The Warlord Titan SUCKS. Here's how to fix it.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
  • Massive thanks to Incogni for sponsoring this madness. Use code midwinterminis at incogni.com/mi... to get an exclusive 60% off an annual Incogni plan.
    Brand new Midwinter Minis t-shirts, sticker sheets, and art prints here: www.midwinterm...
    Music by Midwinter Minis and the RUclips Audio Library.
    Listen to our album: • Grimdark Music For Pla...
    Buy our album: midwinterminis...
    Surprise your friend with a personal video from Guy! www.cameo.com/...
    Here are some useful links for stuff we use. Amazon gives us a few pennies if you buy using these, at no extra cost to you!
    The voiceover microphone I use: geni.us/Podcas...
    The painting lamp I use: geni.us/Daylig...
    The “hobby cam” I use for livestreams: geni.us/LogiBr...
    My favourite headphones: geni.us/BeyerD...
    The camera I used in 2020: geni.us/mwm50
    The camera I use now: geni.us/SonyAl...
    How I mount my camera to my desk: geni.us/Smallr...
    My airbrush compressor: geni.us/Airbru...
    My airbrush: geni.us/IwataA...
    The airbrush set I started with: geni.us/Revell...
    A great model paint starter set: geni.us/Vallej...
    A great beginner paint brush set: geni.us/RLTaklon
    Cheap brushes for detail work: geni.us/RLDeta...
    This video is sponsored by Incogni.

Комментарии • 631

  • @MidwinterMinis
    @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +47

    Titanic thanks to Incogni for supporting this video. Use code midwinterminis at incogni.com/midwinterminis to get an exclusive 60% off an annual Incogni plan.

    • @halkeye20
      @halkeye20 Месяц назад +2

      Im always down for a midwinter 40k video

    • @konstantinbreen
      @konstantinbreen Месяц назад +1

      Titanic 😂

    • @sebastianrubin7476
      @sebastianrubin7476 Месяц назад +3

      Your ad was one of the best I've seen in a while. Genius use of cosplay and roleplay to make an ad fun enough to not just skip past!

    • @valeforedark
      @valeforedark Месяц назад

      Should do a poll to see how many viewers will ever own this.

    • @lektorkovalev8699
      @lektorkovalev8699 Месяц назад +1

      As a player of titans and knights, I want to say that the coolest system for such big guys is the chorus heresy, 40k has long turned into a boring and simple game without any special mechanics, since everything is tailored for fans of sports Warhammer, the fan game that used to make us happy, but the Horus heresy has become much more pleasant and with a bunch of mechanics that ideally make you feel each unit, what is the feeling of a titanium on the table worth, in the heresy these are the gods of war who cover large parts of the battlefield with guns in patterns and hold many attacks and some guns they don't even break through them

  • @CommissarMitch
    @CommissarMitch Месяц назад +569

    Now I love the idea of the Titan being crushed by a bunch of Stompas and Gargants, only for a singular Grot to fire off a bullet that does a Death Star Run and somehow hits the reactor and blows it up.

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +98

      In one of my games the Titan was felled by a handful of Genestealers, so it's not out of the realms of possibility!

    • @CitadelSavage
      @CitadelSavage Месяц назад

      ​@@MidwinterMinisI hope you were yelling "get away from her you bitch!", while that was going on 😂

    • @CommissarMitch
      @CommissarMitch Месяц назад +21

      @MidwinterMinis OK but since I read this now I imagine a short animation of a Genestealer Cultist managing to crawl their way up the leg of the Titan and plant a single stick of dynamite on a really broken piece of armour.
      The genestaler cultist is shot but not before they light up the dynamite which causes the chain reaction.

    • @Triceratopping
      @Triceratopping Месяц назад +8

      "Luke, use da WAAAGH!"

    • @Jamgeoso
      @Jamgeoso 29 дней назад +1

      These kind of David and Goliath scenarios are always really fun but the game has to make them unlikely enough for them to feel exciting. If your big thing dies to small arms fire every game the drama will quickly fade...

  • @isabelleclavering4397
    @isabelleclavering4397 Месяц назад +118

    I'm old-school about titans in 40k. A designer (Gav Thorpe maybe?) once said "if you want a warlord titan in 40k, wrap yourself in tinfoil, point at the map, and say everything on it is dead".
    ... but that said, I see your problem and sympathise.

  • @dagoth-ursbeekeeper9119
    @dagoth-ursbeekeeper9119 Месяц назад +322

    If I had 2000 points of Orks I would totally let my friend wheel this toddler-sized piece of glorified wax out for a good scrap. Like that just sounds fun, like a scene from Helsreach come to life. We'd have 30 photos of damn near every turn.

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +85

      I've just realised I now actually have the models for a Helsreach battle report

    • @I_Stole_Your_Toast
      @I_Stole_Your_Toast Месяц назад +18

      ​@@MidwinterMinisDo it! Do it! Do it!

    • @barbareusz6595
      @barbareusz6595 Месяц назад +7

      ​@@MidwinterMinisDew eet!

    • @Sir_Bucket
      @Sir_Bucket Месяц назад +8

      Battle of the trash tiers: 4 stompas against 1 warlord

    • @squirtydumplings5682
      @squirtydumplings5682 Месяц назад

      The Guyver t-shirt is the real prize 🏆

  • @EmbraCraig
    @EmbraCraig Месяц назад +417

    The fact that the plasma cannon the size of a train doesn’t have devastating wounds is kinda hilarious, tbh.

    • @Lunalander226
      @Lunalander226 Месяц назад +15

      and the fact it has the same strength as every other plasma cannon if I remember right, like, I get certain weapon types would normally be in certain strength brackets but that cannon's about as big as the main gun on most tanks, if not bigger.

    • @ferdinandrepodan2907
      @ferdinandrepodan2907 Месяц назад +21

      "Sunfury Pattern Plasma Annihilator
      A weapon of terrifying and indiscriminate power, the Sunfury Pattern Plasma Annihilator is capable of incinerating entire cityscapes and rendering the strongest armour into steaming vapour." -Games Workshop

    • @Lomhow
      @Lomhow Месяц назад +11

      Should get Devastating Wounds, Lethal Hits, Ignores Cover, Blast, Fireable into Melee. Thing costs an army and a half in points.

    • @elricdotah
      @elricdotah Месяц назад +1

      @@Lomhow the warlord titan nearly costs two armies in points. Army and a half would only be 3000.
      I honestly believe I could win against a warlord titan and a 500 point knight with 2000 points by VP.

    • @FobianCr
      @FobianCr Месяц назад

      @@elricdotah you need only 2 gallant, 1 castellan and 2-3 crusader/paladin/errant to rip warlord on half. Ironically, that ~3000 pts and can be playable vs other armies in 40k 10th edition.

  • @Charles-mi7yv
    @Charles-mi7yv Месяц назад +34

    Someone on the Tyranids subreddit had a ripper swarm, the little tough 2 swarm, kill a warlord titan. He modeled the rippers with little crowns for their achievement.

  • @user-pu4py3zk6c
    @user-pu4py3zk6c Месяц назад +62

    I like the thought of a random guardsman firing his rifle upwards in glee at the sight of a warlord titan, just to somehow one shot it by accident lol

    • @user-jl5bh6eh2d
      @user-jl5bh6eh2d Месяц назад +2

      For once the tech-priest making every part have a mirror Finnish is a downside

  • @dubart5918
    @dubart5918 Месяц назад +144

    As a Tyranid player, this sucks. There's only like 6 dudes in there anyways. Not worth the fight at all.

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +55

      Like fighting a lion to just get a chicken wing

    • @Secretgeek2012
      @Secretgeek2012 Месяц назад +3

      ​@@MidwinterMinis😂

    • @C0ldramen
      @C0ldramen Месяц назад +3

      @@MidwinterMinisnothing will keep me away from my chicken wings damnit

    • @rileyjessup2414
      @rileyjessup2414 Месяц назад

      And those 6 dudes are really only like 1/10th of an actual dude since they're mostly augmented 😂

    • @user-jl5bh6eh2d
      @user-jl5bh6eh2d Месяц назад +6

      More like 3 guys, 2 cyborgs and 1 large foetus

  • @jaxsonhansen8112
    @jaxsonhansen8112 Месяц назад +170

    He better have a match between the greates of unclean ones, the Barbie of sex and doom, the gargant, and the titan fighting on a room sized board of all kinds of terrain

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +42

      Barbie of sex and doom, haha

    • @Jamgeoso
      @Jamgeoso 29 дней назад

      This would be awesome!

  • @parapotato
    @parapotato Месяц назад +73

    This biggest issue I've noticed just reading the dataslate for the titans is the lack of an actual area of effect. The plasma destroyer is meant to be able to annihilate an entire company of infantry in a single hit, but the way 40k works you shoot one 5 man squad with it and the second squad standing 2 feet away are totally unaffected. Something like the old school blast templates would help this big guy out a lot actually. Imagine slapping down a dinner plate sized template on the board and you hit everything inside of it. Suddenly your opponent doesn't have much of an army left to shoot you with next turn. (please not this is just an observation, I'm not putting this forward as an actual solution)

    • @Badbufon
      @Badbufon Месяц назад +9

      They could keyword it like they did with the Plasma Warhead (it rolls for every unit at a radius from the target)

    • @humantwist-offcap9514
      @humantwist-offcap9514 Месяц назад +2

      It used to have a rule where the plasma wave from the impact would wash over nearby units and deal damage.

    • @moreorless87
      @moreorless87 Месяц назад +1

      Yeah I think Titans arguably need some kind of rule that allows that to spilt up attacks. Maybe not something like the Volcano canon which is meant to kill big units but something like the Sunfury Plasma or the Quake Canon should be able to do so something like target one unit and then allocate attacks to other units a certain distance(6 inchs?) from them. The Apoc Launchers should perhaps be able to allocate 10 attacks to two different units and the Las Blasters perhaps to three different units.

    • @MrJonathan107
      @MrJonathan107 Месяц назад +2

      #bringbackblasttemplates

    • @BewilderedDuck-e5l
      @BewilderedDuck-e5l Месяц назад +3

      The 2nd ed Cyclone missile launchers could choose to fire all 12 krak missiles at once and use a 12” blast template. Couple of those in the first round really softened up the opponent 😂

  • @h4ppyn00dl3b0y
    @h4ppyn00dl3b0y Месяц назад +43

    I have a Warhound.
    I occasionally take it to my local games shop for a bit of fun.
    By fun, I mean giving my opponent the chance to feel great about their army being able to say they killed a Titan.
    Even against mostly infantry... it still dies every time. Every time.
    Still fun.

    • @vortex594
      @vortex594 Месяц назад +7

      If you ever feel like *actually using* a Warhound, they perfectly fit into a Horus Heresy army's Lord of War slot, costing just 750 points, exactly enough to fill the 25% maximum in a 3000pt game. And their rules make them worth using in the slot, too.

    • @kookieslayer
      @kookieslayer Месяц назад

      @@vortex594 That's great to hear!

  • @Bluecho4
    @Bluecho4 Месяц назад +293

    Yeah, there are only a few hundred people who bought the model. But those people dropped _thousands of dollars_ on them. They deserve to have usable rules, regardless of whether most 40K players think it's "worth it" to design for it.

    • @Motorcitynights
      @Motorcitynights Месяц назад +8

      That doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me. Just because something is expensive does not mean it NEEDS to be insanely powerful.
      That being said, I do think that it needs to have like 300 wounds and a special rule against devs like the custodes. Or straight up drop the points like the video says.
      Primarchs die a lot faster than you think they should in lore all the time in game.

    • @vast9467
      @vast9467 Месяц назад +18

      @@Motorcitynightsit’s a warlord titan though, it definitely is supposed to be powerful

    • @firmak2
      @firmak2 Месяц назад +18

      ​@@Motorcitynightsbut he didnt say insanely powerful, he said usable.

    • @hausdorffspace
      @hausdorffspace Месяц назад +5

      Just homebrew some better rules. Sorted.

    • @matthewgagnon9426
      @matthewgagnon9426 Месяц назад +10

      @@Motorcitynights It doesn't need to be insanely powerful, it just needs to be decent enough to not lose every single time to just being focused down without having a single chance in hell at fighting back.

  • @harbl99
    @harbl99 Месяц назад +16

    _WFB_ worked out the utility of 1+ saves ("No AP, no chance") two decades ago. Give the Warlord a 1+ armour save, heck, even a 0+ if you want to ensure that only anti-tank weapons will do more than chip the paint.

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +4

      That's legit a great idea

    • @tomsonlarrson3318
      @tomsonlarrson3318 Месяц назад +2

      @@MidwinterMinis If I saw a warlord titan coming out at me I would legit just bring as many naked 20 stack guardsmen as possible. Tanks with actually damaging weapons would probably be blown off the table first with no real damage done, so infantry all the way. Pretty sure with all those fancy attacks the Titan couldnt chew through 330 infantry with reinforcements before I land enough lasgun hits to eat it. It would really make more sense to have that sorta rule, because the idea of lasguns bringing down a Titan in any other capacity than climbing up the legs and shooting the crew after boarding is offensive.

    • @elricdotah
      @elricdotah Месяц назад

      @@tomsonlarrson3318 330 infantry get 330, maybe 660 shots. You need about 3600 HITS to kill the titan. So over 5 turns, you can't kill it given you wound on 6+ and have max AP-1 (because the titan can easily get cover, right?), so he saves on 2+.

    • @Jamgeoso
      @Jamgeoso 29 дней назад

      This seems like a really good solution for such a unique unit

  • @vortex594
    @vortex594 Месяц назад +67

    For what it's worth, Titans have totally viable rules *in Horus Heresy.*
    Granted, apart from lacking xenos, it's a better rule set in basically every other way too so this shouldn't be surprising.

    • @imaneeldealwithit969
      @imaneeldealwithit969 Месяц назад +12

      Yep, I’m really sad they fumbled 40K so hard in 10th, HH is basically strictly better now imo except in terms of simplicity but eh

    • @overlordpichu5577
      @overlordpichu5577 Месяц назад +4

      i think thats kinda indicative of the differing design philosophies between the games really. modern 40k is designed around smaller games or a skirmish based level of play. you can have large armies but its not exactly conducive to play em. Meanwhile horus heresy is designed around large armies going to town on each other, so it makes sense a titan fits in more easily in the game where its expected to fight larger blobs of dudes.

    • @mrtcereal1
      @mrtcereal1 Месяц назад

      If anything the warlord is incredibly well costed in HH. Maybe even *too good* because the sheer number of hull points and the difficulty of hurting it even with other titans.

  • @101Phase
    @101Phase Месяц назад +23

    If we reduce the warlord from 3500 to 2000 (a factor of 1.75), then we should do the same for the other titans. A Warhoubd would come down to 629, a reaver would be 1257, and a warbringer would be 1486
    The problem with this is that at 629, the warhound would be cheaper than the Acastus knights (710 and 765)

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +10

      Having faced an Acastus Knight with the Titan, I would say that actually that's fair. That thing is death on legs.

    • @101Phase
      @101Phase Месяц назад +9

      So for simplicity I would propose the following:
      Warhound - 800
      Reaver - 1200
      Warbringer- 1500
      Warlord - 2000
      This works out nicely because it means you can field an army with nothing but 1 warhound and 1 reaver for 2000

    • @Yurt_enthusiast7
      @Yurt_enthusiast7 Месяц назад +2

      @@101Phase sounds about right, a Warhound costed 750 just at couple of editions ago

  • @TheoCoin907
    @TheoCoin907 Месяц назад +107

    It's so expensive that GW will only give it good rules if more people buy warlord titan

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +38

      But maybe more people might buy it if they could use it? Catch 22, haha

    • @foulplay99
      @foulplay99 Месяц назад +11

      GW don’t really care about rules though. The put them there just as an extra thing to support the one thing they REALLY want, and thats selling models. The Warlord Titan is a weird thing though. Too expensive for 99.9% of players, and the rules make it pretty unattractive for the .01% who WOULD buy it just to field it on the tabletop. I seriously think the bulk of people buying this are just doing it to get a huge centerpiece and a large project to keep them busy for a few months/years whilst they build and paint it - and thats the reason I’m building mine now. The rest are people 3D printing them just to give GW the middle finger.

    • @jasoninthehood9726
      @jasoninthehood9726 Месяц назад +2

      @@foulplay99Yeah. It’s a flex and I love flexing.

  • @frankyboi1819
    @frankyboi1819 Месяц назад +82

    Boo ho- oh you beat me to it. Well thanks for the video then!

  • @catcadev
    @catcadev Месяц назад +3

    I think that the titan's rules should include the eight void-shields. Imagine each blowing up and sending shockwaves across the board. Like you're actually fighting a monster, a colossus.

  • @dawsonhealy4327
    @dawsonhealy4327 Месяц назад +6

    In 9th I printed a Warlord for a friend and we did a 3v1 against him, didn't expect him to be shot to death on turn 3. We then did a 1v1 with 2k of knights against the Warlord and it died on turn 4 in melee. Like cmon that's ridiculous.

    • @DarkRaven4649
      @DarkRaven4649 29 дней назад +1

      Hey now, Cerastus Knights are literally known as Titan Killers because a lance of them could (and did!) frequently bring down Titans in melee! Don't rag on the God Machine Jr's!

    • @dawsonhealy4327
      @dawsonhealy4327 29 дней назад

      @@DarkRaven4649 had two questoris, a Dominus, and a few Armigers. Should've been more even but it was a big slaughter, only lost a few armigers and some damage to a questoris.

  • @zieg0r
    @zieg0r Месяц назад +37

    A Warboss + Painboy 20 Choppa Boyz Blob dishes out 76 AP -1 Choppa attacks hitting on 2s during the WAAAGH, supported by a 5++ and a 5+ FNP. It should be pretty easy to get everything into engagement range, even without Green Tide Stratagems.
    That + an Ard Case Battlewagon costs a total of 475 points, leaving 1525 open for other stuff. Even at 2000 points, the Titan seems much more scary than it actually is. You "just" have to occupy it in melee combat with a horde of minis long enough to outscore it.

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +9

      Exactly! In one of my tests, 2 salvos of BOTH Apocalypse Missile launchers failed to take out a mob of 20 green tide Boyz with a Painboy.

    • @zieg0r
      @zieg0r Месяц назад +7

      @@MidwinterMinis It's a bit silly that 48(!!) shots of zoggin' 8/-2/2 rokkits hitting on 3s isn't sufficient to reliably take out a bunch of sentient mushroom hooligans trying to refashion your millenia old sacred war machine into a fancy convertible with guns. So yeah, I totally get you.
      This thing should OBLITERATE stuff.

    • @Squig96
      @Squig96 Месяц назад +2

      There should be a rule for attacks with strength under like 6 to not being able to damage the titan at all, really. Its just ridiculous to imagine a titan dying from some Orkboys hitting his toes with an axe.

    • @GundamReviver
      @GundamReviver Месяц назад +1

      ​@@Squig96well it's not really hitting it's toes so much as literally boarding it and breaking vital stuff.

    • @dracometeors3010
      @dracometeors3010 Месяц назад

      Boys are ridiculous this Edition tho.
      There is little, either Infantry or Vehicle that survives a Squad passing them.

  • @PaintingNorth
    @PaintingNorth Месяц назад +31

    Played a game with one where it was two teams against each other and the warlord against both and the warlord was killed turn one

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +19

      It's like 20 distraction Carnifexes standing on each other's shoulders

    • @PaintingNorth
      @PaintingNorth Месяц назад +2

      Yeah we really thought it would be stronger we also had 2 warhound titans to go with it

  • @BlueBoy0
    @BlueBoy0 Месяц назад +5

    The painting on the headlight is so good that for a minute I thought you had an LED in there.

  • @alexandreboureau6175
    @alexandreboureau6175 Месяц назад +8

    Funnily, the Warlord titans also underperformed badly in Space Marines(epic 2nd edition), with a poorly armored plasma reactor. It went down from 900 to 500 or 750 in Adeptus Titanicus(750 for a single one, and 1500 for a battlegroup of 3, which is a deeper discount than what you usually can see on GW shops), which made it eventually playable (and even overpowered in groups of 3).

  • @Fools_Travels
    @Fools_Travels Месяц назад +4

    i own 3 titans, (two warhounds, 1 reavfer, with a massive group of titanguard secutarii) one of the worst things to happen recently is to be told that my army and the titans are a fake forgeworld dream and it doesn't have a place on the 40k tabletop by a GW store manager where i am. i'm glad to see more attention going to these models. i'm frustrated with the rules, and i'm frustrated with how the community seems to treat and handle the bigger models in the tabletop, and this extends beyond the titans themselves. even the spaceships/flyers and the imperial knights seem to get this same ball of treatment.
    at the moment i'm refusing to collect with any intention of playing, and my own engagement with the hobby has dropped drastically as a result of this perceived hostility towards showcase rule of cool models. i hope for something better one day.

  • @101Phase
    @101Phase Месяц назад +7

    Nessa caught 13/16 treats, so her invul save is roughly 2++

  • @Thebritishhistorian
    @Thebritishhistorian Месяц назад +12

    To be honest, I think all rules writers at GW is just terrified of being the person who allowed Warlord Titans to be a legitimate 2000 point army list for tournaments. The pay to win backlash would be as colossal as the titans are if one ranked remotely well at an official tournament.
    All that being said.. Yes. I would love the Warlord Titan to be more playable, and also fieldable with other things too! And I feel 2000 points should be the goal... that being said...
    The desire for "Silly huge games only" models will always be in the hearts of wargamers.
    And maybe the role you want the Warlord to fill is already filled by the likes of Reaver and Warhound titans.

    • @user-hv6gi9ux6z
      @user-hv6gi9ux6z Месяц назад +1

      That said it isint even legal for a 2k game as you still need a unit to be your warlord

    • @elricdotah
      @elricdotah Месяц назад

      "The pay to win backlash would be as colossal as the titans are if one ranked remotely well at an official tournament. "
      I highly doubt it. With a 40% win rate, nobody would bat an eye. And it's just one model, so there is a very very slim chance of winning in the first place, even if at some point you table your opponent before you table them.
      On WTC terrain, you can't move at all, so you're stuck on your home objective. Let's suppose you're getting something like take no prisoners or assassinate each turn, to score 4-5 points on them. That's maybe 50 points tops. Which army in a tournament loses to 50 points if you have several turns of free reign in nomans land?

  • @4hedgesfamily
    @4hedgesfamily Месяц назад +2

    I'm glad to see this video. I just took a Reaver into a 2,000 Horus Heresy game. It played like a giant bullet magnet, got taken out by a squad of Astartes with meltaguns, and did more damage when the reactor blew up than it did shooting at anything. I thought maybe it was because I'm a sucky player or my dice hate me, but you let me know I'm okay, it's just titans that suck.
    They're still cool, though!

  • @quadcannon
    @quadcannon 23 дня назад +2

    My fixes:
    - No weapon under S8 can harm a Warlord Titan. The Titan can ignore any damage that would result from any weapon which strength is below 8.
    - The Warlord Titan counts as always passing any Leadership that may result from any source.
    - Titanic Weaponry (main weapons) ignore all saves, including invulnerable and cause a -1 to any Feel No Pain to a maximum of a 6+.
    - A Warlord Titan's feet causes 2D6 automatic Mortal Wounds to any unit it is in base-to-base contact with within each Fight Phase.
    - A Warlord Titan's melee weapons have the [Titanic 2+] [Monstrous Creature 2+] rules for wounding and also inflict +1 mortal wound for every successful point of damage inflicted by a normal attack. If against [Infantry] then it inflicts D6 additional mortal wounds for each successful point of damage inflicted by a normal attack.
    I'll have some more, but this is what rolled off the string of consciousness first.

  • @edwadloozley5309
    @edwadloozley5309 Месяц назад +4

    I wholeheartedly agree with the points made here. I’ve played several Apoc games with my Warlord w/ turbo lasers, plasma, and volcano cannon, and since going to 10th it’s felt a lot worse. It doesn’t help that’s it’s 10th Edition datasheet is vastly worse than it’s 9th Edition datasheet. Almost every gun is effectively worse even if it’s stats didn’t change because of the new strength and toughness scale of 10th, the Titan has less base wounds and has less movement, and the void shields were just busted in 9th. I know nobody could fucking agree on how they worked even after FW confirmed it’s 24 extra wounds you can only lose three of at a time, that healed in increments of 3, that also gave you a 5+ Invulnerable save while they lasted.
    Everyone who points at “OMG STRENGTH 32 WDYM THIS IS BAD??!!!??!?!” is someone who’s never played with or against Titans. And I don’t blame them because they’re very rare models to come across, so let me give you two examples. The Volcano cannon was S20 last edition, which already wounded everything on 2s, so 32 is nothing new. It has less shots but more damage which unfortunately maths out to be exactly the same damage if everything goes through, so it’s only change is that it’s now more swingy because it’s relying more on each individual attack. The plasma is especially a joke. It’s AP went down so it now has less AP than the new Primaris Macro-plasma Incinerators on the Repulsor Executioners and Redemptor Dreadnoughts. Like you’re telling me this tiny plasma gun has more AP than this genuinely real-life-arm sized resin brick of a gun? And in an edition where everything’s toughness went up, the plasma’s strength went down. The standard charge is S10 and the Supercharge is only S12. Even supercharging the largest plasma weapon in the game won’t wound a Custodes Terminator, or Space Marine Centurion exosuit on a 2+. Supercharge wounds a Baneblade on a 5+ and Imperial Knights on a 4+.
    Standard doesn’t even wound a standard Custodes guardian on a 2+. It’s a fucking joke now and I’m mad.
    It’s makes it more maddening that everyone who has no experience in the matter chimes in and is like “oh there’s no way it’s that bad it’s a WARLORD TITAN,” and then they pint at some ridiculously high number on its profile like it’s 100 wounds. I don’t think some of y’all realize how quickly 100 wounds disappears in 40K. A full 2k army has more than 100 wounds on the table. The Warlord is almost double that point cost and has less wounds than an army half his point cost. This thing genuinely evaporates in one turn to concentrated AT weapons from things like Tyrannofexes, Shadowswords, Imperial Knights in general, Hammerheads, all units you can take in ABUNDANCE in a 2k army. Like yeah no it’s fucking awful for its point cost and general hobby time sink. Like you have to get a shelf with it specifically in mind, they take forever to assemble and paint, and they’re a pain in the ass to transport anywhere.
    Guy if you read this whole ass comment 1. Thanks for your time love your videos 2. Use the 9th Edition rules you already made for your gargant and for the Warlord instead. It’ll be a lot more fun because you can just fill in the points difference with your Orks that the gargant can transport anyways

  • @RenMomoDotPog
    @RenMomoDotPog Месяц назад +38

    hey guy, I finished up my lethal company interns on simon's day! just wanted to letcha know that I did get that hobbying in, even if it was all slapchop (it does look appropriate for orange space suit guys tho)

  • @toblexson5020
    @toblexson5020 Месяц назад +6

    The massive over-simplification since I left warhammer is one of the two reasons why I just haven't got enough motivation to get back into the game (The other being cost). Special rules, blast templates and apocalypse battles were the most cool things in the game, and now everything seems to be focused on making the game easy enough for children to play, which feels like such a weird target audience for an apocalypical hellscape universe filled with murder, torture and body-horror. I remember when apocalypse came out they actually encouraged scratchbuilding superheavy tanks and monsters, and even creating your own rules for them. (Also, space marines still need more a vindicator with a mini volcano cannon, it's the perfect chassis for it)
    There used to be a rule that if the to-hit/to-wound/save/etc. roll was above a 6, you would have to roll a 6 and then roll again (using a roll table), so that 6+ wasn't the limit. It was such a simple way to counter the limitations for D6. Basically, I'm saying that to wound a T18 unit, only the most powerful weapons should be wounding on a single die.

  • @Mr.Goufball
    @Mr.Goufball Месяц назад +6

    Whilst I mostly agree with what you are saying, I am a little bit concerned that simply lowering the points cost of the Warlord Titan might cause some issues since that would mean you also have to lower the points costs of the other titans, at which point they might interact weirdly with other big high points units.

    • @Firefrab
      @Firefrab 28 дней назад

      yeah... acastus knights are arund 7-750 points, where the warhound used to be in 9e I beleive, so you'd have to be very careful...

  • @Gaulwa
    @Gaulwa Месяц назад +5

    12:34 Time to tell you the way I would not only fix the Warlord Titan but also make Warhammer 40K a cooler game in general. All it takes is 3 words: ONE PAGE RULES.

    • @stephenwitham
      @stephenwitham 27 дней назад +1

      OPR is garbage though, that would only make the game far worse. OPR is just a cult.

  • @My_wife_left_me
    @My_wife_left_me Месяц назад +30

    I think the warlord titan would be fantastic if we had templates in 10th

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +17

      Dishing out pie plates like it's Christmas dinner

    • @user-jl5bh6eh2d
      @user-jl5bh6eh2d Месяц назад +2

      Why were they removed in the first place, I think they make vehicles and weapons visualise way better

    • @My_wife_left_me
      @My_wife_left_me Месяц назад +3

      @@user-jl5bh6eh2d so they got removed when we have the 8th ed re-fresh because they wanted to "simplify" the game
      It might be worth checking out the WLT Horus heresy rules?

    • @Jamgeoso
      @Jamgeoso 29 дней назад +1

      @@user-jl5bh6eh2d Whilst they were thematic, they did lead to a lot of unfun play patterns. People spacing out they're units in ways that made the table look strange and it was always tricky to be really precise about whether a model is just outside or just inside

  • @fandaeckert1915
    @fandaeckert1915 Месяц назад +2

    The Megagargant disassembling itself over the time almost feels way too accurate to be done unintentionally.

  • @EnordAreven
    @EnordAreven Месяц назад +3

    as someone from outside Warhammer, I genuinely assumed this thing was 2000 points as the "baseline for that many battle point" measuring stick,
    SERIOUSLY,
    Like "what could my army 2000 point army face? One of those." How many teenagers do you need to fight one bear, ya know? 😅

  • @adorimable9690
    @adorimable9690 Месяц назад +2

    I used a Legions Imperialis warlord against my friends as a proxy, against a 1400 point army, and lost. It was fun still! I painted it in Legio Astraman colors

  • @euansmith3699
    @euansmith3699 Месяц назад +4

    0:48 That Atlas model, to the left of the tabletop display, is froggin' amazing; I was going to say "awesome", but that could be confusing.

    • @zosoknight
      @zosoknight Месяц назад +1

      Now imagine if it was a Warhammer instead of an Atlas.

  • @toxicwaste225
    @toxicwaste225 Месяц назад +13

    Honestly I don’t really like 10th edition as they made the death guard even weaker and there my favourite army

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +7

      Seems like there's lots of dissatisfied Death Guard players out there!

    • @toxicwaste225
      @toxicwaste225 Месяц назад +4

      @@MidwinterMinis yea GW basically made them chaos space marines that look like death guard by removing disgustingly resilient

    • @Yurt_enthusiast7
      @Yurt_enthusiast7 Месяц назад +1

      the thing that gripes me the most is that they made DG into a aggressive army who de-buffs instead of a defensive one who grind down their foes

    • @toxicwaste225
      @toxicwaste225 Месяц назад +1

      @@Yurt_enthusiast7 exactly there’s an offensive chaos space marine so defensive ones are needed

  • @chaosgrunt9554
    @chaosgrunt9554 Месяц назад +4

    A lot of the problems with the Titan in 10th is mostly caused by 8th to 10th treating these units like "big infantry" rather than having armour values like they do in HH and prior editions. With armour values and the void shields in the prior editions, these things are a lot nastier and very hard to take down without specific units. It's why I've stayed with the older editions myself (plus gaming club pals, obviously).

  • @EmGieCzy
    @EmGieCzy Месяц назад +2

    That was the best pronounceation of Grzegorz Brzęczyszczykiewicz that I've ever hear from non-polish guy xD

  • @johnbruce4004
    @johnbruce4004 Месяц назад +3

    Next time its Hatty throwing sausage cuts to you 😂

  • @simonrobinson4761
    @simonrobinson4761 Месяц назад +1

    It’s a universal truth in RPGs and wargames is: “If it has stats, it can be killed.”
    This is also why I was dead agains the primarchs being made as playable models. It’s just wrong that such a unique and badass character gets spayed by a grot.

  • @MrBertie7
    @MrBertie7 Месяц назад +1

    I honestly thought his 3 words were going to be "Just play Heresy" - at AV15 it looks like a BEAST in Heresy.

  • @DaFalk216
    @DaFalk216 25 дней назад +1

    That was one of the best ads I've seen in a while my dude

  • @alphawolves8809
    @alphawolves8809 Месяц назад +1

    Not only entertaining but as well interesting. Nice vid.

  • @poshboy4749
    @poshboy4749 Месяц назад +1

    Okay I wasn't not thinking the thing you said at the beginning when I saw the thumbnail. So you got me haha!
    Seriously you make a good point. Very interesting.

  • @Secretgeek2012
    @Secretgeek2012 Месяц назад +3

    The loss of the S vs T chart has been one of the biggest faults of 10th.

    • @florianpal9633
      @florianpal9633 7 дней назад

      But.. the S vs T charts are there? 10th didnt remove anything in that regard

    • @Secretgeek2012
      @Secretgeek2012 7 дней назад

      @@florianpal9633 I was thinking more the nuanced approach with the table.
      I mean, was it really so difficult for people that it slowed games down so much it needed removing?

  • @Zorgdub
    @Zorgdub 29 дней назад +1

    Today I learned: 40k now uses Toughness for vehicles. Oooh boy.
    Yeah, thing dies to laser pistols. This is so dumb...

  • @figureartout
    @figureartout Месяц назад +1

    I came across this problem , when looking in to making 2000pt titan lists

  • @wolf2403
    @wolf2403 Месяц назад

    First ad read in a long while I didn't skip, simply because it was done so well. Love the outfit!

  • @Yurt_enthusiast7
    @Yurt_enthusiast7 Месяц назад +2

    Biggest issue with it is GWs long lasting vendetta against FW models, feels like they haven't had been given the time/resources for making well written rules for them in 10 years at least

  • @TheDRAG0N22
    @TheDRAG0N22 Месяц назад

    Honestly, titans need a unique special rule on their weapons. This allows them to do blasts effectively in 40k. For example, "When firing this weapon, you may spread your successful hit rolls across the target unit and any enemy units within x inches of the target unit."

  • @AJB2K3
    @AJB2K3 28 дней назад

    In the days of Epic people used to get annoyed with me fielding mine as it was armed with a landing pad and 3 MRL's. I used to hide it behind scenery then use the flyer as a spotter and launch barrages around the table without taking it out of cover.

  • @TheMrFishnDucks
    @TheMrFishnDucks Месяц назад +1

    Awesome video. If the new edition rules don't worry and use house rules just like the Team Deathmatch series. Completely forgot how awesome the titan looks.

  • @aerlands100
    @aerlands100 Месяц назад

    I'm loving this new spicy side of Guy lately!!

  • @MrBiggybit
    @MrBiggybit Месяц назад +1

    You need to make that boarder for your infomercial
    Make a miniature frame/boarder
    Photoshop the center out
    That’s your layer!

  • @Mrreaper643
    @Mrreaper643 Месяц назад +1

    So what I’m hearing is angron has a pretty good change to claim this things skull for khorne?

  • @hubertborusinski1647
    @hubertborusinski1647 Месяц назад +6

    Grzegorz Brzęczyszczykiewicz is a pun from old Polish comedy

  • @zoogoo404
    @zoogoo404 29 дней назад +1

    You're sorta lucky you even *get* a 10th edition stat block. Xenos always suffering.

  • @Vortex0514
    @Vortex0514 Месяц назад +3

    i feel the old MoE glaive zerker blob pre nerf would easily eat warlord titan for breakfasts😂

  • @enderkid2388
    @enderkid2388 Месяц назад

    I solved the problem by having it on the sidelines, and flavouring it as battlefield condition esque rules. For example at the start of each turn it would shoot randomly across the board and deal some major damage to everyone

  • @crwarren
    @crwarren Месяц назад +4

    Got as far as you complaining about pistols wounding on 6s and I already know the answer...
    Play horus heresy

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад +3

      Yeaaah, I just don't really find Space Marines very interesting though

    • @crwarren
      @crwarren Месяц назад +1

      @@MidwinterMinis well I've got even more good news, plastic mechanicum

    • @deckofmanytoyboxes8845
      @deckofmanytoyboxes8845 Месяц назад

      Funny enough, most of the issues Guy stated still exist for the model in 30k, I've tried it.

  • @davidhalfpenny2799
    @davidhalfpenny2799 26 дней назад

    you should bring the Warlord to a Titan Owners Club walk! that would make the most EPIC battle report - EVER!!

  • @EnordAreven
    @EnordAreven Месяц назад +1

    BETTER IDEA, set basic Warlord titan at 2000 points... AND... Release updates rules for more powerful weapons, armour and rules to make a higher point cost warlord titan actually worth its reputation!!!

  • @giorgiofenu5563
    @giorgiofenu5563 Месяц назад +2

    14:20 Guy i love you dude but i don't think it's the point cost that hinders seeing more titans around, it's more the... uhhh... actual money cost

    • @dracometeors3010
      @dracometeors3010 Месяц назад +2

      False, everyone who wants titans prints titans. Easily accessable and appropriately priced.
      The problems are space, rules and finding opponents for big games.

  • @9forMortalMen
    @9forMortalMen Месяц назад

    I had a couple of thoughts about the rules. It's pretty clear that the classic rules, especially strength vs toughness, fall apart when confronted by the behemoth that is the Titan. IMO, it should get specific rules against small arms fire, be able to essentially ignore engagement as a rule with most units, and yes get various instances of dev wounds or lethal hits.

  • @bludragon77
    @bludragon77 Месяц назад

    It’s kinda like when I get asked why you paint models, cause it’s fun and once I buy that kit you could go the box art or you can take the paint job or the base in any direction

  • @jaysunbodaysun3302
    @jaysunbodaysun3302 Месяц назад +1

    Guy, a great video. I hope you are still enjoying your hobby. I pray that you are still finding time to play games. I wish the best for you, I can tell you are a good person. Please never loose your passion. It's why I joined your patreon. Keep it up.

    • @MidwinterMinis
      @MidwinterMinis  Месяц назад

      Thanks buddy! I appreciate it. A bit worn out the last couple of weeks as the kids' childminder is off on holiday so I've only been working 2 or 3 days each week, and running around after the little'uns the rest of the time! Haha

    • @jaysunbodaysun3302
      @jaysunbodaysun3302 Месяц назад

      @@MidwinterMinis are you still playing games?

  • @bio-boosted
    @bio-boosted Месяц назад

    Love the guyver shirt!
    Guardsman being able to do damage to it would be a sight to see!

  • @MatthewFEnfield
    @MatthewFEnfield 23 дня назад

    Ive often thought that maybe if your strength is less than 1/3 of their toughness, you cannot damage them

  • @Turkos245
    @Turkos245 Месяц назад +1

    Imagine getting shot at by a cannon the size of a fuckin train car and you just say "naw"

  • @SabersWorkshop
    @SabersWorkshop Месяц назад

    At first when you suggested that a warlord be 2k I thought you were out of your mind. But then upon further reflection of your arguments I found them all well reasoned and convincing. I think 2k is fair for this behemoth and it would be epic if a points drop meant I fight one of these bad boys at some point in the future. That seems sick.

  • @Writh811
    @Writh811 Месяц назад

    I think it's funny we both had the same idea for how to right size Titans. They just don't have the heat to face off against 3k+ armies. But against a 2k army it is like a raid boss fight.
    When it comes to rebalancing them to have more punch I think they should still cost less than 3k even with added punch, all their attacks should have an effect radius just on the nature of their size. But a new keyword should be given predominantly to fliers and some bigger artillery "Anti-Titan." I just love the idea of a Titan being surrounded by Dakkajets and the like while boyz are getting crushed under its feet.

  • @foulplay99
    @foulplay99 Месяц назад

    I’m about 3/4 through building and painting my warlord titan now, since I got it in May this year. I’ve asked my local GW store manager if he can think of some sort of game we can make up just so I can have one go with this on a tabletop. After that it’s gonna be display only like the rest of my WH models.

  • @hallsofvalhalla1749
    @hallsofvalhalla1749 Месяц назад

    It's fun to do the probability calculations for dice rolls. it only gets more complex if you start doing conditional probability. But the to hit probabilities are not that complex.

  • @Jessforprez
    @Jessforprez 27 дней назад +1

    And adult conversation? On the internet?! No way!

  • @Izayoink_Saccuy
    @Izayoink_Saccuy 14 дней назад +1

    I had killed a reaver titan with a suicide poxwalkers melee charge before that says a lot about titans

  • @Fatalli666
    @Fatalli666 Месяц назад

    You had me at "Big resin frisbee."

  • @BouncingTribbles
    @BouncingTribbles Месяц назад

    I'd watch a 2k battle report with this guy.

  • @thexdatabase
    @thexdatabase Месяц назад +1

    not goona lie that add was fire

  • @martin-mz2dv
    @martin-mz2dv Месяц назад

    that atlas on your desk looks like such a cooler model than the gw stuff.

  • @nathanguice2417
    @nathanguice2417 29 дней назад

    I like your solution of the points drop, and I would add a "lore friendly" explanation that the reason that the rules currently stink for it is that the Mechanicus doesn't know how (or are too dogmatic) to put the weapons and shields on the "optimized" settings. Thus, it SHOULD be doing much better, but it just isn't as the crew just doesn't know how to operate the thing correctly. Works for me.

    • @tarnetskygge
      @tarnetskygge 10 дней назад +1

      Titan weapons and tactics are presumably designed for proper large-scale open battles (like in the epic-scale games they come from), it actually makes sense to me that they would perform badly against skirmish forces. Like a modern MBT ambushed by infantry in a street fight, the princeps has already fucked up by allowing his machine to be engaged in such a fashion.

  • @sammelisi8073
    @sammelisi8073 Месяц назад

    The viewers could act as the grot/human mechanic force and based on donations or poles they could add bonuses and affects to each titan model. Both of these giant models need a bunch of little guys to keep them running and this could represent that in game. Especially since it could be a weighted vote type thing, where the guys in charge (The players) are giving out orders to the rest of the ship and then the middle management guys "distribute" the work force to accomplish those goals. I'd say that would be fairly thematic

  • @Corusame
    @Corusame 29 дней назад

    Infantry being able to block a Titan's movement and shoot through its void shields are some of the most ridiculous things I've heard in a long time.

  • @KriegHammer
    @KriegHammer Месяц назад

    Man that intro cracked me up something fierce!

  • @steaky6523
    @steaky6523 29 дней назад

    The fact that the warlord titan moves as fast as a tau crisis suit is kinda crazy

  • @deadswordsman
    @deadswordsman 14 дней назад

    OC 30 is easy to contest by 10 guardsmen under the +1 OC order.

  • @toresvensson8969
    @toresvensson8969 Месяц назад +1

    Warlord titans are amazing in Apocalypse! Use the Apocalypse 3rd Edtion ruleset from 2019, not 40k 10th edtion as thats really a skirmish game. Its still found online, all datasheets are free from GW. There is even community updates for all new GW kits released since Apocalypse came out.

  • @CarburetorThompson
    @CarburetorThompson 29 дней назад

    I haven’t played warhammer in years, I thought 8th ed was supposed to be the big rule simplification, can’t believe they did another big simplification so soon

  • @siph_horridus
    @siph_horridus Месяц назад

    We at Titan Owners Club do Titan vs Titan and use AT rules, AT28mm just means adapting ranges, x4 to be fair.

  • @nathanlovin
    @nathanlovin Месяц назад

    lol I know this is really not related but I learned the term "war dolly" from you and it's my absolute favorite. At least in the US, folks find it really disarming and are immediately more opened up what the hobby is.

  • @anthonyhall6562
    @anthonyhall6562 Месяц назад

    I love the amount of effort that goes into even your ads

  • @aaronm3795
    @aaronm3795 29 дней назад +1

    I want the titan at 2001 points. You can use it in casual games but no competitive warlord titans 😂

  • @JonathanUsmar
    @JonathanUsmar Месяц назад

    The boohoo "saved you from typing that out" was fantastic 😂

  • @Parabueto
    @Parabueto Месяц назад

    This is why I play 4th and 5th edition and Apocalypse when I can. Really that was the best for the giant units, where all the other stuff was really window dressing.

  • @liesureleeminis8268
    @liesureleeminis8268 Месяц назад

    Now you need a chaos warlord titan for it to fight

  • @Pierre845
    @Pierre845 Месяц назад

    I agree! Last Monday I played my 810 point Tyranid Heirophant Bio-titan at Warhammer world in 6000 point game. We got turn 1 and it shot and killed 3 Aeldari wraith guard. Then died in my opponents turn 1.
    I brought it for fun but I just exchanged 810 points for almost nothing.

  • @Abefroman-lq3md
    @Abefroman-lq3md Месяц назад +2

    Always glad to see the channel post a video. Love your work.
    Salutations from Belfast Northern Ireland 🇬🇧

  • @eronth
    @eronth 29 дней назад

    The 2k points is a neat way to make a simple fix, but I think most people want to see a devastating titan rather than the one that's shown here.