Drum Teacher Reacts to Meg White - The White Stripes - Hardest Button to Button - Episode 47

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
  • #KeepPracticingUntilItsEasy #regaltip #makesdrumsmusicalagain
    Steve's analysis, initial reactions and hot takes of Meg White of The White Stripes playing "The Hardest Button to Button"
    If you'd like to support the channel you can donate here:
    / junkdrummertv
    PayPal.me/junkd...
    Please check out my Merch Store
    teespring.com/...
    Original Video - • The white stripes - Ha...
    This song is the copyrighted property of it's owner(s).
    Fair use allows repurposing content for educational, critical, and commentative purposes used in accordance with US Copyright Law 17 U.S.C. Section 107 "Fair Use" is allowed for the purposes of criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, and or research and is not an infringement of copyright.

Комментарии • 584

  • @jetsamperes5762
    @jetsamperes5762 4 года назад +506

    1. Meg White had anxiety disorder - yet still played live in a two piece rock band in front of 100,000 festival goers - a few hundred times.
    2. Without Meg White there would be no Jack White. He'd be John or Jack Gillis
    3. He put her kit to his side - not behind him.
    4. They didn't use set lists.
    5. Jimmy the Exploder; The very first note of their very first album is her drums.
    6. Their on stage chemistry was undeniable.
    7. She was exactly the drummer that band needed. Steve's absolutely right. Anything more would be overkill. Jack's solo stuff proves that point. He wanted raw and she did her job with no formal training.

    • @pleasmarryme
      @pleasmarryme 4 года назад +21

      As a somewhat working musician ive found that most "pro" players or "virtuoso" are really hard to work with, maybe just my experience, usually the guy that can keep a solid beat, or consistant strumming and tone is all you need

    • @NoMoreBsPlease
      @NoMoreBsPlease 4 года назад +5

      Jack wouldn't have made it with clearly better drummer? LMAO 😂 Sure, whatever you say...

    • @ryaaa
      @ryaaa 4 года назад +9

      No More BS Please they meant his name. He took her surname... you really twisted this one

    • @True_Christian
      @True_Christian 4 года назад +30

      ​@@NoMoreBsPlease Jack *certainly wouldn't* have become a world-famous superstar *if not for* Meg. He 100% *needed* his White Stripes marketing gimmick in order to rise to that level, and Meg was a *an essential core part* of that. Without her, then he'd *still* be a nobody as now in 2020.

    • @jmbrosendo
      @jmbrosendo 4 года назад +8

      I was about to write a reply but you nailed it. In the end it is how good they sound, and together the sounded great.

  • @tdawggonzo88
    @tdawggonzo88 4 года назад +222

    I wanted to request Meg White but was so scared of being trashed so I’m so glad to see this!!!!!

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +33

      She's amazing. And I think you're gonna love this video.

    • @prs149
      @prs149 4 года назад +16

      Sometimes you just need to give the haters the old middle finger

    • @scottgardner2985
      @scottgardner2985 2 года назад +3

      Yeah f the haters. Meg is cool as f. How do people expect her to play. John Bonham would not sound right in the white stripes.

    • @JoneyJefe
      @JoneyJefe Год назад +5

      Don’t ever be scared of being trashed for loving a musician that you love

  • @EightiesTV
    @EightiesTV 4 года назад +298

    *She got the gig*
    Before you come down on her, ask yourself... Did you get the gig?

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +32

      Comment of the day

    • @jairogarcia7539
      @jairogarcia7539 4 года назад +32

      I don’t think anybody cares about any of that. You don’t have to be a fan. She’s part of music history...I don’t think anybody knows your name

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +11

      @@jairogarcia7539 sick burn!

    • @NoMoreBsPlease
      @NoMoreBsPlease 4 года назад +5

      From nepotism! Jesus the cherry picking excuses!

    • @NoMoreBsPlease
      @NoMoreBsPlease 4 года назад

      @@jairogarcia7539 That's why Fanboys are considered morons!

  • @waylonbedlam792
    @waylonbedlam792 4 года назад +221

    She was everything she needed to be for that band. Nothing more, nothing less.

    • @speluniarz-2045
      @speluniarz-2045 4 года назад +3

      Preach!

    • @robertbrooks01
      @robertbrooks01 4 года назад +8

      Dave Grohl said the same thing about her. Much respect.

    • @SpongeBath_ShitPants
      @SpongeBath_ShitPants 3 года назад +2

      She was basically a modern-day Ringo.

    • @eldoabrahamson
      @eldoabrahamson 3 года назад +2

      She was also all she could be for that band, and nothing more.

    • @RadoDani
      @RadoDani Год назад

      @@SpongeBath_ShitPants Ringo was an innovator, Meg wasn’t.

  • @spartacus2296
    @spartacus2296 3 года назад +37

    Meg White is a badass man, nobody’s bass drum sounds like hers, it thumps you in the chest. She has her own unique primitive style which, as you say, gets knocked by the prog/jazz, coffee sipping, 13/8 playing RUclipsrs. I’m glad you shone some positive light on her :)

  • @Ash-jq7qc
    @Ash-jq7qc 4 года назад +57

    She always gets so much shit and it makes me so happy to finally see people who recognize her value to this band

    • @bahnadumitru.5864
      @bahnadumitru.5864 Год назад

      What else to be expected from people who are full of shit themselves...

  • @otakuholly8885
    @otakuholly8885 3 года назад +27

    As a drummer who cannot follow the human octopus wheels within wheels of most cerebral drummers, Meg White reminds me that I can create music that is powerful, while living within my limits. I cannot say enough, Meg White is my drummer hero. She is the only drummer i have ever heard with her unique primal quality, as a introvert who has plenty of issues, she is capable of always stirring me.

    • @kikeenriquez4436
      @kikeenriquez4436 Год назад +1

      Not a fan of the white stripes, not a hater either just don’t listen to them. But the simplicity/ power of the drumming kinda reminds me of U2’s drummer. Intentional drumming for the song. Would you agree?

  • @oneblood7411
    @oneblood7411 4 года назад +55

    I guarantee Meg White's roadies loved her! Or at the very least loading/unloading her minimalist drum kit. Lol. Seriously I never understood why she caught flack, She's competent, keeps tempo, and most importantly perfectly fits the pure raw energy that The White Stripes had at the time. Thanks for posting.

    • @scottrap
      @scottrap Год назад

      Could you picture Meg sitting behind Alex Van Halen‘s drum kit?? 🤣

  • @yulmp2
    @yulmp2 2 года назад +4

    Saw them live once. It was the best show I’ve ever seen. It was like the heat from the sun was coming off the stage. My future wife and me sloshing around in the front of GA.

  • @Glopez12345678910
    @Glopez12345678910 3 года назад +16

    Jack started as a drummer and taught meg just enough to keep time and by doing that they reinvented the wheel. The white stripes will forever be my favorite band. Meg's style is so simple but so integral to the sound. They just played the blues to a bunch of people that didn't know it was the blues and the drums were a huge part of that

    • @TheDUKEZ117
      @TheDUKEZ117 Год назад

      They are my favorite band too

  • @7TheBeAllAndEndAll7
    @7TheBeAllAndEndAll7 Год назад +7

    Great video - I love Meg's drumming. It's perfect for the band. It has a magic in it. Jack is a genius, and Meg it the perfect drumming mate for him!!! A perfect partnership. I agree with you absolutely. Thank you very much, I appreciate your excellent comments. I love the "feel" her drumming gives me. It actually brings me to tears. I agree - PRIMITIVE DRUMMING. That's it. It connects with your soul, and your heart. Perfectly said. Perfectly. And this is a fantastic song. It moves me too. Yes, it is perfect.

  • @mmartinisgreat
    @mmartinisgreat 4 года назад +115

    "Meg sucks" say people that have never sold an album or written a cool piece of music.

    • @eldoabrahamson
      @eldoabrahamson 3 года назад +2

      You're conflating monetization with quality. As far as a "cool piece of music" goes, well, that's for a listener's taste to determine, which is completely malleable criteria.

  • @wingracer1614
    @wingracer1614 4 года назад +51

    Love the love for Meg. I feel the same way about her as a drummer as I do about Kurt Cobain as a guitarist. Do they play like SRV or Danny Carey? Hell no but it wasn't how well they played, it was WHAT they played. Plus in the case of Meg, there was definitely a musical connection between her and Jack. It just worked.

  • @laika1660
    @laika1660 2 года назад +6

    I saw them in Atlanta during what was close to their last tour. I liked them a lot before I saw them but you would not believe the sheer force of them together onstage. I couldn't believe just two people could create such a feeling. Jack did go to the front to sing to the crowd at times but spent most of his time singing to/at Meg. Everyone in the crowd was going wild. They were a magical duo and I know, having seen them, that Meg WAS an equal force in the music they gave us. Good reaction and true.

  • @sydhamelin1265
    @sydhamelin1265 4 года назад +55

    Finding a musician that doesn't feel the need to play showy, that's something to hold onto.

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад +1

      that is one way to look at it. i would say that she does not contribute much to the music.

    • @seb5542
      @seb5542 4 года назад +1

      I think " feel the need to" is the wrong word here she wasn't very technically proficient and so she couldn't really.

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад

      @paula the band would sound better with a real drummer. he picked her because he wanted the spotlight. she does not have the talent to do anything interesting on the drums. no legitimate drummer could ever stand to play in such a basic way. it is too boring. it does nothing for the music. she just cant play any better. meg could have played for a band like the cars too. and they still would have good. but i think their drummer would always lend a lot more to the music than meg would have. I like the white stripes. just dont think she is a good drummer. she certainly has never shown it one time. where is the proof that she can play?

    • @phishcatt
      @phishcatt 4 года назад +1

      @@Hollingsworth2781 Tf are you smoking? Where is proof she can play?? Where is proof she can't?

  • @victoria5885
    @victoria5885 Год назад +2

    All the love to Meg. She is amazing!

  • @TeaRanosaur
    @TeaRanosaur 4 года назад +73

    I learned about Jack White through the Raconteurs first, so to this day that is my favorite Jack White band, but I will say this about Meg White: Meg White was by far the best musical choice of Jack White's career. She cuts to the point on every song and always plays something fun. If you listen to Jack White's solo work, you notice pretty quickly that he likes to fill in space with every idea that comes into his head. The White Stripes were great because Meg kept that from happening and kept the songs the way they needed to be.
    That said, I saw the Raconteurs live last year on Patrick Keeler's Birthday (they were great), so even though I'm not a drummer I'm really looking forward to seeing the video that explores his style as well.

  • @johnforjustice2350
    @johnforjustice2350 4 года назад +19

    In anything at all, perfection is finally attained not when there is no longer anything to add, but when there is no longer anything to take away, when a body has been stripped down to its nakedness.

  • @mrwormmyone
    @mrwormmyone 4 года назад +50

    I got the privilege of seeing Meg play, in a tiny venue, at one of their concerts. Not only is she an amazing drummer, but the raw chemistry she had with Jack was breathtaking. Like you said, I'll never forget it.

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад +3

      a 12 year could play with more creativity.

    • @Slappysan
      @Slappysan 4 года назад +15

      @@Hollingsworth2781 How many comments are you going to leave? Nothing should bother you THAT much. SMH

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад +2

      @@calypsodrumsWhy is it is childish to thing someone is not a great musician? There are many people in many field who are not talented. And some of them still make a lot of money. I am 54 and have graduate degrees. I am a mediocre drummer. But yes, I feel that I am better than meg. Any pop or rock drummer in a legit band can do what she does and a whole lot more. I stated my reasons. Read my other posts. Many people on here are angry. I am not. I like the white stripes. I just dont think she has very much genetic talent. Why? She has never showed it once. She has never done anything unique on the drums. She was in the band because Jack was her husband. Jack wanted the spotlight. And he got it. But I just think jack would have been complimented more with a more prolific drummer. That is all. My statements are not that outrageous.

    • @susanmaggiora4800
      @susanmaggiora4800 4 года назад +6

      HollingsworthGroup Jack has played with plenty of other drummers. He still went back to play with Meg & would’ve continued had she not decided to stop. She has a certain lackadaisical style which is actually very difficult to pull of well, or at all. Listen to other drummers play White Stripes songs. It’s different. You can tell that it’s missing that ‘thing’ that Meg brought to the song. That’s a special gift. I also don’t think she’s the greatest drummer in the world, but she’s certainly very competent. Plus, I’m not the one leaving snarky messages all over the place. Why are you doing that? Think hard about it. I’d say it’s jealousy. But regardless, it’s YOUR problem, don’t force us all to deal with your insecurities, my guy...

    • @robertbrooks01
      @robertbrooks01 4 года назад +4

      Chemistry is probably better than everyone being great. The sum of the whole can is greater than its parts (well Jack White is pretty great).
      Watching this channel helped me learn that while good drumming is awesome, the best drummers tend to play what the song needs.

  • @ivkafox369
    @ivkafox369 11 месяцев назад +3

    Thank you, Sir for appreciating Meg White, especially as a drum teacher yourself. I've seen so many drummers roll their eyes at the mention of Meg White's name and it always made me feel a certain way. I'll never forget her drums opening up their self titled album on Jimmy The Exploder. Suddenly rock and roll made total sense to me as a young girl. It also made an instrument like the drums which had seemed so inaccessible and boys only before feel inviting and empowering to the child in me who had always loved banging on things with sticks. Meg does divide people. Mostly into wizards and muggles. You either see the magic or you don't. I think she especially appeals to people who love the purity and rawness of music, which is the thing that no amount of technical skill can conjure. I've seen a great many technically brilliant musicians play, who've made me fee nothing. But Meg bangs on the skins and Jack plays a couple chords and my heart is moved. Go figure.

  • @user-ox5kh3fy8g
    @user-ox5kh3fy8g 4 года назад +37

    It’s like judging a writer based on how proficiently he/ she types....

  • @jarellano4395
    @jarellano4395 4 года назад +120

    Meg gets alot of gruff but she's got excellent rhythm. She doesnt get fancy because the style doesn't call for it.

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад +3

      she could play a lot with a lot more sstyle if she knew how to. she plays almost the same way on every song. dumbest idea i have seen. but yes, her timing is decent.

    • @DeathToTheDictators
      @DeathToTheDictators 4 года назад +23

      @@Hollingsworth2781 "she could play a lot with a lot more sstyle if she knew how to" - you don't get what the Stripes were about....Jack called his label 'Third Man' for a few reasons (he's a Catholic), but mostly because the idea behind them was always 'three'....three verses and chorus', three colours, three instruments (including vocal), etc....he intentionally wanted to limit and box the artistry of the band, because Jack knows that (VERY often in music/art) 'less is more'. Therefor she was PERFECT for this band.
      Also, they NEVER had a set list, yet they would often switch songs MID song, and then double back to the original song (like a song within a song) and she would ALWAYS intuitively know when/how to switch to the other song (AND back again), UNPLANNED.
      Think of it this way....i'm a big fan of both Yes and Nirvana...technically, Yes is a WAY more skilled band than Nirvana...but who's the better band? Who was by FAR the bigger band (and at one point the biggest band in the world)? Tom Petty once said (paraphrasing) "all the best songs in the world have just 3 or 4 chords"....you need to think of Meg in that sense.

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад +3

      @@DeathToTheDictators I know all about the white stripes. I just don't think she has any talent. I am all for simplicity. I love the early beatles music, elvis and many more. Those musicians are all a lot better than meg. Rock music can be simplistic. It does not have to sound like rush, dream theater, yes etc. I love straight pop music. But pretty much all the drummers in normal pop music are are talented than meg is. And even if meg was a good fit for jack's playing, it doesn't make her a good drummer. She is not. Almost all drummers think that she is not good player. Everyone here is probably sticking up for her because they are fans of the white stripes. That makes it hard to objective And I do believe that there are many drummers that would have helped the white stripes sound better. I know you are saying about yes vs. nirvana. Totally different argument. Even though nirvana played simple chords, every person in that band was a lot more creative than meg. And both yes and the nirvana drummers are far superior to meg. She has even admitted that she can't do too much on the drums. I like a lot about the white stripes, but her drumming skills are lacking. Besides a few stripes fans, the rest of the world shares this opinion. Do you you really she is a drummer? junk drummer is right, I need to stop responding as the argument going nowhere.

    • @DeathToTheDictators
      @DeathToTheDictators 4 года назад +12

      @@Hollingsworth2781 "I just don't think she has any talent." - dude, she's just as good as ANY simpler 'just keep time' drummer, but even more so, because she pretty much embraced her 'lack of skill'. That in itself IS a talent (know your role, and perform at your best in said role, no matter how 'important)'.
      You honestly think the Stripes would've been better/bigger with another drummer? They would've been the Black Keys, which are really good, but in the minor leagues (as far as 'song writing that hits/touches BILLIONS') as compared to the Stripes, which are MAJOR league WORLD WIDE stars (EVERY sports stadium plays Seven Nation Army). LESS IS (at least often, though not always) MORE.

    • @przemekdude
      @przemekdude 4 года назад +14

      People who critcize Meg keep forgetting that Jack's guitar on most Stripes song is just as simplistic and stripped down as her drumming, yet there's no discussion whether or not he's a great guitarist

  • @tinatingabeskiria3360
    @tinatingabeskiria3360 Год назад +22

    Thank you! This video moved me to tears. Everything seems so shallow nowadays, as if the real art was sucked out from this world. True artists are mocked by nobodies and Meg White is definitely a legend! A quiet girl who speaks, shouts even, through her art medium.

  • @strawberryjam119
    @strawberryjam119 Год назад +2

    I just watched this! I appreciate you showing, Meg, some love! I miss, The White Stripes, they were freaking awesome, and, Meg, helped make them what they were!

  • @ajrob77
    @ajrob77 4 года назад +11

    One of the main goals of music is to make living creatures FEEL something just by shoving the right vibrations into our ear holes.
    I had to stand up and applaud after watching this 🙌🏻👏🏼

  • @cmh111671
    @cmh111671 4 года назад +48

    Most drummers in her place try to play the crowd, she just played the drums and got the crowd as a side effect.

  • @michaelhand4246
    @michaelhand4246 4 года назад +1

    I managed to see the White Stripes front row in Stone Mountain Georgia in 2003. It was surreal. And it was a free concert! the whole field was packed.

  • @FGLGF3rd4th
    @FGLGF3rd4th 4 года назад +8

    Steve's best video yet. It's easy to forget that the essence of musicality is connecting with other humans.

  • @vivianpurplemess
    @vivianpurplemess 3 года назад +6

    I love Meg's simple , natural, raw and emotional drumming. I prefer it that way for garage rock . Her minimalistic emotional drumming fits so well with Jack's wild guitar chords. They are yin and yang , fulfilling each other in the best way possible. LOve this duo

  • @bwestby1
    @bwestby1 4 года назад +16

    Far out Prog Jazz snobs lmao. That’s me but I laughed and I respect meg white.

  • @BathedInMilk
    @BathedInMilk 4 года назад +41

    "She's one half of the White Stripes"
    She is and always will be one of the all time great rock drummers. Keyboard warriors, to put it mildly, are not. Well done for shouting her out dude. Meg's the best.

  • @markgarber3465
    @markgarber3465 4 года назад +12

    Love The White Stripes...At the end of the day it's still a two person band that could bring the house down.

  • @mycatisabastard2361
    @mycatisabastard2361 2 года назад +1

    She's rock solid and that's always awesome to see and what she needed to be.

  • @ghadrackpotato960
    @ghadrackpotato960 4 года назад +12

    Lol, love it.
    There is also something special about a great two piece band that can generate big noise. Local H back in the day gave me the same shiver down my spine. (Kinda still does) that much awesome noise outta two people is #ucking impressive.
    You you know what else she did that the cry babies who hate on her didn't do? Played on stage and on records that millions, and millions of people have listened to and love and will love for eternity. Be a cry baby all you want when Meg croaks, she's got that experience you never will have. Hate on cry babies.

  • @EricHitsDrums
    @EricHitsDrums 4 года назад +48

    Hey, Meg White can hold a steady tempo, Lars Ulrich can't say that! BTW, the beard it's looking strong!

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +5

      Thanks! And that might be the comment of the day.

    • @EricHitsDrums
      @EricHitsDrums 4 года назад +1

      Well bearded drummers need to look out for each other!

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад +2

      lars is a thousand times better than than meg.

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +5

      @@Hollingsworth2781 and?

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад +1

      @@JunkdrummerTV the other poster commented that meg can hold a steady beat and lars ulrich cannot. that is a ridiculous statement and simply not true. lars is better than everything by a wide margin compared to meg white. I like the white stripes. but as a drummer, i cant say anything good about her skills. she was jacks wife and is in the band because jack wants all the attention.

  • @nealwesco7465
    @nealwesco7465 4 года назад +2

    One of the things so many musicians forget is you don't need to be the best at everything. You only need to be the best at whatever the song you are playing calls for

  • @markcerrone5147
    @markcerrone5147 Год назад +1

    You are so right on with Meg White. Even though it’s 20 years old I still listen to the album Elephant. White Stripes at their best.

  • @siobhanfagan5802
    @siobhanfagan5802 2 года назад

    Brilliant. All three of you. Thanks man.

  • @rontoriussmith6047
    @rontoriussmith6047 4 года назад +3

    Honestly her style is timeless in my opinion

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +3

      Exactly

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад +1

      i would cal it monotonous, not timeless

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +1

      @@Hollingsworth2781 it looks like you're proving the point of my video dear sir, now that you've responded to 5 different comments in the pejorative. I'd suggest maybe Tinder or Grindr. You know. No judgement here.

    • @rontoriussmith6047
      @rontoriussmith6047 4 года назад

      @@Hollingsworth2781 you are entitled to your own opinion

    • @Hollingsworth2781
      @Hollingsworth2781 4 года назад

      @@JunkdrummerTV why? you only want opinions that are the same as yours? isn't this channel about sharing their opinions. almost all drummers and musicians think meg is bad. you can have your opinion and so can i. I do not think is a professional caliber drummer. if you think she is, that is fine too. nothing personal. just an opinion.

  • @ShayneMcGuire_music
    @ShayneMcGuire_music 4 года назад +5

    Love this vid man! I’ve been defending Meg forever now. Solid drummer. She created that sound they had. And people say her beats are easy, well most are BUT the discipline is takes to steadily keep time like that (she does do some weird timing things a lot too) just proves how professional she is! Songs like Rag and Bone really show her stuff

  • @bigrivermedia762
    @bigrivermedia762 4 года назад +1

    Thanks for the shoutout my man! We both have always known Meg rules!!! Play what the song needs and a not a fucking thing more.

  • @kamaliancirranoush1916
    @kamaliancirranoush1916 4 года назад +25

    The best drummers know how to shape the negative space between beats, not just play a beat. Kinda like tatting lace, the holes are just as much a part of the design as the yarn- what is not played is equally important as what is played. Great video!

    • @angelea2184
      @angelea2184 2 года назад

      Thanks! I just posted above, with elaborations, your statement.

  • @bluecalix
    @bluecalix Год назад +1

    This is a great reminder considering the recent hot takes.

  • @elwray3506
    @elwray3506 2 года назад +1

    You really said it all, man. I never really cared about technical prowess, but I sure do care about musical prowess.

  • @tracypaxton1054
    @tracypaxton1054 3 года назад +4

    Yes, I think her drumming is primal and that's what they're songs need.

  • @hal-c
    @hal-c Год назад +2

    The first thing I do before watching a drumming video is check if the channel has covered Meg White and what their take is. If they do anything but praise her musical prowess I can't trust anything else they say. The White Stripes was the best show I've ever experienced. She is a pro through and through.
    "Meg White is the shit" ... subscribed

  • @jspanos500
    @jspanos500 4 года назад +4

    Thank you for making this video! Meg's drumming is ragged AF* and it fits The White Stripes like stars in the night sky. Her drumming is a breath of fresh air.
    *ragged like Crazy Horse

  • @_Ben_Draws_-xg8wi
    @_Ben_Draws_-xg8wi 8 месяцев назад

    As someone who’s learning how to play the drums Meg White is my biggest inspirations when it comes to drumming as she always reminds me that you don’t need to be the very best and know everything to make good music

  • @stephenphilip5294
    @stephenphilip5294 4 года назад +2

    The best part of meg white Is that she isn’t a trained drummer, her drumming is emotional not over run by focus on rudiments and rhythm

  • @10bunks12
    @10bunks12 Год назад +1

    Always loved Meg. And the white stripes. I don’t understand all the hate that get thrown her way. They gave us 6 flawless albums. Meg was fantastic. Alway just kicked out that thunderous beat. And Jack did his thing. Meg was the most rock star going. She didn’t even want to do it. Got famous then said F it I’m done and just disappeared. That’s Rock and roll.

  • @ssga_tgbuddy3082
    @ssga_tgbuddy3082 3 года назад

    Some of the greatest artists that move people had no formal training.
    I can proudly say I got to see the White Stripes live in Atlanta. The rawness of the White Stripes was the awe.

  • @fishybob9059
    @fishybob9059 7 месяцев назад

    As a 50 year old just about to start his drum journey Meg White is THE inspiration. F*** all the RUclips skills, I want the visceral soul of Megs sticks

  • @kimberlysullivan7554
    @kimberlysullivan7554 Год назад +1

    Meg White is incredible!

  • @Panellada22
    @Panellada22 Год назад +1

    I love her drumming. It's dirty and garage as fuck. Isn't that why The White Stripes are so liked?

  • @shermanmi
    @shermanmi 4 года назад +2

    I love Meg so much and I hope she is living happily and quietly somewhere

  • @ricorofficial
    @ricorofficial 4 года назад

    The white stripes are truly inspiring!!! as a drummer i agree that meg white is a legend! this guy is right on

  • @matt09ward
    @matt09ward 4 года назад +3

    Shes very underrated. its not easy to play what she does. most drummers wouldn't be able to control themselves the way she does. the beats are simple but they are simple by design. shes also extremely locked in with jack, not locked in with time/click but with jack which gives the music a sense of breath and life.

    • @matt09ward
      @matt09ward 4 года назад

      To illustrate her control. just look at what jack does from live performance to performance. he's always adding in little licks and riffs to the main riff. licks and riffs that to be honest dont really serve the song and most of the time makes it worse. as a musician of any instrument it is very hard to stop yourself from doing that. she has that control.

  • @lesraconteurs6969
    @lesraconteurs6969 4 года назад +4

    Steve, I agree 100% !! My wife bought me a drum set last year.... I'm 49 and trying to learn. Quarantine got me practicing more and it is getting a bit easier. But every once in a while I put on headphones and try to drum along to Meg.... just enjoying it and trying to keep up. I'm probably not even hitting the right skins and cymbals.... but I'm having fun and smiling.
    Also..... how the F is BlackMath so fast !!

  • @w4dZ0o
    @w4dZ0o 2 года назад +10

    Her groove is not easy to play tho! It remained pure, it wasn't tainted by ego. It's all feel. One day I'll find the words that express what her drumming means to me.

  • @hankkauffmann7648
    @hankkauffmann7648 2 года назад +2

    Meg had the place jumping.
    Meg's playing was so approachable. I can't help but wonder how many people started to play the drums by following along with The White Stripes. Heck, I wish I knew about them when my kids still had their drum kit.

  • @guybezant9009
    @guybezant9009 4 года назад

    Glad to read the comments are just as positive and supportive as in the video. Saw White Stripes at Glastonbury '05 and will always remember it, had an amazing time and that's all that mattered.

  • @johnny5stacks60
    @johnny5stacks60 4 года назад +2

    I love Meg White and her contribution to the sound of her band. You have to recognize that sometimes it sounds like she has slight trouble with timing, but it’s part of what makes their music unique. If it’s deliberately a little off sync, then it’s genius. I love it. Thanks for the video.

  • @soulsgamer385
    @soulsgamer385 3 года назад

    Finally someone that understand music, vest review ever !!!

  • @speluniarz-2045
    @speluniarz-2045 4 года назад +1

    One of my drum idols.
    I absolutly love her so much, everything about her

  • @teranc8384
    @teranc8384 Год назад

    Love this! They were a epic duo and we would not have all this great content from a band without her and the way she complimented him. Always was and always will be one of my favorite bands, and even though its off the subject, the people saying Meg was not a great drummer are like the same people saying Tim Tebow was not a great football player, all you have to do is look at their accomplishments and it becomes painfully obvious they have nothing to prove to anyone.......because they already did!

  • @akw8372
    @akw8372 4 года назад +2

    You're speaking nothing but truth. Mucho Respect 🤙🏼

  • @paulamorris3138
    @paulamorris3138 Год назад

    Totally agree. Great band and hard hitting!! The combo of them and their art = genius and great!

    • @paulamorris3138
      @paulamorris3138 Год назад

      Even Taylor Hawkins said her simplicity was genius!

  • @angelea2184
    @angelea2184 2 года назад

    If you don't mind, I will repost what I just wrote on another channel regarding Meg White. "Here's the secret to Meg's drumming, this from a professional musician. As Artur Schnabel once said (paraphrased), "it is not the notes, but the silence between the notes that defines good playing." What I love about Meg's style is that she is so loose. She has not one bit of tension in her whole body while playing. I thought she would slide right off her drum stool at times. That is the secret to superior accompaniment. Her playing is super relaxed and provides perfect support to Jacks solo work. This may sound simple to our ears, however, it is not at all simple, and even the greatest drummers in the world have difficulty with this. Their music, in various ways is very stretchy. This requires of an accompanist extreme perception, along with remaining very tight against the soloists expressions, which can vary, ever so slightly, or greatly, depending on hw the soloist feels at the moment of playing each note and each phrase. A good accompanist is a gem, and should be well appreciated. As to the not funny "joke" about her replacing Neil Peart, I read him speaking on his technique and how he matured and learned over the years to advance. He said that one of the most important things he had to learn (late into his career) was to loosen up. He spoke of rebuilding his technique after being involved with another drummer that he admired. Meg had this mastered.

  • @buckesmalls
    @buckesmalls 4 года назад +1

    Undeniably raw.. Don't try and figure out why you like this just enjoy that you do.

  • @jasongairn
    @jasongairn 3 года назад +1

    Well said. No argument here. 100% agree.

  • @johncoleman3188
    @johncoleman3188 4 года назад +4

    It's like when you go to your first Slipknot show. All the anticts just click. You'll never forget it haha.

  • @garynumen13
    @garynumen13 4 года назад

    I have been to well over 100 concerts over 40+ years. The White Stripes rocked me as hard or harder than anyone else I have seen and I have seen some greats. Nuff said!

  • @cowetaok
    @cowetaok Год назад

    If most could play with the heart and feel that Meg White does they would one day maybe be the rock star she is.

  • @llywelyngruffydd8474
    @llywelyngruffydd8474 Год назад

    Her drumming was like a lot of garage or punk rock guitarists who had an amazing sound because they only knew one or two chords. They were creative within tighter confines and so what you got was rock that was stripped down to its most essential elements. That's what made it great.

  • @williamchapman9178
    @williamchapman9178 4 года назад +4

    You should check out their cover of Jolene if you haven't already seen it. The way she works with Jack on the build ups and fall backs throughout gives me goosebumps.

  • @DirkRadloff
    @DirkRadloff 3 года назад

    All true .. what many musicians don't realize: A unique style is more important than brilliant technique to stand out.

  • @mikmook4781
    @mikmook4781 3 года назад +1

    Very true. She might not be the most technically proficient drummer but her sound was perfect for the band. Hard to imagine The White Stripes without her.

  • @bruh4004
    @bruh4004 Год назад

    Love your reaction bro, and you are 100% right

  • @bobbysimpson5540
    @bobbysimpson5540 2 года назад

    One if not the Best Live show Ive seen. At the Fillmore Denver. It was electric and gave me goosebumps.

  • @PCMESS
    @PCMESS 4 года назад

    This band captures what being a band is all about. It's about making people feel something special, it's about creating a whole that is greater than the sum of its parts. To anyone in the comments who like this band and hasnt seen this concert, do yourself a favor and watch it. Its so sick. 2003 was my favorite year of The White Stripes.

  • @WarrenLeggatt
    @WarrenLeggatt 4 года назад

    Meg is to the White Stripes what Kim Deal was to the Pixies. No fancy stuff added, just played what was needed when it was needed and that is what made it gold :)

  • @cheveronactionstripe5005
    @cheveronactionstripe5005 4 года назад

    Spot bloody on !

  • @AmaraNott
    @AmaraNott 4 года назад +12

    1 minute and 45 seconds of slaying everyone haha. Queen didn't make "We will rock you" to please drumheads either, it's another example.
    With that said, I was never the biggest fan of the White Stripes so I never gave her that much attention.

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +1

      Haha yeaaahhhh. I wanted to start some shit.

    • @AmaraNott
      @AmaraNott 4 года назад

      @@JunkdrummerTV "sipping some scotch and waiting for the Offended&Entitled bus to arrive"

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад

      Oh they're on their way. Hell I'm currently in a text battle with an old bass player over it Haha.

    • @AmaraNott
      @AmaraNott 4 года назад

      @@JunkdrummerTV I bet he finds Lars transcendent

    • @JunkdrummerTV
      @JunkdrummerTV  4 года назад +2

      Ugh no worse. Jazz snob

  • @MattGabrielRI
    @MattGabrielRI Год назад

    Bear in mind this a three piece band with two of the pieces being the same virtuoso guitarist and vocalist. The third piece, she put the BOOM in the room, and she makes it seem like there’s an orchestra on stage, she’s that into what’s going on with her band as a whole. Her band was one other dude. His band was one other Meg radioedit White.

  • @babyshambler
    @babyshambler 4 года назад +2

    Meg's drumming is perfect in every song they ever recorded.

  • @Sean-hi5ec
    @Sean-hi5ec 3 года назад

    Hey,
    Just stumbled on this video. I don't comment much, but....man....you just get it. They were the right band at the right time. Meg was a primative drummer and Jack used Kay and Gretch guitars from Sears.
    Thank you for your insight.

  • @mattyc.9332
    @mattyc.9332 4 года назад +2

    Love it! Not all drummers go nuts on the skins. Look at Ringo Starr, he played for the song in his Beatles work. Not flashy, but his parts always fit the songs perfectly....🤘

  • @timknight2737
    @timknight2737 2 года назад

    Top 100 drummers of all time!

  • @AlexColberg
    @AlexColberg 4 года назад +2

    To be critical of Meg White is an admission that I don't get laid enough? In that case, I love her! PS - Anyone who doesn't like Steve of Junkdrummer TV's RUclips videos doesn't get laid enough.

  • @ratty860997
    @ratty860997 4 года назад +1

    I saw them at the Razmatazz in Barcelona about 15...? Years ago. One of the best gigs I’ve ever been to. We saw the tickets cheap on eBay and got them and then booked at cheap flight and stayed in a hostel. Also one of the sweatiest gigs I’ve been to aswell.

  • @x2PUNKx
    @x2PUNKx Год назад

    Just seeing this but I love the video and your professional description of how good and essential to THAT band she was. The songs they were soooo good and yes one of the best bands of the last 25 years. I love garage sound and they make it

  • @simplyavery3
    @simplyavery3 4 года назад +4

    Thank you for this review! Meg deserves more credit but never gets it, it seems.

  • @stephene9368
    @stephene9368 4 года назад

    Spot on with every word. The White Stripes weren’t about flash and technique. They were about raw energy. Emotion. Most of The greatest songs ever written were simple. The songs you hum after hearing once are simple. The more your brain has to work to understand the song the longer it takes to connect. The more you have to deconstruct to understand the less impactful it is. Rock should connect at a primal level not cerebral. A simple drum kit making thousands of people jump like that? That’s rock and roll.

  • @tcianidrico
    @tcianidrico 2 года назад

    What an awesome video! Thanks for that, great to know that Meg has fans in drums community, she deserves so much!

  • @jev2damaximum934
    @jev2damaximum934 4 года назад

    Meg White is going to be in the Rock N' Roll Hall of Fame. And that's all there is to it.

  • @aprildrummond8457
    @aprildrummond8457 4 года назад

    I am blessed to have gotten to see them at sloss furnace on my birthday in 2007. Best experience ever and Meg's presence that night was undeniably magnificent

  • @kamaliancirranoush1916
    @kamaliancirranoush1916 4 года назад +9

    You say it better than me, the visceral feel and connection is palpable with this band. I always just say they’re showing their guts lol

  • @quintonstanley2485
    @quintonstanley2485 Год назад +1

    All Hail Meg!! (3-17-23)

  • @sherripettigrew
    @sherripettigrew 3 года назад

    Yep I agree with everything you said 100%.

  • @vrjustin82
    @vrjustin82 3 года назад +1

    My favorite part of her drumming, is the fact she's the pulse of the band and they turn that shit up loud live.
    She's got good bounce.