Bring Your Kids To Work Turns Into A Disaster | Mayday: Air Disaster
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 мар 2023
- Russian International Airlines Flight 593 left Moscow’s Airport to Hong Kong. The aircraft was the pride of the Russian fleet, a fully automated Airbus, newly arrived from France. In the cockpit was a very experienced flight crew. The captain’s children were also on board and shortly after take off, he invited them into the cockpit. This triggered a series of disastrous events.
Want to watch more full episodes on our channel? Watch them here: • Full Episodes | Mayday...
Mayday: Air Disaster - From Season 3 Episode 10 "Kid in the Cockpit": RIA 593 - March 23, 1994
RIA Flight 593 from Moscow to Hong Kong was routine in every respect. Then, in less than five minutes, it fell from the sky. There was distress call. No warning. The investigation reveals a shocking event in the cockpit
Welcome to the OFFICIAL Mayday: Air Disaster RUclips Channel.
Mayday: Air Disaster is a dramatic non-fiction series that investigates high-profile air disasters to uncover how and why they happened. Mayday: Air Disaster follows survivors, family members of crash victims and transportation safety investigators as they piece together the evidence of the causes of major accidents. So climb into the cockpit for an experience you won’t soon forget.
Subscribe to the OFFICIAL Mayday: Air Disaster channel here: bit.ly/2PQnaMI
#MaydayAirDisaster #MaydayInvestigation #AirEmergency #MaydayEpisodes #planecrashes #airplanecrashes #aviationaccidents #Fullepisode #airplanedisasterdocumentary #aircrashinvestigation #FallingFast #Flight1549 
Развлечения
Want to watch more full episodes on our channel? Watch them here: ruclips.net/p/PLiXVS8S6-YAUBts83-WRHLjn1DCSSNcjb
16:15 As soon as the pilot had no idea why the plane was acting strange... TIME TO GET THE KID OUT OF THE DAMN SEAT!!
I noticed that, its like he forgot his son was flying the plane, also why didnt the son move the stick the other way when they said No the other way!
@@magnumpi28 I don't blame the kid really both because he's a kid and also IMO he did exactly what he should've by immediately calling out an issue and keeping still/not making any movements that the pilot wouldn't have known about or seen
Why wasnt the co-pilot on full alert and ready to take full control?? im missing something???
@@magnumpi28 lol nope my friend youre not missing anything. The pilots are 100% to blame for allowing the kids behind the controls in the first place
Yes, that moment passed and they all perished for no reason.
"It's OK son, just hold the scalpel steady, don't sever the brain stem."
Except is is also ~80 lives and not just one… 😡
So true. I mean how irresponsible can you be?? Letting a child fly a plane that you yourself JUST learned how to fly! But they tried to tiptoe around blaming him completely.
100th like 😁
😂 LOL.
"It's OK son, just slowly lower the control rod into the reactor, if you do it too fast reactor 4 might take a trip into the stratosphere.
Imagine traveling and boarding into a plane then all the sudden you hear a voice saying
"Little did they know this was their last flight"
🤣🤣🤣
What if the voice was Morgan Freeman's?
What if it's their last flight because they'll never travel by air again, and they live long and happy lives.
Ì7
Imagine if they had managed to save the plane. Prison quicker than you can say, “kids in the cockpit”.
Cocke in the ki… umm oops
And in Russia it shouldn't be limited to aviation only. The country is in total mess and for a very good reason.
I am so sorry for the mother of the child who controlled the plane. She literally lost her family, must be so frustrating.🥺
I'm far more sorry for the passengers of that plane. At least they had no responsibility in this. That kid and his imbecile of a father caused this accident that cost so many lives.
*This is the most preventable and easily avoidable air disaster I'm aware of.*
Because it is....... the choice of the adult to allow an untrained child to take control of a commercial airliner is the most morally irresponsible act in aviation history that I'm aware of.
Absolutely unconscionable and sickening that the adult did that.
🤬
P.S. And no, I'm not blaming the child.
It’s Russia. How is this surprising in the least?
@@liesdamnlies3372
Not so much surprising........just very disturbing. 😔
The pilots daughter did ok.
@@magnumpi28 but if he did not allow her to take control, it would have not been a problem. So he also bare the blame for it.
@@magnumpi28
But it was still manifestly irresponsible to let her be in that seat and have her grab the yolk.
Next time I get on an airplane, I will play one of these "Mayday: Air Disaster" videos and see what the other passengers next to me thinks about it. I'm sure they will get a kick and a blast with it.
Start talking to the person next to you. "Hey, I saw an air crash documentary about a plane just like this that had the same exact sound come up too! Want to watch it?"
If those kids went too sleep like everyone else this would have never happened.
Moral of the story, don't let children fly a commercial airliner. You would think that would be common sense, but I guess for some people it is not.
"Hey kids, want to hear what the ground proximity warning sounds like?"
16:50 Instead of just standing there how about getting the kid out of the seat immediately or have the co-pilot take control and fix the bank angle?
Regardless of what else was involved in the crash having a kid at the controls with a plane full of passengers was NOT the time to be doing R&D on the plane. It was the crew's fault for letting the situation start in the first place.
The crew's recklessness was unforgivable. Russia doesn't have much of a safety culture.
“Terrain. Too low. Pull up!” 😂
"Pull up"
Kid be like: I'm a big kid now!
Seems to reveal the obvious lack of respect to the responsibility of a pilot, from both this pilot and his son Aldar, in that the pilot allowed untrained personnel (children or not) to take the pilot's seat and the son to maneuver the control column like a toy!
And from the fact that when the son pointed out that an issue was happening, the pilot did not immediately take back his pilot's seat, still assuming that the auto-pilot could be easily re-directed by his turning a few knobs with him standing away from his pilot seat!
The pilot's and first officer's ignorance about the auto-pilot being turned off and would not give them a warning and their lack of thorough training in flying this airbus still could not excuse them from treating the pilot seat like a video game, and make all passengers pay with their lives for their actions!! Very upsetting to see what had happened to cause this unnecessary tragedy!
The entire Airbus company was oblivious to the weirdness of their AP system! The pilots do not design or build the plains that they get to fly. So, the flight deck crew is only as good as the level of training they receive.
The title of this clip with the thumbnail of the kid holding the airplanes control stick is hilarious 😂.
When a coworker of mine described this episode, I assumed alcohol must have been involved too.. RIP everyone
@@davidglad nope, just stupidity.
Ikr it’s like wth is he doing in the cockpit???
@Anthony Graham ya, bring ur kids to work day doesn't mean let ur kids do ur job. It's like if a member of the bomb squad brought his kid to work and said "son, why don't you come over here and take a stab at defusing this pipe bomb." 😅
@@Kevincarlloven LOL
I have probably watched over one hundred episodes of Mayday..this is by far the most shocking and chilling one I have seen. It is truly unbelievable.
This is the one episode that gives me so much anxiety as if I was a passenger on the plane….so unbelievable.
I sat in the captain's seat once. That said it was parked at the gate after the flight and engines were powered down for refueling. The pilots didnt have to but im thankful they did so only after all these safety requirements were set.
The voice recording for this flight is actually one that is available to listen to. It’s kinda horrifying next to the graphic the plane’s current orientation paired with the tape
This is why in today's world nobody except the pilots are allowed to be on the flight deck.
The 11th of September attacks reinforce that.
Aren’t flight attendants allowed if they need to tell the pilot?
All things considered it is very surprising that this was released to the public. There have been attempted cover ups in less centrally controlled countries
My guess is they couldn’t cover it up. Since it was an Airbus involved the French BEA had to investigate.
Don't believe all the propaganda. The west is just as censorious when it suits them. In fact, the US never releases CVR audio. Russia released it.
@@dottoysm Hmm, thanks
@@HarryBalzak that's what I said re attempted cover ups
"Yeah it was a special training operation. A kid was being trained and he didn't know there were 80 dummies in the back."
I'm surprised the plane didn't shatter with the up and downs
Awesome episode. One small mistake in the beginning, though: a Russian person who ever had any military or law enforcement backgound will never under no circumstances salute with one's head uncovered. Not even at home, not to a family member, not to a favorite aquarium fish. If must, one covers his head with a left palm and then salutes with the right hand. It is a historical tradition.
probably the reason my dad never took me to his workplace.
That plane was operating perfectly until the pilot let the boy start turning it against the controls of the auto pilot, something had give , and this was the results,,,,, this was indeed the fault of the pilot and co-pilot ,!
when "bring your kids to work day" goes wrong
All died
Because one captain think his kids so special blame him not something else
That was a terrible tragedy…..
i would be angry at this polite. disrespect to all the passengers who died on this day. all due to ego.
All things considered, Eldar is probably still a better pilot than Pierre Bonin.
No way. It wasn't Bonins fault. He never should've been flying. But his Cpt was hungover from partying in Rio w his mistress.
Agreed
This disaster could have been prevented💥 if the captain had just let his kids to see the cockpit instead of them touching the control column😡 heck he could’ve also taken them on a flight simulator🛩 .
Absolutely. The pilot, the father of the kids, and even the rest of the crew became too relaxed, unwary when they left Eldar in the seat with his hands on the control column without anyone of them paying attention to him. After he let Eldar in the seat, he needed to have him immediately leave after turning the plane with the auto pilot, but anyway you slice it, it was a major breach of regulations, and entirely irresponsible . The Capt ended up being the major catalyst for getting everyone killed.
Hey, look everyone..it’s captain obvious.
Talk about stating the obvious
@@milesaway3699 well placed well placed.
@@edward9643 too late man, too late
23:21 Never mind, RIP everyone who died in the crash.
MY uncle Ned saved the day and didn't die!
@@jacobkeira4eva947 Ye, my uncle Ned is smarter then anyone even you and anyone you know....
@@jacobkeira4eva947 Thanks for your comment Jacob&keira.... You could learn lot from My Uncle Ned. Are you are girl or boy?
This could have been easely avoidable 🔥🔥🔥
In ruzzia you can’t advocate anything
U should bring ur son into simulator not a real flight
Why would you even take your kids into the cockpit of a moving plane, especially whenever there's passengers inside at risk?
Irresponsible Pilot . How dare he let his children seat and fly a plane …
This is so unbelievable 😟
I agree with the man who said the final minutes are what people will remember about the pilot. This is so freakin sad. RIP to all.
WHY ARE THE CREDITS CUT OFF AT THE END? This seems very nasty and uncalled-for, considering all the work that goes into the making of these documentaries. What's the point? How hard is it to let the credits run?
BTW, this traditional type of aircraft controller is now called a "wheel". As it does more than just horizontal direction control. So, it is called a yoke. Russians don't call it a "wheel" either. The Russian term for "yoke" is "shturval", which comes from a Dutch word "stuurwiel".
Always respect your ELDARS!
that would have been a cool story for the kids to tell if they didn't crash.
that British lady seems sweet. I feel really bad for her.
I felt sorry for her too, she lost her son because of that Captain's recklessness.
My father use to work at the auto plant, and he never brought me to work with him.
Stupidest cause of a crash ever! I feel bad for Mrs Kadrinksi. 😓
This is why we have flight simulators now. We can learn how planes operate without killing anyone in the province 🙂
If I was a dad and a pilot, I would never let my children fly an actual plane full of people!!!!
When I was 8 in 1978 I was on a plane from Portland to Texas and the flight attendant came and said the pilot wanted to know if I wanted to fly the plane. She took me to the cockpit. I sat on the pilots lap and he let me hold the stick and placed his palms under it on left and right so I could only turn it so much. I turned left then right the straight and felt it. I steered the plane at eight. The 70's were awesome.
When I was 17 the pilot let a group of us students come up to the cockpit and look out the windows. It was amazing seeing the clouds like that from that height.
Did he ask you if you liked movies about gladiators?
I thought that Airbus used a side-stick control column, but this video shows a control column like Boeing uses.
The Airbus A310 used a yoke. Airbus started using side sticks in 1985 in the A320. Other models use the side stick as well, but the A310 wasn't one of them.
The old school airbus used to have the boeing yoke
@@kd5you1A300 too.
When my brother got his pilot's license...twenty or more years ago now? He took the family up in a single engine plane. I was the biggest so I was sitting copilot. At one point he talked me into turning the plane. I'd always been unenthusiastic about planes, that was the day that started my deep and abiding love for the ground. Nothing had happened, nothing jumps out in my memory, but the entire experience was unnerving. My brother has told me the experience gave him a long list of not-to-dos.
How many times are they going to replay this?
too many ads--have to stop what I am doing too often...
It seems like there were a lot of commercial aviation disasters in the 90s
There were.
I think the 2020’s will exceed that. Now they’re talking not enough minorities as pilots. People will be hired because of the color of their skin, not their abilities as pilots.
Scary, dark times ahead, folks.
@@stellakowalski1 you soundRidiculous. They've BEEN doing that for over 25 yrs! Ever hear of "Affirmative Action"? Get a clue. And they STILL have to pass the same flying standards. Get a clue!
@@stellakowalski1 thats why your racist comment was shadowbanned! 🤣🤣🤣🤣😜😝
45:03 another lesson of this tragic story: LEARN TO LET GO. Let it go, let it go. ❄🎶🎶🎵🎵❄
When Auto Pilot Turns Off or Partially Turns Off the pilot should know immediately through an Alarm System
A light came on to tell them, but they didn't see it. Being experienced pilots, they should've known the auto pilot disengaged, but they couldn't figure it out.
I honestly couldn't imagine it to be in any other way.
Ah yes, let your 15 year old son fly your multi million dollar plane with over 100 people on it. What could possibly happen?🤔
Omg here we go again
are you kidding me? wtf to the Captain pilot...
Extremely irresponsible.
A re-load.... again. :(
Been watching so many of these very good analysis videos of a cumulation of factors and one thing keeps standing out in my head as a red flag on so many of these that i have to speak up and can’t believe i am the only one that thinks this so its time to push for change. Have yet to see a findings report address the complexity of the autopilot as a must fix. I see too often the auto pilot and its ability to disable partial capabilities is too often a contributing cause - this partial autopilot capability is not a good thing for humans to have to be shocked into dealing with, requires a significant behavioral change to properly compensate. Yes training helps, but the reality is the pilots are humans and humans struggle under pressure, yes having partial computer support helps in difficult times, but does also hurt. To me it seems that each auto pilot feature that can be disabled independently needs its own green/red light front and center (not a tiny indication on a screen) ideally at the sharp edge of the “dash” well above the throttle controls. These lights should be push button toggle switches that allow either pilot to instantly evaluate the auto pilot status and quickly try to reengage any that are red. There has to also be some audible verbal warning when any of the sub features or the full feature gets disabled (regardless if by autopilot or human). We expect the humans to have great communication /CRM, yet how can we not expect the same from autopilot?
45:32 That so called expert is an idiot : "it's not the crew's fault","they can't be blamed". With such "experts" I know the future of civil aviation in Russia. And taking into account that they have such "experts" everywhere (it was my first hand experience by the way), future of the whole country looks no better than the plane's fate.
This video makes me very upset. They seem to what to whitewash and event that was indeed totally preventable... the pilot NOT allowing his kids to even pretend to fly the plane. The other things that came out of this investigation did improve safety in a more general way but still this accident was totally pilot error and not the fact that they did not know about a feature of the plane.
And why didn't the first officer object?
So sad all around ! I think the child would have not be able to play with that controls so sad 😞
Who would do this there were a thousand ways to prevent this this could of been 1000 easily prevented
I kinda feel sympothy for the dad trying to guve his childeren a good time but rip
Why would you let a child fly a damn plane?! I don’t give a damn it’s YOUR child, it is still a child!
it wasnt the son's fault, it was a design and training fault which sadly the son exposed for the greater good of the industry. could have been done by any other guest on any airline or even a pilot hot dogging a plane. kinda like the early days of ABS brakes, many ppl not understanding the shaking motion of a brake peddle would take their foot off the brake not knowing better or think their brakes were faulted. when not knowing, its easy to react wrong
I can see both sides in regards to this. While this was against regulations and irresponsible of the pilots to let their kids onto the cockpit, none of them expected the autopilot being able to be disengaged like that. I’m sure that all of the pilots thought this was an innocent gesture because they knew at the time that their kids wouldn’t have been able to disengage the autopilot, but this was unfortunately not the case. Either way, regardless of who is to blame, may all of the crew and passengers Rest In Peace. This was something that exposed this flaw of the autopilot system to everyone.
it was the pilots fault. Who is blaming the son?
I'm still going with, "Don't put a kid in the pilot's seat." At least an adult would likely be paranoid about touching anything. Still, the blame is clearly on the crew that let them sit at the controls. Russia has a very poor safety culture.
"Strictly speaking it is a violation but..." - what the f### are you talking about ? It is a serious violation - full stop. No but's.
Get outta here if you wanna complain
This is why you don’t fly Russian airlines… 🤔
That's why I don't have kids. DAMN KIDS!!!!
The girls do ok, she was perfect.
I'll never forget my grandfather's last words, "Quit shaking the ladder you little sh!t"!
@@HarryBalzak :DDD
Y'all dumb I swear 😂
IT WASNT THE KIDS FAULT THE DAMN PILOT SHOUND NOT HAVE LET THE KIDS FLY THE PLANE AND THE MOMENT SOMETHING STARTED TO HAPPEN THE PILOT SHOULD HAVE TAKEN OVER
I remember that one.
It was 100% the pilots fault...if he never put his son in the pilots seat during the flight the accident would not have happened
It was not simply a "freak accident "
29:50
"Again...I think I'm on to something."
“Respect your Aldars”
Dear Lord
Omg.
Please don’t bring children into the cockpit ever again
Can I just add that the pilot's name was Vladimir Makarov, which doesn't go well with airports or planes....
Are you thirsty, Captain Makarov ?
I will get a cocktail for you . ". LOL
After the plane turning 45degrees right why did the bang angle alarm never go off?
Oh, those Russians.
whats a "russians"?
@@gpt-jcommentbot4759 that term is used to describe people who live in Russia.
@@gpt-jcommentbot4759 Looking at your channel, you really need to see a therapeut. There is no shame in getting the help you need.
I mean if the kid turned the wheel for long time and it disconnected autopilot silently thats also a big issue if the plane simply had noises for that to alert pilot or even lights or something that could also have been preventable pilot would of turned it back on
For real... Unbelievable amounts of unprofessionalism here from the pilots dubbed "the best of the best". Awful.
I don't mind re-runs but it wouldn't hurt to upload something new...
Right?! 😂 the different title caught my attention.
how about you being in the next plane crash , so we'll have something to watch. i will definitely enjoy that.
Are we going to get any new content anytime soon?
Not until a plan crashes,
@@magnumpi28 Jeez
@@stefardtech7050 is sad, but true!
😢😢😢😢😢
The more prestigious or elite division they create in Russia, the more it's prone to nepotism, corruption and unprofessionalism.
That's Russia for you. I am from Russia, and this sloppy behavior is everywhere you go. Which is why I left that place 20 years ago and never looked back.
До свидания
Passengers should have the right to supervise the pilots and punch them if they are not following the rules
It's pilot's fault.
Easily one of the dumbest and most preventable airplane disasters in aviation history.
I’ve only flown on Alaska airlines
Good thing the pilot wasn’t a surgeon.
"An expert in 310" I mean, anyone just by listening to the cockpit voice recorder would have found out what happened...
However, if you do want the details (airspeed, pitch angle, etc.), wouldn't hurt to bring them in.
How pilots didn't know all the autopilot and other carasteristic of this plane. Are pilot supposed to know what they're flying . Unbelievable !!!
There is not a place for kids on the comercial plane ✈️ don’t matter who is it
Alaska airlines has only had one crash I believe and it was Alaska flight 261
Plot twist: Vladimir Putin is the actor playing the pilot 😂
Had to quit watching after 15 minutes. Red flags after red flags came to me when the baby sitter asked the kids to see the cockpit. Sorry, but with something like this about to show a disaster I couldn't go on. Am very glad our NTSB would never allow this to happen.
i mean. Neither would the russian authorities, if they ever found out about it. Well, unless the pilot butters their hand, they might look the other way. lol
Computers do not make decisions. They react to instructions. It is a good design that the pilot, the human who makes decisions, has easy ways to override the autopilot, which can only follow instructions, in a situation which falls outside the scope of the computer's instructions. However, the basic premise of favoring human decisions over computer calculations is that the human is actually making decisions. A partial control like this setup...I see the value but it's something that really needs to be drilled into pilots' heads. The foolishness of sitting a kid in that chair aside, the copilot could have easily prevented the problem from existing in the first place if he knew not to trust the computer to take care of it for him.
Im thinking bring you kid to work day ended this day
Ah, the days when Russia seemed to slowly heading to a brighter future...
The road to a brighter future is seldom a smooth one.
Yeah, Russia was falling down like this plane. We'll see the results of this dive very soon and it will not be much better than for this plane.
@@andreypetrov4868You realize that the Airbus is a French made plane right?
another accident that could have been avoided if the pilot did not raise the plane's nose up.
Everyone blaming the pilots for allowing the kids to take control is wrong. It's that the pilots didn't know about the autopilot function that was the issue. THEY could have just as easily made that mistake.
Except that if they had made that mistake themselves, the pilots would have already been at the controls and not fighting to get to the controls. The pilots were not sitting there & watching what the plane was doing.
@@kd5you1 But would they have known how to undo their mistake?
@@simpsonfan13 If they see the plane starting to roll over and continue, they would have been able to correct it before it got too steep.
It was the pilot, Kadrinsky's fault, because he let his children in the pilot's seat, and let them hold the controls, which was strictly prohibited. After he let Eldar in the seat, he let him stay there, and didn't even notice him forcing to move the control yoke, partially disengaging the auto pilot. Then the pilots over corrected on the dive, forcing the plane into a steep climb, which eventually stalled it, which they couldn't recover from.
@@kevinmalone3210 Again if the pilots had known that this was a possibility in the first place they might have thought about it and done something different. While the kids shouldn't have been there, the lack of training is the ultimate issue here.
Greg Feith for President!
Let your kids train in pilot training sessions not during an actual flight with hundreds of people onboard!