iPad Pro Keyboard Showdown: Magic Keyboard vs NEW Logitech Combo Touch
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
- Check out my productivity course for those in the Apple ecosystem who want to get more done in less time with less burnout: bit.ly/3YkA4Aq
My wallpaper packs: www.aiartwalls...
Paperlike: paperlike.com/...
DailyTekk wallpaper packs: bit.ly/dtwllppr
Jasper (AI writing assistant): bit.ly/jasperd...
When it comes to iPad Pro keyboards, these 2 are probably most people's top picks. This isn't the same comparison as it has been in the past, however, as the Combo Touch got some much needed upgrades this year!
DailyTekk wallpaper packs: bit.ly/dtwllppr
I made a video on whether the OLD Magic Keyboard fits the NEW iPad Pro: • Tested: NEW iPad Pro W...
Check Magic Keyboard price: geni.us/XlkAM9
Check Combo Touch price: geni.us/DLBn9
🎧 HEY, IT’S CHRIS PODCAST - heyitschris.tr...
My podcast is a weekly discussion of Apple and tech lifestyle topics. New episodes every Friday!
🍩 DAILYTEKK CLIPS CHANNEL - bit.ly/2GoktKR
Get snack-sized video clips from the main channel and the podcast!
👋🏻 SOCIAL
Twitter: / dailytekk
Instagram: / dailytekk
🌊 APPLE MUSIC PLAYLIST - apple.co/2JnuMQu
Catch This Waaaave is a playlist of some of my latest music discoveries on Apple Music.
☕️ Wanna say thanks? www.buymeacoff...
FTC: As an Amazon Associate DailyTekk earns from qualifying purchases using links on this channel and across the web. Where possible, DailyTekk uses affiliate links in order to be compensated for our recommendations.
To be fair, Bearing in mind that they rank the iPad as a laptop replacement, it’s almost criminal that they don’t put the function keys on the Apple keyboard
I understand that it can suck, but to be honest it’s not something that I really see as a deal breaker. Don’t get me wrong, it would be nice if they were there, but I’ve learned to live without them.
Deal breaker for me is that after few years of magic keyboard , they couldn’t even try to make a thin case compatible with magic keyboard. I don’t want a 1000-2000$ ipad pro totally naked. Don’t ever mention some crap third party case like pitaka or switcheasy with cheap plastic quality
@@mikelo9006 I know what you’re saying! That’s why I just got a Smart Keyboard case off Amazon (only $20), cut it in half, and stuck it in the front of my iPad carrying case to I can magnetically snap it onto the back of my iPad when I’m gaming handheld (I have large hands so the 12.9” isn’t too unwieldy for me), or writing on desk. Otherwise, I got a Dbrand skin for it, so it won’t scratch. The Magic Keyboard Case also has sheet metal in it, so that is the primary source of protection for the iPad.
Excellent point imo
They want use to still use the touch screen aspect of the iPad.
My jaw drop and completely sold me when you pulled the keyboard off in the combo touch
YO same 😂
It makes me go "i will DEFINITELY buy that one instead of the magic keyboard" 😂
@@Shaturnite so true especially for an art student like me and that lower prize mhmmm
It copies the design from windows surface
@@Jungkith honestly i went with the magic keyboard bc the lap use with the logitech was a dealbreaker to me. And removing the ipad from the case is super satisfying and easy with the magnets. Usb c pass thru is also great. But you really cant beat that logi price
I’ve just made the switch from the Apple Magic Keyboard to the Logitech Combo Touch for my new iPad Pro M1 11” and I’m really happy now!
Very honest review. Wobbly Magic Keyboard, no side protection, high price, no function keys but better looking, better usage, one more port. I would still go with Combo for the detached keyboard and better protection. iPad Pros ain't cheap.
That's so true.
Opinion
One thought on the „go-anywhere“ aspect. I think that really depends on your type of workflow, because as someone who uses the Pencil a lot, having to completely remove the iPad from the case to write on it and leaving it without protection is a real no-go for me, especially on trains or public transport. That thing is way to expensive for me to risk that.
Exactly what I thought, the protection is more important. Also it wouldn't be that enjoyable to write on a train or public transport with all the shake
EXACTLY! Took the words right from my fingers!
THIS is the reason I upgraded from the Logitech combo touch to the Magic Keyboard.
@@soculesewait… but the Magic Keyboard is the one that requires you to remove the iPad and leaves it completely unprotected, whereas with the Logitech you can just remove the keyboard and still have the iPad inside the case and protected.
@@soculese¿?
How about a video on how to use the ipad optimally as a teacher and as a student. Recommended apps, widgets, accessories and tools. Thanks bro.
It’s going to change depending on what you use. Like my district uses Google classroom, someone else might use Zoom. I mean he can make okie but it’s only going to benefit the people who are forced to use that platform.
i’m pretty sure other you tubers will have a better idea/video on that than him. he’s not either so i don’t recommend him making that video
This combo touch is definitely better than the old one and it's nice that it's now available for 12.9 inch but I have been noticing that the Logitech cases are increasing in price each version and the old ones don't reduce in price.
Pro functions that I can’t find reviewers talk about:
1) Spreadsheet - Copy pasting data between opened sheets, between Google Sheets and Excel. Running desktop class formulas.
2) GIS software - Maybe try ArcGIS online? Would be great if it could open a basic SHP file, and allow me to plot CSV coordinates, create grids, create hotspots.
What pro functions is this? Does it belong to the keyboard, or the iPad Pro?
The magic keyboard jiggles heavily because of the floating design, the combo touch doesn’t do that because it’s fully supported by the stand. Could be a deal breaker
Guess it depends how thunderous your typing style is…
@@a23oj28 interesting question 🤔
Mine doesn’t jiggle… but I am thinking about returning it because of the corner protection alone
You only have one viewing angle lol it's kinda frustrating
Not just that. But sometimes doing using magic keyboard to work on the bed and lap, it feels like the iPad Pro can flip over.
I honestly love the look of the magic keyboard more. They both could be much cheaper though
I’ve used the Logitech keyboard and it’s ok but I bought the magic keyboard and honestly, I like it a lot better. More sturdy and a more satisfying typing experience.
Agreed... everything Apple should be cheaper. I bought the logictech and it's solid.
@@lolosmith8446 that’s honestly what I’m doing right now got both on my order will return which one I don’t like or may just keep both and when I need to use one more note taking use the MK or if I need to use the pencil for notes use the CT.
They look raggy after a year of use unless you clean it. So many oily looking magic keyboards
Update: I actually got the Magic Keyboard as a gift a year ago, I love it! It’s well made, doesn’t look dirty, and it looks very nice
THE most extensive, in depth review I’ve seen so far about the comparison between Magic Keyboard and Logitech. Super useful.
I went for the magic keyboard instantly. I hated the lack of different screen angles the most. That just irritated me to no end, especially for a $350 purchase. So I starting looking at keyboard comparisons, including yours. I'm back to say that the combo touch was the one for me.
The screen angles you can have is superior. The function keys are great. The typing experience is on par with the magic keyboard. I like that it is still protected when not attached to the keyboard. Though the material is not AS premium as the magic keyboard, I don't have to worry about smudges at all. And should I need to attach devices, I have a couple of thunderbold docks I have around the house with power delivery, So I'm good.
Thanks for the review. This really answered what I was looking for. Like if I want to draw, on the Logitech, there’s an assurance that it’s still protected with the detachable case. Not so with the magic keyboard. I have made up my mind!
i've had the combo touch for 8 months now, the sides with the holes are now loosened and disfigured.
the case also traps heat big time, don't believe me? Compare using the ipad playing games with the case vs without the case. i have heard lithium ion battery don't like extreme temperatures, there goes your battery life span. The keyboard randomly does not work, you know what i mean if you have this product, imagine doing a powerpoint presentation in front of class and the case malfunctioned, how's that for a premium case.
everytime i play, i remove the ipad from the case, i'll rather buy the magic keyboard, believe me, this is a case you'll regret
The case is heavy, when you play with it while carrying it. it will put pressure on your wrist. notice it? do it for a year. prepare for De Quervain Tenosynovitis. you have been warned
Best comment bro, i faced the same issues
So when trying to decide between the combo touch and the Magic Keyboard, this was one of the videos I watched when trying to decide. I bought both keyboards, just because of how hard it was to make a decision.
I work in field sales and my iPad Pro 12.9 M2 is my work computer. Deciding on using an iPad Pro as my work computer was another decision process that resulted in trying and taking back both Chromebooks and PC’s. What I was really wanting was an asset that provides an awesome user experience but is also a productivity warrior. The iPad Pro 12.9 in end won the debate, as well as the Apple Magic Keyboard.
The Apple Magic Keyboard won with me because of the typing experience and trackpad. The TrackPad is not the biggest but it is very accurate and just works every time. I had found that when I was using the Combo touch, the TrackPad would out of the blue make random key presses and not follow my gestures. The typing was great, but the overall case for me added to much bulk and added to much weight to the device that when you work in field sales weight matters.
Using the AMK, I do wish there was function row, because on the 12.9 version of the AMK there is enough room for a function row. Great video as always and thanks for your insight.
An Edit to this comment:
I agree that the Combo Touch is not an all terrain keyboard case option for the iPad. When trying to use the Combo Touch in the lap, it just was not convenient due to the kickstand and length of the keyboard. However I did find that when using the Combo Touch while my legs were stretched out across an ottoman or propped up on the coffee table the Combo Touch was a delight to use with the iPad 12.9. I also did not realize how much I rely on the function row during my work flows. The convenience of the home button and media keys work great when going back and forth between apps. The Trackpad is not as precise as the one on the Magic Keybaord but the Combo Touch is bigger. I do use the Magic Mouse more when working for longer periods of time on the iPad because of the gesture compatibility. Between using the Combo Touch and Magic Keyboard it is more comfortable using the Combo Touch as the keyboard is slightly spaced out better. Lastly, I like the fact that when you are not needing the keyboard you can detach the iPad from the Keyboard and the iPad is still protected; which when paired with the Paper-like screen protector offers the best protection for using the iPad while on the go.
This product is phenomenal. It fits the 4th (2020) generation iPad Pro 12.9 which I have. It is a snug fit. I’m not sure why Logitech only included the 5th gen. But this works great if anyone is wondering. Great replacement for the magic keyboard if you’re on a budget. However the speakers don’t align . But overall . Perfect fit for the 4th Gen IPad Pro
This is what I was hoping to hear, thanks for this! Is there a particular way they don’t align? Maybe it could be compensated for in some manner…
@@johnmackay13 they are just slightly off center . I think it’s how they placed the 5th Gens speaker . Like one of the holes of the 4 speakers are too close to the bumper itself.. but its something I overlooked since the speakers are perfectly fine
AND to one of Chris’s last points, I can confirm that with the Paperlike installed, the older Magic Keyboard works without any issues (closing). It’s perfect.
I have paperlike with the magic keyboard plus the Pitaka Case so that when I take it out, the camera bump doesn't scratch.
Can confirm that even with both of these on, still no issues
For someone who is mainly wanting this for illustration purposes, the Logitech is looking pretty sweet. I like how it's more protective and overall more versatile. I was tossing up between the magic keyboard and the standard one, but this might be a winner.
Hello! I'm curious- did you end up buying either one? And if so, which was your favorite?
Thanks for the thorough overview. I was worried I might regret getting the cheaper keyboard, but now I know I made the right choice for me.
Also, I see the tablet wobbles constantly as you type with the Magic Keyboard. That would drive me crazy!
Combo touch is great!
The true deal killer is the price
Yep. I pay 160€ more for a better looking keyboard that has les protection and lacks multifunction keys...
The combo touch definetly wins
True. That’s exactly the reason I am think and rethink and rethink.... to buy. But that price though!!!!
@@LoveTech i would say buy both and test them a week or so and when you decided whih one you like more simply resend the one you dont like :)
Just coming back to confirm that the Logitech one is definitely worth it. Got it in today. ✌🏾
I just feel like the magic keyboard should have been improved. There are some major design flaws with the viewing angle and lack of protection, even having to take the ipad off in order to use it flat. I think both are sort of just sub-par sadly.
Right, it would be very nice if the keyboard had the same versatility as logitech (detachable keyboard, function keys, and wide variety of viewing angles.) That would be the perfect keyboard for me.
My new iPad Pro came today, also got the new magic keyboard and Apple Pencil, the Xdr display is incredible
Bro, from where do you play HDR content on the ipad pro to get the full advantage of XDR? Also while playing any HDR content, do you turn off true tone? Or change any settings?
Just the video I needed! Have the combo coming in the mail today, I use it for school and will be doing a lot of back and forth so I need protection!
How are you finding it?
@@dirty_diver love it! I have 0 issues other than the fact the fact it needs the stand out while typing, the magic keyboard is nice that it holds itself up but I’ll take the combo over the magic any day. The fact the keyboard comes off and it still functions as a regular case makes it great for casual use like in bed or on the couch watching videos or doing work that doesn’t require a lot of typing! I could go on about how great it is lol
@@LucaJames this might be a dumb question but, when you close it, is the keyboard lying directly against the screen? and if so, is that ever an issue with like smudging or dust?
@@comradeluffy haha I get what u mean! The keyboard does sit flush but the keys and indented so there’s no key marks on the actual screen when shut! Dust and stuff isn’t bad I tend to clean my screen a lot tho like every other day
7:57 was the breaking point for me. i’d much much rather have a keyboard that’s durable for being on the go - i’d definitely go crazy with the logitech although i was pretty much sold up until this point of the video. thank you for such a detailed & informative video - really really helpful !!
Actually I found that you can nudge that stand portion of the Logitech between your knees and it feels fine, comfortable, and you can type while it's on your lap.
I am using the logi combo touch right now and I have to say that the existence of almost frequent bugs on the trackpad is a huge deal breaker to me. And I’m returning it to buy a white Magic Keyboard. It happens multiple times a day, the cursor would suddenly move from one random place to another, or can’t tell if I’m pressing down or not (not sure if it’s because i enabled ‘’ tap to click’’). Although I really love the keyboard, it is REALLY nice. No bug at all with the keyboard, very responsive, never miss a key and no lag. But the trackpad, well unfortunately I can’t bear it. If it’s not for the trackpad I would love to keep it
i experience the same thing with the curser and im using magic keyboard though.. maybe it's the ipad
I've watched a couple reviews for IPad Pro keyboard cases between Magic, Brydge and Logictech already. For my uses, such editing and digital drawing, and for my needs, such as ergonomics and versatility, the Logictech is a winner for me here.
Great review. I tried both for several days too. Magic Keyboard won because of lap stability and lighter weight. Kick stand on Logitech just felt wonky to me and using it on your lap is not doable in IMO with the 12.9”.. LCT is really heavy. Function keys not a deal breaker since I mostly use volume control and occasional screen brightness; easier to adjust from on-screen control panel for me. Protection is enough with MKB since I mostly use at home at table or desk or In my lap.. I like screen closer since I use pad gestures at lot. There is a subtle but better typing and trackpad experience on MKB. There was a slight muffling of sound too with LCT with more bass, but some might like it. I liked the texture of the LCT.and hand rest slightly better on LGT too but doesn’t seem to bother me since MKB is so thin. I also like the white MKB because I can see it better in all light. Taking the keyboard off and on was just awkward and when carrying LCT keyboard open did come off on me. MKB easier to open. Smaller footprint on MKB is convenient too. As an easel I just like I-Pad flat better and the LGT just did not seem stable enough. Some have said flip the MKB to use as easel but this is not stable either. The charging USB-c on left side fits where my charger is and less stress on cable and port when flat rather than hanging.
In the end LCT is better protection if you need it, but that and the function keys are the only reason to buy, except the price difference. Apple once again has a solid here folks.
I’ve been trying to find a video like this! Thank you 😄
I get mine on Sunday… Ready
Really? Mine is saying the end of June. I hope it doesn't really take that long.
Mine is saying mid June , really can’t wait to get it
I just bought an iPad Pro and I was dead set on buying the Magic Keyboard. However, the store that I went to had the Combo Touch on stock, so for some reason, I decided to buy it last minute instead. I do not regret it at all. I thought that it would be less immersive because the tablet was not floating, but I don’t feel it. I also have more confidence when using and transporting the iPad because of the case. It also does not feel bulky or heavier than the magic keyboard. What I appreciate the most though is that the keyboard is detachable and that there’s a kickstand so I can use it in many orientations without the keyboard. I don’t regret getting this great product while saving money!
I’m going for the Logitech! Thx for the good review
I have the Logitech Combo Touch Case and it's an incredibly efficient purchase. I highly recommend it! ☺
Getting my Combo Touch with my iPad Pro today, excited to try it out
How is it?
@@gdhyphen797 using it right now and I’m really liking it. The typing experience is good and the trackpad works incredibly well. I’m coming from an 2018 11” iPad Pro so I’m just trying to get use to the larger 12.9” size. I wish the case did something similar to Zugu case with the Apple Pencil so when it’s not attached the iPad is still protected in that area, plus having a place to store the pencil so it doesn’t get lost. Other than that it’s a really solid option and for $120 less than the Magic Keyboard and it’s an actual case where the keyboard detaches, I think it’s a pretty solid buy.
One thing I didn’t realize, until I saw you typing using both keyboards, is that the magic keyboard shakes the iPad as you typed. I was contemplating on buying the magic keyboard to see if I liked it, but seeing the iPad shake with the magic keyboard on a flat surface is a deal breaker for me.
I have the iPad Air 4 with the Logitech Folio Touch. Price was one consideration. Another was the protection it offers. I take my iPad with me to many places I go. I don‘t always have control of where the iPad is placed in vehicles.
I use the iPad Air in place of a traditional computer. I use the keyboard a lot. I find the typing experience to be miles ahead of Bluetooth keyboards I have used in the past. I find the gestures to work well. I generally hate trackpads on computers, but I enjoy this trackpad.
I don‘t mind the lack of the charging port. I use headphones most of the time, and I also use an iPad Air 3, so I am used to dongles. I use both iPads at the same time when I am doing certain tasks, such as video conferencing. I can use one for the video and have the other dedicated to chatting or using Office apps for my workflow during the calls.
I also like the many viewing angles the keyboard supports. I do wish the Air 4 keyboard was detachable like that iPad Pro version.
The paperlike film on the 2021 12.9” iPad Pro would hinder from experiencing the Liquid Retina XDR display in full.
Really?
So does a glass screen protector. It’s impossible to make something actually 100% transparent so they block some color and brightness.
My main issue with the magic keyboard, and most reviewers dont talk about it, is the apple pencil. How it just sits there without any extra security. Drive me nuts that it would just fall off
Yeah that's true, I don't know but how reviews didn't mention it?!
I’ve had mine for ages and haven’t had the Apple Pencil fall off a singe time. And I’m not cautious.
I’ve had mine for ages and I can confirm the pencil is constantly falling off lol
Had mine since day 1, keep falling off seriously.
Excellent review. (As are all of your videos!) I’ve been on the fence with the Magic Keyboard. I have the Smart Folio now and finding I do a lot of very early morning typing - in the dark…. The lit Magic keyboard solves some of my keyboard stroke misses. Showing how easily it is to take off the iPad from the Magic keyboard to use the Pencil is a game changer. Your example in your video sold me! Also, the 2nd port is a killer move for peripheral devices. Thanks!!!
I have the new combo touch and I love it. I have the 11” so I have no problem writing from my lap, couch or a bed. And the function keys are a killer feature, I use it for volume and display brightness all the time. You can also flip the keyboard backwards and rest the kick stand against it when you are in a bed and just watching videos.
The white MK case is beautiful but I find myself constantly be extra careful and looking at it front to back frequently making sure it’s not getting scuffed up and dirty, I’m really considering returning it for that Logitech combo case
You can access the control panel by hovering the mouse over the utility bar (battery, wifi) it snaps to is and you can use 2 fingers to adjust the volume and brightness bars. Never have to touch the screen.
I’m careful with my iPad when I’m outside but I get too comfortable and tend to throw my iPad around my room or slam it on my desk when I’m at home. The ruggedness of the Logitech is a benefit for me, I like that the case and kick stand stays on with the keyboard off. That top row Function keys is just a nice quality of life aspect and convenience. Hoping Logitech makes a slightly thicker version of the Combo Touch for the iPad Air 4th gen.
Please do a video on the "Sidecar" feature working alongside the M1 Macbook Pro! Interested to see if the M1 chips working alongside each other have many/any benefits...Cheers from the UK! ✌️🇬🇧
Bro! Sick, you can detach the keyboard now. This is a game-changer for me. As a student, a pilot, and a parent. I can now easily change my iPad to best suit my needs with a snap! Thanks for the video fam.
Just got the white one and I love this premium look🔥🔥🔥
Nice!
@@Dailytekk I also put a white matted skin on it and it feels great to the touch and protected🙌
@@Dailytekk I know it’s only been a few days but how do you see the white holding up to dirt and fading compared to the gray/black?
Got the Combo this past week. It’s awesome. So much better the magic keyboard (returned it) and protects the iPad so much more.
I am leaning more towards the Apple keyboard because the keys or white instead of black. I’m older and it’s getting more difficult to see the darker keys so this is a big selling point for me. Also I do most of my work from my recliner or a seated position rather than at a desk. I like the ability of moving my tablet closer to my eyes are farther away without the restriction of a holder/keyboard
I bought the magic keyboard for my 2018 12.9" Pro since logitech did not offer this one for the 12.9" pro before this release apparently. I'm still extremely happy with my magic keyboard, but the logitech does also appear to be a compelling option at its price point.
Chris, your videos are captivating, intriguing & addicting.
This one was no exception.
So very well done. Thank you.
Glad you enjoyed it!
I’ve used both iPad Pro sizes for years and if you’re buying accessories I’d say consider this:
You can just use a Bluetooth keyboard that has a trackpad to do the same thing these do.
While a case adds bulk, a bumper case protects the sides which are very vulnerable. I use this plus a sleeve when it’s not in use.
It’s so uncomfortable to use a laptop or iPad+keyboard flat on a desk compared to elevating the screen on a portable stand.
That’s why I use a a keyboard and a stand with both my iPad 12.9 and my MacBook Air, and when I just want to do something quickly… typing on the screen feels perfectly natural.
The coolest feature I see in these cases is the Logitech’s kickstand. I might buy the origami stand to get that feature.
One thing to be considered: I would love to get the Combo Touch, as the extra protection and the ability to separate the keyboard are really nice, but the length of the keyboard + the kickstand make it too big to be used on small lecture hall tables in university, while the magic keyboard's floaty design reduce the iPad's footprint
Edit: I kept watching and I'm glad you mentioned it
You make it seem like you have to detach the ipad from the keyboard to draw/take notes. Just push the kickstand out further.
I just bought an 11 inch iPad Pro and the combo touch. I felt like if I wanted to use the pencil with the magic keyboard, I would have to take it off every time and the iPad was unprotected. The combo touch has worked great. A good workaround for the charging/using accessories issue is getting a usbc hub that has a pass through charging port. Although it hangs on the side, functionally, it works great
Does the combo touch secure the Apple Pencil well enough that it won’t dislodge in a back pack? It seems neither Apple or Logitech secures the pencil any more than the iPad itself.
@@stevenl7878 neither case really protect the pen from falling off. The magnet is pretty good but no, it is unprotected.
Thanks for the quick reply
@@BryanSmith705
Another perk is it amplifies speaker volume. Its speaker holes focus the sound that is concentrated in the plastic sills that creates a nice stereophonic speaker effect that echoes & amplifies music and media really well. Another side perk is the keyboard cover I’ve for Magic Keyboard works for combo touch too; it just doesn’t cover the function row but 90% transferability ain’t bad at all.
I lean to the Combo Touch. They did a great job with the detachable keyboard. I’ve always used an Apple Smart Cover with a plastic shell case so I could use the device without the cover when I wanted. I get that feeling with the Logitech.
Also, test your thunderbolt drives. They seem to have speed limitations on the iPad.
Isn’t it annoying to have the iPad screen to shake when typing or touching the screen when using the magic keyboard? Combo touch seems much more stable
I tried it, but the tight space between the top keys and the bottom of the keyboard meant I kept banging my fingers on the iPad while typing. I wish they could have added some space to the back. That would have meant the more would be more space for function keys. I went with the Logitech Combo Touch. Perfectly satisfied.
I just got the Combo Touch for my 12.9 inch over the weekend and I absolutely love it. Very “MacBookesk”. Mainly like it due to the function keys. I use my ipad while working from home to watch YUouTube videos and love having the function keys to play/stop and such.
This video sold me on the Logitech. I actually didn’t realize at all that the Magic Keyboard would be so limiting in so many ways.
You can literally get a dock for the iPad Pro, which most power users need anyway. And they usually come with pass through charge so that’s no longer a disadvantage for the Logitech.
I got the Logitech combo touch and i could not think of anything better and slimmer to use on any iPad from now on . Terrific combo. Magic Keyboard just can’t be even compared , i can use the combo touch stand in the back to put my iPad anywhere and place it whatever and whenever i need plus its protected with the case around it
This is the video I have been looking for all week! Just got my new Pro today
I had a logitech keyboard lasted me 7 years still works good today. Just bought a new one for my 12.9 inch iPad Pro $129 on Amazon. The magic keyboard is poorly designed when you touch the screen it bounces around like a rubber ball. Even in your video when it’s on your lap and you’re doing the typing, couldn’t you see how much that thing was bouncing around you’re gonna have to have some Dramamine using it.👈👀
99.9% of the time if you are plugging a Thunderbolt 4 cable to your iPad Pro it will have some form of charging capability be it a monitor or docking station so passive charging really has no point honestly. It would be cool if that passive port had Thunderbolt capabilities but $350 for a keyboard is just dumb to me. $230 for a keyboard/detachable case combo and legit shortcut keys on the keyboard (you know, the whole point of having a keyboard in the first place) makes sense. If the Magic Keyboard was $100 less to the price it should be and included shortcut keys, it would be a tougher choice but I just do not trust a levitating magnet to hold my $1000+ tablet. Logitech seems to have protection of investment in mind more so than Apple (what a shock).
Thanks for the video. I've been on the fence. I'm still not sure what I want to get. I might use the MK and buy a Zugu for everything else.
I think I would go for the logitech combo because Ofcourse it has more features! Magic keyboard might have a better angle but the fact that I can remove my iPad with a case on, detaching the keypad is gravitizing me to buy that. And you may buy magic keyboard if you want that premium touch and better angle, because the shortcut keys are not meant to be taken for granted in the folio which magic keyboard doesn't have.
I have the old combo touch for iPad Air 2019, the only valid choice with trackpad, and I really love the upgrades they made most of all the detachable building which was a feature in the air 2019 model. But I think the main issue to upgrade is the keybord ultrathin enclosure which it seems to unglue all the time and I really loved if they’d made something more durable
could you elaborate more on the keyboard part? thanks
I have had the Logitech Combo keyboard for a little over an hr right now. Before buying the accessory, I tried out the keyboard in store. While the keyboard clicks are a little bit more satisfying on the Magic Keyboard, the typing experience on the combo touch is no slouch. The keyboard presses are very accurate but I do notice the slight lag or inconsistency in the trackpad compared to the Magic Keyboard. The added real estate of the TracPad on the combo touch is nice, but still prefer the trackpad on the Magic Keyboard.
What else I like about the combo touch is the fact that I can detach the keyboard from the case and use it as a stand or in tablet mode to sketch out notes or just as a tablet without having to detach the iPad Itself and leave the iPad with no protection. What else I like is the function row, but what you don’t have are the do not disturb, screen mirroring, or camera shortcut. The shortcut key is nice, but you have that already as a keyboard shortcut.
Like Chris mentions, it really depends on your likes and it also depends on if you are wanting to save a few bucks. For me, I have both keyboards at this moment. I have my old Magic Keyboard case which is still compatible with the new M1 11 inch iPad Pro, but I wanted something with a little bit more protection because I have three year old son; which is why I wanted to try out the combo keyboard. So far I am not disappointed but not sure on if I am keeping it due to price. I have a month to decide so we will see. Great video as always.
So a little re-edit. I have decided to take back my Combo keyboard. What led me to this decision, is the typing experience is just better on the Magic Keyboard. Also, like Chris mentioned, the Magic Keyboard just provides a more immersive experience on the iPad. What I also decided about my decision is that you can just tell that the Magic keyboard was just meant to be used on the iPad and nothing else. Just the fluidity between the gestures of the tracPad and the typing experience just nothing else compares.
Do you have any issues with wobbling with magic keyboard?
I am not sure what swipe experience you are having with the Logitech. I find swiping with the Logitech as smooth as the Apple trackpad. As for typing on my lap, I have no issues either. It is like the Microsoft Surface Pro. Honestly, I just cannot justify the price of the Apple keyboard.
I will say that from all the reviews I've seen I had settled on returning my magic keyboard (which is still en route) to get a logitech combo touch. I'm glad I watched this review, I can't see myself compromising "laptop" usage on my lap with the combo touch AND not having a secondary charging option in the case I need to plug into a usb using the lightning port. I do hate that the magic keyboard does not have function keys and has a smaller trackpad area. I feel more comfortable when my wrist is resting on the keyboard area. I won't know for sure until I test it out when it arrives. Thank you for the candid review!
Hi, how is ur Logitech Combo Touch? Any update?
One point I would love to hear your opinion about is that it seems that Logitech does a better job at steady your screen while typing.
You can see at 10:46 that the iPad is shaking while you are typing while it does not shake with the Logitech combo.
@DailyTekk
Good observation. I didn't notice that until you pointed it out That would get really annoying for me over time. I have the Logitech combo for my iPad and I love it. Was considering the Magic keyboard but I will pass.
This video, helped me decide that the combo touch was perfect for me. I don’t normally sit and type on my lap, and when I do I use a recliner so it works with this. Also, being able to break it away from the keyboard is awesome, and I found that if you open the kick stand slightly and hold it you can almost hang the ipad on your hands under the kickstand. It is great! Loved saving the money on it, love the track pad, love the typing experience. I only use the 11 inch as well, as its my on the go device. I have a mac mini set up as my primary.
Love to see the comparison of the experience of ipad Magic Keyboard and bluetooth Magic Keyboard (and Magic Trackpad)!
I agree!
I am returning my Logitech Combo Touch. First time ever... I feel bad about it because usually I'm a massive fan of Logitech products, but this one is a fail.
It's hard, awkward to open it, takes up a lot of space, but the worst of all is the hard edges on the keyboard that scratch your wrist when your rest them. Yowser...
Can you try the Combo touch with the iPad 12.9 2020 please? I was waiting for it and logitech seems to forget me !
It seems like it doesn’t work on it! I checked on the website and they specifically said that its only for the ipad 5th generation. I really hope it actually works on the 2020 ipad since i was thinking of getting one
Yes it will probably work, but its gonna be a bit lose, since the newer model is 3 mml thicker
I would suggest you go look at the new magic keyboard on the 4th gen ipad, that will give you a sense on how it would fit
Anyone already tried this?
It works. It’s just that the speaker cutout isn’t aligned but i don’t hear a difference. It’s like one hole off on each speaker.
Hey, what is the cool thing in the background that spins and is metallic looking silver, thanks!
Swinging sticks/kinetic desk sculpture
Thinking of getting the White MK because it is just so beautiful for when I need a keyboard together with Zugu case for best of both worlds.
Generally speaking, I like the Logitech for the ability to detach the keyboard. Magic keyboard that I purchased in 2017 only lasted one year. Still using the previous same year Logitech.
Why did it only last one year? Did it come to break?
I really wish I could love the logitech keyboard but i just personally dislike the kickstand design i like the more clamshell design but the magic keyboard you have to remove the ipad pretty much to use tablet mode you cant flip the keyboard to the back of the ipad on the fly. I wish i could just find a ipad keyboard case that just has all the necessities…smart connector, a good keyboard with function keys, ability to flip into tablet mode without having to remove the ipad, a good big size trackpad and a clamshell design similar to the magic keyboard or the brydge line of keyboards. These would really improve the laptop replacement experience
Can you test to see if the 12.9 4th gen will work with the new combo touch?
Yes it will probably work, but its gonna be a bit lose, since the newer model is 3 mml thicker
I would suggest you go look at the new magic keyboard on the 4th gen ipad, that will give you a sense on how it would fit
Been wondering the same
It works really well. The speaker cutouts aren’t perfectly aligned, but I can’t tell the difference.
They’re both great And one could certainly discuss the price. What is far more important, as somebody below said, Is your personal need and your workflow. For example, I am a classical musician working in a professional orchestra. I also teach violin students and thus my iPad moves between various music stands every day so number one I need the protection of the bumper. Then I’m also traveling a lot and I have meanwhile realized, after having used a MacBook Pro for 15 years, that the iPads have become so incredibly capable, that everything except for recording and producing a video conveniently, can be done on the iPad. I’m sure even that could be done on the iPad for an amateur or medium professional. So I have a nice desktop set up at home which I have become tired of disconnecting and reassembling many times a week when I travel between my main and secondary residence . I’m going with the logitech keyboard because it offers me a laptop replacement exactly when I need it without having to carry anything extra at the moment when I need the iPad as a music sheet on a music stand I can just remove the keyboard plus the iPad is more protected whereas with the Apple keyboard it would not be protected at all. This is my choice for my very personal and professional reasons. For putting it on the lap I have bought a cheap but very functional lap desk that solves the problem for just 20 bucks and as far as my desktop set up in my main residence is concerned, this is going to be replaced finally by an iMac after almost 20 years.
Great comparison! I switched from a Microsoft Surface Go to the 11" M1 iPad Pro. (my Surface overheated and cooked the internal SSD. I will definitely buy the Logitech. I loved having a detachable keyboard with my Surface.
The perfect keyboard is something with a fixed hinge like the Magic Keyboard or the Bridge keyboard (to let it be lapable), utilizes the 3 pin connectors like the Magic Keyboard or Logitech's keyboard (because who wants Bluetooth connection if it can be hard connection and eliminates the need to charge 2 devices) *AND* can detach at the keyboard, similar to the Surface Book line up. Meaning the iPad stays magnetically connected to the back and physically disconnects from the keyboard so you can carry it around or lay it flat on the table to write but still provide some protection to the back of the iPad.
A Surface Pro like kickstand to stand up the iPad when it's separate from the keyboard would be the final ideal setup. Like the back portion of the Samsung Tab S7+ keyboard case.
Everyone comes close. But no one quite gets it.
The Combo Touch wins it for me. With the Magic Keyboard you can only use it in one way, which would be fine if you needed your iPad to be a 'laptop replacement'. But not everyone uses it like that. They want to be able to use it off the keyboard to watch movies or even hide the keyboard by flipping it around if you wanted to read books on or again watch movies or something like that. And also the addition of the function keys on the Combo Touch is nice and convenient too.
Does the new Logitech combo touch works on older iPad pros 12.9?
I assume yes just with the fit a bit different, I’ve asked the same to apple and best buy support and neither have given a clear answer
I would be careful with the new combo touch and the old iPads if you care about audio quality. I believe the speaker placement on the new iPad (my 2021 11 in model has less speaker holes and they’re closer to the charging port) is slightly different from the old one so the new combo touch might cover the speakers of the old iPads.
Anyone got a clear answer to that?
It works fine
Vielen Dank für dieses hervorragende Video und die Aufklärung der Unterschiede. Ich selbst wie von Ihnen erwähnt wurde, bevorzuge, die Logitech Case zu nutzen, da es abnehmbar ist und in diese Weise spart man zusätzlich viel Platz am Büro auch für Handbewegung ❤
Does this work with ipad pro 12.9 4th gen/2020? Please share :)
Thanks man! This video helped. The Combo Touch is definitely the top pick for me 👍
I only charge my iPad over night when I’m not using it, so I don’t need this extra Port.
The combo has a function key and it the thing has a stronger material. I owned both this and the magic keyboard. The Magic Keyboard has so much wear and tear, I hate that material they used. Meanwhile the Logitech Combo still looks exactly the same after a year.
Thank you for the video I been thinking about getting the Logitech touch key bard for my I pad .
This was a great help .
Logitech should also add detachable screen cover in the box similar to Apple's folio case. So when you don't want to carry a keyboard along but want to have protection for your ipad screen then you can use that lighter cover.
That'll boost the products demand like crazy tbh.
The deal breaker for me with the magic keyboard is the fact that if you want to hold the very expensive iPad in your hands without the keyboard, the iPad is exposed to fall damage.
I actually love the way the Magic Keyboard looks but i dislike that wobble i see when people type on it.
My solution to the naked iPad problem was to buy a smart folio for when I detach it from the keyboard. The smart folio is ridiculously over priced. I’ve also found that when I transfer the iPad back to the Magic Keyboard trackpad stops working and simply restarting the iPad doesn’t fix the problem. I found the procedure that does work is to put it back in the Smart folio and shut it down and then transfer it to the Magic Keyboard before turning on Alain. Kind of weird.
Thank you for making this video. Now I know which keyboard should I have for my iPad 👍🏻
Looks like the iPad shakes and vibrates quite a bit while typing on the magic keyboard (3:44)(10:42) as opposed to no shaking or vibration on the combo touch. (3:50)(10:02) The Combo Touch looks like a much more solid experience. When I saw Chris touching the iPad screen when on the Magic Keyboard (8:56) there was a lot of movement. When he touched the screen with the iPad on the Combo Touch, it was rock solid with no movement. (8:23) I am sold on the Combo Touch with bigger track pad, dedicated shortcut keys, better overall protection of the iPad, easy keyboard removal for tablet use, no vibration or shaking while typing, and over $100.00 less than the Magic Keyboard.
I just wish the combo touch came in different colors like in black
Thank you soo much for this comparison! Sooo helpful
I've had the magic keyboard for almost a year and a half, and I'm even a complete apple SHEEP....BUT. the stupid magic keyboard material drives me insane!! it gets all torn up, dirty, hard to clean, etc. and this ipad never really leaves my bag/desk. I just ordered the combo-touch so fingers crossed.