You can see the gorgeous art within this performance. The White Flowers, and the blood all over him. Shows how tragic this song, and the whole album really is. The falling snow is beautiful Also. This song is beautiful. Brilliant. So emotional.
Nemoris Inferioris should have seen it live, I was 15, and the dead to the world/ all America Antichrist tour was fucking the best live show I ever fucking seen to this day.. this is gold , he only did this song a handful of times for this tour and was only played as a closer ..
I just finished reading his autobiography, The Long Hard Road Out of Hell, and in one of his journal entrie's I saw this in my mind. In the entry he writes: "UNDATED For a moment tonight I felt like Christ. It was snowing on me, and I could have been anywhere-Wichita, Berlin, Golgotha. There was a mirror behind the crowd on the wall, and I watched myself like a painting, frozen. The gash in my side bled and bled. It was so beautiful that I cried right there in front of five thousand people. I was letting out the boy who died on his plastic cross in elementary school. He escaped through the hole in my ribs." I couldn't hold back my watery eyes as I read this, and as I watch this beautiful performance. This man will forever be in my heart and an endless inspiration to me.
@@matthewriser1091 Omg lol I, to be honest, wouldn't care about the snow blinding me. I would still have the best time of my life seeing MM live in the 90s. I wasn't even born yet when this concert went on. I wish I was a teen in the 90's but I'm a teen in 2022. Ew. I wish shows were like they were then.
This was Manson's encore song during the Dead to the World Tour. If the crowd cheered long enough he came back out and played this song with the snow machine. It was sick.
He’s not wrong, you have to leave some behind while you fulfill your wishes. Poetry even after this long. Kinda makes me sad but happy I grew up with it.
This song is perfect for the ones in pain physically or emotionally. The tears are flowing releasing and letting it go. A voice for those who aren't able, who have been hushed or shunned. Let it ring loud and strong. Forevermore. Mother Metal
imagine he had completely disappeared after holly wood album (guns god and gov world tour) what an absolute icon he would be. he had that mystery around his persona. just watch in this concert what a piece of art it actually is, the subtle light show, that reveals once in a while the presence of some entity in the back, his face in the shadow and once in a while a synced throb lightens it.. the whole thing is just a piece of art. this sense of mystery had the advantage of pre-internet videos, with vhs resolution and the scarcity of means to access these videos contributing to the persona. I grew up listening to this guy and I feel so privileged for that. I think these kind of artists, the least they expose themselves to the media, the better.
I know I’m too late but it was said he was apparently going to retire after Golden Age of Grotesque album which is why he released his Lest We Forget Best of Marilyn Manson compilation album which would’ve been badass because by that point he had a great career that would’ve been badass retiring with 5 badass albums plus one compilation album that would’ve been a great way to end his career but still it’s not bad that he kept going.
He kind of turned into goofy clown Manson during Holy Wood with surface lyrics like "disposable teens" and "Fight Song". His songs became more about the hook than the meaning. He lost his passion and decided to cash in after Animals. The great imagery was gone after Antichrist and he realized people were not as in love with his glam imagery so he made a desperate attempt to recapture it with Holy Wood. I can't blame him. I would lose energy too after playing with Rose's attributes on top of a pile of cash.
@@tombooty5144 Songs like Disposable Teens and The Fight Song were singles, they're catchy and are what draws in audiences. The Rest of the album is full of some of his best lyricism and the album imo has the most well executed imagery of all albums, the album artwork and Tarot Cards, all to accompany the novel he wrote... Holy Wood imo is his magnum opus. Holy Wood was a declaration of war, retaliation against America and the media. It combined ACSS and MA perfectly to have the glam rock accessiblity that MA had, while having the themes and messages that ACSS introduced and expanded upon them. If anything, TGAOG was him cashing out (Tainted Love cover..), but even that he was totally original and found a way to rebrand himself once again without losing the integrity of his art and message. Hard to go from ACSS-MA-HW-TGAOG and not get burnt out, so it makes sense he wanted to retire from music and move on to other mediums of art. Then in 2005 his marriage fell apart and his mother's health was deteriorating, and he found music to be a limiting way for him to express himself. Like how Jim Morrison wanted to quit music and become a poet. Lucky for us and himself, he kept going, found retribution and made another 6 amazing albums (imo).
Fucking amazing. There are no words. I hope he brings this back to the live set. This year and last year, he's brought back old classics like "Angel with the Scabbed Wings", "Disassociative", "Coma White", "Mister Superstar", and even "The Last Day On Earth".
I listen to this song when im at my lowest and wanting to give up. I suffer a disease that is not curable and will eventually take my life. i have severe pain all over my body. Also have been shunned by family who dont want to deal with my medical drama. Imagine that. This song helps me heal. I cry and let the pain out. Thank you Mr. Manson for this precious gift that is a light of hope for me. Mother Metal
MARILYN MANSON AT HIS BEST. MAKES ME CRY EVERY TIME I HEAR THIS SONG I USED TO BE IN A MANSON TRIBUTE BAND CALLED APPLE OF SODOM AND WE USED TO END OUR SHOWS WITH THIS SONG.
A perfect ending from a perfect album... a collective work of the whole band, in studio as much as in this live, it sounds like they all channelled that kind of desperation.
One of the most stunning live performances Manson, or any musician has ever given! I would have absolutely killed to be there in the audience, crying with him. Definitely one of, if not my favorite song of his.
It was an amazing time. My sister and I went to do many Manson shows. We went to Las Vegas for New Years Eve 1998-1999 Hard Rock/Manson was crazy! I got crushed by a barrier. It was still epic! We were up against the stage. I love this song. I love all of them. This is in my top 10 Manson songs. Coma White, Man that you fear, tourniquet, Get your Gunn, Lunchbox, ..(more)
I love this. I was lucky enough to see him and his lovely band about 5 times back in the day... between 1997 and 1999. In Jacksonville, FL, Orlando, FL, Washington DC, and Denver CO.... And recently in Knoxville (in like 2019)
Same! I mentioned Manson to my mom for the first time in over 20 years about two months ago and she said "Hey! I still have that Marilyn Manson shirt of yours from when you were a kid, if you want it." The first Xmas gift I ever got from my boyfriend back in 1998 (still together 26 years later) was the "I wasn't born with enough middle fingers" shirt. I thought it was loooong gone, but she had put it in a ziploc baggie and saved it for me all these years. When we met up for her to give it to me, I thanked her for never trying to ban me from Manson. She wasn't a fan of all the posters in my room and ACS blasting all day and night, but she never tried to stop me. Thanks mom!
This performance and video is the best ever on youtube. I can relate so much to this song. My past present and future. I say this as im laying here in bed. Too weak to get up and after all ive been through i dont even care. This song helps me deal with it. Thank you Mr. Manson for giving me peace and solace that i so needed. I wanted to go to your concert in Phoenix. Wanted to see. You. The dr wants me to go to the er. Im not going. And it looks like i may not make it to see you. But i do have this video and this beautiful performace. The music and lyrics soothe me. Tears of pain from years of rejection and abuse. To the final moment of having the worst pain and disease known to man that is killing me. So to those who read this. Hey. Keep your chin up keep fighting because you can. Mother Metal
in his book he said the whole time recording this song he was crying his eyes out and in some parts you could here his voice crack so to all of you saying shit about why he stopped seeing it was probably to emotional to finish
@@v10l3t40 The actual Reference is to Minute of Decay. The reason why Minute of Decay is such an emotional song to brian is because his girlfriend at the time had an abortion...
I believe this was in 1997 in saginaw michigan. I was front row. He cut himself during sweet dreams. All the lights came on. I think that they were gonna call the show due to all the bleeding but the lights turned back off and you could feel the snow which was bubbles but couldn't see what it was. It was sooo eerie! I've seen just about everyone in concert but this is still my all time favorite show....I was blown away!
A great ending to a great story! Not my favourite album, but its up there. Moral of story: Don't stoop to others' levels. Be yourself! A constant theme throughout Manson's music over the years! :DDD
Seen him 11 times and he's never played it. He used this flower thing on his mic stand with the snow falling while playing coma white one time tho that was cool
I have said it in the MV of this song and I'll say it here this is maybe my favorite song of all of them and it always brings tears to me because of the passion he puts in this song
I feel like the recorded version doesn’t do justice to the songs meaning. The live version however, seems to capture more emotion and more grit in his voice. I can feel him sort of cry out his true self on stage.
Who do I have to sell my soul to to be him. Wish the world was in a state where someone could be this again and I wish that could be me. Thought at one point that Chris motionless would take his place but that didn't end up being a thing he became more like the new Ben burely lol this is what heaven is to me this is all I could want it to be
Marilyn Manson became famous because of this album and also because of his shock rock acts and his lyrics and in this generation rock and metal music isn't promoted by the music industry anymore.
Since you mentioned that other singer I remember reading RUclips comments back in 2012 and 2014 that his fans were saying he's going to be the next Marilyn Manson and that made me laugh.The difference between them is that when Marilyn made his debut people were terrified of him they thought that he came from the underworld or something and that other singer was never scary or made an impact like Marilyn Manson.
this song is 21 yrs old and still better than today songs
Jimmy Manson Yup
This song is worth much more than all his albums combined since 2002
The people who make music today couldn't imagine thinking of music even close to half as good as Marilyn Mansons music
Jimmy Manson omg way to make me feel old as sh*t
well, that happens to be true, but anyway it's not like the newer the song, the better
Apparently this was Daisy and Marilyns favourite song, RIP Daisy Berkowitz :(
You can see the gorgeous art within this performance. The White Flowers, and the blood all over him. Shows how tragic this song, and the whole album really is. The falling snow is beautiful Also. This song is beautiful. Brilliant. So emotional.
Nemoris Inferioris should have seen it live, I was 15, and the dead to the world/ all America Antichrist tour was fucking the best live show I ever fucking seen to this day.. this is gold , he only did this song a handful of times for this tour and was only played as a closer ..
So real so raw so beautiful so artistic so unique and perfect. Mother Metal
The snow burned my eyes though lol
This album is one of that pieces of art that transcend time.
When all of your wishes are granted all of your dreams will be destroyed
I just finished reading his autobiography, The Long Hard Road Out of Hell, and in one of his journal entrie's I saw this in my mind. In the entry he writes:
"UNDATED
For a moment tonight I felt like Christ. It was snowing on me, and I could have been anywhere-Wichita, Berlin, Golgotha. There was a mirror behind the crowd on the wall, and I watched myself like a painting, frozen. The gash in my side bled and bled. It was so beautiful that I cried right there in front of five thousand people. I was letting out the boy who died on his plastic cross in elementary school. He escaped through the hole in my ribs."
I couldn't hold back my watery eyes as I read this, and as I watch this beautiful performance. This man will forever be in my heart and an endless inspiration to me.
Beautiful 🖤
Sky The Artist this is the deepest comment I’ve ever read on all of RUclips.
@@dasmegacool ahahah really...but MM is this & not only!
That really is so beautiful
@@dasmegacool right
I am speechless. This is the most beautiful performance I have ever seen, I can't even imagine how amazing it would be to be there
It was amazing . I was 15 . The fake snow burned my eyes though lol
@@matthewriser1091 Why did that make me laugh
@@Ih8u1527 I mean imagine experiencing that then being blinded by fake snow lol I bet it looked funny
@@matthewriser1091 Omg lol I, to be honest, wouldn't care about the snow blinding me. I would still have the best time of my life seeing MM live in the 90s. I wasn't even born yet when this concert went on. I wish I was a teen in the 90's but I'm a teen in 2022. Ew. I wish shows were like they were then.
@@Ih8u1527 yeah they definitely aren’t . Music isn’t either . Maybe it will change 💜
This was Manson's encore song during the Dead to the World Tour. If the crowd cheered long enough he came back out and played this song with the snow machine. It was sick.
when all of your wishes are granted, many of your dreams will be destroyed
He’s not wrong, you have to leave some behind while you fulfill your wishes. Poetry even after this long. Kinda makes me sad but happy I grew up with it.
ANTICHRIST SUPERSTAR possibly THE most important album of the 90s. And it Still has not been surpassed for sheer atistic integrity & coolness.
97warlock ismyname nirvana unplugged imo
Watain - Lawless Darkness
97warlock ismyname this album was a high point for me. 1996 forever.
the downward spiral > antichrist superstar
One of the best songs he ever created. EPIC.
This song is perfect for the ones in pain physically or emotionally. The tears are flowing releasing and letting it go. A voice for those who aren't able, who have been hushed or shunned. Let it ring loud and strong. Forevermore. Mother Metal
Exactly! Why I LOVE this song!
Yes
When all of your wishes are granted many of your dreams will be destroyed
That's why I'll always love that man
I want this song played at my funeral
Me tooo! Just requested to.a listening ear wallA go.
you made my death day. haha
Same 😭💔💔💔
🎶✨
You are all sick fuck nerds and need help.
imagine he had completely disappeared after holly wood album (guns god and gov world tour) what an absolute icon he would be. he had that mystery around his persona. just watch in this concert what a piece of art it actually is, the subtle light show, that reveals once in a while the presence of some entity in the back, his face in the shadow and once in a while a synced throb lightens it.. the whole thing is just a piece of art. this sense of mystery had the advantage of pre-internet videos, with vhs resolution and the scarcity of means to access these videos contributing to the persona. I grew up listening to this guy and I feel so privileged for that. I think these kind of artists, the least they expose themselves to the media, the better.
Very well said, I completely agree. There will never be another artist like Marilyn Manson.
I know I’m too late but it was said he was apparently going to retire after Golden Age of Grotesque album which is why he released his Lest We Forget Best of Marilyn Manson compilation album which would’ve been badass because by that point he had a great career that would’ve been badass retiring with 5 badass albums plus one compilation album that would’ve been a great way to end his career but still it’s not bad that he kept going.
He kind of turned into goofy clown Manson during Holy Wood with surface lyrics like "disposable teens" and "Fight Song". His songs became more about the hook than the meaning. He lost his passion and decided to cash in after Animals. The great imagery was gone after Antichrist and he realized people were not as in love with his glam imagery so he made a desperate attempt to recapture it with Holy Wood. I can't blame him. I would lose energy too after playing with Rose's attributes on top of a pile of cash.
*Holy
@@tombooty5144 Songs like Disposable Teens and The Fight Song were singles, they're catchy and are what draws in audiences. The Rest of the album is full of some of his best lyricism and the album imo has the most well executed imagery of all albums, the album artwork and Tarot Cards, all to accompany the novel he wrote... Holy Wood imo is his magnum opus. Holy Wood was a declaration of war, retaliation against America and the media. It combined ACSS and MA perfectly to have the glam rock accessiblity that MA had, while having the themes and messages that ACSS introduced and expanded upon them. If anything, TGAOG was him cashing out (Tainted Love cover..), but even that he was totally original and found a way to rebrand himself once again without losing the integrity of his art and message. Hard to go from ACSS-MA-HW-TGAOG and not get burnt out, so it makes sense he wanted to retire from music and move on to other mediums of art. Then in 2005 his marriage fell apart and his mother's health was deteriorating, and he found music to be a limiting way for him to express himself. Like how Jim Morrison wanted to quit music and become a poet. Lucky for us and himself, he kept going, found retribution and made another 6 amazing albums (imo).
I usually can't stand to watch videos of live shows but DAMN was this unbelievably incredible. I love this man.
Me too n im a male. But i love Peter Steele too. Just id never touch them...only listen. More ppl need to listen and read.
I cant wait till he (hopefully) plays this on his newest tour
Fucking amazing. There are no words. I hope he brings this back to the live set. This year and last year, he's brought back old classics like "Angel with the Scabbed Wings", "Disassociative", "Coma White", "Mister Superstar", and even "The Last Day On Earth".
The flowers he did bring back back. Instead of snow, he wears a white tux while performing coma white.
+Jon Smith also snow
+GLITZandGLOOM he tried to do this song months ago but he stopped i don't know why but he was singing it
lukeysuperfly1999 Yeah, I saw that. It sounded good till it abruptly stopped. And then didn't they just play "Coma White" in its place?
I think he stopped because he forgot the lyrics
I listen to this song when im at my lowest and wanting to give up. I suffer a disease that is not curable and will eventually take my life. i have severe pain all over my body. Also have been shunned by family who dont want to deal with my medical drama. Imagine that. This song helps me heal. I cry and let the pain out. Thank you Mr. Manson for this precious gift that is a light of hope for me. Mother Metal
Stay strong till the last minute... I guess you call it the minute of decay....
Bro stay strong! I'm with you!
Stay strong bro. Life your life to the fullest 🤘
Wish i was already born to attend this
MARILYN MANSON AT HIS BEST. MAKES ME CRY EVERY TIME I HEAR THIS SONG I USED TO BE IN A MANSON TRIBUTE BAND CALLED APPLE OF SODOM AND WE USED TO END OUR SHOWS WITH THIS SONG.
Beautiful, emotional, artistic, expressive and more, I honestly dont think anyone can top his performances
This song still gives me chills and tears in my eyes. Manson will always be a big part of my life.
Me too! Manson is a part of my life since i had 14 years old! Manson fan 4 ever!
A perfect ending from a perfect album... a collective work of the whole band, in studio as much as in this live, it sounds like they all channelled that kind of desperation.
The falling ashes .... no words to describe how powerful and full of real art this performance is...amazing!!!!
One of the most stunning live performances Manson, or any musician has ever given! I would have absolutely killed to be there in the audience, crying with him. Definitely one of, if not my favorite song of his.
It was incredible
This makes me CRY EVERYTIME I LOVE HIM.
It was an amazing time. My sister and I went to do many Manson shows. We went to Las Vegas for New Years Eve 1998-1999 Hard Rock/Manson was crazy! I got crushed by a barrier. It was still epic! We were up against the stage. I love this song. I love all of them. This is in my top 10 Manson songs. Coma White, Man that you fear, tourniquet, Get your Gunn, Lunchbox, ..(more)
I love this. I was lucky enough to see him and his lovely band about 5 times back in the day... between 1997 and 1999. In Jacksonville, FL, Orlando, FL, Washington DC, and Denver CO.... And recently in Knoxville (in like 2019)
Im jealous.
One of his best singing performances of all time. Absolutely amazing. Sadly his voice live today doesn't come anywhere close to this : (
I’m so thankful my parents never censored my music as I blasted this album over and over again as a 12/13 year old.
I feel you. My dad dropped me off at the Mechanical Animals tour and I ended up on the local news being yelled at by protestors.
Same! I mentioned Manson to my mom for the first time in over 20 years about two months ago and she said "Hey! I still have that Marilyn Manson shirt of yours from when you were a kid, if you want it."
The first Xmas gift I ever got from my boyfriend back in 1998 (still together 26 years later) was the "I wasn't born with enough middle fingers" shirt. I thought it was loooong gone, but she had put it in a ziploc baggie and saved it for me all these years. When we met up for her to give it to me, I thanked her for never trying to ban me from Manson. She wasn't a fan of all the posters in my room and ACS blasting all day and night, but she never tried to stop me.
Thanks mom!
this is pure art. and its majestic.
Goosebumps all throughout this performance.
Performance Art
The piano and the synth strings here Always made me cry.
Beautiful video. He was so amazing over and over again. I miss those old days.
This performance and video is the best ever on youtube. I can relate so much to this song. My past present and future. I say this as im laying here in bed. Too weak to get up and after all ive been through i dont even care. This song helps me deal with it. Thank you Mr. Manson for giving me peace and solace that i so needed. I wanted to go to your concert in Phoenix. Wanted to see. You. The dr wants me to go to the er. Im not going. And it looks like i may not make it to see you. But i do have this video and this beautiful performace. The music and lyrics soothe me. Tears of pain from years of rejection and abuse. To the final moment of having the worst pain and disease known to man that is killing me. So to those who read this. Hey. Keep your chin up keep fighting because you can. Mother Metal
"Cotillion Ballroom, Wichita, KS, USA on January 8, 1997 from the Dead to the World Tour" - is this that performance? This is brilliant.
in his book he said the whole time recording this song he was crying his eyes out and in some parts you could here his voice crack so to all of you saying shit about why he stopped seeing it was probably to emotional to finish
singing not seeing
Teliyah Samura what page I have this book I haven't read that though
Teliyah Samura I thought it was Minute of Decay Brian broke down in tears whilst recording. Eh, both still great songs though!
Teliyah Samura why was he crying?
@@v10l3t40 The actual Reference is to Minute of Decay. The reason why Minute of Decay is such an emotional song to brian is because his girlfriend at the time had an abortion...
Imagine if for the 20th birthday of the album he had played this entire setlist. This would have been awesome
2016 was
Dead to the World Tour was THE FUCKING BEST I got to go to 3 shows and I am so lucky for that.
Yes ur correct.
Daría lo sea por verlo con esa energía e interpretación de aquellos ayeres.
Alessandro Lunacy Ya la edad pesa
This mans voice is out of this world, Manson is and always has been my absolute favourite singer of all time.
I believe this was in 1997 in saginaw michigan. I was front row. He cut himself during sweet dreams. All the lights came on. I think that they were gonna call the show due to all the bleeding but the lights turned back off and you could feel the snow which was bubbles but couldn't see what it was. It was sooo eerie! I've seen just about everyone in concert but this is still my all time favorite show....I was blown away!
So gorgeous ❤
Pure genius!! Love this dude, Rip Daisy!!
When I watch this video I know that I will always be a Marilyn Manson fan, whatever happens. It is just too good to be discarded.
Prolly my second favourite performance of his 😍😍😍
Saw him a couple weeks ago, still sounds awesome live. Wish I could have saw him in the 90’s though!
It's been 10 years since this video and I still like it a lot
So poetic and deep
THIS WAS FUCKEN AWESOME
I WISHES I COULDVE SEEN MANSON LIVE
This is pure art
I love the song and Mr. MARILYN MANSON! "Forever he will ROCK"
Never seen any live version of this before, absolutely magic 🖤
The best vocal in concert!!!!
the best live version of a awesome songs! love your video ! :)
He is an absolutely amazing artist
the real MM.... MM are not a one person..... are a metal band!! that incredible ERA !!
I love this song so much, so dark and full of emotion, I love Manson 🖤
Words can't explain how amazing this is!!!!!!!!!!!
Thank you for your encouragement.
Pure unrefined art!
this song rocks me to sleep whenever i cant sleep at all..its so soothing and ugh i just love it
Mindblowing performance
It's been years and I still like this performance a lot and his music as well
A great ending to a great story! Not my favourite album, but its up there. Moral of story: Don't stoop to others' levels. Be yourself! A constant theme throughout Manson's music over the years! :DDD
So fabulous!!!
great quality. makes we want to go back in time and see it live again.
now thats the Marilyn Manson that i remember i miss it so much
they've played it seldom, almost never, great song form amazing album
It's the first time I saw this song in live. Thanks for updated it!
Thanks for posting this very high quality video!!! It brings back memories from seeing this live!!! This is visionary and so original!!!
THANK YOU
2022 🦋
BEST LIVE BALLAD SONG EVER???? SOOOOO FUCKING YESSSS!!!!
Seen him 11 times and he's never played it. He used this flower thing on his mic stand with the snow falling while playing coma white one time tho that was cool
I have said it in the MV of this song and I'll say it here this is maybe my favorite song of all of them and it always brings tears to me because of the passion he puts in this song
This sounds just as good as the recording!
Natasha Lomov its better than the recording on the album I love both though
May I have that snow n flowers 4ever?
This is amazing
I feel like the recorded version doesn’t do justice to the songs meaning. The live version however, seems to capture more emotion and more grit in his voice. I can feel him sort of cry out his true self on stage.
They need to add this to the set on the heaven upside down tour.
A beautiful performance!
I don't know if I ever been in love. If I ask myself such a question, the answer should be obvious.
Superb!
I love that song
this is gorgeous!
When all your wishes are granted many of your dreams will be destroyed...amazing!
One thing I don’t know if I love this Manson or the man I know
se me enchina la piel, bella canción...
We love you 😘 Manson form Glenwood
Pure art
Marilyn Manson is my favorite artist but damn he sung better back then
So beautiful so raw so perfect.
Just love this song!🤘
Awesome performance
holy fuck 20 years ago? I feel old.
Who do I have to sell my soul to to be him. Wish the world was in a state where someone could be this again and I wish that could be me. Thought at one point that Chris motionless would take his place but that didn't end up being a thing he became more like the new Ben burely lol this is what heaven is to me this is all I could want it to be
Marilyn Manson became famous because of this album and also because of his shock rock acts and his lyrics and in this generation rock and metal music isn't promoted by the music industry anymore.
Since you mentioned that other singer I remember reading RUclips comments back in 2012 and 2014 that his fans were saying he's going to be the next Marilyn Manson and that made me laugh.The difference between them is that when Marilyn made his debut people were terrified of him they thought that he came from the underworld or something and that other singer was never scary or made an impact like Marilyn Manson.
so powerful
❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥❤️
not only last , he is firs and last , he is unique !!!