I'm a die hard Alanis fan, and normally when her songs come up on shows like idols I always find it a bittersweet moment. Initially I'm so glad an Alanis song is gonna be performed, but laterly, I'm disappointed 'coz it always somehow comes up short of the power Alanis can put into her live performances. That being said, Haley did a superb with this performance - loved it! She has the vocal power to infuse the raw emotion of this song. Awesome talent!!
The top 3 show always makes me mad. The producers always give one contestant an odd song choice to sabotage them from getting to the finals. It wouldn't be so bad if the producers choice wasn't always the last round (the most watched and influential toward votes) Although given the horrible song choice she still did a pretty good job with it.
+Tigerkem . Agreed. I'm as big of an Alanis fan as there is - but this is a completely asinine song choice to showcase vocal skills. This song was NEVER about the melody! Alanis isn't a top-ten voice but if they HAD to give her an Alanis song they could have chosen a dozen better ones.
It was a bit low for her voice at the beginning, but overall she did a really great job. She killed it in the choruses. What a hard song to sing for a competition as it isn't that melodic a song. About as good as one could sing it. Any other of the contesttants trying to sing this would have been a disaster for them. Can you imagine giving this song for Lauren to sing. It woud have been a nightmare for her
@rumpledore The nice thing about Repad's work is that you are watching and listening to the finest quality on this site. For those of us that could not be there to witness it live this isw as good as it gets. And the nice thing is you can see and hear it over and over. I love all of her work - purchased all studio versions and keep coming back to Repads work to enjoy the performances over and over. Thanks Repad! I go to all the others to help with the view counts - but your work is the best.
Better than the original imo and of course she killed the chorus, but what did she say in that blunder? "cause the love that you gave her to made'll make it enable you to be... open wide"
It's great to sit back and watch and listen. Her stage presence was beyond any we have seen. Go the the dictionary and look up the definition of X-factor - there you will find Haley's picture.
Check out how the judges were rocking out to this. Like one judge said many times "nothing to judge here". Its sad that two of them could not give her the credit she deserved.
IMHO the reaction of all three of the judges rocking out during this performance is validation that Haley was robbed. Tough song - epic performance. She is right - this ain't the end of this thing....shindig!!!
People who are saying she only got through this was because she sang it pissed off, your not COMPLETELY wrong, but at the same time, ytou are. She got through it because she has and amazing voice AND sang it pissed off. KEEP IT ROCKIN' HALEY! WWWWHHHHHOOOO!
Actually after listening to many of the other different live and studio versios of this song, I never realized how good Haley's is. It is actually the one so far I enjoy the most, and she really did a great job! Again, not necessarily the best song choice for AI, but she didn't pick it!
i remember watching this season, she should have won, it was the last season i watched because i felt producers wanted a POP singer to win.. they tried to sabotage her with this song and it didn't work.. made sense why Simon left the show..
@TheWilfredpascua well at least Jimmy said he's planning to sign Haley. seriously, it's sad how everyone is waiting for CDs from everyone who were voted off and don't give a crap about the top 2's CDs
@ronhep49 I agree with you - not only is this the best cover of this song - but it has become the one that I play most on my IPhone. She rocks the chorus - It really grows on you. Many great performances by this angel - but this has become my fav.
Actually this was a disgraceful choice by the judges. They continued their sub-standard performance this season by picking a song outside Haley's preferred range. To get the chorus into her sweet spot the verses had to be too low for her voice. Yes the chorus was up to her usual high standard but ...
@seker7 I agree with you about the hypocrisy, as well as the epic quality of HOTRS and I Who have Nothing... however by choosing this song Haley comes out a winner. While some may hold the belief that Alanis performed her song better the comparison should be with a "live" version from Alanis. IMHO Haley does more than hold her own - (still my favorite performance). Factor in that Haley had to learn and perform THREE monster songs this week - under the pressure of being judged.....WINNING!
its funny what this show did, I come back to these renditions of songs because from what I've heard this girl sang the chorus of this song better than ive ever heard.. a lot of these contestants added flair to these songs and I always come on youtube searching for them.
Kind of laughable that Randy and JLo spent all season critiquing her song choices, then choose this song for her to sing lol. Such sabotage, this isn't a singer's song at all, but she still killed the choruses.
@sincitysinglemommy Right after her EP came out I was playing it on my car stereo. As soon as this song ended I switched to the radio. What should be playing, but YOK? It took me a few moments to realize that it was Alanis' version and not Haley's. It was that good, and I hadn't heard YOK played on the radio in a few years.
+Richard Sarabia ????????? What the hell? Are you tone deaf or something? She could give Janis Joplin a run for her money in emotion when she sings. I bet you're a Mariah Carey saccarine fan, aren't you? There wasn't a hetero guy in the audience that wouldn't have thrown her down on the stage and did her, and I suspect a few gay dudes were thinking about taking a walk on the other side as well.
Simply awesome! No other idol contestant could even dare attempt this. Randy and JLo must be wearing diapers cause they for sure shit in their pants after she nailed this.
She kinda did screw up the part of “cause the love that you gave that we made wasn’t able to make it enough for you to be open wide” I thought it was awesome though
@gaybasher1oo The masses are lemmings - we are a bit more sophisticated, and she is gaining fans at every stop on the tour. The following is from the Charlotte Newsobserverdotcom. “Third-place finisher Haley Reinhart showed more vocal prowess and charisma than the rest of the field combined; it was interesting that she, rather than Alaina, got the penultimate performance slot.” Given this is ground zero for Scotty fans this is quite a compliment!
@wthgtfo Thanks - But the older I get the better I was. Like Al Gore I helped create search engines, so I'm familiar with how to use them.We can agree that this performance was not bad- listen to her "studio version" where she does not mumble. Again, she did not choose he song - the "judges" did. And she had to learn two other songs which were equally challenging. What I'd suggest is that you learn to write better. It's RUclips, and I believe you meant "better thAN this"
@sincitysinglemommy I disagree completely, but this is indeed the best version I've ever heard of this song. Better than Britney's and MUCH better than Beyonce's/
im sad she got voted off but let's be honest, she'll definately have an amazing career ( most likely ten times better than lauren or scotty will )!!!! I LOVE THIS GIRL!!!!
10 seasons have past and still...carrie underwood and kelly clarkson are the only ones that may be called an "idol"? well, the others were great too, but the names are not making a scene in the industry! how i wish haley will go make a name with her music all throughout the world! lots of love from the philippines!
Much better voice and singing that Alanis, and what a sexy live performance! She blew it out of the water. She should have won. The teeny-boppers screwed her over though.
Haley is not only a far more talented, plus a lot better singer than Alanis Morissette in her heyday, she is also astronomically far sexier as well you fuckin dumb moonbat!
+Space Cowboy Alanis is perfect for the music that she wrote. I don't think singing can be a competition like they make it out to be. Look at Neil Young... the guy can't sing a proper note to save his life, but he's a goddamned legend. Same with Mick Jagger. It's all in how it fits, you know?
@hgrebnesor So true. If you listen to the one other cover done on AI in a duet with Cyrstal Bowersox and Alanis, it was a bit of a disaster in my mind. Haley's was so much better! Now when you search on you tube for the songs Haley did on AI, you now see more and more people doing covers of Haley's versions instead of the original. Hers are that good!
I'm not sure if I'm more impressed by the way she lays into the song or by her running up the steps in high heels.
It's 2019 and I'm still obsessed with this.
Lil Rayz same, 2020
2021.
Let's all see each other again on this video on 2022.
@@peppermint5351 2022
2022 baby
2022 here
she shoulda won
She "outta" won😂
1:57
God was not screwing around when he made this girl !!!!!!
"Is she perverted like me? Would she go out with you to a theater?" Oh yusss so dirty.
Lol I love censors.
lol
wat a hussy
Salem Corbeaux - it was a porn theatre
😂😂
I'm a die hard Alanis fan, and normally when her songs come up on shows like idols I always find it a bittersweet moment. Initially I'm so glad an Alanis song is gonna be performed, but laterly, I'm disappointed 'coz it always somehow comes up short of the power Alanis can put into her live performances. That being said, Haley did a superb with this performance - loved it! She has the vocal power to infuse the raw emotion of this song. Awesome talent!!
She slayed every song LOVE HER
I love how she wears heels for BOTH songs after falling! What confidence... (she deserves it though)
the fast part of the first verse was rocky but the choruses were great
that's what I thought
The top 3 show always makes me mad. The producers always give one contestant an odd song choice to sabotage them from getting to the finals. It wouldn't be so bad if the producers choice wasn't always the last round (the most watched and influential toward votes) Although given the horrible song choice she still did a pretty good job with it.
+Tigerkem . Agreed. I'm as big of an Alanis fan as there is - but this is a completely asinine song choice to showcase vocal skills. This song was NEVER about the melody! Alanis isn't a top-ten voice but if they HAD to give her an Alanis song they could have chosen a dozen better ones.
+Aaron Snyder alanis is number 1 voice you bitch
I think she would have killed it if she sang "Ironic."
Absolutely nailed the chorus!
She stuffed up the first verse yes, but she nailed the rest of it and her voice is incredible, her raspiness and tone, love her!
It was edited due to sexual content.
@@lindaclarke204 Not the first verse...the first run. Nothing was edited, it appears she forgot the words.
Haley is so amazing ,she can sing anything and make it her own
Ehm not so much
Gosh, I actually love this performance!! Rocked it. And the fact she was pissed was a fuel to the fire. :)
The Final 3 of this season were just so stellar 🔥 I was pulling for Haley. I remember those were the text-in days.
Wow, at the beginning, I didn't really like it. But when she started singing the chorus it was just incredible.
great quality video! goo haleyyyy
wow this really is a monster song to pull off live. Off the charts in terms of difficulty. Amazing performance.
Haley Reinhart, you are truly the Idol :)
This song got stuck on my head for a whole week!
It was a bit low for her voice at the beginning, but overall she did a really great job. She killed it in the choruses. What a hard song to sing for a competition as it isn't that melodic a song. About as good as one could sing it. Any other of the contesttants trying to sing this would have been a disaster for them. Can you imagine giving this song for Lauren to sing. It woud have been a nightmare for her
wow. This was amazing!
@rumpledore The nice thing about Repad's work is that you are watching and listening to the finest quality on this site. For those of us that could not be there to witness it live this isw as good as it gets. And the nice thing is you can see and hear it over and over. I love all of her work - purchased all studio versions and keep coming back to Repads work to enjoy the performances over and over. Thanks Repad! I go to all the others to help with the view counts - but your work is the best.
Better than the original imo and of course she killed the chorus, but what did she say in that blunder?
"cause the love that you gave her to made'll make it enable you to be... open wide"
This is the best cover ever!!!
It's great to sit back and watch and listen. Her stage presence was beyond any we have seen. Go the the dictionary and look up the definition of X-factor - there you will find Haley's picture.
Check out how the judges were rocking out to this. Like one judge said many times "nothing to judge here". Its sad that two of them could not give her the credit she deserved.
IMHO the reaction of all three of the judges rocking out during this performance is validation that Haley was robbed. Tough song - epic performance. She is right - this ain't the end of this thing....shindig!!!
I really like the part when she says "and you know it"
i loooove when she scratches the desk in front of randy then gets all up in jlos face....."can you feel it!" aahhhhh love her!!!!
Great picture
People who are saying she only got through this was because she sang it pissed off, your not COMPLETELY wrong, but at the same time, ytou are. She got through it because she has and amazing voice AND sang it pissed off. KEEP IT ROCKIN' HALEY! WWWWHHHHHOOOO!
I would have loved to see a studio version of this and rhiannon.
QUEEN
Haley always delivers!
Wasn't a fan at the beginning of the song, the chorus was amazing!
WONDERFUL!
Love from Canada.
Actually after listening to many of the other different live and studio versios of this song, I never realized how good Haley's is. It is actually the one so far I enjoy the most, and she really did a great job! Again, not necessarily the best song choice for AI, but she didn't pick it!
the BEST of Idol.. HALEY should've won.
This is the last song sang before she got eliminated... I don't know who could hear this and think she's not good enough lol
Lo sigo viendo desde España en el 2023.
1:46 Running as if to prove a point! I will miss this ballsy girl
i loved how she saved the scrathing part for randy and jlo. hahahaha
@pionero83 Actually all of her arm pumping is epic. Like Beyonce said "Haley is a rockstar" - she sure looks like one here!
amazing
i don't know, i keep on going back in here even if it's already a season ago. haley reinhart should've won over those country shits :(
i remember watching this season, she should have won, it was the last season i watched because i felt producers wanted a POP singer to win.. they tried to sabotage her with this song and it didn't work.. made sense why Simon left the show..
@TheWilfredpascua well at least Jimmy said he's planning to sign Haley. seriously, it's sad how everyone is waiting for CDs from everyone who were voted off and don't give a crap about the top 2's CDs
Unique as alwqys.. Thats why I LOVE her... Until now.. Shes the best ever happen in in AI
I get goosebumps every time!!.. The real winner!!!
haley is going to perform her single on idol tonight remember to watch it
She slayed the chorus
@ronhep49 I agree with you - not only is this the best cover of this song - but it has become the one that I play most on my IPhone. She rocks the chorus - It really grows on you. Many great performances by this angel - but this has become my fav.
Haley gave best performances consecutively until ahe reached the top 3 and i think that was enough for her to win' she was so dedicated
Actually this was a disgraceful choice by the judges. They continued their sub-standard performance this season by picking a song outside Haley's preferred range. To get the chorus into her sweet spot the verses had to be too low for her voice. Yes the chorus was up to her usual high standard but ...
@seker7 I agree with you about the hypocrisy, as well as the epic quality of HOTRS and I Who have Nothing... however by choosing this song Haley comes out a winner. While some may hold the belief that Alanis performed her song better the comparison should be with a "live" version from Alanis. IMHO Haley does more than hold her own - (still my favorite performance). Factor in that Haley had to learn and perform THREE monster songs this week - under the pressure of being judged.....WINNING!
its funny what this show did, I come back to these renditions of songs because from what I've heard this girl sang the chorus of this song better than ive ever heard.. a lot of these contestants added flair to these songs and I always come on youtube searching for them.
this is my favorite song she sings
this makes mee wish i woulda watched american idol:)
love her
I gave her rolling on the floor ovation
She needs to get to Top 2 :)
Ugh where is the studio version for this.
She definitely deserved to be in the top two, especially over Lauren...
I just ordered her American Idol c.d.
Dang I’ve been sleeping on her and missing out
i missed this performance =(
2020!
Haley kicks ass everytime!
Love this girl
Kind of laughable that Randy and JLo spent all season critiquing her song choices, then choose this song for her to sing lol. Such sabotage, this isn't a singer's song at all, but she still killed the choruses.
@33stryker I can't wait to hear it on the radio!
ohh and she should have locked in the winning seat with this i play this version live and its the BEST TYPE OF SONG I HAVE EEVVVEERR PLAYED
@sincitysinglemommy Right after her EP came out I was playing it on my car stereo. As soon as this song ended I switched to the radio. What should be playing, but YOK? It took me a few moments to realize that it was Alanis' version and not Haley's. It was that good, and I hadn't heard YOK played on the radio in a few years.
@TheWilfredpascua lol, nice theory, only one problem with it, Scotty and Lauren also had only one song for download from the top 3.
@ihugtrees321 Mick Jagger?! that is Steven Tyler lead singer from the band Aerosmith!!!
I think she shoulda won with this one!
every song she sing ,she sing better than original
Suuuper frustrated when she lost. Love you Haley!!!
She shouldn't have been voted off... *sigh* America smh...
Why am I not surprised she was voted off? It's sad though...
Absolutely LOVE her!
Her emotions do not match the lyrical content of the song. That's just unacceptable to me. She's fuckin hot though, I'll give her that x)
+Richard Sarabia ????????? What the hell? Are you tone deaf or something? She could give Janis Joplin a run for her money in emotion when she sings. I bet you're a Mariah Carey saccarine fan, aren't you? There wasn't a hetero guy in the audience that wouldn't have thrown her down on the stage and did her, and I suspect a few gay dudes were thinking about taking a walk on the other side as well.
The studio version of this song is awesome!
Simply awesome! No other idol contestant could even dare attempt this. Randy and JLo must be wearing diapers cause they for sure shit in their pants after she nailed this.
She kinda did screw up the part of “cause the love that you gave that we made wasn’t able to make it enough for you to be open wide”
I thought it was awesome though
perfeita.
@gaybasher1oo The masses are lemmings - we are a bit more sophisticated, and she is gaining fans at every stop on the tour. The following is from the Charlotte Newsobserverdotcom. “Third-place finisher Haley Reinhart showed more vocal prowess and charisma than the rest of the field combined; it was interesting that she, rather than Alaina, got the penultimate performance slot.”
Given this is ground zero for Scotty fans this is quite a compliment!
this girl should've won
why the hell isn't this for download?
@wthgtfo Thanks - But the older I get the better I was. Like Al Gore I helped create search engines, so I'm familiar with how to use them.We can agree that this performance was not bad- listen to her "studio version" where she does not mumble. Again, she did not choose he song - the "judges" did. And she had to learn two other songs which were equally challenging. What I'd suggest is that you learn to write better. It's RUclips, and I believe you meant "better thAN this"
bring on the haley growl!
If it was any other year that Haley would have appeared on American Idol, she would have won. I
From2020
@sincitysinglemommy I disagree completely, but this is indeed the best version I've ever heard of this song. Better than Britney's and MUCH better than Beyonce's/
and where/who won AI over her ? Haley not winning has given her tremendous drive pint sized badass
I soo love this performance
Do you mrs hollandor shes a fourth grade teacher
im sad she got voted off but let's be honest, she'll definately have an amazing career ( most likely ten times better than lauren or scotty will )!!!! I LOVE THIS GIRL!!!!
10 seasons have past and still...carrie underwood and kelly clarkson are the only ones that may be called an "idol"?
well, the others were great too, but the names are not making a scene in the industry!
how i wish haley will go make a name with her music all throughout the world!
lots of love from the philippines!
Much better voice and singing that Alanis, and what a sexy live performance! She blew it out of the water. She should have won. The teeny-boppers screwed her over though.
+Space Cowboy better than alanis? are you fuckin dumb bruh?
Haley is not only a far more talented, plus a lot better singer than Alanis Morissette in her heyday, she is also astronomically far sexier as well you fuckin dumb moonbat!
+Space Cowboy Alanis is perfect for the music that she wrote. I don't think singing can be a competition like they make it out to be. Look at Neil Young... the guy can't sing a proper note to save his life, but he's a goddamned legend. Same with Mick Jagger. It's all in how it fits, you know?
I'm glad you feel that way, I feel Haley's version nonetheless sounds better to me.
Totally reasonable. That's what music is all about.
@hgrebnesor So true. If you listen to the one other cover done on AI in a duet with Cyrstal Bowersox and Alanis, it was a bit of a disaster in my mind. Haley's was so much better! Now when you search on you tube for the songs Haley did on AI, you now see more and more people doing covers of Haley's versions instead of the original. Hers are that good!