Yes, the Logitech works with the 2018 and 2020 iPad Pro but does obscure the speakers a little bit. NO, the Air 4 will not work because it will cover the Touch ID.
Logitech for the win. I don’t feel comfortable walking around with my 1300$ iPad without a case while I’m using it as a traditional tablet 75% of the time lol
Yes reassuring to hear. That slight detail you noticed may be a very small gap for the sound to travel through - that or it doesn’t make any difference in front camera mode.
I decided with the combo touch personally. Although the Magic Keyboard is nice, it's kinda pricey. The function keys and the ability to detach the Ipad is what made me choose the combo option
I’ve watched DOZENS of these comparison videos (because I’m torn on which to get) and I think this is the best video I’ve seen. Touched on every single aspect, and I loved that the footprint was actually measured. Good job!
@@JerrySchulze Correct. With the Combo case, it sounds clear. Without it, it sounds like you are talking from the bottom of a barrel, the sound comes across “muffled”? It appears to be hampered, perhaps by the surface (table?) you are putting the iPad on. I think a better comparison would be between the Magically Expensive Apple keyboard and the Combo. Using Apple’s, there are no obstructions around the iPad’s microphones/speakers, while with the Combo there would be.
I’ve been using the Logitech for a few months and it’s just a super capable and ergonomically pleasing device, and because of the protection I’ll keep using it despite craving a little less bulk. There’s no way I would feel comfortable with a naked iPad… as nice as it feels. Logitech really did a great job with this combo case.
Great review! I just recently bought both of them, and they both have their own pros and cons; the Combo Touch is great for tablet and keyboard use, I love having a detachable keyboard so I can draw, take notes, and read more easily, but having a separate app just to update the firmware for the keyboard is not ideal. I actually had to get 2 Combo Touches since the first one had a problem with the keyboard connecting after having it detached for too long, and both combo touches i got have a problem with the trackpad freezing. Not only that but the bigger footprint isn’t ideal, and it’s not easy to use in bed or on my lap. The Magic Keyboard on the other hand doesn’t have any issues with that, it just connects and that’s it, no need to worry about a separate app to update the firmware or anything. The smaller footprint is great for me and it’s also easy to use in bed and on my lap. Plus, the USB pass through is very handy. But then there’s no protection whatsoever when you take it out and also limited angles, not to mention no function row. It really is a tough decision! I wish there could be some good in between. Right now I’m leaning towards keeping the MK and buying a case for the iPad that can work with the MK but not 100% sure. Update: decided to keep the MK, the Combo Touch just wasn’t worth the trouble imo. Maybe I happened to be unlucky and got two faulty Combo Touches but yeah I can’t recommend it sadly
hmm, was debating on buying the magic keyboard for office and touch on the go but dont want to mess with firmware. Has your ipad experianced any issues since installing the firmware? Was there a clean way to roll back the firmware?
@@elizabeth3280 no, no issues at all, the firmware is downloaded from an app onto the keyboard. if by rolling back you meaning removing it then i assume the firmware is deleted once you delete the app
@@yolk818 So the firmware is installed onto the Keyboard and not the ipad itself? Typically Firware is configured to send instructions to your hardware on layer 1 not at the layer 2 software level. hmmm, will need to look into it thank you for responding though it was a useful comment.
I was debating between the two and I opted for the Combo Touch. The Magic Keyboard is a great dock. It does what it does well. But I needed the flexibility of iPad and laptop. It protects the iPad very well. Function keys are useful and the materials are premium. Hopefully it will have a longevity.
Describing the magic keyboard as more of a dock is spot on. One thing I like about the older folio keyboard is being able to fold it back. The Logitech gives many of the benefits of the surface Pro range
I have used both the Magic keyboard and just recently bought the Logitech combo touch. After owning the combo touch for over a 24 hrs, my initial impressions is that I love the Logitech over the Magic keyboard and I will share why. 1. Function keys….I got use to not having them on the Magic keyboard, through gestures and touching the screen to invoke Control center but when you have actual function keys, its nice to have faster input because you have dedicated keys for that action like raising the volume, screen brightness/keyboard brightness and then of course multi tasking. 2. Protection, the Combo touch protects our iPad all the way around the device, so you don’t have to worry about the device coming apart from the keyboard and dropping. Also what’s nice about the case is that it does not show oils or scuffs from sliding on surfaces. The surface of the Combo touch is a really nice durable material and is easy to clean. 3. The keys, all though I do prefer the typing experience on the Magic over the Combo touch, but I prefer the spacing of the keys on the touch. It may be a placebo affect, but they do feel different to me. 4. Angles, I do prefer the angels on the Combo touch over the Magic Keyboard. I don’t ever use it at the angles that are depicted in the video, but I have used both on my lap. What I have found by using it on my lap, is that the Combo I don’t have the kickstand out on my lap which means I hold the iPad from falling on one hand and the other I use for typing …This is not ideal, but honestly, how often does someone need to use this on their lap or if you need to use it on your lap why can’t someone just use dictation? 5. Lastly, the price, the price of the Combo touch, although still not cheap, it is cheaper than the Magic Keyboard. 6. TracPad, both TracPad’s are nice and I do prefer the one on the Magic because its a little more precise over the Combo, but having a bigger trackpad on combo touch is nice to have.
I got the Combo Touch for my 11” iPad Pro 2021 right when it came out, and I got so used to the function keys, larger trackpad, and the way the keyboard feels that when I tried Magic Keyboard at the Apple Store the other day just for the comparison, it felt like an inferior product. Like a downgrade. Though, I would still love a smaller footprint and an extra charging port. The Magic Keyboard is sexier, but having seen the combo touch on someone else’s iPad in a coffee shop the other day seemed kind of sexy too.
I read reviews that Logitech keyboard would randomly disconnect from the iPad or sometimes the iPad wouldn't respond to the keyboard. is it true that it has compatibility issues?
@@talhatariq6420 I have to say it’s pretty dependable in this regard. I can’t say it’s never gonna happen but it hasn’t happened to me yet. Back in 2017 when I had the Apple folio keyboard it was happening very often. It kept not responding. Then through years it got better as OS got better. I think by now the support and the software on both sides is pretty reliable, apple and logitech. However, I have a different and a bit funny problem with the keyboard. Since ipados15 sometimes when I disconnect the keyboard from the case Apple Music app starts playing a random song. It happens maybe once a week. I don’t even use apple music just Spotify so i don’t understand how disconnecting the keyboard can trigger that.
Great video! I haven't bought an ipad in over 10 years. (the last one being the ipad 2). I was blown away by how far these things have come since the days of Steve jobs calling it the best internet browsing experience. With the best buy sale I bought the 2020 11 in Ipad Pro and also picked up the combo touch case as well as a nice matte screen protector. I'll be checking your channel out for more awesome content. You've earned my subscription!
One of the better videos I’ve seen on this topic. I would add that a docking station solves the limited USB access. The angles and smaller foot print of the magic keyboard also puts the screen closer to your face. I have the same issue with my knuckles hitting the screen if the iPad is too close. I hate that. I think the Logitech is a no brainer. It seems to be way more functional and better thought out. I do wonder about those soft endpoints with the angle adjustment. It looks like if you treat it well it will probably last 2-3 years in the hands of a heavy user like myself.
I love the Combo Touch, how detachable it is, the build, and the Function Keys, but I still shelled out for the Magic Keyboard. It takes less space on a desk, is better on a lap, extra port, the keys are slightly nicer to type, and I like how it's slightly elevated.
Your reviews are excellent and give the every day person like me a thorough insight into the dos and donts of iPad. I am now a subscriber. Cheers and I look forward to learning a lot more. I am a senior citizen from Australia by the way so never too old to learn. Age is just a number.
Honestly, i wish Apple do learn from this Logitech Combo cause what we really want is to protect the iPad seamlessly even after detached it from the keyboard.
Nice one, Jerry! The Logitech looks really appealing and would probably be my choice, but I feel like the Magic Keyboard scores some portability points considering the smaller table footprint. Probably a better experience when working in coffee shops etc.
I was worried about table footprint but after I started using the combo touch, I found it comfortably fits on even the smaller fold-out lecture hall style desks
Hi. Combo Touch user here, for the last eight months. What can I say is, right away after using the Combo Touch, it has never crossed my mind "Oh my, why didn't I get the Magic Keyboard?". That's how good the Combo Touch is. But hey, if you love the magic keyboard, go for it. What I'm saying is, neither one is a bad choice.
I had to go with the magic keyboard at the end of the day, the combo touches dethatch feature is nice but its bobs up and down when you write on it, which makes writing really awkward. The MK just looks so sleek as well, especially with a custom skin on it. Also if money isn't and issue, get the pitaka ipad pro case with the new folio cover, and it is compatible with the magic keyboard, so you get very similar protection to the combo touch and the detachability.
Hi Jerry, thank you for clarifying my question from your other video. The funny thing is you sounded more louder and clearer watching on my iPad pro 12.9 2020 when you demo the case on vs off. I’ll definitely go with the Logitech instead of magic keyboard (retails $449+gst=$471 CAD= ouchy). I have now subscibed. Much appreciated.
I think the Logitech is the better option for most people, just wish they would not have upped the price so much over previous versions. The sweet spot is about 150-179, half the price of Apples.
Thanks for the review. I do want to point out Clearly Apple also approves of Logitech as well. It’s on of the few brands sold on their website and stores.
Great comparison video. I learnt so much just by watching your review on every details. You even mentioned the charging port that some cable might have issue with the Logtitech Combo Touch. For its price, I am going to buy the Logitech new Combo Touch for my iPad Pro 11 2018. Thanks, Jerry!
I have used both the Magic keyboard and the combo touch. Both keyboards have pros and cons but for me the combo touch came out as the winner and here is why. 1. Although the combo touch obstructs the use of the thunderbolt port, i still have access due to the dongle i use does not have to sit flush to the iPad for it to work. It connects via USB type c cord and its one I have used ever since owning the 2016 MacBook Pro. I also prefer the protection the combo touch offers over the Magic keyboard as I work out in the field and not behind a desk. So its nice that I don’t have to worry about dropping my iPad. 2. The touchpad, although the touchpad on the Magic keyboard is slightly more responsive than that on the Combo touch, its nice that it is bigger and I don’t have to carry out as many finger gymnastics when pasting and copying notes. 3. The price. Cheaper is cheaper, and right now savings is king with the added cost of everything due to inflation. It’s nice that the Combo touch is cheaper and offers more like a function row, non obstructed typing, more viewing angles, and the materials do not take on oils and smudges as easily. I work in field sales, visiting multiple stores in my assigned territory. The combo touch I feel is just more suited for my workflow than the Magic keyboard. Not to take anything away from the Magic keyboard, i just feel the Magic Keyboard is just more suited for those working in a stationary environment.
@@ThibaultxDxCx I just bought the 11'' Logitech combo touch just this Wednesday. It came supeerrrr early, I was expecting to get it next week but I got it today. The keyboard is definitely detachable, although it is a little hard to get off the hinge and magnets holding it are much much stronger and sturdier than I had assumed 😂 so its a good thing in the long run for sure.
@@michaeldodd9671 I have been asking this question since forever and i really can’t find an answer 😭 does the folio touch works on 2021 iPad Pro 11 inch
Thanks for a very comprehensive comparison! I just picked up the Magic Keyboard because I watch videos in my bed and I’m getting sore arms holding my 2021 12.9” iPad. Now I can do it on my bed table with ease! And yes, the forward tilt is a deal breaker for me!
Great comparison mate , thanks for posting , both keyboard cases look good , i already have the magic keyboard on my air 4 , and i have no complaints it does the job well , although on occasion it has occurred to me it would be nice to have some extra functions like the extra row of keys on the Logitech , and these ipads being fairly expensive devices , i am always wary having a dropsy or some clumsy moment where the ipad may get damaged , so the extra protections on the Logitech keyboard do look attractive .
I have both and the Logitech is better for me, I prefer to push the screen back more, the mouse pad is larger and easier to use, the thing I like the most is the added side protection...
The Logitech’s footprint is it’s largest drawback. I used the Logitech Combo Touch on my Air 3 and that was a complete dealbreaker - and the fact that the magnets keeping the keyboard attached were way too weak on that one. To the point where I switched back to the Smart Keyboard and a Magic Mouse instead.
I'm mighty tempted by the Apple Magic Keyboard, for purely esthetic reasons. It just looks a thousand times more elegant, and that makes a difference. However, I'll probably go for the Logitech for the price. It's good to hear (from you and some other reviewers) that the keyboard itself is so good.
Just to sway your decision a bit, I’m typing this on a Apple magic keyboard and the aesthetic reasons sell me. Not only that, but it’s infinetly more intuitive. The way the iPad just connects to the case magnetically and works right away is what makes the keyboard feel like an extension to the iPad. I can easily take off the iPad and put it back on without tussling with the case itself. Given its design, the Logitech keyboard really limits you on where you can use it. The Logitech keyboard may be more practical, but the magic keyboard is far more intuitive.
@@abrararifify have you dropped your ipad with the case on with any damages? i’m not sure if i wanna take the risk or not just because of the protection
Thanks for a well detailed review. The only problem I had really with the Logitech is when using the iPad to draw, the kickstand doesn't really offer sturdy enough support. Other than that, its a winner. I hope they fix this in the next gen.
To me, I went with Logitech because the dealer breaker was the magic keyboard has no protection around the edges. My iPad is always in my backpack to and from school! Even on my my motorcycle in my bag, there’s lots of movement. The combo touch I can detach the keyboard as well and has a row of functions gives me more of a laptop feel. The only thing I hate is the hinge of the combo touch makes it tricky for “lap” use so I’m limited with where I can use it as a laptop if not at a table if using on my lap I just pop the keyboard off and use as a tablet :( but Atleast my iPad is protected !
Great video. I think the footprint and angle adjustments on the Magic Keyboard are too necessary for QOL. I think I'd get frustrated with the footprint of the Logitech, even though the case and kickstand would be really nice for writing and that layer of protection. and then having the thunderbolt port on the hinge side is just too cool. I think they are both equally impressive.
Just got the combo touch for my 2021 iPad Pro and I really like it. If the magic keyboard didn’t cost double the decision would’ve been more difficult. With the features of the combo touch and the price point it isnt’t a comparison in my opinion. Sure the magic keyboard looks nicer, but it doesn’t offer protection, and at that price point it is a massive oversight by apple.
When Apple products are not perfect, that’s because they don’t want them to be. Look for logical applications of this principle. WRT minimal protection for iPad in $300 keyboard case… they want you to drop it, as that means you will NEED apple care, after investing laptop money on a tablet…
@@jomow9335 in the case of the apple keyboard I 100% disagree. It’s all about the aesthetic and the apple keyboard looks futuristic in a non novel way with legitimate functionality.
Thanks for your review. I really like the extra protection of the logitech case but I really love and need the screen angle adjustability of the Magic keyboard...
Selling point for the magic keyboard is that extra port. I like that I can charge while using the iPad and have an external storage device attached when editing. Also wired headphones are still a thing lol.
the typing on these two keyboards actually feels quite different. I personally like the trackpad and keys on the magic keyboard much better, but prefer better protection and detachable case on the ligitech
Precisely the info I needed to know. These keyboard cases are expensive. So, it’s important to know all you can as you will be living with it for awhile. One other tidbit I might have missed though. Did you mention the battery drain for both keyboards? If you did, my apologies. Another great video! Thanks, Jerry!
Thanks for watching. I did not mention battery life and sorry for that. With general use I am not seeing any difference in battery life between the 2 but I have not done any formal testing.
The fact that even when I detach the keyboard with the combo touch my iPad is still protected is big for me. These iPads are super expensive now making protection ever more important. The function keys also make for a much better experience
The magic keyboard really puzzles me: lots of added weight for minimal protection, and it makes it impossible / uncomfortable to use one of the iPad Pro’s main features - the pencil. Though the Combo Touch looks like it flexes too much when laying almost flat - it’s not great if your drawing surface moves, and I’d be concerned about the longevity of the hinge.
I have an older combo touch and it helps to be able to fold the keys back and use the pencil and you can use the iPad in portrait mode that way. It just doesn’t really stand up in portrait mode. But totally agree with you, I wish the magic keyboard was more protective and then it might be worth it for me. I have a toddler!!!
as much as I was 100% sold on the magic keyboard, after watching comparison videos, including this one, I am now going for the combo touch mainly because of the extra protection. As much as I want the Magic Keyboard for the magnet/ease of detaching, it wouldn't be safe/I wouldnt feel safe doing so OUTSIDE of my house. I could see a scenario if I had extra cash to buy both. But thats definitely not anytime soon lol. Thanks for this
@@ballooneyjr4294 i ended up caving but getting a cheaper used one lol. Great buy IMO..it really does add an extra "feel" to it, but still overpriced lol
@@ballooneyjr4294 haha for sure..its just funny because the ipad pro was already a splurge purchase so the idea of paying that much for a keyboard was a big no to me and I was sold on the Logitech one..aaaand look at me now lol. Glad I bought it though!
They both are great and all it depends on your needs. I preferred the Combo Touch because it makes me feel that it protects my iPad. It also feels a little tough and indestructible, Finally, because of my job, the thunderbolt port is not a big deal or something that I need. Great video! :)
Excellent review Jerry - for me the iPad Pro is used when traveling, on the go, or going to meetings so functionality and protection are most important to me - so the Logitech Combo Touch is my choice.
Great review :) Definitely I can understand both Keyboards are truly Awesome. Of course love the Magic also its perfect for me cause so many years used Track Pads and it makes easy instead using the Magic's short cuts. Again Great review!!!
The kickstand is a nono for me because I like the flexibility of using my iPad on my lap and on my desk. What happens if you do not have a desk? Just got my magic keyboard for $250 and I'm happy with that.
As someone that has tried to use cases that are not sturdy for ipad for so long and now using a laptop stand with a mechanical keyboard and resting my ipad on it i really want the magic keyboard, its just so much of a hassle of things moving and not being sturdy on a lap
the fact that you can comepletly take off the keyboard whenever you want and set it to the side or put it on the back is the best part of the combo touch, i think its the best keyboard case design out there IMO. this is like the magic keyboard folio but for ipad pros lol. just a little bit thicker.
I have both keyboards and like both but overall I prefer the Apple keyboard.. I prefer the protection of the Logitech but I prefer how the Magic Keyboard places the iPad Pro much closer to you. If I am traveling I prefer the Logitech as the I am afraid that the White Apple keyboard will get dirty and if in the unlikely case that it dropped the Logitech would provide more protection. Another advantage of the Logitech is that if I am using the iPad without a keyboard then I prefer the protection of the Logitech. I am most likely to drop the iPad if it is not on a keyboard. In actual use I find myself changing almost daily in between keyboards which makes me crazy but I switch cases on my iPhone so I should calm down about this and enjoy both cases for different uses.
I literally watched this video in Best Buy with both in my hand just trying to justify the extra money to an already expensive Christmas present. In the end , the Logitech won . Both do the exact same job . But one has a lot more protection. Great video..
Look, I loved the Logitech case. I got one for my first iPad and another one for the iPad Pro. But let me tell you. It’s not worth it. The edges in my first case, as well as the parts next to the speakers, started stretching out. I though this was because maybe I had accidentally pulled on them, so when I got the second case (hitch is even thinner around the edges) I made sure not to touch them. Still, I had the same exact problem. It’s gotten so bad that one of the edges actually broke, and its stretching out to the point of showing the Inter parts of the case. I got the Logitech keyboard for the cheaper price, kickstand, and very importantly, protection. But if the edges are breaking they might as well not be there. I also checked on Reddit, and this has happened to an extent to so many people. Its ridiculous that a product this expensive breaks within less than a year of purchase, and although I checked and it has warranty, a replacement unit would have the same issue. The case also completely stopped working after the iOS 16 update, and as a student I can’t afford to not be able to write for a week. If you’re on a budget a mouse and a Bluetooth keyboard works wonders. I’ve been using them and it’s incredibly comfortable. I do give points to Logitech in that they have been able to give me a refund, since it has a 2 year warranty, but that’s all I can say about it. The case was really really good while it lasted, but it has no longevity. 2/10
I actually preferred the sound of the mic coming thru the Logitech. A bit more low end. Thanks for the excellent review. Heavily leaning towards the Logitech.
I bought both, but kept the Apple Magic Keyboard. The Logitech is awkward to use on a lap - you have to keep your knees close together and push the keyboard right up into your belly, and the screen feels much further away. The Magic Keyboard also wins on a cramped desk or plane/train tray table. The Logitech needed a much harder press on the trackpad to register clicks, it was only working for me 1 in 4 presses. It is more versatile though and the material is much more durable.
Oh thanks so much for saying that. I’m a student and I love apple’s trackpads I used brydge but the track was not good at all and I highlight 100’s of questions a day I need a good trackpad I guess I’ll stick to my magic keyboard then
Such great comparison, covered everything! Must say i would prefer the magic keyboard, just seems easier to use on your lap or in bed. Wish there was something similar for the Tab s7 or the upcoming Tab s8.
Thank you for this video. Based on your video I went and picked up the Logitech model. My biggest complaint about the Apple model is that it provides zero protection for the iPad itself whereas the Logitech model does. It works excellently.
I bought the magic keyboard on a spending spree and ended up returning it. Thoughts: 1. Make sure your iPad is not just simply a tablet device to you and you will actually find need for a keyboard 2. Magic keyboard offers very little protection 3. Magic keyboard suede material is NOT sustainable - picks up stains so quickly which is just unacceptable for the expensive price point
I had the Logi combo case for a day or two on my 11” iPad Pro, but it’s bulky and the kickstand with keyboard it too much to comfortably fit anywhere I wanted it. I upgraded to the M1 12.9” and I have the Magic keyboard. I’ve never actually used a keyboard as much as I do now. This is convenient, easy to use and with the float, it raises enough for me to play the games I like without the keyboard being in the way. Plus I got it for $200 brand new, so it was a no brainer, lol. I’m considering buying a CoverBuddy so that the iPad itself is protected if it ever falls.
This was a very well done comparison; you covered all of the differences better than any review I have seen. One small thing that would have been useful - the distribution of total weight in the Logitech between the case and the keyboard. I want to know how much weight is added to the iPad when the keyboard is detached. The case makes the iPad grippier when holding in portrait mode with one hand to read. That has to be traded off against the extra weight it adds, making it more tiring to hold up.
I love both of these cases and have always wanted to have and use Apple's... sadly though I wish they would take elements from Logitech like a full-body shell (that's also detachable) and still have the "magic keyboard" aesthetic and design. I personally just feel like it would make the keyboard case more valuable cost-wise and a great option altogether.
Logi Combo for me ,better protection when out and about , also no one I have watched so far mentions you can remove the Logi keyboard and plug it in backwards and use it for a stand in bed for viewing content or just fold it up against the back of the case for the reading experience . The Logi keyboard also has more room between the function keys and the screen stoping you from accidentally hitting the screen when typing something that can be annoying if you lose an email you are typing . To me the Logi is an all around better pro keyboard . When I am typing it is more the laptop experience with bigger trackpad and just nicer feel . I haven’t had to many issues with it freezing but I don’t have it disconnected for long and happy to use the on screen keyboard in combo when in the iPad mode as I an usually only typing comments like this or short emails . There is room for improvement but neither keyboard has it all . I just like the Logi as it has the most options and the price point makes sense
I read reviews that Logitech keyboard would randomly disconnect from the iPad or sometimes the iPad wouldn't respond to the keyboard. is it true that it has compatibility issues?
Yes, the Logitech works with the 2018 and 2020 iPad Pro but does obscure the speakers a little bit. NO, the Air 4 will not work because it will cover the Touch ID.
They have a case for Air 4 :) www.apple.com/shop/product/HPB92PA/A/logitech-folio-touch-keyboard-case-with-trackpad-for-ipad-air-4th-generation
@@cjane2501 they also have the combo touch for the ipad air 4
What about the iPad PRO 11" ?
@@chrisrybak4961 They have a model for that.
Logitech for the win. I don’t feel comfortable walking around with my 1300$ iPad without a case while I’m using it as a traditional tablet 75% of the time lol
You’re going for the worse keyboard just because you don’t wanna buy another case?
Finally someone that actually knows how to compare something. Great review.
High praise. Thanks!
@Paul Kryder as my math teacher would say GRAMMAR PEOPLE!!!!! (proceeds to use no grammar whatsoever)
Right
As I listen to you talk through the iPad with the Logitech Combo Touch, there is no voice distortion & you sound clear.
My choice is the Logitech
I was surprised that in the case it actually sounded better to me.
@@JerrySchulze I thought it was just me but it sounded better to me too.
Yes reassuring to hear. That slight detail you noticed may be a very small gap for the sound to travel through - that or it doesn’t make any difference in front camera mode.
I got an M1 iPad Pro with the Combo Touch and I love it so much!
Can confirm on headphones there is a difference and it is clearer
I decided with the combo touch personally. Although the Magic Keyboard is nice, it's kinda pricey. The function keys and the ability to detach the Ipad is what made me choose the combo option
Yes!!! Finally someone who listened to us! Thanks for testing the mic. I would say it even sounds better with the Logitech case. Thank you.
No problem!
I also thought that
Same thought
Without the case, sound bounced on the hard surface of the table. Mybe it sound better on hand or softer surface like a mattress.
I’ve watched DOZENS of these comparison videos (because I’m torn on which to get) and I think this is the best video I’ve seen. Touched on every single aspect, and I loved that the footprint was actually measured. Good job!
Yay! Thank you!
Which one are you getting?
Which one you pick?
did you buy one?
Yes there is a big difference: with the case on it sounds way better:)
Strange, right?!
@@JerrySchulze Correct. With the Combo case, it sounds clear. Without it, it sounds like you are talking from the bottom of a barrel, the sound comes across “muffled”? It appears to be hampered, perhaps by the surface (table?) you are putting the iPad on. I think a better comparison would be between the Magically Expensive Apple keyboard and the Combo. Using Apple’s, there are no obstructions around the iPad’s microphones/speakers, while with the Combo there would be.
@@uwekonnigsstaddt524 SO the first one was connected to the magic keyboard and no obstructions. the second one was in the combo touch case.
Yep. Sounds better in the case
Wow I didn't expect this lol 😆 dang this feature alone might be worth getting it over the magic keyboard. SMH
Logitech seems better in every way other than looks
I prefer it's looks tbf
@@benparkes9805 same it protects the ipad more as well
I’ve been using the Logitech for a few months and it’s just a super capable and ergonomically pleasing device, and because of the protection I’ll keep using it despite craving a little less bulk. There’s no way I would feel comfortable with a naked iPad… as nice as it feels. Logitech really did a great job with this combo case.
With case, sounds better - odd but true
I was thinking the same thing!
Great review! I just recently bought both of them, and they both have their own pros and cons; the Combo Touch is great for tablet and keyboard use, I love having a detachable keyboard so I can draw, take notes, and read more easily, but having a separate app just to update the firmware for the keyboard is not ideal. I actually had to get 2 Combo Touches since the first one had a problem with the keyboard connecting after having it detached for too long, and both combo touches i got have a problem with the trackpad freezing. Not only that but the bigger footprint isn’t ideal, and it’s not easy to use in bed or on my lap. The Magic Keyboard on the other hand doesn’t have any issues with that, it just connects and that’s it, no need to worry about a separate app to update the firmware or anything. The smaller footprint is great for me and it’s also easy to use in bed and on my lap. Plus, the USB pass through is very handy. But then there’s no protection whatsoever when you take it out and also limited angles, not to mention no function row. It really is a tough decision! I wish there could be some good in between. Right now I’m leaning towards keeping the MK and buying a case for the iPad that can work with the MK but not 100% sure.
Update: decided to keep the MK, the Combo Touch just wasn’t worth the trouble imo. Maybe I happened to be unlucky and got two faulty Combo Touches but yeah I can’t recommend it sadly
Your comment is useful! Thanks!
hmm, was debating on buying the magic keyboard for office and touch on the go but dont want to mess with firmware. Has your ipad experianced any issues since installing the firmware? Was there a clean way to roll back the firmware?
@@elizabeth3280 no, no issues at all, the firmware is downloaded from an app onto the keyboard. if by rolling back you meaning removing it then i assume the firmware is deleted once you delete the app
@@yolk818 So the firmware is installed onto the Keyboard and not the ipad itself? Typically Firware is configured to send instructions to your hardware on layer 1 not at the layer 2 software level. hmmm, will need to look into it thank you for responding though it was a useful comment.
@@elizabeth3280 yeah if the keyboard isn’t connected to the ipad (like it needs to be attached to the case) then you can’t update the firmware
I was debating between the two and I opted for the Combo Touch. The Magic Keyboard is a great dock. It does what it does well. But I needed the flexibility of iPad and laptop. It protects the iPad very well. Function keys are useful and the materials are premium. Hopefully it will have a longevity.
Describing the magic keyboard as more of a dock is spot on. One thing I like about the older folio keyboard is being able to fold it back.
The Logitech gives many of the benefits of the surface Pro range
I have used both the Magic keyboard and just recently bought the Logitech combo touch. After owning the combo touch for over a 24 hrs, my initial impressions is that I love the Logitech over the Magic keyboard and I will share why.
1. Function keys….I got use to not having them on the Magic keyboard, through gestures and touching the screen to invoke Control center but when you have actual function keys, its nice to have faster input because you have dedicated keys for that action like raising the volume, screen brightness/keyboard brightness and then of course multi tasking.
2. Protection, the Combo touch protects our iPad all the way around the device, so you don’t have to worry about the device coming apart from the keyboard and dropping. Also what’s nice about the case is that it does not show oils or scuffs from sliding on surfaces. The surface of the Combo touch is a really nice durable material and is easy to clean.
3. The keys, all though I do prefer the typing experience on the Magic over the Combo touch, but I prefer the spacing of the keys on the touch. It may be a placebo affect, but they do feel different to me.
4. Angles, I do prefer the angels on the Combo touch over the Magic Keyboard. I don’t ever use it at the angles that are depicted in the video, but I have used both on my lap. What I have found by using it on my lap, is that the Combo I don’t have the kickstand out on my lap which means I hold the iPad from falling on one hand and the other I use for typing …This is not ideal, but honestly, how often does someone need to use this on their lap or if you need to use it on your lap why can’t someone just use dictation?
5. Lastly, the price, the price of the Combo touch, although still not cheap, it is cheaper than the Magic Keyboard.
6. TracPad, both TracPad’s are nice and I do prefer the one on the Magic because its a little more precise over the Combo, but having a bigger trackpad on combo touch is nice to have.
I got the Combo Touch for my 11” iPad Pro 2021 right when it came out, and I got so used to the function keys, larger trackpad, and the way the keyboard feels that when I tried Magic Keyboard at the Apple Store the other day just for the comparison, it felt like an inferior product. Like a downgrade. Though, I would still love a smaller footprint and an extra charging port. The Magic Keyboard is sexier, but having seen the combo touch on someone else’s iPad in a coffee shop the other day seemed kind of sexy too.
I think they both look great. For me, the footprint made the difference and I am sticking with the magic keyboard.
I read reviews that Logitech keyboard would randomly disconnect from the iPad or sometimes the iPad wouldn't respond to the keyboard. is it true that it has compatibility issues?
@@talhatariq6420 I have to say it’s pretty dependable in this regard. I can’t say it’s never gonna happen but it hasn’t happened to me yet. Back in 2017 when I had the Apple folio keyboard it was happening very often. It kept not responding. Then through years it got better as OS got better. I think by now the support and the software on both sides is pretty reliable, apple and logitech. However, I have a different and a bit funny problem with the keyboard. Since ipados15 sometimes when I disconnect the keyboard from the case Apple Music app starts playing a random song. It happens maybe once a week. I don’t even use apple music just Spotify so i don’t understand how disconnecting the keyboard can trigger that.
Great video! I haven't bought an ipad in over 10 years. (the last one being the ipad 2). I was blown away by how far these things have come since the days of Steve jobs calling it the best internet browsing experience. With the best buy sale I bought the 2020 11 in Ipad Pro and also picked up the combo touch case as well as a nice matte screen protector. I'll be checking your channel out for more awesome content. You've earned my subscription!
Very cool and thanks so much!
One of the better videos I’ve seen on this topic. I would add that a docking station solves the limited USB access.
The angles and smaller foot print of the magic keyboard also puts the screen closer to your face.
I have the same issue with my knuckles hitting the screen if the iPad is too close. I hate that.
I think the Logitech is a no brainer. It seems to be way more functional and better thought out. I do wonder about those soft endpoints with the angle adjustment. It looks like if you treat it well it will probably last 2-3 years in the hands of a heavy user like myself.
I love the Combo Touch, how detachable it is, the build, and the Function Keys, but I still shelled out for the Magic Keyboard. It takes less space on a desk, is better on a lap, extra port, the keys are slightly nicer to type, and I like how it's slightly elevated.
Such credible and detailed comparison, not manipulating in any way just informative guidance towards a decisive buy. Thanking you!!
Your reviews are excellent and give the every day person like me a thorough insight into the dos and donts of iPad. I am now a subscriber. Cheers and I look forward to learning a lot more. I am a senior citizen from Australia by the way so never too old to learn. Age is just a number.
I really appreciate the comment. I hope to have some more iPad videos out in the next couple of months.
Honestly, i wish Apple do learn from this Logitech Combo cause what we really want is to protect the iPad seamlessly even after detached it from the keyboard.
Nice one, Jerry! The Logitech looks really appealing and would probably be my choice, but I feel like the Magic Keyboard scores some portability points considering the smaller table footprint. Probably a better experience when working in coffee shops etc.
I think the footprint is probably the biggest factor for me. I would like the extra protection but so far I have never dropped or damaged an iPad.
I was worried about table footprint but after I started using the combo touch, I found it comfortably fits on even the smaller fold-out lecture hall style desks
Thanks Jerry,
That was the best comparison I’ve seen of these two keyboards. I appreciate the help!
You bet!
Very helpful! Before this video I was pretty lost, but after watching this review, I know exactly which keyboard I’m going to pick up. Love it!
Great! Which one?
@@JerrySchulze Logitech combo 🙏👍😀
This is the best review of this case, and one of the best reviews of any product I have seen yet. Great work!
Wow!!! Thanks you!
Hi. Combo Touch user here, for the last eight months. What can I say is, right away after using the Combo Touch, it has never crossed my mind "Oh my, why didn't I get the Magic Keyboard?". That's how good the Combo Touch is. But hey, if you love the magic keyboard, go for it. What I'm saying is, neither one is a bad choice.
I had to go with the magic keyboard at the end of the day, the combo touches dethatch feature is nice but its bobs up and down when you write on it, which makes writing really awkward. The MK just looks so sleek as well, especially with a custom skin on it. Also if money isn't and issue, get the pitaka ipad pro case with the new folio cover, and it is compatible with the magic keyboard, so you get very similar protection to the combo touch and the detachability.
Hi Jerry, thank you for clarifying my question from your other video. The funny thing is you sounded more louder and clearer watching on my iPad pro 12.9 2020 when you demo the case on vs off. I’ll definitely go with the Logitech instead of magic keyboard (retails $449+gst=$471 CAD= ouchy). I have now subscibed. Much appreciated.
Awesome! Yes, it was strange.
This is the best review I’ve found for these two accessories. Thank you/great job!
I think the Logitech is the better option for most people, just wish they would not have upped the price so much over previous versions. The sweet spot is about 150-179, half the price of Apples.
Thanks for the review. I do want to point out Clearly Apple also approves of Logitech as well. It’s on of the few brands sold on their website and stores.
Good point!
This is a very good comparison video, Logitech should have paid you for promotion, this video has made a lot of people went for combo touch
That would be awesome! lol
Great comparison video. I learnt so much just by watching your review on every details. You even mentioned the charging port that some cable might have issue with the Logtitech Combo Touch. For its price, I am going to buy the Logitech new Combo Touch for my iPad Pro 11 2018. Thanks, Jerry!
Very nice!
I've watched about 15 reviews of the combo touch and the magic keyboard and this is by far the best review I've seen. Thank you. Subbed.
Wow, thanks!
I have used both the Magic keyboard and the combo touch. Both keyboards have pros and cons but for me the combo touch came out as the winner and here is why.
1. Although the combo touch obstructs the use of the thunderbolt port, i still have access due to the dongle i use does not have to sit flush to the iPad for it to work. It connects via USB type c cord and its one I have used ever since owning the 2016 MacBook Pro. I also prefer the protection the combo touch offers over the Magic keyboard as I work out in the field and not behind a desk. So its nice that I don’t have to worry about dropping my iPad.
2. The touchpad, although the touchpad on the Magic keyboard is slightly more responsive than that on the Combo touch, its nice that it is bigger and I don’t have to carry out as many finger gymnastics when pasting and copying notes.
3. The price. Cheaper is cheaper, and right now savings is king with the added cost of everything due to inflation. It’s nice that the Combo touch is cheaper and offers more like a function row, non obstructed typing, more viewing angles, and the materials do not take on oils and smudges as easily.
I work in field sales, visiting multiple stores in my assigned territory. The combo touch I feel is just more suited for my workflow than the Magic keyboard. Not to take anything away from the Magic keyboard, i just feel the Magic Keyboard is just more suited for those working in a stationary environment.
This is the real definiton of what "comparison" really is.
Good job Jerry
wow, thanks so much.
@@JerrySchulze no worries. Keep it up sir😊
Brilliant comparison video. Hope to see more of the same. This is one video where I'm sure which option to go with!
Amazing comparison. Exactly what I needed to see.
Honestly, when you detached the keyboard I was already on Amazon buying the Logitech 😅😅😅 didn't wait for the end 😅😅
Amazing video
lol, thanks!!
I have the case on the 11 inch M1 and it’s not detachable 😳
@@ThibaultxDxCx I just bought the 11'' Logitech combo touch just this Wednesday. It came supeerrrr early, I was expecting to get it next week but I got it today. The keyboard is definitely detachable, although it is a little hard to get off the hinge and magnets holding it are much much stronger and sturdier than I had assumed 😂 so its a good thing in the long run for sure.
@@ThibaultxDxCx did you buy the Logitech Combo or the Logitech Folio? The Folio is almost identical but the keyboard does not detach.
@@michaeldodd9671 I have been asking this question since forever and i really can’t find an answer 😭 does the folio touch works on 2021 iPad Pro 11 inch
Nothing like needing an additional accessory to protect your $350 accessory.
youre so smart ryan
That’s the Apple way. Surprised you haven’t caught on 😂
Thanks for a very comprehensive comparison! I just picked up the Magic Keyboard because I watch videos in my bed and I’m getting sore arms holding my 2021 12.9” iPad. Now I can do it on my bed table with ease! And yes, the forward tilt is a deal breaker for me!
very cool, Glad I could help!
So glad they released 12.9 inch model, bought it right away when I saw it on Amazon
After five months
absolutely this is the best review of these two cases
Great comparison mate , thanks for posting ,
both keyboard cases look good , i already have the magic keyboard on my air 4 , and i have no complaints it does the job well , although on occasion it has occurred to me it would be nice to have some extra functions like the extra row of keys on the Logitech , and these ipads being fairly expensive devices , i am always wary having a dropsy or some clumsy moment where the ipad may get damaged , so the extra protections on the Logitech keyboard do look attractive .
I have both and the Logitech is better for me, I prefer to push the screen back more, the mouse pad is larger and easier to use, the thing I like the most is the added side protection...
The Logitech’s footprint is it’s largest drawback. I used the Logitech Combo Touch on my Air 3 and that was a complete dealbreaker - and the fact that the magnets keeping the keyboard attached were way too weak on that one. To the point where I switched back to the Smart Keyboard and a Magic Mouse instead.
Agree with the footprint.
I'm mighty tempted by the Apple Magic Keyboard, for purely esthetic reasons. It just looks a thousand times more elegant, and that makes a difference. However, I'll probably go for the Logitech for the price. It's good to hear (from you and some other reviewers) that the keyboard itself is so good.
Just to sway your decision a bit, I’m typing this on a Apple magic keyboard and the aesthetic reasons sell me. Not only that, but it’s infinetly more intuitive. The way the iPad just connects to the case magnetically and works right away is what makes the keyboard feel like an extension to the iPad. I can easily take off the iPad and put it back on without tussling with the case itself. Given its design, the Logitech keyboard really limits you on where you can use it. The Logitech keyboard may be more practical, but the magic keyboard is far more intuitive.
@@abrararifify have you dropped your ipad with the case on with any damages? i’m not sure if i wanna take the risk or not just because of the protection
Thanks for a well detailed review. The only problem I had really with the Logitech is when using the iPad to draw, the kickstand doesn't really offer sturdy enough support. Other than that, its a winner. I hope they fix this in the next gen.
To me, I went with Logitech because the dealer breaker was the magic keyboard has no protection around the edges. My iPad is always in my backpack to and from school! Even on my my motorcycle in my bag, there’s lots of movement. The combo touch I can detach the keyboard as well and has a row of functions gives me more of a laptop feel. The only thing I hate is the hinge of the combo touch makes it tricky for “lap” use so I’m limited with where I can use it as a laptop if not at a table if using on my lap I just pop the keyboard off and use as a tablet :( but Atleast my iPad is protected !
Great video. I think the footprint and angle adjustments on the Magic Keyboard are too necessary for QOL. I think I'd get frustrated with the footprint of the Logitech, even though the case and kickstand would be really nice for writing and that layer of protection. and then having the thunderbolt port on the hinge side is just too cool. I think they are both equally impressive.
Fair enough!
Just got the combo touch for my 2021 iPad Pro and I really like it. If the magic keyboard didn’t cost double the decision would’ve been more difficult. With the features of the combo touch and the price point it isnt’t a comparison in my opinion. Sure the magic keyboard looks nicer, but it doesn’t offer protection, and at that price point it is a massive oversight by apple.
When Apple products are not perfect, that’s because they don’t want them to be. Look for logical applications of this principle. WRT minimal protection for iPad in $300 keyboard case… they want you to drop it, as that means you will NEED apple care, after investing laptop money on a tablet…
@@jomow9335 in the case of the apple keyboard I 100% disagree. It’s all about the aesthetic and the apple keyboard looks futuristic in a non novel way with legitimate functionality.
@@f00f1ght3rs12 perhaps, but for your take to be true, one would have to accept that there was no way to make it sexy AND protected… a claim I reject
Thanks for your review. I really like the extra protection of the logitech case but I really love and need the screen angle adjustability of the Magic keyboard...
Selling point for the magic keyboard is that extra port. I like that I can charge while using the iPad and have an external storage device attached when editing. Also wired headphones are still a thing lol.
I’m so undecided about this... I think I’m getting both!!!
Logitech makes some good stuff, man. They continually innovate. Great stuff.
Thanks!
This was highly informative ! You helped me out tremendously .
Fantastic!
the typing on these two keyboards actually feels quite different. I personally like the trackpad and keys on the magic keyboard much better, but prefer better protection and detachable case on the ligitech
Precisely the info I needed to know. These keyboard cases are expensive. So, it’s important to know all you can as you will be living with it for awhile. One other tidbit I might have missed though. Did you mention the battery drain for both keyboards? If you did, my apologies. Another great video! Thanks, Jerry!
Thanks for watching. I did not mention battery life and sorry for that. With general use I am not seeing any difference in battery life between the 2 but I have not done any formal testing.
@@JerrySchulze Thanks for your quick reply. FYI, I thought the same on the Logitech keyboard sound. It sounded better with it on to me, as well.
It’s louder with the combo case. Maybe that indentation amplifies the sound -
It’s a no-brained…Going with the Logitech. Thanks for the review.
Any specific feature?
This is an excellent comparison video. Thank you very much.
Thank You!
The fact that even when I detach the keyboard with the combo touch my iPad is still protected is big for me.
These iPads are super expensive now making protection ever more important.
The function keys also make for a much better experience
Sold on Logitech back cover 😁😁 beautiful
Hope you enjoy it!
You deserve as many subscribers as MKBHD, man! Such an in-depth review!!
I appreciate that!
Wonderful comparison! Thanks a lot!
thanks for watching
That test of the microphone hole on the bottom…actually the second was better than the first( uncovered) to my ear.
The magic keyboard really puzzles me: lots of added weight for minimal protection, and it makes it impossible / uncomfortable to use one of the iPad Pro’s main features - the pencil. Though the Combo Touch looks like it flexes too much when laying almost flat - it’s not great if your drawing surface moves, and I’d be concerned about the longevity of the hinge.
I use it on the magic keyboard at least 90% of time and am not a big pencil user but totally get that many want to be able to flip it around.
I have an older combo touch and it helps to be able to fold the keys back and use the pencil and you can use the iPad in portrait mode that way. It just doesn’t really stand up in portrait mode. But totally agree with you, I wish the magic keyboard was more protective and then it might be worth it for me. I have a toddler!!!
I wouldn't give a toddler an iPad Pro, lol.
No sound obstruction. Great video.
as much as I was 100% sold on the magic keyboard, after watching comparison videos, including this one, I am now going for the combo touch mainly because of the extra protection. As much as I want the Magic Keyboard for the magnet/ease of detaching, it wouldn't be safe/I wouldnt feel safe doing so OUTSIDE of my house. I could see a scenario if I had extra cash to buy both. But thats definitely not anytime soon lol. Thanks for this
Hope you enjoy it!
@@ballooneyjr4294 i ended up caving but getting a cheaper used one lol. Great buy IMO..it really does add an extra "feel" to it, but still overpriced lol
@@ballooneyjr4294 haha for sure..its just funny because the ipad pro was already a splurge purchase so the idea of paying that much for a keyboard was a big no to me and I was sold on the Logitech one..aaaand look at me now lol. Glad I bought it though!
They both are great and all it depends on your needs. I preferred the Combo Touch because it makes me feel that it protects my iPad. It also feels a little tough and indestructible, Finally, because of my job, the thunderbolt port is not a big deal or something that I need. Great video! :)
Excellent review Jerry - for me the iPad Pro is used when traveling, on the go, or going to meetings so functionality and protection are most important to me - so the Logitech Combo Touch is my choice.
Thanks for sharing!
Typing on the Combo Touch right now! Love it. I think that blocking the bottom mic sounds more clear. Less tinny.
WOW! I hadn’t even thought about flipping the keyboard around. Great idea!
Great review :) Definitely I can understand both Keyboards are truly Awesome. Of course love the Magic also its perfect for me cause so many years used Track Pads and it makes easy instead using the Magic's short cuts. Again Great review!!!
The combo touch is $200 cheaper than the Magic Keyboard in Australia, seems like a no brainer to me.
I’m sold,great job!
The kickstand is a nono for me because I like the flexibility of using my iPad on my lap and on my desk. What happens if you do not have a desk? Just got my magic keyboard for $250 and I'm happy with that.
Very nice!
As someone that has tried to use cases that are not sturdy for ipad for so long and now using a laptop stand with a mechanical keyboard and resting my ipad on it i really want the magic keyboard, its just so much of a hassle of things moving and not being sturdy on a lap
Iam often lying on the sofa having the the combo touch placed on top of me and its absolutely no problem at all.
the fact that you can comepletly take off the keyboard whenever you want and set it to the side or put it on the back is the best part of the combo touch, i think its the best keyboard case design out there IMO. this is like the magic keyboard folio but for ipad pros lol. just a little bit thicker.
Thank you! This video helped me so much! You did a great job in comparing both keyboards:)
I have both keyboards and like both but overall I prefer the Apple keyboard.. I prefer the protection of the Logitech but I prefer how the Magic Keyboard places the iPad Pro much closer to you. If I am traveling I prefer the Logitech as the I am afraid that the White Apple keyboard will get dirty and if in the unlikely case that it dropped the Logitech would provide more protection. Another advantage of the Logitech is that if I am using the iPad without a keyboard then I prefer the protection of the Logitech. I am most likely to drop the iPad if it is not on a keyboard. In actual use I find myself changing almost daily in between keyboards which makes me crazy but I switch cases on my iPhone so I should calm down about this and enjoy both cases for different uses.
Thanks! I have a 2018 12.9 iPad version!
I have the magic keyboard and love it. I do not have any scratches on the sides; nor do I have an issue with my hands touching the screen when I type.
great!
I literally watched this video in Best Buy with both in my hand just trying to justify the extra money to an already expensive Christmas present.
In the end , the Logitech won . Both do the exact same job . But one has a lot more protection.
Great video..
Wow!!! Very cool!
Look, I loved the Logitech case. I got one for my first iPad and another one for the iPad Pro. But let me tell you. It’s not worth it. The edges in my first case, as well as the parts next to the speakers, started stretching out. I though this was because maybe I had accidentally pulled on them, so when I got the second case (hitch is even thinner around the edges) I made sure not to touch them. Still, I had the same exact problem. It’s gotten so bad that one of the edges actually broke, and its stretching out to the point of showing the Inter parts of the case. I got the Logitech keyboard for the cheaper price, kickstand, and very importantly, protection. But if the edges are breaking they might as well not be there. I also checked on Reddit, and this has happened to an extent to so many people. Its ridiculous that a product this expensive breaks within less than a year of purchase, and although I checked and it has warranty, a replacement unit would have the same issue. The case also completely stopped working after the iOS 16 update, and as a student I can’t afford to not be able to write for a week. If you’re on a budget a mouse and a Bluetooth keyboard works wonders. I’ve been using them and it’s incredibly comfortable. I do give points to Logitech in that they have been able to give me a refund, since it has a 2 year warranty, but that’s all I can say about it. The case was really really good while it lasted, but it has no longevity. 2/10
I got both. The magic touch is heavy. The combo touch is lighter in weight. The only annoying part with the combo os getting it open😅
I actually preferred the sound of the mic coming thru the Logitech. A bit more low end. Thanks for the excellent review. Heavily leaning towards the Logitech.
Thanks for watching!
I bought both, but kept the Apple Magic Keyboard. The Logitech is awkward to use on a lap - you have to keep your knees close together and push the keyboard right up into your belly, and the screen feels much further away. The Magic Keyboard also wins on a cramped desk or plane/train tray table.
The Logitech needed a much harder press on the trackpad to register clicks, it was only working for me 1 in 4 presses. It is more versatile though and the material is much more durable.
I agree with everything you said.
Oh thanks so much for saying that. I’m a student and I love apple’s trackpads
I used brydge but the track was not good at all and I highlight 100’s of questions a day
I need a good trackpad
I guess I’ll stick to my magic keyboard then
Such great comparison, covered everything! Must say i would prefer the magic keyboard, just seems easier to use on your lap or in bed. Wish there was something similar for the Tab s7 or the upcoming Tab s8.
Thank you for this video. Based on your video I went and picked up the Logitech model. My biggest complaint about the Apple model is that it provides zero protection for the iPad itself whereas the Logitech model does. It works excellently.
The CalDigit Thunderbolt cable doesn’t work with the ComboTouch, but the Apple branded Thunderbolt cable fits. Just, but it fits. ComboTouch all day.
I bought the magic keyboard on a spending spree and ended up returning it.
Thoughts:
1. Make sure your iPad is not just simply a tablet device to you and you will actually find need for a keyboard
2. Magic keyboard offers very little protection
3. Magic keyboard suede material is NOT sustainable - picks up stains so quickly which is just unacceptable for the expensive price point
This is customer service. You just have been subscribed.
Wow, thanks!
I had the Logi combo case for a day or two on my 11” iPad Pro, but it’s bulky and the kickstand with keyboard it too much to comfortably fit anywhere I wanted it. I upgraded to the M1 12.9” and I have the Magic keyboard. I’ve never actually used a keyboard as much as I do now. This is convenient, easy to use and with the float, it raises enough for me to play the games I like without the keyboard being in the way.
Plus I got it for $200 brand new, so it was a no brainer, lol. I’m considering buying a CoverBuddy so that the iPad itself is protected if it ever falls.
Thats great! I actually have a video on the CoverBuddy.
@@JerrySchulze that’s good to hear. I’ll check that out.
After watching your review for the second time I decided on the Logitech combo touch. I don’t use my iPad laying down.
Well this was the best comparison video for the keyboards
Really? I haven't looked at any others yet.
I had logitech combo touch and found many bugs and issues. I suggest people get apple original accessories to avoid problems
This was a very well done comparison; you covered all of the differences better than any review I have seen. One small thing that would have been useful - the distribution of total weight in the Logitech between the case and the keyboard. I want to know how much weight is added to the iPad when the keyboard is detached. The case makes the iPad grippier when holding in portrait mode with one hand to read. That has to be traded off against the extra weight it adds, making it more tiring to hold up.
I would but I don't have a small scale to test. Thanks for checking it out!
I love both of these cases and have always wanted to have and use Apple's... sadly though I wish they would take elements from Logitech like a full-body shell (that's also detachable) and still have the "magic keyboard" aesthetic and design. I personally just feel like it would make the keyboard case more valuable cost-wise and a great option altogether.
Logi Combo for me ,better protection when out and about , also no one I have watched so far mentions you can remove the Logi keyboard and plug it in backwards and use it for a stand in bed for viewing content or just fold it up against the back of the case for the reading experience . The Logi keyboard also has more room between the function keys and the screen stoping you from accidentally hitting the screen when typing something that can be annoying if you lose an email you are typing . To me the Logi is an all around better pro keyboard . When I am typing it is more the laptop experience with bigger trackpad and just nicer feel . I haven’t had to many issues with it freezing but I don’t have it disconnected for long and happy to use the on screen keyboard in combo when in the iPad mode as I an usually only typing comments like this or short emails . There is room for improvement but neither keyboard has it all . I just like the Logi as it has the most options and the price point makes sense
Nice summary!
I own the logitech and I had no idea until now you could flip the keyboard around!
Great!
I read reviews that Logitech keyboard would randomly disconnect from the iPad or sometimes the iPad wouldn't respond to the keyboard. is it true that it has compatibility issues?
@@talhatariq6420 Yes, sometimes it disconnects at random. It's pretty annoying.