Niacin supplements & NAD boosters increase vascular inflammation/cardiovascular mortality | Fontana
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 мар 2024
- Actung. Have you been relying on supplements or other substances to possibly prolong your healthspan or lifespan? Then, It's crucial to take note of recent findings published in Nature Medicine.
www.nature.com/articles/s4159...
These new data highlight a concerning finding regarding the excessive consumption of niacin (vitamin B3) and NAD-boosting supplements. The study reveals that 2 terminal metabolites of niacin and NAD metabolism are clinically linked to CVD and vascular inflammation, regardless of traditional risk factors. This suggests that overuse of niacin supplements or NAD-boosting molecules like nicotinamide riboside and nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) could potentially exacerbate vascular inflammation and increase the risk of CVD, despite claims of anti-aging benefits based on inconclusive underpowered trials.
For those who know me, it's evident that I've long been cautious about supplements, advocating for their use only when clinically necessary due to identified deficiencies. The recent study underscores this cautionary approach, revealing that certain supplements or CR-mimetics may not only fail to impact aging but could increase mortality. It's a stark reminder to exercise prudence. Before considering any supplement, it's crucial to rely on solid RCTs that affirm both safety and efficacy.
Let’s go back to the study. By employing untargeted metabolomics as a discovery tool, alongside subsequent structural elucidation studies and rigorous validation, genetic, and vascular functional analyses, Ferrell et al. demonstrated that two terminal metabolites arising from niacin and NAD metabolism are clinically correlated with cardiovascular disease (CVD) irrespective of traditional risk factors. Additionally, both metabolites are genetically associated with vascular inflammation.
Niacin, commonly found in fortified food staples, plays a role in NAD synthesis and has been observed to increase circulating levels of 2PY and 4PY when consumed excessively, whether as an over-the-counter supplement, a cholesterol-lowering medication, or, even worst as a NAD booster. The findings from this study suggests that the terminal metabolites of excessive niacin intake, particularly 4PY, are linked to increased risks of major adverse cardiovascular events (MACE) and may contribute to the underlying mechanisms of residual cardiovascular disease risk through inflammatory pathways, including the direct enhancement of VCAM-1 expression. Both laboratory-based and in vivo investigations indicate that 4PY can act as a catalyst for vascular inflammation and contribute to vascular phenotypes relevant to the initiation and development of CVD. Recent clinical trials have even revealed that while niacin can lower LDL cholesterol and elevate high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol while reducing triglyceride levels, when used alongside high-potency statin therapy, niacin not only fails to mitigate CVD risk but, according to a meta-analysis of the latest trials, may even increase overall mortality.
Niacin is prevalent in Western diets, with recommended daily allowances varying based on age and sex, typically ranging from 14 to 18 mg. Despite its natural abundance in foods like tuna and peanuts ( e.g. 100 g tuna contain 22 mg of niacin, 100 g of brown rice contain 2.6 mg, 100 g of Peanuts (Dry Roasted) contain 14.4 mg) over 50 nations, including the United States, mandate niacin fortification in staple foods to prevent pellagra. Moreover, approximately 36% of US residents reported supplementing with niacin between 1999 and 2010, leading to an estimated daily consumption of 35 mg in 2010, which tripled the recommended intake. Recent surveys suggest an average daily niacin consumption of 48 mg, that is more than triple the recommended daily allowance. Additionally, NAD-boosting supplements like nicotinamide riboside and nicotinamide mononucleotide NMN also increase the levels of 2PY and 4PY. These supplements are often marketed for their alleged anti-aging benefits, despite incomplete weak clinical trials.
The findings from current studies suggest that optimal niacin supplementation may require a more tailored approach, balancing the replenishment of NAD pool members while avoiding excessive generation of 4PY. This nuanced strategy could help achieve intended health benefits without exacerbating risks associated with elevated 4PY levels.
In summary, it's crucial to exercise caution amidst the noisy abundance of information available, as not all of it is beneficial to your health. Don't blindly accept claims without proper evidence from well-designed RCTs regarding safety and efficacy. Remember, if a substance is powerful enough to extend lifespan, it can't be inherently safe at any dosage. Therefore, if something is deemed safe regardless of dosage, it's likely just plain water. Conversely, if a substance is potent, it must be approached with careful dosing to mitigate potential risks.
Important findings, which should motivate cautious changes in use of supplements and long-term practices concerning additives in foods.
Trigonelline,found in fenugreek and coffee for instance is also a NAD booster. Could it also be harmful?
Salve Prof. - sempre molto interessanti i suoi video.
Prendo da più di un anno un integratore di riboflavina per mal di testa e vari altri motivi.
Lei crede che ad oggi ci siano controindicazioni (come è venuto fuori per la B3) rispetto ad una integrazione di B2?
ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Riboflavin-HealthProfessional/
@@LuigiFontanaMDPhD Sulla base dell'articolo postato immagino di capire che l'eccesso di b2 non produce danni paragonabili all'eccesso di b3
@@riccardo859 anche io ho avuto questa impressione, ma chissà. I benefici della b2 sembrano molti specialmente in caso di malassorbimento intestinale(come il mio caso). Nel mio caso abbassa anche l’omocisteina.
100g of peanuts that's a lot for a healthy diet.
How nutrients/vitamins RDAs are determined? What's the science behind this?
What are some other supplements that you have found similar to this?
Sarebbe interessante Professore creare una rubrica sulla vitamine che in eccesso producono effetti tossici. Complimenti per i suoi contenuti
What about focusing on the salvaged pathway of NAD ,using supplements like apigenin 🤔
"Statins stimulate atherosclerosis and heart failure: pharmacological mechanisms" Harumi Okuyama et al. Expert Rev Clin Pharmacol. 2015 Mar.
In italiano lo metterà?
Sure...statins good...niacin bad...say the experts that really care about your health...
🙏
The pressure to waste money on supplements is unprecedented. The average person has no chance against the marketing machine aimed at him masked as "science". Thanks Prof. Fontana.
I have used 1500 mg for 30 years. Many people use niacin for cholesterol. This is just one study and there are many, many more! I wouldn't pay that much attention to it.
@@jimmiers8218 sure pal, you do what you feel like...I meant it in general..
No disrespect you need read more!!!!
@@jimmiers8218 Shouldn't we all?