Can Scientists and Religious Leaders See Eye to Eye? | Middle Ground
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 май 2024
- Scientists and religious leaders come together to find middle ground in exploring their worldviews.
SUBSCRIBE for more! 👉bit.ly/SUBSCRIBEjubilee 👈
Watch more Middle Ground: bit.ly/WatchMiddleGround
Follow us on INSTAGRAM: / jubileemedia
Are you a loyal Jubilee fan? Join our Facebook group: / 407942859721012
Want to be in a Jubilee video? Fill out our casting form: goo.gl/forms/EYJEIGgtGTOrb8GC2
FEATURING:
Jess
/ volcano.jess
Andrew
/ oddrobotband
Don
www.donaldprothero.com
Gyokei
longbeachbuddhistchurch.dosug...
Matt
profile.php?...
| ABOUT |
Jubilee exists to bridge people together and inspire love through compelling stories. We create shareable human-centric videos that create connection, challenge assumptions, and touch the soul.
Ultimately, we aim to inspire people to LIVE GREATER.
| SOCIAL |
Jubilee Facebook: / jubileemedia
Jubilee Instagram: / jubileemedia
Jubilee Twitter: / jubileemedia
Jubilee Website: www.jubileemedia.com
Jubilee MERCH: www.jubileegear.com
For brands interested in partnering with Jubilee, email us:
hello@jubileemedia.com
Help us caption & translate this video!
amara.org/v/mja2/ 
Развлечения
Middle Ground is back!! Thanks everyone for watching this highly requested episode. As always, we are not saying science and religion necessarily have to exclude each other - there are religious scientists out there! Instead, we are exploring two sides that society often pits against each other in hopes of finding middle ground #radicalempathy. Let us know in the comments below what future episodes you'd like to see!
Please do Catholics and Protestants!
They should have an Imam or a Muslim scholar its the second largest religion with over 1.8 Billion followers.We need to hear Muslims.
Please make more video of theses bruh, It’s the best thing on your channel
ONLY with:
spirit-ghost Scientist AND Natural-scientist in HAMRONIY and Balance
can you see and find the REAL truth of life, "god" and the Universe!!! O:)
Industrialists vs Environmentalists.
These are 3 religious people and 3 scientists, BUT More importantly, these are 6 very intelligent very humble people.
That goes a LONG way...
pepi88 it’s sad that so many people don’t understand this
Apart from the rabbi lady
Yesss ! The answer!
The rabbi doesn’t be deserved to be called a rabbi- she denies that there is a creator, whereas she’s supposed to be teaching the laws of God
*5 intelligent people
It's ok to say..."I'm not going to do that because of my religion."
It's not ok to say..."You can't do that because of my religion."
Thats the thing in islamic republic of iran you are forced to live like what they believe
As a religious person totally agree
But you can't stop me from joking about it
@@amirseigal2187 if you don't you lose your head
@@amirseigal2187 and many middle eastern countries
@@steffanmevel6599 u from middle east?
It would be interesting to see an episode between religious and non-religious scientists
OMG yes exactly! I would love to see that
it would be very interesting, but i highly doubt that Jubilee would make one
Yh, but isn't the percentage of religious scientists like less than 1%?
Exacto, así parece que un científico no puede ser creyente...
@@djhemp2o5 I don't think it's as low as that. I think it's more like 3/4 of scientists are either atheists or agnostic.
I remember telling my aunt who is extremely religious
"I question religion,I can't just do orders without knowing the reason behind them "
She told me "questioning is the start of your journey" and now I believe she is such a wise woman, as "questioning is the start of the journey" applies on everything in life ,you should never be ashamed of asking questions.
You have a wise aunt
Very true words indeed
yea but if you keep questioning religion in an honest fashion the idiocy and contradictions become glaring clear.
@@oliverfrench2847 false
dude your name and what you are saying do not match
I’d like to see Christian Scientists with Atheist Scientists.
You can just find debates of that.
richardo yeah but I want to see one with this format
Adam Ingi that’s a common misconception. There is scientific evidence for Christian scientists to go off of.
@@gracegiordano4583 like?
Adam Ingi just do some research 😂 I’m not an expert on apologetics but I will have more knowledge soon when I take that class going back to school for my senior year. I’m friends with people that are. One of them has a program called educate for life. There are plenty of sources if you take some time to look into it
I love how the Buddhist monk listens rather than talks.
Yes, he didn't create any turbulence, yet his presence brought a really peaceful athmosphere.
Sign of an intelligent person: listens more than talks
He talked so much! What??
@@emdadahmed5592 though atheists don’t look it 👀
Matt Patterson he’s talking about when all of them were sitting
I love how they chose different leaders from different religions, it gave control and unbiased to the conversation.
And different kinds of scientists
@@brandigonofrieza7277 lol was about to add this
I'm not a Christian but I really like how calm and understanding the pastor is. Loved to see how the flat earthers didn't even want to hear the scientist's thoughts but how the pastor was quite understanding of others' opinions.
Its like Christians aren't a monolith and not everyone is the same. Really funny how some people say Christians are this and that when there are 2.5 billion of them on earth, if anything they have the most charitable organisations in the world.
@@delightk So true. I mean, just look at how they spread all these weapons around the globe!!! So charitable! Biggest arms dealers all come from xtian countries.
PS and if a country has abortion, all charities are withdrawn.
@@delightk well can you blame them, within that 2 bill christians, there are different types of christian groups that do believe in certain things that is used within hatred for other people.
@@TJ-xe1cx could say that about any group though? extremism, bigotry, etc. exists everywhere but that doesn’t mean we should portray every major group as a monolithic entity based on those subsects.
Because in the end, no one can claim any of their beliefs with 100% certainty. Everyone in this video walked a road to get to where they are now, and each road was completely different. Meaning that each person here understands that they can't think less of each other for not having the same beliefs, but can only explain how they came to their own beliefs.
We should all be more respectful of each other, because that's the only time problems start to arise. When we start to infringe on the rights of others beliefs.
The monk is 40, his mind is over hundreds. But his face, 25?
Monk minister look like the ninja villain in john wick 3
Because he is vegan...
AYU SEKAR RINI that’s not why
Stress ages you, a Monk is the opposite of stress
Yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhh
The Buddhist guy is just like "hmmmmmm, good opinions. They will mean nothing in the end"
Its true
Yeah that’s all opinions good and bad🤷🏾♂️
@@TheFINNHERO Not actually. Science is based on continual re-evaluation of the claims as supported by the evidence. When a claim can't be shown to comport to the evidence, then the claim is dismissed. When multiple lines of empirical evidence converge, in inferential-space, upon a singular conclusion and no lines of evidence refute the conclusion -- then that suffices as proof. It's a justified true belief - or knowledge.
In science, researchers continually try to disprove and refute and challenge what we currently think.
Nope - not opinions at all.
Exactly. I’m with him. I just want to make money and die peacefully.
It also means nothing now
It was so interesting that at the statement, "It is important to question one's own beliefs," everyone came to the table. That shows how mature these people are...it's an important quality for any person to have the humility to question their beliefs if something contradicts them.
You can't question the bible. When it says that there was a talking donkey, then there was a talking donkey. The foot is down. ;-)
@@schmetterling4477The bible has been translated several times in the past hundreds of years. There is bound to be some, if not a lot of mistranslations there which changes the meaning of certain parts. We can definitely question it.
whilst I agree that everyone in this video were all very mature, i don't think that coming to the table for that particular prompt is a signifier of that maturity.
Take the flat earthers in the 'flat earthers vs scientists' video. I can picture every single one of them stepping forward to that prompt because they are all self proclaimed 'free thinkers' and their whole identities revolve around questioning what they've been taught. But none of them would listen to reason, they would all interrupt the scientists as they tried to explain themselves, and overall they were very immature. But I am 99% sure they they would all claim that they 'question their own beliefs'
A curious mind (the Scientist), that is nurtured with a loving heart (the Pastor & Rabbi), but is also rooted in a balanced perspective (Buddhist) is probably what I took away the most from this discourse.
And a volcanologist to 🔥 things up
This dialogue was missing a Muslim. The question of things that can't be explained by one's belief applies to all the 3 religious guests, but it doesn't apply to Islam. Islamic view explains everything, encourages people to search and experience the universe in every aspect of it, and the Quran actually emphasizes that the more one learns and searches, the more one believes, and this happens only in Islam.
If you would like more information, you can search the multitude of Islamic literature. I would highly recommend iERA, Sapience Institute and Blogging Theology.
@@MShreefUK So was this before or after Occasionalism became a major aspect, of it?
@Mohamed Shreef the Islamic view is brutally conservative and in practice, anti human rights. I am from the Islamic Republic of Iran. There is no true love or peace in that religion.
@@MShreefUKmuslim are not peaceful when crossed checked....so it wont be that peaceful...they jump into debate with narrow mentality instead of open mindness...no one gets peace hearing such things...when instead of finding middle ground...they start insulting other religion...
Him: “I’m a paleontologist”
Me at my big age: COOL A DINOSAUR MAN !!!
Same thought crossed my mind😂😂
OMG SAME BAHAHA
Was maybe on par with my maturity level. Lady said she was a Volcanologist and my immediate thought was "That's hot."
@@Bancheis hahahaha😂😂
I shouldve thought that.
y o u r b i g a g e
The minister of a Buddhist church doesn't look 40 at all he looks like he is 25
Edit: thanks for the replies and the likes 🥰
Happiness and peace are the only inhibitors of aging.
@@michaelhagadorn2546 trueeee
@@michaelhagadorn2546 I'm 17 but I have wrinkles maby because I'm not happy at all
@@zainatarawneh7104 bald makes you look younger
Happiness, peace, and asian cause that. Im Asian too, and i hope i'll look young at my 40s and feel happy and peace lol
I loved the Buddhist dude. The ocean reference was amazing
It's a classic Buddhists go-to when explaining life and death. They also use a river as an example. Always flowing. Always changing. Its still a river but nothing like the river from a moment ago and nothing like the river a moment from now.
Buddhist minister you mean
I am as atheistic as it gets, but I have nothing but respect for the religious folk in this video. The humility in admitting they do not have answers and they lean on their faith is far more respectable of a position than forcing others to believe in delusion.
Love you guys! Thanks for a great video.
Why do u have an islamicc name if you're atheist???
@@aryanhassan4659 maybe he is a ex muslim
@@aryanhassan4659 bro half the Mohammeds, youssefs, and ahmed that I know ain't even Muslim (yes atheist or agnostic). People choose their beliefs, but don't necessarily change their names
I cringed when the rabbi said "I'm totally Zen" while the Buddhist is there
that was really cringy. The Buddhist guy looked like he was trying to hold in a facepalm
The Buddhist cringed hard
Extreme cringe. 😂
The buddhist guy: oh no no no.......
Why though? I understand that Zen is part of a school of Buddhism that centers around meditation. But in my mind it has always meant being aware and present with your thoughts. Is she wrong to state that?
Flat Earth vs Astronout Please
That'd be interesting.
Yes, I just wish people looked into it before bashing. Any great debater studies both sides of an argument
PLEEEASSEE
That'll be funny
Dany Tri Kusuma omg yes yes yes yes
I'm an agnostic and I really don't like Christian folks but I really love this Pastor
So calm
So understanding
So open minded
the thing that us non - religious people tend to avoid is the positivity that religion brings
It's interesting having everybody praise the pastor from one conversation. None of us know him - obviously - which really does show how easily one can form a judgement based on appearances.
@@angellindbergvazquez9002 The same can be said about anyone. Even a close family member.
Hi Juan! May I kindly ask why you you tend to avoid the positivity that religion brings as an agnostic?
Nah I'm non religious yet I don't try to avoid the positivity of religion lmao. You must be a fool to avoid something which is positive.
Religion doesn’t bring anything positive. It only destroys.
This was not a discussion between religious leaders and scientists, this was a discussion between 6 wise and intelligent humans with different beliefs.
We need Karen's vs gen z. It's be hell
Lmaooo
@Abdalluh no, gen z can't be middle aged.
@@remusnotlupin2264 Ah, ok.
That all depends who thinks they're a Karen.
That would be absolute chaos. I want ittt
rabbi: im totally zen (points at monk)
Monk: did she just-
tonya wayne hi bakugou
@@bqtgrl sup nerd
tonya wayne don’t be so mean kacchan 😔
*I'm
Left side front guy noticed and laughed
I strongly believe that this is one of my favourite conversations. It's so refreshing to watch people listening to each other with respect and having such a healthy interaction. Thank you for that.
People that disagree coming together having a respectful conversation. They have one sex workers and religious leaders that was awesome too, also LGBTQ vs religious leaders and that was civil and respectful. I was looking forward to the conservative Trans vs the Liberal Trans, that one disappointed me
I loved what the buddhist guy said about how we are like waves on a beach, always a part of the ocean, always coming back again, but never the same.. thats a very beautiful way to think of it! Ill remember that on.
Nobody said that lies can't be beautiful. They are still lies. You aren't coming back.
@@schmetterling4477 Its not about me as who I am now coming back. I agree we are not coming back in that sense. The same wave never comes back to the beach, but everything that wave was will always be a part of the ocean.
I’m not Jewish, but that Rabbi seemed more like an atheist to me.
You’re right, she’s not a real rabbi, she’s a reformed rabbi from some type of extreme reform group
She is my old rabbi and the reconstructionist movement is not based in the belief in G-d but what Judaism as a whole can teach someone.
yeah, also my first time encountering a "reformed" jew
She doesn't believe in God, or an after life....not sure how she's a religious leader....they didn't vet her I'm thinking lol
Money and war is their main beleifs ;)
I don’t care who you are or what you do. It is so cool to say “I am a volcanologist”
Same
Agreed!☄️
I used to want to be one as a kid .
Right!? I literally said Wow out loud lol
Laugh all you want being called a gynecologist by other people gives me UNLIMITED POWER!!!
I am confused on Amy’s beliefs. She doesn’t believe that the earth was created, she doesn’t believe in the afterlife, but she’s religious?
That’s what I was thinking as well lmao 😭 She’s literally a rabbi so , what exactly in the scripts and religion does she believe?!
Wow, one of my favourite episodes so far. Although I'm an atheist, I could relate with both sides. I love people like those 6, they make the world a better place
No one is theist or atheist everyone is agnostic if we should be brutally honest
Im also an atheist!
@@xie_lians_beliver1494 Hi. You don't have to reply but can I ask if you were previously a Christian?? And what led to the conclusion that you are an atheist?
@@iwillloveyoursoulifyourepl5557you’re atheist if you belive there is absolutely nothing after life
@@iwillloveyoursoulifyourepl5557atheism or theism is a claim of belief, agnosticism and Gnosticism is a claim of knowledge. And rationally, yes everyone is agnostic, but theism or atheism is about what you believe is true, like what do you think is most likely to be the case
The Christian guy is how I wish Christians were perceived in today’s society. He’s so understanding and chill.
agreed, glad I found yet again another person with iq
Facts
Ikr I wish more Christians were like him
@@TheKlutz31013 Most are, but you never see the good side. Just like most Christians think Athiests are anti-religion instead of not religious. The bad side gets the spotlight.
@@emperorsponge9208 exactly, because the empty barrels always ring hollow and loud. the close minded people are always the loudest
I came down to the comments expecting a war. But... it’s not so bad... people are actually being civilized
C H I Ł Ł I thought the same thing, find me riddled.
As you can see people are getting wiser and smarter way faster than you think, proving only one thing, there’s hope yet
It’s a rare occurrence we should value
C H I Ł Ł Welcome to the Jubilee comment sections. We’re a peaceful few 👌🏿💯
THERE MIGHT BE HOPE FOR HUMANITY AFTER ALL
I am a catholic but I do believe in science as well. My biggest part of how I worship my religion is hope for the afterlife. I just want to be able to see my grandparents again and tell them how much they mean to me and how much I love them.
Exactly it's this beautiful hope which we have and not without a cause.
The term "delusional" refers to a state of holding beliefs or ideas that are not based on reality. Delusions are fixed, false beliefs that persist despite evidence or rational arguments to the contrary.
@@faresmarzouk3742 ok? what's your point?
@@faresmarzouk3742r/atheism is that way bro 🤓🤓
@@faresmarzouk3742you made my day worse; just want u to know the negative impact u created
This is what happens when a room full of people who dedicate themselves to beliefs and ideas of rational thinking and peace have a discussion about them. Everyone here had the common interest of being open to learning from the others, and that’s what made this discussion so great.
Man buddhist monks are always so calm and likeable. Makes you wanna know more about their philosophy
Yeah that’s Buddhism
@@elf_vip_sone_blackjack_arm2254 not all buddhism. Look up Wirathu in Myanmar. Just like many religions they have many different sects.
In general, Buddhism is more a way of life than a religion. The main branches are Theravada, Mahayana and Tibetan Buddhism.
Contrary to popular belief, they don’t believe in a deity or god. Buddha was not a god, he was a man who achieved enlightenment by discovering the Middle Way/Middle Path. Basically living both a life of excess/wealth/luxury and a life of extreme poverty and realising that balance was better than excess.
Buddhists believe in reincarnation, how you act in life depends on who/what you’ll reincarnate as, and that one can break from the chain of reincarnation (Enlightenment) through meditation, living a good life, etc.
AKA = they chill af
Ikr? I've never seen a Buddhist lose his cool, I've always had a positive energy from them...
@El-ahrairah educate me with what you said
I love how the pastor is talking love and the monk is talking peace
In Christianity, it’s all about love. While in Buddhism, it’s all about peace.
There can be peace without love but with love comes peace.
@@frost1804 with love also comes jealousy. With jealousy comes conflict. That's the problem with love
@@delta61 that's logical fallacy
@@Nearaero say that to the crusades
I love how everyone believed that they should question their own beliefs. I wish humans were more respectful towards each other like this on every topic. That was beautiful to watch.
As a Christian this was a very respectful middle ground
This was surprisingly calm. Flat earthers vs scientists went horribly lol
Well when you have someone who prides herself and makes a title out of being a critical thinker it was fairly obvious how it was gonna go lol
That One Coconut
Are you referring to the flat earthers or the scientists?
I wouldn't say flat earthers
@@oarsman11 A flat earther karen
Whould love to see a part 2 just to see what the flat earthers will say this LMAO
I feel like the Monk and the Pastor could become best friends and form a life long relationship with each other.
Steven Martinez we’re meeting up after the holiday for coffee!
@@mattkladnik6965 that's awesome to hear! Thanks for being such a great representative of the religious community, and articulating such a position of faith so well and graciously. You truly reflected a lot of what other people of faith believe in so emphatically! God bless you Brother.
@@mattkladnik6965 this was unexpected
@@mattkladnik6965 That fills my heart with so much joy, pastor.
And then get reincarnated together lol
I think this video was worth watching. I’m Japanese and as many Japanese tend to be, I don’t really see myself having strong faith in a specific religion.
I do participate in Buddhism events regarding my passed relatives & ancestors, enjoy Christmas, sometimes go to various Buddhism & Shintoism temples during my walk and pray, all as a cultural custom or a seasonal event and not so much as a believer,which is also a very common thing in Japan, even though it may sound weird.
Also, experiencing half my life in Protestant school and kindergarten I think I have positive influence from it, as well as Buddhism influence from living in Japan. So for me, I guess I’m made by pieces that I like out of each philosophy even though I don’t identify as part of a specific religion.
You're just like me😇
“I’m Japanese as many Japanese people tend to be”
Lmao
This was INCREDIBLY interesting. I wish it was longer. I was lost in it and so grateful they were as respectful as they were.
"Volcanologist" damn girl decided what she wanna be at 5 years and stayed with that.
Huge respect
she's made of fire....just look at her hair....
I'm 21 and I still don't know what to do.
@@ashokbhosle7947 Start thinking
@@T94869 I was thinking about Zoology, Ethology.
I’m 18 and I want to drop out of uni :)
I’m an atheist, but still love these religious leaders, so wholesome and pure in their beliefs’ ways.
True.
Elpi Noles fax
Love people like you 🤟
クリスタルきみこ
*Jesus is returning*
That’s what he said 2000 years ago lol
クリスタルきみこ The Christian god is proven to be wrong and if he was right without evidence then other religions would be right without evidence too which means that out of the thousands of gods only one is real , so the odds are against you
What a beautiful conversation ! The difference - these folks are willing to listen and validate each other. Wow ! The power of listening and conveying to another “your okay, even though your different.”
3 practical people vs 3 spiritual people....6 people are curious for answers of life. 3 went towards godly path...3 went to proof path...thats why they are trying to know each other...
This is so unfair to the scientists who came for the flat earth episode😂😂😂 why these guys get to have meaningful conversations with intellectual individuals while those poor scientists spent half an hours damaging their brain cells. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I totally agree.
@@martindithers9570 That's because being an intellectual person does not go well with believing in flat earth.
😂😂😂😂
LMAO IKR
@@donijaya crazy people do exist!
Even though it seems so hard to believe
A Pastor, a Rabbi and a Buddhist Minister Walk into a Bar. The Rabbi doesnt believe in God. The Pastor and the Buddhist Minister become best friends.
Buddhism (Tibetan and not sino) doesn't have a god
@@alphestanley7194Buddhism has accession being that everyone believes in, so technically god, but not the god who creates the universe and stuff
@@trilamhuu46 and that's Buddha but I don't count him/her as a god since they're (mythically and not widely accepted) reincarnations.
Something makes no logical point in your comment. I believe to be a Rabbi you have to believe in God, otherwise, I would see no point in that person's profession. A Rabbi is literally a teacher of the Torah. Something is not right here.
@@rosedalinevaletine6931 Was about to take my nationality as a reason for the rigged sense of humor but then I realized saying I'm German while making a Joke concerning a Jew might just awaken quite the shitstorm.
I'm an atheist and have been my whole life. But I simply love researching and studying Buddhist philosophy, it is just so relaxing and peaceful
I'm agnostic, and yes, I love researching Buddhism as well as other religions. Setting aside questions like 'agree or not with this' or 'believe or not in that,' there are so many interesting things in them, even from a scientific perspective
You guys are doing amazing work. In today’s age, it’s so easy to become isolated from other by our personal beliefs not aligning with theirs. It’s so important to be able to have these respectful discussions that bring us back together as a society even if it means agreeing to disagree (respectfully).
Teacher: “What’s your passion?”
Volcanologist: “Volcano go BOOOOM!”
Dam this made me laugh, wow👍🤩
Yeah hahahaha
how is this funny
@noob noob ikr how tf is this getting likes
When u realize tmtheres a rabbit hole on that one
Rabbi: [pointing at the monk] Yeahh, like some days I’m totally zen...
Monk: girl did you really just point at me and say zen
Brylee Dean I also don’t quite understand the Buddhist belief. There’s an afterlife but no creationist.
@@user-pb3po5rk7x so reincarnation is just a cosmic, natural phenomenon.
@@Wesleythelin sort of, but the belief is that there is a spiritual element to reincarnation, and if you are born a human you have a unique opportunity to realize nirvana (the end of the cycle of reincarnation)
@@user-pb3po5rk7x feel free to correct me of my ignorance, but would it be inaccurate to say that Buddhism isn't concerned with the idea of creationism? It's not so much how we started, but where we will be going?
Wesley Lin I think its not concerned with any of that, because it is just a natural process that just goes on. There is a start and there will be an end, and at the end is where something starts again.
5:09 "Science is all about understanding what we can't understand." SO DAMN TRUE.
This was such a chill conversation. Everyone was so mature and calm. More conversations like this.
My God the Buddhist minister is such a calm and peaceful person, I would like to be like him
Practice buddhism then
@@nenonvosky5501 i don’t think you need to be religious to be sweet and kind
@@oh-ohstinky5819 buddhism is all about daily life not as a religion. Buddha never said he made a religion. We follow him as a teacher like we are attending a course at buddha. So u can practice nomatter ur religion. Buddhist mindfulness class are open even in egypt.
@@nenonvosky5501 oh, thats great! thanks for explaining!
@@oh-ohstinky5819 u r most welcome my friend.
Rabbi: I don’t believe in god
Me: ?
They could of replaced the Rabbi with a Rabbit and it woulda been more benefecial lol
@@AwesomeMan2696 lmao
AwesomeMan2696 bahah😂😂
@@AwesomeMan2696 *could've (contraction of "COULD haVE")
Similarly, it's should've, would've, might've, and must've.
As with most contractions, the apostrophe takes the place of the omitted letters.
*beneficial
@@alvallac2171 how insecure can someone be to comment on 4 comments correcting grammar
I love the fact that every person on that video differs and they are still getting along. Thats the best thing ever. Respecting other’s beliefs and not making them feeling bad about it. Loved this video!
I love it seeing people being so open and respecting each other regardless of backgrounds
Rabbi: "Like some days I'm like TOTALLY ZEN"
Buddhist Monk: *NANI?*
I could feel him cringing 😂
Lol i read this at the exact time she was saying it and i felt like totally zen in that moment
iDealaeDi 😂😂😂
what minute was that lol, never noticed
Artist Flare around 9:20 lol
I’m not religious, but the Buddhist Minister’s vibe is so cool
FACTSSSSSS🥰
hot too
I’m not trying to be rude but why did you have to mention you are not religious just asking
@@losvegan6382 Omg I just saw ur comment and now I suddenly have the will and motivation to do mah schoolwork💀
Funny af, you ain't even the first one who's said sum like this 🤣
Even better lmfaoo
It's like he's your master and you're the student and he's gonna teach you some cool martial arts like in the movies
I think they chose wonderful people to discuss this. Everyone was so calm and listened to each other, yet they were still able to challenge each other. They were just so respectful
This should be a masterclass on how to discuss issues and agreeably disagree on issues. The fact you have science and religion balancing discourse is inspiring.
Rabbi: like some days.. I am totally Zen...
Buddhists monk: *say sike right now*
THE DUOLINGO OWL I was laughing so hard 😂
He had this look in his face where he was all like "ohhh...why did she say that" 😂
She is a reform "rabbi" what do you expect they are a heretical sect of Judaism
Servant of Christ what is a reformer Jew, like what are their beliefs? I’m curious
Im actually a buddhist and i dont get it-
There’s always one person who comes off as arrogant in these videos, but there was not one bad apple in this group. This was the most productive discussion I’ve seen in a long time.
Wish more people were like these 6 people. They were all understanding, calm, chill, intelligent and accepting.
This is how all debates should go - not really arguing with each other just expressing your beliefs and respecting those who think different... unfortunately most of the time that is not the case though 😕😕
The female so-called Rabbi laughed mockingly when the palentologist dude shared his view
1:53
There is your arrogant participant
@@Therizinosaurus I mean the way he said it was intended as humor so I don't think that was her being arrogant. I think its her exited personality.
@@iceyrage6121 How tf was it intended as humour???? in what part of his speech???? I didn't see any jokes or humour in his statement where the women laugh mockingly.
This was an amazing discussion, everyone was so understanding and if the world was this way we’d have advanced much more than we could believe.
I wish there are some more videos on this topic, it went really well and I would love to see more videos like this cause this is actually making me think more
The best part of this debate is that EVERYONE here, did not look down on each other. They shared their intellect with a calm conversation. Great!
Unlike the flat earthers vs. scientist. That one was a wild ride from start to finish. The whole video was a "try not to get mad" challenge for the scientists.
now if only the rest of the planet could learn to do that :l
Minarchism4Lyfe bruh
Minarchism4Lyfe you’re a minarchist(as in you’re foolish enough to believe that state expansion isn’t the natural state of the state as an institution ) and watch Minecraft videos. I really don’t wanna accept your opinion😳.
Minarchism4Lyfe there you go again
The pastor reflects a Christ like character, he listened, he answered, he looked and tried to understand. Never saw him angry. If we only respect each others beliefs and not judging with a "you're wrong and I'm right"
.... I read Chris and I thought it was like a Chad type name
(a name that when you say it you know the type of person)
I see what you're saying, but a true Christian would still preach the true gospel message, because that is what we are commanded to do.
Christ talked with everybody but still preached repentance and turning from sin.
It's not about judging so much because Christians believe that God has already judged us for our sin through the 10 Commandments.
Our job is to tell the world about the coming judgment, and the way to be saved from that - repentance and faith in Jesus Christ.
Most people don't want to hear that they're sinners who need a Savior.
but you do know that internally, he probably did go like they are wrong and his belief is right?
@@bluecloudsss and what about it
@@bluecloudsss we all do that
This is one of the most calm episode i have ever seen hahaha.
My respects to all of them for their respectful way of hearing and understanding each other.
Love this episode, so much respect, critical thinking, self jokes, and very very interesting, and everyone talked their own opinions in a ver articulated clear way 👍🏼
Rabbi: like some days I'm like totally zen **points to the Buddhist monk**
Buddhist monk: **here we go again**
nerd in shining glasses I..I.....I don‘t get it
Having a " volcanologist " as your working title is the coolest thing ever
And one more thing:
“Volcanologist”, only means a person STUDIES volcanos.
People have been doing that for millennia.
The job I believe he’s describing means being on the taxpayer dole to do that.
O people, know by us we are actually one descendant, namely the descendants of the prophet adam as and siti hawa,
the differences that exist today are because our mindset is not the same, there are those whose minds are intelligent, smart, mature and some are late thinking.
and there are those who do not use their brains at all to think and do not want to think, thus giving rise to various ethnic groups, nationalities, languages, cultures, traditions, ethnicities, slogans, dances, and diverse religions.
all that Allah created so that we can get to know each other, be able to respect each other, be able to realize each other, that life in the world is certainly lacking and there are advantages of each.
and so that we want to learn and learn the weaknesses and strengths of ourselves, our tribe in our language, all of them have been outlined in this life.
this life has been arranged so that everything is balanced. because what we believe is if in the world the minds of all humans are the same, you can imagine yourself, ribeuutt explain ... hahaha
so that's why the human mind is not the same. There are intelligent and intelligent people, some are only using their reasoning just to deceive other human beings into fulfilling their own interests.
then what are our similarities as humans?
humans actually have the same conscience, feeling and feeling.
and the purpose of our lives is the same. every human being in this world has the same purpose in life, which is to live happily and want to live safely.
happiness and safety in life are our main goals as humans.
who are humans who don't want to live happily and live in a safe place?
because in a safe place that we can comfortably live this life.
in a safe and comfortable place that will create prosperity and prosperity to make this life peaceful.
our enemies are the same, that is, what is in us, selfishness and lust.
fighting the enemy that looks is easy. the difficult thing is to fight ourselves. admit that our selves are weak and there are many shortcomings in us.
we always boast about things that really aren't ours. are we proud of the assets we have, the position we are using, just for what?
for the sake of ourselves. we forget outside ourselves there are still many who lack.
How about theoretical physicist
@@Jilan-rv8rj everyone has a different conscience and feeling. Like psychopaths and murder3rs.
I would say the hottest thing ever 😄
One of the best episodes. I loved all the three spiritual people - their wisdom in simple words.
I appreciate how professional they answered these question and how they respect each others beliefs. It really looks like there just sharing ideas and opinions and everyone is just relax.
I trust Gyokei with my life
Ronza - me too
Me too
Ronza - I trust the loving father God with my life
@@supersassy9441 what does this have to do with the comment
@@supersassy9441 That's good for you, but I'm an atheist and I don't really care
I’m a Christian but why have a Rabbi who doesn’t believe in God? Doesn’t seem like a fair representation for the Jewish faith.
There is actually a lot of different types of Judaism, and there is an atheist part within it too.
Atheistic Judaism? Sounds like an oxymoron.
@@SupaFlossy95 As someone who is Jewish and is surrounded by many Jewish people, this belief is very common. It is primarily in reform Judaism. We are mostly jewish in identity but not so much in religion. We have set values and traditions and are very proud to be Jewish but the belief in the actual religious aspect varies from person to person.
Zoe :p Hmm, I do notice that jewish people hold their culture and traditions in high regard, the religious aspect can be a separate nature? Am I understanding correctly?
@@SupaFlossy95
Atheism is just not believing in god or a higher power
This convo was offensively civilized and respectful. Loved every minute of it 🙂
The monk and pastor had so many smile lines around their eyes you could tell that they do feel at peace and happy
Ignorance is bliss & that is True.
@@thedyingwizard4029 true happiness is when we are acting in accordance with our God given nature. Did you just come off a Rick and Morty binge or something?
@@joannaclary491 haven't seen it, is it interesting ???
@@thedyingwizard4029 yes for humanity, despite it would be good or bad and become chaos for world
Joanna Clary you do realize not everyone on this earth is christian and or believes in a so called "god"
The monk and the pastor could be good friends.
both Jesus and Buddha were quite similar if you think about it. They believed in love and peace
@@ronoverflow5890: There were more dissimilarity than similarity among them.
a monk and pastor walked into a bar..
That would be the most epic friendship , uuu
Chypheir Prod lmao
That was great! Thank you ‘middle ground’ and the people who participate in these discussions!
This was low key chill, refreshing to see people talking and listening to one another with the intention of learning and understandinng
7:08 i'm not a buddhist or anything but what the buddhist said about a oceans waves was beautiful. the way the pastor and the buddhist spoke to eachother was so peaceful, the vibe was really there.
oh yeah the Buddhist minister was my favorite, everything he said just seemed to calm me
That's actually the truth, if you meditate or take psychedelics you could actually experience it first hand. So when that geologist said he cannot see any evidence for the life after death, he is just not trying to see and being ignorant.
@@dayelu6028 From what I've heard, it seems pretty hard to take psychedelics and feel cynical about the reality we face after death. Even clinical studies demonstrate that those facing death feel more at ease and ready to die after taking psychedelics. Somethings science can't explain...
It's poetic and beautiful, but it's not an accurate metaphor to describe "us", the consciousness. It would be more like waves without an ocean. Waves that simply disappear rather than retreat back to the ocean. It however does describe life from biological perspective, just another way to say from ashes to ashes, dust to dust. Which is not really beautiful anymore, but rather depressing.
*"That's actually the truth, if you meditate or take psychedelics you could actually experience it first hand. So when that geologist said he cannot see any evidence for the life after death, he is just not trying to see and being ignorant."*
When you take psychedelics you have proof for an afterlife? Not very convincing. What they do, is fool you to see things that aren't really there.
That Buddhist Minister looks like the most understanding father a child could have
But try can’t have children right?
@@gwaladrielle Yes unfortunately monks and Buddhist priest can’t have children because that’s considered inappropriate for a monk or priest in Buddhism.
He was married and have a child
@@toOzthadiitha plot twist!!
@@toOzthadiitha you serious?
"...anytime I have the opportunity to exercise my faith in a supernatural way; I want to take that opportunity, because I just don't know what the answer might me. It could be something terrific (exciting)"
❤️ I love this lines!!
This was genuinely a great discussion!
if everyone were like these 6 people, the world would be a much better place.
Then be like them. Be what you hope to find in others!
@@stonedNcreepy yes
I dont try to be anyone but jesus
@@poiused your trying to be a god or are you trying to say your trying to follow in his footsteps and do good in the world we are currently living in
@@BoBbOb-bx2tu yes the second one
they got scientists barely related to the conception of the universe. They should have gotten physicists
Chemist is good too
I think the group of people they chose is perfect as it is.
True they should have gotten physicist and cosmologists
They should've brought the three scientists from the flat earth debate, that would've been perfect.
Exactly I thought there would be more astrophysicists,physicists or cosmologists
I love this discussion so much. So calm and respectful
The only problem I have with this is you’re not letting the people talk long enough. you’re not letting all the people talk.
Honestly, the christian guy was so likeable. So calm and open
It’s sad that this is surprising to people. Christians who are very close in their relationship with God are almost always like this. However, you may have found him more likable simply because they didn’t really raise any of the divisive issues that Christianity addresses(sexuality, abortion, etc). I believe this guy would have the same demeanor answering those questions but his answers wouldn’t be pleasing to lots of people(thus making them dislike him)
@@lacyhart7707 yes
@@lacyhart7707
"Christians who are very close in their relationship with God are almost always like this."
Good joke !
@@lacyhart7707 true
@@TheCyrix1 they are tho
This literal comment section.
Why is this video calm?: 40%
Buddhist handsome: 20%
Buddhist really damn calm: 30%
Suggestions:10%
hahahahaa
Hohoho
Fax
But people need intellectual stimulation, and there are no other venues except religion vs ........
AHAHHAHA true xD
Just found you guys. I absolutely love this type of format exists. Keep it up.
Just watched this immediately after watching flat earthers vs scientists. Such massive differences between these two videos. This was surprisingly peaceful plus they were so respectful. I especially liked the Buddhist monk. The way he speaks it so calm and peaceful.
Also I couldn't help straighting my back whenever he sat down 🤣
The Buddhist minister is such a beautiful human being, so polite and gentle. I want to give him a hug.
Same
riteeee... I'm an agnostic but now I'm so tempted to go do my research on Buddhisms, i want the kinda peace he exudes, very beautiful indeed!
@Alma
I highly recommend reading the book: *"Secular Buddhism: Eastern Thought for Western Minds" by Noah Rasheta* If you want a short introduction to Buddhism from a secular point of view, without any of the religious and ritual aspects of it.
@@reverieo9307 Thank you for saying this.
that's Buddhism for you, good luck finding a Buddhist that isn't absolutely lovely
I love how the Christian was so open minded and wasn’t afraid to let out his beliefs
Yes
I'm a psychiatrist and a christian. I always try to find a middle ground between science and my faith.
When they were asked the question if there are things their beliefs cannot explain I do not understand why not one of the scientists moved? Surely there are things that they believe in that they cannot fully explain? What about gravity, since when do we know why gravity works? When we observe a photon it will behave differently to when it is not being observed by a person, but from what I know we also do not know why this occurs. Do these examples fit this question or am I just having a slow day lol.
@@Faxy95 well, science is not a set standard when it comes to laws and principles, it is dynamic and ever expanding. So they probably do believe that science can explain everything, but just not right now. But eventually we will get an explanation for everything through the scientific process.
Also there are many theories present for the 2 scenarios you gave. Theories are equally valuable and sometomes accepted in science as laws. Despite not yet being proven.
@@Faxy95 There's also the posibility that they don't consider science as a belief as the chemist pointed out later he knows there are things he can't explain but he doesn't have a belief for it.
What a refreshing, calm, and very fruitful open dialog, I wish all discussions where performed like this one, really nice
I love how much respect they showed for each other
The monk wasn't saying that he believes he will continue living as a being after his death, he was saying more that he believes we are part of something bigger, something perhaps we may not be able to comprehend. In the same way that the bacteria inside of us that makes us function isn't aware of the impact it has in its lifetime.
This is how some people like to interpret reincarnation.
Thanks for clearing that out. Peace
No
I’m agnostic (which means that I believe in some higher power but I do not care what it is. I just try to be a good person and think rationally with the evidence at hand) but if I had to pick a form of religious faith it would probably be Taoism (basically go with the flow)
Call me a hippie I don’t care I just like simplicity
@GenericGamer no.227 Thank you i agree also that it was a great answer.
@@thedingo23 If you dont care than that doesnt mean youre an agnostic. It makes you an apatheist.
The buddhist cringed so hard when she said "I'm totally zen" lmao
9:18
LOL He was like wtF???? I'm not even zen yet
*MMM*
lmao
Right after, you can see the geologist notice and then chuckle. Lol
he's trying not to laugh
See, this is what a mature and respectful conversation looks like!! We need more of this in the world. You don’t have to be at each other’s throats or insult the other person’s intelligence. It’s okay to disagree. Treating beliefs that contradict your own as a personal attack is not constructive.
Well done. Way to go. I like all these people and their ideas. Great conversations.