Tool Wings for Marie Reaction!!!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- VIN AND SORI GEAR
www.teespring.com/stores/the-village-market
PAYPAL vinandsorimerch@gmail.com
Patreon / vinandsori
MAIL US SOMETHING AT
Vin and Sori
P.O. Box 7024
Lewiston, Maine 04243
EMAIL US vinandsori@gmail.com
MIDDLE AMERICA WITH VIN AND SORI
/ @middleamericawithvina...
Facebook / vinandsori
Twitter / vinandsori
Instagram / vinsoriseven
Part 2 of Maynard's Mom trilogy
Website~ Vinandsori.com
Patreon~ / vinandsori
Facebook~ Facebook.com/vinandsori
Twitter~ @vinandsori
Instagram~ vinsoriseven
I cry my eyes out almost every time I listen to this. I've lost more than a few people in my life and I can't think of a more beautiful tribute to the ones I love and can no longer tell it to
Word! -Sori🤟🏻
Welcome to the Army! You will never be the same.
I’m already different!!! I LOVE TOOL!!! -Sori🤘🏻
Tool changes lives
@@sangtran8300 tool is a religion... not only music...
It's way better than Bts aha.. I really dislike Bts, there was a chance I would have listened to them, if it wasn't for the fans. Maynard keeps most of us fans in check.
I want to join the chorus of those advocating for Lateralus and Right in Two. There's such richness in those songs (as with so many in the Tool catalog) ... one listen will not be enough.
Noted!
That ones coming up real soon
This is just my interpretation, but I think the line "She never told a lie, Well, might've told a lie, but never lived one." sums up Maynard's attitude towards his mother's faith. He doesn't agree with Christianity, but he respects that his mom believed in it honestly and with all of her conviction. His major problem with religion seems to be hypocrisy, not so much the belief in itself.
10000 seems to confirm your assessment
Michael Bayles the belief in a higher consciousness than self, does not require a deity of self. Some see it as spiritual atheism.
Spiritual atheism is counter intuitive, because one must define proof of a "spirit" with hard evidence. 99% it becomes word soup argumentation like many theology positions can drift into.
Several things which exist are counter intuitive. Like the differences between gravitation and electricity, when moving away from the source. Gravity dissipates to the square, where plasma dissipates to the square root. The latter is counter-intuitive, but is necessary for any electrical engineer.
What if energy is spirit and has no core deity? Then spiritual atheism might not seem so absurd.
Wings For Marie (Pt. 1)"
You believed.
You believed in movements none could see
You believed in me.
A passionate spirit.
Uncompromised
Boundless and open.
A light in your eyes, then, immobilized.
Vacant, broken.
Fell at the hands of
Those movements that I wouldn't see.
'Cause it was you who prayed for me so
What have I done to be a son to an angel?
What have I done to be worthy?
Day light dims leaving cold fluorescence.
Difficult to see you in this light.
Please forgive this selfish question, but
What am I to say to all these ghouls tonight?
She never told a lie.
Well might've told a lie,
But never lived one.
Didn't have a life.
Didn't have a life.
But surely saved one.
Saved one.
See? I'm alright, now
It's time for us to let you go.
I lost my mom too “it was you who prayed for me so what have I done to be a son to an angel, what have I done to be worthy?”
So you know...
All too well
Hearing that lyric, "Hard to see you in this light" reminds me heavily of when my grandmother was in the hospital dying of throat cancer, seeing her like that, in that light as the last thing I saw of her. It shattered me utterly through and through. It hurts, so much to see a loved one in pain like this, or on the end of their mortal life. Every time I hear that I break the hell down with tears in my eyes.
"What am I to say to all these ghouls tonight?" I took this to mean the people from the church on death watch, asking about her and Maynard having to tell them she finally passed away. He feels they are ghouls. I dunno if that is right, but it was what I got from the lyric...
I think you’re right... I think I heard an interview where he refers to them as such. You’re spot on -Vin
You’re close. When he says ghouls he is referencing the congregation and it’s derogatory bc he’s upset with their hypocrisy. Which is another reason why he’s questioning God as to why Marie is suffering yet the congregation is fine.
Damn... seeing Sori's reaction at 8:20 almost made me cry
Can't wait for Sori to hear lateralus by Tool.
Ya I’ve had a bunch of those requests. I’m so excited to hear more!
My brother was completely incapacitated by Cerebral Palsy his whole life. Trapped in a useless body for just over 13,000 days. His faith never waivered. So much of Tool's songs resonate with me.
I think there is a difference between song writers and composers. The more I listen to Tool, the more I'm convinced they belong to the latter.
Good reaction, again. I swear, we would be friends in another life. I'm not Christian, but very spiritual and accepting of others views. Keep listening to great music! I'm really starting to look forward to your reactions.
We’re friends in this life friend 🤘🏾
I really like your guys reaction videos. I envy you guys who are experiencing Tool for the first time.. I remember how I felt back in the 90s. True to their name, they are a tool to take you someplace else and no other band does what they do. They are one of just a handful of musicians that changed my life and even helped me out of some bad spots. Welcome to the Tool army.
What am I to tell the ghouls tonight, I'm pretty sure is a dig at the hypocritical congregation from Judith that called her an inspiration. Now he has to stand up and eulogize his mother to those people he still loathes who were false friends, the people that fanned the flames of his rage to cause Judith to be a song he had to write.
This song and 10,000 Days are deeply personal songs for me. I feel like I lived this exact situation with my Grandmother who is very much like Judith... and I had a very difficult time with my faith watching cancer slowly torture my grandmother over time. When she finally passed there was a relief and a sense of peace, and I prayed that her faith would be rewarded.
Similar... 10000 is uploading as we speak ...
I never really paid attention too deeply in these later TOOL albums (was a huge fan of Aenima and Undertow) and some of this information about his mother def brings a new meaning to some of these songs, and must revisit them. This one def hit home alot more knowing the lyrics and meaning behind it.
Keep up the awesome reactions folks! Really digging them!
Thank you !!
Can't wait for pt 2 guys.
Appreciate these vids
Thanks !!
It’s def my fav part✌🏻
Your review made me cry and I'm not joking 😅, the lyrics and the instruments fit perfectly to transmit the message and the feeling of the emptiness of a missing person , you are so right about the phases that Maynard passed through the songs.
I'm excited about the second part of this video because "10 000 days" talks so much more about the faith of his mother
It’s a great thing to experience all this for the first time with people like you 🤟🏻-Sori
So good to delve into the lyrics and appreciate the love and respect he had for his mother, 10,000 days is even better imo. Great job guys.
Yes! We feel the same ...!!!
Wings for Marie and 10000 days are both a great song but make an epic singular work. Everytime I listen to these I am still moved. Very excited for the next part of this series.
We’re excited to post
VinAnd Sori there are so many things I want to say but they tie the two together so I have to refrain.
Keep your eyes peeled!!
Apparently, Maynard called the people from his mom's church Ghouls. They were the ones that inspired him to write Judith for APC. you can see in this song that she is dying and he is asking her the selfish question of what is he supposed to tell her congregation.
Ohhhhhhhh ok that makes sense
Welcome to Tool, lovely lady. You both are so enjoyable to sip a cup of coffee with.
My mother is a stroke patient and has been paralyzed for over 4 years and every damn day is a struggle seeing her this way especially knowing how she is the strongest human being I've ever known and her spirit remains unbroken. This song and the others about his mother say it perfectly for me.
@Dexy Chan she passed away this day last week. We buried her on Saturday. Thank you for your kind words
@Dexy Chan thank you for the kind words my friend I really appreciate it
For you Tool fans that are in the Chicago area or might even be worth traveling here...
www.ticketfly.com/purchase/event/1679035
Tool, one of rock music’s most mysterious
and speculated about bands, give fans a rare glimpse behind-the-scenes
via a series of intimate music clinics. The discussions include drummer
Danny Carey, bass player Justin Chancellor and guitar player Adam Jones
walking attendees through a handful of the band’s songs, from the
process of writing them to playing them live. Audience members are
encouraged to ask questions via an open discussion, as well as mingle
with the band following the session.
This is awesome!
Amazing reaction! You guys do a great job, I'm looking forward to watching more.
Thanks !
“What am I to say to all these ghouls tonight”
I think he means that tonight is her funeral and he’s expected to make a speech and/or just interact with everyone. I think “ghouls” was a jab at the people that are never there for her until her death, as ghouls are said to be attracted to and feed on the dead.
I believe in you, bro. The two of you are beautiful. Please don’t stop.
I just found this song after watching you guy's videos. It immediately made me think of my Momma. I've spent the last seven months underwater inside a submarine. I had no communication with the outside world. I was lucky to see her again on the pier to welcome me home. I spent the next three days with her before she returned home on the other side of the States. She's the only woman I've lean on through the good times and the bad times. A couple of weeks ago, my momma put a gun to her head and took her own life. I don't understand it. I never will. But one thing I do know is this song allows me to cope with the pain I've been feeling in my heart these past weeks. Thank you both for sharing this.
Much love big homie
Tool touches your soul like no other and takes you to another dimension, keep listening
Thank you so much for this reaction. I believe we have two new members in the TOOL army 😉.
I am an atheist but i really enjoy and respect your views on things.
As Peter Reese mentioned. Right in Two would be a perfect song. A lot of religious references in that song.
Anyway : bring up 10000 days 🤘
Coming in less than ten thousand days ..😀
Oh wow I had an emotional moment there. Haven't listened to this album in a few years and I forgot how potent and powerful this song was. You both gave a great breakdown btw 👍 Highly recommend Lateralus (and if you want his best vocal 'wow he has lungs' moment then listen to The Grudge).
Thx! Glad u enjoyed the content! -Sori
Great Part 1, Excellent discussion! I have no doubt your reaction to 10,000 days will be even better. Can’t wait to see your reaction to even more Tool songs as well.
Appreciate that!!
This maybe the most beautiful song ever dedicated to a single human being in the spance of our time
A lot of reactors hear the music they react too but they don't listen to the music. Even just the way you immediately picked up on the line about daylight dimming and cold flourescents being a hospital room. I'm excited to see and hear more Tool reactions from the two of you.
Thanks man!’ Appreciate that !!
When I hear those lyrics I see Maynard looking at his mothers dead body in a morgue or funeral home.
Loved the reaction, cannot wait for you guys to do part 2
Keep your eyes peeled later on today -sori
It’s amazing how I can connect with you guys just like if I was there next to you watching the same thing. As a devout atheist I’m very amazed by your open-minded insight regarding metal and rock and how you can dissect songs and lyrics very deeply (even if I don’t agree nevertheless). But I love your take on the lyrics. New fun and subscribers for sure. I think the song “Tool- Reflection” would be interesting for you guys. It is by far Tool’s most spiritual song and very redeeming. Would love to see you guys dissect it. Love from the republic of Latvia.
My mum was a true giving Christian who did good for good sake, not for ego. She stroked when I was young and screamed every day for three years in a care home until she passed. This person I truly thought the world of deserved better. This trilogy captures all the emotional changes I faced, it's amazing how Maynard captures little things I remember. Much appreciated for your review, such great insight.
I just stumbled onto your channel, and couldn't be happier that I did. I've listened to this song before, and it reminded me of my relationship with my own mother (very pious mother, unbelieving son), but your review helped me to further reconcile this relationship in that I'm not the only one to go through this, but want to somehow make it work. You've gained a dedicated follower, thank you, and keep up the amazing work!
Why does this have so few likes? This was really good discussion. I had thought about the music composition for this song as well and u guys are the first who mention it I've found.
I think the lines "daylight dims leaving cold fluoresence, difficult to see you in this light..." is during the eulogy or whatever you call it in English, at church, when everybody's there to say goodbyes, especially because it's followed by "what am I to say to all these ghouls tonight?" Ghouls being all those 'close' relatives who really didn't care during her lifetime, but then are there to 'shed tears of cozened indigo'... This part always takes me back to my best friend's mom's funeral. Cold winter day in Northern Europe, starts getting dark around 3pm, those narrow church windows only letting in so much light, my bro up there looking at his mom for the last time with tears in his eyes, only time I've seen that too... Leaves literally a dark blue memory, hence the cold fluroesence :(
Tool - Parabol + Parabola, amazingly beautiful song.
It’s on the list... right after “right in two”
Tess Boyd passed on the 15th btw. She was 94. I painted her coffin in branches with leaves, and four fantail birds. I named it Wings for Theresa.
So this is really hitting home for me. "jIMMY" talks about Home.
Wow brother. You Maynard and I have that in common. I’m glad you were able to send her off with your art just like Maynard did.
Yeah man, I didn't let the video ride out,like you said,he says A LOT WITHOUT SAYING SO MUCH !! Damn man it's refreshing to hear others interpretations of it!
I love you two very much! Thank you for your videos. I am from Kent, Ohio and have ties to Judy through mutual friends. She took my friend to get her ears pierced when she was a little girl❤️
Whoa! How cool is that!! -Sori
16:52 couldn't agree more there. the music is all written before maynard gets it and then he is free to interpret and add his piece and own feelings to it.
That’s so cool!
Absolutely love your interpretations and insight, excellent video! Can't wait for part 2, keep up the great work :)
Thank you !
At the beginning of the song you hear the funeral Church bell calling.
I wouldn't be so quick to think that the Maynard's Mom series goes in order. Anyone who has worked through grief or shock knows that you kind of bounce around the stages throughout your life, relapsing back into various stages again and again depending on which color it expresses itself as when broken through the prism of where your are in life overall at the time.
the combination of the music and the words he speak are going hand in hand... Tool is just incredible. they use the hertz sequences to go deep inside your soul.
The echoing impact at the end. It’s the lid of the casket closing. 10000 days is filling in the grave with the sound at the end being the last shovel full.
Again Vin hits the nail on the head with the evolution of Maynards thought process😉
And again yes. The Music says as much as if not more than the lyrics😀 another excellent interpretation and review.
You two are very perceptive. I really enjoy watching your Tool reaction videos.
I can’t wait to shoot another one! -Sori✌🏻
I love these 2. And I really love tool. This will be a great RUclips relationship going forward. Lol subscribing now
sori i cant wait for you to get through all these tool songs with us so you're free to listen at your pleasure. not really any bad tool songs. they put their all into their music and you can always feel that. cant wait for you be able to listen to the albums the whole way through the way they were meant to be listened to
Yessss!!! I anxiously await that! Seriously!!!
just started and i already paused it to say...
You guys are going to friggin LOVE this song...I already know it.
LOL looks like Sori has slipped down the slippery slope of slipperiness known as Tool Love. Welcome sister! We are all family here.
I like to consider we empassioned fans, Tooligans. If Slipknot has their 'maggots', we are the Tool Army/Tooligans.
wow wow wow....
So these two songs are hugely impactful on me...at this point in my life, I can't listen to either one of these without getting emotional and shaken to the core with how real this is. My mom passed when i was 10, she wasn't religious, but she loved me in her own way. She was diagnosed with Brain Cancer about a year after I was born, after hher surgeries...she was a changed person...she was young...and was only just getting to a point where youth ends, and life begins...You're going to love Part II.
Damnit man.. this song. Gets me Everytime! Ballin my eyes out at 530 am on Sunday before work.
Just found your channel last night. Looking to listen to Jimmy cause I was in that mood. And saw a reaction to it. Wasn't going to watch Because I didn't want any interruptions in the song but I got to say im Loving this discussion afterwards. Great job guys. Subbed and can't wait until I get home to watch you reaction to 10000 Days.
Sorry for 1000 comments but as the vid continues I am relating more and more. I lost my mother 2 years ago and I connect so much with these songs of Maynard's.
Losing mom has got to suck soooo badly. -Sori🤟🏻
Wings for marie and 10,000 days made me choke up first time i heard them and read the lyrics.. Tool are the masters of emotion!!!
Great video guys.. not sure if you were aware but this is only part 1 of wings for Marie... it's actually released in 2 tracks.. you should react to part 2 also.. if you have I haven't seen it. Thanks. Keep up the good work
"the music communicates" you are so right. I can't wait for you guys to react to Lateralus and see the attention to detail and hidden meanings behind the entire song. The lyrics and instrumentation attach themselves to one central meaning, definitely need to watch the lyric video for it though.
We’ll be posting an update video soon as to what our lateralus plan is !
Great reaction guys... I hope you guys listened to this and 10,000 days in one listen on the album this goes right into 10,000 days without a pause it’s almost one song. Great either way! Keep it up
Yes we did! Next part tomorrow!!
Intermission/Jimmy should have been the start, but you can still finish with it and come to a full understanding of how an 11 year old boy felt when his mother was basically taken away from him by illness.
Just a heads up (really late), the song Jimmy from Ænema also ties into this story. It's about Maynard (Jimmy) having to move in with his Dad in Ohio when he was 11 years old and his mother became paralyzed. Amazing and touching song. One of my favorites by Tool.
Love hearing your discussion on the songs!
Thank you for taking the Time!!
I took the trilogy as in Judith she's in the hospital and doing poorly, but is alive. In Wings, she has just died and the "what do i tell the ghouls" line being the people outside pretending to care, and 10,000 Days is like the funeral.
Man this song is so sad, the ending hits me so hard. Such a great song!
Totally !!
... new sub and new Fan!!! :) Love the dynamic you both have and the insight (with the little you’ve shared of your backgrounds) ... Maynard’s emotional struggle with organized religion and faith (based on what we know of his life experiences) is fascinating to see as you look at each of Tool’s and PC’s albums... from the anger of youth (Oppiate, Undertow, Aenima) to the struggle to understand (Lateralus) to a form of acceptance (10000days) ... to even themes about Fatherhood (Puscifer) ... the vulnerability is takes to write like Maynard.... hotDAMN!!!
Yes I agree! So many layers to everything they all write !
I don’t know if anybody let you know, but there is a fourth song in the “Maynard’s Mom” saga. It is a song that predates Judith musically and in terms of the “mom” storyline. The song is called Jimmy. Maynard’s first name is actually James. His mother called him Jimmy. You might be interested in the “prequel”(if you will) since you’ve completed the trilogy.
Yes it’s the prequel to the trilogy !
That’s what we’ve been calling it!
Sori your outfit is banging. Love the shirt
WEVE CONVERTED SORI BOYS!
Yes!!! U have no idea!!! -Sori
I’d like to see Gojira, Art of Dying. Super heavy and interesting.
Chevelle is another awesome band I haven’t seen anyone react to. Get Some, Shameful Metaphors, or Straight Jacket Fashion are all great Chevelle songs.
Love chavelle have never heard those songs
Yes great choices on Chevelle Joe!
Gojira is epic
Yay! Glad you are digging TOOL!
Yup!
Maynard is very much into what is called cerimonial magick. Many of TOOL's songs are actual spells. An exercise to manifest intention. To talk to angels and have them do his bidding. I believe in Wings for Marie, Maynard is literally addressing the angels to recognise his mother and make her one of them.
Great stuff both of you,love the well informed and intelligent commentary, subscription earned!
The ghouls symbolize the close family and friends that hover round and feign grief because they vicariously suffer. The finality of death can attract the "best wishes" and "we're so sorry" crowd and Maynard was asking her how to deal with them because he needs her advice and guidence.
Judith was bitterness and anger, and wings for marie was acceptance
I'm a non believer but I love, appreciate and respect the way you guys have handled the first to parts of this. I'll comment again after 10,000 days
I’m pretty sure the A Perfect Circle song “Passive” fits into this story as well. I thought the Maynard’s mom trilogy was Judith, wings for Marie/10,000 days, and Passive. Wings and 10000 days are typically seen as one song, not two.
Good point many folks have told us they are one song, so your math works
“Jimmy” is in that equation as well.
Jimmy Judith Passive Wings and 10,000
Sorry if you already pointed this out. I was multitasking while listening to this, but the thing I found most interesting was how Maynard says that she “Fell at the hands of those movements that I WOULDN’T see”, as opposed to COULDN’T see, in reference to the prior lyric about her believing in movements none could see. Sounds to me like Maynard has accepted that he chose not to believe, instead of their being no real thing to believe in. Interesting stuff. He definitely sounds closer to acceptance, and hopefully repentance. I’m sure God would be ecstatic to see his son, Maynard, come to know him. I love you guys. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
I like you guys, this coming from a guy whose first language isn't English ;)
I'm happy to subscribe
Tool are the absolute greatest band. By miles.
You got it bad girl...Nothing compares to TOOLS music.
Roses are red
Violets are blue
I’m here for sori
And so are you
Ps, Maynard's other band Pucifer is worth investigating. Especially their latest album Money Shot (tracks like Agostina and Grand Canyon)
Amazing song beautiful
You’re awesome guys! Please do Katatonia - Journey Through Pressure
On the list !!
Also "Serein","New Night",Forsaken" are good options.Basically,anything that this band puts out is...you'll see for yourself
The most beautifull song ever!
You believed.
You believed in moments not conceived.
You believed in me.
A passionate spirit.
Uncompromised
boundless and open.
A light in your eyes, then, immobilized.
Vacant, broken.
Fell at the hands of
Those movements that I wouldn't see.
Cause it was you who prayed for me so.
What have I done to be a son to an angel?
What have I done to be worthy?
Day light dims leaving cold fluorescence.
Difficult to see you in this light.
Please forgive this selfish question, but
What am I to say to all these ghouls tonight?
She never told a lie.
Well might of told a lie.
But never lived one.
Didn't have a life.
Didn't have a life.
But surely saved one.
Saved on.
Alright, now it's time for us to let you go.
I love the songs "Reflection" and "The Patient" not the heaviest they did but some of my favorites.
Like Maynard, being an atheist and having a religious mother, he threw his distaste for religion aside and wrote 2 beautiful songs celebrating his mother's beliefs. Good reaction.
Great work!
Jimmy, Jambi, Lateralus, Vicarious, eh, too many to name...
Lol! Got them all on the list!!
If you guys have not figured it out yet, Tools music is very very trible . Music with complete meaning and that makes think about your own relationship with you.
To elaborate on the 'God' and 'Christ' comments regarding Judith, Maynard explained in the aMOTION DVD that when he says that, he's not talking about the actual God and Christ, but YOUR God and Christ. Aka the personal ones people make for themselves. There's a bit more to it than that I forget since it's been a while since I've watched that DVD, but yeah. That's basically the jist of it.
Ya saw that part !
Fun fact: the loud sound at the end of this track is actually that of a casket closing, signifying the end of Judith's physical state and the beginning of her journey to the gates.
This song get's me every single time. Also, you two are awesome.
Another song you would definitely enjoy in regards to this is "Puscifer - Momma Sed"
i get chills every time
I know this may be too much interpretation but this is just how my mind works.. the transition from part one to this was like Maynard assuming the adversarial role (i.e. satan) and confronting all of her beliefs, *but* by remaining firm in her convictions until the very last breath she had passed the test and earned her wings. Now onto this part, leaving behind a seemingly very regretful son who only means well but has fallen for these worldly temptations and lost his way.. whatever the objectively reality is here, I love it.
His anger stems from the fact that his mother was sick and suffering, and sought help not in medicine but in her belief in god. He was angry (first at her, then at god) she resigned her life to an entity/institution he thinks either doesn't exist or is evil.
He loved his mother deeply and these two songs (Wings for Marie/10000 days) is basically him saying goodbye and saying to god, if he indeed exists, like: "God, you son of a bitch, you better give my give my mom some wings because she was a true saint, a champion for god and an angel."
I love the way Vin approaches tool music
this lyric video is beautiful and the official music videos are amazing, BUT personally I feel that the best way to experience/listen to Tool, especially for the first time for a certain song, is eyes shut. hits and sinks much deeper
Also, my take on the 'ghouls' line is the people at the wake, who Maynard doesn't relate to, or that he feels are worthy of Judith.