In complete report. Qatar was an old mediator in the region but the report didn't cover their role. Also, the top three importers of oil from the UAE and Saudi Arabia are China, Japan and South Korea, respectively, but apparently, they didn't want to mention South Korea and Japan because they are allies. Misleading reports as usual from DW.
what did you expect. They even pretend that s arabia and emirates care about green this or that.... lol this is the german government tv....... you watch knowingly. It is no secret
Anyone who knows anything about Saudi politics would never say Jamal was a 'fierce' critic. come on lol. As a Saudi, I find it quite interesting how we are framed in your media. anything good for us means something bad for your countries (mostly western ones). what is the problem with the Gulf region championing peace and stability in our corner of the world? a good human would be happy to see less war and suffering.. and you guys sound increasingly just bitter to be frank.
@@mistermood4164 Not just one factor but several factors. 1- Size 2- Population equivalent to the country’s gross domestic product 3- Economic impact 4- Cultural dimension 5- Religious dimension. Saudi Arabia is successful in all of these criteria and may be the only country in the world that combines all of these factors alongside India, but India fails in No. 2
US is dependent on oil from the Middle East. With current consumption, they would deplete oil within few years without importing. The costs would sky rocket and you could barely afford anything in the US.
@@ReuterL Canada is our largest importer. Only the Northeast and West coast import oil from the Middle east. The Rest of the country gets its petroleum from Texas.
Persia historically never had a coastline across the Arabian Gulf, since it is Arabs living on both sides of the Arabian Gulf for thousands of years...
Bruh, persians to this day live on the persian hill, which is north of the coast of Arabian Gulf from iran's side, with minorities living on the coasts even to this very day. Persians themselves also used to call it Arabian sea in their empires times, simply because Arabs live on both coasts. It is only the English who started calling it the persian gulf cause they had lots of interests in persia in colonialism time. So Arabs are calling it the Arabian Gulf because that's what it was historically called and that is how reality is, as both coasts have Arabs living in it, so it only makes sense to call it Arabian Gulf.@@TronUse999
There is no free military support. It is all weapons that are paid for, and no single US soldier ever protected any Gulf country. In fact, when houthis that the west support, threw missiles at Saudi Arabia, the United States said it will withdraw its single patriot anti missile battery from Saudi Arabia and also block further sales of anti air attacks weapons. That's one of the many reasons why Saudis are industrializing very quickly right now and focusing on self manufacturing of their own weapons at the moment. So in reality, there were no security guarantees and it was just words for the most part.
@@Osirise81This is not a legible comment. The video wasn't even anti-Gulf states or anti-Arab, nor pro-West, it was just an explanation of the situation. Did you watch it?
The US military presence is not there to defend the Gulf Sates but rather to defend America's interests and hegemony in the region from powerful Iran in the 1st place, and when necessary to deny China access to energy resources.
None to both😂😂😂😂 both are untrustworthy. China pretends mutual respect is the goal but they're doing the exact opposite with their south east Asia neighbours bullying small countries. Plus the Uyghurs. Same thing with u.s. hahahah😂😂😂.
@@Akikoolet ure totally wrong ,, i m from south asia Nepal and i say china is good neighbour not like india who bullie sri lanka , maldives,nepal and bhutan ! China respects and helps south asia unlike india ! love china from nepal ❤❤❤
It's such a sad thing that this channel show India wrong map but for China it shows Taiwan it's part...... What message this channel want to give or this channel also become Chinese puppet
Yeah, it is annoying to see a western media channel making such a amateur mistake. Probably some intern that bought a map made in China. Taiwan is starting to be shown as separate from China in the west as it should have been long ago. The problem is that China makes most of the maps and globes and purposely shows Taiwan as part of China which of course it is NOT. Same goes for India, many of these western companies cater to China to avoid a reaction but that is bad for reputation.
Hello child, NO WESTERN GOVT RECOGNISES TAIWAN AS A SEPARATE NATION. All those talks are mere politics. Even US still hasn't dropped the One China Policy.
For thousands of years, the Europeans have referred to the Persian Gulf as the Persian Gulf. The United Nations also refer to it as the Persian Gulf. Have the Anglo-Saxons really conquered Germans so absolutely, that Germans now refer to the Persian Gulf as the "Gulf"? What's next, we refer to the Indian Ocean as "the Ocean"?
Although it's fully surrounded by Arab nations including Ahwaz, as an Arab, it's ok to name it Persian Gulf, we have a whole sea called "The Arabian Sea".
Most european countries who engaged in trade called it the “Arabian Gulf” Or “Gulf of Arabia”, Dutch explorers would call it as such and Ptolemy did the same. Besides, who cares what “the un and europeans” call it? The actual people who LIVE on the gulf from both sides call it either “Al-Khaleej” or “Al-Khaleej Al-Arabi” even the Arabs on the iranian side
People in the region call it Khaleej-e Fars which means the Persian Gulf. @bonafidemonafide7810 Even the populations within the Arab countries that live by the Persian Gulf are either Iranian, Shi'ite or both. @@bonafidemonafide7810 There are no Arabs on the Iranian side. The so-called "Arabs" in Khuzestan are genetically, linguistically and culturally Iranian.
There is saying that says "DO NOT PUT ALL YOUR SEEDS IN ONE PACKET". Gulf countries should not rely on western countries only because you don't tomorrow or the day after tomorrow.
As an American I can honestly say we envy the UAE. It’s like old America. Safety is valued, morals are valued, capitalism is encouraged and as such is growing like crazy. America has abandoned all of these and is burning quickly.
It's clear that the report overlooks Saudi Arabia's robust defense capabilities. With a formidable military force of over 1 million soldiers and advanced manufacturing of UAV planes, Saudi Arabia stands ready to defend itself against any external threat, be it from Iran or any other nation. Moreover, Saudi Arabia's vast size underscores its capacity to safeguard its borders effectively.
It's said that national guards in KSA don't spend a night at the troubled area to monitor enemies hence they have other nationals to carry on the same.
"It's disappointing to see such a biased report targeting the UAE and Saudi Arabia. There seems to be a double standard at play here, where Western countries impose arbitrary criteria to judge others while turning a blind eye to their own shortcomings. It's important to recognize the progress and positive contributions these nations have made, rather than solely focusing on negative narratives."
@@FNA27601a country like Saudi hosts the 2 holy mosques of Islam and is considered the leader of the Arab world, they have way more leverage than any Nordic country has
The truth is since 2011, Gulf countries are trying hard to suppress the change in the region (e.g. Egypt) by all means. I don't see that playing the superpower balance games would stablize the region by any means. Completely opposite, this suppression of change will end up of an explosion of the whole region. Simply because it is coming from the bottom either by violet or peaceful means. Just a matter of time.
@@Wasengenyie and Egypt too. I have seen how the Saudi security has been scared after the Egyptian revolution in 2011. They have "arrangements" with military dictators.
there is a lot to say, but this video is a sponsored video. S Arabia is the property of a small number of people .... they take oil out and play with it like highschool kid who wins the lottery lol. They give money to friends to keep them happy. And spend money on luxury things ( like christiano ronaldo ) and dreal about futuristic things. In the meantime, there is no economy, no local labour market, no own industries. Just expensive buildings and sports things and weapons they won't dare to use.
@@Lucy-iy9ni what areife is saying is a obvious fact and is in the open. If you follow the region even very superficially, you know this. Except the fact that change from the bottom is very very unlikely in the gulf countries in the coming decade or so.
Also, Saudi Arabia is not small. It's larger than germany france and italy combined. This is why calling it a gulf state is misleading. It's Arabia. Additionally, it has the largest economy in the region.
All I see is positives. Positive moves toward sustainability and investment in green energy Positive political moves to de escalate tension in the region and have good relations with the entire world, rather than war and conflict. But what does not please the west they will simply call it Human rights abuse.
Let middle east alone these countries are independent and sovereign . DW so bias maybe you for Afghanistan and Iraq two America failure . America only create problem in middle east 😳
The gulf states success is only short term. Their wealth comes from oil, a resource both limited, and increasingly being phased out by other renewable resources. Not to mention their cities are only sustainable through imports.
Your extreme was: Where is natural resources? How can we get them, use them, blackmail world for them. My vision was: How can I make them. There was no match. You die for word Money. This is just nothing where world has been reached till today
Are they experts !! You guys missed the new deploamtic relationship formed between Saudi and Iran? 😂 So much biased content!! Western very much interested in oil money!
It may be bothering to ask but on what constitutional grounds Jammu Kashmir is part of India? Go through United Nations resolutions, then you will take turn off from fools paradise. Kashmir is disputed region unless govt. Holds a plebiscite there.
They act as if they divided in interest but behind closed doors they are serving one agenda. Saudi is Islam nation’s capital so they have a control in that department. UAE basically controls Yemen, Egypt, Syria, Sudan, and Libya. Qatar managing to be a darling of NATO and Global South. Connect the threads and see who is the beneficiary 🤷🏻♂️
@@sumomaster5585 of course they do, there’s no denying that even among EU they share the same feeling about alpha position. But they aren’t delusional in terms of common interests, what benefits one spills over to the other.
@@NoMadKid you saw the blockade against Qatar? the competition between Dubai and KSA over tourism...etc? The region wouldn't hold so little influence and be so weak if they worked for the same goals.
Saudi Arabia today is a balance of power, but it is on the right path to becoming a global power. Several factors enable any country to become a global power: 1- Size 2- Geographical location 3- Population compared to the GDP 4- Economic influence on the world 5- Cultural dimension 6- Religious dimension 7- Military power. Saudi Arabia is one of the rare countries in the world that combines all of these factors, but it is still weak at number 7. There is India, but it is weak at number 3.
How the West makes me laugh when it talks about the capabilities of our army to defend itself. We are a nation that has conquered half the world and we can fight any country, but without America the Europeans will not be able to survive a single day without Russian occupation.
imagine going into an embassy to get your marriage documents, and coming out chopped up in pieces in a handful of briefcases... beautiful. that makes for people that seem trustworthy/friendly.
Access to oil for the US!? What kind of bad journalism is this? Maybe access to oil for US allies. The US is an oil producer by themselves and has access to oil in South America, too. It is access to oil for you dear Germany. So that you won’t invade other countries anymore. Remember that time?
The 1954 resolution of the constituent assembly was followed by the incorporation of Section 3 in the constitution of Jammu and Kashmir which reads: "The State of Jammu and Kashmir is and shall be an integral part of the Union of India.” show the correct map of INDIA. 🇮🇳
this video is excellent and very instructive! however, it should discuss more about soft power. These gulf states extensively use this aim to attract, compete, eye-catch and build opportunities ! they are becoming supersoftpowers
An insightful report. Yet sadly still riddled bias. Also as a media organisation, if they want to call the local palestinian resistance terrorist, then they need to call the occupying power a colonist.
Little Putins here, little Putins there, little Putins everwhere. Me, me and me, me, me, me. There simply can't be a good end to a world that is mainly run by narcissism. Politics in 21st century is still just warmongering, quite primitive. Truly numbing status.
it's all about the DOLLAR! Both the U.S and Gulf benefit from selling oil using the dollar... the Dollar is worth nothing without the oil and the Gulf would not be enriched with security without the U.S
FYI: As a matter of fact, Iran (AKA Persia in the Western text) was formed in 550 BC by Cyrus, The Great. Since then, Iran has been the 1st nation state in the history of humanity and of course, the only nation state that has maintained its language, Parsi (AKA Persian) while others such as Egypt failed and became Arab. . When did Iran die? Did you join the mourning ceremony? England, the Old Fox, has invented your Arab country post WW I under Sykes -Picot's secret agreement. Enjoy. @@jitendratiwari6886
@@Italsat4861Thank you for providing us with this useful information. We have now begun to study further about Sykes-Pico. Special respect to Iran from Finland ❤
Whatever happens the constant truth is US Monopoly is going to over soon. These Middle Eastern Power or The Indian Subcontinent and The Mighty China going to evolove the policy making in near future. DW is so polarized in this particular documenteris .
You can’t say it’s all bcz of oil, most Arab countries r rich in oil, Venezuela, Iran and many other countries. You can say that these countries used oil moneys and invest it in their ppl.
In complete report. Qatar was an old mediator in the region but the report didn't cover their role. Also, the top three importers of oil from the UAE and Saudi Arabia are China, Japan and South Korea, respectively, but apparently, they didn't want to mention South Korea and Japan because they are allies. Misleading reports as usual from DW.
U mean south/Japan are western colonies and yes DW is propgrnda
what did you expect.
They even pretend that s arabia and emirates care about green this or that.... lol
this is the german government tv....... you watch knowingly. It is no secret
And what does it change? It means about supply dynamic.
@@Bell_plejdo568p South Korea specifically and yes Japan too but South Korea is literally a US colony
qatar is american puppet
Anyone who knows anything about Saudi politics would never say Jamal was a 'fierce' critic. come on lol. As a Saudi, I find it quite interesting how we are framed in your media. anything good for us means something bad for your countries (mostly western ones). what is the problem with the Gulf region championing peace and stability in our corner of the world? a good human would be happy to see less war and suffering.. and you guys sound increasingly just bitter to be frank.
Well explained.
Its for western powers for us we always need peace 🙏✌️
Germany sees everything in a negative light. Look how they treat Namibians. Or how they talk down to USA and then demand USA protect them from Russia.
Westerners and good humans? Antonyms
Jamal was indeed a critic, have you read or watched anything he wrote or expressed? why do you think he was assassinated?
Why does the report use a negative tone about the Gulf countries ?
Typical
They didn't bro
This is a critical journalism, take it as it is
because they think they know better both of them are on their 30s and think they understand us
To serve the narrative of western media, ohh DW is the western media itself
They never mention Arabs with high regards
Oman and Qatar is biggest mediator in gulf but I guess they didn’t pay the reporter
not really its mostly the uae
qatar was shunned by the entire region for years
I never saw Putin in Oman or Qatar. They ain’t power house
@@hashemgr3
Who knows 💭???
Oman?😂
Saudi Arabia is NOT small county by any sense of the word. It's one of the biggest countries in the World by land mass.
it is by population
75% of it is useless sandy desert, cannot be used for anything
@@mistermood4164 Not just one factor but several factors. 1- Size 2- Population equivalent to the country’s gross domestic product 3- Economic impact 4- Cultural dimension 5- Religious dimension. Saudi Arabia is successful in all of these criteria and may be the only country in the world that combines all of these factors alongside India, but India fails in No. 2
Even Kazakhstan, Australia and antartica r big in size, what matters is how much your economic output is
25 million people and 90 percent of saudi arabia land is useless .
Correction @4:53, USA was not the "key partner" but rather the "key exploiter"
They are visionary leaders and knows how to manage oil wealth. Otherwise the fate would be like Venezuela, Iraq Iran Libya etc
Iran Iraq Libya were the American and the west crimes. have nothing to do with managing oil wealth.
0:40 "Despite their small size ..." That's what she said!
😂😂😂
But it's true. Their population size. Their wallet size on the other hand.... is not small.
@@HuiChyr they have no army . uae is an oversized parking lot lmfao
@@justinereisler5930 what is the problem 🤔most european countries also don't have army
Saudi's size is equal to the W.Europe . The NEOM project is larger than Britain, which is equivalent to a tourist resort within the project 😂
The US is not dependent on Middle East oil. China and Europe are very dependent on it.
The Northeast and every State west of the Rockies are still dependent on middle eastern oil.
The US is run by these lobbyists, APIAC, UAE, Saudi and Qatar
It's more about the petro dollar trade deal.
US is dependent on oil from the Middle East. With current consumption, they would deplete oil within few years without importing. The costs would sky rocket and you could barely afford anything in the US.
@@ReuterL Canada is our largest importer. Only the Northeast and West coast import oil from the Middle east. The Rest of the country gets its petroleum from Texas.
if the U.S. wasnt so evil, i dont think this would be a problem.
Saudi Arabia Forever.... Yes they're a global SUPER POWER!!!! AND THEY'RE WINNING
Mashallah 🥰🇸🇦
stop calling Hamas terrorist and Israeli as security forces
So in other words they're diversifying their political partners just like they're trying to diversify their economic.
Nothing more
MBZ is not young he is 60 😂 what kind of story is this??
Mediocre report at best. Adds almost nothing but provided a lot of misleading info and avoided many important ones.
Persia historically never had a coastline across the Arabian Gulf, since it is Arabs living on both sides of the Arabian Gulf for thousands of years...
No they did and still do
Bruh, persians to this day live on the persian hill, which is north of the coast of Arabian Gulf from iran's side, with minorities living on the coasts even to this very day. Persians themselves also used to call it Arabian sea in their empires times, simply because Arabs live on both coasts. It is only the English who started calling it the persian gulf cause they had lots of interests in persia in colonialism time. So Arabs are calling it the Arabian Gulf because that's what it was historically called and that is how reality is, as both coasts have Arabs living in it, so it only makes sense to call it Arabian Gulf.@@TronUse999
they're juggling knives here, but they seem pretty good at it...
Truly clever and cunning if I may say.
Good strategy - military support from the US and strong trading relationship with China.
There is no free military support. It is all weapons that are paid for, and no single US soldier ever protected any Gulf country. In fact, when houthis that the west support, threw missiles at Saudi Arabia, the United States said it will withdraw its single patriot anti missile battery from Saudi Arabia and also block further sales of anti air attacks weapons. That's one of the many reasons why Saudis are industrializing very quickly right now and focusing on self manufacturing of their own weapons at the moment. So in reality, there were no security guarantees and it was just words for the most part.
Such a bias report!!
I have no view and have not formed an opinion on this. Please, tell me what subjects are biased.
@@Osirise81 Thank you for info.
@@Osirise81ur confusing countries military industrial complex with an economic forum 😂 hilarious!
@@Osirise81This is not a legible comment. The video wasn't even anti-Gulf states or anti-Arab, nor pro-West, it was just an explanation of the situation. Did you watch it?
@@skullsaintdeadit was clearly misinforming orientalist and anti-gulf
US leadership vs China mutual respect. Whod you rather?
U mean US domination
@@Bell_plejdo568p they like to call themselves "leader" of the freeworld as if it elected by others
The US military presence is not there to defend the Gulf Sates but rather to defend America's interests and hegemony in the region from powerful Iran in the 1st place, and when necessary to deny China access to energy resources.
None to both😂😂😂😂 both are untrustworthy. China pretends mutual respect is the goal but they're doing the exact opposite with their south east Asia neighbours bullying small countries. Plus the Uyghurs. Same thing with u.s. hahahah😂😂😂.
@@Akikoolet ure totally wrong ,, i m from south asia Nepal and i say china is good neighbour not like india who bullie sri lanka , maldives,nepal and bhutan ! China respects and helps south asia unlike india ! love china from nepal ❤❤❤
It's such a sad thing that this channel show India wrong map but for China it shows Taiwan it's part...... What message this channel want to give or this channel also become Chinese puppet
I liked it so much
Yeah, it is annoying to see a western media channel making such a amateur mistake. Probably some intern that bought a map made in China. Taiwan is starting to be shown as separate from China in the west as it should have been long ago. The problem is that China makes most of the maps and globes and purposely shows Taiwan as part of China which of course it is NOT. Same goes for India, many of these western companies cater to China to avoid a reaction but that is bad for reputation.
What's right or wrong？everyone in the world are brainwashed, power decide everything 😅
Cry
Hello child, NO WESTERN GOVT RECOGNISES TAIWAN AS A SEPARATE NATION.
All those talks are mere politics. Even US still hasn't dropped the One China Policy.
So what China did to bring Iran Saudi close,then me countries don’t need USA's security guarantees anymore 😂😂
For thousands of years, the Europeans have referred to the Persian Gulf as the Persian Gulf. The United Nations also refer to it as the Persian Gulf. Have the Anglo-Saxons really conquered Germans so absolutely, that Germans now refer to the Persian Gulf as the "Gulf"? What's next, we refer to the Indian Ocean as "the Ocean"?
Although it's fully surrounded by Arab nations including Ahwaz, as an Arab, it's ok to name it Persian Gulf, we have a whole sea called "The Arabian Sea".
Most european countries who engaged in trade called it the “Arabian Gulf”
Or “Gulf of Arabia”, Dutch explorers would call it as such and Ptolemy did the same.
Besides, who cares what “the un and europeans” call it? The actual people who LIVE on the gulf from both sides call it either “Al-Khaleej” or “Al-Khaleej Al-Arabi” even the Arabs on the iranian side
People in the region call it Khaleej-e Fars which means the Persian Gulf. @bonafidemonafide7810 Even the populations within the Arab countries that live by the Persian Gulf are either Iranian, Shi'ite or both. @@bonafidemonafide7810
There are no Arabs on the Iranian side. The so-called "Arabs" in Khuzestan are genetically, linguistically and culturally Iranian.
There is saying that says "DO NOT PUT ALL YOUR SEEDS IN ONE PACKET". Gulf countries should not rely on western countries only because you don't tomorrow or the day after tomorrow.
As an American I can honestly say we envy the UAE. It’s like old America. Safety is valued, morals are valued, capitalism is encouraged and as such is growing like crazy. America has abandoned all of these and is burning quickly.
The map of India you showcased shows who pays your channel and who you guys fear the most. Shame
Kashmir is not India 😂
It's clear that the report overlooks Saudi Arabia's robust defense capabilities. With a formidable military force of over 1 million soldiers and advanced manufacturing of UAV planes, Saudi Arabia stands ready to defend itself against any external threat, be it from Iran or any other nation. Moreover, Saudi Arabia's vast size underscores its capacity to safeguard its borders effectively.
I'm not anti suadi but those 1 million military personls are vulnerable as they're not hard battled.
It's said that national guards in KSA don't spend a night at the troubled area to monitor enemies hence they have other nationals to carry on the same.
Couldn't agree more.
The western economy is taking a deep dive. European cities are showing big signs of that.
Learn to show correct map, before making these biased reports. 🤬😡
Let it be,what they can do?.it's show frustration on india.😂 they can't touch india. Let this racist show there helplessness.
Let it be. Nazzzu can't do anything else.
What is wrong?
Kashmir is not a part of india bro
@@acrobat6217even Lahore will one day be a part of Bharat
"It's disappointing to see such a biased report targeting the UAE and Saudi Arabia. There seems to be a double standard at play here, where Western countries impose arbitrary criteria to judge others while turning a blind eye to their own shortcomings. It's important to recognize the progress and positive contributions these nations have made, rather than solely focusing on negative narratives."
Why do you use a scary background music ????
The Chinese Yuan is the second most used currency in the world .The Yuans overtook the Euro.
Dream on!😂
Idiotic, Yuan is half the global trade of tiny Australian Dollar lol
A communist currency like Yuan will never dominate the world, because of the single reason that it is a communist currency.
@@icu17siberia
That's because Xi seizes the property of a Chinese billionaire whenever he wants.
Alibaba is prime example.
doubt it ... millions of chinese move to Europe but millions of Euro people never move to China
Saudi Arabia and UAE are not the gulf’s mediators, that’s Oman and Qatar
These Arab states have a lot of leverage and i mean a lot : OIL
And also global assets and investments. They're like Norway in a sense but with far more global leverage.
@@FNA27601a country like Saudi hosts the 2 holy mosques of Islam and is considered the leader of the Arab world, they have way more leverage than any Nordic country has
@@keymot1491 yes that's what I said
India and UAE is now some what alley now.... Deepens its friendship in all areas...
India is not an important country.
What a weird ominous musical tone in the background. Just give us facts, save the theatrics.
The truth is since 2011, Gulf countries are trying hard to suppress the change in the region (e.g. Egypt) by all means. I don't see that playing the superpower balance games would stablize the region by any means. Completely opposite, this suppression of change will end up of an explosion of the whole region. Simply because it is coming from the bottom either by violet or peaceful means. Just a matter of time.
Throw in sudan, Somalia, Yemen, libya, sahel. They will never allow democratic governments in Arabic speaking countries.
@@Wasengenyie and Egypt too. I have seen how the Saudi security has been scared after the Egyptian revolution in 2011. They have "arrangements" with military dictators.
there is a lot to say, but this video is a sponsored video.
S Arabia is the property of a small number of people .... they take oil out and play with it like highschool kid who wins the lottery lol.
They give money to friends to keep them happy. And spend money on luxury things ( like christiano ronaldo ) and dreal about futuristic things.
In the meantime, there is no economy, no local labour market, no own industries.
Just expensive buildings and sports things and weapons they won't dare to use.
Where did you hear this and do you belive that BS?
@@Lucy-iy9ni what areife is saying is a obvious fact and is in the open. If you follow the region even very superficially, you know this. Except the fact that change from the bottom is very very unlikely in the gulf countries in the coming decade or so.
Iran was never an enemy to us during Shah time (King of Iran), it is only when Khomeini came to the Government which he represent the minority Shia .
Isn't Iran majority Shia.
Gulf states mostly believe in money. I don't blame them.
lol as if western countries believe anything else 🤣
That's just countries 101
What? I thought they believe in Alah.
While the West believes in colonialism, stealing others’ money, and genocide
@Boymanjusri not at all 😊
Saudi Arabia is not really a gulf state. It sees itself as the hegemon of the gulf states and ruler of arabia.
Also, Saudi Arabia is not small. It's larger than germany france and italy combined. This is why calling it a gulf state is misleading. It's Arabia. Additionally, it has the largest economy in the region.
As a saudi I want to thank you for the clear explanation, you've done well.
What you call Authoritarian Nations provide for their populations what Western Democracies populations dream of.
Persian gulf state ! Are you media ? :)
Gulf countries should stop their dependency on western countries which have double standards when it comes justice and freedom for the region
All I see is positives.
Positive moves toward sustainability and investment in green energy
Positive political moves to de escalate tension in the region and have good relations with the entire world, rather than war and conflict.
But what does not please the west they will simply call it Human rights abuse.
china and middle east lacks human rights
Doesn't please the West🤗
Great analysis! Thank you for your work!
what was the analysis?
Let middle east alone these countries are independent and sovereign . DW so bias maybe you for Afghanistan and Iraq two America failure . America only create problem in middle east 😳
The gulf states success is only short term. Their wealth comes from oil, a resource both limited, and increasingly being phased out by other renewable resources. Not to mention their cities are only sustainable through imports.
@@razorburn7745 don't warry they' will be strong cause they don't steal african resource like european countries
Your extreme was: Where is natural resources? How can we get them, use them, blackmail world for them.
My vision was: How can I make them.
There was no match. You die for word Money. This is just nothing where world has been reached till today
Are they experts !! You guys missed the new deploamtic relationship formed between Saudi and Iran? 😂 So much biased content!! Western very much interested in oil money!
Jammu and Kashmir is the Intergal Parts of INDIA please try to use proper Map of United India...
Why are you pleasing that's their fault
Lmao no
It may be bothering to ask but on what constitutional grounds Jammu Kashmir is part of India?
Go through United Nations resolutions, then you will take turn off from fools paradise.
Kashmir is disputed region unless govt. Holds a plebiscite there.
😂😂😂 and delhi is part of pakistan
@@ahmad4436then come to Delhi and taste 93k past😂😂😂😂😂
Your report discloses your wrong assumption or bad agenda
They act as if they divided in interest but behind closed doors they are serving one agenda.
Saudi is Islam nation’s capital so they have a control in that department.
UAE basically controls Yemen, Egypt, Syria, Sudan, and Libya.
Qatar managing to be a darling of NATO and Global South.
Connect the threads and see who is the beneficiary 🤷🏻♂️
not really, they are fighting over who is the top dog.
@@sumomaster5585 of course they do, there’s no denying that even among EU they share the same feeling about alpha position.
But they aren’t delusional in terms of common interests, what benefits one spills over to the other.
@@NoMadKid you saw the blockade against Qatar? the competition between Dubai and KSA over tourism...etc? The region wouldn't hold so little influence and be so weak if they worked for the same goals.
Saudi Arabia today is a balance of power, but it is on the right path to becoming a global power. Several factors enable any country to become a global power: 1- Size 2- Geographical location 3- Population compared to the GDP 4- Economic influence on the world 5- Cultural dimension 6- Religious dimension 7- Military power. Saudi Arabia is one of the rare countries in the world that combines all of these factors, but it is still weak at number 7. There is India, but it is weak at number 3.
Nah, that country is cursed by geography, it's just pure desert fully dependent on imports for everything.
Both Saudi Arabia and India never want to assert itself as a Global power like 🇺🇸 🇷🇺 🇨🇳 (Old Soviet Britain ) .
How the West makes me laugh when it talks about the capabilities of our army to defend itself. We are a nation that has conquered half the world and we can fight any country, but without America the Europeans will not be able to survive a single day without Russian occupation.
Stay out of ukrain then europe will be secure.ukrain belarus russias sphere of influence.
Good one, thanks!
imagine going into an embassy to get your marriage documents, and coming out chopped up in pieces in a handful of briefcases... beautiful. that makes for people that seem trustworthy/friendly.
Access to oil for the US!? What kind of bad journalism is this? Maybe access to oil for US allies. The US is an oil producer by themselves and has access to oil in South America, too. It is access to oil for you dear Germany. So that you won’t invade other countries anymore. Remember that time?
Such a condescending, inaccurate and biased report you have here.
Report it for bias report and showing wrong map.
The amount of bias in this report is through the roof.
their trying to twist the narrative so bad 🤣🤣🤣
How can you leave out the fact that the gulf states were weaponizing their oil...
Us is weaponizing their bobms
Such a good report, ty!
No it’s propgrnda
my nephew of 8 could do a better report than this...... this was a sponsored video.
The 1954 resolution of the constituent assembly was followed by the incorporation of Section 3 in the constitution of Jammu and Kashmir which reads: "The State of Jammu and Kashmir is and shall be an integral part of the Union of India.” show the correct map of INDIA. 🇮🇳
who cares? 1 state won't change much anyways 🤷
Western + Persian reporting on Arab affairs = loud barks 😂
its name is PERSIAN gulf not arab gulf
Western Iran is an originally Arab region called Al-Ahwaz It was occupied by Iran
Germany is Americas vassal state.
Not middle east
this video is excellent and very instructive! however, it should discuss more about soft power. These gulf states extensively use this aim to attract, compete, eye-catch and build opportunities ! they are becoming supersoftpowers
GCC is a strong power house
Let me guess you intention
Gulf and Iran mending the relationship ❌
Stability / development in the Middle east ❌
More money for Lockheed ✅
India providing groceries to Gulf states as well as the world where the Indian living.
3:02 Apologies for visibility, Ireland & Scotland factors and LEEDS real estate
An insightful report. Yet sadly still riddled bias.
Also as a media organisation, if they want to call the local palestinian resistance terrorist, then they need to call the occupying power a colonist.
3:22 "So Called Global South" ??
Why you west country only talk about problems in middle east.
Great documentary, I was hoping for more comments on how sar fared in leading the war against Yemen and how it ended
If you mean their goals of containing Yemen’s revolution then Id say they fared well, the ending seems to be a peace with political concessions
So when we go solar these areas will have no use at all since they have zero human rights law n order and value added skill???
😂😂😂😂. If they use their oil legacy cleverly they can do a lot.
plain wrong
the gulf state have tens of trillions of dollars invested around the world, they'll be fine. plus we will use fossil fuel for quite sometime.
look who respect human rights and law🤣what a nonsense bro look your country then talk about human rights
Report prepared by amateurs. Nothing new nor real analysis.
Little Putins here, little Putins there, little Putins everwhere. Me, me and me, me, me, me. There simply can't be a good end to a world that is mainly run by narcissism. Politics in 21st century is still just warmongering, quite primitive. Truly numbing status.
Persian golf
it's all about the DOLLAR! Both the U.S and Gulf benefit from selling oil using the dollar... the Dollar is worth nothing without the oil and the Gulf would not be enriched with security without the U.S
"Aukaat" is the word for dw
Hahahaha those slappers wouldn’t even be equal in the countries they’re promoting
The Middle East owe the USA alot. I mean a lot.
Like?
3:20 Taiwan is not part of China.
There is no Arab gulf , only Persian gulf.
True. It's just Persian Gulf❤ Respect from Finland.
It's UAE gulf.. not arab or Persian gulf..
there is no Persia anymore it died long time ago when Persia became Iran
FYI: As a matter of fact, Iran (AKA Persia in the Western text) was formed in 550 BC by Cyrus, The Great. Since then, Iran has been the 1st nation state in the history of humanity and of course, the only nation state that has maintained its language, Parsi (AKA Persian) while others such as Egypt failed and became Arab.
.
When did Iran die? Did you join the mourning ceremony? England, the Old Fox, has invented your Arab country post WW I under Sykes -Picot's secret agreement. Enjoy. @@jitendratiwari6886
@@Italsat4861Thank you for providing us with this useful information. We have now begun to study further about Sykes-Pico. Special respect to Iran from Finland ❤
3:20 show the real map of India dw
What on Earth is "The Gulf" when every map in every history book ever has recorded the correct name of it which is "The Persian Gulf"!
مهلا، هذه ليست دول الخليج العربية: قل ذلك بشكل صحيح: الدول العربية في الخليج الفارسي. كن حذرا، هذا هو التحذير الأخير.
This was good.
A good review but lacks the aspect of covering Türkiye in the balance :D
its not a gulf state
very poor research. 😂
why on your map occupied teritories of Georgia are shown as a separate states?
Whatever happens the constant truth is US Monopoly is going to over soon. These Middle Eastern Power or The Indian Subcontinent and The Mighty China going to evolove the policy making in near future. DW is so polarized in this particular documenteris .
You can’t say it’s all bcz of oil, most Arab countries r rich in oil, Venezuela, Iran and many other countries. You can say that these countries used oil moneys and invest it in their ppl.
Correct 👍 but they pointed out how they relied on the USA 🇺🇸 which Iran and Venezuela never did
Ye sab nehru se sekhe h ek South Africa ka tha pehle vo bhi middle man tha😂
India increased foreign exchange through the time approaching to 500 billions mainly grocery exports.
FYI, it is called the Persian Gulf, not the Gulf! It has been since ever. You haven't got used to it yet?
Meanwhile India is playing in his own way😂
Mediator 13:15