Neil Peart VS Mike Mangini - Drum Battle
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- Neil Peart and Mike Mangini are both famous professional drummer. Who do you think is better? For me there is no better than the other because they are both great in their own ways of drumming.
Neil is the greatest rock drummer I've ever heard and witnessed
Neil all the way
Peart. Period. No contest.
Not even close!
Neil is the best drummer ever! 😊
.look at this, 60 plus years old. The GOAT! Case closed!
Peart was and always will be the best!!!
I like Neil better, but Mike is more technical by a pretty large margin.
As a drummer, I watched them closely. What can I say about Neil? What can anybody say at this point, Neil is a true legend of all time. He built my own drumming more than anyone. His style is more magnetic to me than anyone else. But Mangini is no pushover, as he holds a world speed record, and he is extraordinarily complex. He is responsible for taking Dream Theater to a new level, and has became my favorite living drummer. Watching Neil so much, and almost every concert in Ga since 87', I must give him the candle. What he brought to the genre is unparalleled, and his ambidextrous activity in timing blows my mind. If I had to choose one for my band, I'd probably just choose Neil with no regrets.
The fucking professor❤❤❤❤
There may be faster drummers but Peart had speed and style. Will never likely be bested.
Neil❤️
No one ever will and no one ever has played the drums like neil
There are many great drummers but when you see and. Listen to Niel not just his solos moreso his drumming in their songs you realize no one can touch him. He is a god
Amazing master drummers 👍❤❤👍
Sorry mike will never have the breath of Pearts work and influence he's just another guy that can perform lots of beats per minutes with no hits or any lasting memorable songs albums . SORRY and actually I don't know of any hits this guy has played on .
Well that’s just a piss poor answer because that has nothing to do with drumming ability. You’re comparing the success of a drummer’s band to the actual ability of a drummer.
Conheço NP o outro não sei quem é.
Both are phenomenal musicians. In my opinion, we all win with their music.
One is a legend and one is still building his legendary resume. I am sure both would agree with this, music is one of the purest forms of love, and love is a pure, selfless desire for others to be happy, without expecting anything in return. It's about what you give not what you get. Or as Coach Alex Atkins once said "It's not who you are, it's what you do, but who you are, shows through what you do."
Mangini is good but Neil is on another level period!
Yikes.
Impossible to arrive at an actual conclusion. However, as a drummer of 40 yrs, one can observe tremendous independence and technical prowess of Mangini (never heard of him - appears more in alignment with AVH than Peart) HOWEVER his solo doesn’t appear purposeful outside of those elements. Neil’s solos are a masterpiece of continuity and transitions, musicality and diversity along with all of that independence and technique. First saw him in 1980 coming off of Hemispheres and prelude to Permanent Waves. Needless to say, his skillset and approach had great influence on me.
Neil stands alone as a Lyricist/drummer and Composer Unfortunately Mikes Drumming will go over many people's Heads
Neil will always be the Professor of drums, period!
mangini skill and speed 2 bass drums better than pearl. Try listening to DT album the Alien album. I'm also a drummer who can't play like him
Neil is # 1 in so many ways even Bonham was a close second and I saw both in their prime....!!
Neil peart's drum solo's were so well thought out, more musical than anyone else's. You can say the same for his drum parts for rush songs as well. That's why peart is held in such high esteem. There are drummers who are just as skillful, if not more so. But they cannot compose a drum part like neil.
As a drummer, Neil built my playing better than any other. But Mangini is no push over - he holds the world speed record. He's responsible for taking Dream Theatre to another level. In the end, having seen Neil so many times, I must give him the candle. There are things in his solo that I'm still trying to figure as far as ambidextrous movements in timing; A true extraordinaire. timing
Neil Pert is the GOAT 🐐
Peart will always be the best and famous " The Professor " ...btw ;)
It's not the best comparison. Mangini is a machine, but Neil is an artist. Mangini plays as if he were reading a punch card, but Neill creates a pleasure for the ear and the soul.
That's not accurate. Listen to Mike's compositions in Dream Theater and how well-thought out and dynamic as well as creative they are. They are built to not only serve the song but elevate it and compliment all the complex parts in a band with much more diverse styles than Rush. He's also great at groove when it is a simple part. Taste is subjective but you can still appreciate how much passion and attention to detail Mike put into the last 3 Dream Theater albums if you listen carefully.
The other drummer, I bet was inspired by Neil.
Neil Peart was and always will be „The Professor of Drums“ God bless❤
Love both of these guys and am glad I am alive during their lifetimes!!
Mike sure sounds like he spent a lot of time studying Neil. RIP the greatest percussionist ever, Neil Peart
Neil. Not the most technical drummer ever - many can play faster or more complex. Neil could write drum parts that probably nobody could ever write as good or better. He was lyrical in his playing; actual drum ‘hooks’ like a melodic hook, that people fell in love with. I lost some interest after Moving Pictures, and I’m not a huge fan of his later solos compared to earlier Peart. But he was the Professor and a Maestro of music and a poet of song lyrics. I wouldn’t compare anyone to him. He was on an island of his own. One of the greatest and most unique rock drummers ever.
I think, when you’re trying to compare drummers at this level, you really can’t say that one is better than the other. It’s more subjective, it’s a matter of who you like better and I like Mike Mangini slightly more than Neal Peart. That’s just my opinion.
Agree, too many styles, etc.
I would say that Neil composition is far more refined and limb independence makes him incredible. He’s not the fastest or most explosive.
Watching this video, Neil was the busier of the two plus Neil's solos sound like songs and not just random drumming. Like someone once said, a drummer uses a metronome, a metronome uses Neil Peart. RIP PROFESSOR❤
Peart more creative, that's what makes him great. Technically many drummers can play but the creativity sets them apart
I'm a drummer and all I can say is they are both a 1000 times better than me . ha 🥰
maginas solo was boring as Shit!!!!1,
No contest
In my opinion the only other drummer that even comes close to Neil is the one and only Mr. Buddy Rich
Neil will always hold number 1.
The Professor! RIP
Neil...hands down.
He also wrote most of the lyrics to their songs.
A video about two different men. You say "he"... Nice.
Neal Peart was a huge influence on me as a drummer and is my favorite of these two, BUT, he never had the technical skills of a schooled drummer such as Mangini. I was a little embarrassed for him at the Buddy Rich Memorial as the schooled jazz players out played him with school taught technical skills. I suspect that's why Steve Smith encouraged him to go get lessons .
It is not about being g the best it’s about what each drummer contributes to the band
Wrong.
@eriklarson9137 No he's right. I don't think Rush would've been as great as they were without Neil. Not only did he bring a complex level of drumming, he wrote a majority of their lyrics. You can see an immediate change in Rush's music from the first album to Fly By Night. Their music became way more intricate. He definitely made a difference in their approach to how they wanted to sound. Am I wrong??
I remember the moving pictures tour when Rush played at the Target center in Minneapolis in 1981, I believe if my memory serves me right, all the air drummers in the crowd were indeed something to behold.
Mike mangini the Best
SUPER!!!
Pointless hands down Neil the GOAT..........
I agree the music you like colors your choice
No comparison, The Professor can't be touched.
Not even close!
@@jamesspalten5977 blah, blah, blah
P E A R T the best
Neil está só....
As always, when the Professor is sitting behind a drum kit, class is in session. There is no comparison between student (Mike) and Neil (Professor).
Melhor colocação que já vi.
Mike Mangini is literally a professor and has been for decades now. I love both but you must be (understandibly) delusional to call Mike Mangini the student and Neil the professor just because Mike is younger and learned to play from bands like Rush (and many other styles of music that Neil could not play). Listen to Mike's concepts on teaching drums, his experience teaching at Berklee and around the world, his books, educational DVDs, etc... and how he explains his approach to composition in Dream Theater, which is incredibly detailed and creative/dynamic. Again, I absolutely love both and without Neil and Rush, Dream Theater and drummers like Mike would probably not exist, but to ignore all he's accomplished since 1990 (34 years or more) is just plain irrational. This happens because of the emotional connection to Rush's music and Neil's impact as an artist and innovator, but again, you have to realize that Mike is actually a much more accomplished teacher who Neil could have taken lessons from if he were still alive, especially when it comes to improving his technique, balance, stamina, flexibility and accuracy around the drumset (and more). Check out Mike's teaching concepts.
No disrespect to Mike. But I mean come on.
Mike portnoy
Mike all the way!!
Really 😂🤦🙄
Technically, Mangini is light years better but Peart was a master at his craft equally.
Peart is the greatest of all time, not even debate worthy😮 It’s Neil Peart at the top and then everyone else……….