Marilyn Manson performing Coma White and Coma Black live in New York City in January 2008. This show was in support of the 2007-2008 Rape Of The World Tour.
Both of this song speak so loudly to me it's so profoundly beautiful for the disabled me at 55!!! I just found him during my time of need and it's been a life changing experience!!! 💔🖤💔🖤💔🖤
Rob Holliday was definitely the guitarist Marilyn Manson needed to have inside his band in this new incarnation after geniuses as Pogo and Skold and Five left - he was excellent live and I think he could have wrote phenomenal things with him and Ramirez. It's a pity that now the band still a sort of toy of Ramirez and Manson... I loved Marilyn Manson THE BAND... The singer and frontman which takes ahead everything still got an excellent voice, but deeper concepts and songwriting is definitely missing despite some incredible songs.
I hear ya, Rob was awesome. I wish he would've joined Manson as a permanent member of the band. I loved his early 2000's work with Gary Numan. Manson and Twiggy were always the heart and soul of the band, but literally now the only OFFICIAL members of the band. It's refreshing sometimes to get some new blood in there, to collaborate with different people. The new MM album, 'The Pale Emperor', is great because Manson trusted someone else to take the reins; film and television composer Tyler Bates. And Manson and Tyler wrote the album together, without input from even Twiggy. But now that Tyler has exited the fold and gone back to his composing career, Manson and Twiggy should collaborate with someone else on the next record. Since Manson and Billy Corgan are friends again, and MM and the Pumpkins are touring this summer, I don't think it'd hurt to, collaborate with Billy. They almost did on Mechanical Animals, but Billy just acted as consultant and advisor back then, and not musical collaborator.
I'm a guitarist (unlike you, clearly) and I can tell you that the playing was fine. The problem was the tone, which you can blame more on the sound tech than the guitarist. Also it probably sounded a lot shitter because of the mic on the camera. The guitarist did a great job.
4:07 coma black
My dear friend... What a video!!!! I'd love to witness a live perfomance of both songs like this... Thanks for posting this jewel!!!!
I agree.
Both of this song speak so loudly to me it's so profoundly beautiful for the disabled me at 55!!! I just found him during my time of need and it's been a life changing experience!!! 💔🖤💔🖤💔🖤
I was at this concert!!
Damn this is a great performance Mr. Manson holy fuck, especially for 07!
This was posted 12 years ago holy s*** I was already 20 years old
Rob Holliday was definitely the guitarist Marilyn Manson needed to have inside his band in this new incarnation after geniuses as Pogo and Skold and Five left - he was excellent live and I think he could have wrote phenomenal things with him and Ramirez. It's a pity that now the band still a sort of toy of Ramirez and Manson... I loved Marilyn Manson THE BAND... The singer and frontman which takes ahead everything still got an excellent voice, but deeper concepts and songwriting is definitely missing despite some incredible songs.
I hear ya, Rob was awesome. I wish he would've joined Manson as a permanent member of the band. I loved his early 2000's work with Gary Numan. Manson and Twiggy were always the heart and soul of the band, but literally now the only OFFICIAL members of the band. It's refreshing sometimes to get some new blood in there, to collaborate with different people. The new MM album, 'The Pale Emperor', is great because Manson trusted someone else to take the reins; film and television composer Tyler Bates. And Manson and Tyler wrote the album together, without input from even Twiggy.
But now that Tyler has exited the fold and gone back to his composing career, Manson and Twiggy should collaborate with someone else on the next record. Since Manson and Billy Corgan are friends again, and MM and the Pumpkins are touring this summer, I don't think it'd hurt to, collaborate with Billy. They almost did on Mechanical Animals, but Billy just acted as consultant and advisor back then, and not musical collaborator.
I can honestly understand why he choose to going away... the band meaning is stronger in The Prodigy than in Manson...
Great comment I absolutely agree
So beautiful D:
Beautiful Art, i like both songs .
......so the guitar is prerecorded? ....damn notice how his hands stop matching up in the intro?
If we think about it .... how would this sound if it was played by The Sisters of Mercy in their prime ?
Good question
Lol HaHaHa actually play the intro can't even call that a guitar piece
I'm a guitarist (unlike you, clearly) and I can tell you that the playing was fine. The problem was the tone, which you can blame more on the sound tech than the guitarist. Also it probably sounded a lot shitter because of the mic on the camera. The guitarist did a great job.
@@aaronpearson1744 Haha I can say the same and totally agree
totally agree with Aaron. The tone is the issue and also the shitty camera mic