@@At0mHeart May,Paige,Clapton,even Slash are coming to my mind,but Dave is genuine white bluesman.BB King told him,after hearing "Shine on...";"are you sure you're not black?"
Or not. It is a good song, but it does not have the Pink Floyd magic for me. I know that is personal and there are a lot of people who will agree with you :)
@@LittleMelianna Yes I know, I'm weird. I just don't like it when you don't want to work with somebody anymore but still keep playing his songs. Also I miss Waters' bass and singing. No magic for me.
@@Meine.Postma that is an odd way of describing their divorce. Do you subscribe to leaving children with only one of their parents as well? It should be noted that it was Waters who left, it was Waters who fired Richard, it was Waters who wished to stay in the past, as evident by the horrible creations Waters has embarked on since his departure, to include bigotry. I think it is universally acknowledged that Division Bell & Momentary Lapse of Reason are far greater than Final Cut & Ummagumma, the last Waters & Syd albums. The support of what Steven Sorrell stated is simply the success that can be seen, especially in comparison to Waters.
this band would have been lost without David gilmour from the start they haven't needed anybody else for the last 25 or 30 years this guy's vocals and instrumentals are vital Roger basically created the band but this guy has kept his craft at the forefront of his concentration and it shows... anytime Roger is there they kind of diminishes from everything cuz he's so dramatic David gilmour always sings the songs to perfection...
David Gilmour is one of the Greatest musicians to ever take a breath on this planet. Then God placed a string instrument in his hands and made him a music God!
About min 7:38 David Gilmour is just an unmatched musician in so many words that I can't even be able to find accuracy to describe, those dynamics he just produces out of thin air, but how they just hit real Sutil in the soul fibers. This man was indeed blessed with a gift of music, if I can go further, before Pink Floyd, he was just a busker, playing music for coins, now he is a living legend, but he deserves it for sure. God bless David Gilmour!!
These guys were highly educated and intelligent. They were all studying architecture when they met up. If I recall, Syd and the others formed the band to help pay schooling costs. Also note: Gilmour and Barrett were childhood friends. Gilmour taught Syd how to play guitar. It was one of the reasons they brought Gilmour into the band when Syd began to slip away.
David Gilmour is a contemporary Confucius of British psychedelic rock.Simple,ingenious and soulful music.I respect you for your choice(Hello,salute from Russia,Gilmor & Pink Floyd forever).❤️🖐️👍
Kristin you are beautiful. You remind me so much of my ex-wife when we got married 30 years ago this month by the way. She was gorgeous as well. Keep doing Pink Floyd and David Gilmour. This is a great song with a lot of passion and emotion
I've seen Floyd twice live (Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell/Pulse) and it's not a show, it's a religious experience. This song reminds me of my childhood in the English countryside, mowing lawns, bees, birds and church bells. Always brings fond memories and a smile to my face.
Hi Kristin. Thank you for reacting to this. Glad you liked it. This is one of my favorite versions of this song. He visited Pompeii with the Pink Floyd in 1971 and played in that same ancient amphitheater, but without any spectators other than their crew. It was very surreal, they played "Echoes" (another of my favorites) along with other songs. He returned to the same amphitheater with the band in the video we just saw in 2016(45 years later). They played to some 3,000 people over two nights I believe. They are all phenomenal musicians in their own right. I've heard that was the first live performance to a crowd of any kind since the year 45 AD. Hence they were not allowed to sit in the seating area. They were all on the floor of the arena. David Gilmore was 70 years old at the time. The video on the screen was the original video released with the song by Pink Floyd(minus Roger Waters) in 1994. I believe Mr Gilmore doesn't play notes on his guitars......he plays emotions on the strings.
I was too young to see the original Pink Floyd back in the day but I did see them on both the Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell tours and I don't think anyone can touch them for the sheer magnitude and majesty of their performances. David Gilmore is a true master on the guitar.
The version from LIVE in GDansk with an orchestra even better on lap steel slide solo and outro with acoustic classical guitar is simply sublime. As the producer of 'The Wall ' Bob Ezrin said, "David has the best hands in the business. You could give him a ukulele and he'll make it sing like a Stradivarius" Yes, indeed. I couldn't agree more.
That is quickly becoming one of my favorite songs of all time. The best version of this song I've found is live at the AOL session in 2006. DAVID'S voice has never sounded better.
Yes! I have the AOL Sessions on DVD; when “ The Endless River “ was released the sale included a live performance DVD which included three or four songs from The AOL Sessions. So well recorded, produced and performed.
Knowing the bands history and the lyrics of this song, it chronicles the bands climb to super stardom and he's now looking back on such. Basically says how they all desired to reach the top of their mountain but when they did, they still felt the need to reach for more. Also looking back on what they had to go thru to get there...aka the burning bridges, etc.
Sorry for the multiple posts, but a lot of people either don't realize or look past the fact this show was the first live broadcast with an audience in the coliseum since 92 AD. Think about that...the last performance there in front of people were actual gladiators.
Love your inspired requests and reactions !! DG is a living god and to sound that good at 70 years young is testament too fine wine ageing beautifully . This version loses ground due to not having other Pink Floyd members around it ,so pulse live version is better. The last time DG played here was recording Live at Pompeii in 1971 with no audience,so epic too go back there in 2016.
Great choice! If I had to choose a favorite PF song (and there are SO many) it would be this one - as we grow older, songs like this take on a deeper meaning - the loss of our childhood dreams as we become adults. i agree with one of the other comments that the Pulse Live version (or the studio version) is even more so.
I agree with you Charleston. It is one of my PF faves as well. Could've been better if more of them(Original Pink Floyd) were there with him. However what makes this so special to me is #1: the quality of his performance at the age of 70, #2: His return to Pompeii after 45 years and playing to a crowd in the same arena and last but not least the closing of the song with the acoustic guitar after he finished playing on the slide guitar. He did not do this so beautifully on the Pulse version nor the studio version.
A reflection on Gilmour's, Waters and Barrett' young lives in Cambridge . the movie's set in one of the Cambridge Colleges, Grantchester and the Cambridgeshire Fens with a view of Ely Cathedral.
If you really want to enjoy Pink Floyd. Listen with Headphones 🎧... The Albums tell you a Story from Beginning to the End.... Greatest Light Show Ever.... Great Show ☺️
Man, man, man... David is getting so old!! Pink Floyd is all but gone... damn this video reminds me that things are finite. * however we do have all the goodness to reflex upon when listening to video's and recorded music from guys like David!! \m/
@@KristinKali Have you heard his acoustic version ( with choir & strings )? ruclips.net/video/lgE-FNhHy54/видео.html I have this entire concert on DVD. It's FANTASTIC! That 'movie' projected on the screen behind him, is actually the official 1994 music video.
Get emotional listening to David. All the feeling he puts into playing comes out again and it's physical. Great reaction and I am very glad you did it!
As amazing as this concert was, I still feel it's missing something, which Pulse in 1994 had. There's an extra layer of warmth and soul that this concert just doesn't have. 1994 was peak, the high water mark before the tide rolled back. They had a perfect collection of musicians, vocalists and stage designers, and I suspect it will never be equalled.
Haha. Awesome eh? This song is from the Division Bell. Many of the songs were written or co-written by David's wife, Polly Sampson, who's a novelist. Great songs on that album. The Pompeii concert is incredible for audio and setting.
"So David, what are you gonna play tonight?" ..... "Well, I rather thought we could start off with a little slide solo that will make you think my strings are made from liquid gold followed by a modest bit of acoustic noodling that'll make you believe that the Angel Gabriel is playing at the feet of god himself....."
What runs there in the background behind the film is the original video clip for the recording. Not only the music but also this work is fantastic and phenomenal.
Kristin, you should also check out David's version of High Hopes at the Gdansk concert with fellow band member Richard Wright (his last performance before he died). It's just as good as this one. And their performance of Echoes at that concert! My Lord! Their musical chemistry was sublime. You should react to Echoes.
I don't know what the significance is but I'm pretty sure that the bust they are carrying at the end is Syd Barrett. That's too long of a story to get into now but a lot of respect for David doing that. You can't really see it in this video but if you watch the actual video you will.
I can tell he’s struggling more to play the instruments. It’s really sad. But High Hopes Live at PULSE in 1994 is way better. Such a different experience.
I can see you’ve been Floyd encapsulated totally stuck to your screen, When David plays the acoustic guitar, I ve played this song on my stereo for my 4 year old who doesn’t sit still for more than a minute but this song works tho
The song, Dogs Of War, by Pink Floyd is really good, but not a lot of air play....here's the link to the live performance if you're interested in reacting to it...ruclips.net/video/XpTXHhMa_YQ/видео.html ...it's symbolic of the issues of today....
Kristin ❤️! I'm going to be 🔥 #controversial 🔥 and say I prefer Nightwish's version. 😋 I wonder if David is goung to retaliate with a Nightwish cover? Maybe "The Islander"?
![FNAF Into the Pit has A LOT of Unused Graphics | LOST BITS [TetraBitGaming]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6YhZCRdipl4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Sepultura - Territory [@Volta Club, Moscow, 13.03.2015]](/img/1.gif)
He’s just on another level
Chills every time Gilmour comes in with the slide guitar at 5:54. So powerful.
That's a lap-steel guitar friendo
The only guitarist that actually add melody and emotion in his solos freaking love him
Not only but one of the best
Mark knopfler is the only one that comes close in that aspect in my opinion
@@krypto_9872 David Likes Mark.
Search for his opinion. Its nice to read about it
Not the only,but certainly the best.
@@At0mHeart May,Paige,Clapton,even Slash are coming to my mind,but Dave is genuine white bluesman.BB King told him,after hearing "Shine on...";"are you sure you're not black?"
"High Hopes" is one of these latter-day Pink Floyd songs that, without Roger Waters or Syd Barrett, Gilmour could carry the mantle with pride.
Or not. It is a good song, but it does not have the Pink Floyd magic for me. I know that is personal and there are a lot of people who will agree with you :)
@@Meine.Postma it DOES have the Pink Floyd magic for me
@@LittleMelianna Yes I know, I'm weird. I just don't like it when you don't want to work with somebody anymore but still keep playing his songs. Also I miss Waters' bass and singing. No magic for me.
@@Meine.Postma that is an odd way of describing their divorce. Do you subscribe to leaving children with only one of their parents as well? It should be noted that it was Waters who left, it was Waters who fired Richard, it was Waters who wished to stay in the past, as evident by the horrible creations Waters has embarked on since his departure, to include bigotry. I think it is universally acknowledged that Division Bell & Momentary Lapse of Reason are far greater than Final Cut & Ummagumma, the last Waters & Syd albums. The support of what Steven Sorrell stated is simply the success that can be seen, especially in comparison to Waters.
this band would have been lost without David gilmour from the start they haven't needed anybody else for the last 25 or 30 years this guy's vocals and instrumentals are vital Roger basically created the band but this guy has kept his craft at the forefront of his concentration and it shows... anytime Roger is there they kind of diminishes from everything cuz he's so dramatic David gilmour always sings the songs to perfection...
David Gilmour is one of the Greatest musicians to ever take a breath on this planet. Then God placed a string instrument in his hands and made him a music God!
About min 7:38 David Gilmour is just an unmatched musician in so many words that I can't even be able to find accuracy to describe, those dynamics he just produces out of thin air, but how they just hit real Sutil in the soul fibers. This man was indeed blessed with a gift of music, if I can go further, before Pink Floyd, he was just a busker, playing music for coins, now he is a living legend, but he deserves it for sure. God bless David Gilmour!!
what can you say when you have just seen greatness
You don't need to say anything.
David. Is. The. Best. 👍👍👍
I heard this the other day on satellite radio.. 😳 omg 🔥 it was still just as epic as the first time I heard it!
These guys were highly educated and intelligent. They were all studying architecture when they met up. If I recall, Syd and the others formed the band to help pay schooling costs. Also note: Gilmour and Barrett were childhood friends. Gilmour taught Syd how to play guitar. It was one of the reasons they brought Gilmour into the band when Syd began to slip away.
This is actually one of Pinks Floyd’s best songs. it is truely one of Pink Floyd’s masterpieces & shows the true core of what Pink Floyd is👍
This performance in particular is great. I feel like you can tell he’s up there playing for his long lost mates.
David Gilmour is a master of emotional music. His or Pink Floyd music is special to other music.
what heaven sounds like
Wowwww he's a master
David Gilmour is a contemporary Confucius of British psychedelic rock.Simple,ingenious and soulful music.I respect you for your choice(Hello,salute from Russia,Gilmor & Pink Floyd forever).❤️🖐️👍
Kristin you are beautiful. You remind me so much of my ex-wife when we got married 30 years ago this month by the way. She was gorgeous as well. Keep doing Pink Floyd and David Gilmour. This is a great song with a lot of passion and emotion
Absolute genius!!!
Lost innocence of childhood when everything held a sense of wonder.
I've seen Floyd twice live (Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell/Pulse) and it's not a show, it's a religious experience.
This song reminds me of my childhood in the English countryside, mowing lawns, bees, birds and church bells.
Always brings fond memories and a smile to my face.
Brilliant absolutely so. Still can bring a tear to my eye
Hi Kristin. Thank you for reacting to this. Glad you liked it. This is one of my favorite versions of this song. He visited Pompeii with the Pink Floyd in 1971 and played in that same ancient amphitheater, but without any spectators other than their crew. It was very surreal, they played "Echoes" (another of my favorites) along with other songs.
He returned to the same amphitheater with the band in the video we just saw in 2016(45 years later). They played to some 3,000 people over two nights I believe. They are all phenomenal musicians in their own right. I've heard that was the first live performance to a crowd of any kind since the year 45 AD. Hence they were not allowed to sit in the seating area. They were all on the floor of the arena. David Gilmore was 70 years old at the time. The video on the screen was the original video released with the song by Pink Floyd(minus Roger Waters) in 1994.
I believe Mr Gilmore doesn't play notes on his guitars......he plays emotions on the strings.
👊❤️🗣I came back to reread your comment! It’s very well put together and so true!
The only misstep to your very well written breakdown of the Pompeii experiences is the misspelling of David Gilmour’s name.
David is truly a gift to this troubled world!
Got to love how Dave Gilmour plays slide guitar
I truly believe that David Gilmore was sent here from another WORLD 🌍 just so WE HUMANS can appreciate the Way He PLAYED the GUITAR 🎸🎶💜
I was too young to see the original Pink Floyd back in the day but I did see them on both the Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell tours and I don't think anyone can touch them for the sheer magnitude and majesty of their performances. David Gilmore is a true master on the guitar.
The version from LIVE in GDansk with an orchestra even better on lap steel slide solo and outro with acoustic classical guitar is simply sublime. As the producer of 'The Wall ' Bob Ezrin said, "David has the best hands in the business. You could give him a ukulele and he'll make it sing like a Stradivarius"
Yes, indeed. I couldn't agree more.
He is the only one who can get into my soul beautiful
That is quickly becoming one of my favorite songs of all time. The best version of this song I've found is live at the AOL session in 2006. DAVID'S voice has never sounded better.
Yes! I have the AOL Sessions on DVD; when “ The Endless River “ was released the sale included a live performance DVD which included three or four songs from The AOL Sessions. So well recorded, produced and performed.
This was an amazing performance from Gilmour! I wish I was there to see it!
👊❤️🗣me too!! 😀
Knowing the bands history and the lyrics of this song, it chronicles the bands climb to super stardom and he's now looking back on such. Basically says how they all desired to reach the top of their mountain but when they did, they still felt the need to reach for more. Also looking back on what they had to go thru to get there...aka the burning bridges, etc.
David Gilmour is a absolute genius amazing talent doesn't get much better than this
Coming back To Life...the live Pulse concert...will blow your mind!
Gilmour on the lap steel never will get old.
DG is my favorite guitarist, and has been since I heard his solo in Time way back in 1973! Great way to start my day! Thanks KK!
What do you want from me - Live Pompeii is amazing
Looking back on our youngest days...sounds like...all the above❤
thank you for a genuine reaction x
Sorry for the multiple posts, but a lot of people either don't realize or look past the fact this show was the first live broadcast with an audience in the coliseum since 92 AD. Think about that...the last performance there in front of people were actual gladiators.
Just time,ambition, success and the loss of the simplicity of youth -
Love your inspired requests and reactions !! DG is a living god and to sound that good at 70 years young is testament too fine wine ageing beautifully . This version loses ground due to not having other Pink Floyd members around it ,so pulse live version is better. The last time DG played here was recording Live at Pompeii in 1971 with no audience,so epic too go back there in 2016.
👊❤️🥰🗣I Thankyou bc it definitely is a learning experience and a journey that I am here for the long run!
Great choice! If I had to choose a favorite PF song (and there are SO many) it would be this one - as we grow older, songs like this take on a deeper meaning - the loss of our childhood dreams as we become adults. i agree with one of the other comments that the Pulse Live version (or the studio version) is even more so.
I agree with you Charleston. It is one of my PF faves as well. Could've been better if more of them(Original Pink Floyd) were there with him. However what makes this so special to me is #1: the quality of his performance at the age of 70, #2: His return to Pompeii after 45 years and playing to a crowd in the same arena and last but not least the closing of the song with the acoustic guitar after he finished playing on the slide guitar. He did not do this so beautifully on the Pulse version nor the studio version.
A reflection on Gilmour's, Waters and Barrett' young lives in Cambridge . the movie's set in one of the Cambridge Colleges, Grantchester and the Cambridgeshire Fens with a view of Ely Cathedral.
Magic ✌️
David Gilmore is a music genius.
His last name is spelled Gi l m o u r
If you really want to enjoy Pink Floyd. Listen with Headphones 🎧... The Albums tell you a Story from Beginning to the End.... Greatest Light Show Ever.... Great Show ☺️
SHOUT OUT TO YOU
👊❤️🗣Shout out to you King! 🙏💕
Another great song from this album is “what do you want from me?”
One of my favorite Pink Floyd songs....great job, and thanks.
Thanks for listening Raymond!
Man, man, man... David is getting so old!! Pink Floyd is all but gone... damn this video reminds me that things are finite. * however we do have all the goodness to reflex upon when listening to video's and recorded music from guys like David!! \m/
Thank you Kristin for sharing this masterpiece!
My pleasure 🙏💕 I wish I was more educated in this kind of music.. it’s profound 🙂
Sublime!.
Have you ever seen a guitar crying, that is David Gilmour
Love David Gilmour! Love your reaction! Please react to" Run Like Hell" live at Pompeii. It will blow you away!
once again the pulse version is better but imagine being that good at 70
🤯 you nailed this comment! This man is a Legend for a reason
@@KristinKali Have you heard his acoustic version ( with choir & strings )? ruclips.net/video/lgE-FNhHy54/видео.html I have this entire concert on DVD. It's FANTASTIC! That 'movie' projected on the screen behind him, is actually the official 1994 music video.
The Royal Albert Hall version is even better
Get emotional listening to David. All the feeling he puts into playing comes out again and it's physical. Great reaction and I am very glad you did it!
As amazing as this concert was, I still feel it's missing something, which Pulse in 1994 had. There's an extra layer of warmth and soul that this concert just doesn't have. 1994 was peak, the high water mark before the tide rolled back. They had a perfect collection of musicians, vocalists and stage designers, and I suspect it will never be equalled.
It is missing Richard Wright. Unfortunately we didnt get to see them do echoes together in Pompeii again. But Echoes live in Gdansk was incredible.
Haha. Awesome eh? This song is from the Division Bell. Many of the songs were written or co-written by David's wife, Polly Sampson, who's a novelist. Great songs on that album. The Pompeii concert is incredible for audio and setting.
😳👊❤️🗣BYRNEZ!!! You know your stuff! And yes! This was immaculate! 🥰
She wrote LYRICS, not music.
Cool
OMG, GOD EXIST. AND PLAY THE GUITAR
I AND IT'S CALLED DAVID GILMOUR
"So David, what are you gonna play tonight?" ..... "Well, I rather thought we could start off with a little slide solo that will make you think my strings are made from liquid gold followed by a modest bit of acoustic noodling that'll make you believe that the Angel Gabriel is playing at the feet of god himself....."
What runs there in the background behind the film is the original video clip for the recording. Not only the music but also this work is fantastic and phenomenal.
y el video oficial es hermoso tambien, todo es onírico, un sueño nostalgico e inalcanzable.
I loved your reaction!
Very underrated album.
The sequel to time, Being successful but older much older,
You are 🔥
Sos hermosa
Great reaction, there is so much more from Pink Floyd to come, try Shine on you Crazy Diamond from the Pulse concert.
The person who requested it. Should have gave her the pulse version.
The person who requested this should have suggested the pulse version.*
The video has lots of postmodern themes, how human desires and greed drive out all that is good, innocent and even aesthetic beauty.
You should watch Pink Floyd Comfortably Numb, live Pulse
The amphitheatre dates back from 70 BC. it is hard to find a more special and fitting location for this spectacle
Listen to Castellorizon from David
the 1994 Pulse concert version of this is way better that steel guitar solo is so awesome in it
One of the great guitar players on a not so great song :)
Or maybe it's just these times kicking in and I can't enjoy it.
@@Meine.Postma The lyrics are so true... You must hear this song in a silent moment and you see, it's a great song....maybe ;)
It is a great song.
Kristin, you should also check out David's version of High Hopes at the Gdansk concert with fellow band member Richard Wright (his last performance before he died). It's just as good as this one. And their performance of Echoes at that concert! My Lord! Their musical chemistry was sublime. You should react to Echoes.
All the girls loved David when he was young
React to David Gilmour play the saxophone in Red Sky at Night (Remember that Night)
Hi is not juste phenomene hi is the king of gitar , you must look his history withe gitar in his life
Please try "Legend of a Mind" The Moody Blues, Live at Red Rocks
"He's even speaking the language"
Multilingualism is very common, globally, just not in the US.
Hi great reaction you have to do on the turning away live if will blow you away trust me gilmours solo at the end please
I don't know what the significance is but I'm pretty sure that the bust they are carrying at the end is Syd Barrett. That's too long of a story to get into now but a lot of respect for David doing that. You can't really see it in this video but if you watch the actual video you will.
I can tell he’s struggling more to play the instruments. It’s really sad. But High Hopes Live at PULSE in 1994 is way better. Such a different experience.
It isn't Pink Floyd. It's David Gilmour.
You'll find out in 30 40 years
listen to i'm alive by anderson wakeman bruford and howe
I can see you’ve been Floyd encapsulated totally stuck to your screen, When David plays the acoustic guitar, I ve played this song on my stereo for my 4 year old who doesn’t sit still for more than a minute but this song works tho
Floyd are all about creating an atmosphere you.can lose yourself in
and not an emotion shown or a tear shed .... are you human !?
Father o all
POMPEI ITALY??
Hola Kristin....saludos....por favor reacciona a "Coming back to live"....P.u.l.s.e.
Trust me on this one .. react to " Dire Straits sultans of swins alchemy live "
The song, Dogs Of War, by Pink Floyd is really good, but not a lot of air play....here's the link to the live performance if you're interested in reacting to it...ruclips.net/video/XpTXHhMa_YQ/видео.html ...it's symbolic of the issues of today....
not a movie ust a video
Kristin ❤️! I'm going to be 🔥 #controversial 🔥 and say I prefer Nightwish's version. 😋 I wonder if David is goung to retaliate with a Nightwish cover? Maybe "The Islander"?
👊❤️🗣Wooooo! Nightwish did High Hopes? That is amazing! I gotta find the video for that!
Maybe this version but the Pulse version blows Nightwish away!!
Not bad for pensioners hey?
Hi kirstin react to snowy white my bird of pradice check it out
❤❤❤