The CONTROVERSIAL Moments in All England 2024
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 мар 2024
- 🎬The just-ended All England Open 2024 saw continuous controversies, with both referee decisions and off-court factors severely impacting players' performances. Let's review the events together.
🔗 Channel Link: youtube.com/@ThisIsBadminton?...
🕒 Check out our New videos - Subscribe & turn on notifications so you won't miss any!
🌟 Why This Is Badminton?
💡 We're passionate about promote the popularity of badminton and use innovative ways to showcase the uniqueness of this sport.
👥 Subscribe my channel:
🔔 For more high quality badminton videos, be sure to subscribe and turn on notifications. 
Спорт
我們现在也提供中文字幕了,在播放
😂😂😂
棒球都能重播了，羽球還是蠢材決定輸贏。
Provide hindi subtitles ❤
Bing chilling
they should add a recording of the stand in the future and issue penalty if a problem does arise or else the problem will continue to happen.
Delete the recording after the whole tournament if nothing occur.
I don't get why a person (even if its a child) isn't escorted out after doing it more than once as if its some type of tiktok challenge =/
The ban can be enforced onto the parent too. Q did no one went to tell the parent that his/her son was using flashlight "intentionally" on the phone...??
Why doesn't security remove the flashlight people? It wasn't even a photo, it was flashlight on.
What horrible hosts.
BWF things lol
The flashlight is on a phone, no? You can't expect security to remove ALL phones with a light. They announced, " Please, no flashlights/camera flashes." many times. It's down to the public to be more careful, I don't think the venue could have done much more. If they do it again, then tell them to leave, but I don't think this happened?
@@curnowbascombe5400 reports seem to indicate this was a repeat offender
What I'm saying is it's not a photography flash. The light remained ON, indicating it's the use of the flashlight feature, not merely taking a photo with a quick flash.
@@curnowbascombe5400 o please... u dont even know we in pakistan the people are not allowed to bring their phones while watching live cricket matches. In this kind of situation, security should sumbit all phones and when one needs to make a call or receibe he must go to secueity room within the match times ans then get their phones back once the matches are over. Simple and can be managed by the venue administration😊
Ironic that it happens in Britain. Remember when Tom Daley was allowed to retake his botched dive during the 10m men diving final at the 2012 London Olympics because he complained of "flash distraction"? He ended up stealing the bronze!
That damn flashlighting person should be escorted outside
Sure
absolutely
That person must be fined and banned from all bwf events .
BWF HALLO22 HALLU22 ...dont silent ..🤭💔😭
Marin was attacked several times by someone leaving the red light on during a rally, surely deliberate. The people who do this have very sick minds, sore losers.
These athletes have been honing their reflexes and reaction time to the point that a single flashlight is enough to disturb their focused state. Those who say they're overreacting are people who hasn't done anything that requires focus. Even when you are talking and someone suddenly interrupts, aside from getting annoyed you sometimes forget what you were going to talk about and it's pretty frustrating really.
excatly.
Agree. It's like someone shouting during a golf swing at a PGA Masters. 😖
exactly that ball is also white its always confuse your brain
Most of the staff are not athlete
just drive 120kmh at night(not that fast) then u got high beam.... thats how it feel....
With the current technology, should just introduce instant replay, and allow player/coach to challenge the umpire's decision.
imagine we all see what should be the correct call for a netplay but still umpire call cant be changed, that's frustrating . Also challenge should not be instant because player should ask the partner player if they will challenge even Gill commented this to WD finals.
Agree, especially so many wrong judgement kill player's heart
No sport makes full use of technology because that would stop them from fixing matches and profit from the controversy (free advertisement) when things like this happens. Remember, it's a business first, sport second.
@@DanDan-li4hr Same thing was for cricket, but then they introduced DRS (Decision review system). I guess every sport needs that.
@@jesusojeda7850 This
Nishimoto's over rule was pathetic. Such umpires should be fined for being stupid and dumb. Only then BWF umpires will start taking their jobs seriously. And yes what happened with Tunjung was unfortunate. There was clear proof that there was a huge flash. I hope the kid who used the flash and his irresponsible parents would always remember this
Instead of blaming the umpires, There should be a var system for these kind of mistakes and players should be given permission to appeal on these.
@@ramjai2007 Por qué no los dos?
Flash light during such level of badminton is strictly prohibited. The organiser must be proactive to stop this. The players should not be penalised for the flash light that disturb the player's concentration.
@@hyzanyusof6204penyelenggara allENGLAND tak PROFESIONAL...penonton bebas????😢
@@mualim4130 Benar.. Penyelangaraan ALL England semacam peringkat pertandingan sekolah sekolah. Bila pemain pemain seperti Tunjung and Lee Zi Jia sudah komplain, seharusnya ada tindakan segera.
Dan penonton Piala Sudirman dan Malaysia open lebih tertib!
This year's all england is just purely umpire show... They have too much power unchallenged. Any review of instant replay can help these players
Maybe its coz if the betting that's influencing them
Don't worry, the police will look into this case 15 years later after they are done convicting the local town drunk for writing "inappropriate speech" on his Instagram and Facebook accounts.
Nishimoto's overrule is the most ridiculous of all.
Crazy hey. It wasn't even remotely obstructing the play.
He was not even close to net😢😂😂
Similar thing happened with Christie. I've never seen a volleyball block like that got disallowed.
Exactly, it was clearly a legal block. Ginting was fully able to play a legal stroke.
Umpire was 100% racist.
This year's all England is just pure pathetic.
Lots of issues with bad umpire calls and flash photography in the crowd interrupting the usual high standard of badminton.
So many bad umpire decisions and line calls. Some of them are too old on the jobs.Bad visions contributory,too. Get younger officials and not those over 55 years old or retirees.be selective when choosing umpires and line judges. I observe All England Championship is alway marred by bad or unfair decisions to the chagrin of players.
@user-uw1br3cr8d Age has nothing to do with it, it's about the rules preventing umpires from reviewing their decisions using a replay
What would you expect from that nation. Especially that teenage geezah
they started to kill the beautiful games just like football and the video assistant refree
Change the standards of umpiring/officiating in BWF. Tired of seeing umpires rudely shrugging their shoulders and ordering players on court/shut-up and play.
Agree. I think the umpires themselves don’t even understand/know rhe rules.
Too dictatorial or rather throwing their weight around as umpires. Be reasonable and consider appeals made on legitimate grounds.
imagine having so many controversies in 1 event championship that someone could do a whole compilation on it 😂
@@11-ng6rwyeap but what my comment meant was that this years all england had too many bad calls from the umpires so much so that this channel could create a whole vid on it
And what it has to do with my guy comment up there?@11-ng6rw
@@devileye90so you take a stand and let your audience cheat for you😅, lol , miserable losers
dont imagine, it happened
@11-ng6rw And what does someone's nationality had anything to do with their factual accuracy, or "rights" to speak/discuss about a topic?
I don't understand how can the parents of the child with flashlight do nothing to correct his behavior. Also why is there no security taking action?
cz they dont care about that match..
@@masfu3597 yeah, They must be are told to do so by the Host, such a Racist tournaments
Western people so much care about "right", even for a bad guy. They'll say he has a right to do that and keep watching the game. animals protect animals.
typical western culture. them kids are all fked up. Useless parenting.
English Karen
I cannot believe you did not insert the one where Jonatan Christie returned a quick net shot (at a lower angle) from Ginting in the finals. That referee's response was "The outcome is up to me" instead of obstructing like Nishimoto. Absurd!
Bro wtf 😂 what is this?? A cartoon villain???
Did he also look at the camera grinning doing finger taps with both his hands 😂.
Yes😂@@fauzanaziz6365
That umpire who ruled Nishimoto should be investigated
1) The Nishimoto block.
Completely ridiculous. He was so far back from the net and you’re allowed to make reasonable movements and preparations to receive the shot. The referee is just being absurd.
2) The Ginting kill.
Looks like they missed a net touch, but realistically no human eye in real time will be able to discern whether the shuttle is a millimetre either one side or the other of the net. Unless some sort of net-call technology is introduced into the head of the shuttlecock (which I don’t think will be cost feasible) I can’t see this resolved easily. Maybe a benefit of doubt system favouring the referee but ruling out obvious errors and missed net touches.
3) The Flashlight.
Oof. Clearly Tanjung shouldn’t have stopped midpoint - you have to halt before the point begins, unless there’s a catastrophic interruption of course which the referee calls let for. The main issue is having enough stewards to reprimand the offenders. It was a kid in this case but nevertheless an official rebuke and temporary kick out of the hall for him and his dad would have been appropriate earlier on to prevent such a horrible end to the match. Only way of teaching the kid/parent.
How does one stop before the point if the flashlight is off then and when the point starts the flashlight is on? R u stupid?
Yh, but the flash came after the serve, making it impossible to call prior. And even after she made a complaint, nothing was done.
1) Use hawk eye to assist match Referee in this decision. 2) Players can have 1 or 2 reviews per game and Referee themselves unlimited. 2) As long as the racquet does not touch the net or crosses the net it should not be construed as an obstruction. The Referees may refer to the slow motion replays or hawk eye. 3) Any person in crowd uses flash light or other forms of nuisance to the players or the match should be evicted and the players should be allowed to replay the point (upon referee reviewing that the disturbance interfered with the player)
1) Hawk-eyes use-fullness in this is questionable, but use of slow speed cameras at the net.
2) These could be good, but they have downsides. They would allow more time wasting as they could be used in situations that don’t really need it in order to get a break, break opponent flow etc. The BWF is working hard to speed games up and this would probably go against it. Also these are still rare and very rarely determine a match. Take into account the number of matches at the All England for example.
2) The rules could be made clearer but that doesn’t mean that umpire’s are unfair or incompetent. They have a split second to make a decision, most people couldn’t do the job. The rules allow for you to finish your swing on the other side of the court if the contact is on your own side, but obstructing this movement or making it harder is a fault. Although generally it shouldn’t be called in my opinion if the rackets don’t make contact.
3) Replaying the point isn’t always a good idea. There could be people in who are paid to disturb the match in favour of a player etc. Also evicting viewers can bring a lot of bad press on you. Should we then ban drums or shouting when smashing etc. since they could disturb some players even when used during breaks or maybe just ban viewers all together from the venue only having livestreams as an option. Having referees review events could also take significant amounts of time and isn’t in most cases realistic.
Rules cannot be written too specific and will always require interpretation. Which gets more consistent over time and training which happens at all tournaments. At the beginning, during and end to some extent.
The thing people really need to remember that umpires, players and the BWF all want to see the sport succeed and grow. But saying umpires should be fined or fired because they made a mistake is very harmful for the sport. Umpires are people too and make mistakes and in many cases learn from them. But in a match it isn’t possible to allow all decisions to be questioned, changed or otherwise reviewed because there needs to be some control (as unfair it sometimes seems) of the situations and there are time constraints. Matches can’t last for hours because of debate about rules, calls etc. That kind of attitude creates a versus atmosphere and makes progress or change very hard.
All England = better just change its name to All Flashlight
How many more times will we have to go through sh*t like this before badminton tournaments actually install a VAR system and beef up their security? If the Olympics is going to be like this as well, I hope they face serious backlashes.
VAR in football also a criminal
So many bad moments, from a very bad umpire calls to flashlights going off like there is no tomorrow. This is a trend for All England. Every All England tournament (expect during covid times) there will always be controversy like these, yet, they did nothing to prevent these outrageous mishaps from happen.
What has happened before? It's just Indogs crying as usual
Nowhere near as many flashlights or bad umpire calls last year or the previous years I have attended since 2019. This year was very very bad.
all plyer better not join AE next time...england country so dumb
Ask the user with flash to pay a huge fine, that will surely deter future happenings, no matter if he/she is a kid, let the parent pay
if it's just a fine, someone is probably willing to pay it just to make someone winning,banned and got escorted out of the stadium by the security would be the best action.
Why not both @@easygoing4964
@@easygoing4964 I would say it depends on how huge the fine is. I mean, would anyone really be willing to pay, say 100000 pounds to have a player win 1 match that isn't a finals match?
Though, if they bet on it, then I can see a reason. If the person bet like 200000 pounds on the match I can see them having reason enough to do it, but can any "normal" working person really bet that large an amount of money on a single match that isn't even a finals match?
Edit: Not to say I'm against banning and escorting people out of the venue.
Imo, they should be banned for a season, escorted out and fined for hurting the players and venues.
Especially if people are found to use a laser pointer, as they can actually make people go blind or reduce their eyesight.
I'm glad there is discussion on these issues. I would also like to discuss the amount of delay players like Carolina Marin cause to the game. There are many instances where she gets away with delays, in addition to that, she also doesn't return the shuttle properly many times as well. Would be nice to see a video discussing that as well.
she always does that so annoying and doesn’t even get yellow card. Umpires are so racist
She is the worst of all! Just because she is european she gets away!
And her bloody irritating sounds she makes .
Really well made video 👏🏼
Really, Greg? The poor kids face is all over the internet.
@@unexpectediteminbaggingare8074
Look at it this way, Badminton players spend most, if not all their time and money to Badminton. From training, nutrition, accommodation, equipment, etc. One big way to earn money is by winning tournaments, and even then it's not a lot. Being obstructed would cause you to lose thousands of dollars in prize money.
Now how about, let's see, Basketball and Baseball games. I'm pretty sure plenty of faces appear on jumbotrons and online at 4K quality. This kid's basically the same. Arguably, even at worse quality.
They're in public, with hundreds of cameras around.
Not just flashlight many bring small leaser light nd direct it on players eyes.....
Anyone with flashlight on shall be escorted out from the arena and barred from entering the tournament again until the following year. Repeat offense mean permanent bar
Yamaguchi also faced flash light continously,
She should point it out as well then
Problem is she lacks the self-assertion.
if you're being wronged then point it out, you were the one being quiet, don't make it out like you're better just because you "didn't let it affect" you
You don't stop a rally whenever it's convenient for you@@zirconia1205
Don't put your words in yamaguchi mouth , as if you are playing for yamaguchi
I dont know why Volleyball have more superior VAR technology 😅. They have cameras in every corner
BWF is too cheap to implement this technology. Hawkeye wasn't even implemented
no budget?
@@YungAntoine
BWF tidak akan pernah memikirkannya
And sensor motion in the ball just like FIFA
In victors case we cannot blame umpire but rather that we need to be equipped with better technology as it is extremely difficult to catch if it was indeed a net touch. In case of flashlight there are two ways to look at it umpire should have escorted that person out because he was reportedly doing it and was not an one off exception but also at the same time player could have completed really but in this case we can't really blame Tunjung because it happened 2-3 times for her. In case of Nishomoto definitely umpire error imo. :)
Too many glaring errors. The quality of umpires leaves much to be desired especially in the All England Championships.
The fact that badminton tech is so behind it's funny
Well done! Good recap of events.
SO WHAT ABOUT CAROLINA MARIN???EVERY POINT SHE WILL ROAR,SCREAM ,HOW IS THAT GESTURE?? WHY THE HELL NO UMPIRE GIVING HER YELLOW CARD OR RED CARD WHICH SHE DESERVED???😡😡😡
FAVORITISM BWF???😡😡😡
whats wrong with that
totally agree. So fucking anoying.
@@west9383Everything! Deliberate attempt to cause disturbance & pretty much favouritism from Refree's! She doesn't return the shuttle property, shouts, delays, taunts etc....
They are Racist
Normal bro
His not from asian 😂😂😂
Obstructing a shot or a stroke is pretty well defined and in Nishimoto's case the umpire was just bad. This wasn't at any point a "grey area". There was no obstruction of stroke possible as the players were so far apart from each other. In the Axelsen Ginting case it's very hard ot judge whether the shuttle crossed the net but Ginting clearly was hitting the net with his racket which is illegal.
Agreed. For Ginting (and I am a Ginting fan), it wasn't so much about the racket crossing the plane of the net, it was that Ginting's racket touched the net. That is a fault.
Axelsen made Ginting swear he did not touch the net and you can see Ginting raise 2 fingers in a gesture to mean "he swears" he did not touch the net...lol.
Jonathan vs Ginting
In the net also
That is a contoversial
Do the umpires know the rules well enough? Also , they may have bad vision and make bad judgments due to old age..
Ginting had the refs in his pocket in this tournament. He still lost
With the flashlight, am I missing something, is the "undue delay" rule quoted in the video even relevant? The rally had already started, she wasn't delaying anything. I have to assume the umpire just didn't believe her that there was a flashlight? Not sure what reason he would have had for that though, she wasn't in a tough spot in the rally that could be cause for "trying it on" by making a false claim. Really strange decision by the umpire there, don't understand it at all
3:12 x0.25speed net touch
no
@@jimbojimbo6909my eyes are pretty good, that was a net touch of some degree for sure, the air from the racket wouldn’t cause the entire net to rattle like that my friend.. it was a net fault.
I don't think it's a net fault, but it's definitely up for debate. I mean, if it was a net fault, shouldn't the net be shaking? If we consider it from the last point of view, the racket did touch the net, but it was such a light touch that it's hard to say for sure.
Shuttel cock certainly did not attack the field because it fell straight on the court victor, maybe it was the reason for the judge
@@johanryuzaki1963 Later in the video it's shown that Ginting has touched the net before hitting the shuttle.
ginting touched the net 100%
audience using flashlight should get kicked out immediately, no second chances
Given the net didn't appear to move its tough to claim he 100% touched the net.
@@PaulFilmer that's the thing, the net 100% moved. if you watch carefully you can see it move in real time, and in slow motion replay.
@11-ng6rw the ones crying are the players. the audience is there to watch the players, and you think it's ok for them to disrespect the players and cause them to lose. that says a lot about you, lmao, were you one of those people having your flashlights out?
If it was the kid messing around with the light, blame the dad sitting next to him, or his mom behind him. Better yet, dont take children to important games;)
I really like your videos because you take a neutral perspective when looking at events, which is lacking in many other channels.❤❤
Designate a certain quantity of seats facing the backs of the players as no camera seats so that players play will not be interfered; which means to say audience who bought those seats are not allowed to bring their cameras into the stadium/hall.
These points need to be taken seriously, as the sport must strive towards being fair and competitive.
There so many different aspects of each match that has been evaluated really well here! Thank you.
Human error’s can happen but it absolutely bizzare that there is no appeal or evaluation done to rectify the issue.
There have been some good suggestions in the comments but i guess the match officials/ organiser need to self evaluate that human error can happen and they can atleast listen to the appeal and have a review system in place.
Sometimes, the organizers and match officals look like authoritarian rather than facilitators of a game. It so unfair to make player go out of the court with a feeling of injustice. Which leave’s a bitter feeling in everyone’s mind.
We are human’s hence first need to reflect that we all can make mistakes, but we need to correct if something is not right. ❤BADMINTON.
Well, Ginting was helped by questionable umpiring at least three times during the whole tournament, including the final against his compatriot Christie, which was so ridiculously absurd, one which he should have conceded. But you know what, karma is shit and he eventually ran out of luck.
Karma is when you get punishment for doing something wrong. Ginting didn't really do anything wrong, the umpires were just biased for him in this tournament
@@leob4403 I beg to differ. That net point off Christie's block was clearly his point, the chair umpire was probably dumb, but Ginting should have conceded that point to his compatriot as he clearly saw it wasn't his. Instead, he happily accepted it and played on while Christie was left stunned.
@@briangmoh5261 but christie won that match quite easily innit?
I really want momota to comeback ❤❤
Great content, very informative, Like in other sports they should have a review system to challenge the umpires decision.
There has been several incidents like this in the past but no changes made from BWF so far. Are they going to stay silent or do sonething different? We'll see
Yamaguchi never complain I guess, I like her personality anyway 😅
She doesn't have as much self-assertion, I'm afraid.
Japanese always great examples how sportsman should behave. Salute!!!
@@vehlan I think this has little to do with sportsmanship.
@@vehlanbecause she’s not on the receiving end of a bad call. Look at the all England 🏴 open WD match years ago, where umpire missed a fault call, the Japanese WD players protested the call.
@11-ng6rw excuse me ?
They should hire an umpire who is healthy not a discord modder.
Most of the umpire's decisions are WRONG!
One of the worst is actually the final between ginting and christie, there's a point ginting get because of "obstruction"
As a non-badminton player it seems wild to me how predicting and blocking a shot is considered obstruction.
Sometimes, I look at the umpires and question if giving the absolute power over professional players to someone who looks like they have not touched a treadmill for 10 years let alone played badminton really the right decision!
What does that have to do with anything?
There were many many many close call
Surely introduce the equivalent of VAR to ensure the umpire's decision can be independently checked - outcomes of matches are at stake!! As regards flashlights, individuals need a warning, then phone or person removed
if i would say if there are people using flaslight in the mid of the game they should be kick quickly or the people who is using flashlight in the mid of the game they gonna pay so much
@This is Badminton, can you please share the ljnk to pdf of bwf rules. I want to read them
www.badmintonbible.com/rules You can check these rule in this website.
The orange t shirt kid should be regreating now!!
hawkeye might not work for those net shots/flash offences but can follow soccer. empire hand draw a rectangle for various cams reviews. each player gets 2 of those cam reviews as well
Yeh BWF should consider this and change some rule like they should provide a challage for net play close shot like side line judgement
Viktor is goat he already have everything but his comeback was brilliant, no doubt ki he would have won too if he take 19-18 ,,,
I thinks You'r comeing from India,,yeahh India fans hate Indonesia player,,,but why Indonesia fans loves India player...🤔🤔like i love sen..he's good personality ..👍👍
@@maulanayusuf6924 I don't hate indonesian player at all, even I love ginting play his smashes are so asthetic and beautiful to watch, I just feel sad to see indonesian fan hating chirag and satwik,,, so in India it's common to find not liking of indonesian fan but yeah as u know there are good and bad people everywhere, so yeah, I don't hate indonesian player ( I was saying that viktor was sad so I was refring that he don't need to be sad, he have everything) .
@@tiwariabhinay868 yeaah mungkin anda bukan dari pembenci,tetapi banyak sekali India fans dalam coment section sangat membenci pemain indo,saya melihatnya ketika Bagas/Fikri mengalahkan rankiaddy/Shetty dan Jhonatan c mengalahkan laksya sen..India fans tidak menyukainya...☹️☹️
@@maulanayusuf6924it's okay, good and bad people are everywhere, even I see many indonesian fan goes under chirag insta photo and write bad comment even chirag have said it he don't know why indonesian fan hate him,,,, so bad and good people are everywhere,, even U go to any satwik chirag game U will find someone mocking them for winning,,,,
bro i feel like this year England Open mens single umpire are all bias to Indonesia😂
nope, it's just their poor judgement,even in the final between Indonesia vs Indonesia this kind of thing still happened.
It held in the UK though
Biased towards Ginting. Still happened in the final
Meanwhile take a look at WRC drivers at night stages with people feet off the track. It is sad that we react to flashlights....
Very strange n Sad to see players getting affected by the cellphone/mobile lights. Need some rules to be implemented so that Umpires can take the decision on the court.
Ting ting just brushed the net 😏🤫
One thing I don't like of indonesia fan that, they will feel sorry of tunjung and troll umpire but at the same time they will be silent at viktor and make joke of it, hypocracy,
which Indonesia fans ?
@@joMan1060 on x, they were making joke and fun that let ginting and viktor have coffe date( I know viktor said to have coffe if ginting is right) still, would they react same way if condition is reversed?
@@tiwariabhinay868 yeahh true asf and even the surprising thing is that ginting got 3 points which he didn't deserve at all
I'm as indonesian fan agree with you, my people always upset and angry to the referee/judges if it harms their player , but they also close their eyes if it benefit them 😅 maluu woy indonesia
it's happened everywhere on every sport, why you should making out of it? max verstappen defended by FIA and half of the world and nobody bats an eye. just "indonesian fans" also doesn't make your statement right
heart breaking, how flashlight person gets most painful death of it was intended to hurt the game.
hope, if *
Fair play! The Organization should look into this and attend to all players concerned.
Sangat merugikan atlet. .
Flashligth actually kinda disturb ,On Match we really need that Focus at Shuttlecock and these Audience took Flashligth like they never played Badminton
Why do people turn on their phone flash? That little lightbulb isn't going to make a difference to the image quality, it's far too weak and far away to add any additional brightness to the scene. Those courts are already very strongly lit. It might even add glare and make it less clear. There's literally nothing to gain from using it.
Because they think haha flashlight no seeing for you trololololololo
@@toara yeah that's what I think too. There are sporting bets going on behind the scenes. I wouldn't be surprised if they are in the crowds to purposely sabotage players. It just doesn't make sense to use flash if they really cared about taking a photo, because it makes no difference.
The ammount of hardwork that the players put in is insane ... and they get repayed by the audience with some random flashlight ... not fair. In tunjung's case , the umpire atleast could replay the point
All Engalnd 2024 was the Worst in history!! YUCCKKKS
Sometimes we dont realize the flash is on. I'm sorry for Gregoria, but she can't stop the game.
I was watching the semi finals in the stadium and there were many occasions where players complaining about the flash lights. But no any security or umpire obstruct the culprits who often use the flashlights even after the announcement regularly not to use any flashlights. Actually it was just one or two people who sit opposite side use flash lights with intension.
Yes from what it seems even if the shuttle was on AS Ginting's side, the racket most probably definitely touched the net as if you see the footage in slow mo, the net does move as well. The fact this was 18 all in the deciding game of the QF is too serious. What should be done is players should have 2 reviews as well (just like challenges) and the umpire should watch a replay closely and then remake the decision or something.
Elxsen puasa gelar wkwwkkwkwk
One thing the players dislike is inconsistency and where the umpire has to make a subjective call, we get exactly this - inconsistency. In Nishimoto's case, these net blocks have been played for several years now and I have rarely seen any called a fault even when it appears the rackets have actually clashed. Nishimoto's block was very well played and there is no way he hindered Ginting's stroke - it wasn't even close, so a bad decision by the umpire (probably less experienced on the World Tour?). In Axelsen's case, the umpire has the best view and he has to call what he sees. The players know that in this case the decision cannot be reviewed or challenged. It was unfortunate that it was at a critical stage in the match but that's it. If the shuttle had been allowed to drop and fell on Axelsens side, he would have lost the point anyway. The only way Axelsen could win the point would be if the shuttle dropped onto the net tape and fell on Ginting's side. Bottom line: Ginting played a great dropshot and Axelsen played a poor return so perhaps erring towards Ginting was the right call? With flashlights, the organisers need to have stewards policing this constantly - it happens at all tournaments but is particularly bad where the crowd are in semi darkness. The fans can also "self police" this of course. I don't think the rally should be stopped if a flash goes off as this would break the flow of play. However, I do think it is ok to delay serving/receiving if a flash goes off.
I think the reason for Axelsen's reaction is that he was in the middle of a comeback and poor decisions like this one greatly disturbs players. After that call, Viktor looked affected and I'm not certain he would have lost the match, had the call been right.
@@astronoteek1512 well, it was an important point for sure - not sure it was the wrong decision by the umpire though.
@@JockyT1 Upon watching a high quality clip multiple times, I personally concluded that Ginting had, at least, touched the net. I'm not sure if hé crossed the net, it looks like it but I wouldn't conclude on it
I wouldn't want to be in the ref's position...p
Great video!
Imagine fifa and national games such as nba changing the rules, audience behavior, and referee performance to help become more transparent and protect the players
Nishimoto was the most terrible!
मुझे इंडोनेशिया के प्रशंसकों की एक बात पसंद नहीं है कि, उन्हें तुंजुंग के लिए खेद महसूस होगा लेकिन साथ ही वे विक्टर पर चुप रहेंगे और इसका मजाक उड़ाएंगे, पाखंड,
it a shame that all happened in all england which is a BWF 1000 series, the competition with all the great players participant
One thing we have to mention here is the incorrection of the lines judges in AE 2024 this year,. I have not seen any tournaments that players had so many successful challanges in this tournament. Maybe the gray color of the carpets this year makes it more difficult for the judges to observe,... but i think the judges and the umpires have not done well their jobs in this tournaments ( Sorry if i have any mistakes in my english )
Some are not up to the mark. Send them for refresher courses before appointing them again
Really pathetic, this same thing happen during lzj vs lakshya, viktor vs ginting, tunjung vs yamaguchi,
( for information that flash thing not just happened to tunjung but yamaguchi also faced just she didn't complain, okay)? Don't cry
Darimana anda tahu bahwa Akane Yamaguchi juga mendapatkan sorot laser dari tribun penonton
वीडियो है इंटरनेट पे,twitter पे देखा था,,,जब यमागुची खेल रही थी तब भी फ्लैश हो रहा था@@davidadisaputra3101
its a shame no one talk bout ginting got point from 3 fault from 3 diff enemy because he is indonesian
blocking opponent shuttle is fault, there rules in bwf code. nishimoto and christie had fault of this
as you can see from Popov lcw even random player nvr got fault if this happen to Indo player by other country player then you can see alot of hate comment to bwf ig
Don't leave a hate comment.
You critiqued those people who flooding BWG IG with hate comments, which it would be good not to do the same.
@@paristiawangnugraha nisihimoto was not blocking . He was far away from the net . This is like calling mixed double front court blocks faults .
@@atulofau9006I didn't leave hate comment just didn't satisfied with Indo fans keep atking when they player receive fault and cheering when enemy got fault
There was a game in China and I believe the organizer shined a laser pointer on somebody was turning on the flashlight until they realized and stopped.
It's clearly disturbing. I think the BWF should not allow people to use cameras during the game, especially right in front of each player on both sides.
The dumbest thing is not because there's no assistance technology being used, it's because people still belive and dependant on umpire decision.
People make mistakes doesn't matter what title / age or status they have.
I think what they should do is before every match starts is say to the audience members to turn off all flashlights and flash photography so it wouldn't distrupt the game.
at 1:06 speed 0.25, it hit the net, the mistake was the umpire said fault after the next hit at 1:10, and the player thought the fault was at that point
this will make every audience from every country 'legally' disturbing the players they dont support
When it comes to the flash lights, remove the audience, problem fixed. Let them watch live on screen.
not only these, those crowds that 'hiak', 'hiak', 'hiak' on every shots that certain players are about to hit are damn irritating as well.. they are killing an otherwise exciting game & should be escorted out too. offenders should be recorded & ban from entering such events for 2 years as each game/location is played once a year.
2:00 yes, lack of clarity in the badminton regulations ; hopefully they'll just ban the net block once and for all before the Olympic Games
External factors like the flashlight event can be seen as external factors trying to rig the game and should be treated as a criminal offense.
this players have their whole focus on the the shuttlecock of course it would be a great distraction for them. as to why people who take pictures should be advised to turn off their flash as the court is well lit and a small flash from your cellphone camera does not have any affect on the image but greatly affect the players.
I believe there should be a ban imposed (say 3 match ban) on people who use flashlight inside the stadium.. whether they do it knowingly or unknowingly is irrelevant as it's common sense to not distract the players...
Umpire was already wearing glasses and he's still blind 😂😂
This is the BWF's next task to implement fairer rules. Not only for players but also spectators and referees. Spectators must be safe from cheating which is usually done with flashlights and referees must also have healthy five senses. It's strange that BWF always uses old referees. We know that older people definitely have many deficiencies in the health of their five senses ..
An umpire's decision should always be overturned if video footage proves it to be wrong. Letting them have the final call just screams corruption.
Ginting's racket did touch the net, that was clear in the normal slo mo -- but it was so slight and it occurred so near the end of the point when the players are moving around and no longer concerned about touching the net that it was very difficult to see, and the umpire cannot be faulted for that -- also there is no clear evidence that Ginting hit the shuttle when it was on Axelsen's side of the court -- Axlesen's reaction was a bit over-dramatic, but it was a crucial time of the match
Yes the touch was not obvious enough to be caught by the umpire's eye in live play. It was a human error in judgment but understandable.
Nashimoto’s racket wasn’t even close to the net…
What happen to axelsen 's case ? Rediculous, he complained the stupid thing😅😅😅