Thanks for mentioning my comment. I feel honored man :). What if Tugs continued and never got cancelled? What if The Missing Coach never got cancelled and became the official introduction of Donald and Douglas in Season 2? What if Wilbert Awdry continued writing RWS books until he turned 70? What if Shining Time Station never aired in the US? What if the 1953 RWS TV Adaption attempt didn't have Henry's model derail?
I know you might not see these two but I have two 1:What if Lyrick Studios (Lyons group),the creators of Barney got the rights to do a Railway Series adaptation in 1992 2:What if Christopher became a consultant for the show after season 5
Another one: What if Nickelodeon bought Thomas in 2002 instead of Hit entertainment? (Yes. Hit entertainment bought Thomas in 2002 despite the first season in the Hit era being in 2004.)
Boy do I have a load of questions for a potential part 2 or their own videos. What if Wilbert Awdry saw season 5? What if we started calling the Brenner era something different like Arc era, similar to how some people now call the Miller era Nitrogen era? What if BWBA was much better, like the Unlucky Tug’s version? What if newer fans who grew up with BWBA start feeling nostalgic about it in many years from now and start defending it, similar to what’s happened with the HiT era in recent years? What if Mattel was involved with the Miller/Nitrogen era? (A friend of mine discussed this with me a while back) What if ERTL continued? What if Thomas fans didn’t blindly hate Chuggington and Underground Ernie for "ripping off Thomas"? What if Mattel allowed Bachmann make characters who weren’t in the CGI series? What if the original cut of Thomas and the Magic Railroad was released? What if the narrow gauge engines appeared in AEG? (I don’t think this would look good) What if the learning segments were left in the Great Discovery? What if the Brenner era brought back characters from the HiT era?
I've got a pretty good one. And it's one I've made stuff out of. What if Thomas got the generation reboot/rebrand treatment that brands like MLP and Transformers get, and TTTE got a Generation 2?
I got a few very good what if's for future vids... 1. What if Thomas and the Magic Railroad NEVER HAPPENED??? 2. What if Thomas season 6 & 7 had the same quality, writing and tone as Season 5? 3. What if Thomas & Friends hadn't done Wilbert Awdry dirty by stop using Railway Stories literally right after he died? (AKA What if they adapted Railway Stories for Seasons 5, 6 & 7?) 4. What if Thomas and the Magic Railroad was instead something like The Adventure Begins? 5. What if Mike O' Donnell and Junior Campbell stayed to compose Seasons 8-24?
What if David Mitton never return to Thomas season 3 after Tugs cancelled but instead he make another shows about Ocean Liner? (Do you think Ocean Liner shows would be success or not if David Mitton never return to TS3 if he has made another shows about ship?)
What would happen if Alec Baldwin did S7 and the Production wasn't rushed? What is your thoughts on the 80th Anniversary? What would happen if sny other company bought Thomas?
What if Duck was part of the Steam Team and Oliver was a major supporting character in the HIT era? Do you think Emily would still appear in CGI, or would she fade into obscurity like Arthur ans Murdoch?
Here are my what if ideas for you What if Hasbro bought the rice to Thomas in 2026 after the 80th anniversary What if illumination entertainment Rewritten or rebooted Thomas and the Magic Railroad Either in 2019 or 2020 What if Andrew Bender What's the head writer during season 8 Through 16 What if the dark cut of day at the Diesels made into the Final Cut What if Sharon Miller Was the writer for King of the Railway and season 17 What if a Thomas and the Magic Railroad sequel replace calling all engines In 2005
There is no dark cut of Day of the Diesels, the only difference from the final version is that the fire in the opening was much more extreme and Dennis, Splatter and Dodge returned in place of Norman, Paxton and Sidney.
What if the workers Who worked on the movie Thomas and the magic railroad damn forget The characters cranky Edward and George The steamroller and if they still put PT Boomer in the movie and the final cut
That’s why Trevor would say Because cranky Edward and George they didn’t make it in the storyboard because they forgot but luckily we seeing cranky’s legs
What if hasbro bought Thomas and friends like they would easily bring back from ERTL toy line and the take along toy line as well for older fans like who grow on those toys as well and update into the modern day
What if Thomas was a lner J50 I just wonder how the Thomas franchise be completely different then the one we saw Thomas as a E2 plus I think fans would’ve been happy for Thomas being a J50 I think plus I don’t mind Thomas being a J50
If the nitrogen era continued I think the Thomas franchise would be way much more popular and heck they would still keep nitrogen cgi style up to season 15 to 24 I think don’t know 🤷 but thats just my theory of a what if Thomas what do you think
Thanks for mentioning my comment. I feel honored man :).
What if Tugs continued and never got cancelled?
What if The Missing Coach never got cancelled and became the official introduction of Donald and Douglas in Season 2?
What if Wilbert Awdry continued writing RWS books until he turned 70?
What if Shining Time Station never aired in the US?
What if the 1953 RWS TV Adaption attempt didn't have Henry's model derail?
You mean Shining Time airing in the UK? It was from the US.
@@joshuaW5621 never aired. My mistake. thanks
@@therocknrollgamer9572 no problem. But what if it aired in the UK?
HiT is the reason the reason the Brenner era happened not Mattel. the Mattel changes started in 2016 due to the 2-to-3-year production timeline
Also, Andrew Brenner was the script editor for Blue Mountain Mystery.
And he was writing for Fireman Sam around the time.
I know you might not see these two but I have two
1:What if Lyrick Studios (Lyons group),the creators of Barney got the rights to do a Railway Series adaptation in 1992
2:What if Christopher became a consultant for the show after season 5
what if the HIT era never ended but it was like "refurbished" just what brenner did to cgi thomas
Another one: What if Nickelodeon bought Thomas in 2002 instead of Hit entertainment? (Yes. Hit entertainment bought Thomas in 2002 despite the first season in the Hit era being in 2004.)
@@EImposter2005 where would it go during the Viacom CBS split up
Knowing what Nickelodeon has become since 2009, they probably would have assassinated it anyway.
Boy do I have a load of questions for a potential part 2 or their own videos.
What if Wilbert Awdry saw season 5?
What if we started calling the Brenner era something different like Arc era, similar to how some people now call the Miller era Nitrogen era?
What if BWBA was much better, like the Unlucky Tug’s version?
What if newer fans who grew up with BWBA start feeling nostalgic about it in many years from now and start defending it, similar to what’s happened with the HiT era in recent years?
What if Mattel was involved with the Miller/Nitrogen era? (A friend of mine discussed this with me a while back)
What if ERTL continued?
What if Thomas fans didn’t blindly hate Chuggington and Underground Ernie for "ripping off Thomas"?
What if Mattel allowed Bachmann make characters who weren’t in the CGI series?
What if the original cut of Thomas and the Magic Railroad was released?
What if the narrow gauge engines appeared in AEG? (I don’t think this would look good)
What if the learning segments were left in the Great Discovery?
What if the Brenner era brought back characters from the HiT era?
What if Thomas and friends was bought by Disney when hit entertainment was on sale
What If Jack and the Pack had some form of a crossover with Bob the Builder
I've got a pretty good one. And it's one I've made stuff out of.
What if Thomas got the generation reboot/rebrand treatment that brands like MLP and Transformers get, and TTTE got a Generation 2?
What If Thomas Remake This Episodes
I got a few very good what if's for future vids...
1. What if Thomas and the Magic Railroad NEVER HAPPENED???
2. What if Thomas season 6 & 7 had the same quality, writing and tone as Season 5?
3. What if Thomas & Friends hadn't done Wilbert Awdry dirty by stop using Railway Stories literally right after he died?
(AKA What if they adapted Railway Stories for Seasons 5, 6 & 7?)
4. What if Thomas and the Magic Railroad was instead something like The Adventure Begins?
5. What if Mike O' Donnell and Junior Campbell stayed to compose Seasons 8-24?
What if David Mitton never return to Thomas season 3 after Tugs cancelled but instead he make another shows about Ocean Liner? (Do you think Ocean Liner shows would be success or not if David Mitton never return to TS3 if he has made another shows about ship?)
What If: Thomas: The Great Discovery was a very perfect Thomas film that it got a sequel.
It would’ve been nice to have an actual series 25 before AEG
What would happen if Alec Baldwin did S7 and the Production wasn't rushed?
What is your thoughts on the 80th Anniversary?
What would happen if sny other company bought Thomas?
Hers another one, what if there are more rws books between 1973-1982 and 1997-2006
What if Micheal Brendon and Micheal Angelis narrates the brennar era
What if Disney bought Thomas?
What if Duck was part of the Steam Team and Oliver was a major supporting character in the HIT era? Do you think Emily would still appear in CGI, or would she fade into obscurity like Arthur ans Murdoch?
What if Saban Brands brought Thomas in 2008
Would hasbro bought thomas and turning it back to the model series or CGI series?
Don’t know about that.
Here are my what if ideas for you
What if Hasbro bought the rice to Thomas in 2026 after the 80th anniversary
What if illumination entertainment Rewritten or rebooted Thomas and the Magic Railroad Either in 2019 or 2020
What if Andrew Bender What's the head writer during season 8 Through 16
What if the dark cut of day at the Diesels made into the Final Cut
What if Sharon Miller Was the writer for King of the Railway and season 17
What if a Thomas and the Magic Railroad sequel replace calling all engines In 2005
There is no dark cut of Day of the Diesels, the only difference from the final version is that the fire in the opening was much more extreme and Dennis, Splatter and Dodge returned in place of Norman, Paxton and Sidney.
What is Thomas and the Magic Railroad never existed?
Then season 5 wouldn’t have been as action packed as it is.
Alternative companies to buy Thomas?
(Like name one completely random company. Preferably one that isn't hasbro. Everyone says that)
What if the workers
Who worked on the movie Thomas and the magic railroad damn forget The characters cranky Edward and George The steamroller and if they still put PT Boomer in the movie and the final cut
Edward was never in the script, they never planned to have him in the movie for whatever strange reason.
That’s why Trevor would say
Because cranky Edward and George they didn’t make it in the storyboard because they forgot but luckily we seeing cranky’s legs
(This is for msfan18738) what if Thomas and Friends had dot eyes.
What if Hit entertainment never gave thomas and friends to mattel
What if hasbro bought Thomas and friends like they would easily bring back from ERTL toy line and the take along toy line as well for older fans like who grow on those toys as well and update into the modern day
It’s possible they would have done the same thing Mattel has done, probably sooner, and some fans would be claiming that Mattel would be better.
What if Thomas was a lner J50 I just wonder how the Thomas franchise be completely different then the one we saw Thomas as a E2 plus I think fans would’ve been happy for Thomas being a J50 I think plus I don’t mind Thomas being a J50
If the nitrogen era continued I think the Thomas franchise would be way much more popular and heck they would still keep nitrogen cgi style up to season 15 to 24 I think don’t know 🤷 but thats just my theory of a what if Thomas what do you think
What if the brennar era continued
I have already made that, here if the link: ruclips.net/video/siG0vV7nruQ/видео.htmlsi=Kslv_yodKfDE7At2
@Stepney2009 oh ok