glossy MLA OLED are.
+=========================++
Come along for the ride! bit.ly/2VZS3fL
++=========================++
MERCH STORE:
teespring.com/stores/villaman...
++=========================++
SOCIAL MEDIA: @tha_villaman
/ tha_villaman
/ tha_villaman
++=========================++
PRODUCT LINKS:
LG G4 OLED TV
Value Electronics: bit.ly/4bz2Jsz
Amzn: amzn.to/44EYPvN
Samsung S95D QD-OLED
Amzn: amzn.to/3IXklC8
BestBuy: howl.me/clVGqFk94zF
Value Electronics: bit.ly/3xdnU4z
TCL 98" 98S550G
Amzn: amzn.to/4bdsYW0
TCL 98" 98QM850G
Amzn: amzn.to/3vTxjO5
BestBuy: howl.me/clwCTVWJX9n
Hisense 100" MiniLED TV
Value Electronics: bit.ly/3On89xA
Amzn: amzn.to/48TO4au
BestBuy: howl.me/clwCI5pdDWs
AWOL Vison LTV-3000 Pro
Value Electronics: bit.ly/3RcRLA6
Amzn: amzn.to/49NjoZj
2023 LG G3 OLED
Amzn: amzn.to/43e3VOf
Value Electronics: bit.ly/3O2vjbA
2023 Samsung S95C
Amzn: amzn.to/3C6m9Fa
2023 Samsung S90C
Amzn: amzn.to/43aIVb5
2023 LG C3 OLED
Amzn: amzn.to/43A8UZp
2023 Sony A80L OLED
Amzn: amzn.to/43BnkbH
Is everyone wrong about matte screen OLEDs? | QD-OLED vs OLED Picture Comparison 
Наука
Love the video - best comparison of the two TVs on YT. Nice work. Bought the 77" S95D on a July 4th deal.
Best unbiased comparison on YT between the two...
I wanted to buy S95D, so was searching for an unbiased comparison between the two...
I love LG too, in fact my current TV is an LG too, but the way some people were bashing the S95D, I got confused, thinking is the matte screen really that bad?
This video proved that S95D has more superior picture quality than the G4...
Thanks man.. I don't need to see any more videos now... :)
This is a solid review that I think most people would find helpful. It's unfortunate you are being harassed by a swarm of LG fan boys. They're been like this since QD-OLED panels started mud stomping WOLED panels. Competition in the market place really bugs them. Thanks for taking the time to put this together.
Ive noticed this too. Seems like LG fanboys are kinda delusional.
Great review. Really appreciate you showing the impact of ambient light from windows, a common real life situation. Both great TVs, but leaning toward S95D to replace older LG C8 which I’ll move to a room with shutters and better light control.
Love that you record your videos in 4K HDR 👍🏾
Best s95d v g4 Comparison video on youtube! Thanks!
Without looking at the price. The tv will be used for movies, series, soccer and some gaming. Which one of these 2 models do you recommend at 77 inch?
Samsung have much better accurate colors out of box, higher brightness, and awsome reflection handling! LG: slightly better motion interpolation. Better uppscale from SD low res. and dolby vision, dts audio passtrought.. I prefer S95D. Matte screen is game changer! and the colors...
Been waiting years for a large truly matte anti-glare screen. I hate screen reflections and always notice them. Just bought the 77” S95D. It blew me away in person. You need to see it in person. Nice review!
In which setting did you set the screen saver at 01:00? I upgraded from LG C8 to G4, but I couldn't find this setting anywhere in G4.
I gave back my Samsung s95d with the matte display... I don't like it at all... it looks like an LCD TV... I'd rather keep my Panasonic woled with a glass display for a while
S95D Color Brightness and Color Volume is insane. Love my S95D. And for the glossy vs matte discussions: i can’t imagine switching back to a glossy TV. the Samsung coating is doing magic.
Indeed
but no Dolby Vision!
Looks like shit 😂
@@gosman949that makes little to no difference and can even be beneficial since some dv content is over darkened
@@gosman949 and no DTS passthrough
Very nice video,thank you,I think you're method of comparison is unique!
This is amazing. Can you do an S95D vs. A95L next?
Really good comparison. Thanks for the HDR presentation.
Hi does s95d come in 83 inch. If not would you recommend bravia 9 85 inch or g4 83 inch
Which one of these you recommend in 77inch, most use for watching/streaming movies, series from netflix etc. Watching soccer and some gaming? Light control is no issue
Great video. We never use Movie Mode, as we've always commonly used Standard Mode.
I'm enjoying my Sony A80L with its semi-glossy screen. It does enough rejection of lights in my dining room and kitchen but keeps the deep black levels. And it's plenty bright for my space.
I just bought an LG G$ 65" yesterday. I can't wait to get it. It'll replace a 50" QNED in my bedroom.
I used to be concerned about the screen reflections with OLED's. But since owning a 2020 48" LG CX for 4 years I don't even notice reflections, and that's with it placed in a room with a large double west facing windows that blasts in full sun in the afternoon. Thanks for this comparison vid. I can tell a difference with the image quality. I'll be sticking with a glossy screen when it comes time to replace. 👍
Thank God for stumbling upon your video!
You are the best TV reviewer on RUclips.
You got straight to the point, you care about our time and you upload HDR videos.
I don’t care how good anyone else is, if you don’t upload HDR, you are irrelevant!
All that is best from Romania!
would be great if you could compare these 2 to the 85 inch BRavia 9. Would be great to know which is the best premium tv out of those 3 panels
you need to compare with S95C
same tech, if ypu want focus on finish type
This is decent. One of my reliable tv youtubers you are😊
I think the issue with s95d is still the lack of a polarizer with qd-oled that can further improve bright room performance. I'm not a fan of matte displays but I'd be interested to see how a polarizer will improve the matte look.
Had the tools but did not do Post-calibration and EOTF correction comparison? That's disappointing.
Can we put 77" Or 83" Inch Lg g4 on Stand, Is their a cabinet available at the back of the G4 for a stand
You can buy a stand for it.
Look at how much richer and more entertaining the Samsung is. WOLED is inferior.
Im guessing using filmmaker mode on both would create very similar brightness with probably the s95d appearing slightly more saturated?, i would have preferred to see s95d movie compared to cinema home on the g4 since those are the less accurate more brighter modes, cinema is the accurate mode for the g4 so it would obviously appear dimmer than movie on the s95d, so i would have preferred it being compared with filmmaker mode, but overall nice job.
The Samsung is really good. I've had both (C2 and S95B), and I prefer the Samsung display. The matte finish would be great in my bright living room.
I had the CX then the s95b, massive upgrade!
Fantastic comparison. I was eagerly awaiting this one and you did not disappoint. I would personally go with the S90D over both of them; it has a glossy screen which I prefer and is cheaper than the S95D. RTINGS actually gave them the same score.
I have the s90d and sadly it is only a 800 nit tv
@@corzabourne2101 the S90D has a peak brightness of 1300 nits.
@cun7us did you read the brochure or did you measure this ?
@@corzabourne2101 RTINGS measured it. It does however, have aggressive ABL and ASBL so that will affect the brightness a lot more than other OLEDs.
Panel lottery of QD-OLED and WOLED with the S90D
Please do gaming comparison. I would like to know how Samsung dims over time games like elder ring
7:22 why does the S95D blacks look light here?
it the top right corner? that's the g4 reflection, he should've put the 2 TVs side by side not perpendicular from each other so they don't interfere with each others screens
Because the matte crap panel
@7:07 the s95d whites look a lot more accurate/pure white than the G4, at least to my eyes. Don’t know if that’s how it looks like in person but the G4 seems to have a blueish tint. Thought Woleds were meant to have the brighter and more pure whites because of the white sub pixel?
S95D looking great 👍
Yo Villa, both TVS look good but now I see that the Samsung is brighter than the MLA LG G4. Wow I thought that matte screen would make the TVlook like crap, but it really looks good on the S95D.
Interesting point at @3:20 about off angle becoming more sharp.... Optics! I guess!
Question:
Would you be able to measure/compare APL capabilities of those sets?. In higher APL scenes we lose brightness which means lower contrast and lowers the depth perception - so that is as important as pure blacks, more important than peak brightness alone.
A lot of people say G4 is brighter in real content - that is probably due to higher APL (or worse Samsung tone mapping). Perhaps the combination of inky blacks that WOLED has and higher APL than ever before (it apparently draws 30% more energy over G3 and can heat up the room) - could unlock this 3D pop people are talking about. Perhaps it’s not only thanks to better processing but higher overall picture brightness. Possibly they have crossed this threshold of contrast/brightness where objects stand out to our eyes. Would love for someone to compare APL to see the difference between them.
Ps. I know you compared subjectively APL here but this was in incompatible modes - inaccurate Samsung and accurate LG. You would need to load up min 2000 or 4000 nit content and see them on both what it looks like in bright scenes.
09:30, thats why you want glossy if you have even moderately lit room
It’s hard to tell if both TVs are subjected to the same window lighting here. Would have been more fair to place both TVs in the same position, and then do a video side by side comparison. 8:30
Shouldnt the tvs be facing the same direction?
What do you think is the benefit vs how they face in the video?
@@tHAvIlLaMaNyou can tell by the angle and direction of the sun light that the sun is low and the LG is facing almost directly at it. Not nearly as much direct light on the Samsung.
Great video! thanks.
Very good video, thanks.
Good video. Motion?
Its easy to dial back excessive colour saturation whilst theres nothing you can van do about white pixel diluting washing colours out
Thank you for this. An informative and bias free comparison.
Besides that’s QD OLED is just the superior technology
No clue
Movie mode with active tonemapping :on?
Yup
Which tv has more clarity between the Two
Haven’t tested them with low quality content yet. I’ll do it for the review
What a great video! Best comparison of these two sets, and love you dont use filmmaker mode. And i HDR! Thanks man 🥳 The S95D looks incredible.
Thank you for the review , S95D is a banger , can’t wait the Black Friday
They have smart shades now 🤔 Jesus, i'm getting old ... i still do it the old way, like getting up and close the curtains.
I have both the S90C and S95D.
I must be living in an alternate universe, because the matte screen is amazing - I can now game with lights
Also, the S95D is significantly better than my S90C in every way, I am just shocked that it seems I am the only one who sees this.
I have calibrated, and used the settings on both extensively. It just isn't close at all.
The winner is clearly the S90D. The S95D is just awful, the matte surface looks like a cheap laptop screen when exposed to light! Luckily I was able to return it after 2 weeks.
@@loopcx3761 Not in my experience. The matte screen has allowed .e to finally game with lights on and I see no degradation
I think ALL OLEDS look great they all will have color differences etc… what I want to know is how do the different brands compare in processing. I have an S90C I just purchased and it looks great on 4k HDR but it actually doesn’t as good as the 10 year old Samsung 4k edge lit led it replaced as far as upscaling and motion of regular television shows we’ve watched for years. Is there that much difference in picture motion and processing between LG and Samsung? Why would my older Samsung process lower quality content better than a more advanced processor.
the matte is more cinematic. but i never watch TVs in movie mode it looks dull I watch in standard mode and tune in the picture
S95d is the best imo
Thanks Bro !
Thanks for watching!
Couple of remarks - comparing inaccurate Samsungs movie mode to accurate cinema on LG is a bit pointless. It doesn’t show what LG is capable of only how Samsung oversaturated colors.
Secondly - with reflections being in the picture - Samsung loses color saturation to the point it looks under saturated compared to LG accurate mode? I mean that shows how much contrast gets a hit. Whilst on LG we don’t see reflections when colors are present, only when blacks. Gloss wins no doubt. Not to mention reflections and picture are at different focal lengths - which means it’s easy to lock your eyes on the picture and totally ignore reflections - unless they are too strong and attract our focus more than picture itself.
I adore your hdr videos man. Well done putting them with similar reflections also. You might be first who managed to do so. It’s fun to watch.
You make some good points, thanks!
The fact that Samsung has manipulated the TV internally to make it stand out and the accuracy is not there defeats in immediately. Add no DV and it’s over.
@@zelko0768 Samsung's Oleds, well at least since the S90/95C and this S95D as well are very accurate in filmmaker mode especially after a calibration. It's simply pointless to compare two TVs in anything other than their most accurate picture modes, you'll simply see each manufacturers approach to manipulating the picture - that doesn't tell you which TV is better. To learn that, you'd have to get them as accurate as you can and play demanding content (= very bright content with wide color gamut and/or high color saturation, scenes with high dynamic range and very high/very low APL scenes) that's where the wheat separates from the chaff.
Regarding showing the coating; VillaMan did a decent job capturing the reflections on camera there but to fairly compare them, they have to be at the same angle towards the camera! Put them right next to each other or on top of one another otherwise we have no idea how the reflection of one TV would actually look like on the other.
@@floz9718 thanks for putting me to sleep
@@zelko0768 So you're an idiot... Got it!
I'll upgrade from my 85" Neo Qled Samsung once they start selling 85" and up OLED TV's. My living room is pretty big so I don't want to go down in size. I can only imagine how good gaming would be on a huge screen OLED and my RTX 4090....
I mean, there is a 97” OLED available 😅
I haven’t games on my PC monitor is weeks. Been exclusively on the G4
@@tHAvIlLaMaN I went from playing Xbox on my Qled to using it as a PC gaming monitor. Still trying to figure out why I didn't do it sooner lol. I'm Samsung bias and sold a 77" LG CX before I bought my QN90A. That 97" LG is out of my budget 🤣🤣🤣. I've been watching your channel for years and love your content. 👍🏽😎
Hi!
Great review! I would like you to measure the temperature of the screens on the G4 and S95C in various viewing scenarios. (HDR, SDR, Cable TV) I would like to see the performance of these TVs in SDR, if there are any differences between QD-OLED and WRGB in SDR. And upscaling SD and HD TV channels.
Yes the Samsung is brighter, initially, but the TV after a very short time throttles down the brightness from over 1000 nits to 100 according to tests.
If you watch the digital trends comparison of these TVs, he explains when testing the TVs with test images and percent widows, the nits measurements don’t accurately reflect a true comparison. The G4 brightness is adaptive and depends on content. Watching real content side by side, Caleb at Digital trends (among other reviewers) point out that the G4 appears brighter.
The person is an LG rep or toxic fan boy retail assistant who pushes lg to store customers. Of course, he or she is going to talk shit about samsung
@@TVAVTechlol what
@Dr_No_PhD yet Vincent from hdtvtest, who's better than caleb in many regards and respect who also has a reference monitor had said samsung s95d was brighter than lg in real world scenario and accurate using reference monitor and apart from low bit rate bc he can't couldn't disabled overscan but now he has learned how to do disbale to using overscan he might be give S90D a better score.
The G4 may be more accurate but the S95D has a more pleasing punchy picture. I saw both at the local big box and while the G4 has better white brightness, the color brightness in the S95D was far superior and more impressive. Also artist intent is overrated, I want the picture quality that looks best to me.
On a side note, I held up my phone flashlight to the S95D and the way it minimized the glare was impressive. If I were shopping for a bright room OLED, it would be my first choice.
Once Ph-OLED comes out commercially, QD and MLA will be done and all flagships will have the same tech as there will be no brightness for color saturation tradeoff.
OY!!!......You didn't say "SO stick around"!!!!
20 vs 2 delta e is crazyyyyyy even outside of filmmaker mode wtf
The LG G4 already won one shootout this year and the S95D was behind it. I get the G4 over the S95D anyday.
Which shootout?
@@Solidariity Mwave.
Qd-oled dominate...Fact!
@@TheBJ2012all day!
And the s90d over all of them 😂
Too bad no 83-85inch size
Keep in mind the S95D throttles brightness by around 30% due to heat
not true...
When you keep bright window for 10 min. In normal use not gonna happen
Huh? Did I miss something Why didn’t you use FMM on the Samsung? You compared LGs accurate mode to Samsungs inaccurate mode? No wonder they tracked EOTF differently - this wasn’t a good comparison.
That’s the only things missing a real heatsink for Samsung
What if I told you I elected to keep the g4 over the s95d . The media playback is smoother . The Samsung was like watching everything as cartoons . Sports look better on the lg also . So keep your measurements. I loving the lg g4
I think I see a kind of gray tint on the Samsung, because it smears the reflection over the screen. In most tests the G4 wins.Qdoled better colors and better technology blah blah, and in general the G4 wins 😅😅😅shoot out and RTINGS
Apple praised for having a matte finish on their iPad Pros, but exclusive for their 1TB plus models. Samsung bashed for putting it standard on their top model Oled. Typical. The Samsung has de best Oled technology, matte screen and best looks, why is it so hated?
Delta E of 20!? Something doesn't make sense.
I always close all windows and doors so my room is completely dark. That's why reflections don't exist to me.
I actually prefer the yhe matte look of a projector image to a tv image would that mean the samsung would be the tv to get 🤔
I would choose the G4 all day. The LG is sharper and has a better color accuracy where as the S95D’s picture is softer and the color is washed out. The Deer and Lizard comparison tells it all.
Its sharper because of the undefeatable sharpness lg baked in. Just put any other tv upto 20 sharpness(including other lg oleds) and you're there
@@enzopied3015 This doesn't change the reality. I know Villa man is a pro and gave us both tvs at their peak settings and the LG is just better in color accuracy and sharpness and to me better overall.
Fake Samsung internal settings to attract the clueless. Anyone who knows anything can see that the LG is far superior plus no DV on one so don’t even understand why this is even a question. Samsung should be going up against the likes of Hisense for true comparison
Or you could just get the s90d which is exactly the same but doesn't have the dumb screen or one connect box for cheaper than both
Washed out😂😂, you are blind, woled g4 is pale, cant even show real colors are real world, white balance su.cks considerably, also if you dont watch right in front of tv you cant notice sharper image of g4, but paled woled colors can ve seen even from 5 meter😂😂
I'm surprised your ps5 hasn't fried itself yet..
I have to use it first for that to happen 😅
Accuracy is overrated. Give me color. Give me pop. Muted 📵 💀 Samsung for the Win
S95D is terrible in daylight. Images are washed out and lifeless. The only scenario i think it would be worth buying it is if you have a very bright room with direct sun light in your screen and no curtains. Great job! Cheers from Brazil.
As a s95D owner, yes they are wrong.
G4 ❤❤️
The whole matte screen breaks and destroy the contrast everyone know this who had the stone age LCD mnitors as a screen, no thanks
Man Please Add God of war in your Gaming Review of these tvs, Man i want to see the colour and Clarity Difference between the two in God of war. There are videos but I am not able to trust them At all 😂 They are confusing
This was a complete and utter waste of time. Why compare these two sets in completely inaccurate modes?! Samsung Movie mode vs LG’s more accurate Cinema mode was a massive mistake. Please use Film Maker modes in your comparisons going forward, so we have a level and more accurate playing field.
Sooo the video told you nothing?
@@tHAvIlLaMaN No I didn’t. I already knew Samsungs movie mode would be highly inaccurate and over brightened due to their lack of adherence to the EOTF curve. I also knew LG would be more accurate because their sets are used as client monitors in Hollywood grading suites. You need to understand that people willing to spend thousands on a TV are hardcore enthusiasts, looking for highly accurate picture quality. Your assumption that we leave TV’s in “Standard” or “Vivid” modes is completely wrong. Accurate modes like Filmmaker or LG’s Cinema mode is what we want to see.
Filmmaker mode sucks, put the LG on standard, colour 65 and native/dynamic colour gamut, that's what I use, nothing below 68 is oversaturated on my G3. Filmmaker mode is accurate to 30 year old standards. If the world looked like it, I would think I'm going blind. Just buy a cheap TV if you want to use filmmaker mode, they all look the same
@@GGP337 😂
That's what I think of using filmmaker mode in comparisons, imagine spending 5k on a TV and then turning it back into the 1960s @@Sonola777
qd oled is top tier to Lg but that matte screen is terrible
👍👍👍👍👍
S95d clear
Matte is absolute no go🤮
Did you see them side by side in real life?!
Do you mean that a consumer is more knowledgeable than the best team of engineers at Samsung?!
You’re acting like they don’t sell TVs to turn a profit!
@@cezarstefanseghjucan jepp i seen it and its absolute crap
Samsung 💪🏻
Ewww
Samsung fun boy
Do you not know how to accept opposing opinions?
LG fan boy...😅
In a dark room, the S95D is the more impressive TV. It has that wow factor. To be honest, I would prefer the G4 if I had it for everyday use.
-Owner of the S95C
The G4 is better your S95C?
@@CaliFinestDemon In terms of colors and gaming, I don't think so
S95 d Black level is suck
LG just looks more natural
Der s95d hat eine Testbild Erkennung hingegen der g4 nicht schummeln braucht 😎💪dazu noch die extrem übersättigten Farben bei s95d.
Kennt man ja von Samsung. Und an noch das grauenhafte matte panel
A delta E of 20 is a disaster. The green color on the samsung is awful. Colors are over saturated. It does not look natural at all. Welcome in the Samsung's Barbie world 😂
I can't imagine the Vivid mode on Samsung TV 😱
Movie mode isn't the right choice for accuracy
I tried the vivid on one of their older models. Straight up hurts your eyes
Can easily fix that in settings. When set accordingly, Samsung's TVs these days can be extremely accurate. But Samsung knows that 99% of their customer base has no idea what a Delta E is lol. So they set up their TVs so that out of the box they're appealing to most while still providing the extra flexibility to appeal to the few
The qd oled is clearly better
It’s wayyyyy not as good. You gotta see them in person
@@tropicalwaffle2348the S95D in store is much better than my G3 on any settings, it was on a completely different level from everything else. It didn't look oversaturated in store and looked very three dimensional. Unfortunately it is matte though.
everyone is trying to convince us to like the matte finish. It is just rubbish and stop making vids to defend samsung. Lg is just better
Or, how about discussing the merits and pitfalls of both?
@@tHAvIlLaMaN there is no discussion at all. Oled with greyish blacks is not an oled.S95d is the shame of oleds.The end
@@mankat6562 you are right. I saw the TV live in the shop, and it really has a bad black color
disagree: 77 or 83 look so uneven when walking by and the reflections bending. almost bought g4 after deep diving reddit but in the store it looked so cheap. the s95d made that effect just disappear. actually this made my decision.
@@mankat6562
Qd oled looks grayish purple with light even with a Glossy coating
Once you go glossy, you don’t go back. Shout out to everyone who loves that disgusting matte coating
Until the G4 every LG doubled as a mirror, there's degrees to it.
If you want accurate picture like most do when buying a product pick up G4 if you want fake picture settings done by Samsung to make it look so called punchy go in that way. Plus one with no DV and it’s not even a contest
Goofy take the Samsung qd oled is superior to the LG and if LG were to hop on the qd oled wave you’d probably buy it in a heartbeat
@@jay2official412 clueless clown