Super Edition Poll
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 авг 2024
- This video was finished on 9/29/21 and by the time I uploaded it Mistystar was suddenly 30% higher in the poll than in the video. Whatever happens after this I am not aware of at the time pf uploading.
Poll:
warriorcats.co...
Looks like the issue with the rigging has been fixed! Here's the link to vote. warriorcats.com/content/article/2021-super-edition-character-vote
I forgot my account info :(
@@tallulahconesverison l feel ya
For some reason It doesn’t let me sign up, the next button of the age part just turns red and doesn’t do anything
@@Orion-ih5xl Same here
Turns out I dont have an accaunt
I don’t care who gets the next book. I just want there to be a SE on my boi, *Thrushpelt.*
Yes!
Yeah, THRUSHPELT
YES
ME TOO
PLEASE
THRUSHPELT
thrushpelt is overrated
Riverstar invented the mentor mentee thing in the clans. THAT. HAS NEVER. BEEN MENTIONED. SINCE.
Why has that never been mentioned since Erins? IMAGINE IF WE GOT A BOOK ABOUT LEARNING HOW THE APPRENTICESHIP GOT STARTED FANDOM.
Imagine the title becomes Riverstar's Apprentices
I would read that
and he spent his kithood with a WHOLE NOTHER GROUP OF CATS??? who MEDITATED??? and lived in A PARK??? PLS VOTE RIVERSTAR HES SO MYSTERIOUS
This fact has been in my mind nonstop since I’ve known about the polls. If they write a book about Riverstar and not include this, I’ll be very disappointed.
@@abigailc.5126 i just hope if we get a riverstar se they dont skip over the fact he was living in a park with a cool ass group of cats
Me who hasn't read the new warriors books: LIONBLAZE IS GETTING PERSONALITY?! It's a miracle
As far as Warrior Cats personalities go so it might dissapear
@@finnsnow2495 this truly is a dovewing moment
Me who joined late and is only on power of three (but still has way to many spoilers) and knows that Lionblaze has had no personality from the very start: how. just how. how is this possible. I want a boring character that I can hate without being punished. then again I also want to see something impossible happen. * relizes that the broken code is years away from me * I guess I'll have to wait a long, long time.
Ha same
@@skyeecho5319 He’s still hateable in TBC, but he’s not boring anymore. Just an interesting but hateable character.
I am so rooting for riverstar se bc Riverclan was kinda already formed in a loose “a few cats who fish and chill” way before the tribe cats showed up, and is the only clan we never got a look at from a POV character in DOTC, it’s also worth exploring how he used his experience in the park to codify the mentor system and also his very lax and peacemaking attitude is something so different from the modern “start a battle over a squirrel” attitude in the clans
Net fish and chill, the riverclan way
I want a novella about Nightpelt/Nightstar. Poor guy had a tough life and he was present during a very chaotic time during Shadowclan's history and idk, i just think his POV would be interesting!
He's getting a graphic novel
@@simmy0019 you mean the exile from shadowclan novel? pretty sure thats about the exiled sc elders, not nightstar
@@lumeanoastra1252 i dont recall nightstar being an antagonist? just a cat who wants to bring shadowclan back to normal after brokentail’s reign of terror
@@lodgimoss Nightpelt is part of those elders and the focus of the novel
@@lodgimoss he and crookedstar wanted to keep windclan out
Honestly the only way I think an Ivypool SE would work is her having to bond with Dovewing over their kits going to the Dark Forest, and her dealing with the stress and horror of her own daughter repeating her path.
@Minty She seems to have matured slightly since OOTS, and if I’m incorrect this potential book could showcase her maturing and growth
I just want a super addition about Goldenflower. I know there is definitely cats who deserve a super addtion more than her but I just want to see her pov during the whole Tigerstar situation.
Ehhhh her story isn’t that big a novella would be fine, but a se book would probably have lots of filler
Ehhhh her story isn’t that big a novella would be fine, but a se book would probably have lots of filler
@@thenyan3095 True, but I really wished the Erins would of done more with her. Like I don't think we even got how she died in the books (Not 100 percent sure on that) It's like she was just forgotten.
@@shrubbee445 I was going to say she chose to stay behind in the forest, but I remember her guiding Longtail through the mountain and fighting in the badger attack. I literally have no idea how she died
@@shrubbee445 Actually I believe she died of old age after the Great Journey.
I voted Riverstar because I really like Dawn of the Clans and I want more books focused on it. He doesn’t have much as a character through the arc and I’d like to see more of his personality. Ivypool already had an arc of her POV and Mistystar already has a novella. I really wanna see Riverstar win, but Ivypool wouldn’t be horrible either. 🙂
My point EXACTLY we literally get like what, 4 chapters of Riverstar content? BRING BACK ANCIENT RIVERCLAN!!!
Honestly, Ivypool winning might be a disappointment to the community. Sure, we can live in hope and assume the writers will do their best for the character, but Ivypool is just so popular that lots of people have their own headcanons/fanfics already, and people will likely get salty if a new Ivypool story isn't absolutely perfect. I'd love to see Ivypool get some much-needed attention and maybe even become deputy, but a special edition for her would be treading on an uneven ground of audience expectations.
Agreed
I know I should continue the agreed but I honestly hate Ivypool and so while I don't really enjoy dotc I'll rather have riverstar
very true. That's why I had a hard time deciding between Riverstar and Ivypool, but also I really like Riverstar and would want to see the apprenticeship stuff beginning to form cause that would be really cool.
Hell just having an Ivypool book with her mate in it would make people angry
@@annawesometheflameingpikac3688 Probably, considering how divisive Fernsong is within the fandom.
We need a SE or novella on Featherwhisker, he had goosefesather as a mentor and spottedleaf as a apprentice. I would love just a day in the life of him lol
omg finally someone brings up lionblaze’s recent development. suddenly he seems like such an interesting character with many paths to go down and im really hoping that things go to his head and he becomes a ‘good guy gone bad.’ or at least have consequences pile on as he continues to act abrasively
I very much want him to go bad and the other characters to actually dislike him without excusing him for being a "hero"
I'm very worried with him being the grandson of Firestar, Bramblestar and Squirrelflight's son (you know), ect he's never going to get the punishment he deserves... there was a whole thing about him being afraid of murdering cats but now he's done it several times anyway and NOBODY cares..... his sister needed to go through a whole redemption arc, but not Lionblaze! He is good and strong and loyal! Kind of like how Bramblestar is described despite not really owning up to those traits.
I just... UGH. I'd LOVE if Lionblaze becomes a more morally grey character but right now it just looks like he's the one who goes on tantrums and everyone just kind of goes along with it/forgives him for it. He's stupid and stubborn and dangerous, and nobody dislikes him for it. Ivypool for deputy >:c
(I actually REALLY wanted Rosepetal be deputy but.................... yeah......................)
@@foxygrin I’m still pissed off they killed off Rosepetal with only a mention
@@foxygrin Frankly? It's *bizarre* just how much Thunderclan specifically clings to the whole "bloodlines" thing.
Obsessing over the Firestar thing's already led to both an abuse of (subconscious) privilege, and unwarranted high expectations thrusted onto newborn kits.
Or tension with other clans because a new leader just so happened to be descended from "the wrong guy." And not... The qualities of that leader specifically.
@@izzy1356 The irony about the firestar leader bloodline is noticable as well.
Remember how Thunderclan made a big fuss about Firestar's blood having a nepotism problem, only to suggest Ivypool as deputy, who in turn is related to Firestar THROUGH Cloudtail. it mat not be direct blood, but it shows again, the people writing the stuff at WP don't take account of the family trees.
Personally I don't care about the Firestar bloodline thing, it's just a thing that happened I suppose, especially with the fucked up family tree, I just find TC's hypocrisy at that moment kinda hilariously backwards.
I don’t care who wins since I don’t really read warrior cats anymore I’m just enjoying the chaos of all this.
same
@The Rare Husky RIVERSTAR RIVERSTAR RIVERSTAR
Did you make your profile picture? It looks nice!
@@Kitschune24 yes I did! And thank you! =3
honestly...
in my opinion, a re-telling of River Ripple's life since he was a kit would be my best-case-scenario.
He had a bonus scene at the end of Thunder Rising, which gave me just enough tiny facts to want *more.*
Before he was forced into the forest, River Ripple had a sense of routine. We know that the cats of the park lived in a consistent group together, had mentors, and meditated.
That stuff is *interesting!* I want to know more about it!
How did their lives work? How did they treat each other? What problems did they face?
Did River Ripple ever see any of his former friends or family again?
I want a more in-depth explanation to his gratitude towards the water.
I want something *new.*
My worst-case scenario is that they add unnecessary romance to his character, like they did with Leopardstar and Frogleap.
Changed my mind😅 so compelling
this. and his personality is so different from the other founders, too- he has a kind calmness and a way of just seamlessly working with his circumstances that we've never really seen in other leaders, even competent ones. i want to see if he's always been like that, or if that's something that developed in him over time. i want to see more of his life philosophy! and i would like also to see the changing of hands in riverclan after his leadership is over, and what ways riverclan chose to follow in his footsteps. there's admittedly no point in river ripple's life that wouldn't make for a solid super edition. but seeing as his kithood provides such a unique setting and insight into his perspective, i think it's my best case scenario too.
worst case scenario for me, i think, is that they flesh out his backstory and give that perspective on outsiders, only to once again hit the "but here's why clans are so much better" nonsense that happens with every nonclan group in the series. it's okay for other groups to be just as fine as a clan, working partners... i am beyond tired of the superiority complex they write into clan cats that just gets reinforced by the narrative.
Make him Aro Erins 🔫
@@annawesometheflameingpikac3688i hc riverstar as aroace too but he has a mate :(
DOTC is my favorite arc (I’m one of not many) and I really like Riverstar. I feel like Riverstar is the best choice bc we know so much about Ivypool and Mistystar but Riverstar never got that much screentime. They could write the book on anything and have it not be written about stuff we’ve already read. And he’s like my 3rd favorite leader so please..
Yes!! Dawn of the Clans doesn’t get as much love as it deserves, and Riverstar is arguably the least popular out of the 5 and I just don’t think that is very fair (seriously, what did Tall Shadow do??) I would love a super edition on River Ripple simply because we have seen nothing on ancient RiverClan apart from the couple of chapters from Gray Wing and River Ripple’s epilogue.
I have three favorite arcs and DOTC is one of them, even if it may not mean that much.
I hope Riverstar's book is about him learning now to deal with being leader and understanding Clan life. He was the only founder who didn't previously life in a tribe group and it never seemed like he knew a lot about their culture. He was also the most peaceful, despite never really asking to be a leader. He got involved with the tribe cat drama simply because he walked up to Four trees that one time.
My opinions-
Mistystar- N o
Ivypool- Cool, but maybe just a Novella like Dovewing
Riverstar- I want
I. WANT. MORE. DAWN. OF. THE. CLANS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MORE DAWN OF THE CLAMS! MORE DAWN OF THE CLANS! MORE DAWN OF THE CLANS!
I think mistystar would be really good because we get no fucking information on modern riverclan
After just reading AVoS, Ivypool is pretty insufferable (much like other characters this arc) towards Dovewing. She was nice enough to Twigbranch as a mentor but I really can't stand her angst at Dovewing for being with Tigerheartstar. You literally trained in Hell with murderers but moving clans is just too far?
Edit: remembered the part when ivy and dove let their kits play and that was a sweet scene. Doesn't change my opinion that we've had enough from her perspective and I still think river ripple will be cooler
FR
also she’s LITERALLY a protagonist why make a SE on a cat we already got a POV for?
DOTC doesn’t get enough love
@@thenyan3095 Lots of people skip DotC because it's a side series, I Love DotC
Personally I think it’s pretty realistic(I’m not saying it’s right.)With the way the clans are set up their more seen as enemies rather then allies. Going to another clan is seen as being a traitor because she’s going ahead and putting Shadowclan before Thunderclan. If there was a battle Dovewing would have to be prepared to seriously injure or kill the cats that raised her and helped her. This includes Ivypool and her kits so her joining another clan is obviously going to feel like a stab in the back.
As for the dark forest Ivypool was manipulated and thought it was Starclan for a period time. She also did it mainly to be loyal to her clan (and to show off) which probably more backs up her feelings then goes against them. It was also a long time ago and Ivypool was only an apprentice.
@@thepetobsessedrainbow I just expected her to have matured a bit in the time since, that's probably my fault for expecting any character to actually grow given how these books are written. I also just really feel like we don't need her perspective again, especially if it's going through OoTS or AVoS again. Maybe if she became Ivystar
@@darkninjafirefox It's highly unlikely that Ivystar will be a thing since we got Bramblestar back. I'm not a big fan of retellings because warriors don't know how to do it right most of the time. I'm not saying that Ivypool is a bad character, it's just that I prefer Riverstar over her at the moment when it comes to SE.
If its not Riverstar ima throw a fit. He has so much potential plus idk why but I would love to see him refuse to take a mate or something
I’m a Dotc simp
I’ve always thought he’d take Night as a mate but I’d also love if he didn’t have one.
Whatnot they made Riverstar gay?
@@rowanheart8122 we will never get a gay warrior cats character because the publishers are homophobic/don't want an uproar from homophobic parents iirc
What a cute birb is your pfp.
It's a good day when Moonkitti posts
I agree
Is that a Luz pfp?
I’d enjoy Riverstar the most because they can write any story about him and make it work, and even a half decent story would benefit riverclan at this point. Riverclan’s culture is so undeveloped that they could say riverclan cats could hunt badgers at this point and I wouldn’t bat an eye, which will be especially good for the next arc(unless you know, it’s a traveling book).
Ivypool becoming deputy would work(I guess) but that would raise its own issues like Squirrelflight having to retire for one. Then again, that seems inevitable and I’d rather have her than Lionblaze. It really has been long since a female leader has been important and I’d just like to see how they’d act in certain situations in comparison to the toms who’ve never been queens.
Ah, damn, I wish they gave us an option on voting for a Barley super edition, I just love him so much and his backstory would be so much fun to read about
River Ripple has been my little 'I like this character because I feel like it' boy for a while now and seeing him perhaps get a SE both scares and excites me at the same time. As Moon stated it's a pretty win-win situation, but the ever growing anxiety of them ruining what little personality he has haunts me at night.
Even before the botting, it was surprising to see how many votes riverstar was getting, it was really nice to see a character we don't know much about get as much attention as he was getting! :]
I kinda want to see Ivypool so she can resolve her feelings and stuff. Also, did anybody else find it weird that they made her daughter, Bristlefrost, a deputy for the impostor? Like, a much younger, much less experienced warrior compared to her mother. Her mother who fought in the Dark Forest, worked as a spy for the clans, and is known for being a great warrior of Thunderclan got passed up for her much more inexperienced daughter. I'd like to see Ivypool's feelings about that.
Edit: Well, now Ivypool has even more feelings to resolve. Poor Bristlefrost, she did not deserve to meet her demise that way😢
yeah i agree fully,, i just hope they dont mess it up if she does get a novella or se
I'd accept any of these (scared if Mistystar wins). I want Riverripple the most cause I'd love to see focus on Riverclan in Dawn of the Clans what the heck are they doing in there. Ivypool would be fun cause there is a lot they could do... if they actually do it.... and also Fernsong :3
i voted Riverstar!! I don't think we need an Ivypool SE honestly her story has been told :)
Plus Riverstar has so much potential!! I love him so much lol
I love how Mistystar isn't even an opinion in most of the comments xD
This is making me want a Ivypool novella where she does something with Shadowsight(AND MAYBE HIS SIBLINGS OR MAYBE HER OWN CHILDREN HINT HINT???????) and they bond (Like Tawnypelt and Dovewing in that one novella)
Misty star gets a super edition where she accomplishes the final thing she wants to acheive and then d i e s
Mistystar spending 400 pages just doing nothing, maybe doing a few patrols to make sure no other clans come close, and then at the end she just trips on a branch and dies
@@9nikolai the final thing she wants to do is block every other clan from using the lake. Again. River clan Chile borders.
@@SquidsINCIsABadRUclipsr Ah yes of course, she'll just get all of RiverClan to make a big wall around the lake
@@9nikolai looooooong riverclan
While I would be more interested in a good Ivypool book over Riverstar, I don't trust the writing team to deliver anything great, if they butcher Riverstar, it doesn't impact the main series at least, which is a dumpster fire already
That’s true
The Broken Code really screwed up with how they have handled characters. Lionblaze and Jayfeather are acting like impulsive morons (despite having entire arcs humbling them), and death in the series doesn’t have much consequence to the overall plot.
Just like most of the fandom, I have also lost hope for the remainder of the franchise. Given that they did Leopardstar and Redtail dirty, and The Broken Code is an absolute flop compared to A Vision of Shadows’s success.
My hope is they do something right with Riverstar
I wonder if I should buy the broken code or not. Are the super editions that released at the same time necessary to understand the story? I had no problems reading AVOS without it's super editions, for reference. If the SE aren't, I probably will get it for Christmas, the arc compilations aren't too costly usually.
@@WarriorLionstripe Meh, people were already saying that back when Omen of stars released, and now it's got a bunch of fans.
At some point (I think the ultimate guide but IDK for sure) it's mentioned that Riverstar was the one who invented the mentor/apprentice system and I would love if they went into detail about that, or even mentioned it
“We’ve already seen Ivypool throwing rocks at Bumblestripe!”
-Moonkitti 2021
Honestly even if Riverstar wins, I don't think they'll do the SE on him
I hope he wins, dawn of the clans is epic and rivertar is a good lad
I feel like they would only include options they were already willing to do a book on? Like a "yep pick any of these three things i like, that way i win every time" kind of thing.
I really think that Riverstar would be a great super edition. He has a different personality to most generic cats (DOTC is good for developing individual personality anyways, but he seems different in a way), that could be used in loads of cool interesting ways in a super edition for him. Honestly though, I’d love a super edition on some of the main side characters (like thrushpelt for example) because that could develop the main books/other SEs more by giving a more broad perspective on them, and different POVs similar events. If they did a Thrushpelt SE, it could be a great addition for Bluestars Prophecy, because he is used a lot in that book and it would be good to see his perspective on things.
River Ripple, from the moment he was introduced, was just oozing with personality. I loved him from the start. It was a shame he got so little attention in dotc, but I'm really hoping they can make up for it now...in a good way.
My kneejerk was Ivypool too but like... You're right. The only nagging thing left in Ivypool's arc is to wrap up her resentment towards Dovewing, but Im not sure we'll ever see that because I think Ivypool is a character that the writers, and most of the fandom, thinks is completely in the right, even tho it's kind of childish to be like 35 and still pissed that your adult sister moved in with her boyfriend that loves and cares for her deeply in a neighborhood where people won't hate her for having illegal kids even though she's at LEAST 1/3 of the reason that Cat Hell isn't currently running the show. I would love to see Ivypool come to realize Dovewing's struggles and just how much she gave up and realize that the most important thing is that Dovewing is happy, instead of having the same gripe of "We're supposed to do everything together where are you going" when Ivy is like 35 and married with kids.
And don't get me wrong! I would love that, but I don't think we'd get it.
And Mistystar.... eeehhh. I don't care for Misty.
So that leaves River Ripple, who is probably gay.
vote riverstar, he needs a chance to shine
princess should have a super edition for after the clan leave
maybe a novella
i kinda just ment a book about her
Also, Ivypool should be deputy. I disliked Lionblaze before he was deputy for no reason, after that, I hate him. And I want more DoTC, but I don't care about Riverstar, I want a next generation sequel arc. Plus, Ivypool is one of my favourite character, I have bias.
Edit: Seriously, comment people, y'all never heard of "opinions"? Stop attacking me for putting out my opinion on an arc I would hate even more without Ivypool.
No offense But ivypool doesn't deserve deputy she already is way to overrated just my opinion lol
@@Bitchypoetsblog Once she has gotten over her emotional baggage, she will probably deserve it.
@@9nikolai possibly I mean she acts like dovewing leaving is worse then her training in hell like ivypool is a toxic sister lol
Ivypool would make a horrible deputy 😂 She’s immature and let’s her emotions take control of her. She is very self-centered as proven time and time again in the books. She would probably make her cousin/mate Fernsong deputy and declare war on ShadowClan out of her jealousy of Dovewing lmao
@@autumncookies8541 exactly finally someone who understands
Honestly despite Ivypool being one of my favorite characters, I want to see Riverstar have his own book. I'd love to see some more attention on dawn of the clans and there's not many ways a new story with new characters can go horribly worng. Also Riverstar stands out to me a bit with the DoC leaders, it'd be interesting to learn more about his way of thinking as compared to the other fledgling clans.
I sorta want a brightheart super edition, that takes place Tpb-tnp. Yes it'll mostly be a retelling and there's some super editions I'd want before brightheart. But I'd love to see her point of view with the dog attack, and trying to find her place in her clan, and the whole thing that happened with cloudtail becoming suspiciously close to daisy. But I'm scared that the authors are going to write it badly... Like alot of other things they've written. I believe that even though it will be sorta a retelling and unnecessary, I feel like it could be an amazing book with good character development and some extra details. (Maybe a subplot that we didn't see in the main series book, but isn't so important that it ruins the main series books aswell As the super edition.)
Also a barley novella. Because we know from the field guides that he was in blood clan, and apparently he was living with his sister there. Scourge didn't want cats living together, because he was scared of the rebelling. Barley and his sister lived together, and scourge found out and almost killed her. Barley brought her to live with two legs and saved her life. I'd like to see barley's day-to-day life in blood clan.
The fandom wants a Thrushpelt SE
Rrngh I really wanna see Ivypool on the cover of a whole freakin super edition but I just don’t trust the Erin’s enough to make an entire 400-500 page book about her interesting. A novella like Dovewing’s Silence that takes place in between arcs would be perfect imo 🙏
what I'm hoping for in this possible super edition is that lion blaze is almost deputy but like everyone realizes how super toxic he is and then ivypool can get some character development and they realize that she's the best choice for deputy
Honestly I really think River Ripple should win this poll. Misty had a novella, Ivy had an entire series and was a mentor of a main character AND the mother of another, and River has literally one epilogue… so yeah…. Also I just really love Dawn of the Clans and don’t think it gets enough love. Ivypool would be a good second choice but I think Riverstar has so much more to tell. We barely get anything about ancient RiverClan apart from the couple of chapters Gray Wing stayed and Riverstar’s epilogue. Alright thanks for reading my rant goodbye.
Something I would love to see for an Ivypool super edition would be a post broken code book where ThunderClan is trying to figure out what to do.
Right now I think that it is very likely that both Bramblestar and Squirrelflight (and possibly even Lionblaze) could die at the end of broken code. This would create a massive power vacuum in ThunderClan that could easily drive the plot for a super edition.
There could be two, three or even four cats all trying to become the next leader of ThunderClan; especially if StarClan is still cut off. Imagine if there were no leader, no deputy, and the medicine cats cannot communicate with StarClan.
You could even do something like Akira said where there is an external threat that forcibly ends the conflict and forces ThunderClan to rally behind someone
if squirrelflight dies in the broken code i will LOSE IT
I'm okay with either Ivy or River getting one, but if River gets one, I would really REALLY like a Novella or something for Ivypool just... because things were left so sad and open-ended with Dove just leaving her after all they went through int heir OOTS arcs. Like hey I'm glad things are changing to where Dove can make that choice and move, but having that resolution (if any) between them happen offscreen is really devaluing to their entire relationship, and to us fans who got to see them grow up and develop together :( I love the new books but my main gripe is they're still telling old characters' stories through the eyes of a new generation.
Riverstar ngl im so into seeing more abt the old clans and they're leaders.
Absolutely- I also find Riverstar an interesting character! We didn’t learn more about him
I'm rooting for River Ripple/star because we already saw Ivypool's pov throughout oots, and Mistystar is just, no. We've only seen River Ripple's pov in one addition scene on how he got his name. Especially sense he was a calmer, more laid-back character, so he never strongly expresses his opinion.
And because he is already the sweetest thing anyway.
Hi fellow murder cat fans, here before this blows up
“Worst case scenario for RiverStar is that they make it a traveling book”
Welp, this aged poorly
I really just want an appledusk super edition. It would be so interesting to see his life before meeting mapleshade, and his perspective on the events that happened during her novella... Anddddd maybe how he feels about his kin being haunted.
Can we talk about how much of a genuine joy it is for me to watch Moonkitti? No matter what the topic is, I could listen to her for hours.
Ok im reading dawn of the clans and that bonus story for River Ripple was so good to me please i want more of him i always see him as an alolan ninetales haha
I want Riverstar for sure. He has the most to tell.
I do really want an Ivypool Novella though. A short story showing her perspective on Dovewing leaving ThunderClan for ShadowClan because of Tigerheartstar and all that plus the imposter rising to power in ThunderClan and how Bristlefrost seems to be a traitor and all that would be interesting to read. So like a Novella about her taking place from the end of River of Fire to Veil of Shadows would be quite interesting to me. I'm not sure it would need a whole Super Edition though.
Personally, I hope Ivy wins. I know logically she *shouldn't* because we already had a main pov with her, but I really want one. But I'm also.. worried that they'll retcon important stuff and/or completely ruin her character
@@lumeanoastra1252 Yeah. I think Bramblestar's Storm was ok (I read it a loong time ago and was also like.. high on anesthesia from getting my tonsils out when I read it so I don't know if my memory is entirely accurate--) but I like to consider Spottedleaf's Heart noncanon
I want a Riverstar SE and Ivypool and Onestar novellas. A novella could be good for Ivypool and I would love one for Onestar. I don’t know who the third character in their set would be though. They did a novella for Blackstar when he lost the SE poll so I’m guessing they do have intents and ideas of making books for these poll characters but want to know which ones should be full on SE’s and which should just be novellas.
*Really looking forward to a Riverstar super edition. It sounds very interesting and as someone who loves dotc it’d be pretty cool.*
so i recognize that riverstar is a popular character whos entire life we know mostly nothing about, and should the next super edition be about him i will read it and enjoy it just like anyone else, but also i adore ivypool. i know a super edition with her would give us almost nothing new except for ivypools thoughts during times she wasnt narrating a chapter. i still really want it! itd make me happy, if not most of the fandom lol
I'm not leaving until Thrushpelt, Cinderpelt, or my gal Brightheart get a Super Edition.
Or Lionblaze
I loved riverstar from the moment he came into the books. 10/10 best cat
I think after A Light In The Mist, we need a Ivypool SE.
I mean cmon, Rusty was a kit when Mistystar was a warrior. And he got nine lives too, but when he died for good, Mistystar was still alive
Mistystars book should be about her getting dimentia and not knowing whats going on. But you cant make leader an elder.
Imagine that. Going "crazy" like her mother did
Dawn of the clans is my favorite arc because it started reading the series and I just love the cats so… yes to Riverstar!!!
I actually think it be cool to see Mistystar's story tell from a few of another character
Introducing a old character in more detail, watching them struggle with how Riverclan is going.
While it be similar to Bluestar's fall it be more interesting because we would be learning about thier connections slowly and in fresh light. It would show how riverclan sees eachother and thier leadership.
Maybe through a character that will be connected to the next arcs rc protag?
Or maybe a character who struggles as Mistystar , Reedwhisker, or both die in the beginning and must learn to take on leadership duties they weren't expecting. This could lean into the next arcs innerclan struggles and maybe give the new protag a cat to trust that we know connects with them.
I feel like killing off Reedwhisker would be a bad move, honestly. Even though Reedwhisker has served nothing to the overall plots of past arcs, there have been small details that show that he does have some potential. Specifically with the fact that he doesn’t hold much trust in his own mother’s leadership. Only going with it since she is leader.
@@WarriorLionstripe true!
Only thing keeping me from want both dead so they can give him more personality vdhcd
@@painthedoll Eh, knowing the current state of Warriors, probably not. Especially with how much the Erins’ screwed up Lionblaze, Jayfeather, Leopardstar, and Redtail in recent stories. Tree having one of few good stories that the majority of the fandom can agree as good so far.
@@WarriorLionstripe yeah-
As someone who adores personality build up and relationship stories its pretty sad gbdyv
@@painthedoll Man, I still remember when Lionblaze’s popularity shot up like a rocket due to how he was depicted on Omen of the Stars and A Vision of Shadows.
I like how you point out the possible paths they take with new book ideas.
My guess is that the Erins expected Ivypool to win, so they hadn't really thought through a Riverstar super edition that hard. That's probably why Riverstar is getting a super edition in 2023 and Onestar is getting the 2022 super edition instead. I would love if maybe the Riverstar super edition took place in StarClan way after he'd died, I thought an Ashfur super edition could've been good for a StarClan centric book, but Riverstar could work for it too (That probably won't happen though).
Imagine a Stormfur book, like what happened in the mountains during the other arcs, it sounds bad and good.
Honestly, I feel as if Riverstar would be a good candidate for the super edition, as he is mysterious, and we don’t know much about them. Whereas with Ivypool and Mistystar, their characters are already somewhat thoroughly covered. I’m honestly just waiting for our long awaited Squirrelstar lol
I would like Ivypool but I really want a Riverstar Super Edition . Preferably retelling his backstory because I don't have the bonus scene of his backstory then it would Preferably hop to a part of the timeline that hasn't been told yet
*BEST SCENARIO:* Bramblestar dies, we get Squirrelstar and Ivypool becomes deputy.
id want a longtail super edition. itd be neat to see the great journey and exploring the new territory with mousefur by his side.
Oooooooo excited for the next one- :>
Honestly I'd rather see a Riverstar super edition because we've already had a whole arc through ivepool's perspective
The only reason I’m biased for Mistystar, is because that Bluestar is my fav. I hope a cat like Reedwhisker eventually gets to take over, and maybe have some offspring. Also, i kinda like the idea of Mistystar being slight tyrannical/insane due to the relation of Bluestar at the end of her life. After old cats, can lose their faculties.
Hi moon, just gonna say, I love it when you just talk about warrior cats.
I would love the *best case scenario* for Ivypool but I'm not sure how confident I am in that so I voted Riverstar.
I loved DOTC- it was my literal favourite arc
Ima simp for it
A book about ivypool would make a good novella, but I fell like a super addition about her would only restate the things that we already know. I voted Riverstar.
I think I'll start a write in campaign for Tawnypelt. There's so much potential there.
Bruh Ivy is like my favorite character in the series but I would ADORE a story on Riverstar that just sounds so interesting!
Cats who should probably get SOMETHING: Whitestorm, Brokenstar(I NEED his POV so badly), Riverstar, Cinderpelt, Blossomfall, Silverhawk, Snowtuft, Darkstripe(I want more villains), Bone, Breezepelt, Goldenflower, Onestar, Willowshine, Sharpclaw, etc
OH my goodness that last ending bit was perfect
I’m compelled to vote Riverstar because I feel like he would have the best story to tell, but considering the fact that I loved Squirrelflight and Crowfeather’s supers and didn’t even give Hawk Wing or Moth Flight a chance, I doubt I would ever read River Ripple’s either.
I honestly wouldn’t mind if it was a Graystripe’s Vow thing where Ivypool and River Ripple have past and present thing especially for River Ripple so that we can understand more about present DoTC and the cats at the park.
Thank you Moonkitti. Your videos always make me smile =)
You know what I really want a super edition on?
A super edition about Loudbelly getting revenge on Hailstar for naming him Loudbelly.
i feel like the only interesting mistystar book would be some kind of psychological thriller about how she's getting unbearably old, but her gift of nine lives prevents her from dying and being at peace. all of her senses and motor functions are deteriorating, and being alive is literal hell, but every time she dies, she just comes back again. maybe she gets mad at starclan for putting her through it, idk
I wanna book about about some random side character. Idk, just something from a non-main characters POV. How they see main conflicts, no tragic back story, no predictable angst, just a warrior living their life, going on patrols and stuff.
Riverstar is like my favorite Dawn of the Clans cat! 💙
The only Mistystar content I genuinely would want would be about her life before becoming a warrior. Her thoughts and opinions about suddenly being dropped into the middle of Riverclan camp as a kit, her slowly forgetting her previous life or wondering about it. I always thought it was a bit odd that it seemed like Stonekit and Mistykit just... Didn't seem to mention Thunderclan at all?? Unless I'm forgetting some key plot they just didn't really talk much about Thunderclan despite being raised for a small part of their lives there. I also wonder what they thought of Thrushpelt. These could be things brought up in the book and explained, I think it would be pretty interesting to see that! However, I think it would be best for a novella and not a super edition. Yes, Mistystar already has a novella but I mean in my opinion it wasn't the most interesting and could have instead been a Mothwing novella
So yeah. Thoughts on Mistystar even though this is a year old at this point. I think we can all agree that Riverstar is perfect and wonderful and can do no wrong unless the warriors team somehow mess up this cat with so much potential and so much empty space. I genuinely don't know how the erins could screw up Riverstar, I mean I don't doubt their ability to mess things up but c'mon it has to take effort to mess up this cat book
I love River Ripple SO MUCH!!
Lionblaze now has a personality cool
Mistystar is one of my fav characters, a super edition of her would make me so so happy :')
Lionblaze being in a position of power would be really cool but on the other hand.... im so sick of firestar/tigerstar's family being the leaders of Thunderclan
Ivypool's also part of Firestar's family though?
I think Mistystar would only be interesting if she died at the start of the book and it was about her being a ghost and trying to not get possessed and help out the others
like dealing with being dead and not moving on to star clan? Kinda sounds creepy (I have not read past The last hope so sorry if I get something wrong
@@inalidohiwaya9193 yh but I won't continue on since it would have tbc spoilers
omg. this is actually a brilliant idea. i would definitely accept a super edition with a story like that.
In my opinion, Dawn of the Clans was the best arc and underrated. There is so much room and opportunity for expansion and to delve deeper into the stories of cats from back then
her: nobody wants mistystar and no one wants traviling book
me: wants mistystar and wants traviling books
I did actually have the instinctive reaction of wanting ivy, but you explained very well that there isn't that much to talk about. Althought I haven't read anything past AVOS and I also likely won't ever read this super edition. Still, I'm voting for Riverstar.