Subscribe to FXitinPost! Also if I seemed a bit out of it in the beginning I was, not enough sleep lately. - Jeremy ruclips.net/video/to2SMng4u1k/видео.html
Thanks for taking the time to review Scene 38 and support FXitinPost! This project took a very long time to create so it's been wonderful seeing all of the positive reactions.
Congratulations on a job well done! Consider me very impressed with this scene. The way the sabers moved during the fight felt very raw and powerful. A small critique, the force push by Obi at the end looked a bit too fast and didn't have enough weight to it, but overall, I enjoyed watching your clip!
In this reshoot, Obi-Wan is no longer just an old man biding time for his friends. In this re-telling, he is a hardened knight past his prime. You can see it in his moves. This is a grizzled warrior who finally realizes that his former apprentice has indeed surpassed him. You can actually see and feel the unbridled fury in Vader’s strokes and parries, and a sense of desperation in Obi-Wan’s counterattacks as he gives everything he’s got to complete what he KNOWS will be his last mission as a Jedi Master. There is now a stronger sense of tension created by the new ferocity of this duel where you are actually concerned that Obi-Wan won’t be able to buy his comrades enough time. That, and the resignation in Obi-Wan’s body language as he ignites his lightsaber one last time as he stares down his former brother in arms.... Jesus, these guys nailed it.
Yeah I guess we'll always just have to wonder what an uncrippled, unburned Anakin would have been like. One who didn't attempt the flip jump and let Obi-Wan escape on Mustafar instead, reasoning it best to fight him another day. God knows what he would have been capable of by this point. Force lightning probably would have been like Thor or something. No doubt would have already usurped and killed Sidious by now and be sitting on the Emperor's throne...
@@sidious76 I feel like Sidious would have already had a plan to prevent that from happening, but Obi-Wan in a way helped Sidious have better control of Anakin
@@applejuices Agreed, Rogue One was good, the rest was sjw trash. One reason I think Rogue One was so good was because the writer and directer of the Jason Bourne series did the rewrites/reshoots.
The REVENGE OF THE SITH call back gets me here. You KNOW each of them were remembering the past: For Vader, his memories are of all the betrayal, pain, resentment of his descent into darkness and loss of his humanity...and for Obi-Wan, it's the loss of his brother, his failure and just the glimmer of hope that Luke Skywalker would take up the fight and defeat the Dark Side. Yeah...THIS is what STAR WARS is for many of us.
This is not redeemed Vader. This is Vader the monster, the most feared Jedi Killer in the Empire. Vader isn't blocking or deflecting here; he's BASHING Obi-Wan's saber aside because he utterly wants to KILL HIM; you can FEEL the power and RAGE in every strike -- and then when they were in the corridor and Vader SMASHED Ben into the wall, then near-took his head off! WOW! And then, the callback to Revenge of the Sith before he near CUTS BEN IN HALF just finished it; goddamn, almost tears in my eyes... These guys just GOT this, they nailed this, they killed this and I love it!
@David Tolin Simple answer, Kray-Kray Kay-Kay has forced her head, and everyone elses heads at Lucasfilm so far up her own ass they've all gone brain dead and gotten indoctrinated to her vision. Kill the past and all that malarky. Disney would have to literally fire EVERYONE at Lucasfilm and utterly rebuild the studio from scratch to fix all the problems they've got there.
Nah, bro. OT lightsaber fights are far better and more dramatic and have more weight to them than the crappy PT, which is all flash, rave stick lights, and no substance. Both trilogy's lightsaber fights are still far better than whatever crap Disney's doing though. But OT is the ultimate.
I straight up reached out with the Force and felt Ben’s fear when Vader was angrily stomping towards him. Its made clear now that he was only able to accept becoming one with the force after hearing Luke call for him. The directors did a fantastic job at portraying this perfectly.
The frightening thing to me is his intentions and power but even more it's his efficiency, how he closed the door behind him to seal off the exits without even looking/in his stride. You can say that the imagery of darth vaders roboticised appearance make him more intimidating but also consider that he's still effective and a force not only to be reckoned with but to be feared DESPITE being less than half man and more than half machine. You can see his stiff movements and attribute them to his bodys limitations but he still is efficient and menacing. His breathing is telegraphing his presence but if he weren't so menacing the breathing itself wouldn't be scary but it also reveals that his body can't breath on it's own or at least it's too painful for him to do so YET he is the highest commander in the empire second only to the emperor. Kylo Ren put on a mask to look cool... nothing wrong with that but the similarities makes us compare him to Vader and when we do he seems like a boy controlled by emotion, throwing tantrums. and the fact that his wins are never clever, shows any of his strengths and his losses show us his weaknesses we're not impressed or intimidated by him.
This is the pissed off, in your face Dark Lord of The Sith we craved. Man the headbutt, back fist and punches in close quarters on that hallway, the force throw of Kenobi, you can feel his anger pouring out of him. Outstanding.
That not only was Vader a furious, 7 foot tall, former brother in arms whose power dwarfed Kenobi's and was towering over him the whole fight? Sounds like the Vader we know!
@@CT-5736-Bladez Or they could have used traditional makeup techniques for the more distant shots, and only put Sir Alec in for the closeups. We'll probably never know, unless they decide to tell us.
5 лет назад+1
Baby vs Dragon from 6 years ago. ruclips.net/video/1oHWvFrpocY/видео.html
@@marywise7418 I've explained multiple times why they weren't good movies. The first movie was forgivable. But they weren't good star wars films. They destroyed a charscrers persona to the point that death was redemption. And they broke so many rules without thinking about it.
Well, it's perfectly conveyed who and what are fighting, and the why is a bit secret atm. I don't think the idea is to get rid of Han and the Stormtroopers or Luke & Leia swing across. So my only perfection destroying nags are: 1) Telekinesis is supposed to surprise and overwhelm the untrained Luke (unenlightened audience), so I dislike it's inclusion - they should've found some other way to set Vader on fire. 2) "Then I will show you the true nature of the force!"- uh, no. "You should never have come back" didn't make sense, like Kenobi had previously visited the Death Star while Darth Vader was out shopping for groceries and they juust missed each other. But it's something like: "Your powers are weak, old man... You shouldn't have come... You knew, you couldn't stop me. Now you will die." 3) I get that the Mustafar flashback is supposed to say: This is the fated moment, in reverse. But even that doesn't really fit, and the lyrics themselves: "I hate you - I loved you" also doesn't really fit chord and cadence of what this fight is. 4) Darth Vader is imposing by just standing there. The frog perspective takes away from him, especially when Obi-wan (the only one there) can't look at him that way. 5) Surprising misattention to detail, when they must include the knowing smirk, cut to the retracted hood, then right back to the covering hood.
@@philippeamon7271 His hood is not retracted it's just on half way(ironically enough in a way that is fashionable nowadays lol) but it is not retracted and I imagine that they kept the covering hood to help conceal further the new actor as to make it more seamless.
Well 4 me I was hoping for Luke Skywalker vs snoke in a epic force battle like this but u know what he doesn’t even F-ing see the guy in that movie 🎥 lol
It's better but it's still shit...Wtf is this drama in the end? "I loved you", LOL is this some kind Turkish drama TV show? Ridiculous and unnecessary, also I don't like the lens flare on lightsabers.
What's the best part? You can FEEL Vader's anger. This, Lucas Film has never understood. It's not a simple anger like a spoiled kid. Its deep dark anger.
It's not that lucasfilm didn't understand the hate aspect of Vader. The only scene in which they could have made it better is this exact scene(luckily we have this masterpiece). Obi wan was the only character Vader hated, if we don't count palpatine. He never hated luke(maybe in rotj final duel but luke overpowered him pretty badly) so there was no way they could have shown the anger. Unless they made him go against like a rebel battalion or sidious.
Disney really needs a new leader. It needs someone who cares about the fans & telling a good story & not trying to push an agenda. I suggest either Jeremy or myself. If I ran Disney, I'd fix it.
But this isn't original cmon disney has to come up with new shit while this is from the old movies everything used here is from the older movies except for the new fight obviously.
I know. Look at Scott and Sigourney Weaver when seeing the play done a few months back. Gave them money for an encore, recognition, and special visit from Weaver herself. I hope Lucas does the same.
*SC 38 Reimagined* : Force users in bad ass mode. Budget: Miniscule. *Rian Johnson* : LoOk aT ReY JuMp OvEr dA SpAceSHiP!!! Budget: Your entire mortgage.
@@GrugSmesh I haven't seen John Wick, but personally I'd say Daredevil set the industry standard for fight scenes (especially the insane 12 minute one shot fight through the prison in season 3!)
It boggles my mind how fans could do this but a multibillion dollar company couldn't. Edit: Now it boggles my mind that some people thought I was talking about Lucas films and not Disney. I've been a fan of the films since episode 4. I know they weren't a billion dollar company starting out. Disney however is and there is no excuse for their bs.
I suppose that everyone conveniently forgot that at the time, Lucasfilm was NOT a billion dollar anything. It was a long shot by FOX to even greenlight this. The year was also 1977. It's easy for any of us to look back 40 years with today's technology and software and go, "Oh man I so could've done this waaaaaaay better..." You wanna impress someone? Try to propose how, in 1977, any of this reimagined scene could've been pulled off. Go ahead. We'll wait.
Disney could without a doubt make content like this, but they choose not to. They care more about shoving politics down our throats than trying to make quality Star Wars.
''Needs more pointless CG editions to clutter the screen. And let's add Obi-Wan screaming in pain when killed despite it being a willing sacrifice. And let's have Vader scream 'nooo' when the door closes on him because after all how are people supposed to know Vader was pissed that the Rebels were getting away if we don't use words to convey it''? - George Lucas
@The Black Knight Dark lord of the universe Exactly. There's no need for him to be raging. 20 years have passed. The way he's so cool, and removed from it all is perfect. I do like up-tempo swordsmanship tho
@@MidnightLight. He had more than enough creative talent to continue. He chose not to cause any choice he made, no matter how small, always resulted in furious backlash and hate comments from the so called "fans". Eventually a person gets tired of it. Even now, man has nothing to do with SW anymore and hes still being attacked. Why would you expect him to go out of his way to keep making content for people who will hate him for it? Also all the money he got from the deal he donated. So theres that.
@@toddpeterson8653 Oh I'm fully aware of how good Rogue One was. It's my favorite Star Wars story to come out of the last several years (aside from Ahsoka/Rex in Rebels/Clone Wars). But my statement stands :P
@Barrie Bekwyth None of what you said had anything to do with the video? Vader and Obi Wan are both masters of the lightsaber, it was neck and neck when they dueled before... which was actually quite like this fan made scene, really intense and drawn out. Are you saying that when they dueled on Mustafar it was wrong and clumsy?
In this fight you get the feeling for how hard and heavy Vader can swing his sword. Every hit with his robot arms must go through Kenobis Bones. Best scene when he one handed fights after covered in flames. God, that chills!
@Cataclysmic Dildoser You can see a little of that in the canon Vader comics. Tarkin's group of bounty hunters steals his lightsaber and he goes through most of them with just his hands.
If the fan community can do this, the possibilities are staggering. Instead of selling Star Wars, imagine Lucas had gathered together all the most devoted and skilled fan-fiction writers and filmmakers, and all of them putting together a script and screenplay for a production that Lucasfilm would fund. It would be the best Star Wars movie ever. Then imagine them doing that every couple of years, bringing in new fan talent as it comes along. Star Wars is creatively and financially sorted for decades to come. Instead, it went to Kennedy and her gang of feminists.
Look at Alien. After Covenant, they brought in the fans to do shorts and showed the potential that's still there in that franchise. Lucas should had done this, and we'd be a better place than the crap were getting with Disney.
I think because how the prequels got destroyed by the fans initially he got saddened by it all and didn't want to do more so he sold it to Disney who I guess made him believe they could make it good again for fans which everyone believed for awhile But now both George and fans realize how much they needed each other.
UncleFeedle Yeah no. If Lucas did that, it would probably suck because everyone has their own idea of what they would want to see. And we’d more than likely just get constant retreads of the original trilogy out of pure nostalgia.
I like it too, except for the parts where the rocket launcher took out an entire ATAT, the machine gun guy (forgot his name) kills more stormtroopers then Vader does rebels, and where the planetary shield can block anything from the planet (why not a blockade or landing pad turrets like in the Clone wars? A planetary shield, if possible, would certainly be built around the death star.) But in terms of story and character development it was much better then any other Star Wars Disney made in my opinion.
@@darthbomber2818 Not that I'm a big fan of Rogue One, but the rocket barely damaged the ATAT, it only moved its head for a few seconds before an X-wing shot at its very exposed neck, which is its complete weak point. And I'm pretty sure if a character has been on screen in more fight scenes in the movie than another character has, they are probably going to get more kills shown off in that movie. As for the planetary shield, there was actually planetary shields in Legends. They were usually reserved for some of the most fortified bases however, like Uxio from Legends. However there weren't any space station required to maintain the shield and required multiple of them around a planet's surface. Thrawn was able to beat this however by using cloaked ships that were inside the shield to fire whenever one of his star destroyers fired. And the Death Star was at least partly shielded, and most of the officers would be arrogant enough to believe that any rebel ship would be obliterated by its thousands of turbolasers, nevermind the superlaser.
@@alduintheanti-dragonborn I mean, most of what I consider "problems" can sometimes be justified, but it just isn't the best course of action in my opinion. Like that guy gunning down storm stroopers, the problem wasn't necessarily him and Vader, he killed more stormtroopers then Luke, Leia, and Han combined over the course of 3 movies (in ground blaster to blaster fights). Sure a character could be good, but 100 men with blasters should not be beaten by 1 man with a blaster, especially since neither side is force sensitive. You could come right back at me and say "he was a really big pro" or "his gun is a modified turret" but like seriously don't you think it would be nicer if they just had more rebels fighting there. The way the movie portrays it it seems like a couple rebels beat a force hundreds of times more powerful then they were, which screams of incompetence on the empire's behalf. This stuff I'm complaining about isn't rare, almost every Disney movie has it, but I just want Star Wars to be different from the rest. The shields also have their uses in lore, and Disney picks and chooses what they take from the lore and put it in the movie, I feel like that was one of the things better left in the lore. Of course this is all my opinion, sorry for the rant.
That was beyond epic. This is super embarrassing to Disney. Besides Rouge one Disney star wars has been super disappointing. Disney this is how you do star wars.
For what it is, they did a really great job. Definitely a few parts that felt a bit clunk or rushed in terms of the overall flow and the graphics/animation, but it's important to bear in mind that this was a fan-made bit. They really worked hard on this, and it shows. This really is the Episode 4 lightsaber fight that we all deserve.
Honestly, the best saber fight since episode 3. WTF ARE THE SEQUELS DOING?? episode 7 fight was good, but left a major tease for 8. All we got was a single saber fight against guards and a lame fake force Skype saber fight
ge - it still wasn’t SABER ON SABER action. Guards are boring knowing they aren’t force sensitive. Having two force wielding people hack each other with lightsabers is Star Wars. I guess the goal was to subvert our expectations. Yayyyyy
@@ge-8135 Right, because teleporting daggers and extremely held back choreography (so as not to have the guards just fucking kill the actors) is '' well done''.
@@TheStraightestWhitest I think 'ge' means it was "good enough" that the visual effects & eye candy would keep people from looking too much into the lackluster choreography.
I love how they added a slight red tint into Obi-Wans beard, things like that where people pay attention makes these things amazing! Bravo to the people who made this!
This is the only part of Star Wars you had to tolerate that definitely does improve with time; the fight scenes. That was the remastering they should have done when remaking the originals, as well as realistic explosions
@Matthew Welch yeah but they were small explosions, a ship blowing up shouldn't look like a small petrol canister going "pop", and a moon/planet sized space station should have more realistic debris than sprinkles when it explodes Not criticising of course, they did well considering what was available at the time, but as for digital remastering it at a later date with modern animation technology they should have looked into the explosions more in my opinion
Don't get me wrong, it is absolutely amazing and I loved it, but it wouldn't fit with the footage of the original movie. It looks 'too' modern next to the original footage. The CGI is noticeable, Vader's armor looks different and is much shinier, and the background's ceiling lights weren't in the original scene. It would look out of place and jarring mixed with shots of the original.
0311uli it’s not that hard to add noise and camera jerks and desaturate the color. But if George Lucas added this in you’d be pissed like little babies
I love when Luke sees obi wan and get looks back at Luke then back at Vader and I always love how he smiles despite the fact obi wan knows he’s going to die.
Absolutely stunning. The ferocity of the battle is amazing....the voice over from ROTS worked incredibly well. When you take into account this and The Star Wars Theory’s Vader film it just shows that the fans have a much better understanding than Lucasfilm. Out of the four films that have been released since Disney took over the only scene of any note really has been the Vader attack at the end of Rogue One....and as good as it is....this is better. In a way it makes me sad for what might have been with someone competent running things...instead of things like this...we get Rey vs Kylo.....no wonder Star Wars is dying. Sad indeed.
Ep1 wasn't the best, but that fight scene is the best in a SW movie. Vader approach in Rogue one was badass too (come on, credit where credits due). This was great. Well done guys!
*Yep, this is one of the main reasons why I LOVE the prequels so much, because the Light Saber fights are so epic like this, also i really hope they do more of these, like Luke vs Vader both round 1 and 2.*
George Lucas: Releases new edition with Solo stepping on the Hutts tail, for a price Fans: Releases reworked fight scene with special effects and background music, for free
🤯 The intensity of the this duel only makes sense given the savage way Vader wipes out the Rebel Fleet Troopers at the end of "Rogue One". This is part of my Episode IV canon which also consists of parts from the original, the Special Edition, STAR WARS Revisited and anything Ivan may do in the future. Despite everything KK has done, the Force is still with the true fans of STAR WARS.
When i first saw this I actually felt fear, this is brutal! Vader had been reimagined since Rogue One....he is the brutal vader we all should have seen.
One of my favorite things about this is that this iteration of Vader reminds me of the Vader in Rogue One and the EU/Comics. He's a literal one man wrecking crew fueled by pure rage and hatred, and he just UNLOADS on Obi Wan. The callbacks to the prequels were superbly done and just made the scene that much more intimate and emotionally powerful. I've watched it like a dozen times on their channel and a bunchaton of reactions as well. I cannot say enough good things about this. Great review Jeremy. Thanks!! :)
THIS IS MY SECOND TIME.. It is even better the 2nd time as I see more details . The buildup, the pov and the action is really solid. The fight is fast and ferocious. learn young directors..
absolutely. Like, its not that hard to get star wars right this is what we want but disney is just like "no, we want to do something DIFFERENT" fuck them
This is actually the most hyped I've been for Star Wars since Episode III...or possibly before. Like when I was a kid watching Empire or Jedi for the first time. So awesome..
A truly sad state of affairs when fans have to make their own Star Wars just to be able to enjoy star wars. Ps. I recognize that a lot of fans like Disney's films, but a lot (a helluva lot) don't.
This is the wrong impact though. In the original version of this, Obi Wan was clearly in total control the entire time, smirking and toying with Vader. In the original, Obi Wan never had any intention of coming out of that fight alive. Whereas in this version, it looks like Obi Wan was trying to kill Vader and lost and sacrificed himself out in the spur of the moment because he had no other choice. Also, the prequel callbacks don't make sense here, because Vader had suppressed all memory of his former self by this point.
@@AStageForTheKingdom yes I do agree with you there as obi wan in the original had more control. However for me the the fight is more impactful as if darth vader fought like this in the original then it would give a whole new meaning to vader toying with luke in the empire strikes back as in it truly shows how powerful vader is. Not to mention vader was using all his anger built up for 20 years to cut down his old master as that day on mustafar was a life changing event that has haunted him his life and this was the man he hunted down ever since for revenge as lets be real here anyone would be angry to meet the person who threw them near a river of lava burning them and cutting of their limbs again. But I do like the original fight as well in A New Hope and what it means.
The original was boring af people keep giving excuses oh obj wan was in control lol. They just had no clue on what they were doing. Vader would destroy obi wan. Obi wan hadn’t duelled in a long time while Vader hunter down Jedi
You gotta remember too that A new hope was the first star wars. The music and the prequel callbacks weren't even invented or thought about for another what.. 27 years?
Vader walking with such determined purpose. In the scene you can see Vader carefully measuring every step and every strike is with hate. Vader is younger, stronger and you can feel the mouth-watering glee in Vader as he realizes he is out besting his former master.
As much as I love the Luke-Vader scenes in TESB and ROTJ . . . this is the best lightsaber duel in the entire _Star Wars_ saga. It's the single best combination of choreography and pathos.
Not sure how I missed this for 3 years, but glad I saw it from you. You and a small handful of other YT content creators that truly understand and devote to Star Wars are the ones that can really give a reaction worth watching of the SC 38 Reimagined. As you stated - This too is my head canon and I'll die on that hill. The original, great for it's time and budget is easily replaced with this amazing work of art and love from FitItinPost.
Of all of George Lucas’s edits to the originals I always wanted something like this. This fight is in all honestly huge to Anakin’s story and it didn’t seem like it was when you first watch it. I understand Lucas did the best and the original sabers were really fragile but I would have loved if this was added.
HOLY CRAP!!! I am a HUGE Star Wars purist, and THAT. WAS. AMAZING! I seriously can't believe how well done that was! I LOVE this! I want to add it to my collection!
Omg, this is amazing!! The pacing is perfect!! All the dialogue inlays seem so well integrated, and the original sound track? Giving me goosebumps. Thanks for reaching Jeremy gonna go pay my respects over at the creators channel after I finish this
The add-in of the Prequel callback, made Obi wan's smile before his death so much more meaningful. Before it was just a smile for Luke ~your turn now, this re-imagined scene made it for Anakin as well. The whole "Your my brother, I love you" then the smile ~chills. Guys who made that video A+
Subscribe to FXitinPost!
Also if I seemed a bit out of it in the beginning I was, not enough sleep lately.
- Jeremy
ruclips.net/video/to2SMng4u1k/видео.html
This is why i still love Star Wars
see if the fans can make something that brings tears to the eye; why cant not-Lucasfilm? They dont fucking want to.
Get some sleep Jeremy. You're over 40 and need more sleep.
👏👏👏
Now this is Star Wars. Take note Disney.
Thanks for taking the time to review Scene 38 and support FXitinPost! This project took a very long time to create so it's been wonderful seeing all of the positive reactions.
"Impressive. Most impressive."
May the Force be with you
for keeping the love of Star Wars alive
♥️
... We're not worthy! We're not worthy!! =)
Great work!
Congratulations on a job well done! Consider me very impressed with this scene. The way the sabers moved during the fight felt very raw and powerful. A small critique, the force push by Obi at the end looked a bit too fast and didn't have enough weight to it, but overall, I enjoyed watching your clip!
Man, you did an AWESOME job, thanks for that!.
In this reshoot, Obi-Wan is no longer just an old man biding time for his friends.
In this re-telling, he is a hardened knight past his prime. You can see it in his moves. This is a grizzled warrior who finally realizes that his former apprentice has indeed surpassed him.
You can actually see and feel the unbridled fury in Vader’s strokes and parries, and a sense of desperation in Obi-Wan’s counterattacks as he gives everything he’s got to complete what he KNOWS will be his last mission as a Jedi Master.
There is now a stronger sense of tension created by the new ferocity of this duel where you are actually concerned that Obi-Wan won’t be able to buy his comrades enough time.
That, and the resignation in Obi-Wan’s body language as he ignites his lightsaber one last time as he stares down his former brother in arms....
Jesus, these guys nailed it.
Very well said!
Alec Cobham fukkin’ AGREE!
Perfect!
Yeah I guess we'll always just have to wonder what an uncrippled, unburned Anakin would have been like. One who didn't attempt the flip jump and let Obi-Wan escape on Mustafar instead, reasoning it best to fight him another day. God knows what he would have been capable of by this point. Force lightning probably would have been like Thor or something. No doubt would have already usurped and killed Sidious by now and be sitting on the Emperor's throne...
@@sidious76 I feel like Sidious would have already had a plan to prevent that from happening, but Obi-Wan in a way helped Sidious have better control of Anakin
You see that, Disney?
That’s EMOTION.
That’s CHARACTER.
That’s MOTHERF*CKING STAR WARS!!!
Disney didn't make the Original trilogy...
yea but, they kinda did the same to old luke and shit
@@applejuices Agreed, Rogue One was good, the rest was sjw trash.
One reason I think Rogue One was so good was because the writer and directer of the Jason Bourne series did the rewrites/reshoots.
The REVENGE OF THE SITH call back gets me here. You KNOW each of them were remembering the past:
For Vader, his memories are of all the betrayal, pain, resentment of his descent into darkness and loss of his humanity...and for Obi-Wan, it's the loss of his brother, his failure and just the glimmer of hope that Luke Skywalker would take up the fight and defeat the Dark Side.
Yeah...THIS is what STAR WARS is for many of us.
This is not redeemed Vader.
This is Vader the monster, the most feared Jedi Killer in the Empire.
Vader isn't blocking or deflecting here; he's BASHING Obi-Wan's saber aside because he utterly wants to KILL HIM; you can FEEL the power and RAGE in every strike -- and then when they were in the corridor and Vader SMASHED Ben into the wall, then near-took his head off! WOW! And then, the callback to Revenge of the Sith before he near CUTS BEN IN HALF just finished it; goddamn, almost tears in my eyes... These guys just GOT this, they nailed this, they killed this and I love it!
@@PCFixer you're a strong person than I. I indeed had tears in my eyes toward the end
Disney - "FXitinPost was able to build this in a cave! With a box of scraps!"
L2Luridus
Iron man reference?
LOL THIS
Gold! 😂
@@CT-5736-Bladez no captain underpants.
Ok! You won the internet for the day.
Trilogy-Great lightsaber fights for its time
Prequel-Still amazing and breathtaking
Disney- Rey wins(without training) in 3 seconds
As much I'm a Prequel Guy, the OG trilogy will always be in my heart.
@David Tolin Simple answer, Kray-Kray Kay-Kay has forced her head, and everyone elses heads at Lucasfilm so far up her own ass they've all gone brain dead and gotten indoctrinated to her vision.
Kill the past and all that malarky.
Disney would have to literally fire EVERYONE at Lucasfilm and utterly rebuild the studio from scratch to fix all the problems they've got there.
Same here
Nah, bro. OT lightsaber fights are far better and more dramatic and have more weight to them than the crappy PT, which is all flash, rave stick lights, and no substance.
Both trilogy's lightsaber fights are still far better than whatever crap Disney's doing though. But OT is the ultimate.
Super JLK the forest fight was corny as shit all Rey does is STAB and do stupid somersaults
Vader is frightening, just like he should be. Captured it perfectly.
Reminds me of Vader in Rogue One.
I straight up reached out with the Force and felt Ben’s fear when Vader was angrily stomping towards him. Its made clear now that he was only able to accept becoming one with the force after hearing Luke call for him. The directors did a fantastic job at portraying this perfectly.
The frightening thing to me is his intentions and power but even more it's his efficiency, how he closed the door behind him to seal off the exits without even looking/in his stride.
You can say that the imagery of darth vaders roboticised appearance make him more intimidating but also consider that he's still effective and a force not only to be reckoned with but to be feared DESPITE being less than half man and more than half machine.
You can see his stiff movements and attribute them to his bodys limitations but he still is efficient and menacing.
His breathing is telegraphing his presence but if he weren't so menacing the breathing itself wouldn't be scary but it also reveals that his body can't breath on it's own or at least it's too painful for him to do so YET he is the highest commander in the empire second only to the emperor.
Kylo Ren put on a mask to look cool... nothing wrong with that but the similarities makes us compare him to Vader and when we do he seems like a boy controlled by emotion, throwing tantrums. and the fact that his wins are never clever, shows any of his strengths and his losses show us his weaknesses we're not impressed or intimidated by him.
Darth Vader is the greatest Jedi hunter to ever live..
The way it's portrayed in this, I can f***sing believe it!
This is the pissed off, in your face Dark Lord of The Sith we craved. Man the headbutt, back fist and punches in close quarters on that hallway, the force throw of Kenobi, you can feel his anger pouring out of him. Outstanding.
When Ben used the Force Push and Vader basically absorbed most of it.....I was afraid for Kenobi at that point. Even though I knew the ending! lol
That not only was Vader a furious, 7 foot tall, former brother in arms whose power dwarfed Kenobi's and was towering over him the whole fight?
Sounds like the Vader we know!
Yup it was/is!
This is before the dark times. Before the wokeness.
This comment wins
@@libertyspeak1883 That's what they will call the remake of ep 4.
Eeesh Disney took an absolute wrecking ball to SW!
@@libertyspeak1883 lol . I like it short and to the point.
🖒
How they made it look so much like Sir Alec in the action shots is beyond me, super impressive.
strangely enough, it looked better to me in my second time watching. That's something.
CGI they are obviously very good at it
Super impressive for such a low budget!
@@CT-5736-Bladez Or they could have used traditional makeup techniques for the more distant shots, and only put Sir Alec in for the closeups. We'll probably never know, unless they decide to tell us.
Baby vs Dragon from 6 years ago.
ruclips.net/video/1oHWvFrpocY/видео.html
"This is my canon!" ...Exactly. And Disney's crap is NOT.
oh for the love of god give it a rest.the force awakens and the last jedi were awesome movies
@@marywise7418 hahaha You must have seen two totally different movies than I did!! Good for you.
@@toadsmoothy everyone has their likes and dislikes.so you didnt like them big del i did all that matters to me
@@marywise7418 I've explained multiple times why they weren't good movies.
The first movie was forgivable. But they weren't good star wars films.
They destroyed a charscrers persona to the point that death was redemption. And they broke so many rules without thinking about it.
mary wise shut the fuck up those movies were terrible, deal with it
I actually smiled during this. It's been a while since I've smiled for anything star wars!! This is awsome!
Absolutely! I'll give Rogue One a pass but all the other new movies have been SO shit!
Thumbs up if you accept this as CANON!
👏Yes!
Oh this is absolutely true
Yup that's how it happened.
👍
Yes!
You can actually feel Vader's hatred in the way he fights. Its awesome.
Well, it's perfectly conveyed who and what are fighting, and the why is a bit secret atm.
I don't think the idea is to get rid of Han and the Stormtroopers or Luke & Leia swing across. So my only perfection destroying nags are:
1) Telekinesis is supposed to surprise and overwhelm the untrained Luke (unenlightened audience), so I dislike it's inclusion - they should've found some other way to set Vader on fire.
2) "Then I will show you the true nature of the force!"- uh, no. "You should never have come back" didn't make sense, like Kenobi had previously visited the Death Star while Darth Vader was out shopping for groceries and they juust missed each other. But it's something like: "Your powers are weak, old man... You shouldn't have come... You knew, you couldn't stop me. Now you will die."
3) I get that the Mustafar flashback is supposed to say: This is the fated moment, in reverse. But even that doesn't really fit, and the lyrics themselves: "I hate you - I loved you" also doesn't really fit chord and cadence of what this fight is.
4) Darth Vader is imposing by just standing there. The frog perspective takes away from him, especially when Obi-wan (the only one there) can't look at him that way.
5) Surprising misattention to detail, when they must include the knowing smirk, cut to the retracted hood, then right back to the covering hood.
@@philippeamon7271 Welp, everyones entitled to their opinion. Me personally, I find it to be well constructed. I enjoyed it!
@@isaaca.7732 i think this comment is saying why he wouldn't change the original scene with this, and i think we can all agree
@@philippeamon7271 His hood is not retracted it's just on half way(ironically enough in a way that is fashionable nowadays lol) but it is not retracted and I imagine that they kept the covering hood to help conceal further the new actor as to make it more seamless.
I enjoy the fact that when Vader says: "your powers are weack old man" the pose Is almost identical to a concept art for Vader by Ralph McQuarrie.
Vader on fire! Holy Shit! Goosebumps. This is STAR WARS!
Fans make good Star Wars because they love Star Wars, while Disney views Star Wars as its prostitute
That wasn't the first time Vader was on fire, fam
@@reek4062 😂😂😂
Thats a gd one bro!
And yet, The Last Jedi couldn’t have Luke do something like this.
Well 4 me I was hoping for Luke Skywalker vs snoke in a epic force battle like this but u know what he doesn’t even F-ing see the guy in that movie 🎥 lol
They wanted to "subvert expectations" and they succeeded that by giving us a fat juicy shit burger nobody wanted.
LovelessDogg *The Gay Awakens you mean
So much better than ep 7 nd 8.
Move on.
FACTS!!!!
Because this was made with passion
And 9, don't forget about 9.
I know it not out yet, but holy fuck!! There no way to save it.
It's better but it's still shit...Wtf is this drama in the end? "I loved you", LOL is this some kind Turkish drama TV show? Ridiculous and unnecessary, also I don't like the lens flare on lightsabers.
This is what happens when you have PASSION and RESPECT for the lore - it shines through! Well done to the creators of this magnificent project!
That's no moon, it's a space station.
Luke: "No, it's not. It's Rian Johnson's abnormally large and round head!"
What's the best part? You can FEEL Vader's anger. This, Lucas Film has never understood. It's not a simple anger like a spoiled kid.
Its deep dark anger.
Only place I've felt it is in Rebels when Ahsoka confronts Vader at the Sith Temple. And even that doesn't compare to this
that aspect is fantastic! the best thing about it. feels near enough as to how it would really break down.
It's not that lucasfilm didn't understand the hate aspect of Vader. The only scene in which they could have made it better is this exact scene(luckily we have this masterpiece). Obi wan was the only character Vader hated, if we don't count palpatine. He never hated luke(maybe in rotj final duel but luke overpowered him pretty badly) so there was no way they could have shown the anger. Unless they made him go against like a rebel battalion or sidious.
Makes Vader so darn scary! And you can't even see his face!
Richard McGowan: I agree with you. I wouldn’t want to meet up with this Darth Vader ever. He moves with purpose and danger.
More feels in that short time than all of what Disney Star Wars could pull off.
Sad.
But it still doesn’t have jar jar
@@firenze6424 this doesn't have jar jar either
Disney really needs a new leader. It needs someone who cares about the fans & telling a good story & not trying to push an agenda. I suggest either Jeremy or myself. If I ran Disney, I'd fix it.
Well I honestly had great feels when i saw Han and Chewie together again in Force Awakens.
But this isn't original cmon disney has to come up with new shit while this is from the old movies everything used here is from the older movies except for the new fight obviously.
It would be epic if George Lucas saw this and gave it the recognition the creators deserve
I know. Look at Scott and Sigourney Weaver when seeing the play done a few months back. Gave them money for an encore, recognition, and special visit from Weaver herself. I hope Lucas does the same.
Someone please give this guy money to make a Special Edition and an actual Third Trilogy!
*SC 38 Reimagined* : Force users in bad ass mode. Budget: Miniscule.
*Rian Johnson* : LoOk aT ReY JuMp OvEr dA SpAceSHiP!!! Budget: Your entire mortgage.
🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Eh, JJ filmed and crafted the scene of Rey jumping over the ship, not Rian, but I get your point
You just won the internet today!
Reality is often disappointing. JJ is to blame for that one, but Rian made her lift an entire mountain with zero effort and no training.
Thats one of the many examples that there are some things you cant simply buy :)
I like how they filmmakers followed the John wick formula of making a good fight scene instead of the last jedi crap.
John Wick should be the new industry standard for Hollywood action scenes.
@@GrugSmesh I haven't seen John Wick, but personally I'd say Daredevil set the industry standard for fight scenes (especially the insane 12 minute one shot fight through the prison in season 3!)
As his barber, I would have to agree with you whole heartedly!
They actually look like they're trying to hit each other rather than a dance
That showcase Vader perfectly. His aggression & power.
Dem one handed swings tho!!!
This connects the skill and ferocity that Anakin had in ROTS and Vader had in R1, with his saber fights in TESB and ROTJ.
Darn right it's better! At least I'm featured in this video! It's like Disney forgot I existed!!!
You're dead, Thanos.
“No ones ever really gone.”
@@thanos7459 Welcome, I am the Grim Reaper.
My pussy hurts
Disney forgot everyone existed except Leia, as if she was the main character of the OT and not Luke.
It boggles my mind how fans could do this but a multibillion dollar company couldn't.
Edit: Now it boggles my mind that some people thought I was talking about Lucas films and not Disney. I've been a fan of the films since episode 4. I know they weren't a billion dollar company starting out. Disney however is and there is no excuse for their bs.
Money can't buy talent, passion and imagination, something those people will never understand.
It’s no trick. Everything good is under attack welcome to hell.
I suppose that everyone conveniently forgot that at the time, Lucasfilm was NOT a billion dollar anything. It was a long shot by FOX to even greenlight this. The year was also 1977.
It's easy for any of us to look back 40 years with today's technology and software and go, "Oh man I so could've done this waaaaaaay better..."
You wanna impress someone? Try to propose how, in 1977, any of this reimagined scene could've been pulled off. Go ahead. We'll wait.
Disney could without a doubt make content like this, but they choose not to. They care more about shoving politics down our throats than trying to make quality Star Wars.
@@fredrikengstrom2107 Money can't buy talent. CalArts doesn't teach passion or imagination either... only a shortcut to work at Disney.
Go figure.
as vader walks away "who has the high ground now?"
Still Obi
puddle of goo on my shoe
Know what the saddest part is?
Disney will probably try to have this taken down...
well considering the fact star wars is a copyrighted product and the person had no right usein it probably so
Let them. Streisand effect will not let us forget it.
Download it while you have the chance!!!
He can upload this on bitchute
@@marywise7418 it's starting to look like you're a disney shill
Lucas would smile in approval for what they’ve done.
The Black Knight Dark lord of the universe How come?
''Needs more pointless CG editions to clutter the screen. And let's add Obi-Wan screaming in pain when killed despite it being a willing sacrifice. And let's have Vader scream 'nooo' when the door closes on him because after all how are people supposed to know Vader was pissed that the Rebels were getting away if we don't use words to convey it''? - George Lucas
Watch your tone boy or I'll digitally replace you with Hayden Christensen.
@The Black Knight Dark lord of the universe Exactly. There's no need for him to be raging. 20 years have passed. The way he's so cool, and removed from it all is perfect. I do like up-tempo swordsmanship tho
@@MidnightLight. He had more than enough creative talent to continue. He chose not to cause any choice he made, no matter how small, always resulted in furious backlash and hate comments from the so called "fans". Eventually a person gets tired of it. Even now, man has nothing to do with SW anymore and hes still being attacked. Why would you expect him to go out of his way to keep making content for people who will hate him for it? Also all the money he got from the deal he donated. So theres that.
6 Minutes of fan-made content > ALL Star Wars Movies released since Disney took over
Change My Mind
Except maybe Rogue One but because of nostalgia and the tension and the prequel quotes too yes absolutely
Rogue One, easily. But I still got to give these guys a lot of credit!
Disneys new canon is a myth change my mind
@@toddpeterson8653 Oh I'm fully aware of how good Rogue One was. It's my favorite Star Wars story to come out of the last several years (aside from Ahsoka/Rex in Rebels/Clone Wars).
But my statement stands :P
@@GaldierMusic You were right the first time. Rogue One was monotonous, contrived and pointless, with a completely forgettable cast.
Hey GG did u notice that in the comments someone said to send this to Rey and Kylo to teach them how to properly duel with lightsabers
Gabriel Sidloi Rey and kylo ren are children playing with toys compared to the prowess of the old masters, to quote kreia
@Barrie Bekwyth Wtf would be an example of how to fight with a lightsaber then?
Rustarus ignore the ignoramus he knows not of what he does nor does he have a Brain
@Barrie Bekwyth None of what you said had anything to do with the video? Vader and Obi Wan are both masters of the lightsaber, it was neck and neck when they dueled before... which was actually quite like this fan made scene, really intense and drawn out. Are you saying that when they dueled on Mustafar it was wrong and clumsy?
To be fair, most of the records for lightsaber combat hasn't exactly been kept well since the Jedi Order died.
Also: Disney’s reimagining of this world be the Princess taking on and beating Vader
Just when you thought you couldn't hate 7&8 any more this masterpiece comes along.
I think we found the cure for Star Wars "fatigue"!
It's even more emotional having watched all of The Clones Wars, knowing how close they were.
What a great franchise totally ruined. It makes me sick.
And all the wasted potential
Eighth time watching and I still get chills. Masterful work.
The prequel call backs are what make it so much more meaningful.
These fan creations are so embarrassing for Disney and Lucasfilm.
That's the best part. The hate is swelling in them now. SJW fools.
@@Dousch Yup
Nathan Chu when he missed her head ?
I like how all the fan creations that disney has to compete with all center around the empire
@@ratbat1072 Because the Empire is cool ! :D
In this fight you get the feeling for how hard and heavy Vader can swing his sword. Every hit with his robot arms must go through Kenobis Bones. Best scene when he one handed fights after covered in flames. God, that chills!
@Cataclysmic Dildoser You can see a little of that in the canon Vader comics. Tarkin's group of bounty hunters steals his lightsaber and he goes through most of them with just his hands.
Adding them Italian and German longsword techniques i see... Much more sexy than basic katana.
@Tedman Torres basically same to katana. But more mix combinations due to having a double edged blade. Two edges on both sides.
That is perfect. The original duel is obviously great on its own but this interpretation of it makes it even more epic.
If the fan community can do this, the possibilities are staggering.
Instead of selling Star Wars, imagine Lucas had gathered together all the most devoted and skilled fan-fiction writers and filmmakers, and all of them putting together a script and screenplay for a production that Lucasfilm would fund. It would be the best Star Wars movie ever.
Then imagine them doing that every couple of years, bringing in new fan talent as it comes along. Star Wars is creatively and financially sorted for decades to come.
Instead, it went to Kennedy and her gang of feminists.
Look at Alien. After Covenant, they brought in the fans to do shorts and showed the potential that's still there in that franchise. Lucas should had done this, and we'd be a better place than the crap were getting with Disney.
I think because how the prequels got destroyed by the fans initially he got saddened by it all and didn't want to do more so he sold it to Disney who I guess made him believe they could make it good again for fans which everyone believed for awhile
But now both George and fans realize how much they needed each other.
UncleFeedle Lucas DID do that with “Star Wars Live Action TV Series” but he kept delaying it due to budgeting
UncleFeedle Yeah no. If Lucas did that, it would probably suck because everyone has their own idea of what they would want to see. And we’d more than likely just get constant retreads of the original trilogy out of pure nostalgia.
@UncleFeedle
Lucas did all that when the expanded universe was a thing and then Disney scrape it all down the drain.
Rogue One gets my official pardon. I watched it again last night and then watvhed SC 38 as a Post Credits scene.
I like it too, except for the parts where the rocket launcher took out an entire ATAT, the machine gun guy (forgot his name) kills more stormtroopers then Vader does rebels, and where the planetary shield can block anything from the planet (why not a blockade or landing pad turrets like in the Clone wars? A planetary shield, if possible, would certainly be built around the death star.) But in terms of story and character development it was much better then any other Star Wars Disney made in my opinion.
Maestro Drake rogue one is garbage
@@darthbomber2818 Not that I'm a big fan of Rogue One, but the rocket barely damaged the ATAT, it only moved its head for a few seconds before an X-wing shot at its very exposed neck, which is its complete weak point. And I'm pretty sure if a character has been on screen in more fight scenes in the movie than another character has, they are probably going to get more kills shown off in that movie. As for the planetary shield, there was actually planetary shields in Legends. They were usually reserved for some of the most fortified bases however, like Uxio from Legends. However there weren't any space station required to maintain the shield and required multiple of them around a planet's surface. Thrawn was able to beat this however by using cloaked ships that were inside the shield to fire whenever one of his star destroyers fired. And the Death Star was at least partly shielded, and most of the officers would be arrogant enough to believe that any rebel ship would be obliterated by its thousands of turbolasers, nevermind the superlaser.
Rogue 1 was great.
@@alduintheanti-dragonborn I mean, most of what I consider "problems" can sometimes be justified, but it just isn't the best course of action in my opinion. Like that guy gunning down storm stroopers, the problem wasn't necessarily him and Vader, he killed more stormtroopers then Luke, Leia, and Han combined over the course of 3 movies (in ground blaster to blaster fights). Sure a character could be good, but 100 men with blasters should not be beaten by 1 man with a blaster, especially since neither side is force sensitive. You could come right back at me and say "he was a really big pro" or "his gun is a modified turret" but like seriously don't you think it would be nicer if they just had more rebels fighting there. The way the movie portrays it it seems like a couple rebels beat a force hundreds of times more powerful then they were, which screams of incompetence on the empire's behalf. This stuff I'm complaining about isn't rare, almost every Disney movie has it, but I just want Star Wars to be different from the rest. The shields also have their uses in lore, and Disney picks and chooses what they take from the lore and put it in the movie, I feel like that was one of the things better left in the lore. Of course this is all my opinion, sorry for the rant.
That was beyond epic. This is super embarrassing to Disney. Besides Rouge one Disney star wars has been super disappointing. Disney this is how you do star wars.
For what it is, they did a really great job. Definitely a few parts that felt a bit clunk or rushed in terms of the overall flow and the graphics/animation, but it's important to bear in mind that this was a fan-made bit. They really worked hard on this, and it shows. This really is the Episode 4 lightsaber fight that we all deserve.
No we don't lol, SW fans have ruined SW, along with sjws
Honestly, the best saber fight since episode 3. WTF ARE THE SEQUELS DOING?? episode 7 fight was good, but left a major tease for 8. All we got was a single saber fight against guards and a lame fake force Skype saber fight
The Snokeroom fight was well done, it was ruined by characters that nobody cared about. Reys wierd war cries and huffs were silly too.
ge - it still wasn’t SABER ON SABER action. Guards are boring knowing they aren’t force sensitive. Having two force wielding people hack each other with lightsabers is Star Wars. I guess the goal was to subvert our expectations. Yayyyyy
@@ge-8135 It has lots of mistakes, though.
@@ge-8135 Right, because teleporting daggers and extremely held back choreography (so as not to have the guards just fucking kill the actors) is '' well done''.
@@TheStraightestWhitest I think 'ge' means it was "good enough" that the visual effects & eye candy would keep people from looking too much into the lackluster choreography.
I could feel Vader's Anger, literal chills
Absolutely Incredible!
I agree with you, this is now Canon.
I love how they added a slight red tint into Obi-Wans beard, things like that where people pay attention makes these things amazing! Bravo to the people who made this!
Either that or they forgot to make the stand-in's beard completely white.
*_KENOBI !_*
Budget to destroy a classic saga: *$4 Billions*
Budget to put Disney to shame: *Tree Fiddy*
_snicker_
GAWT DAMN EET WOMAH!!!
Wow, this is like the equivalent to a SNES remaster on a modern handheld. Same soul, loving touchups.
Except Disney didn’t make Star Wars
@@jamieanddebable When did I say anything about Disney?
Give this guy a budget and watch a masterpiece grow.
Amazing. Made by a true fan.
Disney should’ve just done a whole Darth Vader movie with him in the mask. He’s the best Charachter
Like rouge one
Like Star Wars Theory's fan-project
Thanos Rogue one was TRASH and barely had Vader. I WANT A FILM OF HIM HUNTING JEDI FOR 20 YEARS
This is the only part of Star Wars you had to tolerate that definitely does improve with time; the fight scenes.
That was the remastering they should have done when remaking the originals, as well as realistic explosions
You are spot on. This is a special edition I would watch.
@Matthew Welch yeah but they were small explosions, a ship blowing up shouldn't look like a small petrol canister going "pop", and a moon/planet sized space station should have more realistic debris than sprinkles when it explodes
Not criticising of course, they did well considering what was available at the time, but as for digital remastering it at a later date with modern animation technology they should have looked into the explosions more in my opinion
*THIS* is what happens when you do things with passion.
Et Tu Rian, kathleen.
Those 2 Gungans can fuck off
"This is canon!"
-Jeremy G&G
I wouldnt mind this edit being in a rerelease of Episode 4.
This edit was so beautiful
Don't get me wrong, it is absolutely amazing and I loved it, but it wouldn't fit with the footage of the original movie. It looks 'too' modern next to the original footage. The CGI is noticeable, Vader's armor looks different and is much shinier, and the background's ceiling lights weren't in the original scene. It would look out of place and jarring mixed with shots of the original.
I agree. I'd throw some Hollywood money and just age the footage to nicely match to a New Hope, and were good to go.
0311uli it’s not that hard to add noise and camera jerks and desaturate the color. But if George Lucas added this in you’d be pissed like little babies
Agreed. This has more heart and dramatic intensity in 10 minutes than all of Disney's Star Wars films combined.
I love when Luke sees obi wan and get looks back at Luke then back at Vader and I always love how he smiles despite the fact obi wan knows he’s going to die.
The love and passion of Star Wars is strong with this one.
It;s canon for me, this is just what we never saw because of limits that time... THIS IS AWESOME
The situation was so hopeless for Obi-Wan there but yet he still even with his death learn Luke and Darth Vader a lesson
Watching this after watching Prequels and Clone Wars.
Lay down, try not to cry, cry a lot.
Absolutely stunning. The ferocity of the battle is amazing....the voice over from ROTS worked incredibly well. When you take into account this and The Star Wars Theory’s Vader film it just shows that the fans have a much better understanding than Lucasfilm. Out of the four films that have been released since Disney took over the only scene of any note really has been the Vader attack at the end of Rogue One....and as good as it is....this is better.
In a way it makes me sad for what might have been with someone competent running things...instead of things like this...we get Rey vs Kylo.....no wonder Star Wars is dying. Sad indeed.
Disney, take notes! This is how you do a climactic fight. Not swing a lightsaber towards a projection with no contact
Or cheesy ass random stabs and somersaults in the Forest
@WillFanofMany All the actors were noobs before training moron
THAT is Star Wars! That is what a Jedi fight looks like!
Please Disney sell Star Wars back to George Lucas.
Ep1 wasn't the best, but that fight scene is the best in a SW movie.
Vader approach in Rogue one was badass too (come on, credit where credits due).
This was great.
Well done guys!
Yeah Vader in Rogue One was the single good thing Disney has put out. That scene was incredible. If only they rest could be as good.
I thought the Mustafar battle in Ep3 was the best fight scene in an SW movie
better ?! there are DIMENSIONS between this and the (lack of) quality of E7&8 !
*Yep, this is one of the main reasons why I LOVE the prequels so much, because the Light Saber fights are so epic like this, also i really hope they do more of these, like Luke vs Vader both round 1 and 2.*
Its gonna be challenging to try to cgi mark hamill face but it could be done
@@Hanoua2 Yep, because they nailed Obi-Wan's face.
George Lucas: Releases new edition with Solo stepping on the Hutts tail, for a price
Fans: Releases reworked fight scene with special effects and background music, for free
The reflections of the lightsabers in Vader's mask.....OMG
🤯
The intensity of the this duel only makes sense given the savage way Vader wipes out the Rebel Fleet Troopers at the end of "Rogue One".
This is part of my Episode IV canon which also consists of parts from the original, the Special Edition, STAR WARS Revisited and anything Ivan may do in the future.
Despite everything KK has done, the Force is still with the true fans of STAR WARS.
I haven't seen real star wars for 15 years. 😢 absolutely beautiful.
When i first saw this I actually felt fear, this is brutal! Vader had been reimagined since Rogue One....he is the brutal vader we all should have seen.
One of my favorite things about this is that this iteration of Vader reminds me of the Vader in Rogue One and the EU/Comics. He's a literal one man wrecking crew fueled by pure rage and hatred, and he just UNLOADS on Obi Wan. The callbacks to the prequels were superbly done and just made the scene that much more intimate and emotionally powerful. I've watched it like a dozen times on their channel and a bunchaton of reactions as well. I cannot say enough good things about this.
Great review Jeremy. Thanks!! :)
THIS IS MY SECOND TIME.. It is even better the 2nd time as I see more details . The buildup, the pov and the action is really solid. The fight is fast and ferocious. learn young directors..
THIS! This is the Star Wars I know and love, not whatever the hell SJW Disney is doing.
absolutely. Like, its not that hard to get star wars right this is what we want but disney is just like "no, we want to do something DIFFERENT" fuck them
Masterge77 TFA was SJW garbage
@@weknowthetruth6863 Tell me something I _don't_ know already...
would you please drop the star wars justice warriors crap for god sake.the force awakens and the last jedi were awesome movies
mary wise THEY SUCKED ASS
This is actually the most hyped I've been for Star Wars since Episode III...or possibly before. Like when I was a kid watching Empire or Jedi for the first time. So awesome..
A truly sad state of affairs when fans have to make their own Star Wars just to be able to enjoy star wars.
Ps. I recognize that a lot of fans like Disney's films, but a lot (a helluva lot) don't.
A new hope will always be a classic but this remastered scene has way more impact than the original.
This is the wrong impact though. In the original version of this, Obi Wan was clearly in total control the entire time, smirking and toying with Vader. In the original, Obi Wan never had any intention of coming out of that fight alive. Whereas in this version, it looks like Obi Wan was trying to kill Vader and lost and sacrificed himself out in the spur of the moment because he had no other choice. Also, the prequel callbacks don't make sense here, because Vader had suppressed all memory of his former self by this point.
@@AStageForTheKingdom yes I do agree with you there as obi wan in the original had more control. However for me the the fight is more impactful as if darth vader fought like this in the original then it would give a whole new meaning to vader toying with luke in the empire strikes back as in it truly shows how powerful vader is. Not to mention vader was using all his anger built up for 20 years to cut down his old master as that day on mustafar was a life changing event that has haunted him his life and this was the man he hunted down ever since for revenge as lets be real here anyone would be angry to meet the person who threw them near a river of lava burning them and cutting of their limbs again. But I do like the original fight as well in A New Hope and what it means.
oh please, not even close to the original.
The original was boring af people keep giving excuses oh obj wan was in control lol. They just had no clue on what they were doing. Vader would destroy obi wan. Obi wan hadn’t duelled in a long time while Vader hunter down Jedi
You gotta remember too that A new hope was the first star wars. The music and the prequel callbacks weren't even invented or thought about for another what.. 27 years?
This is way better than seeing Leia abuse Chewie, Han and Luke.
Vader walking with such determined purpose. In the scene you can see Vader carefully measuring every step and every strike is with hate. Vader is younger, stronger and you can feel the mouth-watering glee in Vader as he realizes he is out besting his former master.
Congrats on the 150k subs this was pure perfection
Send this to George Lucas maybe he'd love it
Yeah, I want his reaction to this.
This video gives me goosebumps! This guys should direct a Star Wars movie
@WillFanofMany True, but you gotta admit that this action sequence is way more awsome than what Ryan Johnson did on TLJ.
@WillFanofMany totally agree!
As much as I love the Luke-Vader scenes in TESB and ROTJ . . . this is the best lightsaber duel in the entire _Star Wars_ saga. It's the single best combination of choreography and pathos.
Not sure how I missed this for 3 years, but glad I saw it from you. You and a small handful of other YT content creators that truly understand and devote to Star Wars are the ones that can really give a reaction worth watching of the SC 38 Reimagined.
As you stated - This too is my head canon and I'll die on that hill. The original, great for it's time and budget is easily replaced with this amazing work of art and love from FitItinPost.
The call backs of Fallen Anakin and Obi-Wan gave me chills. A perfect reunion for a fitting end.
Nothing like we will get in Episode 9.
Of all of George Lucas’s edits to the originals I always wanted something like this. This fight is in all honestly huge to Anakin’s story and it didn’t seem like it was when you first watch it. I understand Lucas did the best and the original sabers were really fragile but I would have loved if this was added.
HOLY CRAP!!! I am a HUGE Star Wars purist, and THAT. WAS. AMAZING! I seriously can't believe how well done that was! I LOVE this! I want to add it to my collection!
Omg, this is amazing!! The pacing is perfect!! All the dialogue inlays seem so well integrated, and the original sound track? Giving me goosebumps. Thanks for reaching Jeremy gonna go pay my respects over at the creators channel after I finish this
The add-in of the Prequel callback, made Obi wan's smile before his death so much more meaningful. Before it was just a smile for Luke ~your turn now, this re-imagined scene made it for Anakin as well. The whole "Your my brother, I love you" then the smile ~chills. Guys who made that video A+
If they release the Saga in 4k special editions, something like this should be added to ANH!
Would be a slight step up to a lot of the actual moronic changes in the OT. Like the 'Nooo' shit from Jedi.
No
honestly I'm just so happy seeing Jeremy enjoy star wars again.
What that I love about this fight. That nearly every strike is a strike to kill, decent amount of proper lunges, and enough flash to make it cool.