Ningning is still young, she can still develop her technique to an extend. Based on what I know, they(aespa) are still undergoing vocal lessons. Hopefully we'll see improvements soon
finally someone recognize lina’s vocal ability, i’ve been enjoying kpop since the beginning and she’s still one of the best vocalist i’ve ever witnessed by far
The grace was such a talented group, I would love for a newer group to cover boomerang or even one more time okay. My everything the vocal runs at the end are EVERYTHING, To bad SM fucked them over, The Grace could have been everything and more.
csjh's case was mostly a series of unfortunate events Steph's back injury, and allegedly Dana-Steph's feud that makes them torn between two Dana-Sunday (though Sunday was okay with all of them) and Lina-Stephanie It saddened me during those 5 years of their active days, they only have 1 full album the only group I can think of who could pull off their song is mamamoo, if not then it's collaboration of girl groups main vocalists for their ballad song like my everything and 5 cm, or all rounders who have great vocal for song like one more time okay, dancer in the rain, girl talking, piranha
Her mix and hv isnt that bad, tho her lower register is just that well developed and effortless. Even the unsupported D3 in dreams come true suprised me. Her range is just so beautiful and wide overall 😍
I can see that NingNing is truly inspired by Beyonce by how developed her lows is. But idk who is she inspired by her mix... Probably Selena Gomez maybe
Mostly ariana grande lol, or maybe other chinese singers she know. Im not generalizing but most chinese singers i hear use light coordination which made their sound light
Taeyeon is my fav singer of all time. Most of her songs are a style I just do not enjoy, but I love everything she releases because I just love her voice so much. She stands out to me for something she’s been praised for a lot: her ability to express emotion.
I would give Wendy an edge on lower register to Luna, since Wendy is consistent with F#3/G3 and can keep tone even down to E3. But anyway, great video. Hope you will do a vocal ranking of JYP I would love to see your opinions on them.
A JYP ranking would be interesting. Their vocalist are not so far one from another Jamie, Yerin, Lily, Haewon, Sunye are close (I'm not saying that they are interchangeable or something),Yeeun is not at the level of them but she is better than Jihyo, who certainly is better than Min who also is definitely stronger than Lia.
@@allykelly right that Eb3 caught me off guard. and even when she doesn’t support like notes under F3, the ease she has down to D3 is really crazy and also the tonality? her lower range really is something special
@@kledi3817 The bE3 carried support although there's a slight lowered larynx but not too much that there's no support! Her Lower register is for sure crazy for her age I can only imagine how it'll be when it matures later on
Ningning’s low is decent even compared to her legendary unnies! I am wondering why people do not give her above average even if she is the most developed in low register in 4th gen, although her mix is not as strong as others. Honestly, her mix is not bad though!!
@@hexagonalc5703 NN has a pretty clear Tone I believe she will have F3/F#3 in future cause like NN doesn't have a problem going down until Eb3s! hope SM gives NN more solo covers.
Thanks for watching ❤️ what's your Vocal Ranking of these ladies? To summarize 1. Lows Ningning>Wendy=Luna>Taeyeon>Lina>bada 2. Belting Lina>Luna>Taeyeon>bada>Wendy>ningning 3. Head voice Luna=Lina>Wendy>bada>Taeyeon>ningning 4. Agility Lina>Taeyeon>Wendy=ningning>Luna>bada Overall Lina>Luna>Taeyeon=Wendy>Bada>ningning
still wondering why SM not doing another SM The Ballad because I really want female vocalist for SM The Ballad vol. 3 imagine if SM still do SM The Ballad in 2016 and the line up would be Lina, Taeyeon, Luna, and Wendy 🥲 I am wondering with the other three CSJH members vocal analysis because it was always mostly Lina
Ningning low is so outstanding for her age and vocal type. I can't imagine if she gets older and her voice gets much more weight and fullness. I think all the aespa members have good low registers so it could be like Ningning>Karina>Giselle>Winter
Bit of a weird ranking to be honest, Lina is definitely the strongest SM vocalist here, but if you're going to segment them into their registers. Dana from CSJH has by far the strongest lowest register. CSJH the Grace were acapella and did so much harmonizing. Lina's vocal ability is strongest for her ranges, but Dana is far stronger than any of them for lower registers. One of the best in K-pop groups as agreed and according to Kpop Vocal Analysis website
Their supported range Lina G#3-Eb5/E5-A5 Luna G3-D5/Eb5-A5/Bb5 Taeyeon G3/G#3-C#5/D5-F5/F#5 Wendy F#3/G3-C#5/D5-A5 Bada A3-C#5/D5-F#5 Ningning F#3/G3-B4/C5
even though its late…… but my ranking is 1-the grace’s lina (A). Good 2-F(x)’s Luna. (high A-). P-G 3-S.E.S’s Bada. (A-). P-G 4-snsd’s teayeon. (B/B+) AA-P 5-red velvet’s wendy (B/B+) AA-P 6-aespa’s ning. (^C+) high A-AA
i wouldn’t say Lina is the most agile vocalist in SM Entertainment at all, unless you’re talking abt female only but for a moment it sounded like you were saying just in general. it’s kyungsoo if males are included
Also at 5:34, didn't you mention previously that Bada is a mixer?? I know she does belts but you've said that she mostly uses a mixing coordination. How would you equate mixing to belting if belting is essentially "better"??
@@allykelly okay thanks!!! If she was to be a mixer around C#5/D5, would you still say that she's better than Wendy in the Belting/Mixing department?? I'm still not sure how you guys here equate mixing and belting 😅😅
I don't agree that Bada and Wendy are on the same level on belting. And I don't hear any great chest development from Wendy. Bada is much more open, while Wendy has some serious issues with vowels and tensions. Other than that, great video!
Well that's why I'm more leaning towards Bada but Wendy has lil more chest and fullness but yes i still chose Bada tho just wasn't really sure or who's the clear winner
Wait so based from the comments here, your overall ranking of them is: 1. Lina 2. Luna >= Bada 3. Taeyeon 4. Wendy 5. NingNing Or is this only on Belting?
@@berceuse9620 ehh nevermind i was wrong i forgot that the comment above was asking about the ranking of those girls who are from different companies 🤣
I'm sorry but I'm curious it is just me or not, but your voice is too small, I have turned up my PC volume to max but it's still small. others are normal
@@eyebrowstj then bye she still has serious issues with lifting soft palate and producing projected/less muffled sounds. Your Wendy is on your PFP and that attitude says it all 😍
@@allykelly what's the ranking between seulgi(red velvet) , jihyo (twice) and winter (aespa), particularly in the belting department . I suppose jihyo is mid A while other two are high A .
@@allykelly owwww :( Well, u didnt get attacked by lambs on ur last mariah video? But im not forcing u tho, i mean I myself have been attacked by lambs in reddit aswell😬
@@allykelly awww, im glad u didnt delete ur mariah video. Bcs some lambs are making vids spreading misinfos abt Mariah's overall skill, and these fans are toxic to bone oh god
@@allykelly For me the lambs and Whitney stans are toxic ( I say this as a fan of both ) . Celine fans are more chilled. I do agree with Mariah being last if you look at it from vocal technical point of view (She is still my favourite 😪 ). Mariah lacks consistency but on her best days I believe that she is better than Celine. IMO Celine is the most complete vocalist in the vocal trinity but Whitney was the better belter ,headvoice user, better dynamics , best resonance . Whitney was also the most consistent live performer in her prime. For me Prime Whitney > Prime Celine >= Prime Mariah ( Celine over Mariah for consistency, better headvoice and better low notes )
Luna is a dancer, she majored in dancing. SM scouted her because of her dancing skills. If we placed all-rounders, 1. Luna (main vocalist, main dancer hip hop, can rap, best stage performer, great musical actress, songwriter) 2. Wendy (main vocalist, best rapper in her group, good dancer 3. Ning Ning (main vocalist, dancing is average and can rap) 4. Bada (main vocalist, dancer, good musical actress) 5. Lina (main vocalist, dancer, good musical actress) 5. Taeyeon (main vocalist, an average dancer)
I'd say 1.Luna (obviously) 2. Bada (her raps are great especially in aespa cover + her dancing 3. Wendy (good vocal and rap) 4. ningning (decent vocal and good dancing) 5. Lina (great vocal)
@@allykellyif it’s an actual all rounder list I wouldn’t say taeyeon is above nn. Yeah taeyeon is a far better vocalist but taeyeon is an average idol dancer, I don’t think she ever rapped. NN is slightly above average dancer and can do an okay rap so i would say nn is more all rounded
Wendy is so underrated, people only know best vocalists of SM such as Bada and Taeyeon and rarely talk about her. Even in her group, she is considered as the two least popular members despite of her amazing vocal. I hope they acknowledge her and respect for her talent someday
Also, if Jessica was included, wouldn't Dana have to be included too? I'm pretty sure she was a Main Vocalist too (or it's another member and I'm confusing their names)
give the ranking to whoever you feel deserves it but Taeyeon is still that Btch. She's the only soloist in SM I know to have reached 200M strems on YT, most wrded solist under SM, OST Kween, nd most of'll, sold out concert king.
I'm a soneMy but I do agree that overall ranking taeyeon got the 4th place..but maybe third along with wendy, lina and luna is better altough their gap isn't that big
@@allykelly yeah but Wendy is more consistent with support imo, NingNing can get a lil muffled below G3/G#3, not always but it can happen, Wendy has been very consistent down to F#3/G3 during her career, i dont think there is a big gap but just for the quality of support id rank Ning 2nd
@@liftedb9591 umm which performances when she get muffled only 1/2 performances her good F#3/G3s still outnumbers Her bad G3s ningning has Been having quite a lot of F#3s in savage and her English cover not to mention ningning has one Eb3 that sounds easy and clean Heck even Luna is more consistent than Wendy but Wendy support lower and a bit fuller at best
@@vampiregaming9820 Luna can belt too she just belt less than these 2 Luna has more development than Taeyeon above D5 I'd say Eunji is equal to Luna since both have D5/Eb5
Im fine with his pronounciation its just that his volume is kinda low compared to the clips' volume💀i have to turn my volume up to the highest then suddenly one of them is belting and my ears are bleeding💀
Lina> Luna=Bada> Taeyeon> Wendy> Ningning... OGGs were the best i think.
@allykelly What made you change your mind about Wendy and Taeyeon being the same level and Bada being ranked 4th?
@@darkmoonlight2377 more consistency, cleaner approach
Ningning is still young, she can still develop her technique to an extend. Based on what I know, they(aespa) are still undergoing vocal lessons. Hopefully we'll see improvements soon
Yes some said about that. They still get vocal lessons.
Every can improve.
Look at Tiffany ♡
finally someone recognize lina’s vocal ability, i’ve been enjoying kpop since the beginning and she’s still one of the best vocalist i’ve ever witnessed by far
by the way i enjoy your video, pretty much agree with everything
Omg that’s why i love ningning’s lower register. Her magical tone just shines
LINA csjh the grace so underrated :(
She is
That Bb5 from Luna is just so lovely.
It is
The grace was such a talented group, I would love for a newer group to cover boomerang or even one more time okay. My everything the vocal runs at the end are EVERYTHING, To bad SM fucked them over, The Grace could have been everything and more.
Couldn't have said it better 😭❤️
csjh's case was mostly a series of unfortunate events
Steph's back injury, and allegedly Dana-Steph's feud that makes them torn between two Dana-Sunday (though Sunday was okay with all of them) and Lina-Stephanie
It saddened me during those 5 years of their active days, they only have 1 full album
the only group I can think of who could pull off their song is mamamoo, if not then it's collaboration of girl groups main vocalists for their ballad song like my everything and 5 cm, or all rounders who have great vocal for song like one more time okay, dancer in the rain, girl talking, piranha
NingNing development on her lows is a justice for her mix😭
omg😭
Her mix and hv isnt that bad, tho her lower register is just that well developed and effortless. Even the unsupported D3 in dreams come true suprised me. Her range is just so beautiful and wide overall 😍
I wish her mix will be improved soon
In this last comeback she has support sone D5s and Eb5 once. I think she will be improved
@@ceci7488 oh really when?
@@kittygalore7344 it's good, she does well up to C5/C#5, but it's not comparable to the other girls ligsedt
luna and lina are so good, sm lead/main vocalists are sublime
I can see that NingNing is truly inspired by Beyonce by how developed her lows is. But idk who is she inspired by her mix... Probably Selena Gomez maybe
Ariana grande or Madison beer are probably who inspired her in belting. Selena Gomez is a bad belter sorry not sorry
@@allykelly hes joking 😂
Mostly ariana grande lol, or maybe other chinese singers she know. Im not generalizing but most chinese singers i hear use light coordination which made their sound light
@@kittygalore7344 NingNing said once that she is influenced by the western artists. So it's probably Ari or she is just holding herself back
@@Dimyixx yea its mostly ari, she mentioned onetime on the showcase that the artist she loves is Ari
Taeyeon is my fav singer of all time. Most of her songs are a style I just do not enjoy, but I love everything she releases because I just love her voice so much. She stands out to me for something she’s been praised for a lot: her ability to express emotion.
I would give Wendy an edge on lower register to Luna, since Wendy is consistent with F#3/G3 and can keep tone even down to E3.
But anyway, great video.
Hope you will do a vocal ranking of JYP I would love to see your opinions on them.
I already said i learn more towards Wendy but overall they're almost equal in lows
A JYP ranking would be interesting. Their vocalist are not so far one from another Jamie, Yerin, Lily, Haewon, Sunye are close (I'm not saying that they are interchangeable or something),Yeeun is not at the level of them but she is better than Jihyo, who certainly is better than Min who also is definitely stronger than Lia.
12:02 SO POWERFUL
this video introduced me to lina and now I'm a big of csjh so thank you so much
Big fan*
nings lower range is so amazing if she ever has a solo i need her to do use it A LOT
Agree it's surprisingly solid and strong for her age
@@allykelly right that Eb3 caught me off guard. and even when she doesn’t support like notes under F3, the ease she has down to D3 is really crazy and also the tonality? her lower range really is something special
@@kledi3817 The bE3 carried support although there's a slight lowered larynx but not too much that there's no support! Her Lower register is for sure crazy for her age I can only imagine how it'll be when it matures later on
Ningning’s low is decent even compared to her legendary unnies! I am wondering why people do not give her above average even if she is the most developed in low register in 4th gen, although her mix is not as strong as others. Honestly, her mix is not bad though!!
Ningning lows are superior compared to her unnies her mix just has flaws
@@allykelly Yes hope to see Eb3/E3 in her consistent range in the near future lol
@@hexagonalc5703 NN has a pretty clear Tone I believe she will have F3/F#3 in future cause like NN doesn't have a problem going down until Eb3s! hope SM gives NN more solo covers.
@@d.o3675Even D3s are so easy for her
Thanks for watching ❤️
what's your Vocal Ranking of these ladies?
To summarize
1. Lows
Ningning>Wendy=Luna>Taeyeon>Lina>bada
2. Belting
Lina>Luna>Taeyeon>bada>Wendy>ningning
3. Head voice
Luna=Lina>Wendy>bada>Taeyeon>ningning
4. Agility
Lina>Taeyeon>Wendy=ningning>Luna>bada
Overall
Lina>Luna>Taeyeon=Wendy>Bada>ningning
You repeat Wendy twice on head voice.🤣🤣🤣
@@FeelsLikeHeavenFeelsLikeHell fixed haha
@@allykelly are u agree with this video I am pretty sure this isn’t correct.
ruclips.net/user/shortsyusriMWd9Oo?feature=share
@@allykelly and Karina don’t support B4 right?
@@zeroc00k14 i never heard her doing any
still wondering why SM not doing another SM The Ballad because I really want female vocalist for SM The Ballad vol. 3
imagine if SM still do SM The Ballad in 2016 and the line up would be Lina, Taeyeon, Luna, and Wendy 🥲
I am wondering with the other three CSJH members vocal analysis because it was always mostly Lina
Ballad genre is not famous in this generation of Kpop. They only do Ballad for B-side.
Ningning low is so outstanding for her age and vocal type. I can't imagine if she gets older and her voice gets much more weight and fullness. I think all the aespa members have good low registers so it could be like Ningning>Karina>Giselle>Winter
Bit of a weird ranking to be honest, Lina is definitely the strongest SM vocalist here, but if you're going to segment them into their registers. Dana from CSJH has by far the strongest lowest register. CSJH the Grace were acapella and did so much harmonizing. Lina's vocal ability is strongest for her ranges, but Dana is far stronger than any of them for lower registers. One of the best in K-pop groups as agreed and according to Kpop Vocal Analysis website
Dana has better lows but her belting and hv sounds really weak compared to Lina that's why she fall short
@@allykelly I mean yeah, but she has C5/C#5's for me.
@@aenning currently no she even get tense at Bb4
@@allykellythat's soo sad. she used to have good consistency up to C#5 in her prime, pretty sad she regressed that much.
Great video again!! Thank you so much, please keep up the awesome videos!
Thank you 😍
Can we get an updated of this ranking? I know Ningning improved a lot.
4:35 OMG THAT EB3
Their supported range
Lina
G#3-Eb5/E5-A5
Luna
G3-D5/Eb5-A5/Bb5
Taeyeon
G3/G#3-C#5/D5-F5/F#5
Wendy
F#3/G3-C#5/D5-A5
Bada
A3-C#5/D5-F#5
Ningning
F#3/G3-B4/C5
Tbh NingNing is safe with C5/C#5
@@ceci7488 the C5/C#5 are are too iffy and small tbh
@@ceci7488 not rlly, she can be messy even below B4
@@ceci7488 I thought the same.
After Coachella, I changed my mind
Ning has C5/C#5, please stop lying on her lmao
even though its late…… but
my ranking is
1-the grace’s lina (A). Good
2-F(x)’s Luna. (high A-). P-G
3-S.E.S’s Bada. (A-). P-G
4-snsd’s teayeon. (B/B+) AA-P
5-red velvet’s wendy (B/B+) AA-P
6-aespa’s ning. (^C+)
high A-AA
Yap, totally agree
i wouldn’t say Lina is the most agile vocalist in SM Entertainment at all, unless you’re talking abt female only but for a moment it sounded like you were saying just in general. it’s kyungsoo if males are included
I forgot to say Female 💀💀 sorryyy
16:37 best Bb5
My ranking:
1. Lina
2. Luna
3. Taeyeon
4. Wendy
5. Bada
6. Ningning
Actually bada is above Taeyeon and wendy
linaaa
Also at 5:34, didn't you mention previously that Bada is a mixer?? I know she does belts but you've said that she mostly uses a mixing coordination. How would you equate mixing to belting if belting is essentially "better"??
Bada mix above E5 but yes i was to clumsy about Bada her high pitched/childlike voice fooled me she's actually full up to C#5/D5
@@allykelly okay thanks!!! If she was to be a mixer around C#5/D5, would you still say that she's better than Wendy in the Belting/Mixing department?? I'm still not sure how you guys here equate mixing and belting 😅😅
@@jayjade6003 you can replay the part that I'm more leaning towards Bada since i wasn't sure about the clear winner but yes she's better
I don't agree that Bada and Wendy are on the same level on belting. And I don't hear any great chest development from Wendy. Bada is much more open, while Wendy has some serious issues with vowels and tensions.
Other than that, great video!
Well that's why I'm more leaning towards Bada but Wendy has lil more chest and fullness but yes i still chose Bada tho just wasn't really sure or who's the clear winner
Umm 💀 do u understand what ur saying bcz……..
@@subliminal5543 wym
Omg not me using the queen emoji
@@subliminal5543 BYE
Love it!,Can you do Yuju for the next vocal analysis :)
I can on the other days maybe
@@allykelly oki and I'm surprised there's no blue here i thought Taeyeon actually had resonance- and if Yuju was here which place would she be in 🧐
@@hinacharmbraceletera283 no the video isn't focused on resonant/ringing but many of these notes are well done
@@allykelly ohhh ok but how high can they all produce resonance?
@@hinacharmbraceletera283 umm
Taeyeon D5
Wendy C5
Bada D5
Lina E5
Luna Eb5
Wait so based from the comments here, your overall ranking of them is:
1. Lina
2. Luna >= Bada
3. Taeyeon
4. Wendy
5. NingNing
Or is this only on Belting?
Belting
was that eb3 from ning ning supported also? cause then damn
I don't detect any air sound or shoving larynx down so yeah it's a pretty nice Eb3
Yup carried support for sure, there's a slight lowering of the larynx but not enough to cause it not be supported
16:40 forever iconic head voice moment
Lead vocal version please
On my list
Low
1 tifanny G3/G#3
2 seulgi G3/G#3
3 seohyun G3/G3
4 winter A3
5 kristal A3/Bb3
6 sunny Bb3
Mix
1 Seohyun C5
2 Sunny Bb4/B4
3 winter Bb4/B4
4 tiffanny/ seulgi Bb4(B4)
5 kristal A4/Bb4
Upper
1 sunny F#5/G5
2 seohyun E5(F5)
3 tifanny D5
4 seulgie N/A
5 winter N/A
6 Kristal N/A
Overal
Seohyun^^^tifanny ^sunny^seulgie^winter^^^kristal
Who has better lows between Ningning and Eunji?
Eunji
@@allykelly what are the strength of Eunji's low that NN doesn't have?
@@vampiregaming9820 fullness and projection
@@allykelly who has better resonance between Lina and Kim yeonji?
@@vampiregaming9820 Lina
Would you say the notes around 5:16 are done in a mix coordination?? They don't sound as "gritty" like her other notes nor do they sound as powerful
It's belt but light
@@allykellythanks!!! But idk it sounds more like a mix to me 😭😭
@@jayjade6003 well just like how u see Lara above D5
@@allykelly I think Lara would sound like that if she doesn't have a good belting technique and great resonance too 😭
@@christoffermillerante1772 Lara is a great example of how light belt is properly done
How would NingNing lows compare to Uji, BoA and Jamie (15& Jimin)
Umm
Uji>boa>ningning>jamie
@@allykelly boa from spica or soloist, i heard that spica boa girl also has good lows
@@berceuse9620 umm is spica from sm ent?
@@allykelly oops forgot to mention no she isn't 😭 since jamie was mentioneed i just included her
@@berceuse9620 ehh nevermind i was wrong i forgot that the comment above was asking about the ranking of those girls who are from different companies 🤣
I'm sorry but I'm curious it is just me or not, but your voice is too small, I have turned up my PC volume to max but it's still small. others are normal
Can you rank Top 10 best lower register among female kpop vocalists according to you ?
I will make a video about it
is wendy improving at all😭 and extend that to the rest of rv too if you can
She just stay intact
@@allykelly
Wendy has improved a lot since coming back from her accident. This channel is so biased. I'm out 🤣🤣🤣
@@eyebrowstj then bye she still has serious issues with lifting soft palate and producing projected/less muffled sounds. Your Wendy is on your PFP and that attitude says it all 😍
@@allykelly is Wendy's Eb5 consistent or not?
@@twiceot9111 no she can get messy on D5 area even
I wonder if you can do JYP version of this
I can if i get more materials
How would you rank Jessica Jung ( snsd's 2nd main vocalist ) ?
Below ningning
@@allykelly she's a high a-aa right ?
@@allykelly what's the ranking between seulgi(red velvet) , jihyo (twice) and winter (aespa), particularly in the belting department . I suppose jihyo is mid A while other two are high A .
@@yeminchanna4662
• Lows
Seulgi >>> Jihyo > Winter
• Mid-Range (Mix)
Winter* >= Seulgi >> Jihyo
• Headvoice
Seulgi > Jihyo > Winter*
• Agility
Winter >= Seulgi > Jihyo
overall Seulgi >= Winter > Jihyo
@@d.o3675 seulgi >= winter in mix
is ningning in top 10 or top 15 when it comes to female kpop vocalist lows?
Top 15
Where's Jessica, she was main vocalist too😭☠️
1st main vocal only
Can u do this again but this time its the Vocal Trinity😊
Yes i can but kinda afraid that I will get attacked by lambs cuz Mariah is the weakest in the trinity
@@allykelly owwww :(
Well, u didnt get attacked by lambs on ur last mariah video? But im not forcing u tho, i mean I myself have been attacked by lambs in reddit aswell😬
@@kittygalore7344 i did and I had to delete some comments but I'll try tho trinity is the reason why I learn singing
@@allykelly awww, im glad u didnt delete ur mariah video. Bcs some lambs are making vids spreading misinfos abt Mariah's overall skill, and these fans are toxic to bone oh god
@@allykelly For me the lambs and Whitney stans are toxic ( I say this as a fan of both ) . Celine fans are more chilled. I do agree with Mariah being last if you look at it from vocal technical point of view (She is still my favourite 😪 ). Mariah lacks consistency but on her best days I believe that she is better than Celine. IMO Celine is the most complete vocalist in the vocal trinity but Whitney was the better belter ,headvoice user, better dynamics , best resonance . Whitney was also the most consistent live performer in her prime. For me Prime Whitney > Prime Celine >= Prime Mariah ( Celine over Mariah for consistency, better headvoice and better low notes )
Luna is a dancer, she majored in dancing. SM scouted her because of her dancing skills. If we placed all-rounders,
1. Luna (main vocalist, main dancer hip hop, can rap, best stage performer, great musical actress, songwriter)
2. Wendy (main vocalist, best rapper in her group, good dancer
3. Ning Ning (main vocalist, dancing is average and can rap)
4. Bada (main vocalist, dancer, good musical actress)
5. Lina (main vocalist, dancer, good musical actress)
5. Taeyeon (main vocalist, an average dancer)
I'd say
1.Luna (obviously)
2. Bada (her raps are great especially in aespa cover + her dancing
3. Wendy (good vocal and rap)
4. ningning (decent vocal and good dancing)
5. Lina (great vocal)
@@allykelly Taeyeon?
@@LLA-lr8kw above ningning
@@allykellyif it’s an actual all rounder list I wouldn’t say taeyeon is above nn. Yeah taeyeon is a far better vocalist but taeyeon is an average idol dancer, I don’t think she ever rapped. NN is slightly above average dancer and can do an okay rap so i would say nn is more all rounded
Where is harram from billlie? U know billlie is under sm right?
She's in the sub label, this ranking in for the one that debuted under the main company
Wheres the last clip of ning2 in the lower register
It's her cover hours by Muni long
12:01 just leaving a timestamp for me to replay it
Is Taeyeon consistent, or at least close to being consistent, with Eb5?
I'd say D5 still
@@allykelly yes, but she has some support E5s in forever1, you know?
@@thanhtien493 not sure it was supported cuz it's quite pushed and lack freedom she even has tense D5 recently in into the new world
As a fan of taeyeon, D5 is right. Eb is still uncomfortable.
Wendy is so underrated, people only know best vocalists of SM such as Bada and Taeyeon and rarely talk about her. Even in her group, she is considered as the two least popular members despite of her amazing vocal. I hope they acknowledge her and respect for her talent someday
I'd say Wendy isn't underrated she's quite well known the underrated one is Luna and even lina
@@allykelly agreed
the fact that she's also a really good dancer, rapper, performer and composer, she's a true all arounder
@@allykelly yeah but compared to the ones in SM like Taeyeon and Bada, she’s still not much popular, even in RV
@@todayissharing well no need to compare wendy is very popular in vocal community what you should appreciate more are Luna and lina
Can you rank the lower register of
Wendy
Taeyeon
Ningning
Eunji
Solji
Eunji
Ningning
Wendy
Taeyeon
@@allykelly what about solji
@@vampiregaming9820 above NN
@@allykelly so solji even with having only G3 is better than ones having F#3/G3 ?
@@vampiregaming9820 her projection is massive down to G3 so
who had better lows wendy or hyorin?
Hyolyn, more solid and deep
@@allykelly who has better lows between Ningning and hyolyn
@@vampiregaming9820 Hyolyn
@@allykelly then who's better between Eunji and hyolyn
@@vampiregaming9820 eunjj
Kinda sad not seeing Jessica here, but still good video^^
Only 1 main vocalist as a representation for each group
Wouldn't she be last in most categories though? She could be above Bada and Lina in Lower Register but that's about it.
Also, if Jessica was included, wouldn't Dana have to be included too? I'm pretty sure she was a Main Vocalist too (or it's another member and I'm confusing their names)
@@abc_jv_xyz the author said only 1st main vocalist represent from each group
She's no longer prt of SNSD
give the ranking to whoever you feel deserves it but Taeyeon is still that Btch. She's the only soloist in SM I know to have reached 200M strems on YT, most wrded solist under SM, OST Kween, nd most of'll, sold out concert king.
Ofc no one deny that she's the most successful even a strawman knows that
I'm a soneMy but I do agree that overall ranking taeyeon got the 4th place..but maybe third along with wendy, lina and luna is better altough their gap isn't that big
That's not topic of discussion here lmao
But not the best vocalist. Periodt 🤷🏾♀️
u on the wrong vid dude
Bada>Wendy
in mix/belting
Is taeyeon regressing btw?
No, shes still on her usual level
No still like a regular Taeyeon just lighter
Why is this guy following ain't other fan
I'm highly inspired by him i never intended to copy him just want to added 2 vocalists that he could've added but understandable tho
@@allykelly ok then
@@kyutiekyujin564 ok
Is luna a light beltet
Balanced but more to lighter side
Would personally put Wendy above NingNing in lows and Tae above Bada in head voice
Ningning has better approach in lows plus she can project lower than her. Bada sounds a bit fuller despite having naturally smaller voice than Taeyeon
@@allykelly yeah but Wendy is more consistent with support imo, NingNing can get a lil muffled below G3/G#3, not always but it can happen, Wendy has been very consistent down to F#3/G3 during her career, i dont think there is a big gap but just for the quality of support id rank Ning 2nd
@@liftedb9591 umm which performances when she get muffled only 1/2 performances her good F#3/G3s still outnumbers Her bad G3s ningning has Been having quite a lot of F#3s in savage and her English cover not to mention ningning has one Eb3 that sounds easy and clean
Heck even Luna is more consistent than Wendy but Wendy support lower and a bit fuller at best
Wendy on a bad day sings better than Ning in any register. Yall crazy in this thread 🤣🤣🤣
@@eyebrowstj not in any register
was ningning's Eb3 at 4:35 supported?
Yes
Is Lily a belter or a mixer ?
Up to certain point she's a Belter
@@allykelly coming to the point I believe taeyeon and even Eunji is a better belter than Luna.
Luna is more of mixer I guess
@@vampiregaming9820 Luna can belt too she just belt less than these 2 Luna has more development than Taeyeon above D5 I'd say Eunji is equal to Luna since both have D5/Eb5
@@allykelly do you think Luna's belt are too light compared to taeyeon or Eunji
@@vampiregaming9820 not too light
what is all of their supported ranges ?
Lina
G#3-Eb5/E5-A5
Luna
G3-D5/Eb5-Bb5
Taeyeon
G3/G#3-C#5/D5-F#5
Wendy
F#3/G3-C#5/D5-A5
Bada
A3-C#5/D5-F#5
Ningning
F#3/G3-C5
@@allykelly is ailee on the same level as lina ?🤔
@@rakransangma4520 no
@@allykelly does it mean lina is better than ailee
@@rakransangma4520 yea a bit
Does Lina still have better agility or has taeyeon surpassed her?
Both are comparable
I want Eng sub title sorry
It will appear soon sorry for my underwhelming pronunciation 💀
@@allykelly no you don’t have to say sorry
I really appreciate for your hard working cuz I’m learning singing that’s why
what part didnt u understand?he sounds fine to me and i can understand him
@@vyeagra420 yes I can understand too but I have a habit of reading subtitles that’s why haha
Im fine with his pronounciation its just that his volume is kinda low compared to the clips' volume💀i have to turn my volume up to the highest then suddenly one of them is belting and my ears are bleeding💀
oh ok so ningning is a one trick pony
Her mix might not be comparable to her senior, but it's not bad. So no, she's not a one trick pony
you always sound salty about nn for what?💀