I liked him, he was an example of hard working immigrants, which my parents are and it’s not like it’s something to be ashamed about, his accent was part of his character, because a lot of immigrants will have accents and there’s nothing wrong with that, it’s not easy to assimilate into a culture just like that
The points that you made are absolutely moot. Someone not wanting to be referred to as a stereotype from a fucking cartoon is not abnormal. This is why no one asks white guys what they think anymore LOL. Fucking snowflakes
LEGIT as an Indian, growing up in a indian community in michigan, I have never had an issue with Apu nor did any other Indian/brown person that I knew.
I really don't like this whole, "Hey look, you are 'insert random group', you should be angry about this" shit some people are trying to pull. It seems very fabricated. I am not even sure, all those celebrities are really offended by Apu, they just wanted to be in a controversial documentary, because let's face it, these people are almost exclusively hardcore narcists craving attention more than anything else.
I saw a huge amount of Indian people expressing how they hated that Apu was getting canned. There were jokes about every group of people in The Simpsons. Apu showed great family values, was a successful business owner, and was a generally a positive character in the show. I'm sure some Indian people may have had issues with it, but what about Indians who didn't?
And it's clear to anyone without a personal agenda that this wasn't racist in the slightest. He's been on the show forever and I'm sure the logic was "why pay 15 voice actors when we can pay 1".
@ZonaElectronicFilms alright, I see what you're saying. I'm just not really sure what happened behind the scenes, like if he was pressured or not by fans or people at fox complaining. I understand what you mean though, and if it was 100% his decision, then it wasn't unfortunate. Thanks for your reply though. Or if you have more to say I enjoy the conversation.
@@bassmankilla9352 that’s sort’ve why I always sit back on these specific issues. If an actor or celebrity commits a crime or hurts someone, that’s usually cut and dry. But this is a little more complex and yeah, idk we don’t truly know what happened behind the scenes. My take away is that sometimes the actors back the decision, so that complicates things, and it kind of changes my mind about the situation. Thanks for not flipping out on my opinion!
They can make fun of Scottish stereotypes in Willy and also the amount of Irish stereotypes yet not one is offended. These people think they can change everything just because they are “offended”
Grounds keeper Willy is an icon. Being from a small country, it's awesome seeing a Scottish person being so prominent in a one-time, for maybe 5 years straight, greatest show ever
As a Sea Captain, I'm horribly offended by Azaria's portrayal of sea captains. The doc The Trouble with Sea Captains explains the plight of our community and the hardships that come with captaining seas.
They do realize that every character on the Simpsons is an over the top stereotype. The son, daughter,dad religious neighbor the police officer etc etc etc.
I watched the documentary and it was so silly. He was so careful to attack Hank Azaria and not the writers and producers. Hank is an incredible comedic actor, Harry just isn't in the same class.
Forcing animators to segregate performance by race is just another way to bootlick corporate media. No indie studio could possibly afford the amount of staff it would take to comply.
If a brown guy voiced "Apu", would Indian kids not have been called that? It's just weird to me that people imitating accents are fine, until melanin gets introduced, then it's a problem if the talented actor, who can hear an accent and imitate it, is the voice.
It’s just selective outrage, there will always be some minute detail to get upset about, as long as it props up whatever agenda the accuser wants to push.
the thing is that kids dont even know who or what race voices any character. i grew up with the simpsons and didnt know who voiced apu or that it was a white guy until people started whining about it. these woke idiots are out to ruin everything because their humorless miserable creeps.
@@rondobrondo To get attention and stand up on their soap box and pretend they are a morally superior social justice warrior in shining armor. It's a lot easier than actually being a good comedian or actor.
There is a history of white actors in the US performing blackface and mimicking (poorly) black colloquialisms, so I understand how it hits a nerve, whether I support it or not.
To be fair, Kal Penn in Harold & Kumar is definitely not a stereotypical Indian character. Correct about Van Wilder though. Both Kal and John Cho have refused to do accents for the past 20+ years, because of their frustration with being only offered bit roles with non substantive character traits other than racial stereotypes. That being said - Apu could have been kept on the Simpsons, but maybe his character has a bit of evolution from the early Simpsons episodes. He was a beloved character.
Van Wilder and Raj from The big bang theory, did kinda imo affected or added perception of indian men in dating scene along side "bobs and vagene" stereotypes
The fact that a decently sized segment of the population believes that only actors who perfectly mirror the demographics of a character are allowed to play that character astounds me. It is called 'acting' for a reason. Further, Azaria is a voice actor. You can't even physiclly see the man whole watching the show. These people seem to be so uttlerly lacking in creativity and imagination that they are only able to perceive the most basic and material layer of reality. They are probably the same people who, in scientific research when asked to envision an 'apple', are not able to hold that actual image in their mind's eye. It's like we've uncovered another sub breed of NPC. Congrats on the channel success, too. Great content.
This stuff annoys me so much. I’m Scottish and groundskeeper Willie is beloved by us. He’s a crazy caricature of us and yet, a lot of it is accurate too
entrepreneur, man of faith, devoted father and husband, upstanding community member… I don’t really see how he is a problem, but rather the epitome of chasing and capturing the American dream
I also think it's interesting that Hassan Minhaj started telling people to stop mispronouncing his name as soon as he saw his star rising. Sometimes you can literally see the egos of performers expanding like balloons.
A few weeks ago in college class my teacher made us watch that Apu Documentary, and how it’s important to know the “lasting damage” cartoons can cause etc. Yes she is a white lady and very liberal, Im not Indian but the Simpsons have stereotypes about Catholics and Hispanics which I actually find funny and don’t have a problem with, I never had a problem with them as part of both of those groups, the simpsons is one of the greatest cartoons to ever exist, Atleast it was, now it’s horrible and it’s been going for too long. My stance is if you’re looking for “inclusion” and “representation” then don’t look to Hollywood or the existing institutions, you have to build your own institutions and representation, those institutions are already corrupt and degenerate (Hollywood is a perfect example). I don’t want Hollywood to represent me because if it does then it’s just going to do it in some white savior or overly corrective way, that’s why no one takes this nonsense seriously while they’re CONSTANTLY pushing it
If you live in a region that has endless 7/11 stores, you know they're mostly owned and operated by Indians. When I lived in LA, I loved saying whats up to them as I bough my Big Gulps. They sensed my Iranian heritage no doubt.
All of this is just so whack. The silent majority does not care about a white man voicing an Indian on a cartoon. They're actors. That what acting is, whether a cartoon or a blockbuster movie. People need to calm down with being offended over things that do not matter.
I’m not Indian and won’t ever know how it feels to be called apu in a derogatory way or treated differently cause of it, and if a large percentage of the group feel this way, I really can’t say I understand or take that away from them, but the road to hell is paved with good intentions and it won’t stop here.
The worst thing to come out of this doc is the idea that VOICE ACTING can only be done by if your race matches. So hari has screwed over tons of non white actors out of jobs since now of course why would they be allowed to voice other ethnicites and not whites? This is something ProZD came to find out real quick For ex Phil Lamarr a black man has been a prolific voice actor who's voiced of course blacl chatacters but also white characters like Aquaman and Japanese ones like Samurai Jack. So should he cancelled for voicing outside his lane? Azaria should've kept voicing these characters ah well.
Thank god I'm white with mostly Western European heritage so that I can mimick Podcast Cringe's accent without any fear of reprisal or cancellation. Akash really was spitting facts. Thank you, come again!
Man that clip during Rogan was damn good break down. I have so many friends of Indian decent and the stories they have about their parents are always so good. But they all have a central theme that their parents came to America with nothing and achieved the American Dream. Unfortunate the cut the character
Damn, I liked him as Carl, I can't speak for indian peoples but I prefer a great voice actor than just an actor of the right color. Mo, Bumble Bee, Apu, Carl had all distinctive voice taht you can recognize, thats skills.. Hank Azaria is a really cool guy, his heart was in the right place, we will never hold it against him.
I like that you took a cringe thing but pointed out how akaash did it right and it was heartfelt comedy he vented it out in a funny way, sure him and shulz can get hacky and corny but they can still be funny and cool to respect that as much as we clown on them for the other stuff
Don't regret it! You did an impression, who cares, I'm a Stoke I've impersonate a brummy no one cares. Edit: also it's acting! Ffs!! You can't have a disabled person playing that, if they're terrible at acting....
I hope us Paddies never lose our sense of self deprecating humour, it's not exactly a common trait any more when victim cards are so cherished, expensive, imaginary and MUST be used at all times!
I'm just thankful The Simpsons having characters cancelled happened long after the show stopped being funny. I would've been real pissed if characters were canceled by wokeness back when it was like in season 11 or somewhere around there.
We always pick out the negatives. We are literally programmed to only nit pick at the lows and not acknowledge ANYONE at the highs. What about instead of us hating on these actors and animators, we should really appreciate the representation that was given. The industry only cares about money, the writers, actors, animators, etc etc are all what put the feeling into the entertainment. Let’s stop fighting each other about this shit and toughen up and learn how to call real bullshit bullshit and take action against problems that really matter
There is no problem with apu, the Simpsons displays America near perfect, and everything in Springfield is a direct reflection of its citizens and viewers. I like worked at a 7-11 for y years and my Manager Jinal was literally Apu. He'd get robbed and make friends with the criminals, tell stories of his home country, and had a lover that he was betrothed to before he got here. He loved his job and was quite literally Apu. Not in everyway but it the most obvious ways. I loved that dude he was a great manager and a good man. I had never met an indian person and made friends with them before him.
Akash is only saying this because he and Andrew Schultz appropriate like no other duo, including black voice. He has no morality, he flops for whichever side benefits him. If there is “thought or consideration” in his tone, its because he’s worked on this defense for a while. He’s a total shill. He offends me.
Bang on. When others make fun of his culture then he gets offensive but he also like to play the non PC role. He can give but can't take it. And if someone else makes a valid point about something offensive they will say that they're just triggered as a way of avoiding valid criticism
nah it was Hanks. Being told that you are ruining the lives of a bunch of kids is a harsh thing to be told. He wants to bring joy to people, and the guilt weighed on him. Here's the show's response: ruclips.net/video/x0idRevzxD0/видео.htmlsi=BAi4_nmcYvBcGUbq
I personally think apu wasnt offensive and shouldn't be taken off the air. However there is a difference between an Indian comedian owning his heritage and making fun of it and a white guy making fun of someone else's. I do think these guys are hypocritical though. I feel like they dont actually care and are just following the court of public opinion and trying to make a name for themselves.
its called acting, also voice acting, its shouldn't matter the color of your skin to voice a character. its just like big mouth when that jewish chick quit cause she voiced a black girl. and that is why Hollywood is to woke for their own good
the whole ban apu b thing was the beginning of the SJW sucking the fun out of life. Now everything is offensive because they lack sense of humor. its like when they tried to cancel speedy Gonzalez and Mexicans were like wtf we love him.
The problem isn't the TV show, the creators or the voice actor. The problem is the people - bullies, to be honest, who use just one or two stereotypes to refer to someone derogatorily. If confronted, they'll respond with "oh, I was just trying to be funny", but you know full well what their true intentions are. I think when Indian comics/writers complain about that, it's that they're referring to, and the fact that it makes it hard to project a sincere foreign voice onto the screen when people in power mock/bully you for something outside your control (probably for their own sadistic pleasures) instead of accepting/rejecting your ideas on their merit. It's not the stereotype that's the problem; it's how people use it to project their sick, ignorant, malicious, sinister views under the guise of juvenile/benign humour.
Agree with Akaash, that they probably threw Apu to Hank because he was the voice guy and didn’t have an Indian accent available. But gotta disagree with your argument that so many actors have done stereo type roles in their earlier work. A lot of them have no choice and just want the job, so they take anything they can get to get into the industry. That’s a bad example to use, but agree with the point saying Hank was just doing a voice never out of Malice. And no don’t write it completely off but we are now 30 years later and realize let’s get a real Indian actor to portray him
This isn’t a social problem. It’s a freaking cartoon. lol. People need to lighten up. The Simpson is amazing. As a Latino, Mexican specifically, I love Bumblebee Man. Lol. He’s meant to mock El Chapulin Colorado but it’s freaking brilliant.
If some one of apu’s nationality would have done that voice then they think some ignorant pos wouldn’t have called them “Apu” or made those awful stereo types??
I like you but im just a regular latino from new York and let me tell you alot of indian people i know think thats shit is mad disrespectful since the 90s . If anything they should of got a real indian to play apu.
As a Mexican growing up and loving The Simpsons, I love bumblebee man and I I loved speedy Gonzalez. I don’t understand the outrage just don’t watch it if you don’t like it, I’m not a big fan, but I don’t bash it. I just don’t watch it but I respect people that enjoy and like it because I have the same love and admiration for The Simpsons if you don’t like something, just don’t watch it.
As a native Rhode islander, Peter Griffin highly offends me and the fact that he's not voiced by an Italian from Johnston is a travesty. But no, what I love about what Aakash said is that people's hurt feelings are valid, people's experiences are valid. But does that make someone oppressed? No.
The things people choose to get their panties in a twist over are baffling. I assume the majority of Indians, Hispanics, et cetera truly don't give a shit.
as an irishman i love to see the Yanks do the irish and our potato lovin leprechauns.. we can have a laugh at ourselves, and not take stuff so bloody serious
So I assume that Hank Azaria is going to play exclusively, from now on, Sephardic Jews, which is his ancestry, ethnicity and heritage. Because, as a Spanish heterosexual man, I would be very offended if he played a Spaniard. He shouldn't also be playing a white Anglosaxon Protestant, as it's not his ethnicity, nor his religion. And what about African-Americans? No, no, no. That's verboten now.
@@PodcastCringe Yes, we can't let them tell us what we can or can't do, otherwise they gather power and will never give it back. The problem with people is that they yield because they are afraid to be called an -ist or a -phobe. Not a single step back anymore, gentlemen.
JR does it again - he doesn't know a truly funny guy in Hank Azaria and I'm still shaking my head that he didn't know why Elon's rockets are so unique - I don't respect his ignorance, sorry 'bout it, Joe Blows.
I mean id feel weird doing a stereotypical indian accent as a white guy. Mind you i wasnt even alive before 2001, and what he said about Azaria already voicing 12 other characters so give him another is facts (just like matt and trey voicing like 90% of south park characters regardless of race or sometimes gender). And on the flip side of feeling weird doing an Indian accent as a white guy, it might be equally cringe when i see Indian or other Asian American actors who dont have the accent being hired to basically make fun of how their parents talk. But ig thats not my place to cringe Above all, the worst/funniest part of all this is that the zombified corpse of the series outlived the beloved character. Im not saying they should’ve cancelled the show over this (or even used this as an excuse to cancel the show). That wouldve been heinous. They should’ve cancelled it when they reached the equinox of good and shit. Not that they would ever do that or acknowledge when it happened tho obviously
I think there's a difference between non white comedians talking about race and a mainly white writers room joking about racial stereotypes. I think a joke really matters where it comes from.
Simply put if Hari and his ilk had been ridiculed and or bullied by people about APU they should be going after thier BULLIES not an Imanginary cartoon character.
The race of a voice actor is entirely meaningless. Phil LaMarr is one if not the greatest voice actor working today, and he’s a Black American that famously voiced Samurai Jack.
Akaash should get in trouble for doing white voice. You can't just steal Steve Buscemi's voice and make is sound slightly gay and get away with it.
hahaha, omg, you're so right about his voice - i can't unhear it now xD
God dammit, I'll never unhear it either@@violetnoire8253
Holy shit that’s fuckin real lol
akaash is no dummy. And he is funny as hell. It is almost like he is a voice of reason during these weird ass times
😂😂😂
Apu was the hardest working person in Springfield and one of the only consistent voices of reason throughout the seasons
"Voices" of reason lol
"Voices" of reason lol
I liked him, he was an example of hard working immigrants, which my parents are and it’s not like it’s something to be ashamed about, his accent was part of his character, because a lot of immigrants will have accents and there’s nothing wrong with that, it’s not easy to assimilate into a culture just like that
The points that you made are absolutely moot. Someone not wanting to be referred to as a stereotype from a fucking cartoon is not abnormal. This is why no one asks white guys what they think anymore LOL. Fucking snowflakes
only for the first 10 or so seasons
LEGIT as an Indian, growing up in a indian community in michigan, I have never had an issue with Apu nor did any other Indian/brown person that I knew.
Hope my home state has treated you and your family well Brother
thank you come again🤣
@EazyDuz18 tbh I always thought that was funny 😂
Nobody is offended by any of these things. It just boosts their clout in a culture that rewards "victimhood"
I really don't like this whole, "Hey look, you are 'insert random group', you should be angry about this" shit some people are trying to pull. It seems very fabricated. I am not even sure, all those celebrities are really offended by Apu, they just wanted to be in a controversial documentary, because let's face it, these people are almost exclusively hardcore narcists craving attention more than anything else.
Hank has a gift when it comes to doing voices, he's perfect for cartoons. It's unfortunate he feels like he has to silence himself.
I saw a huge amount of Indian people expressing how they hated that Apu was getting canned. There were jokes about every group of people in The Simpsons. Apu showed great family values, was a successful business owner, and was a generally a positive character in the show. I'm sure some Indian people may have had issues with it, but what about Indians who didn't?
And it's clear to anyone without a personal agenda that this wasn't racist in the slightest. He's been on the show forever and I'm sure the logic was "why pay 15 voice actors when we can pay 1".
Would you think it’s unfortunate if Hank Azaria actually agrees with the criticism of his voicing of Apu?
@ZonaElectronicFilms alright, I see what you're saying. I'm just not really sure what happened behind the scenes, like if he was pressured or not by fans or people at fox complaining. I understand what you mean though, and if it was 100% his decision, then it wasn't unfortunate. Thanks for your reply though. Or if you have more to say I enjoy the conversation.
@@bassmankilla9352 that’s sort’ve why I always sit back on these specific issues. If an actor or celebrity commits a crime or hurts someone, that’s usually cut and dry. But this is a little more complex and yeah, idk we don’t truly know what happened behind the scenes. My take away is that sometimes the actors back the decision, so that complicates things, and it kind of changes my mind about the situation. Thanks for not flipping out on my opinion!
Apologizing to the woke mob never works. Never fold to these ridiculous race baiters
@@sentientcardboarddumpster7900 Exactly!
They can make fun of Scottish stereotypes in Willy and also the amount of Irish stereotypes yet not one is offended. These people think they can change everything just because they are “offended”
Nobody gaf about gingers
The Celtics leprechan is offensive and should be replaced with Apu.
Grounds keeper Willy is an icon. Being from a small country, it's awesome seeing a Scottish person being so prominent in a one-time, for maybe 5 years straight, greatest show ever
I sound like groundskeeper willie and I approve
Usually it’s white people that are “offended” for other groups. And that’s coming from a white guy
As a Sea Captain, I'm horribly offended by Azaria's portrayal of sea captains. The doc The Trouble with Sea Captains explains the plight of our community and the hardships that come with captaining seas.
lmaoo
Yarrrrrggghhhh! As a fellow Sea Captain, Ayeee agree!
😂😂
Normally cant stand Akaash but this is a W for him...
The problem with Apu...there is no problem.
If a race or ethnicity is going to be represented maybe it's better if it's performed by a person of that race or ethnicity as it's happening nowadays
They do realize that every character on the Simpsons is an over the top stereotype. The son, daughter,dad religious neighbor the police officer etc etc etc.
The most gratifying part of this story is that the ones cancelling Frank Azaria are never gonna be as successful as him.
So if he starts doing British, Irish or Scottish accents, will they hold that same standard? Pretty sure they won't.
Never heard anyone complain about groundskeeper willy even though he is presented in an even less favourable way than apu.
You mean English right? British includes English, Scottish, north Irish and Welsh.
No because there is no history marginalising those groups.
I watched the documentary and it was so silly. He was so careful to attack Hank Azaria and not the writers and producers. Hank is an incredible comedic actor, Harry just isn't in the same class.
Forcing animators to segregate performance by race is just another way to bootlick corporate media. No indie studio could possibly afford the amount of staff it would take to comply.
Who knew that “comedians” could be so sensitive
They all are. Liberal and reactionary, they're all incredibly sensitive about everything
If a brown guy voiced "Apu", would Indian kids not have been called that? It's just weird to me that people imitating accents are fine, until melanin gets introduced, then it's a problem if the talented actor, who can hear an accent and imitate it, is the voice.
It’s just selective outrage, there will always be some minute detail to get upset about, as long as it props up whatever agenda the accuser wants to push.
the thing is that kids dont even know who or what race voices any character. i grew up with the simpsons and didnt know who voiced apu or that it was a white guy until people started whining about it. these woke idiots are out to ruin everything because their humorless miserable creeps.
@@treverfarted what is their agenda?
@@rondobrondo To get attention and stand up on their soap box and pretend they are a morally superior social justice warrior in shining armor. It's a lot easier than actually being a good comedian or actor.
There is a history of white actors in the US performing blackface and mimicking (poorly) black colloquialisms, so I understand how it hits a nerve, whether I support it or not.
To be fair, Kal Penn in Harold & Kumar is definitely not a stereotypical Indian character. Correct about Van Wilder though.
Both Kal and John Cho have refused to do accents for the past 20+ years, because of their frustration with being only offered bit roles with non substantive character traits other than racial stereotypes.
That being said - Apu could have been kept on the Simpsons, but maybe his character has a bit of evolution from the early Simpsons episodes. He was a beloved character.
Van Wilder and Raj from The big bang theory, did kinda imo affected or added perception of indian men in dating scene along side "bobs and vagene" stereotypes
"Akaash be spitting facts." You're a fool for that one. 🤣🤣
The fact that a decently sized segment of the population believes that only actors who perfectly mirror the demographics of a character are allowed to play that character astounds me.
It is called 'acting' for a reason. Further, Azaria is a voice actor. You can't even physiclly see the man whole watching the show.
These people seem to be so uttlerly lacking in creativity and imagination that they are only able to perceive the most basic and material layer of reality.
They are probably the same people who, in scientific research when asked to envision an 'apple', are not able to hold that actual image in their mind's eye.
It's like we've uncovered another sub breed of NPC.
Congrats on the channel success, too. Great content.
Exactly. They don't realize that the talent part of voice acting includes mimicking an accent that you don't have yourself naturally.
lmao I don't think people who are against 'whitewashing' roles all have aphantasia, but that's a pretty funny idea lol
Funfact: Most of the people in the documentary did not know that they were featured in the documentary for the purpose of Apu being a problem.
Lol is this real?
Barney was a sober astronaut, I'll have you know
This stuff annoys me so much. I’m Scottish and groundskeeper Willie is beloved by us. He’s a crazy caricature of us and yet, a lot of it is accurate too
Hank agreeing to stop doing those characters honestly sucks but I totally get why he would. He’s really an incredible talent.
Most Indians are happy to have someone..just someone to represent them
Hank Azaria is a talent and should not not have felt ashamed.
entrepreneur, man of faith, devoted father and husband, upstanding community member… I don’t really see how he is a problem, but rather the epitome of chasing and capturing the American dream
I also think it's interesting that Hassan Minhaj started telling people to stop mispronouncing his name as soon as he saw his star rising. Sometimes you can literally see the egos of performers expanding like balloons.
A few weeks ago in college class my teacher made us watch that Apu Documentary, and how it’s important to know the “lasting damage” cartoons can cause etc. Yes she is a white lady and very liberal, Im not Indian but the Simpsons have stereotypes about Catholics and Hispanics which I actually find funny and don’t have a problem with, I never had a problem with them as part of both of those groups, the simpsons is one of the greatest cartoons to ever exist, Atleast it was, now it’s horrible and it’s been going for too long.
My stance is if you’re looking for “inclusion” and “representation” then don’t look to Hollywood or the existing institutions, you have to build your own institutions and representation, those institutions are already corrupt and degenerate (Hollywood is a perfect example). I don’t want Hollywood to represent me because if it does then it’s just going to do it in some white savior or overly corrective way, that’s why no one takes this nonsense seriously while they’re CONSTANTLY pushing it
That teacher was tripping for sure.
If you live in a region that has endless 7/11 stores, you know they're mostly owned and operated by Indians. When I lived in LA, I loved saying whats up to them as I bough my Big Gulps. They sensed my Iranian heritage no doubt.
As a twin, I believe Patty and Selma are detrimental to my community
😂
Living in a country with a high population of indian immigrants, I would much prefer everyone be more like Apu honestly.
All the characters within the SIMPSONS are stereotyped including the town Springfield and how it exists in every state ……
6:44 probably one of his best points ever. Great observation on cancel culture
All of this is just so whack. The silent majority does not care about a white man voicing an Indian on a cartoon. They're actors. That what acting is, whether a cartoon or a blockbuster movie. People need to calm down with being offended over things that do not matter.
Stereotypes are funny for a reason
Akaash killed that shit 🔥
I’m not Indian and won’t ever know how it feels to be called apu in a derogatory way or treated differently cause of it, and if a large percentage of the group feel this way, I really can’t say I understand or take that away from them, but the road to hell is paved with good intentions and it won’t stop here.
Yeah, now the Simpsons has no Indian representation.
Yeah ok apu. Problem solved.
The worst thing to come out of this doc is the idea that VOICE ACTING can only be done by if your race matches.
So hari has screwed over tons of non white actors out of jobs since now of course why would they be allowed to voice other ethnicites and not whites?
This is something ProZD came to find out real quick
For ex Phil Lamarr a black man has been a prolific voice actor who's voiced of course blacl chatacters but also white characters like Aquaman and Japanese ones like Samurai Jack. So should he cancelled for voicing outside his lane?
Azaria should've kept voicing these characters ah well.
Isnt he the "are you for scuba?" Guy from ALONG CAME POLLY? He was fuggin jacked man.
Thank god I'm white with mostly Western European heritage so that I can mimick Podcast Cringe's accent without any fear of reprisal or cancellation.
Akash really was spitting facts. Thank you, come again!
Man that clip during Rogan was damn good break down. I have so many friends of Indian decent and the stories they have about their parents are always so good. But they all have a central theme that their parents came to America with nothing and achieved the American Dream. Unfortunate the cut the character
Their Australian portrayals leave me offended - I want reparations.
Hahaha 🤣
"Who needs the Kwik-e Mart?......I dooooooo!!"
💔😭
Damn, I liked him as Carl, I can't speak for indian peoples
but I prefer a great voice actor than just an actor of the right color.
Mo, Bumble Bee, Apu, Carl had all distinctive voice taht you can recognize, thats skills..
Hank Azaria is a really cool guy, his heart was in the right place, we will never hold it against him.
I dont see the issue. If a black guy voiced goku and vegeta i could careless
It really is cringe to watch these people degrade themselves like this. Have some self respect.... R.I.P. Apu 😂
I like that you took a cringe thing but pointed out how akaash did it right and it was heartfelt comedy he vented it out in a funny way, sure him and shulz can get hacky and corny but they can still be funny and cool to respect that as much as we clown on them for the other stuff
Don't regret it! You did an impression, who cares, I'm a Stoke I've impersonate a brummy no one cares.
Edit: also it's acting! Ffs!! You can't have a disabled person playing that, if they're terrible at acting....
As a caucasian european i have never had an issue with Apu, i dont know why some people in LA have an issue with it.
I hope us Paddies never lose our sense of self deprecating humour, it's not exactly a common trait any more when victim cards are so cherished, expensive, imaginary and MUST be used at all times!
I'm just thankful The Simpsons having characters cancelled happened long after the show stopped being funny. I would've been real pissed if characters were canceled by wokeness back when it was like in season 11 or somewhere around there.
We always pick out the negatives. We are literally programmed to only nit pick at the lows and not acknowledge ANYONE at the highs. What about instead of us hating on these actors and animators, we should really appreciate the representation that was given. The industry only cares about money, the writers, actors, animators, etc etc are all what put the feeling into the entertainment. Let’s stop fighting each other about this shit and toughen up and learn how to call real bullshit bullshit and take action against problems that really matter
Well said, appreciate you
“Give me a break” - White Dude hahahaha
There is no problem with apu, the Simpsons displays America near perfect, and everything in Springfield is a direct reflection of its citizens and viewers. I like worked at a 7-11 for y years and my Manager Jinal was literally Apu. He'd get robbed and make friends with the criminals, tell stories of his home country, and had a lover that he was betrothed to before he got here. He loved his job and was quite literally Apu. Not in everyway but it the most obvious ways. I loved that dude he was a great manager and a good man. I had never met an indian person and made friends with them before him.
It’s called. Voice ACTING
Akash is only saying this because he and Andrew Schultz appropriate like no other duo, including black voice. He has no morality, he flops for whichever side benefits him. If there is “thought or consideration” in his tone, its because he’s worked on this defense for a while. He’s a total shill. He offends me.
😢
Bang on. When others make fun of his culture then he gets offensive but he also like to play the non PC role. He can give but can't take it. And if someone else makes a valid point about something offensive they will say that they're just triggered as a way of avoiding valid criticism
Holy fuck Akaash legit sounds like discount Aziz Ansari
I wonder if it was Hanks decision to stop or people above him telling him to stop and then saying "you can say it was your decision"
I reckon probably a bit of both, but for sure the producers stepped in and made the final decision… I think you’re right
nah it was Hanks. Being told that you are ruining the lives of a bunch of kids is a harsh thing to be told. He wants to bring joy to people, and the guilt weighed on him.
Here's the show's response:
ruclips.net/video/x0idRevzxD0/видео.htmlsi=BAi4_nmcYvBcGUbq
@funnyberries4017 you are awesome man thank you for your reply
You know that documentary be smelling crazy.
😂
Hank Azaria is woke, and this is the result
What I really find offensive is when a British actor plays an American actor. Ooo that really chaps my hide.
Bahaha 🤣
Or when an American Actor attempts an “AIRISH” accent
I personally think apu wasnt offensive and shouldn't be taken off the air. However there is a difference between an Indian comedian owning his heritage and making fun of it and a white guy making fun of someone else's. I do think these guys are hypocritical though. I feel like they dont actually care and are just following the court of public opinion and trying to make a name for themselves.
its called acting, also voice acting, its shouldn't matter the color of your skin to voice a character. its just like big mouth when that jewish chick quit cause she voiced a black girl. and that is why Hollywood is to woke for their own good
Nobody had a problem with Apu until someone randomly created one 😂
Who needs the kwick-E-mart, I dooooooo!
Lol 😂
Simpsons are more memorable than Harold and Kumar movies we get it you don't really smoke weed
the whole ban apu
b thing was the beginning of the SJW sucking the fun out of life. Now everything is offensive because they lack sense of humor. its like when they tried to cancel speedy Gonzalez and Mexicans were like wtf we love him.
I really hope I don't get suggested Flagrant episodes because I watched this.
Too bad his stand up sucks . The bring back apu was wack
Poking fun at stereotypes is nothing to get offended by. I’m white and I love Dave Chapelle’s white guy voice Lmfao.
Poor Southerners are the only stereotype that doesn't get heat.
Something something sex with cousin something something stupid
Waiting for a video on lex fridman
For no reason here's Apu... Those were the days!
I never found this dude funny at all.. he’s like Andrew Schulz weird sidekick who laughs alongside him on his podcast and it’s just weird lol.
Like the Jerry Springer Show, a lowering of the bar. But I think Jerry was in on the joke.
Andrew and his sidekick think they have big talent.
So is the former voice actor only going to play the voices of his people specifically? Or will he do a cowboy voice from time to time?
The problem isn't the TV show, the creators or the voice actor. The problem is the people - bullies, to be honest, who use just one or two stereotypes to refer to someone derogatorily. If confronted, they'll respond with "oh, I was just trying to be funny", but you know full well what their true intentions are. I think when Indian comics/writers complain about that, it's that they're referring to, and the fact that it makes it hard to project a sincere foreign voice onto the screen when people in power mock/bully you for something outside your control (probably for their own sadistic pleasures) instead of accepting/rejecting your ideas on their merit.
It's not the stereotype that's the problem; it's how people use it to project their sick, ignorant, malicious, sinister views under the guise of juvenile/benign humour.
Agree with Akaash, that they probably threw Apu to Hank because he was the voice guy and didn’t have an Indian accent available. But gotta disagree with your argument that so many actors have done stereo type roles in their earlier work. A lot of them have no choice and just want the job, so they take anything they can get to get into the industry. That’s a bad example to use, but agree with the point saying Hank was just doing a voice never out of Malice. And no don’t write it completely off but we are now 30 years later and realize let’s get a real Indian actor to portray him
Well he got his 15 minutes for acting outraged, that documentary was a hard watch.
This isn’t a social problem. It’s a freaking cartoon. lol. People need to lighten up. The Simpson is amazing. As a Latino, Mexican specifically, I love Bumblebee Man. Lol. He’s meant to mock El Chapulin Colorado but it’s freaking brilliant.
If some one of apu’s nationality would have done that voice then they think some ignorant pos wouldn’t have called them “Apu” or made those awful stereo types??
I like you but im just a regular latino from new York and let me tell you alot of indian people i know think thats shit is mad disrespectful since the 90s . If anything they should of got a real indian to play apu.
Hehe I like you too
As a Mexican growing up and loving The Simpsons, I love bumblebee man and I I loved speedy Gonzalez. I don’t understand the outrage just don’t watch it if you don’t like it, I’m not a big fan, but I don’t bash it. I just don’t watch it but I respect people that enjoy and like it because I have the same love and admiration for The Simpsons if you don’t like something, just don’t watch it.
As a native Rhode islander, Peter Griffin highly offends me and the fact that he's not voiced by an Italian from Johnston is a travesty.
But no, what I love about what Aakash said is that people's hurt feelings are valid, people's experiences are valid. But does that make someone oppressed? No.
The things people choose to get their panties in a twist over are baffling. I assume the majority of Indians, Hispanics, et cetera truly don't give a shit.
God the fact I know your voice and can't place where it's from is driving me nuts.
as an irishman i love to see the Yanks do the irish and our potato lovin leprechauns.. we can have a laugh at ourselves, and not take stuff so bloody serious
Im sadden that Bumblebee Man isnt around because of that apu bullshit. We Mexicans loved that mf
So I assume that Hank Azaria is going to play exclusively, from now on, Sephardic Jews, which is his ancestry, ethnicity and heritage. Because, as a Spanish heterosexual man, I would be very offended if he played a Spaniard. He shouldn't also be playing a white Anglosaxon Protestant, as it's not his ethnicity, nor his religion. And what about African-Americans? No, no, no. That's verboten now.
Yeah exactly! Where do we draw the line, and who tf is drawing them 🙄
@@PodcastCringe Yes, we can't let them tell us what we can or can't do, otherwise they gather power and will never give it back. The problem with people is that they yield because they are afraid to be called an -ist or a -phobe. Not a single step back anymore, gentlemen.
This is one of your best videos.
JR does it again - he doesn't know a truly funny guy in Hank Azaria and I'm still shaking my head that he didn't know why Elon's rockets are so unique - I don't respect his ignorance, sorry 'bout it, Joe Blows.
I mean id feel weird doing a stereotypical indian accent as a white guy. Mind you i wasnt even alive before 2001, and what he said about Azaria already voicing 12 other characters so give him another is facts (just like matt and trey voicing like 90% of south park characters regardless of race or sometimes gender).
And on the flip side of feeling weird doing an Indian accent as a white guy, it might be equally cringe when i see Indian or other Asian American actors who dont have the accent being hired to basically make fun of how their parents talk. But ig thats not my place to cringe
Above all, the worst/funniest part of all this is that the zombified corpse of the series outlived the beloved character. Im not saying they should’ve cancelled the show over this (or even used this as an excuse to cancel the show). That wouldve been heinous. They should’ve cancelled it when they reached the equinox of good and shit. Not that they would ever do that or acknowledge when it happened tho obviously
Are Juggalos offended by Krusty though 😂
I can't beleive the Simpsons listened to this clown and got rid of Apu and the rest of the Indian characters.
I think there's a difference between non white comedians talking about race and a mainly white writers room joking about racial stereotypes. I think a joke really matters where it comes from.
Simply put if Hari and his ilk had been ridiculed and or bullied by people about APU they should be going after thier BULLIES not an Imanginary cartoon character.
The race of a voice actor is entirely meaningless. Phil LaMarr is one if not the greatest voice actor working today, and he’s a Black American that famously voiced Samurai Jack.
If youre half american you cannot call out "cultural appropriation" or any bs like that. If you dont have an accent you cant be offended.
Apu owned the store. He didn't just work there. Shit, I used to look up to Apu, we live in wild times.
Hank made Indians cool.
Hey man, Barney evolved and got sober.
Did he really??