🐶🐶 WOOF WOOF! NEW VIDEO! 🚨🚨 Yeah... I'm gonna get some backlash for this one. But after hearing the hype for Tom King's Supergirl: Woman Of Tomorrow, I had to check it out, and as always in my reviews, here are my honest opinions on what many have already called 'One of the best of the decade' 🤦♂ So here's my review, and I'll be signing off for now 😂 . Yes, you heard right, MADDOGG MERCH IS HERE! 🤯 We've got some phenomenal designs by @shadowcatmanga that you can pick up today and support the channel! This has been a long time coming, so please show some love! Www.MaddoggComics.com 🐶 . If you want to support the channel, why not treat yourself to something from the channel sponsor: OrganicPricedBooks! Make sure you use code WOOFWOOF for $2 off your orders! 💵 Ordering 4 or more books together? Use code WOOFWOOFSHIPITTOGETHER for 5% off your entire order! 🤯 . If you're in the EU and you want free shipping, free gifts in every order and Hulk-proof packaging, Comics Bugle is the only website you need! Use code WOOFWOOF for 3% off all non-sale items! 👑 . Hope you guys enjoy! Hopefully 2024 will be a good one for the channel! If you like this, give it a like, subscribe if you're new, and share where you can! . Should have a Where To Start for my next video, but until then, stay Mad, Doggs! WOOF WOOF! 🐶
This was my favorite read of last year, and yet it’s very refreshing to hear a respectful difference of opinion! Really enjoyed your video here as always brotha 💪📚
I'm glad you had a good time when you read it mate! :) and thank you for the kind words, half the fun of this hobby is being able to see what we agree and disagree on and I appreciate you for being cool about it :) thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
MY GOD! I thought I was the only one that thought this story was overrated. Tom King has this tendency to just. keep. rambling with a narration that is not only unneeded with art of this quality, but actively detracts from it.
Thank you for the kind words, always want to make sure I say how I really feel about a book, for better or worse :) there'll always be some titles we don't see eye to eye on, but that's what makes the discussion fun and thanks for watching the video! 🐶
I often make this comment about Tom King's writing. He uses a lot of words to say very little. He uses a lot of flowery language making it seem smarter than it is, when you could sumarize a character's thoughts and still get the point across. I didn't like how this ended. Putting aside what is the cold blooded murder of Ruth's father, there's a point about half way involving a very obvious metaphor for racism and him being responsible for what amounts to a genocide. In my eyes he had lost the right to live at that point. I found it very middle of the road. If you know Kara Zor-El he just wrote a good Supergirl story. There's nothing ground breaking here.
I mean I'm glad that you found some kind of enjoyment out of it but I didn't find any enjoyment out of it because it felt like a sloth and let's be honest the story was literally true grit just with Supergirl instead of Clint Eastwood like the fact that the story focused mainly on the side character then Supergirl it's kind of like well damn what was the point of this book you know yeah it had onions but for the most part it's just kind of a sloth and it's not even a good Supergirl story
Finally saw someone talk about a heavy word count in Tom King's writing. I think this is one of his main weaknest in his writing, if the story is good, people can ignore it maybe, but if the story is mid if not bad, this worsen the reading experience (Maybe that's why people hate it or love it). I think he actually try to use 'this narration is actually from a book' excuse in women of tomorrow, but sometimes I just speed read most of it just to have a minimum acknowledge. But I like his character study/relationship story if it done right, so it is still my personal recommandation tbh
I gave up after issue 1 because I was bored with it. I don't really vibe with Evely's work here for one thing, but like you it's just the amount of verbiage that comes out of Ruthye's irritating gob that really made it feel tedious. I wasn't down for Kara's characterisation either. All the people I know who are big Supergirl fans absolutely despise this comic, without exception. Generally it's people who aren't fans of her who are the most receptive to it, I guess becuase they have no expectations? For that reason when Gunn announced the movie would be based on it they were pretty annoyed. I think it *could* make a decent movie but the screenplay writer would be wise to rethink how this story is told because having so much of the narrative rest on Ruthye and not Kara herself is an absolute non-starter - thank god you can't just put narration in movies (unless you've really gone wrong somewhere).
I felt the final battle was a let down, and the characterization of Supergirl left much to be desired. My favorite version of Supergirl is the 2005-2011 comic Supergirl. She went through arguably worse than the stuff new 52 Supergirl did (which is who rebirth supergirl more or less is, unless you count her as a compilation of ALL canon Kara Zor Els because of the death metal DC comic event). Like I could and would have been more engaged if not for Woman Of Tomorrow Supergirl not being the main character in the comic bearing her name. She was not like the Supergirl I knew and loved, not fun, just serious and sullen. Now if they wanted to they could have sold me on Kara's depression if they brought up the fact that she was suffering from the combined trauma of multiple Kara Zor El comic eras. Meaning she lost Krypton and her people a grand total of 4 times (because 2005-2011 Kara lost her people twice). But they never bothered to really show much from Kara's perspective and it made the story ultimately rather... hollow. Did not really have much of a point. A much better comic and far shorter you may want to review is Supergirl's 2 part comic in Future State where her story ends... literally. At least that comic actually has meaning and a lesson to ponder after. Not so with the hollow Woman Of Tomorrow by Tom King.
I get this feeling sometimes when I read critically acclaimed super hyped runs that I'm left feeling unfulfilled wondering what all the fuss was about. I thought I was the only one in the world who didn't enjoy the Immortal Hulk as much as I thought I would until I found your video on it and you raised a lot of the same issues I had with it too. Just because a run is considered a modern day classic or a must-read doesn't mean it is for everyone.
I have read so many glowing reviews of this book and have had it in my cart 3 times. And removed it 3 times. And now I’m glad it did. Mind you when the Deluxe edition is announced I’ll probably get seduced again. But looking at your screen grabs, there’s an awful lot of speech bubbles and narrative going on - it looks a bit like a transcript of a poor football commentary telling me what I’m already looking at. Hopefully I will remember this and resist again when the time comes.
It still may be a book you enjoy, I'm just one opinion, but in all honesty if you tend to not like excessive narration, this may be a miss 😂 thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
...Did he miss that the planet had red sun? Im pretty sure Supergirl went there soley so she could actually get weakened to the point she could get drunk.
I fell asleep several times while reading this book 😅Ruth's narration voice was interesting at first, but quickly became tedious to read and even got annoying at times. Overall, I though this story was just ok - the main plot was "meh", but some of the adventures Kara & Ruth have on their journey were interesting to read, as well as how their friendship was developing. Beautiful art though.
Thanks for this. I have no opinion on Tom King. He’s done things I like, and things I haven’t. I wanted this to be great, as a Supergirl fan, but I could not get into it at all.
Milly Alcock was cast as Supergirl in January 2024, to debut in another DCU project, reportedly Superman: Legacy. Filming is expected to begin in late 2024.
I think I’ve enjoyed only one title from King which was Vision but honestly everything else from Mr Miracle or Strange Adventures which I hated to the core has been let down after let down so I just basically stay away from his stuff from now on.
Thank you mate, sometimes the honesty is a blessing, sometimes a curse, but I'd rather say what I think about a book than just waste everyone's time or try to get a sale. Thank you for the kind words, it means a lot, especially lately, and thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
If I'm honest, it didn't fascinate me as much as most people. I agree that it can be heavy because of King's narration and, above all, I didn't like the ending, it was like those sudden changes that you mention. Otherwise I love the art and the color, I accept this version of Kara and I think it is an experience and journey that is quite emotional. Thank you for your honesty.
My personal opinion is that the art is outstanding, but I'm with you on the narration. I don't even think the voice of the narrator stayed the same throughout the book; at the beginning she sounded like she'd stumbled out of a golden age Thor book, but by a couple of issues in she sounded like an extra from Firefly 😂 I enjoyed the book on the whole, but it would have been much better paced if they halved the narration.
I wasn’t a fan of the book It’s good, but gains nothing from being a Supergirl story And I’m not a fan of the origin retcon considering n52, rebirth and post rebirth were near perfect Not sure why it’s the film basis, it gains nothing being in a universe And the art was meh Didn’t do it for me I’ve found most readers of Woman of Tomorrow They don’t normally read Supergirl
Glad I'm not alone, almost scrapped doing a review for this video because I just thought no one would agree haha! Thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
Honestly ur unbiased reviews usually gives me a idea whether its any good. Keep it up👍. Get ready for the death threats and mobs. 😂😂 What the heck, lets share this puppy with the world😇 Worst thing that has happened is being accused on reddit of being you before, just for sharing ur video. I take that as a compliment😂.
Oh, I'm always prepared for the mobs, but fortunately it's been quite civil so far, just reminds me that the majority who watch the videos are supportive and it's what I need to remember :) thanks for the support mate, and for watching the video! 🐶
No, No you are not. It was overlong, maudlin and tedious. It contioues to baffle me how so many people seem to think this is the best thing since sliced bread. Really cannot see it.
Agreed, the story kept teasing you about cool adventures that they could've had but then just jerks us out at the last second back. They did that 2 or 3 times and I just noted out after that. Nice art and premise, it just needed more space to breath as a series not a one shot
This for me was good not great as most people say it is. The same goes for The many lives of Leila Star for me it was ok not great. Great seeing and hearing different opinions on some hyped books. Keep them coming.
characters can have a different personality it was decent book I think his Wonder Woman is better at Least he added new characters for supergirl to interact with and fight it it would be a very good strategy for your new movie if the sun was red than kryptonian are gonna be humans
I had to buy this series because of Bilquis Everly! I regretfully bought a book written by Tom King in the process. He had two good cynical books - Omega Men and Vision - and he's been locked in ever since.
People like this story? I heard it’s just a rip off of True Grit in space. I’ve avoided Tom King since the end of Mister Miracle. Ending was so bad it ruined everything that came before and I have no interest in reading anything by King ever again the ending was so terrible
I'm glad I'm not alone, was a bit concerned this video may get backlash, but it seems to be the vocal minority that rave non stop about it (and never seem to explain what makes it great, but still) thanks for watching the video mate!
It’s always interesting to see how different people can have different takes on the exact same piece. I liked the story and polished it off in one day. You’re right in that I’m not as versed in Supergirl lore like I am with Superman. I *really* liked that King wrote a story that can be uniquely Kara’s and not a retread of Superman’s villains like Arrowverse Supergirl writers did. I liked that King created villains unique to Kara. I don’t know if King created the Brigands or not, but there are lots of uses for them in the future. Perhaps Terra Man can find a new purpose and origin there? I loved the fresh take on Argo City. I loved the direction of the story and the relationship of the setup to the ending. I didn’t mind the narration. It felt like a fantasy prose story and stretched the form a touch. In fact, I’m reminded of Gaiman’s writing of the Sandman. This may have a very Vertigo feel to it. Certainly, Morpheus was written as the driving force of the story if not always the main character much as we see Kara portrayed. Although I wonder if King wrote Ruthye’s story first and then inserted Kara later changing parts of the story to fit the new edition..? I appreciate your review. It was honest and relevant to what you wanted from the story. I picked it up because of the hype and Gunn’s admission of its relevance to the Supergirl he wanted to portray. I’d read more Supergirl stories like this.
Thank you for the kind words, and I'm glad you had a good time when you read this book. That's an interesting aspect I didn't consider about Krem being a villain specific to Kara, and does add to it being her story. But I think you might have a point too about King writing it as Ruthye's story first and retroactively adding Kara, but sometimes things happen that work out better and I can't imagine how this story would have been if it was just Ruthye's journey. I'm reviewing King's Batman run at the moment, that was another one I was confused on, hopefully you check out that video too! Have a good weekend!
I’ve got to say, I really enjoyed this book for the art and the story but I’m 100% with you on the narration it felt so jarring to especially with how Ruth was narrating, sure at first I thought it was funny she was using such over the top big words for a simple scenario but by the end of the story I felt jaded, still enjoyed it and think the DCU project will elevate this story so much because there is no way they can keep all that narration in a film..(they wouldn’t would they?!)
Writing this before watching the video through. I personally cant stand the art or completely unnecessary overuse or narration (what is this prose with art at the side) so never got past issue 1. I have heard story points from other who read it through, that I also think are completely out of character, which makes me feel this is another indie story written in advance and then simply skinned with the SuperGirl brand. I still advocate to Red Daughter as a much better idea to use to make a Supergirl Movie.
To be fair Supergirl is such a bad character that it looks impossible to make a good story with her, ever. That they managed to make one that is as passable as this one is already an amazing achievement.
🐶🐶 WOOF WOOF! NEW VIDEO! 🚨🚨 Yeah... I'm gonna get some backlash for this one. But after hearing the hype for Tom King's Supergirl: Woman Of Tomorrow, I had to check it out, and as always in my reviews, here are my honest opinions on what many have already called 'One of the best of the decade' 🤦♂ So here's my review, and I'll be signing off for now 😂
.
Yes, you heard right, MADDOGG MERCH IS HERE! 🤯 We've got some phenomenal designs by @shadowcatmanga that you can pick up today and support the channel! This has been a long time coming, so please show some love! Www.MaddoggComics.com 🐶
.
If you want to support the channel, why not treat yourself to something from the channel sponsor: OrganicPricedBooks! Make sure you use code WOOFWOOF for $2 off your orders! 💵 Ordering 4 or more books together? Use code WOOFWOOFSHIPITTOGETHER for 5% off your entire order! 🤯
.
If you're in the EU and you want free shipping, free gifts in every order and Hulk-proof packaging, Comics Bugle is the only website you need! Use code WOOFWOOF for 3% off all non-sale items! 👑
.
Hope you guys enjoy! Hopefully 2024 will be a good one for the channel! If you like this, give it a like, subscribe if you're new, and share where you can!
.
Should have a Where To Start for my next video, but until then, stay Mad, Doggs! WOOF WOOF! 🐶
This was my favorite read of last year, and yet it’s very refreshing to hear a respectful difference of opinion! Really enjoyed your video here as always brotha 💪📚
I'm glad you had a good time when you read it mate! :) and thank you for the kind words, half the fun of this hobby is being able to see what we agree and disagree on and I appreciate you for being cool about it :) thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
@@MaddoggComics yeah good stuff :)
Thanks again!
The comic is garbage
Supergirl was weakened cause it was under a red sun in the a whole issue
MY GOD! I thought I was the only one that thought this story was overrated. Tom King has this tendency to just. keep. rambling with a narration that is not only unneeded with art of this quality, but actively detracts from it.
Man, I really appreciate how honest you keep the videos. Sure, I disagree with a couple of reviews, but I'm watching because I want YOUR opinion.
Thank you for the kind words, always want to make sure I say how I really feel about a book, for better or worse :) there'll always be some titles we don't see eye to eye on, but that's what makes the discussion fun and thanks for watching the video! 🐶
I often make this comment about Tom King's writing. He uses a lot of words to say very little. He uses a lot of flowery language making it seem smarter than it is, when you could sumarize a character's thoughts and still get the point across. I didn't like how this ended. Putting aside what is the cold blooded murder of Ruth's father, there's a point about half way involving a very obvious metaphor for racism and him being responsible for what amounts to a genocide. In my eyes he had lost the right to live at that point. I found it very middle of the road. If you know Kara Zor-El he just wrote a good Supergirl story. There's nothing ground breaking here.
I mean I'm glad that you found some kind of enjoyment out of it but I didn't find any enjoyment out of it because it felt like a sloth and let's be honest the story was literally true grit just with Supergirl instead of Clint Eastwood like the fact that the story focused mainly on the side character then Supergirl it's kind of like well damn what was the point of this book you know yeah it had onions but for the most part it's just kind of a sloth and it's not even a good Supergirl story
Finally saw someone talk about a heavy word count in Tom King's writing. I think this is one of his main weaknest in his writing, if the story is good, people can ignore it maybe, but if the story is mid if not bad, this worsen the reading experience (Maybe that's why people hate it or love it).
I think he actually try to use 'this narration is actually from a book' excuse in women of tomorrow, but sometimes I just speed read most of it just to have a minimum acknowledge.
But I like his character study/relationship story if it done right, so it is still my personal recommandation tbh
I liked the book, didn't love it, due to it's a slog to read and kid's narration is freaking annoying.
Great video.
I gave up after issue 1 because I was bored with it. I don't really vibe with Evely's work here for one thing, but like you it's just the amount of verbiage that comes out of Ruthye's irritating gob that really made it feel tedious. I wasn't down for Kara's characterisation either.
All the people I know who are big Supergirl fans absolutely despise this comic, without exception. Generally it's people who aren't fans of her who are the most receptive to it, I guess becuase they have no expectations? For that reason when Gunn announced the movie would be based on it they were pretty annoyed. I think it *could* make a decent movie but the screenplay writer would be wise to rethink how this story is told because having so much of the narrative rest on Ruthye and not Kara herself is an absolute non-starter - thank god you can't just put narration in movies (unless you've really gone wrong somewhere).
I felt the final battle was a let down, and the characterization of Supergirl left much to be desired. My favorite version of Supergirl is the 2005-2011 comic Supergirl. She went through arguably worse than the stuff new 52 Supergirl did (which is who rebirth supergirl more or less is, unless you count her as a compilation of ALL canon Kara Zor Els because of the death metal DC comic event).
Like I could and would have been more engaged if not for Woman Of Tomorrow Supergirl not being the main character in the comic bearing her name. She was not like the Supergirl I knew and loved, not fun, just serious and sullen. Now if they wanted to they could have sold me on Kara's depression if they brought up the fact that she was suffering from the combined trauma of multiple Kara Zor El comic eras. Meaning she lost Krypton and her people a grand total of 4 times (because 2005-2011 Kara lost her people twice). But they never bothered to really show much from Kara's perspective and it made the story ultimately rather... hollow.
Did not really have much of a point. A much better comic and far shorter you may want to review is Supergirl's 2 part comic in Future State where her story ends... literally.
At least that comic actually has meaning and a lesson to ponder after.
Not so with the hollow Woman Of Tomorrow by Tom King.
I get this feeling sometimes when I read critically acclaimed super hyped runs that I'm left feeling unfulfilled wondering what all the fuss was about. I thought I was the only one in the world who didn't enjoy the Immortal Hulk as much as I thought I would until I found your video on it and you raised a lot of the same issues I had with it too. Just because a run is considered a modern day classic or a must-read doesn't mean it is for everyone.
Yep. This is my take exactly. Was NOT a fan of the immortal hulk either.
Yeah I bailed about a 3rd of the way through. It just meandered with no real purpose.
you didn't like the story because I enjoyed it and I thought it was enjoyable😢
I have read so many glowing reviews of this book and have had it in my cart 3 times. And removed it 3 times. And now I’m glad it did. Mind you when the Deluxe edition is announced I’ll probably get seduced again. But looking at your screen grabs, there’s an awful lot of speech bubbles and narrative going on - it looks a bit like a transcript of a poor football commentary telling me what I’m already looking at. Hopefully I will remember this and resist again when the time comes.
It still may be a book you enjoy, I'm just one opinion, but in all honesty if you tend to not like excessive narration, this may be a miss 😂 thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
...Did he miss that the planet had red sun? Im pretty sure Supergirl went there soley so she could actually get weakened to the point she could get drunk.
I fell asleep several times while reading this book 😅Ruth's narration voice was interesting at first, but quickly became tedious to read and even got annoying at times. Overall, I though this story was just ok - the main plot was "meh", but some of the adventures Kara & Ruth have on their journey were interesting to read, as well as how their friendship was developing. Beautiful art though.
Supposedly it was a rip-off off TRUE GRIT 😀
Thanks for this. I have no opinion on Tom King. He’s done things I like, and things I haven’t. I wanted this to be great, as a Supergirl fan, but I could not get into it at all.
Yeah, I'm very 50/50 on him too, but I had high hopes for this book! What's your favourite Supergirl story? Thanks for watching the video!
I like what Geoff Johns, Sterling and Loeb did with her pre New 52. Though I like the Red Lantern arc as well in the New 52
I read first chapter and found it so boring it's sat on my shelf for 4 months now.
Milly Alcock was cast as Supergirl in January 2024, to debut in another DCU project, reportedly Superman: Legacy. Filming is expected to begin in late 2024.
I think I’ve enjoyed only one title from King which was Vision but honestly everything else from Mr Miracle or Strange Adventures which I hated to the core has been let down after let down so I just basically stay away from his stuff from now on.
I enjoyed Vision too, so maybe we're similar! I'm quite 50/50 on his Batman run though 😂 thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
There are dozens of us!
Nah, you're not the only one
FINALLY, someone else, who doesn't love that book. I also thought it was just okay. Strange Adventure was better, Kings old work was much better.
Thank uou for giving your true opinion and not liking every book that comes out like these other fake youtubers
Thank you mate, sometimes the honesty is a blessing, sometimes a curse, but I'd rather say what I think about a book than just waste everyone's time or try to get a sale. Thank you for the kind words, it means a lot, especially lately, and thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
I hated this book. The narration was awful. It was barely about Supergirl. The art was great though.
If I'm honest, it didn't fascinate me as much as most people. I agree that it can be heavy because of King's narration and, above all, I didn't like the ending, it was like those sudden changes that you mention. Otherwise I love the art and the color, I accept this version of Kara and I think it is an experience and journey that is quite emotional. Thank you for your honesty.
I think that's the most disappointing thing, I loved the art too but just wish it had a story on the same level. Thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
@@MaddoggComicsI think supergirl lost her powers in the issue cause she was under a red sun
same problem I had with gotham city year one was the excessive amount of narration.
Ahh, damn, I may have to swerve that title then! Thanks for watching the video mate!
My personal opinion is that the art is outstanding, but I'm with you on the narration. I don't even think the voice of the narrator stayed the same throughout the book; at the beginning she sounded like she'd stumbled out of a golden age Thor book, but by a couple of issues in she sounded like an extra from Firefly 😂 I enjoyed the book on the whole, but it would have been much better paced if they halved the narration.
You’re not alone I thought it was a drag of a story
Glad it's not just me! Thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
I wasn’t a fan of the book
It’s good, but gains nothing from being a Supergirl story
And I’m not a fan of the origin retcon considering n52, rebirth and post rebirth were near perfect
Not sure why it’s the film basis, it gains nothing being in a universe
And the art was meh
Didn’t do it for me
I’ve found most readers of Woman of Tomorrow
They don’t normally read Supergirl
You’re not the only one I honestly wasn’t a fan of the story either because it felt boring and not interesting in my opinion.
Glad I'm not alone, almost scrapped doing a review for this video because I just thought no one would agree haha! Thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
@@MaddoggComics your welcome man :)
Honestly ur unbiased reviews usually gives me a idea whether its any good. Keep it up👍. Get ready for the death threats and mobs. 😂😂
What the heck, lets share this puppy with the world😇 Worst thing that has happened is being accused on reddit of being you before, just for sharing ur video. I take that as a compliment😂.
Oh, I'm always prepared for the mobs, but fortunately it's been quite civil so far, just reminds me that the majority who watch the videos are supportive and it's what I need to remember :) thanks for the support mate, and for watching the video! 🐶
No, No you are not. It was overlong, maudlin and tedious. It contioues to baffle me how so many people seem to think this is the best thing since sliced bread. Really cannot see it.
I really liked this run. Ruth was definitely tiresome, though.
I had the same sensation, but when I'd read 100 Bullets.
Agreed, the story kept teasing you about cool adventures that they could've had but then just jerks us out at the last second back. They did that 2 or 3 times and I just noted out after that. Nice art and premise, it just needed more space to breath as a series not a one shot
This for me was good not great as most people say it is. The same goes for The many lives of Leila Star for me it was ok not great. Great seeing and hearing different opinions on some hyped books. Keep them coming.
characters can have a different personality it was decent book I think his Wonder Woman is better at Least he added new characters for supergirl to interact with and fight it it would be a very good strategy for your new movie if the sun was red than kryptonian are gonna be humans
I had to buy this series because of Bilquis Everly! I regretfully bought a book written by Tom King in the process. He had two good cynical books - Omega Men and Vision - and he's been locked in ever since.
Oh damn, I haven't checked out Omega Men, is it worth it if I liked Vision? Thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
People like this story? I heard it’s just a rip off of True Grit in space. I’ve avoided Tom King since the end of Mister Miracle. Ending was so bad it ruined everything that came before and I have no interest in reading anything by King ever again the ending was so terrible
Tom king gets hate for no reason
Tom King ripping off a popular existing story...?!
@@jabezcreedevery writer does that
@@yarc9 he gets hate for his writing I would argue (in my opinion)
@@jamesedwardclard he did write good books like superman up in the sky
The narration..😔 It was a good story badly executed.
Thank you! I didn't care for this book and thought I was the only one who didn't love/like it
I'm glad I'm not alone, was a bit concerned this video may get backlash, but it seems to be the vocal minority that rave non stop about it (and never seem to explain what makes it great, but still) thanks for watching the video mate!
@MaddoggComics Couldn't agree more! And thank you for making a video I agree with and just an overall fantastic video.
Buwk
It’s always interesting to see how different people can have different takes on the exact same piece. I liked the story and polished it off in one day. You’re right in that I’m not as versed in Supergirl lore like I am with Superman.
I *really* liked that King wrote a story that can be uniquely Kara’s and not a retread of Superman’s villains like Arrowverse Supergirl writers did. I liked that King created villains unique to Kara. I don’t know if King created the Brigands or not, but there are lots of uses for them in the future. Perhaps Terra Man can find a new purpose and origin there?
I loved the fresh take on Argo City. I loved the direction of the story and the relationship of the setup to the ending.
I didn’t mind the narration. It felt like a fantasy prose story and stretched the form a touch. In fact, I’m reminded of Gaiman’s writing of the Sandman. This may have a very Vertigo feel to it. Certainly, Morpheus was written as the driving force of the story if not always the main character much as we see Kara portrayed.
Although I wonder if King wrote Ruthye’s story first and then inserted Kara later changing parts of the story to fit the new edition..?
I appreciate your review. It was honest and relevant to what you wanted from the story. I picked it up because of the hype and Gunn’s admission of its relevance to the Supergirl he wanted to portray. I’d read more Supergirl stories like this.
Thank you for the kind words, and I'm glad you had a good time when you read this book. That's an interesting aspect I didn't consider about Krem being a villain specific to Kara, and does add to it being her story. But I think you might have a point too about King writing it as Ruthye's story first and retroactively adding Kara, but sometimes things happen that work out better and I can't imagine how this story would have been if it was just Ruthye's journey.
I'm reviewing King's Batman run at the moment, that was another one I was confused on, hopefully you check out that video too! Have a good weekend!
This channel is a great finding. I'll be watching from now on.
Thank you for the kind words, the support means a lot, RUclips can be rough sometimes! Hope you enjoy some of my other videos too! 🐶
Im with you on this one.
I got half way through and gave up.
Not my cup of tea either.
The art was phenomenal, but the story was just...... boring.
I personally loved it, but I see your point.
I'm glad you had an enjoyable reading experience, I wished mine was different. Thanks for watching the video mate! 🐶
I’ve got to say, I really enjoyed this book for the art and the story but I’m 100% with you on the narration it felt so jarring to especially with how Ruth was narrating, sure at first I thought it was funny she was using such over the top big words for a simple scenario but by the end of the story I felt jaded, still enjoyed it and think the DCU project will elevate this story so much because there is no way they can keep all that narration in a film..(they wouldn’t would they?!)
Madddogg back with the hot takes I'm here for it
Writing this before watching the video through. I personally cant stand the art or completely unnecessary overuse or narration (what is this prose with art at the side) so never got past issue 1. I have heard story points from other who read it through, that I also think are completely out of character, which makes me feel this is another indie story written in advance and then simply skinned with the SuperGirl brand. I still advocate to Red Daughter as a much better idea to use to make a Supergirl Movie.
I did not like it either scratchy art and choppy story
Is trash I hate it too
To be fair Supergirl is such a bad character that it looks impossible to make a good story with her, ever.
That they managed to make one that is as passable as this one is already an amazing achievement.
Supergirl not a bad character she had a different personality than superman
This is not true at all!