Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
The Innocent Casualties Of India's Surrogacy Industry
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 июл 2015
- About A Boy: The search for an abandoned baby twin in New Delhi, left behind his sister's adoptive parents.
An Australian Adoptee Uncovers Her Roots In Vietnam: • An Australian Adoptee ...
Exposing India's Illegal Baby Trade: • Video
Commercial Surrogacy Exploiting Women Of The Developing World?: • Commercial Surrogacy E...
India's Big Money Baby Surrogate Industry - Trailer: • Video
Subscribe to Journeyman for daily uploads: www.youtube.com...
For downloads and more information visit:www.journeyman....
The story of a twin boy born via surrogacy in India caused outcry after it emerged he was left behind by his Australian parents, who took only his twin sister. In this report, we try to find the missing boy.
How do you find a toddler in a nation of more than a billion people when you don't even know the child's name? This sprawling hunt for the surrogate baby left behind in India's capital reveals the underside of an international surrogacy industry, wide open for abuse. "Was the child sold? Was the child left on the street? What has happened to the child?", asks Australian Chief Judge John Pascoe. He and Chief Justice Diana Bryant were shocked that Australians were at the forefront of an industry "commoditizing children". Since the incident, India no longer grants Australians Visas for surrogacy deals, but the narrative of the twin boy who was left behind remained unresolved. Now reporter Samantha Hawley joins two Indian child protection campaigners to reveal the full story of the adoption that shocked the world. "You cannot just commission two children and leave one behind", says Arun Dohle, one of the protection advocates. His colleague Anjali Pawar is similarly driven by the injustice. I feel really bad about that child and angry at the authorities and the parents, the way they treated that child as a commodity", she says.
ABC Australia - Ref: 6486
Journeyman Pictures is your independent source for the world's most powerful films, exploring the burning issues of today. We represent stories from the world's top producers, with brand new content coming in all the time. On our channel you'll find outstanding and controversial journalism covering any global subject you can imagine wanting to know about.
Can't afford two? But can afford to fly to India and pay for surrogate? How can u leave your child abandoned and not care that your daughter will never know your twin!
I dont know why they didnt mention he had downs they left him be cause he had downs he wasnt a perfect baby thats what is shitty and why they didnt make mention of the TRUTH IS UPSETTING
@@mikebrooks9433 wasn't that the other Australia couple that left their down syndrome son in Thailand in 2016?
Joanna x yes in this case the child did not have a disability
@@michelleanemily thankyou, I thought so. X
@@michelleanemily Actually, it's the same couple.
this story reminds me of that case of surrogacy in Thailand where an Australian couple has twins boy and girl but left behind the boy because he had dawn syndrome. the surrogate mother kept him, although she was so poor. she had more heart than them.
they did it in thailand and it wasn't an actual adoption i think, because the babies where their biological children, the thai woman only carried the pregnancy forward for them... so i don't think there was an adoption agency involved.
That's heartbreaking 😭
Percy Cat he was also a pedofile wasn’t he ? Or convicted of sex offences
Yes baby Gammy!!! First thing I thought about when I heard it was a twin, especially a boy.
Just awful. They don't deserve to have ANY children.
Purplekitty W.O.W. Just Wow & Wild on So many levels!!
How could someone just leave their helpless child, newborn or otherwise in a foreign country? I am speechless!!
He was supposedly diagnosed with downs thats why they left him
Idk people put their kids up for adoption all the time
@@whitneyw.7919 There’s a difference between placing them for adoption and downright abandoning them though. This couple abandoned their child.
The couple was Indian even though they lived in Australia. That point was kind of barely mentioned. Calling them Australians is kind of moot!
@@MontoyaBrandy they are australians too
Horrible way to treat a child. Parents should be charged to the max.
Deana Stevenson the so-called mother should be whipped as well. Publicly. What a heartless bitch!
Mother and father both deserve punishment
How on Earth could someone do that.. how could you leave your own flesh and blood behind?? This couple absolutely sickens me!!!
Felicity Ray Self There are some f$$$ed up selfish people out there. No normal mother could do that. She must be a psycho
The parents didn't think anyone wud find out
As a grandma to a boy and a girl.set of one year old twins I cannot imagine giving away either the boy or the girl! How can a parent do that?
I cant believe the Australian consulate and goverment allowed them to take only one baby. The Australian goverment is also to be blamed
I am actually surprised they didn't take the boy and took the girl. Again orthodox customs, traditions, and back ward thinking, corrupt policies still runs through with many corrupt Indian people. It doesn't matter where they live! Quite sickening!
Radhika Chatterjee Backward is a key word here. Nasty selfish c$$$s!
The boy had downs.
And is deaf
There's a documentary on her "womb for rent" it's all about vimlesh delhi. She wasn't allowed to see the twins or anything. They also paid her late all the time. The twins were born on emergency the surrogate started bleeding.
They told her the sexes of the babies illegally. Now I know why they wanted a girl only
DreamChaser ..& it took the agency Forever to pay her her final payment; told her if she kept 📱to ask for Her $ they wouldn’t give it to her & had the Audacity to ask her why she even needed it, the $ OWED to Her that she earned & upheld her part of the deal. When the agency did (eventually) pay her they pretty much Forced her to open a joint bank acct with her no good ass worthless ass husband in order to receive payment, & well you can pretty much garner what happened to Vimlesh’s $$$ after that. I mean the atrocities forced upon this young lady were horrendous, countless & endless!!! So many Western women wouldn’t have lasted a Month in her shoes, let alone since the age of 9‼️I really hope some Good finally came to her/into her life @ some point since the 1st 25yrs were 💔.
Kiwi the intended parents “ordered” twins.. Vimlesh had twins, the other surrogate had quads. Vimlesh’s pregnancy was allowed to continue bc she filled the “order” adequately & the quads were aborted. The cpl got the 2 they wanted & killed (I myself am ProChoice but I used the word “killed” here bc they purposefully & knowingly sought out the surrogacy & pregnancy then got rid of the ones they no longer needed) the others.. I didn’t think that that cpl could get much worse, until I got to the end of Vimlesh’s docu.. some ppl Really shouldn’t be allowed to have children!!., no matter where in the world they travel to do so!!! Periodt‼️
I saw that!
And what's crazy is she said she would keep the babies if they weren't wanted. :(
Can't imagine how she felt finding about this crap.
Those parents are evil making a baby then abandon him disgusting
A.J. Dem Yes true just like biological parents who make babies and abandon them
I am the mother of a set of boy and girl twins and anyone who can separate twins is cruel and uncaring. When my twins were babies they cried for each other. They couldn't sleep if they weren't laying close together. Even when they were toddlers one would get out of their bed and get in bed with the other one. They had the same groups of friends and similar activities all the way through high school. One of them moved to a different state when they turned 18. They're 21 now and are planning to be roommates soon because they miss each other. They have separate lives and interests now but they have a bond between them that can't be broken.
The parents of the abandoned baby boy are also Indian! They live in Australia!
I would be willing to bet most of the children left behind are done so by Asians most especially Indians life means nothing to Indians. Calling this couple Australians is very disingenuous at best??
Explains a lot sadly.
Yes it does
Absolutely disgusting. That boy is almost 5 now. I live not far away from Sydney. Yes, things are expensive, but you make sacrifices for your kids, not SACRIFICE THEM! I had 5 children and NOTHING could induce me to abandon one of them. You reap what you sów, and down the track I hope karma comes back to bite them. They don't deserve to be parents!
Michelle Sartori I’m a single mom after my husbands death. I have a 3 yr old and have taken in children when their moms were going thru addiction..homelessness or domest violence situations -me footin the bill. If u love a child u sacrifice and make a way.
I can't believe they abandoned their baby boy like he was nothing. That is really cold. Heartless.
Everybody's blaming everyone else.
'We can't afford the baby boy" Yea right!! That family is doing just fine. lf you want surrogate children the drugs they give can MAKE TWINS. Both babies should be taken. Especially if it's your blood. Those babies deserve to know each other. ;(
They even knew the possibilities of them becoming twins like wtf they should have considered that and actually figured it out on how to care for both or don’t go through the process at all if you can’t take care of both.
@@infinitydominguez9539 yeah like isn't having twins or multiple children like the most well known "risk" when it comes to this?
@@bruh-mb1rd Yes it is. That’s a common thing with just about every fertility treatment out there. My husband and I have been trying to conceive, and when I was on medication for it I was told repeatedly that we could have multiples from it. We didn’t get pregnant unfortunately, but if we did and it was multiples we would have been thrilled.
@@brittaniesidebottom Bit of a different process. IVF purposely involves fertilizing multiple eggs and transferring them into the surrogate where more than one may attach to the uterine wall.
They just didn't want him. Females are more expensive than boys even with nonsense like makeup. Menstrual products and bras
Damn!! She knows her rights bUt clearly she doesnt know whats the rights of babies. How convenient!!!
Pathetic.
That's exactly how they women act very rude
This is just UNAUSTRALIAN so Mr Abbot how about cancelling their citizenship it is totally disgusting, I have problems with this as an Australian.
Thank God for these two judges and all the people who searched for the child.
Makes you wonder what kind of childhood the couple’s other children have been subjected to as well.
That's the mother from the other documentary on here iv just watched it that's even more heart breaking.
That’s what I just realised and it just killed me inside
This is so wrong for so many reasons... children are not toys that you can just abandoned.... they are human beings...
Disgusting. I have no words...If a girl wouldn't have been born, would they have just started over again?
Thank goodness this problem is being addressed. So many have suffered in silence too long.
Oh god this heartbreaking if they can leave a new born defenceless baby like that they shouldn't be parents of any child! They are disgusting people.
Ohh ....this case is very special because even the surrogacy part has another documntry already ........i don't know why this documentary didn't reach vimlesh ...........
Wish health n great future for dav
Race doesn't matter if you love the child and raise them as your own, I adopted three children all mixed. But if you surrogate out baby it means no matter what, down syndrome or twins.
I have absolutely NO respect for you at all. How dare you take those babies from their own land and cultures and the possibility to find their relatives. If you want t to help them then donate to them. Never take a child from their own land and culture. So cruel and selfish …
This case is very similar to the case the movie A Child Too Many was based on. Except it happened in the USA. The surrogate also found out she was carrying twins, the couple she was a surrogate for already had 3 sons. After intially telling her they would accept any child conceived, after finding out they were twins,they told her if the babies were girls they'd take them both, if one was a girl & the other a boy they would only take the girl, if they were boys they wouldn't take either. The babies were a boy and a girl. They tried to talk them into taking both, but the couple only took the girl and left the boy with an adoption agency. Surrogate & her husband went and took the boy back & then took the couple to court to gain custody of his twin sister and were successful. Surrogate's name was Patti Nowakowski.
Yes i seen that movie many times. I loved the ending that she got both babies.
Obviously God knew this Australian couple’s heart and made them unable to conceive naturally.
Some people are not meant to be parents and exploit poorer countries to buy their selfish wishes!
If you can afford one, you can afford two in western countries, a fact I know because I’m American.
I hope there is a special place in H for people like them! Children are a gift not a commodity!
My husband and I can’t get pregnant naturally, but if we did something like this we would take any babies that came out of it, regardless of their health issues. All babies are a blessing, regardless of what they look like or what disabilities they have. Heartbreaking 😔💔
How can someone leave their child like this ..i mean this is insane
clinics should b clear to the couples about the surrogacy ...
what they really want
children or chicken ..
When she called them out and said they cant afford it and she said bullshit i wanted to kiss her feet
There is a reason why God denies the gift of children to some couples
And what would that reason be? My husband and I are childless, and would never do anything like this. This is cruel and heartless.
No body in the right mind will abandon there son, and leave him to nowhere.
I feel.sorry for the baby 😢 good God ..I don't wanna live in this world 😢
I watched that documentary on vimlesh. And now this another link to same story. This is just one case. We can't even imagine what's happening out there
I do not understand how could a parent abandoned 1 and took 1. What kind of people are they.
I watched the documentary on the surrogate mother (Vimlesh) of these twins.
Link?
It's called womb on remt
Vanessa Covarrubias ruclips.net/video/Hf_hA_mY6X8/видео.html
Twins no matter what deserve to know each other.
Exactly. Twins should always be together
abandoning babies in india by indians is normal . have you seen how many kids on the streets of india.so dont call them australians .call them indian born australians
+praja558 exactly!!!!!
praja558 people are poor in india, it's different to do a treatment for a child then abandon it.
Then why they fuckers came india
praja558 u right
Australian Govt legalised this so why blame India ? India & so many other countries have human trafficking issue but why are these developed countries encoraging it ? Not that this justifies Human Trafficking anywhere
PieEyedPiper you idiot
PieEyedPiper How about we blame everyone and prevent this from happening again.
People that intentionally separate siblings are terrible to start, but to separate twins...ew. That is going to cause lifelong issues for BOTH babies. “Breaking the law” or not doesn’t validate their decision. Morally, it’s cruel. Imagine how the abandoned child might suffer especially. He was ABANDONED too. There were no formal adoption processes.
My wife and I have 7 sons and would of loved to have a daughter,every child is precious.. We tried one last time for a daughter in 2008 using IVF at Wake Forest fertility in Winston Salem NC USA,but had 2 more boys.:) God has a sense of humor..But we love them ,and would not change the outcome if we could..
Journeyman Pictures should do a video on the millions of Abortions done in the West every year,a black eye on the so called Free World...
Dev would be almost 8 now. He’s the same age as my child.
I hope that, not just the Indian government, but governments around the world are doing things to stop this.
I think surrogacy should be mandatory the biological parents keep the babies doesn’t matter how many babies or special needs
i think in each country there should be a law with strict regulations for rights and duties of biological parents of children born by a surrogate. unfortunately, such cases are not a surprise any longer. i can't understand how a couple who wanted children so much could have abandoned one of the twins. it seems that every intended parent should pass psychiatrist test before starting a program of surrigacy. imo
Exactly make the regulations stricter, i would still like to see it possible for childless couples to have a family, but abandonment must be made illegal .
If there is such a case then it is a criminal case with jail time .
@@uching1718 ok
surrogacy shouldn't be allowed from the very beginning, if you want children but can't bear them yourself, just adopt poor children in orphanage.
I can't understand why anyone want to suffer the pain of preganancy only for a little sum of money.
How could they know they are having twins from six weeks and then choose that they only want the girl how can you deny the twins a life together they are twins the closest bond a human can have absolutely disgusting of them the twin girl will grow up and resent them for this callous decision
That's another consequence of poverty and lack of education. During the 2010 earthquake in Haiti many children were adopted illegaly but under the consent of their parents by some ONGs. Are those kids better or worse? It's impossible to say because after an illegal adoption is made is virtually hard to know what happened to them.
Despicable! Speaks volumes of the couple who wanted only the girl child
Absolutely disgusting 😠
India as overpopulated as it is and poor to add on that, these clinincs should not be operating PERIOD. im appalled
This breaks My heart My Husband and I can't have any Children and for this Couple to do this is despicable
It breaks mine too. My husband and I also can’t have kids. We are currently pursuing adoption.
'Womb on rent' I had gone through that video another day. It clears states the twins surrogate mother Vimlesh Devi, her life and why she is to this business. It also shows the doctor of the IVF clinic in New Delhi. This is exactly the same child and case you are seeking for. I can only question the doctor at this moment of time. DO YOU THINK YOU ARE TO BE LEFT UNQUESTIONED ABOUT THIS? I learned from that video that another surrogaate mother from this same couple( Australian, perhaps kept a secret in that video) had conceived 4 embryos and hence those were aborted. How many lives are you killing for the sake of money? Are you cocksure 'money' can save your own life?!!
Wow.......shocking.smh.
There is a thing called karma for all those involved that think this is ok.
Pray this child is ok and having a decent life from people who love him.
Feel for all the other children .
So wrong this.
I might as well just leave my Jaw on the floor!!., instead of dropping it & picking it back up like every 30seconds!!! Why does it *ALWAYS* feel as though the worst kind of ppl/humanity outweigh the best of us⁉️
With all this intervention in conceiving children, you would think the technology would exist to prevent unwanted twin births. Especially unwanted fraternal twinning, as that requires two separate eggs.
They wanted to make sure that they will have a girl.
i’m sorry but i’m dying laughing at all the ppl looking into the camera as the reporter passes by or stops walking and gives updates on the story lmao 😅😭😂🤣
I wish I could adopt those poor babies. 💔😭😭
My thinking is the baby boy was sold. It took long to pay the surrogate and the monthly instalments took long. So the boy was sold to support the process.
Literally only just watched 'womb for rent' .. wow. This is crazy!!
lol u are right
This makes me feel so sad.
Birth dad is a corporate ceo but they can’t afford 3 kids? Yeah, ok 🙄🤦🏼♀️. Poor baby boy 🥺💔
Where is Dev? it's been five years now. Did they find Dev?
:| Sp, after all, Australia it's a 4rth world country, because even in a third world country. a father will not abandon his own child because he cannot afford to feed him ...
Serious question here, why do people living in such an over-crowded, 3rd world country, keep having more babies? If you lived in a country where you could barely feed yourself, surely you wouldn’t bring children into that?
Those people were horable being so far away they had twins , never bonding or caring to even see them, they picked their daughter without seeing her. They separated twins, this even when they are babies have a bond. Both my parents were twins, my mom sister died when they were 20 mos. Old, she named my sister after, she has always talked about her and her lost. They were mirror twins. My Dad was an identical twin, his twin past when they were 78. My Dad died at 87. He suffered loosening him. I have watched programs of twins separated at birth, getting back together as teens or adults. A horable thing to do. And these being natural parents.
So, the parents ARE INDIAN not Australian...
They are Australian citizens, they can be called Australian. Just like any other non aboriginal person.
surrogacy is a wicked thing, people just aren't honest
I think surrogacy is ok if the surrogate consents and wants to do it because some women can't have babies and that's sad. I don't think it's ok if it exploits the kid or the surrogate keeps the baby after signing the forms
GERARD LEONARD only smart comment on here
GERARD LEONARD its totally exploiting these woman as they're poor and makes huge profit in their country compared to others.
There was another documentary made About Vimlesh and her journey as a surrogate! I remember watching it. It's on RUclips!
That should not be allowed at all
Journalists DO NOT have the right to go into a clinic with patients and disclose information, violation of privacy rights for other patients. I understand what she is trying to accomplish and agree with that, but she has to take into consideration OTHER individuals
No point simply knowing wat right or wrong.. what needs to be done is not been done .
but are the people in that clinic still have a word called "Dignity" for them to claim privacy...what for????
They cant be named as parents. No parent would do that. Not even animals. I wonder what would they do if she was carring the twins her self and give them birth, or if she would do the surogste thing in Australia, if things were diferent.
Why didn't the investigators go to the boy's new adoptive parents, instead of contacting the swindling parents?
@Carena D
*Did you not watch the video?* 😆 *There's no official record of who the adoptive parents are & the few people who do know who they are won't talk. That's what this whole thing has been about.* 🤷
These people sound Gujrati. Don't believe then when they say they have no money to raise a third child
May God have mercy on women and children everywhere 🙏
How do u produce a child and leave it behind???
This is absolutely disgusting behavior from and by the adoptive parents. Such horrendous people. 😡🤯🤬😱
Ridiculous. Unbelievable. What is wrong with these people.
Why did they abandon the boy?
Anna Luisa Rossini Downs baby
Some people truly don't deserve children.
India was the other legal surrogacy behemoth. Where gestational dormitories housed groups of pregnant Indian women as their bellies swelled. But the industry lost a chunk of its market when the country banned surrogacy for gay couples and single parents in 2013. Around the same time India recriminalized gay sex. Recent revisions to the law have effectively banned foreigners altogether. As India’s laws tightened, clinics there quietly began sending the Indian mothers to Nepal to give birth. Many eventually shifted their entire operations over. The two countries share an open border. Allowing citizens of either country to cross without registration. No laws existed on surrogacy in Nepal, so there were seemingly none to break. Nepal’s underground surrogacy operations came to international light after the earthquake last April. When news reports detailed the evacuation of western babies born to surrogates. But Nepali officials had known about the growing market since the previous November. But since other countries are starting to provide the same services at a cheaper price. Like in Kiev, Ukraine, they are so affordable with quality services.
If people can't have kids then oh well but this is just not right
ok the world always criticizes Americans for passing the buck and passing blame but boy the prime ministers and foreign ministers pass the buck left and right the old blames the new and the new blames the old shees
Everyone should have a right to have a child. The surrogacy industry must have organized in a proper way. Surrogate mothers should suffer or feel any inconveniences. And of course they must have medical control and special medical indications that let a woman to be a surrogate mother. When I suffered infertility the unique option for me was surrogacy. I did surrogacy in Ukraine, and I did not regret at all. We had a wonderful surrogate mother. Our surrogate mother was under medical control and lived in good conditions. She also signed a contract with us and was aware about everything. I am sure it is better not to take a risk and do surrogacy in Ukraine or maybe other country but not in Thailand or India, where surrogate mothers live in horrible conditions.
Christiana Burn hey just wondering what surrogate company did you use? And roughly how much were the expenses?
The parents should be charged. They know haw hard and brutal it can be in India. Shame on them. They destroyed the little boys life therefore they are not very good parents. I will pr@y for the baby boy🙏
You can be cold hearted towards something you consider a product as a result of a purchase. When it comes out wrong, you don't want it. You want what you paid for.
Name and shame
Shame on those people. I can’t call then parents
I wonder if this is where Baby Archie and Baby Lilibet from the royal family UK came from??
Absolutely we do that child is half Australian.
I wouldn't go to this country if you paid me.. poor little babies
I would, but only to save and adopt the babies left behind by people like this couple
omg the continued story of vimlesh lol thats not her name and shes an entrepreneur in the business now.
Well, there are many issues with Indian surrogacy industry. I really didn't consider it for my sister at first. I'm preferring going to Kiev, Ukraine for it. My sister is considering surrogacy, she had India on her list. But, now we have moved forward due to lack of standards and other issues in India. I've heard on NEWS. I think people should try clinics in Europe or USA.
Its true... love of money is the root of all kinds of evil.
Vimlesh Davi was featured on another channel recruiting other young women for surrogacy.
Why does it not surprise me that they are Indian?
If you can't have kids just accept it and stop exploiting less fortunate people for your selfish ass desires.
If you pay a woman little to nothing to carry a child for you then she has twins and you decide to just abandon one you don't deserve to be a parent! If she got pregnant with twins she'd be forced to keep both you don't get to pick and choose!
It’s easy to say “just accept it “ if you aren’t living through it. You learn to live with it, but you don’t fully accept it. I know from personal experience. I do however agree that vulnerable women shouldn’t be used like this. They need to redo the whole system, and make it safer for both surrogate mothers and babies.
@@brittaniesidebottom sorry to hear that's your experience but no one needs to have a child so yes just accept it as unchangable circumstances and if you can't accept what you can't change thats literally isn't impacting you negatively then seek therapy.
If the urge to be a mom is that bad you couls also just adopt one of the hundreds of thousands of children thats are in foster systems globally. There is literally no reasonable justification for surrogacy it's unnecessary and the practice is extremely abusive and damaging
Cannot believe what I just read in the description! Makes me so angry!
It is really horrible but don't say you can imagine how australians can do it. Indians do the same or worse . This is horrendous thing regardless.I just saw comments. Australian couple was Indian. Sadly fits.
Breaks my heart and i love to adopt